Speech by the President of the Government at the course "Politics, Citizenship and the Information Society," by Philip Pettit, at the Círculo de Bellas Artes.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

18 July 2004 · Course "Politics, Citizenship and the Information Society" by Philip Pettit · Círculo de Bellas Artes

Context
Zapatero addressed a seminar at the Círculo de Bellas Artes in Madrid on July 18, 2004, reflecting on Philip Pettit's lecture on politics, citizenship, and republicanism.
Main themes
Republican political tradition, citizenism and civic socialism, democracy and freedom, renewal of the Spanish Socialist Party, citizenship and the state, social justice and solidarity, political generations in Spain, Philip Pettit's republicanism, information society, left-wing ideology renewal, imperium and authority, progressive politics
Duration
~14 min
48th percentile
Words
1,641
48th percentile
Sentences
38
24th percentile
Readability
25
9th percentile
Grade
20.5
98th percentile
Syntax
3.91
99th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
40th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 46%45%
  • Institutional 30%29%
  • Ceremonial 22%21%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

38 sentences in 20 paragraphs

Thank you very much, Philip, for your brilliant intervention, which has evoked many of the ideas that we have been weaving together over these years.

I had imagined that this event carried some risk for someone who is the President of the Government, is in power, and ultimately exercises the "imperium," the authority, to which Professor Pettit referred. But I will address that at the end of this brief intervention that I wanted to make to accompany what this event represents and the ideas we have seen; the experience that underpins why, ultimately, I am here participating in this interesting conference.

Just four years ago, just four years ago, or perhaps it has already been four years, depending on how you look at it, a group of comrades from the Socialist Party, very close to here, where we are today, gathered to try to provide a response, a way out, to open a path to the situation that the Socialist Party was experiencing after the electoral defeat, the heavy electoral defeat, that we suffered in the year 2000.

We had two very clear convictions: the first was that a leftist project could only win from ideas and that whenever a progressive project won, it was because it accumulated, built, and tried to convey ideas into a political offer; the second was that politics is always about starting anew, as is life in democracy and as is the demand for freedom that human beings claim for themselves.

The truth is that the option we began to think about initially materialized in what was the change brought about by the Socialist Party at the XXXV Congress. Today I want to highlight a fact, perhaps the most relevant, of what was the expression of that process at the XXXV Congress of the emergence of a new leadership in the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, and that is the generation to which that leadership belonged that emerged at the XXXV Congress of the PSOE.

That generation, which we called "New Path" -- it seems that it could now be referred to as citizenism, with its followers being citizenists, obviously -- represented a very specific generation of Spanish society. We represent the generation of the 80s, born in the 60s; I was born in 1960. It was the first generation of Spaniards whose mother tongue in politics is democracy, and our values, our political ideals, and our socialization as citizens have always occurred in democracy. We have voted as many times as a Frenchman, an Englishman, or a Swede of our generation. Our institutions, since we have had political consciousness, public awareness, are comparable to those of any democracy in our environment.

We were and are, therefore, the first political generation of democracy, the first political generation that has always lived in freedom, and that marks our character. I believe it is the determining element of what represents the change in the Socialist Party and of what that fabric of ideas to which we have dedicated ourselves over these four years represents. And it marks it in a very evident way because, despite being the first political generation of democracy, we have a clear awareness of the contingent nature of it, we value it, because we know that it is not natural and forever, but rather a human work that lasts as long as it is defended.

That commitment to democracy and its maintenance and continuous improvement is also a commitment to the values of solidarity and social justice, which are the values most intrinsically characteristic of the left or socialism.

Without a doubt, from those convictions we were in a fertile ground for us to recognize ourselves in the tradition that Philip Pettit has so well systematized, because by reading Professor Pettit we were able to understand that we were very close in our approaches, still perhaps halting, to the republican tradition of thought; that our way of understanding public life, the future of the left, and the necessary renewal of socialism was a practical formula of citizenism, to start coining the term. That is to say, not a debate around the particular form of Government, but a philosophy about what the relationships between citizenship and the State should be.

That tradition, from my point of view, the republican tradition of thought, the tradition of civism, is undoubtedly the most radical form of liberalism; a tradition that had been largely obscured by the growing use of liberalism as a pretext to carry out a very specific economic project and model: the model, ultimately, of great power for the economic powerful and silence in the face of social inequalities.

Therefore, defending a citizen socialism or a socialism of citizens represents defending a project that does not turn citizens into people either dependent on the State or dominated by any other power, but rather puts their freedom, their initiative, and therefore the conviction that the exercise of being increasingly more citizens, of extending the idea of citizenship, was undoubtedly extending the best values of the left and also of socialism, which has sometimes historically been focused only on economic issues and has lacked, in my opinion, a development or an embrace, as we do in this case, of a solid political theory of the State, of the State and citizenship, of the forms of power distribution, of the call to participation that Professor Pettit spoke about.

In his main work on republicanism, Professor Pettit recognizes that there is a clear path of that solid tradition of thought that has traversed History, that has been reborn at certain moments, that there is a closeness to what socialism represents, and I underline two fundamental themes, as is well known, in the interest of our political project. The first of these is gender equality, which explicitly appears in his work as one of the fundamental elements of democratic development, of citizenship development, and also multiculturalism or the recognition of what it means to coexist in the same political space with different cultures, with peoples of diverse traditions, with different religions, and also with powerful identities as happens in our country. Therefore, his thought and the tradition he has expressed undoubtedly represent a great theoretical help for socialism and for the left.

We have experienced what happened to the bourgeois of Molière, who discovered with great surprise that he spoke in prose without having known it before. And by reading Professor Pettit, some of us discovered that the project we began to think and feel at the XXXV Congress of the party was very close to the renewal of thought around citizenship that we are experiencing at this moment.

We have insisted on many occasions that we wanted to avoid confusions with the form of State. Today Philip has clarified that again in this event, and therefore in the search for a concept, for an idea, that adequately encompasses, we have leaned towards speaking of the democracy of citizens and the socialism of citizens. It is a way of capturing the sense of the republican tradition and, obviously, of what our project has wanted to represent.

Political leaders are not specialists in the history of ideas, and perhaps we should apologize for that; but we must have the permanent capacity to recognize which ideas are closest to our goals and values, to publicly expose them, debate them, subject them to contrast, and remain permanently restless in the field of intellectual production and ideas.

I want, therefore, to say that I owe Professor Pettit for giving me the opportunity to clarify my own ideas and a language that allows me to explain more rigorously what the project of the society with which I am committed is, and to which the citizens of Spain gave their trust in the last general elections.

The citizens of our country have often demonstrated the best civic virtues, and I hope that this will also be demonstrated after what will be this period of Government. Citizens who do not want to be treated as minors; citizens who want nothing to be hidden from them; citizens who have the right to have rights; citizens who know how to value what it is to live as a free man among free men; citizens who know that no one is equal if we are not all equal; citizens who must always have a vigilant and distrustful attitude towards power, because that is undoubtedly a guarantee of avoiding unjustified domination.

I want to conclude. It comforts me, I cannot hide it, that Philip has established the need for there to be power, a Government, an authority, for reasons that everyone can understand; but, as I also belong to that group of people who think that power must be very controlled, that there must be permanent vigilance, that we must produce that demanding, critical citizenship that questions, that opposes the decisions of power, I think it is quite sensible to say that, since we have to have power in society, it should be in the hands of those who love it the least. I think that can be a good reflection.

I invite Professor Pettit to a call. The call is that we hold a public deliberation event, an open debate, in three long years, almost four years, to contrast what four years of Government have been, with the trust and hope that his ideas, the recovery of a profound tradition of which the history of thought and action can be proud, have permeated and been present in what represents the action of a Government that is undoubtedly fully aware that, above all, it wants a powerful citizenship, a strong citizenship, and that its goal, as I have formulated on some occasions, is that the powerful have a little less power every day and citizens more rights every day.

Thank you very much.