Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the opening of the 20th German Banking Day on April 9, 2014, in Berlin:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

13 April 2014 · 20th German Banking Day · Berlin, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the 20th German Banking Day in Berlin on April 9, 2014, reflecting on banking reform and responsibility seven years after the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Banking reform and accountability, financial crisis legacy, power and responsibility of banks, market regulation, ethics in banking, role of citizens as investors, political oversight of financial markets, money and public discourse, debt and credit dynamics, too-big-to-fail problem, trust in financial institutions
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,422
66th percentile
Sentences
143
79th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
10.5
26th percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 78%73%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Social 7%6%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

143 sentences in 42 paragraphs

When the Federal President opens the German Banking Day, in the seventh year after the outbreak of the global financial and debt crisis, he faces very different expectations. Many citizens wish for the banks to be reprimanded once again, for a reckoning to take place with greed, hubris, misconduct, and loss of control. Many bank managers, perhaps some of you here in the hall, on the other hand, wish for recognition of the reforms, including a new business culture that both politics and the industry are striving for.

Both expectations are, of course, valid.

It is true: Some banks and some employees have incurred a lot of debt. The judiciary is still investigating several cases on suspicion of embezzlement, accounting fraud, or market manipulation. And just a few days ago, further allegations were made public: The financial authorities are investigating whether some particularly clever investment models of banks and investment funds have evaded taxes amounting to billions. Even where there has been no violation of law and regulation, some business practices have been ethically questionable, and some risks have been unacceptably high. Misguided incentives in the bonus system, inflated profit expectations, irresponsible behavior at the expense of others – there was a lot of misdirected creativity at play.

In addition, there were deficiencies in state supervision and regulation, a policy of cheap money, and high levels of debt among states, companies, and citizens. All of this contributed to undermining the stability of an already extremely complex financial system. Individual banks had to be rescued by politics because they were too big to fail, of course at the expense of taxpayers. Thus, a central principle of the market economy was suspended: Those who take risks must be liable for losses.

All of this has often been criticized, and rightly so – I have occasionally expressed critical views on it as well.

On the other hand, it is also true: Much has changed since then. Banks must hold more equity today than before the crisis. New rules are intended to make risky transactions more controllable and transparent. Stress tests are used to assess the viability of banks in times of crisis. And last but not least, many institutions have admitted mistakes, developed new business models, and addressed ethical questions. There is no doubt: The industry is undergoing change.

So, a preliminary conclusion almost seven years after the onset of the crisis is mixed: Mistakes have been recognized, political and corporate reforms are underway. This process is in full swing, but it is far from complete.

Thus, I do not want to engage in bank bashing today, nor can I sing the praises of a perfect banking world.

Rather, I would like to take a step back and begin with something fundamental: I want to talk about money.

Now some may think: not the most original idea at a German Banking Day. But the topic is not as obvious as it seems. Because in our society, it is by no means a given to talk about money. On the contrary, it is often said: One does not talk about money! This is considered offensive, impolite. There may be reasons for this opinion in private life. However, in public life, in the social market economy, such an attitude would be fatal. It would be as if citizens in our democracy agreed on the maxim: "One does not talk about politics!"

Money grants influence, but it also creates dependencies. One can earn it, save it, and invest it – and then trust that others will multiply it. One can borrow it and must then pay it back. Banks are intermediaries between debtors and creditors, and they themselves are both: debtors and creditors. Money and credit, claims and liabilities create dependencies. And where dependencies arise, power is also exercised.

What power today emanates from banks and financial markets can be hinted at by a single number: 30 trillion euros – that is the sum of bank balances in the euro area. Since the financial crisis, the value of globally circulating debt securities has increased again. Never before have there been so many debts, and never before has there been so much wealth as today. Thus, the role of intermediaries between creditors and debtors has never been more important.

The financial and debt crisis has shown us the consequences that can arise when actors fail and control is inadequate or even absent. Precisely because the power of finance is so great and reaches so far into people's everyday lives, our economic system is necessarily dependent on all actors acting informed and responsibly. All actors, what does that mean?

For me,

first

: the banks, that is, their employees and managers.

Second

: the citizens, who as investors must not only look for promises of returns but should also inquire about the risks, which must not remain hidden from them.

And

third

: the politics, which faces the challenge of further developing market order and formulating smart rules that help unleash the forces of the market while preventing abuse.

Let me begin with the special responsibility of banks.

It is worth taking a look at the history of Europe to understand the role that banks and the monetary economy played in the transition to modernity. Back then, when market and coin rights were granted, when cities flourished, when the monetary system spread and banking emerged, Europe broke free from the Middle Ages. The space for trade and exchange grew. And that was good for the citizens of that time. And as the bourgeoisie increasingly emancipated itself in the 19th century, banking opened up to craftsmen, small entrepreneurs, and farmers – and to their ideas. At the same time, cooperative banks emerged, shaped by the idea of mutual self-help. This banking world, which consists of large universal banks and specialized institutions, savings banks, and private banks, is today a reflection of the German economy in all its diversity – from small and medium-sized enterprises to internationally active large companies.

On this occasion, I would like to say that it is worth maintaining this coexistence of private and cooperative banks as well as public savings banks! That much must be said at a banking day.

Today, almost every German citizen is a bank customer, with a checking account, savings book, credit card, personal loan, and sometimes also a securities account at their disposal. Because so many people can easily purchase so many financial products – by the way, often encouraged by politics – and because so much in the industry is new, fast, and confusing, their managers and employees bear a special responsibility – for their customers and for the functioning of our social market economy and ultimately for the trust of citizens in the state and society.

So what is important? Even if it sounds a bit old-fashioned: Employees of banks should indeed orient themselves to the ideal of the honorable banker, especially in times when business is more complex than ever before. They must convince through seriousness and expertise, must be able to explain their actions, and disclose opportunities and risks. And not just in the fine print, but in plain language. Not only for their own legal protection but for the best possible clarification of the customers. This avoids the risk that a customer consciously chooses to take becomes a danger to which they are helplessly exposed.

At this point, I see you in a position of obligation!

I am well aware: Most actors in the banking sector in our country adhere to these rules. They have nothing in common with the financial juggler who plays a leading role in some Hollywood film, but they grant corporate and mortgage loans, inform about savings deposits and retirement provisions – and do good work in the process. They contribute to growth and dynamism, employment and innovation.

Gaining and maintaining trust is in the banks' own interest. Otherwise, they deprive themselves and the market of their business foundation. Nothing illustrates this better than the collapse of the money market at the beginning of the financial crisis, when even banks did not trust each other.

At that time, what I once called the "grimace of unbridled freedom" became evident. It is the freedom, one could say, of adolescents, which defines itself only as freedom from something, from rules, from constraints, and which asks too little about the consequences of its own actions. In contrast, the "freedom I mean," and for which we should strive together, is a freedom to something, to shaping and co-shaping. It is freedom in responsibility, which respects and promotes the bonds and relationships with other people and the community.

That is the freedom of the social market economy – not boundless recklessness. This freedom stands for a culture of responsibility that goes beyond balance sheet profit. In our economic order, private individuals and entrepreneurs can earn good money, and they should do so. The pursuit of profit is by no means reprehensible but a prerequisite for investments and innovations. And those who do business also always take the risk of failure. However, responsibility also means bearing losses themselves. Those who take particularly high risks because they know that someone else will shoulder the costs in an emergency act contrary to this principle.

The departure from the virtues of the social market economy has shaken citizens' trust in banks. And, to be honest: In light of some excesses, I understand that. At the same time, I have the impression that criticism of these conditions sometimes throws the baby out with the bathwater. It sometimes turns into a general skepticism towards the market economy. Competition and freedom are seen as the problem, rather than their abuse. I consider this fatal because the social market economy needs informed citizens who confidently participate in economic life. And with that, I come to my second point, the role of citizens.

Henry Ford, the American industrialist, is attributed with the following statement: "It is good that people do not understand the banking and monetary system; otherwise, we would have a revolution by tomorrow morning." In one respect, I must disagree: It is not good at all if citizens do not sufficiently understand or cannot understand an important economic sector. It is not good if many find it difficult to grasp issues because entire sectors of society are intertwined in ways that are hardly transparent. Even experts have often claimed that they could not follow what was actually happening in the financial markets.

Banks, as I just mentioned, have an obligation here. But the citizen also has a responsibility to take. Those who want to understand the sources of our prosperity, who want to seize personal opportunities and assess risks, must inform themselves and become more competent in financial matters. They must not retreat to the position that one does not talk about money.

An informed citizen should actually have a basic economic education. Studies show that many Germans have a backlog in this area. I know that efforts are being made to creatively convey economic knowledge. There are examples where young people in school already start their own companies or trade on the stock market. They learn to act like entrepreneurs, from product development to marketing and sales. The banking association also makes a good contribution in this area. Nevertheless, I wonder: Is economic education sufficiently taken into account in our schools and vocational schools? Does knowledge of economic interconnections have the same rank that economics has today for our lives and economies?

This is not only important so that individuals can make good decisions for themselves. Just as political education can promote the judgment and engagement of young citizens, the ability to follow economic policy debates, form one's own judgment, and participate in those debates is also essential to democracy. The key figure in this is the much-cited "enlightened citizen." And he is also called upon when it comes to shaping our economic order. Not only political but also economic apathy and ignorance are dangerous.

How important the ability to engage in public discourse about economic issues is becomes evident especially when it comes to drawing conclusions from the crisis. So: what rules do banks need, what limits do markets need? What role does monetary policy play, what power may it exercise? And how do we find our way out of high public debt?

In this context, it is not enough to focus on individual and entrepreneurial actions and only rely on changing mentalities and business models. All of this is correct. But it was also the state framework that enabled and often favored misconduct. And with that, I come to my third and final point.

Since the G20 summit five years ago in Washington, efforts have been made to hold banks more accountable and to set rules to make crises less likely. We Europeans are creating a banking union with a unified supervision in the Eurozone and new procedures to hold owners and creditors accountable when banks get into trouble. This can help us in Europe strengthen the market economy and the monetary union.

It would do us good if such important questions were not discussed solely by policymakers and experts, but more than before also by citizens and the media. For there will continue to be a struggle over the extent of regulation, a struggle that must take place. We must ask ourselves: Has enough really been done to make the financial system more crisis-resistant and to avoid excesses? Or are some rules perhaps already going too far for small banks that are not "systemically important" and are intertwined with other banks?

There can certainly be different answers to this. One that I personally find very appealing comes from Karl Popper, the founder of Critical Rationalism. He once demanded that the free market not be viewed as an "ideological principle," but simply as an order that thrives on the idea that freedom should only be restricted where it is necessary for important reasons. He was aware that it will often be disputed where exactly the boundary of necessity lies. That will remain the case.

Drawing this boundary in a wise and responsible manner is the task of politics. It sets the framework. Just as important, however, is how banks and citizens fill this framework. So let us continue to discuss how responsible action by banks and citizens could be strengthened. Let us discuss necessary limits and the boundary of necessity in the financial markets! In this sense: Let us talk about money.