Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the celebratory event for the 60th anniversary of the Federal Social Court on September 11, 2014, in Kassel:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

18 September 2014 · 60th anniversary celebration of the Federal Social Court · Kassel, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed a celebratory event marking the 60th anniversary of the Federal Social Court on September 11, 2014, in Kassel, Germany.
Main themes
Federal Social Court anniversary, German welfare state history, social rule of law, judicial independence, GDR social policy critique, democratic solidarity, Basic Law social principles, rule of law vs. authoritarianism, social insurance history, individual rights and freedom
Duration
~19 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,240
62nd percentile
Sentences
101
63rd percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
12.3
49th percentile
Syntax
3.09
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 50%50%
  • Social 31%31%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

101 sentences in 22 paragraphs

Today we celebrate something precious – the Federal Social Court, a significant part of our democratic community. Therefore, to you and to all of us: Congratulations!

The idea of the German welfare state is, however, significantly older than 60 years. It goes back even further than Otto von Bismarck and his social legislation. Core elements can already be found in the Vormärz movement and among the Democrats of 1848. The social question was raised in Germany very early and very emphatically. And the institutionalized response in the form of social insurance – against the vicissitudes of life such as old age, illness, accident, or unemployment – has survived all changes of government and systems, from the Empire through the Weimar Republic and National Socialism, the GDR dictatorship to the Federal Republic. The promise of solidarity expressed in social insurance has today, as it did then, a particularly high significance for our political self-understanding.

What we value in our social rule of law: The connection of freedom, individual fundamental rights, and responsibility is not an option, but an obligation.

For me personally, this form of welfare state in democracy was for a long time the alternative model known only from a distance to that "welfare dictatorship" that existed in the GDR. Before you stands someone who only became a citizen of the Federal Republic in 1990 and who experienced an authoritarian-paternalistic system in the first half of his life, in which every form of care was somehow also associated with paternalism. Every promise of protection could be followed by repression.

The people in the GDR lived a daily life of deficient or damaged law. There was, among other things, no constitutional court, nor an autonomous social or administrative jurisdiction. I still remember very well that in certain conflict situations of life, the path of submission had to be taken. Like in ancient times, when one still appealed to the prince's kindness, charity, or fidelity to the law. But the person submitting was a citizen. The "socialist welfare state," as it was called in the Ulbricht era, did indeed have a legal form – it was clothed in legal terminology. And if we look at the entire course of the GDR, we even see a certain tendency towards legal formalization, especially where this legal formalization was supposed to demonstrate superiority in the ideological competition with the Western bloc. I take the right to work, Article 24 of the GDR Constitution, as a particularly well-known example. Many people socialized in the planned economy can still quote the showcase argument of secure jobs today. But the advantage of employment for all was indeed associated with the constant overburdening of the state budget and favored the economic failure of the GDR economy.

Back to what was called the "social welfare state" in the GDR. On paper, certain avenues for complaint did exist – there was also a family code since the 1960s and a civil code that followed in the 1970s. But in practice, the SED leadership had control over everything, actually over all instances. In the files of the State Security, one can find thousands of pieces of evidence for this. The law simply followed the interests of the powerful, not the interests of the citizens or even the principle of equality.

Precisely because I have such painful memories of the absence of independent jurisdiction, the independence of our courts and thus also of the Federal Social Court means so much to me: In this country, there exists for everyone the right to be heard in legal matters, thus the legal path is open – independent of good behavior and solely oriented to law and justice and bound to our Basic Law.

There, in Articles 20 and 28, the principle of the welfare state was anchored in 1949, among other things in the remarkable formulation "social rule of law." Let me say, as a lover of both literature and democracy, I find this term both audacious and beautiful. Audacious because it actually brings together something that has traditionally not been thought together. Beautiful because it makes our democratic community something that can evoke the affection, not just the approval, of many for the democratic community. This term is remarkable because, in international comparison of constitutional texts, it is unusual and also remarkable because this term, despite its material indeterminacy, defined a constitutional norm in striking brevity – the duty of the state to ensure a just social order.

From this arose a mandate for those constitutional bodies – foremost the parliamentary legislator – that are responsible for implementing socio-political tasks. Social care, the creation of "social" security systems, the establishment of equal opportunities – all of this can be derived because "social" in the Basic Law is not only understood as a virtue, not as charity or a discretionary provision. It has a binding place in the catalog of norms. Whether someone falls into a state of emergency through their own fault or not: State assistance for all those in need is a valid fundamental principle. It is therefore about a right and not about a charity. The largely liberal character of our Basic Law has thus received a truly decisive complement and revolution. Alongside the formal justice reflected in the rule of law principle, there is also a binding component of material justice with the "social rule of law."

The detailed design is, as is well known, reflected in federal, state, and municipal laws and regulations; it is a permanent topic in societal discourse, in parliamentary groups, but also in families and at regulars' tables. Controversial interpretations of what needs to be done and what needs to be provided find their way from the social courts through the state social courts to here to the Federal Social Court.

With the professional specialization of social jurisdiction, Germany occupies a special position. Just ten years ago – for the 50th anniversary – many voices were heard calling for a merger of the social and administrative courts. Something has been clearly said about that here. And shortly thereafter, when we look at your areas of responsibility after this debate, new areas of responsibility were added: the Asylum Seekers Benefits Act and the areas of SGB II and XII, colloquially known as the Hartz IV laws, which have high case numbers. I have the impression that, especially in light of how you have managed this increase since 2005, it can be said today: The independent social jurisdiction in our country has proven itself!

I say this not only because the Federal Social Court has the shortest processing times despite extraordinarily high incoming numbers.

The pace and complexity of legal changes in your field are completely impressive to an outsider – and for every sociologist, they are something like a paradise! With the chronicle of the Federal Social Court, societal change can be experienced like in fast motion. Since 1954, for example, the effects of new work and family models have been examined here; just think of women's employment. The pension reforms and the generational contract, the introduction of long-term care insurance, and the integration of what were then called guest workers, not to mention the problem of demographic change, all of this is reflected in your judgments. Consequential and large-scale shifts should not be forgotten: There is also Europeanization, globalization, and recently the consequences of international law. Just with the implementation of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, you will probably still be able to fill entire file cabinets in your office.

At this point, even though thanks usually come at the end, Mr. President, amidst the abundance of topics, I would like to express my great appreciation for the work done here. What the judges at the Federal Social Court and also your colleagues in the lower courts accomplish is outstanding!

And it gives me great pleasure to know so many honorary judges among you. My heartfelt thanks go to all of you. The success record that this anniversary makes visible is also your personal achievement!

After a balance sheet, a look ahead must not be missing.

The position paper for today's anniversary – I will only receive it later, but I have already been informed about it – carries the word "challenges" right in the title. I have also heard that it is 800 pages long. This means an enormous amount of learning material, an invitation to reflection and exchange. And it is also supposed to invite interdisciplinary discourse, as countless questions about the welfare state will be found there. It would be nice if the Federal President would now present a concluding statement that encompasses all the essential elements in the position paper. But I cannot do that – let’s say it this way: I am still thinking. And I am also pleased that a festive publication can also be a position paper. And when I say here that I am still thinking, it means: Of course, I want to engage with the important theses and topics, and I also know that this is necessary because the further development of the welfare state does not always proceed easily. It is also associated with conflicts, as we know. Often it is the balance of demanding and supporting that causes us problems. And the state must continually redefine whether it is an activating or a preventive state. This balance is not always easy to find. This is also shown to us by debates in other countries, such as in Scandinavia. For me, in this matter: There is no either-or. Both must succeed: It must be ensured that there is cushioning for social hardships. But it must also not be lacking that there is empowerment for individuals to lead and shape a life on their own.

What is often missing are the right impulses on a personal level. One example: Last weekend, the citizens' festival took place again at my Schloss Bellevue in Berlin, a meeting of many volunteers from all over the Federal Republic. We had over 4,000 volunteers and other guests in the park of Schloss Bellevue. All people who are engaged voluntarily – from all over Germany. I also met active individuals who advocate for young people from educationally disadvantaged backgrounds or for those coming from migrant families. They do this with reading sponsorships or as participants in mentoring programs, in study and career counseling. And in everything I was told, the tenor was always the same: There is no lack of information brochures about scholarships, nor of access to a library or university. But there is often a lack of encouraging signals from the environment – and from a young age: You can do it if you focus on performance, if you recognize your potential, if the struggle for recognition and advancement does not remain a dream, but if you try your best, if you do not give up before you have even started. Speaking to young people like this does not harm them; it strengthens them.

This means to me: Social policy is determined not only by money but also by the social climate. I now know that this is not a legal specialist topic here. But I am also aware that there are people in this room who look far beyond the confines of their legal specialty.

Looking beyond the confines should apply in multiple respects: Our welfare state is no longer shaped solely at the national level. Numerous external factors must be taken into account; just think of internal migration within the EU with the accompanying problems, think of migration movements. And it is likely that in the coming years, this problem will increase significantly in importance. A challenge not only for politics but for civil society – and as we can easily deduce from the past, also for you and for the people working at various levels of the social courts. Just looking at these problem areas and the highly diverse manifestations of the welfare state that exist in the European Union gives us a glimpse of how great not only the intellectual-legal but also the political challenges will be in the coming decade.

With concern, I have read that you, dear Mr. Masuch, lament a noticeable loss of significance in social policy research in the August issue of the journal "Social Jurisdiction." During the judges' week, there was even talk of an "era of social reform in blind flight." I would prefer not to hear that at all, but someone must have found it significant to choose this pointed formulation. It is far from me to interfere in the science policy of the federal and state governments; that is truly not my place, but I would like to know where exactly you see the deficits and what steps could be taken to improve the situation. If you wish, Mr. President, I would like to invite you and other experts to visit me at Schloss Bellevue and discuss this topic in the company of some experts. Consider this now as a counter-invitation, a verbal request.

Let us take a moment to recognize what a blessing it is for us to celebrate today a constitutional and highly specialized part of our social state. I wish the Federal Social Court to remain what it is, by continuing to prove itself daily in step with events and – where necessary – to change consciously: dynamically, challengingly, and independently.