Intervention by the President of the Government at a summer course on "The Fight Against Terrorism and Its Limits," at Complutense University.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

15 July 2004 · Summer course on "The Fight Against Terrorism and Its Limits" at Complutense University · Complutense University

Context
Zapatero addressed a Complutense University summer course on terrorism's limits in July 2004, closing sessions organized by judge Baltasar Garzón months after the Madrid bombings.
Main themes
Fight against terrorism, democratic unity against terrorism, March 11 Madrid attacks, limits of counter-terrorism, gender violence legislation, rule of law, international cooperation, freedom and democracy, moral superiority of democratic norms, victims of terrorism
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,189
78th percentile
Sentences
75
49th percentile
Readability
19
3rd percentile
Grade
21.1
98th percentile
Syntax
3.77
98th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
50th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 77%77%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

75 sentences in 41 paragraphs

I want to begin by thanking the Rector for his words, thanking the course director, Baltasar Garzón, for the invitation he has extended to me to close these sessions and also for his committed work in defense of freedoms, which he has very well established.

Baltasar Garzón recalled that last year, around this time, two commitments were made in this room. The first of these was in relation to the course we are holding. I invite Baltasar Garzón to promote the organization of a new course around what gender violence represents, and in that context, I made two commitments.

The first was to quickly draft and send to Parliament, if I were President of the Government, as I hoped, I must confess, a year ago -- I believe Baltasar can confirm that it was noticeable -- the Comprehensive Law against Gender Violence, a law that, by the way, is generating intense public debate and which is certainly one of the firmest commitments of this Government: to eradicate one of the most painful forms of violence, if it can be distinguished, which represents a more unbearable social scourge, such as gender violence, which represents domination and expresses the inequality that still persists in this society between men and women. I am pleased to say today that we have fulfilled that commitment. Now I hope that the Law is good -- I hope Baltasar thinks so, logically -- and that the Law produces positive effects.

The second commitment I made was to be here, whether I were President of the Government or continued to be the leader of the opposition, at the closing of this course; a course dedicated to the limits in the fight against terrorism and around the phenomenon of terrorism.

Undoubtedly, this takes place at a time when the entire Spanish society still feels the raw pain, suffering, and rebellion against the attack we suffered on March 11, and we still have, and for a long time will have, very close to us all the victims, their families, who have experienced that pain in such an unjust manner as a consequence of the brutal attack of March 11; but also all the victims we have had in our country as a result of the scourge of terrorism.

It is not by chance, therefore, that for Spanish society, terrorism is the primary concern; that violent, unjustifiable, incomprehensible action that generates terror, pain, harm, death, in the vast majority of situations to innocent beings, to people who only wish to live freely and among free people.

Terrorism is, in my opinion, the negation of democracy, terrorism is the negation of progress, terrorism is the negation of freedom, terrorism is the negation of the word; that which has made humanity, society, and civilization stronger.

Terrorism is, therefore, a scourge; it is a new expression of violence that has unfortunately accompanied the history of Humanity on so many occasions and that in this contemporary moment is perhaps showing itself in a more violent, more indiscriminate way and with an evident risk of the phenomenon extending internationally if no decisive measures are taken, if there is no good reflection and good analysis of what the conditions are that produce the spread of fanaticism, of participation in terror, and if, of course, there is no determined will from the whole of the nations, from the vast majority of nations, that want to see themselves free, that want to see free societies and that want to see secure citizens, which is undoubtedly the great objective.

There are two elements that seem fundamental to me when it comes to combating terrorism. The first of these is the idea of unity: international unity and unity within our country. It is not by chance that since I have had the political responsibility of leading the Socialist Party, perhaps my first initiative, my first move, my first great effort, was to sign a Pact against Terrorism and in Defense of Freedoms with what was at that time the Government, which was in the hands of the Popular Party.

I believe that terrorism only has any hope if it divides democrats. I believe that the most forceful message in the political arena against terrorism is that they know at every moment, in every circumstance, that neither one, nor two, nor three, nor the terrorist attacks they are capable of carrying out from the indignity of doing so, will move the foundations of coexistence, will move the essence of democracy, will move the rules that for so long have cost humanity to build reasonable societies to live in, which consist of the laws being above men and that the laws subject force and those who want to subvert the laws.

That moral superiority of what it means to submit to the Law, to submit to the laws, is undoubtedly the great guarantee through which we can defeat terrorism.

Not a democratic conviction can be questioned because terrorism acts, nor can a democratic norm be changed because terrorism acts, nor can a democratic practice be altered because we are in the fight against terrorism.

I said at the beginning that terrorism was the negation of democracy, and precisely the best way to combat and defeat terrorism is the democratic affirmation and the continuous democratic practice in all areas.

That strong democracy, fortunately, in our country and strong in many countries needs unity. I insist, this is the central idea to defeat terrorism, unity, because terrorism, the terrorist, will fundamentally desist when they lose hope of achieving any objective that they could never achieve through democratic means, through the method of the word.

Undoubtedly, the unity of all democrats in our country, which has had high moments of strength, which has had moments of weakness when political forces have fallen into the temptation of making terrorism an element of combat between parties...; when that temptation has been succumbed to, unity has weakened and the hope of the violent has strengthened. When the temptation is succumbed to and the citizenry perceives that the sincere, real unity to fight against terrorism is in question, society expresses its discontent and expresses its distance.

Unity, then, in the internal sphere of our country.

I believe that some or many of you will remember that a few days after being elected President of the Government, I renewed the commitment with the Popular Party, now in opposition, regarding the Pact for Freedoms and against Terrorism. And today I reiterate, and you know that I like to keep my word: that Pact for Freedoms and against Terrorism will last until ETA is finished, until violent terrorism that has caused so much harm in our country is finished. Moreover, it is my will, and we have taken steps in that direction, to bring together the largest number of democratic political forces in the task of fighting against terrorism.

Unity, then, in the internal sphere, but unity also in the international sphere. Undoubtedly, September 11, the tragic attack suffered by the United States of America, and especially the city of New York, was a collective wake-up call regarding the necessary unity of countries, but also of civilizations, cultures, peoples, and intellectuals, to address an intelligent, correct, and united fight against terrorism.

Terrorism knows no borders and does not distinguish sovereignties. The fight against terrorism cannot have the limits of sovereignty or borders, especially when that terrorism today has an international dimension and a very clear, evident, and continuous interrelation. That is why all processes, like the one the European Union is experiencing, to advance in common spaces in the legislative and judicial fields, to pursue this type of serious crime represented by terrorism or by drug trafficking, where in many cases there is a connection, as Baltasar Garzón knows well, is absolutely essential.

I must say that, despite December 11 and despite March 11 in Madrid, the European Union has coordinated a process to put many policies in common that relate to the judicial and regulatory fields in the fight against terrorism; but their application and effectiveness are being slow.

That unity expressed in democracy also has a fundamental version, an essential dimension: terrorism will not be defeated with wars, terrorism will not be defeated with military interventions, terrorism does not allow for a response of military escalation. That can, in many cases, not only not reduce terrorism but can actually fuel more terrorism. Terrorism demands a response of the superiority of democracy, terrorism demands a response of proportionality, terrorism demands a response of individualization of the responsible parties, of the groups and of the individuals; but it cannot represent a support for other types of operations, much less of a military nature.

Every time a military intervention policy, a military response, is proposed in the face of a terrorist act, in the face of a terrorist attack or in response to the phenomenon of terrorism, a step back is being taken in the fight against terrorism, precisely because terrorism will be defeated with firmness, with unity, with decisiveness and with international cooperation in the fields of intelligence, legislative, judicial; but not with military interventions that have called into question the foundations of international legality and, very recently, in the world order.

The response can only be from the Law, which is to say the same as saying that the response can only be from democracy because, when the response is from the Law and from democracy, it means that there is a great social and citizen consensus behind it on the path to defeating terrorism. Neither an external policy nor a policy in matters of security or the fight against terrorism is useful, none is useful, if they do not have the acceptance, support, and consensus of the citizenry behind them.

That is why I have a deep conviction that democracy, democratic values, democratic principles, unity, overcoming the limits of sovereignty, the limits of borders, the capacity for openness in the social, cultural order and dialogue between countries and between peoples are absolutely essential.

In the context in which we live today, in the international context and in the face of the threat of terrorism that has spread and calls practically at any door, to any country, to any culture, to any type of regime and to any democracy, whether young or consolidated, whether a country of the North or the South, the greatest mistake we could make is to understand that behind this international terrorism there is a kind of new ideological division or a path that could lead us to a clash of civilizations.

If that is the analysis, my prognosis is pessimistic. If we manage to make an analysis in which we increasingly extend the capacity to share that the phenomenon is an isolated phenomenon, whether linked or not directly to a religious doctrine, which today may be Islamism and, in historical terms, tomorrow could be any other, because History says that and the future can also demonstrate it... That is why I never refer to Islamic terrorism; I deliberately speak of international terrorism, because I believe it is a serious mistake for all people who may profess that religious sentiment for the category "Islamic" to appear as an adjective to a type of terrorism.

It is international terrorism; it is terrorism, like all terrorism, that does not deserve to be recognized even as a follower of a religion, even if fanatically; not even as a follower, of course, of a homeland or a people, because whoever is capable of putting terrorist violence on the table to try to carry out their fanatical or fanatized political postulates really cannot help but seriously damage that religion, that culture, that people, that homeland or the identity they want to belong to and claim.

There is a high risk, therefore, of not understanding and not addressing the exact nature and dimension of the phenomenon, and that has a lot to do with an evident misfocus of the historical perspective and with a hasty reaction that we have seen on many occasions.

Surely the best lesson of what the path of the fight against terrorism should be has been given by the Spanish people on March 12, the best lesson. They did not let themselves be carried away by fear, they did not seek security; they took to the streets, they bet on freedom, they defended democracy, they asked questions, they wanted the truth, which is the same as wanting democracy, they wanted to be free and that is why they were massively in the streets. Moreover, the Spanish people were united, they were united with the victims and looking at power, questioning power, but questioning it from very clear and forceful values: we are willing to risk freedom, we want freedom above all, we want democracy above all, we want the truth above all.

That is the most important lesson that a society has given in the fight against terrorism, and this lesson has been repeatedly given by the Spanish people.

Therefore, let no one be tempted to run towards the precipice of an ideological war, let no one be tempted to run towards the precipice of a clash of civilizations, let no one be tempted to run towards the precipice of putting our freedoms at risk, of diminishing freedom in the face of security. On the contrary, the greatest achievements that peoples have attained in their history — and today defeating terrorism is a great achievement, of course, first and foremost, for those who may have the slightest temptation to understand terrorist violence — the greatest achievements in history have been made by peoples affirming the best democratic values and freedom.

It is true that history sometimes tests political forms, models of coexistence, and international relations, and we are now living in a moment when all of that is being tested. Since September 11 in New York and also since March 11 in Madrid, it is being tested. And what I can say is that I will be an activist for the defense of democratic principles in the fight against terrorism, an active activist, and, of course, even more active in denying the clash of civilizations.

Today, precisely when terror invokes a religion, a civilization, it is the most appropriate moment for peoples and cultures to say that here, in the land we must care for, there is only one civilization, which is human civilization, and that human civilization has only progressed when it has recognized the other, because recognizing the other is to affirm oneself when one has recognized the other in their way of thinking, feeling, having a vision of life, transcendent or not transcendent, or having a strong sense of identity for the environment in which one lives. The recognition of the other is the guarantee that we will not have a clash of civilizations.

The superiority, the so-called superiority, of free nations, of democratic nations, which are something more than Western nations or societies, must be demonstrated precisely in the most difficult moments, when fighting against terrorism. That is when we must be more respectful of international law, more respectful of domestic law, and more open to understanding between peoples, cultures, and religions.

I want to put before you a horizon of optimistic perspective: terrorism will be defeated. To achieve this, it will be necessary to nourish and revive the best democratic values; it will be necessary to cultivate the dialogue of civilizations and peoples; it will be necessary for the United Nations to be an institution with greater governance capacity in the interests of international order; it will also be necessary for a better distribution of development in the world.

Terrorism has no justification. No cause can be invoked to even understand or comprehend what terrorism represents; but let us not give any opportunity for terrorists, for the violent, for the fanatics, to invoke hunger, hopelessness, the marginalization of peoples, and the prospect of a future without any direction and without any horizon for so many human beings, as is happening today on Earth.

Fighting against terrorism and making the battle against terrorism a great collective objective is undoubtedly one of the noblest ideals that a society, a person, a collective, or a country can have at this historical moment; but let us maintain the principles. It is the democratic soul that makes us strong against terror; it is the passion for freedoms that will make us invincible against the violent; it is the capacity to understand the different ways of life, the diverse collective histories that exist in humanity, that will allow us to see that final horizon, which has undoubtedly been a progressive objective in the history of the world: to reduce violence, force, imposition, and to ensure that every day there are more citizens, that is, more free people, with rights, with a voice, with the ability to listen, to understand, and to tolerate.

Baltasar, I want to conclude by making a reference to you. You are a fighter for freedoms and an active defender of a legal order that must inevitably be firm and strong against terrorism. Rest assured — you invoked that reflection at the beginning — that I want to lead a government that is firm against terrorism; a government that puts at the service of the State Security Forces and Corps all means, and also at the service of Justice; a government firm in democratic principles; a government scrupulous in the use of legality as the only weapon to fight against terrorism; a government that defends the path of understanding, peace, cooperation, intelligence, intelligence services, increasingly integrated justice, increasingly integrated legislation, to corner terrorism; and not the defense of preventive wars, of anticipatory wars, which do not reduce but rather fuel terrorism.

I also want the government to be characterized as one of the governments in the world that encourages a better distribution of development and progress; that the collective consciousness of humanity must be present in the direction that it is not possible for many peoples, many countries, and many societies to be left behind; that we will not be equal if we are not all equal; that we will not have rights if not everyone has rights; that surely we will not have well-being in the future if the vast majority does not have well-being.

In short, the affirmation of the best values, the defense of human rights, the defense of democracy, the defense of freedom, and the defense of solidarity is the most compelling way to fight against terrorism. The limits are in reason and in conscience, and the obligation, of course, of a government and all political representatives is to be up to the level of society. And I can assure you that being up to the level of Spanish citizens, with what they have demonstrated over these thirty years, with what they demonstrated on March 12, the day after the attack in Madrid; being up to the level of Spanish citizens is a task worth pursuing. Difficult, but worth pursuing.

Congratulations, Baltasar, once again for your dedication, and thank you all very much.