Answers of the President of the Government during the Assessment Session at the Parliament

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

2 October 2007 · Assessment session at the Parliament · Parliament

Context
Zapatero addressed the Spanish Parliament on 2 October 2007 during a government assessment session, responding to questions from the Catalan Convergence and Union parliamentary group on Penal Code reform.
Main themes
Penal Code reform, organised crime legislation, sexual offences and recidivism, road security legislation, parliamentary consensus, post-sentence security measures, rehabilitation of offenders, women's safety, police resources, fight against illegal immigration
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,739
72nd percentile
Sentences
75
49th percentile
Readability
39
34th percentile
Grade
16.0
83rd percentile
Syntax
3.53
95th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 58%57%
  • Economic 22%21%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

75 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Answer of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antonio Duran i Lleida, from the Catalan Parliamentary Group Convergence and Union (Convergencia i Unio)

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran .- This Parliamentary Group, by the beginning of the previous Parliamentary period, said publicly that it would be a shame for the Congress of Deputies to go on holidays without having approved of the reform of the Penal Code. It is true that, as was agreed on by the different Parliamentary Groups, we separated what affects road security and it is being processed and, thus, we are making the final steps towards its approval.

But beyond road security, this Parliamentary Group said and it still keeps saying that the reform as far as organised criminal groups are concerned should have also been undertaken. Nowadays, a person is found in the garden of a house, let's say, and as it is not an offence to belong to a group, I insist, of common criminals, this person cannot be applied the corresponding penal measures.

I do not have the feeling that there is a willingness to move forward in this sense and in this regard and this is one part of the question and of the explanation of the reasons that justify it.

The other part is the one that refers to those offences that go against sexual freedom. This Parliamentary Group, Mr. President, has never been in favour of legislating under the influence of what can be termed as the impact of a piece of news on the media, concerning a real event. But it is evident that lately there have been news, based upon real events, that have created social alarm with regards to the liberation of certain people for, although this people have served a conviction according to the penal legislation in force, they are not still adequately rehabilitated and, as a consequence, they are dangerous in so far as they are persons that may relapse. Thus, they are a threat for the security of society and in particular for women.

Mr. President, our Parliamentary Group would like to ask you whether you do not deem it important for the Government to try to achieve a wide consensus among the different Parliamentary Groups before this Legislature is over, and we have little time now, in order to carry out an adequate legislation and give an answer to this fair social concern with regards to this type of problems.

The proposed reform of the Penal Code points out four measures: four fifths of the sentence served in order to be allowed to apply for parole and this will also be complemented with the follow-up of an adequate psychological treatment, until it is verified that the person is ready to live inside society. What measures, Mr. President, are you willing to promote, knowing that this is a serious problem that affects, to a great extent, the security of women, in particular?

President .- Mr. Duran, I must say that the Government is ready to do it and is considering the possibility to carry out several legal initiatives in order to improve the fight as far as organised crime is concerned and, of course, also as far as those persons that are responsible for offences against the dignity of others and sexual offences are concerned, as Mr. Duran has pointed out.

Let me tell you that you have mentioned the example of the reform that will affect road security. It is true that, in the case of organised groups, a reform would affect a higher number of precepts in the Penal Code. This is the only reason why it has not taken place right now; but, of course, the Government is open and prone to incorporate reforms in order to reinforce the fight against organised crime.

Some steps have already been taken with their corresponding results, and they have to do with the material means, and there are fourteen thousand more policemen and civil guards, nowadays; in 2006 there was a 8.9% decrease in the number of burglaries; we have approved of legislative reforms, such as the Public General Act of Parliament concerning the Judicature, in order to prosecute, outside the Spanish territory, illegal traffic of people and illegal immigration. But, of course, we are open to any possible reforms.

As to rapes, I share your concern. Just like all citizens, we are worried about the fact that a criminal that has served a rape sentence may be let out without any expectations of being re-educated. Yet, I would like to tell you that in the case of the rapist of Vall d' Hebron, he was sentenced by the Penal Code previous to 1995 and the 1995 Penal Code incorporated new measures.

But let me announce that the Ministry of Justice is already working in order to incorporate security post-crime measures to our legislation, in order to harmonize the rights of those who have already served a sentence and the demands of society, which are rather reasonable, to prevent an eventual relapse efficiently. And, of course, the Ministry of Justice is prone to let this work, from this very moment, become a shared work for all the Parliamentary Groups and, in particular, given your interest, for Convergence and Union (Convergencia y Unio).

Answer of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, from the Parliamentary Group People's Party

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy .- Mr. President, I think that the concern of the most Spanish citizens is sufficiently justified. We are going through a delicate moment and you, with your style of government, are not unaware of it. The supporters of democracy do not feel at ease with what is happening to our symbols and to our institutions, and they feel even more uneasy when they see the Government being challenged from the presidency of a regional institution, which dares to say, publicly, not only that your will shakes when it comes to applying the Law, but also -and I quote-- "that it would be surprising for the President of the Government, who has been negotiating with ETA and Batasuna until a few months ago, not want to negotiate with him".

Mr. President, it is obvious that your imprudence is the reason why you have lost control, because all this has been caused because you entered the Government saying that the Spanish nation was a debate-raising and debatable matter, and these are the consequences. When you entered the Government you assured that you were going to offer a new territorial design in which everyone would feel comfortable, and here we are, with all the problems that have been generated and the referendums that certain leaders are already announcing. You negotiated with ETA and now some are using that negotiation as an argument in order to negotiate something similar. You entered the Government despising the consensus and questioning the Transition, and now some are already questioning its protagonists.

But the worst thing is, Mr. President, that you cannot understand the seriousness and the consequences of what you have been doing so far. You cannot see the mistakes and you think that you have not made a mistake during the debates that you have promoted, unnecessarily, and it is precisely in this regard that you have made the greatest mistake.

Most Spanish citizens do not understand or share the situation we are living. Most Spanish citizens want to see the President of the Government leading the respect for Law and Constitution; a President of the Government that would guarantee the stability of our institutions; a President of the Government that would seek for a consensus with the main party of the opposition with regards to those issues that really worry our citizens; a President of the Government that would transmit calm to the Spanish people by telling them that the continuity of their sovereignty would not be threatened in the future; to sum up, a President of the Government that would not undo what others made possible with generosity, with effort and with a willingness to establish an understanding after so many years of democracy.

President .- Mr. Rajoy, either you have a bad memory or your intention during your intervention has not been really positive. I will tell you why: because the proposal of the inquiry of Mr. Ibarretxe was made seven years ago, just ten days after the victory of your party in the elections back in 2000, and by a vast majority. As you know, at that moment, I was not the President of the Government, I wasn't even the General Secretary of the Socialist Party.

The proposal was put forward ten years after your victory in the elections of 2000; thus, it was while you were in the government that the Political Statute or Plan Ibarretxe was put forward at the Basque Parliament; during this government it was put forward in this Chambers, and we answered, as the Constitutional Court emphasized, adequately and democratically, that is, debating and rejecting the Political Statute of Mr. Ibarretxe with so many reasons as votes, in these Chambers, because it did not respect legality; and he is going to have the same answer if he keeps on trying to do the same with the proposal for an enquiry.

It was us who did it, and facts are here and they refute your reasons completely. Our answer has always been responsible and it has applied the law in a democratic State, with prudence and serenity. Do you know why? Because in a democratic State in the Rule of Law, those who comply with the Law should not fear. Democratic institutions should not fear. It is those who make the mistake and do not comply with the law that should fear. That is the strength of democracy, the authority, the legitimacy of the Rule of Law, and this Government defends it and applies it in a responsible way, which is one of the main requirements in order to be able to govern.

Finally, let me tell you, as you were talking about different things, that Spain is what it is because it belongs to us all; symbols such as the flag are what they are because they belong to us all and the main institutions of the State, whose evolution during the last thirty years in order to consolidate democracy has been great, are what they are because they belong to us all. The difference, do you know where does it lie? If that enquiry proposal had been made while I was the leader of the opposition and you were the President of the Government, I would have intervened to tell you: you have my support to apply the Law and reject that enquire.

Answer of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Agusti Cerda, from the Parliamentary Group Republican Left of Catalonia (Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya)

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Cerda .- Mr. President, as you know, Republican Left (Esquerra Republicana) has always made an emphasis in the relevance of El Prat airport as it is the most important infrastructure in Catalonia and also an obviously and absolutely necessary element for its international project.

Yesterday, the Governing Board of AENA made a vital decision concerning the future of the airport of Barcelona: it assigned the new Southern Terminal to the groups One World and Star Alliance, and to the low cost companies Vueling and Clickair. That is a decision that condemns El Prat airport to keep depending on Barajas and it punishes Sky Team, which is the group that offers more intercontinental flights from Barcelona.

Therefore, Mr. Rodriguez Zapatero, in our opinion, a great opportunity has been lost and, once more, Iberia has won. El Prat will end up becoming the Terminal 5 of Barajas. Thus, from Republican Left (Esquerra) we would like to know whether you think that the assignment of the Southern Terminal made by AENA is the best one in order to guarantee the consolidation of El Prat as a flight hub for intercontinental flights, which is just what we are demanding and what I think our country needs.

President .- Thank you Mr. Cerda, for your question. As you know, the Governing Board of AENA held a meeting in Barcelona yesterday, according to the established agenda, and assigned the spaces of the new Southern Terminal. It was done after presenting and discussing the criteria used with the regional government, the Generalitat, with the local entities affected, with the Chambers of Commerce of Barcelona, with the workers unions and with the Catalan businessmen associations, respecting the willingness of the institutions and of the civil society to participate in the process to assign spaces in the Southern Terminal.

This is a discussion process, Mr. Cerda, that -I would like to remind you- has been positively assessed by all the participants, both with regards to its development and with regards to the particular criteria that have been finally fixed in order to carry out the assignment: benefitting from the capacity of the premises; allowing and promoting the operativeness of the airport as a hub-flight distribution centre, both national and international, and also intercontinental; and promoting the growth possibilities of all the companies; because that is the only guarantee to increase all type of connections in the airport.

And be sure, Mr. Cerda, that I am fully aware of this, because I also share the feelings of your Group, the feelings of the Catalan institutions and of all the Catalan forces about El Prat, about its future and about what it represents for the economy and for the citizens of Catalonia.

But I must tell you that at this moment El Prat one of the ten most important European airports that is growing more, in this moment, El Prat has received an investment of 5,000 million Euros, 3,600 out of those have almost been fully implemented and 1,400 have been announced and advanced with the refurbishing of the Terminal and with the new Satellite Terminal; and, as a consequence, it is going to have a great future, becoming a very powerful motor of growth, development and communication in all regards for Barcelona and for Catalonia as a whole; and, of course, the model that we have implemented, a model of participation and consultation with the Catalan institutions and with the social agents has proved to be a successful method, which shows that participation and cooperation bring about very positive results for the Autonomous Government.

Mr. Cerda .- As you can see, Mr. President, it is not just a matter of figures and good intentions. This is a bad start if the best news that you can break about the assignment is that it can still be revocable.

You have made clear once more what your airport management model is: one State, one single manager, one single airport and one single company too. Only if the managing entity of the airport gives priority to intercontinental flights from Barcelona will we be able to establish a real international hub in El Prat; otherwise, we won't, and it will not meet the conditions and it will not fulfil the missions for which it was designed. It is clear for Republican Left (Esquerra) that AENA will never do this.

This is why we think that the authentic trial for the airport of Barcelona will be, in fact, the establishment of the future management model; and in Republican Left (Ezquerra Republicana) we urge you to bring the centralist model to an end, once and for all, for it is the only one left in Europe right now, just because it has proved to be inefficient.

El Prat needs a manager that can make it possible for it to compete in equal conditions and that can only be guaranteed, Mr. Rodriguez Zapatero, by means of a management model in which the Generalitat, the Local Administrations and the public and private sector of Catalonia may have a relevant position, if they are the majority with regards to the control of strategic decisions concerning the airport. And, of course, Republican Left (Esquerra) will keep on trying and will not stop because this is a fact, because our country also needs this.

President .- Mr. Cerda, the management of El Prat is another question; but it is clear enough that the evolution of El Prat is extraordinarily positive and it is widely supported by the Government.