Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the celebratory event for the 60th anniversary of the Walter Eucken Institute on January 16, 2014, in Freiburg:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

17 January 2014 · 60th anniversary celebratory event of the Walter Eucken Institute · Freiburg, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the Walter Eucken Institute's 60th anniversary celebration on January 16, 2014, in Freiburg, reflecting on Ordoliberalism and freedom.
Main themes
Ordoliberalism and the Freiburg School, freedom and market economy, Walter Eucken's economic thought, private power concentration and its dangers, social justice and economic order, state intervention vs. free competition, historical lessons from Weimar and totalitarianism, GDR planned economy failure, neoliberalism misconceptions, liberalism spectrum in Germany, too big to fail and financial crisis, freedom of individual vs. state paternalism
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,407
80th percentile
Sentences
166
84th percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
11.9
44th percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 50%50%
  • Social 22%22%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

166 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Dear members and friends of the Walter Eucken Institute, my heartfelt congratulations on the 60th anniversary!

You should not expect a technical lecture from me – on the Walter Eucken Institute in the course of time or on Ordoliberalism as such. The office of the Federal President does not make me an economist, and you also know: The officeholder must refrain from judgments on current politics. But I can and want to share my stance with you. And so you may expect from me that I connect the appreciation of the Freiburg School with a plea.

Here in Freiburg, independent minds – in times of totalitarian rule – designed an order of freedom, an order that, after the Second World War, in times of great skepticism towards liberal economic systems, helped to reconcile Germans with a market economy and competition. A chapter of the history of freedom of the Federal Republic of Germany was written here.

For freedom was brought into society as an important theme by talking about the freedom of the economy. For freedom in society and freedom in the economy go hand in hand. Those who desire a free society should advocate for the market and for competition and against too much power in the hands of a few. However, they must also know: A free society is based on conditions that the market and competition alone cannot create.

The thoughts and concepts of Walter Eucken can help us with this dual task. He sought an economic and social order that "ensures both economic performance and dignified living conditions," an order that is oriented towards the freedom of man. And he found many threats to this freedom – both then and now.

He writes that "the granting of freedom can become a danger to freedom if it enables the formation of private power; that extraordinary energies may be awakened by it, but that these energies can also be destructive to freedom." Do these words not sound very familiar, just a few years after banks and political failures plunged the economies of many states and thus millions of people into a deep crisis, and then, because they were "too big to fail," had to be supported and rescued with billions of taxpayers' money?

Elsewhere, I read in Eucken about the dangers that threaten the individual in the modern division of labor world – not only economic hardship but also the impairment or even loss of his freedom, "whether through private power or, in the worst case, through the total state." How could I not be reminded by these words of the decades I experienced in a "centralized economy," as Eucken called it, of nationalized means of production and central control of all economic processes, of absurd plans of a scarcity economy, and above all: of arbitrary allocation of life opportunities and thus of a policy that did not allow people to develop their potentials and that stunted their personal responsibility? I recall an economy and a state that have both failed!

When Walter Eucken formulated this, he certainly did not have the GDR in mind, but rather the Soviet planned economy, the economic control of the National Socialists, and above all the "punctual interventionism" of the Weimar Republic. He had seen the devastation of the Great Depression, the plight of the unemployed in many countries, as well as chaos and violence. But he also saw the incredible media power of someone like Alfred Hugenberg, who had built a gigantic empire at that time and ultimately helped the National Socialists to power. People were accustomed to such concentrations of economic and political power in one person – it seems incredible to us today. By the end of the 1920s, there were around 3,000 cartels in industry, trade, and the financial sector. State interventions in economic processes were quite common.

And then a Freiburg economist, together with his colleagues, thinks about the disempowerment of all these powerful individuals! He designs an order in which the state leaves as much as possible to the free play of competition – but does not set the rules itself. An order that neither subjects the individual to state paternalism nor to a market where the strong can become so powerful that they determine the rules themselves. An order that aimed at "the concern for social justice" and – to fulfill this concern – at the highest possible economic policy effectiveness.

Anyone who keeps this in mind can only find it very strange that the term "neoliberal" is so negatively charged today. After all, Eucken and his colleagues themselves, as so-called "neoliberals," opposed this pure "laissez-faire," which is so often attributed to neoliberalism today. I am not telling you anything new here in this hall. But in our public debates, I do wish for more intellectual honesty, a closer look. And with that, I also wish for a bit more historical awareness and recognition for the broad spectrum of liberalism in our country, which ranges from Eucken and his idea of an ordering state to Friedrich August von Hayek, who trusted "spontaneous orders" more than the state.

In any case, Eucken's thinking was directed against both the "laissez-faire" of the 19th century and the totalitarian pretensions of the 20th century. This was not only a contradiction against the spirit of the times. It was also remarkably courageous. For with this, Walter Eucken challenged the claim to power of the National Socialists. Their ideology was deeply repugnant to him. He seems to have made no secret of it – according to all accounts. He advocated for Jewish colleagues, protested against the Gleichschaltung of the university – Martin Heidegger had been rector there since May 1933. Later, Eucken sought contact with Freiburg resistance circles and developed – together with others – economic policy guidelines for the hoped-for "after." He took a high personal risk with this. After the assassination attempt on Hitler on July 20, 1944, Eucken was arrested and interrogated by the Gestapo, while other colleagues were sent to concentration camps. Walter Eucken showed then what others lacked: integrity and humanity in a time when so many did not want to see the inhumane.

With this attitude, he also provided guidance to young people in the years after the war. A beautiful testament to this is the speech of one of his students in 1950 at the memorial service for him. The student said: "By showing us that and how a truly dignified order of society and the economy is possible, he also began to create order in the hearts of his students." And that was of enormous importance in that time of lost standards!

The term "order policy" likely sounded good to most post-war Germans, but what lay behind it – not a state-directed economy, but an order of as free competition as possible – was viewed with skepticism: Trade unions hoped for nationalization in the early post-war years, and many citizens did as well. Industry representatives hoped for a return to cherished cartels. It was therefore quite a success that, in the end, although not all, essential elements of the ordoliberal conception could be implemented.

I do not want to go into the merits, the details, and the stages in detail here: the chutzpah of Erhard, who enforced the release of prices in 1948, the astonished people in front of the well-stocked shop windows the day after the currency reform, or the long struggle for the cartel law. Ultimately, the brilliant compromise formula of the "Social Market Economy," conceived by Alfred Müller-Armack, took effect. Not everything that flourished in the economic miracle, of course, grew on its soil. There were the Marshall Plan loans, we remember, and there was also a steady influx of labor from the East.

But in retrospect, we can say: It was not only an economic miracle, but it was also a miracle of freedom that happened. The Germans were able – at least in the West – to reconcile with the market and competition. The Freiburg School had a significant share in this!

This could now be the happy ending: The social market economy has prevailed, and that’s good! And it is indeed the case: German companies successfully sell their products worldwide, and we enjoy – thanks to this economic success – not only material prosperity but also a social standard that exists in only a few countries in the world.

Yet many Germans consider the market economy to be efficient but not just. They associate market economy – according to a recent survey – with "good supply of goods" and "prosperity," but also with "greed" and "ruthlessness." This is, of course, nothing new. Similar research into the soul of the Germans has revealed relatively constant sympathies for state interventions in the economy for decades. Even Federal President Heuss spoke of the "emotionally charged anti-capitalism" of the Germans, which he rightly considered an "unreflective anti-liberalism."

For me, this implies: Not everything is getting worse. To put it casually: One need not despair if one – like me – considers the social market economy to be an achievement. But of course, there is also reason to ask why so many consistently doubt – not to follow the doubters, but to engage with them!

For some, the necessity to shape their own lives freely is more of a burden than a blessing. Freedom has not only the beautiful, opportunity-opening side. It also releases from bonds, it awakens uncertainty and fears. The beginning of freedom is always accompanied by powerful fears. Thus, the word "freedom" sounds threatening to someone who longs not for openness but for manageability. And then there is the constant pressure to assert one's position against others! Many doubt the competition that determines our existence. It begins at the latest in school and accompanies us – not only in professional life or in business but also in sports, in art, in culture. Democracy itself is inconceivable without competition. As a country, we are again not only in competition with our economy but also with our social model against other nations.

But fundamentally, far too many find competition rather uncomfortable. It is exhausting to have to constantly measure oneself against others. And if we must constantly assert ourselves anew, we can also fail again and again. That is the paradox of the free order: I know so many who once feared being locked up, who sought and longed for freedom, but now they fear it, they also fear being left behind. This is humanly understandable, but it is worth explaining what competition is above all, at least when it is fair: Then it is an opening force. It breaks up long-established privileges and cemented power structures and thus offers space for more participation, more involvement. It ideally offers a second and further chances even in the event of failure. And when it is designed correctly, it is also just.

Injustice thrives precisely where competition is restricted: through protectionism, corruption, or state-imposed consideration for individual interests, where the followers of a particular party determine who may achieve which position, or where the rich and powerful change the rules to their advantage and thus arbitrarily allocate life opportunities. We do not have to look very far to register all this in various forms even today. Terms like oligarchy and plutocracy quickly come to mind. And when we speak of globalization today, we should not overlook that there are large economic areas characterized by state-capitalist power exercise or a rather early capitalist understanding of entrepreneurship.

That is why there is so much explosive power in Walter Eucken's simple fundamental insight: Only the limitation of power through free, fair competition enables the many to participate. That is why it is so important to ensure that competition does not benefit a few powerful individuals but offers opportunities to as many people as possible. And that is why it must be defended, if necessary, against all those economic forces that seek to unilaterally change the rules of the game or establish privileges under the guise of freedom. And we must also be vigilant that the state does not distort competition – sometimes in the quite understandable intention of supporting certain groups or areas in their development.

How free an economic constitution is ultimately depends not only on what is available for purchase in the shops but on whether it opens up the opportunity for all citizens to lead a self-responsible life and whether it offers as many options as possible to as many people as possible.

Even well-intentioned interventions by the state can lead to people being excluded rather than included in the long term. When is state care necessary, and when does it lead recipients to no longer see the point in striving for their own livelihood? You know how intensely we debated this during the reforms of the Agenda 2010. We must continue to do so. I envision an activating social policy as a safety net that cushions falls, helping those in need to get back up and stand up for themselves.

However, activating social policy has another indispensable dimension for me, which is closely linked to equal opportunities. The disempowerment of individuals through competition may be a necessary condition for enabling many to participate, but it is not sufficient. For it does not empower the many. Even if everyone is allowed to play by the same rules, it still matters what resources one has when entering the playing field. What would we say if a middleweight boxer had to face off against a heavyweight, or if a runner with a leg amputation had to compete against one with two healthy legs? Equal opportunity thus has prerequisites that lie outside of competition.

We see this particularly clearly in the area of education: children from less educated families are five times less likely to graduate from high school than children from more educated families. We have become accustomed to this state of affairs. But these children are certainly not less intelligent. They simply receive far less of what they will later need to choose from various options at the beginning of their lives. What good does it do to say that we equip all schools equally when children with vastly different backgrounds are sitting there? There are even those for whom no one ensures that they are there every day, or those who simply lack a role model that says, "You must strive, because you can achieve something, and then you can be proud of it." Everyone must reach the finish line on their own. But when it comes to learning to run, we need to help more than we have so far.

Not less, but better-designed competition makes our market economy fairer. When it comes to how this should happen, the name "Walter Eucken" is still often mentioned today.

Eucken himself would probably have been little pleased to be co-opted by a party. He often mocked the "ideologies and wishful thinking of all kinds" that swirl around in everyday discussions about economic policy. He believed: "Economic policy discussion should not be a discussion about doctrines, but about concrete regulatory tasks." There are still more than enough of these doctrines today. But there are also more than enough regulatory tasks, such as the regulation of finances and financial markets.

What the financial and debt crisis has caused is known to every young job seeker in Spain and Greece. This crisis clearly shows us what expands freedom and what restricts it. When we think of "crisis policy," we think of rescue packages for banks and states that had to be hastily put together over the weekend and consisted of substantial sums, of reform programs that became unavoidable. However, we too rarely think of a process that aims for a steady improvement of conditions through careful consideration of arguments, as we would wish in a free democracy. When the crisis is present, it is often too late for that.

Why does this happen? Because something was wrong before the crisis. The regulatory framework of the financial markets has not ensured worldwide that banks limited their risks to a manageable level and were liable for their losses. Banks hold power because they are too big to fail – or seem to be? States become dependent because they have not implemented reforms in time, have catered to too many demands, and their debts have become too large. Here too: the opposite of freedom. Now reforms are being made in many areas. Often, it is about exemplary regulatory concerns, about breaking up power structures, dismantling privileges, and ensuring that those who cause losses are held accountable: thus, about competition, freedom, and responsibility.

In some areas, power structures are being broken up, while in others, they are forming anew – often also emerging from the desired competition, particularly among companies that are especially innovative. While it would likely no longer be possible for an Alfred Hugenberg to maintain such concentrated power today, we would certainly find similar examples elsewhere. In Germany, however, the Federal Cartel Office would intervene, and in Europe, the competition authority of the European Commission. Both are quite successful. But what about globally operating internet companies, for example? How do we create a framework today that allows for innovation but protects against excesses and thus preserves the freedom of citizens?

Regulatory policy is today more than ever a task that goes far beyond the framework of the nation-state. The creation of the internal market in the European Union shows how economic success arises from competition – and how genuine competition can only emerge when power structures are broken up. Not least for this reason, the internal market is one of the important projects of European unification. How global frameworks can be established to promote the freedom of all is a significant yet inadequately solved global problem – despite the existing approaches: I think of the work of the G20, the United Nations, and institutions like the World Trade Organization or the World Bank.

The guiding principle of the social market economy, which is part of our country's self-understanding, could also inspire globally. It is a learning system that does not prescribe all goals but is constantly future-proof. It can be measured by the claim to give individuals the space to decide for themselves, to be active and inventive. It challenges us to reflect on our own freedom in the freedom of others. It is not a perfect model, but one that allows for openness, one with which we can lose, but above all, one with which we can win, and at the same time, one that creates social balance. And one more remark that is important to me in this context: What does not happen due to a lack of political and social will should not be blamed on the market economy, but on our own inability to organize what needs to be organized and can also be organized.

By the way, we should not hope to set the right framework once and for all. There is no ideal state that can be planned or reformed by the state. Nor can all risks be eliminated from a market economy. Those who believe that will be permanently disappointed. And those who assert that will permanently disappoint.

The task of economics remains, as Walter Eucken already said, to enlighten "about the complex interrelationships of modern society that are not accessible to intuition." The Walter Eucken Institute takes on this task. I wish for you much of Eucken's willingness to engage in the "radicality of questioning" – this distinguished man wanted to be uncomfortable, to dare to contradict, while arguing soberly and factually.

Economists should be a "visual aid" for politics and society. They cannot do that if they prefer the clarity and aesthetics of their theoretical models to the realities and interconnections in society. And they cannot do that if they exhaust themselves in reverting to established maxims. However, they can do it well if they combine courage and will for what they see as desirable with political relevance.

In the end, however, it is up to politics – and thus to all of us – to take responsibility for the order in which we live and want to live. Walter Eucken and his companions did that back then – and inscribed themselves in the history of freedom of this country. Let us continue to write it!