Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the end of his term on the question "What should our country look like?" from the inaugural address on March 23, 2012, on January 18, 2017, in ...

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

23 January 2017 · Farewell speech at the end of term as Federal President

Context
Gauck delivered his farewell address in January 2017, reflecting on nearly five years as Federal President and the challenges facing Germany and liberal democracy.
Main themes
Future of German democracy, threats to liberal democracy, European unity and cohesion, transatlantic relations and NATO, rise of nationalist movements, civil society and democratic values, freedom and social balance, generational responsibility, Western political order, German foreign policy limitations, Islamist terrorism, end-of-term reflection
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,584
89th percentile
Sentences
221
91st percentile
Readability
38
32nd percentile
Grade
13.0
57th percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
39th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 34%32%
  • Geopolitical 29%27%
  • Social 27%25%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

221 sentences in 69 paragraphs

When I took office as Federal President almost five years ago, I asked my fellow citizens and myself what this country should look like, the one to which our children and grandchildren will one day say "our country." And I found much that we can build upon and that makes me grateful and optimistic for the future. In thousands of encounters, I have also felt the strength, the energy that the citizens of this country develop for one another, for democracy, freedom, and progress. And I have had the privilege of seeing Germany through the eyes of others. During my numerous trips abroad, I experienced the respect, indeed sometimes even the admiration, that is shown towards our free and stable country.

Yes: We live in a republic that enables personal happiness and advancement and seeks to combine freedom with equal opportunities and social balance. The law is not in the hands of power. Administrative and constitutional courts guarantee that citizens can assert their rights against the state. Free trade unions help shape the world of work, as does a responsible business community. The social market economy, culture, and the arts can flourish, and free media in great diversity invigorate discourse and promote the formation of opinions. And then, particularly pleasing: A strong civil society made up of initiatives, associations, foundations, non-governmental organizations, and ad-hoc groups influences the shaping of public affairs. It is, I believed then and I believe today, the best, the most democratic Germany we have ever had. But when I think of the generations to come, I wish for the courage to face current challenges in such a way that this country remains a great place to live – ideally without some of the shortcomings we know.

Now, after almost five years, I am more strongly influenced by the awareness that this democratic and stable Germany is also threatened. And that great efforts will be necessary to make it strong for the future. Therefore, today I want to ask not only: What should our country look like? More importantly, I also want to ask: What can we pass on to our children and grandchildren so that this peaceful, free, and social Germany can be preserved and developed? And above all: With what attitude should this be achieved?

Even a small selection of the headlines from the past two years that we have just seen reminds us: The world is not only full of contradictions. Many things have simply turned out differently than we imagined a good quarter of a century ago – back then, we remember, when the Berlin Wall fell and we nurtured the dream of a Europe of free and liberal democracies. I still remember well the general euphoria, of course also my own. The triumph of the Western model of society was considered a foregone conclusion. A "new era of democracy, peace, and unity," as the Charter of Paris depicted, seemed almost a natural necessity to me.

Instead, today in Europe we are neither all united nor do we live in peace everywhere. The binding force of the European Union has clearly diminished, and doubts from within are also being fueled from the outside. For the first time, a state even wants to leave the Union. The wars in the Middle East and in Eastern Ukraine, as well as the Russian occupation of Crimea, have revealed the limited options for German and European foreign policy. The threat from Islamist terror has grown. With the inauguration of the new American president, we face challenges for the international order and transatlantic relations, especially NATO.

The expectations from the end of history have long since been shattered – everywhere in Europe, of course also in Germany.

The goal was freedom – now some feel threatened or even lost in freedom.

The goal was a Europe without borders – now some see openness as a threat.

The goal was a united continent – now some fear the loss of too much of their own sovereignty.

In our societies, movements are also emerging that present counter-proposals but lack coherent programs. Yet their line of thought is clearly revealed: They advocate a return to the national, the defense against foreigners and free trade. They prefer cultural homogeneity over diversity and present competing models to representative democracy. They declare themselves the sole spokesperson for the people and attack the so-called system. They question the European project. Some mix anti-American and anti-Western reflexes with sympathies for authoritarian rule in Moscow.

We cannot avoid facing this challenge: Liberal democracy and the political, normative project of the West are under fire.

It is as if we are all in a transitional situation: The extent – as many feel it – to which we are confronted with uncertainties exceeds so far the extent to which we are capable of adapting our democracy to the new challenges.

Every generation must make its own experiences. But a look into history can indeed be helpful. We see that powerful fears have often accompanied significant historical upheavals: the fear of freedom, the fear of risk, and also the fear of losing identity-forming bonds in religion, culture, and familiar surroundings. And yet: People have always managed to turn a development initially perceived as threatening to their advantage. They have familiarized themselves with the unfamiliar, opened up expanded realms of knowledge and action, and ultimately found a home in the new.

Just think of the time of the industrial revolution: It first upheaved society with an unprecedented suddenness and created immense wealth, but also glaring misery. But then the resistance against Manchester capitalism led to revolutions or social reforms, later to the social market economy and to relative prosperity even for workers. Why should we not take historical experiences like these seriously?

We want to continue to trust that great changes do not have to prove to be an inescapable, overwhelming fate. We remain convinced that we can find effective answers – to political developments as well as to climate change, environmental pollution, population growth, and even to the digital revolution, which will soon permeate almost all areas of our lives and is likely to change our image of humanity significantly. So let us draw strength from the previous experience that reasoned perception can lead to understanding and to determined and far-sighted action.

Determined action – yes, but that can be difficult in times of change, when what is just growing can only be recognized to a limited extent, and we must temporarily endure uncertainty. It is also difficult to act decisively when a society that has lived in peace and prosperity for decades has become comfortably settled and shies away from risk.

On the one hand, we have many volunteers and engaged citizens who give our country an inner structure of cohesion and solidarity. But on the other hand, there exists in parts of society an entitlement mentality that sees the state solely as a service provider, from which they expect, like customers, that it satisfies their expectations and wishes as comprehensively as possible. But democracy is not a political mail-order business. Democracy is co-determination of one's own fate – in the community, city, region, and nation. Democracy is based on the free citizen, who does not relinquish imagination and responsibility to a strong man or woman who dictates the way forward. Democracy requires – yes, it is – self-empowerment: We, the citizens, are the ones who decide on the shape of our community. And we, the citizens, bear the responsibility for the future of our children and grandchildren.

Keeping pace with reality is, of course, a particular challenge for governments in times of rapid change. We are witnessing diverse efforts to maintain or regain control and to develop ideas and strategies for change in the present. In general, it holds true: Those who become mired in indecision and risk aversion during such phases, or who stop halfway, may have to pay a very high price, financially and – more importantly – politically, in the broadest sense: externally, socially, legally, and in terms of security. I would like to remind you of just two important current problem areas:

First:

It has been possible to significantly reduce the number of refugees and illegal immigrants coming to Europe and Germany. But everyone knows: Without efficient protection of the European external borders, without a regulated European immigration policy, and ultimately without improving living conditions in the countries of origin, crisis-like escalations can be expected in the future as well. And some European societies may also be overwhelmed by the reception and integration of a large number of refugees and migrants.

Secondly:

It has been achieved, with enormous effort, to develop instruments for the stabilization of the Euro in order not to abandon the common currency. But everyone knows that the future of the common currency would probably be best secured in the long term with a common budget and financial policy.

Decisive and far-sighted action generates trust. But if parts of the population no longer see the rulers as masters of the situation, populists have one more reason to sow doubt about liberal democracy.

However, we must ensure that what the American political scientist Francis Fukuyama warns against does not happen: that the term populism becomes a label "with which political elites label the unpopular political views of ordinary citizens" and exclude them from discourse in general.

Yes, the inclusion of positions and topics that are critically viewed by the political center certainly intensifies the debate – but it can also be helpful, as it increases the acceptance of democratic governance in the medium term. That is what we want: A representative democracy should represent as many citizens as possible. This does not mean, of course, to legitimize resentments and to elevate prejudices to the status of arguments.

I think: We must dare to communicate in a way that involves many more people than before and not just those who regularly participate in political discourse. Exchange and discussion are the oxygen of an open society; debate is its invigorating element. This may not please some, but it seems appropriate to remind us of this right now.

The multitude of life plans has given rise to a variety of milieus in our society, each with its own communication pathways. Plurality often no longer exists in a coexistence but in an unconnected parallelism or even opposition. Therefore, it is all the more important to counteract fragmentation, preferably through encounters with people who think differently than oneself. A substantial engagement is often the precursor to a compromise and the starting point for change – and thus for the development of democracy.

That is why I support the almost paradoxical proposal of the English historian Timothy Garton Ash, who calls for a "robust civility" in the culture of discussion. This surely means: to argue fiercely – but with respect and sometimes with a thick skin. To argue fiercely, but like in sports, recognizing the rules.

Democracy is a large tent. For me, the togetherness within it ends only where parties, movements, and individuals violate the norms and laws of democracy. Where they preach hate and commit violence – regardless of whether from right or left extremist, Islamist, or any other motivation.

We live in rough times: Often it is no longer clear what is true and what is false. Especially in social networks, there is almost limitless lying, insulting, and hurting. Foreign powers are also deliberately waging information wars to destabilize other states. This is made easier by the fact that emotions have often become more decisive for opinion formation than facts. We should keep in mind: If we only accept as fact what we already believe, if half-truths, interpretations, conspiracy theories, or rumors count just as much as truth, then the space is opened for demagogues and autocrats.

Only if we hold on to facts, if we hold on to truth, can power be evaluated and – where necessary – criticized. Let us not allow power to prevail again without truth-based argumentation. Instead, let us defend democracy as a power that entrusts itself to argument and allows itself to be guided by it.

Recently, a friend told me that on a quiet evening she took the Basic Law from her bookshelf and read it – once again, and quite consciously. And to her own surprise, the reading not only reached her mind but also her heart. She suddenly felt proud of her ancestors who established Germany on a democratic foundation after so many years of war and dictatorship. And she felt strengthened within herself because she realized how modern the Basic Law still is and why its norms and spirit can continue to serve as a guideline for thought and action.

That evening, this woman felt politically affiliated. Affiliated to a civic society that values the institutions and principles that have brought our country freedom, prosperity, legal certainty, social security, and peace. Affiliated to citizens who are ready to represent and defend what they do not want to lose because it is dear and valuable to them.

I mention this example because it is a small proof that the term constitutional patriotism, born in the academic world, is not just a theorem but can be a reality – wherever people feel this inclination towards democracy. It refutes all those who consider constitutional patriotism to be a pale, bloodless construct, a makeshift solution from the times of a divided and morally discredited nation.

My own bond to the constitution, that is, my own constitutional patriotism, results not only from intellectual insight but also from emotional touch. This country is the home of my values – it has become that. Especially for this reason, I feel a sense of belonging here, at home.

Like many of my generation, I was only able to develop trust and belonging to Germany late, when it no longer ran away from its own guilt but dared to engage in existential self-examination. Ultimately, it is the miracle of democracy in post-war West Germany and the later "yes" of East Germans to democracy with the Peaceful Revolution that has made me a constitutional patriot in this Germany, with both my heart and my mind. I shared with countless others the experience that the goals of our longing, that freedom and self-determination actually became political reality.

As a constitutional patriot, I remain, of course, a German. I live with our language, with our songs, with our literature. I live with our beautiful landscapes and with our incredibly eventful history. Appreciating a democratic constitution with universal values does not mean shedding one's own culture or ignoring historically grown peculiarities.

Let me just remind you in this context of the development of our constitutionally anchored welfare state – an achievement that many other countries in the world envy us for. Socialist and social democratic ideas merged with conservative notions of a Christian image of humanity during the 19th century: Through state redistribution, help was to be provided to those who fell into need. Bismarck's health and accident insurance, however inadequate it may have been, made Germany a pioneer of a state social system that has historically continued to develop.

Forty-five years ago, Willy Brandt said: "Germans, we can be proud of our country!" I could not have spoken like that back then. This applies, when I listen to this sentence, especially to the inner peace that we have created in Germany, not least because of our welfare state, but also through growing equality of opportunity. Our country cannot give every citizen a filled vault, but it is essential to enable the many different people to receive the education they desire. Unfortunately, this is still not the case everywhere today, but we have made good progress on the way to greater equality of opportunity. These and other precious achievements must not be put at risk. We must exert considerable imagination and great will to make them future-proof for generations to come.

Our historical experiences also shape other core areas of the Basic Law. Under the impression of the Weimar Republic, which proved defenseless against the rise of National Socialism, the creators of the Basic Law made a clear directional decision. The new German democracy was to be not weak but resilient. It was to – as Carlo Schmid, one of the great post-war politicians, said – "also have the courage to be intolerant towards those who want to use democracy to destroy it."

Under the impression of National Socialism, which persecuted all opposition and subjected the individual to a dictatorial regime, many have also retained a fear of a strong state. Liberal defenders of fundamental rights, for example, fear that increased security measures could restrict individual freedoms too much. We face a dilemma: Yes, freedom restricts those who give disproportionate space to security. But the rule of law loses if it proves to be too weak or even helpless in the fight against violence and terror. Not least, it loses its credibility.

Let me remind you: In Germany, there exists a precious, by no means self-evident good – the widespread legal loyalty of the population. This attitude has arisen because people could rely on the ordering and protective hand of the state. It is one of the outstanding tasks of the democratic state to preserve this valuable good. In this respect, it is currently the case that more security does not pose a danger to democracy; rather, more security is a requirement for its protection.

We need closer international cooperation and more effective internal threat prevention. What we particularly need, however, is effective prevention through political, cultural, and religious education, so that people do not fall under the spell of extremists of any kind. We need democracy education, continuing and even more intensively than before – starting in families, but also in kindergartens, schools, integration courses, universities, and extending into the media, especially and particularly on the internet.

Living and learning democracy – as respect for the other.

Learning and living democracy – as responsibility for the community.

Learning and living democracy – as constant self-empowerment for political participation.

Then we notice: Democracy is not simply; democracy becomes. It lives, and it is capable of learning. New topics, new generations, and new communication worlds require new, timely, and needs-adapted responses again and again. For example, the state has integrated the protection of ethnic, religious, or sexual minorities into the democratic framework. It has opened up new areas of law, such as data protection law, environmental law, and now faces the great challenge of regulating digital technology. The mills of democracy may grind slowly, but history shows that despite some setbacks, no other system is as politically and economically adaptable, effective, and thus successful as democracy.

The mothers and fathers of our constitution wanted not only a resilient, a combative democracy, but also a values-based democracy. They aimed for peace and justice and placed the protection of human dignity under an eternity clause that excludes any change. Thus, we now have both: an unbreakable, protected foundation for our democracy and an open space in which plurality is to thrive. This dialectical interplay of binding and freedom has gained even more significance over the decades. Because society has become much more heterogeneous – politically, culturally, religiously, ethnically, and also in terms of the recognition of sexual orientation.

In the young immigration country of Germany, this interplay of binding and freedom remains a challenge time and again. Thus, locals and immigrants are, on the one hand, obliged to respect the constitution and the laws equally. On the other hand, it is left to locals and immigrants to live according to their own cultural or religious beliefs – as they individually see fit and as long as they do not restrict the freedom of others.

For a thriving coexistence, however, the willingness to be open is required: from some towards the majority society, from others towards the minorities. Some must want participation, and others must enable participation. What has no place in this coexistence are defamation, incitement, exclusion, and hatred, and certainly no violence against immigrants. On the other hand, the fear of being accused of racism must not lead us to silence intolerance and violations of norms among immigrants or to refrain from discussing which understanding of Islam, for example, fits a secular, democratic society.

Let me put it this way: The decisive dividing line in our democracy does not run between long-established residents and newcomers, nor between Christians, Muslims, Jews, or atheists. The decisive dividing line runs between democrats and non-democrats. It does not matter where one comes from; what matters is the attitude. Especially among immigrants, there are many who highly appreciate our country because they have found prosperity here and can live in peace, freedom, and legal certainty, far from their homeland and yet at the destination of their longing.

Those who love democracy will protect it, not only against the enemies of open society from within. Those who make respect for human dignity a core essence of their own constitution will also take co-responsibility for the preservation of the international order, whose core consists of shared norms and values and whose goal is the maintenance of peace and law.

We have long known: Germany cannot isolate itself, cannot shut itself off from the world, cannot simply retreat into the national. Peace and well-being in one's own country are inextricably linked to peace and well-being elsewhere, and institutionally we are intertwined with international organizations and military alliances of which Germany is a member. What happens in China, for example, has repercussions on our lives in Germany. It would also directly affect us if the United States were to change its stance towards the European Union or the Western security alliance.

Every day confronts us anew with the fact that what is happening in Syria influences migration movements to Germany. And what is happening in Maghreb countries can increase the threat of terrorism in Germany.

Every day also raises the question of whether we will lose our credibility if we do not at least oppose the most dramatic cases of inhumanity, brutal persecution, and the destruction of human lives in the world. We must ask ourselves whether we are becoming morally numb, falling into fatalism or cynicism, and thereby undermining the claim to the universal validity of human rights.

Also on the international stage, it holds true: Those who replace decisive and reflective action with waiting leave others the law of action. Not least through American self-restraint, zones are emerging where powers regroup or assert new claims. Authoritarian leaders are already dictating their own rules, subordinating recognized norms of international cooperation to their power politics, and creating their own orders.

Germany – but actually the whole European Union – can of course watch and engage in damage control. But Germany, as a strong and responsible partner in the Union, can also bring more will to shape the greater whole than before. We can? – No, we must! We must do more to maintain order together with others, to prevent conflicts, to defuse crises, and to deter adversaries. This also means: We must do more to stabilize the European Union and counter internal and external attempts to divide it.

Despite some self-doubt and internal crises: A unique peace and prosperity project has emerged with the European Union. Germany and most other European states are committed members of NATO, whose significance is not diminishing but rather increasing in light of current developments! Germany and the European Union are significant voices in the world. And they have every reason to confidently advocate for the protection of an international order based on the idea of peace, democracy, and human rights. In the face of the enormous challenges ahead of us, we Europeans, we Germans cannot and must not evade this responsibility.

In recent years, a lot has happened. A change in mentality has begun. The political will for effective and efficient engagement has grown. The federal government has developed various instruments to respond to crises, and it is also spending more money for this purpose.

Nevertheless, Germany is currently far from meeting all its obligations. I therefore support the idea that we should uphold what we have promised to our partners and friends. Given the challenges of our time and our capabilities, we could and should do significantly more: for crisis prevention and diplomacy, for development cooperation and United Nations missions, but also for improved defense capabilities within the Western alliance. Because the statement that there can never be a military solution sounds good, and it is good, but only as long as all parties adhere to this maxim. I therefore support increased European defense efforts, which in no way exclude further diplomatic efforts for de-escalation. And I advocate for a clear clarification towards our Eastern European neighbors: NATO's obligation to assist applies without exception.

No one needs to worry that Germany will lose its character as a peace-loving and dialogue-oriented member of the international community. On the contrary: It is about creating the conditions for peacefulness and readiness for dialogue. For this, Germany must engage, if its own country and other European states are not to become pawns in the interests of those who pursue entirely different goals. This is the core of a resilient democracy; this is republican readiness for defense.

After the Second World War, it was not foreseeable that Germany could again become an integral part of Western civilization. And while the builders of the early Federal Republic still doubted whether the deeply fallen Germans could ever become true democrats, the descendants have felt a special responsibility, indeed an obligation, from the knowledge of their ancestors' guilt to live a credible, reliable, and thus immune to seduction "yes" to the newly arisen democracy. It should never again be a nationalist Germany, but a European Germany that they built together, in which the East Germans also aspired to and later found their place.

Self-confidence, which I care so much about, we have long not wanted to live, not been able to live. It seemed too close to a feeling of unreflected pride. And so the dominant culture of restraint and self-limitation emerged. But when, if not with the establishment of democracy in West Germany and the Peaceful Revolution in the East, with the unification of Germany and Europe, would there have been better reasons for healthy self-confidence?

If we overlook the potentials that lie within us, we will remain stuck in an eternal political waiting loop – in a harmful culture of anxiety, indifference, and self-doubt. Until others, with different values and without any self-doubt, lay hands on our way of life, on our freedom.

When I now ask myself what is the most important thing we can pass on to our children and grandchildren, it is above all an attitude: It is the trust in ourselves, the trust in our own strengths. We remain of calm courage.

May fears accompany us: We will not let our trust in ourselves and in our democracy be taken away.

May the seducers praise the false allure of a worn-out nationalism: We remain Germans as Europeans.

May the uncertainties of the times also frighten us: We do not flee from responsibility.

As decisively as we remain true to our values, we pass on a deep conviction that has grown within us: What we have created and what is dear to us, we will preserve, develop, and defend.