Intervention of the President of the Government in the Plenary of the Congress of Deputies to report on the conclusions of the European Council in Brussels.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

5 April 2005 · Plenary session of the Congress of Deputies to report on the conclusions of the European Council · Congress of Deputies

Context
Zapatero addressed the Spanish Congress of Deputies on 5 April 2005 to report on conclusions from the Brussels European Council of 22–23 March 2005.
Main themes
Stability and Growth Pact reform, Lisbon Strategy mid-term review, European Council conclusions, fiscal policy and deficit rules, sustainable development and climate change, economic rationality in EU governance, public debt sustainability, budgetary balance over the economic cycle, structural reforms, EU enlargement and heterogeneity
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,679
83rd percentile
Sentences
127
74th percentile
Readability
22
5th percentile
Grade
17.3
91st percentile
Syntax
3.26
78th percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
59th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 57%57%
  • Institutional 21%21%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Environmental 6%6%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

127 sentences in 69 paragraphs

Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen of the Parliament,

I appear before you to inform you about the Conclusions adopted at the European Council held in Brussels on the 22nd and 23rd of March.

First of all, I would like to thank the Luxembourg Presidency for its effective work, which, in the face of significant challenges posed at this Council, has successfully facilitated the agreements reached. The Luxembourg Presidency decided to focus almost exclusively on issues related to the Stability and Growth Pact, the mid-term review of the Lisbon Strategy, as well as sustainable development and climate change.

Honorable Members,

The European Council endorsed the Report adopted by the ECOFIN Council on March 20 and approved the reform of the Stability and Growth Pact, a reform focused on improving its preventive component, as well as enhancing and clarifying the Excessive Deficit Procedure. The agreement is excellent news, and its content is promising for revitalizing the European economy.

The first point I would like to highlight about the reform is that the reference values of 3 percent of GDP for the deficit and 60 percent for public debt are maintained, limits that have greatly aided the consolidation of public finances in Europe and that will therefore continue to constitute the core of fiscal stability in the Monetary Union.

In the preventive part, it has been decided to replace the generic objective of achieving budgetary positions close to balance or surplus in the medium term with individualized targets by country, taking into account the potential growth and debt level of each country. As you know, until now the targets were identical for all countries, and there was no possibility of incurring a deficit.

The first advantage of this reform is that, by taking into account potential growth, it allows for rewarding countries that implement policies contributing to the objectives of the Lisbon Strategy. The second advantage is that it strengthens the debt criterion, that is, the sustainability of public finances. Indeed, the targets will be more demanding for countries with higher public debt, which will help make the 60 percent public debt limit established in the Treaties more operational, which until now had had reduced effectiveness.

Only countries with low debt will be able to afford greater flexibility. It is being considered to define a low level of debt for a country as a debt ratio equal to or less than 40 percent of its GDP. This, as is known, is not the situation in Spain.

In short, after the reform, the Pact allows for consideration of the specific circumstances of each country, which is very important in a European Union that has significantly increased its heterogeneity. For example, this condition will help some countries, such as the new members from the East, which need to make strong investments to catch up economically with the wealthier countries of Europe and still have low levels of indebtedness and high potential growth.

Another interesting novelty of the new Stability Pact is that, when deviations occur in the deficit targets, the adjustment to be made must be more intense in times of higher growth and more gradual if growth is lower. That is to say, the European Union has decided to move away from the dogma of zero deficit for all years and has welcomed the concept of budgetary balance over the cycle, which this Government has advocated from the beginning, because it is a concept with much greater economic rationality.

It has also been decided that, as long as there is room to ensure compliance with the 3 percent limit, a temporary deviation in the medium term will be allowed if the member state has carried out relevant structural reforms.

In short, Honorable Members, in the reform of the preventive part, there has been an awareness of the need for governments, like families and individuals, to take advantage of good times to save in anticipation of less favorable moments.

All of this has been complemented by a reform of the Excessive Deficit Procedure, which has endowed it with greater economic rationality. The reform takes exceptional circumstances into account. When they occur, a country can breach the 3 percent limit without triggering the Excessive Deficit Procedure, as long as the deviation is temporary.

Previously, a negative growth of 2 percent in the economies was considered an exceptional situation. This situation was excessively strict, because since the Maastricht Treaty came into force, no European country has experienced such a severe recession. Therefore, from now on, any annual rate of negative real GDP growth or an accumulated loss of GDP caused by several years of low growth will be understood as exceptional circumstances.

Thus, the aim is to better align the Pact with reality and endow it with greater economic rationality. It is intended, in this way, to avoid forcing countries to adopt counterproductive measures in times of low growth, measures that not only do not benefit the economy of the country in question but also do not positively impact the European economy as a whole, but rather the opposite.

The reform also establishes which relevant factors must be taken into account, both by the Commission and by the Council, when deciding whether or not to initiate the Excessive Deficit Procedure and setting deadlines for adjustment.

They will consider, first of all, factors related to the economic situation, such as the cyclical situation and policies aimed at complying with the Lisbon Strategy. They will also consider those related to the sustainability of public finances, such as the level of debt, the composition of public spending, and efforts to save in good times. And, thirdly, other factors that countries may propose when analyzing their fiscal situation will be taken into account. In this area, special attention will be paid to expenditures related to international solidarity and the objectives of the European Union.

The consideration of these relevant factors will allow for greater sensitivity of the Pact towards those policies and expenditures that enhance economic growth, such as spending on Research and Development, education and training, infrastructure, and all those policies aimed at achieving the objectives of Lisbon.

In short, Honorable Members, I firmly believe in the merits of this reform, as it will allow, while respecting the traditional reference values and basic rigor, a greater adaptation to the situation of countries and the needs of economic reality, which involve strengthening the foundations of European growth. I also firmly believe that the reform of the Stability and Growth Pact, ratified at the last European Council, will be one of the pillars on which, along with the review of the Lisbon Strategy, the greater future economic growth of Europe will be based. This reform lays the foundations for economic growth and budgetary stability for the coming years in the European Union, with a new impetus for the Lisbon Strategy.

At this point, it is appropriate for the Chamber to be informed about the situation and position of Spain regarding economic growth and budgetary stability.

Honorable Members,

Currently, the Spanish economy is maintaining a dynamic economic performance. The GDP growth rate in 2004 has been estimated at 2.7 percent, higher than that of a year ago, and it is expected to rise to around 3 percent in the coming quarters.

The fluid development of economic activity in Spain is particularly notable given the difficult international context in which it is taking place. Spanish exports have maintained a weak tone, weighing down sales abroad due to the price of oil; however, despite this, exports grew by 4.5 percent in 2004. On the other hand, the recent increase in oil prices could have diminished our growth prospects. Despite all this, Spain is the only country where expectations are improving, both among consumers and entrepreneurs, as evidenced by the latest report from the European Commission.

The expansion of Gross Domestic Product is also accompanied by certain very favorable qualitative aspects. The strength of investment in capital goods, with growth rates of between 9 and 10 percent in the last two quarters, reflects that entrepreneurs share the Government's confidence in the country's economic future and indicates the financial health of our companies.

In short, Honorable Members, the good performance of investment not only contributes to present growth but also lays the foundations for greater and better future growth.

The clarification and improvement of the Stability and Growth Pact is directly linked to the Spanish Government's commitment to budgetary stability over the cycle. Both in Europe and in Spain, it is necessary to have efficient fiscal rules that combine budgetary discipline with the need for fiscal policy to contribute to macroeconomic stability through the operation of automatic stabilizers.

The Government has made the commitment to budgetary stability over the cycle one of the cornerstones of its economic policy. This commitment has been clearly reflected in the design of the General Budgets for this year 2005, which will close with a surplus, as well as in the budgetary result for the year 2004, which has closed with a small deficit of 0.28 percent in the overall public administrations, despite having undertaken significant operations such as the assumption of RENFE's historical debt or that contracted with Andalusia.

Looking to the future, the commitment to budgetary discipline over the cycle will acquire true legitimacy with the reform of the Budgetary Stability Law that the Government will present this year and that will help correct the less positive aspects of the current text.

The objective of this reform will be none other than to achieve a more rational fiscal rule that can be accepted as its own by all stakeholders, so that it becomes the basis of an internal pact for stability. Specifically, mechanisms will be improved to allow public accounts to adapt to different economic growth situations, and provisions, currently nonexistent, will be introduced so that both the State and the Autonomous Communities must achieve public surpluses in the high phases of the cycles. It will be the first time that a fiscal rule in Spain requires achieving public surpluses at all levels of government, except for municipalities.

The effort to improve the Stability Law will also pursue a substantial increase in the transparency of public accounts prepared by all levels of administration. The reason is obvious: only from a clear commitment to transparency can budgetary stability generate all its positive effects on the formation of expectations of economic agents.

Ladies and gentlemen of the Parliament,

Once the reform of the Stability Pact has been resolved, the European Council focused on approving the relaunch of the Lisbon Strategy.

As you know, the Lisbon Strategy, adopted in March 2000, aims to make the European Union the most competitive and dynamic knowledge-based economy in the world, capable of sustainable growth, with more and better jobs and greater social cohesion. This objective was complemented in 2001, during the Swedish Presidency, by adding the environmental dimension linked to the notion of sustainable development.

Today, five years later, it can be said that the Lisbon Strategy has made some progress, particularly in boosting the internal market, increasing the employment rate, and reducing greenhouse gas emissions. For example, the employment rate in the European Union has reached 65 percent of the working-age population, five points away from the target set for 2010.

However, it is also undeniable that progress has been insufficient. In terms of employment, Europe would need to grow at an annual rate of 3 percent and create twenty-one million jobs to meet the objectives set for 2010.

Allow me now to refer to the current evolution of unemployment and employment in Spain.

The labor market, Honorable Members, is showing a clearly favorable evolution in our country. The rate of increase in employment has been around 4 percent in recent quarters, according to the new Active Population Survey. The new Survey clearly shows the persistence of two of the basic trends in the Spanish labor market, distinct but related: the influx of foreign population attracted by the employment opportunities offered by our economy, and the increasing proportion of active and employed individuals among the working-age population.

It is also noteworthy, and this is a more recent phenomenon, the drop in unemployment, noticeable since the second half of last year, as in the last quarter of 2004 the decrease in unemployment was 4 percent, the most favorable rate in the last three years. The contraction of unemployment indicates that, beyond the expansive evolution of the working-age population and its growing propensity to engage in labor activity, the labor market is increasingly performing its task of matching supply and demand.

No less important is the fact that this expansion of the labor market is occurring without significant wage tensions. The evolution of wages is generally reasonable and in line with inflation trends. This, in turn, is allowing the overall economy to absorb the expansion of aggregate demand without creating excessive imbalances.

Honorable Members,

Everything suggests that economic dynamism will be maintained in our country.

But, of course, where Spain has most failed to comply with the Lisbon Strategy has been in relation to investments in R&D. Against the target of 3 percent investment in R&D, Spain has barely been able to surpass the barrier of 1 percent. Maintaining the slow growth rate of R&D investment imposed by the previous Government, it would take us about thirty years to reach the Lisbon target.

Regarding the goal that the private sector contributes two-thirds of the resources allocated to R&D, not only have we not converged, but this figure has deteriorated by three percentage points, from 51 percent to 48 percent, over the last four years. Also in relation to investment in information technologies as a percentage of GDP, Spain has continuously distanced itself from the European average in recent years: from 56 percent in 2001 to 53 percent in 2003.

All these data explain why Spain has systematically ranked below the twentieth position in the world ranking in the main indicators of the Information and Knowledge Society advocated by the Lisbon Strategy.

Honorable Members,

From my point of view, we have lost precious time, but the Government I lead is determined to recover it. The Lisbon Strategy will be a reality in our country. This time Spain wants and must lead this process. The Government wants the Lisbon Strategy to take root deeply in our society, because our future competitiveness and, ultimately, the well-being of all Spaniards depend on it.

That is why the Government decided to play a leadership role in relaunching the Strategy, which became visible in all the preparatory stages of the Spring European Council. During these months we have taken an active role, presenting a specific contribution to focus the objectives of the Strategy and give it greater visibility; to reorient it towards productivity and closing the technological gap, a decisive issue for Spain, and to nationalize its application through a renewal of its governance system.

Mr. President, Honorable Members,

I can say with satisfaction that our proposals are clearly reflected in the final outcome regarding the relaunch of the Lisbon Strategy.

At this European Council, all member states have committed to reorient and concentrate the Lisbon Strategy on two major objectives: growth and employment. According to the Commission's Report, these objectives would translate into the creation of six million jobs and an annual growth rate of 3 percent of GDP until 2010.

We have also committed to creating a "European Partnership for Growth and Employment" with a single objective, to increase growth through boosting productivity. To this end, we have acknowledged the need to act in three major areas: making Europe an attractive space for investment, turning knowledge and innovation into the axes of economic growth in Europe, and creating more and better jobs.

Within these three blocks, we have agreed to act around ten priority areas, some as important for Spain as the internal market, external competitiveness, education and training, research and innovation, modernization of social protection systems, or European infrastructures.

Allow me to emphasize a series of issues and objectives set at the Council to which I attribute special importance: the common interest in advancing towards a Services Directive that completes the single market without undermining the European social model; the explicit mention of improving European infrastructures and, in particular, European networks, a point especially relevant for Spain, given its geographical position and peripheral situation, and the need to increase investment levels in R&D and maintain them above 3 percent of GDP.

To promote these policies, the creation of a European Research Council has been agreed upon, and it has been decided to develop the European Education Area. In this area, the reference to the need to promote excellence and, at the same time, to promote the closing of the technological gap in the Seventh Framework Programme for Research of the Union is of special importance for Spain.

Also at Spain's initiative, the European Council has mentioned the importance of biodiversity and has endorsed the European Pact for Youth. This Pact originates from an initiative presented by France, Germany, Sweden, and Spain, and aims to ensure that the dimension and expectations of European youth are taken into account in the development of all community policies. The Government has considered this initiative of great importance, as it will introduce specific policies to promote employment, training, and the reconciliation of work and family life for young Europeans.

Finally, to be able to meet the proposed objectives and effectively implement the indicated actions, the European Council has adopted decisive measures to modify the governance method of the new Lisbon Strategy, both at the national and European levels.

Its main innovations are the development of National Reform Programmes, as well as the designation of a national coordinator in each country to give visibility to the process and to articulate the Government's proposals with those of the Autonomous Communities, Parliaments, and social agents. Today I announce that the Government will initiate in May the process of developing proposals, consultations, and dialogue that will culminate in the autumn of 2005 with the presentation of the first National Reform Programme to meet the Lisbon objectives in our country.

The review of the Lisbon Strategy comes at the right time and reinforces what is one of the essential elements of the Government's economic policy: to favor the effective transition to a new growth model based on the dynamism of productivity and the creation of quality jobs.

To achieve this objective, the Government has launched five levers of economic policy, starting with the announced, and known to the Chamber, Plan for the Dynamization of the Economy and Boosting Productivity, and continuing with the reforms planned in the labor market, which are being developed within the framework of social dialogue. There are also reforms underway in the fiscal area, in strengthening budgetary stability throughout the cycle, and in improving the environment in which our companies operate, through the Business Promotion Plan, which we will approve this year.

Honorable Members,

I also want to briefly refer to the agreements reached on climate change and sustainable development. On this issue, the Council has welcomed the entry into force of the Kyoto Protocol and has reaffirmed the Union's firm commitment to give new impetus to international negotiations in this area. To this end, the European Council has reiterated the need to establish a medium- and long-term strategy to combat the effects of climate change, in line with the process carried out in the United Nations.

The Union hopes to examine, with other international actors, possible strategies to achieve the necessary reduction of emissions. Thus, for the group of developed countries, reduction profiles of around 15 to 30 percent by 2020 compared to the reference values set out in the Kyoto Protocol could be considered. According to the agreement reached, it will also be necessary to study the mechanisms to involve in this challenge the countries that are major energy consumers, including those belonging to the group of emerging and developing countries.

Finally, ladies and gentlemen, the European Council has had the opportunity to address two specific issues of international relevance.

On the one hand, the issue of Lebanon, reiterating the European commitment to a sovereign, independent, and democratic Lebanon, and inviting Syria to promptly fulfill the commitments made by its President to withdraw all Syrian troops and intelligence services from that territory. Likewise, the European Council has supported the formation, as quickly as possible, of a new Government that can organize free, transparent, and fair elections within the established deadlines, in accordance with the Lebanese Constitution and without foreign interference or meddling.

Finally, the European Council has positively evaluated the presentation by the Secretary-General of the United Nations of his Report "A Broader Concept of Freedom: Development, Security, and Human Rights for All," in preparation for the United Nations Summit in September 2005.

The European Union has reiterated in the Council its willingness to contribute to common responses to the major problems of development, security, and human rights. It is the intention of the European Union to confirm the central role of the United Nations in all these processes, to assess the progress made since the Millennium Declaration of 2000, and to make a continued and more intense effort for European institutions to actively participate in these debates.

In short, Honorable Members, the European Council, by approving the reform of the Stability Pact and relaunching the Lisbon Strategy, has sent a message of confidence for economic growth and job creation; a message of confidence that, directly linked to the good evolution of the Spanish economy and the positive evolution of job creation, places us before a transcendental challenge: to ensure that this time the Lisbon Strategy and the overcoming of our technological deficiencies in Research, Development, and therefore raising our knowledge potential as an essential engine and channel for future economic development, become the great immediate task. To that task and to the economic reforms I have referred to, the Government is committed, and I am convinced that it will count on the support of all of Your Lordships.

Thank you very much.