Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the festive event "Trust in the Power of the Poor" on the 50th anniversary of the cooperation between the state and churches in the ...

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

8 September 2012 · Festive event "Trust in the Power of the Poor" on the 50th anniversary of the cooperation between the state and churches in development aid

Context
Gauck addressed a festive event marking the 50th anniversary of German state-church development cooperation on September 8, 2012.
Main themes
State-church development cooperation anniversary, poverty and global inequality, solidarity and civic engagement, church-led humanitarian initiatives, foreign aid effectiveness, faith-based development work, courage and action against injustice, David and Goliath metaphor, German development policy, education and health in developing nations
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,589
82nd percentile
Sentences
189
88th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
11.5
38th percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 49%49%
  • Economic 22%22%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Environmental 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

189 sentences in 46 paragraphs

"50 Years of Development Cooperation Between State and Churches"

It is a particular pleasure for me to speak on this occasion, for those who stand against poverty and injustice need strong will, courage, and confidence – all things that are close to my heart and that I wish to strengthen. Today, as well as in the service this morning, many people are gathered here who bring just that: the courage to stand up against resignation and to take action.

You here know: One billion people are hungry worldwide. In the least developed countries, one in ten children does not even reach the age of one. Every two and a half years, 50 to 60 million people die from preventable diseases or poverty worldwide – that is as many victims as the Second World War claimed.

You here know: Alongside this, which weighs heavily on us, there are also successes in global development. For example, more and more children are going to school worldwide, or: fewer people are dying from malaria. And you have contributed to ensuring that poverty does not become overwhelmingly powerful worldwide.

Thus, 50 years of cooperation between state and church development work is a good occasion to reflect on how we should proceed against the seemingly overwhelming Goliath named poverty and injustice, to engage more closely in the fight against it.

You remember: The initial situation of David against Goliath was lamentable. But David did not lament; he went into battle against the overpowering foe, and he had five smooth stones – in development cooperation, there are five areas that seem particularly important to me if we want to succeed in the fight against poverty and its causes. In all of them, the courage and confidence of the active participants, including the churches, play a role.

First:

Development cooperation must convince the citizens of our country. "Those who have seen the poorest of this world feel rich enough to help," Albert Schweitzer already stated. At Easter 1959, the Catholic Church collected funds for the first time under the name Misereor for the poor in the Third World. At that time, only a few people in Germany had personally seen poverty outside Europe. But they knew hunger and need from the last war and the post-war period. Even today, we often see that it is precisely the poorest of the poor who take in refugees from neighboring countries without much questioning and share the little they have. How can we maintain this sense of solidarity in a wealthy society? It is strange that it seems to become more difficult the wealthier and more satiated a society becomes.

Back then, over 35 million DM were raised the first time for Misereor. A substantial sum. This success led the bishops to the good idea of institutionalizing this action. The Protestant counterpart was then Bread for the World. Mercy, solidarity, and social engagement were, by the way, important not only for Christians in the West; they were not limited to this part of Germany.

Even on the eastern side of the "Iron Curtain," Christians engaged in their communities for international cooperation – often with considerable success and not necessarily to the pleasure of the authorities there. When I was a pastor in a Protestant community, development cooperation was supposed to be more about socialist solidarity among the so-called brother nations. We tried to stand against that.

The churches have thrown their weight and their mission into the balance against poverty and have thus kept the commitment to the "distant neighbor" alive. When we read texts from the early years today, we are sometimes taken aback by the vocabulary. We have since developed other terminologies, but the attitude we encounter is similar to ours: Not to stand by, but to engage in solidarity. Two years before the United Nations set the target of 0.7 percent of gross national product for development cooperation, the Protestant regional churches set their own target: In 1968, they decided to allocate two percent of their budget for development projects, and by 1975, it was to be even five percent. The will proved to be greater than the achievement, and we want to note that in passing.

In the federal budget for 2011, about three percent of the total funds are earmarked for development cooperation. One can certainly debate whether that is too much or too little. Just here in this room, there are so many people who could wonderfully engage in that discussion. But one thing cannot be disputed: If citizens are to be convinced that this money is being used sensibly, it cannot be done without information about the results in the partner countries.

Solidarity is never measured solely in euros. What matters are the results for the daily lives of those affected. It is often the lesser problem to build a new school. The greater problem is when teachers work there without training, without curricula, or even without motivation.

Those among us who can report from their own experiences abroad contribute particularly to the persuasive work at home. We must promote this. The churches have made a significant contribution to the establishment of development services that place motivated professionals in developing countries. As early as 1960, groups of craftsmen traveled out.

Today, there are numerous ways to get involved in development cooperation. In German state development cooperation alone, over twenty thousand people work worldwide. Most of them are wholeheartedly committed to the cause. But I also know the cynics who see development cooperation as a well-paid but meaningless job. I think we can agree: A "development industry" must never place its own interests above the development of the partners!

I know: Many people working in development cooperation have become reflective about the effects of their work, about poverty and abundance, and about the significance of solidarity. I believe it does our society good when these people share their experiences with us, in the communities, with the political decision-makers, and also in private settings at family tables.

Those who work far away need many supporters at home. That is why the churches consciously contribute to acceptance in Germany through their development education work. This is extraordinarily important and must not be lost. They explain where it concerns us, under what conditions children in many countries have to work, and what we can do here to ensure that these children have good life chances.

The churches can draw on long experiences and an unparalleled network of contacts to make abstract global questions comprehensible here on the ground, also to examine our behavior in families, authorities, and companies. Thus, love for one's neighbor becomes concrete day by day, and that is good news.

Despite all the frustrations over failures, which also exist in development cooperation and keep arising, the churches can keep the will to combat the causes of poverty alive. The churches do not let themselves be discouraged – so it is not surprising that church development cooperation sometimes enjoys a higher reputation than state cooperation. I believe it was therefore important that we were reminded today in the service where the sources of our hope lie. I have experienced in very different political contexts that believing people sometimes manage to maintain hope longer or more effectively where others have adapted to a "mainstream" and become weary. We must build on such experiences, and you, the active participants in the fields of development cooperation, have the strength that grows from your experience. You have the strength to renew the hope of the many who have not yet been touched by the problems that seem important to us, and thus to enable activities.

My second core statement is: Development cooperation is a partnership community task with those affected on the ground. This may sound banal to some. You have shaped and developed the principles for this way of thinking yourselves. But let’s be honest: How many large development plans have been conceived at a very green table far away, without the planners ever really sitting down with the partners and those in need? You may argue that this was the case in the past, but not today. I would rather not know that too precisely. I believe that we still need to exert a constant effort today to shape the things that matter to us in this partnership discourse. The American development economist William Easterly could fill an entire book on this subject titled "We Are Saving the World to Death." Many of you may know it.

The church development services, on the other hand, have made an effort to genuinely assess the needs of those affected together with the partners. This fundamental attitude was also new territory for the churches at first: For the missionaries who came to South America, Asia, and Africa during colonial times played a role in establishing the school and health systems that is still not to be underestimated, and sometimes even recognized today. But these institutions were also built according to European ideas and standards – many white know-it-alls were at work back then.

The role of European churches during the colonial period has long been critically reflected upon by the partner churches in the affected countries. Desmond Tutu, whom I fondly remember, is known for the saying, "When the first missionaries came to Africa, they had the Bible and we had the land. They told us to pray. And we closed our eyes. When we opened them again, the situation was exactly reversed. We had the Bible and they had our land." It is indeed a great quip – but it is worth taking a closer look. For it must be said that it was probably less often the missionaries who had the land than their business-oriented compatriots. But however it may be – it is certainly true that the churches often remained silent about the state criticized by Tutu.

The partnership approach with the respective local churches also led to the processing of the colonial past. This was not always comfortable. True partnership means addressing problems on both sides and not repressing unprocessed feelings of guilt out of a misguided sense of political correctness or – I add – gratitude. By the way, the missionary schools were, and we want to emphasize this, in many countries the crucial access to good education and ultimately enabled political emancipation in many, many countries, especially in Africa.

In contrast to the structures of state development cooperation that still needed to be created, the churches could already rely on a dense network of contacts worldwide fifty years ago, through which projects could now be implemented. Under the principle that no missionary activities should be promoted, the German churches now use state funds for development cooperation with a high degree of autonomy.

This was an important decision. Both sides benefit: the church and the state. Because through their partners on the ground, the churches can reach people who are otherwise inaccessible or only very difficult to access. So I am pleased that today, as representatives of this great ecclesiastical treasure of international partners, Ms. Richardson from India and Archbishop Kaigama from Nigeria will report on their experiences. I want to listen very closely to you, as well as to the representatives of the German churches and our Federal Minister.

The guiding principle of today's event, "Trust in the Power of the Poor," resonates well with me. The churches are also careful not to create a subsidy or dependency mentality with development cooperation. You, Archbishop Zollitsch, pointed this out very clearly in your welcome today. It is about empowering people to take their lives into their own hands and to let the potentials within them, which have been buried for many reasons, come to fruition. Therefore, for me, the crucial question is: What brings encouragement, what awakens the forces that are within us, which must come into play?

I know: The path to self-responsibility is usually neither wide nor comfortable. Changes in mentality happen incredibly slowly. But these paths of inner development for people are always exciting, fulfilling, and satisfying! So: Wherever we can contribute to people living out their own potential for responsibility, much is achieved, and I am happy to be part of that.

And one more point about partnership is important to me: When we approach a task together, the partners expect reliability and long-term commitment from us. The temptation is great to raise unrealistic expectations in development cooperation. However, transfer payments alone could not create flourishing landscapes in East Germany either – they are always just building blocks in a large communal construction effort.

We cannot expect to achieve material prosperity within a few decades through money, as it had to be built up in Europe over many generations. Reasonable policies and appropriate framework conditions must also come into play. Look at the development of Korea: South Korea is no longer a developing country, while North Korea still faces famines.

My third point is thus addressed: We must not confuse development cooperation with charity. Of course, it happens that people find themselves in distress through no fault of their own, whether due to an earthquake, a flood disaster, or other reasons. In such cases, we cannot simply stand by. We must provide emergency and disaster relief. However, the churches have never limited their work to donations for this purpose. They have not viewed their work as a mere band-aid. Rather, their aim has been to provide people with better development opportunities in the long term.

And this cannot happen without fair framework conditions, that is, without politics. This was clearly demonstrated in the 1960s at the Second Vatican Council and at the Geneva Conference of the World Council of Churches. At that time, the churches called on wealthy countries to dismantle their "protective barriers" against exports from the Third World. Like many others, they criticized trade barriers and export subsidies, as these distorted economic competition. The churches did not limit their criticism of global framework conditions to the North: they also spoke out where elites in developing countries defended their privileges and attempted to block the necessary social and economic progress. In this way, the churches were early participants in the social movements that opposed structural injustice there.

Thus, through their persistence, the churches have also contributed to bringing the long path to debt relief for the most indebted countries to a successful conclusion at the beginning of this millennium. Although not all problems of these countries have been solved with the so-called "Jubilee Year" – we see that every day – the budgets have been noticeably relieved, allowing more money to be made available for social tasks and independent economic perspectives.

The coherence of our policies remains a current issue that directly impacts our credibility. When environmentally harmful production is simply outsourced to other countries, it tarnishes the joy of a clean environment in Germany. When land for food production is converted to grow energy crops, many people view this with concern. These global interconnections are well known. However, the churches recognized them particularly early on. Through their daily feedback with the poor of the world, they know what they are talking about. For this reason, I hope that the churches will continue to participate intensively in all discussions regarding the direction of development cooperation in the future. These are not unwelcome interjections, to be clear, but rather desired contributions.

In these questions, which touch on our contribution to the preservation of creation, you can already see that for me, everything related to sustainable development cannot be limited to poverty alleviation alone. Development and development cooperation is, and this is my fourth core statement, already a question of our personal lifestyle.

Recently, I was appointed a climate ambassador here in Bonn by a group of engaged elementary school students. This brings responsibility. Each of us can now try in our own way to meet that responsibility. I know that many of you are far ahead of me. Each of us can also calculate our own ecological footprint on the computer and estimate how many planets we would actually need if the lifestyle we consider important for ourselves were to apply to all people. But we only have one planet.

One can debate the details of the calculations, just as one can debate the calculations regarding climate catastrophe. But our current resource consumption in Germany simply cannot be transferred to the entire world. And that means development cannot aim for a copy of our way of life. Since the so-called developed countries often claim this for themselves, we must talk about our own lifestyle when we engage in debates with them. Thus, it follows that we too must develop.

Not only for reasons of climate protection is it time for us to rethink the lifestyle of highly industrialized societies. More and more non-European societies are experiencing, in the course of growth, that the correlation between spiritual well-being and material prosperity only holds up to a certain limit.

In our country, the Enquête Commission of the German Bundestag is dealing with the connections between growth, prosperity, and quality of life from the perspective of sustainability. In Latin America, people are reflecting on "Buen Vivir," the good life, which must be thought of in a social context with other people and nature. In Asia, there is also a kind of return to culturally anchored alternatives to lifestyles of excessive abundance. It is important that this reflection takes place collectively and not solely from the high horse of a satiated Western affluent society.

"Live well instead of having much," as Misereor and the BUND formulated it in 1996. The development encyclical of the Catholic Church from Easter 1967 speaks of "justice as a guiding star," which must subordinate the "suffocating materialism." The churches have long addressed the preservation of creation, a culture of peace, and social justice. They are not alone in this. However, they remain an irreplaceable voice in the chorus of those for whom a life in abundance is not determined by the balance in their bank account or their credit card.

I have saved my fifth, perhaps favorite core statement for last: Development cooperation carries its goal within itself. In the first appeals for donations from the churches, there is a multitude of exemplary motives: neighborly love, mercy, pastoral benefit for the donors, but also the memory of the help received and the obligation to pass it on. After the war and after reparations, many experiences had been gathered. These were now to be implemented.

At the beginning of state development policy was the will not to subordinate itself to foreign policy goals. Today, it also refers to a number of important objectives: preservation of peace, protection of the environment, prevention of international migration, and promotion of German economic interests, to name just a few. However, often not all goals are equally achievable and compatible. Can we simultaneously build infrastructure, protect the rainforest, and reduce the AIDS rate?

We must also be careful not to overload development policy with unattainable expectations. Such an approach would only lead to frustration and would obscure what has been achieved, while also limiting the activity of people: frustrated individuals do not engage.

Sometimes I think: Shouldn't the fight against poverty and injustice alone be justification enough to continue to engage in development cooperation consistently and repeatedly? And here, the churches can contribute significantly. They are strongest when they connect their spiritual knowledge, such as "Justice for the Poor" or "I am fed up with others starving," with intelligent support strategies and develop a culture of sharing with the donors, while simultaneously fostering a culture of self-responsibility with the recipients.

You see, my five pebbles are not exactly lightweight. However, I am full of confidence that we should not shy away from taking them up in our fight against what sometimes seems too great and too threatening. We know how it ended with the biblical Goliath. A society that is convinced of its commitment to fighting poverty and injustice has solid foundations to awaken the full potential in people together with partners and to critically reflect on its own lifestyle. Development understood in this way is a holistic task that is self-sufficient as a goal. It encompasses all and each individual: politics and society, state and church. Therefore, their close cooperation remains important. Mercy and justice, Misereor and Bread for the World are the indispensable beginning of church action, but never its end.

We all know it: The poverty and injustice that threaten the lives of people in large parts of the world are caused by humans. But they can also be overcome by humans. And all of you here in the hall have contributed to more people being able to live in dignity and, as far as it is in our hands, free from want. That deserves respect because you have not been discouraged by the magnitude of the task. And it deserves thanks, which I express to you today from the heart.

I thank all those who are active in the distant and nearby fields of development cooperation, as well as those responsible in the church and politics! In this gratitude is the joy that our society, our country is not only shaped by the dynamics of the ruthless but also by the spirit and energy of those who want to recognize and address need. We can only respect ourselves and our country as long as we remain committed to this culture of life.