Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the New Year's Reception 2017 of the Protestant Academy Tutzing on January 19, 2017, in Tutzing:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

6 February 2017 · New Year's Reception 2017 of the Protestant Academy Tutzing · Protestant Academy Tutzing, Tutzing, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the New Year's Reception of the Protestant Academy Tutzing on January 19, 2017, celebrating its 70th anniversary and reflecting on democracy and public discourse.
Main themes
Democracy and democratization, Protestant academies, political discourse and public debate, populism and polarization, echo chambers and social media, German historical memory, trust in democratic institutions, Enlightenment and reason, fragmentation of public sphere, Jürgen Habermas and public life theory
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,100
77th percentile
Sentences
157
82nd percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
11.9
44th percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
26th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 56%54%
  • Institutional 21%20%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 7%6%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

157 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Of course, this is not my first time in Tutzing. And I am pleased to be here with you and to congratulate you on your 70th anniversary. I am happy to be here, especially as the head of state.

I am glad that we have an institution like this that represents such a visible sign of German learning experience in the political and cultural landscape of the country. There are indeed reasons to trust this country. And that was not at all evident at the beginning, when institutions like this were founded. That there would eventually be reasons for a deep trust in this community again, and that you have contributed to that, of course together with many others – this is truly an ensemble of contributors to the democratization of a country. I think only of our political foundations and their beneficial effects. That you have contributed so significantly to this, that you have a name throughout the country, that you are a brand, is truly a reason for great joy and deep gratitude.

If one were to ask about the contribution of Protestantism to the development of a stable and cosmopolitan, a humane democracy, we would not least arrive at the 18 Protestant academies. I have read that the philosopher Hans-Georg Gadamer and the journalist Rudolf Augstein – two very different people, as we know – independently formulated that the academies were the best thing that the churches of the Federal Republic could come up with after 1945. Even if I cannot fully agree with this judgment – I am always happy when I come here.

This is a house of political and cultural education, and a house of open exchange of opinions. And from this spirit, Tutzing, and I think particularly of the conferences of the Political Club of the Academy, has become the starting point for great, moving debates in the Federal Republic.

The Federal Republic has experienced many debates, and the academies of the Christian churches have often been among the arenas where they were publicly fought out, often with considerable intensity. Overall, these disputes have advanced our republic. The struggle of various social currents for influence has found a civilized framework, and larger parts of the population have been able to participate, often mediated by the media.

These debates often ignited around the handling of the German past. I think, for example, of the historian's dispute of the 1980s. It was fought out from the very beginning not only in academic journals but also in the national press.

Or take the debate about the Wehrmacht exhibition, which – fifty years after the end of the war – was conducted in all corners of the republic and in all layers of society and which expanded our engagement with the history of National Socialism by another facet. And which, by the way, also led to the recognition of mistakes in the exhibition and its redesign. This already shows the enlightening effect of serious debates.

It has always been one of the important sources of political stability in the Federal Republic to achieve understanding and reconciliation of interests through conversation. This discourse society, based on the principle of reason and the persuasiveness of factual argument, is evidently experiencing changes today that some of us perceive as a crisis, as so much seems crisis-ridden to us lately. Even if one may doubt whether this is always appropriate.

Not only are we witnessing a decline in trust in democratic institutions and political elites in some political milieus; we are also experiencing increasing domestic political polarization with strengthening populist forces. We are repeatedly confronted with the coarsening of language and the erosion of discussion culture. And this is accompanied by an increasing fragmentation of societal discourse.

Jürgen Habermas, the theorist of democratic public life, predicted this crisis several years ago. In the virtual space, the audience "splits into a huge number of fragmented, randomly grouped factions held together by special interests."

While the assumption that we are all always in the same discourse has always been something of an Enlightenment fallacy. For of course, it cannot be entirely new to us that there have been and are different communication milieus and that we naturally prefer to surround ourselves and exchange ideas with people who have a similar worldview or political stance as we do. What is new, however, is that this effect is amplified many times over and becomes politically effective – especially with the help of the echo chambers of social networks on the internet. Users of such discourse caverns are continually confirmed in what they already believe they know.

But when the view of the world is no longer influenced by independent media that inform one about what is happening, but by the news feed that amplifies what one wishes to read, it becomes very easy, for example, to spread conspiracy theories. It also becomes very easy to paint horror scenarios on the walls and in virtual echo chambers to turn people against each other.

And when authoritarian-led states interfere in the elections of democratic countries through cyberattacks, when it becomes a business model for people in regions far removed from the actual events to spread political misinformation, then even the liberal society and its political culture can eventually be endangered. Elections are the central instrument of representative democracy. Therefore, democracy must remain defensive, even in the virtual space.

How rapidly the digital transformation of our communication is progressing is already shown by the numbers: Today, there are more phones in the world than there are people, and almost half of humanity now has access to the internet. This is actually good, because access to data means participation. But at the same time, social networks have become the most important source of information for hundreds of millions of people. The complex questions this change raises can also be seen in the fact that even the founder of the world's largest social network has difficulty defining the nature of his own company. He wonders whether he is running a technology or a media company. In any case, it also holds true here: With great power comes great responsibility.

The rise of social networks as sources of information is accompanied by a relative loss of significance of traditional media. The sharp rejection they face at the edges of the political spectrum is concerning.

Quality journalism is more important than ever in a fast-paced time, where often the content of a report is not decisive, but rather how quickly it is disseminated. Of course, we also know: There have been misdevelopments and omissions. In some cases, it seemed to hold that what must not be cannot be. This realization has generated a self-critical debate within the media. And that must happen. However, to derive from this that traditional media are a "lying press" is truly a grotesque exaggeration and in itself already infamous political propaganda. Believe me: I know what a lying press is. I experienced it for decades in the GDR, and those older than me experienced it during the time of National Socialism.

And precisely for this reason, I firmly believe that serious journalism can confidently and assertively promote its advantages, with thorough research and political independence.

There are also some insights that are encouraging. Even if it is sometimes difficult for us Germans to accept optimistic messages – let us listen closely: I have taken note of the findings of your research, esteemed Professor Reinemann, with interest. Particularly the observation that trust in established media has not decreased as much in the middle of society as we often think in the wake of current reports. In fact, however, the tone of today's media criticism has sharpened significantly. You also note that there is a connection between fundamental criticism of the media and political dissatisfaction. Those who do not see their opinion represented in the media often find that the media are the lackeys of the powerful. This means in reverse: If politics can regain trust, then so can the media.

Those who want to regain trust must above all not do one thing: give up the claim to seek the truth. Of course, I am aware of how difficult it is to communicate when there is no longer any agreement on what is true. I think of Hannah Arendt, who formulated the following at that time:

"Where facts are consistently replaced by lies and total fictions, it turns out that there is no substitute for the truth. For the result is by no means that the lie is now accepted as true and the truth is defamed as a lie, but that the human sense of orientation in the realm of the real, which cannot function without the distinction between truth and untruth, is destroyed."

By the way, Arendt already noted very early on, in the small volume "Visit to Germany," that there were very marked losses, losses of reality in Germany after the dictatorship. And one of these losses of reality was the loss of facts, of reality, because so many could not comprehend how it was with the guilt and what the facts of the dictatorship were. Thus, a psychological compensation set in, which replaced the real reality with opinions about reality. And when one then said something against it, it was said: But we are now democrats, we have freedom of opinion. This was just a few years after the end of the war.

So what – we ask ourselves after such consideration – can we do to ensure that we do not lose the truth?

Currently, we suffer from "Google-Knowing" – a half-knowledge that arises from the fact that we no longer question the origin of information when acquiring knowledge on the internet. However, we need a certain methodology – the historian would say "source criticism." Without that, it simply does not work in historical research. We need intellectual tools to reflect on information, to classify it, and to draw conclusions from it. And all of this must be brought back into the center of our education. We must imagine what significance the handling of new technology has in our schools. And precisely in a population group that is so intensely connected with these new communication technologies, we let them go into life without pedagogical guidance?

Education must promote a critical approach to the world in every young person, not in the sense of "being against," but in the sense of fostering independent thinking. We need media literacy that allows for an emancipated handling of new technologies. This competence is not only needed by students and learners but also by all adult citizens, as it is one of the essential prerequisites for a democratic education that empowers the individual and enables responsible political participation.

The pursuit of truth always also involves a self-critical attitude. This refers to the insight that our open debate culture does not only suffer from hate rhetoric. This insight is not new, and it has led to thoughtful self-reflection in the media, especially in the past year. One of the guiding questions of the discussion is – and must be: Is there not a danger that a sometimes apparent tabooing and normalization of language – including political language – will encounter increasing resistance from those who perceive it as euphemistic?

It is important to bring openness into a wise harmony with sensitivity and differentiation. However, those who want to be open should also strive for clarity. This also means being able to depict complex issues in a language that is understood by more people, ideally by all. We must not leave the simple word to those who want to exert influence on all of us from the edges of the political and social spectrum. A positively understood and enlightening simplification would contribute to a communication of the many – rather than a communication of the few and particularly educated.

Including many means listening to many opinions – even those that one does not like, that I do not like either. An open society means: being ready for conversation, yes, we all say that, but it actually also means being ready for conflict, for debate. And this conflict may – especially in rough times – occasionally be quite intense. But conflict also needs rules, like in sports. As long as it is conducted with respect, it can indeed help in understanding in the end, whether we fear it or not. It is important that we agree, especially in such cultivated discourse arenas, that not everything that rages out there is already the beginning of the end of democracy. Yesterday, I referred to Timothy Garton Ash and used the term "robust civility." And that is why I believe: Our democracy is strong and mature enough not to faint at every word – but then we stand up against it. And we then open a debate, hopefully according to our rules and always on the basis of our Basic Law.

In all our engagement with the critics of the state and the media, we should not forget how stable our societal center is – it is this, our civil society. This Germany is not the Weimar Republic. We not only have institutions, but we have each other, our togetherness. And we will never allow that this precious good of our democracy is encroached upon or even crushed from the edges. Never. For let us be aware, this country offers its citizens greater opportunities for life and development than ever before in German history. During my travels through Germany over the past five years, I have experienced the abundance of these opportunities and the diverse strengths of the people themselves. And I have also experienced our country in conversation with international partners and thus gotten to know it in a completely new way. The outside perspective helps occasionally, as we know. For example, in recognizing the respect that Germany has earned through its firm and credible commitment to human dignity and other universal values, and how much elsewhere our self-earned prosperity, our societal peace, and our ability to find balance and compromise are appreciated.

The rule of law protects against abuse of power and arbitrariness. In the social market economy, entrepreneurial initiative and innovative ideas are combined with employee interests and fair balancing of interests. And in our citizenship, people – instead of complaining about the so-called system or remaining in a victim role – voluntarily take responsibility for others and for one another. Millions of Germans are engaged in voluntary work. They do it everywhere, in schools and clubs, in churches, in refugee assistance, sports, and culture. The work is not always visible. Often it is done quietly and discreetly. But it creates an enormous social connection. Our media consumption sometimes leads us to define society by its conflict zones. But the knowledge of this network could strengthen in us the deep conviction that this is a blessed country with strong forces and strong citizens. We could arrive at an attitude that we can truly represent a lasting antithesis to this widespread culture of sullen discontent and outrage.

The openness that characterizes our society is often interpreted by its enemies as weakness. Yet it is precisely democracy that is capable of dealing with changes and even with attacks. New concerns and positions are taken into account, as long as they do not leave the ground of the Basic Law.

Our democracy has much experience with transformations and with adaptation. It has already asserted itself against internal and external threats before. Let us think of past decades when the Federal Republic of Germany had to withstand terrorism without betraying its principles. Our country has managed, despite some problems, to integrate 16 million compatriots from the East, who, having grown up in a dictatorship, had largely adopted typical dictatorial attitudes, into the Federal Republic. What tremendous efforts. And not least, this has succeeded through the power of free speech, argument, and debate.

Thus, in the current upheavals and discussions, there is also an opportunity, for we are forced to become aware once again of what we have in our democracy. Once again, democracy can demonstrate its strength, its ability to learn, and its capacity for adaptation.

Undoubtedly, our society still needs forums for human encounters, also retreats from the everyday fast-paced life, places for reflection, and also places for contemplation. And now I return once more to your house, esteemed director, yes, to the actual origin of the academy. I think of how Plato saw it – as a place of knowledge. Such a space is what this Protestant Academy wants to be. Please do not give up this claim. Carry it forward into the future.

It has happened that your president is a Christian. And therefore, I would like to conclude my speech today with a Christian remark. We are here, as we are aware, in a Protestant Academy. And I do not want to say goodbye from here without pointing out that there must be a proprium – something that distinguishes it from other, secular educational institutions. I would wish that such an academy adds something to all the discourses that shape our society – namely, what the Christian faith can add to life. It would be one-dimensional and also unrealistic if we did not include the potentials of all the people who have been shaped by the Christian faith in the life processes of a society. We know of the greater hope and the greater dedication that believing people have brought into the world. Therefore, central themes of faith should also remain on the agenda. The academy can still provide a forum where the issues of the time are negotiated with the most diverse participants in the debate. But it should not give up "the matter of God," for in trusting God, people have been able to expand their potentials. Let us say it in very traditional language: May the Creator God elude our understanding, yet those who are related to Him remain blessed, strengthened, and empowered.

Of course, these words are only approximations to the mystery we approach when we say "God." But there are mysteries that are powerful – and therefore, there should indeed be space for the mysteries of faith in a Protestant Academy.

And now my farewell wish: May you remain a blessing for all who come here. Remain faithful to those who are concerned about the future of our community and the world. Meet the culture of anxiety and discontent with a faith-strengthened "yes" to the future.