Interview with the President of the Government on TVE-1

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

18 January 2005 · Interview on TVE-1

Context
Zapatero was interviewed on TVE-1 in January 2005, addressing ETA violence, the Ibarretxe Plan debate, and prospects for peace in the Basque Country.
Main themes
ETA terrorism and peace process, Basque Country politics, Ibarretxe Plan and referendum, dialogue and democratic order, Spanish constitutional framework, Basque elections, interparty cooperation on terrorism
Duration
~76 min
97th percentile
Words
9,130
97th percentile
Sentences
368
97th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.13
64th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

368 sentences in 151 paragraphs

Lorenzo Milá .- Good evening, Mr. President.

President .- Good evening.

L. Milá .- It is easy to realize that we have started an intense year. Just last Monday, many politicians were talking about something moving towards the end of ETA. But, of course, the car bomb yesterday in Guecho and then Otegi's statements, warning that the conflict continues, left us with the opposite message. Mr. President, what situation are we in now? Despite all that, the noise of the bomb, Otegi's statements, do you have any data that something is really moving in that direction towards peace?

President .- I think we can all agree that a terrorist movement like ETA has to end at some point, that it will not last forever. To achieve this, we must work for hope; without getting our hopes up, but working for hope.

In recent years, with different governments, there have been various opportunities during ceasefire situations. There was one with Felipe González, there was one with José María Aznar, and I believe they tried to see if there was an opportunity to reach the end of ETA, the end of terrorism, and I think they were right. The other day, in San Sebastián, I clearly told ETA, the world of violence, that as long as the noise of weapons continues, the noise of bombs like yesterday's, as long as they do not condemn violence, they will not be heard, neither by the government nor by society.

That is the scenario we have, and I can remind you of an anecdote. When I was elected Secretary General of the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, in my first meeting with Aznar at La Moncloa, one of the first things I said to him was: "Nothing would make me happier, Mr. President, than to see the end of ETA with you as President and me as leader of the opposition." Today I have that desire even more alive, and I believe that Mariano Rajoy shares this as well.

Therefore, let us work for hope; without getting our hopes up, but working for hope.

L. Milá .- Mr. President, this year there are elections in the Basque Country. Before that, on February 1 or whenever the date is set, the Congress of Deputies will debate the Ibarretxe Plan, and we already know what the outcome of that debate will be: it will be rejected. If afterwards the Lehendakari calls for a referendum, what will you do, in the government?

President .- The Ibarretxe Plan will indeed be rejected by a large majority in Parliament, in the Congress of Deputies, and therefore, that proposal, which has not gone beyond being a proposal from Parliament, will never have validity.

Euskadi needs a plan for everyone, Euskadi needs a plan for coexistence that does not bear anyone's name, none of us, none of the politicians. It needs a plan where everyone can recognize themselves. No essential text of coexistence bears the name of just one person. I consider the Lehendakari, Mr. Ibarretxe, to be a democrat, and certainly, as a democrat, I cannot imagine that at any moment he would have the temptation not to comply with, not to respect, the democratic order and the laws.

L. Milá .- But we already know that he has that temptation. If he calls for that referendum, Mr. President, what will the government do?

President .- I reiterate: I consider the Lehendakari to be a democrat, and I am convinced that a democrat will not cross the line of respecting the constitutional order, respecting the laws.

L. Milá .- The future of the Basque Country is one of the important topics, logically, of this interview, but not the only one.

To discuss all of this, I am joined tonight by four other journalists: Javier González Ferrari, President of Onda Cero, and someone who knows Radiotelevisión Española very well; Nativel Preciado, a regular contributor to the magazine "Tiempo," Cadena SER, and Antena-3; Charo Zarzalejos, a journalist for the Vasco Press Agency and a contributor to "Desayunos de TVE"; and José Antich, director of the newspaper "La Vanguardia."

Javier González Ferrari .- There has been an image that may have unsettled Spanish society a bit, which was the Lehendakari's entrance into La Moncloa, not because the Lehendakari entered La Moncloa, but because we all knew what the Lehendakari was going to ask the President of Spain, and we also knew what the President was going to say to the Lehendakari. I think that is something that can be said in a very short time, and you talked for three and a half hours, three and a half hours, because he said -- I suppose -- "this is my plan," and you replied: "this is not the plan." That can be said, and I just said it, in five seconds. The rest, the three and a half hours, what did you talk about?

President .- I want to emphasize the value of words and dialogue; it seems essential to me, because, leading the Government of Spain, looking back at the last twenty-five years, which we have successfully and brilliantly traversed, we can reach a conclusion: dialogue has been essential, the capacity for understanding, for reaching agreements, for renouncing... Even if there is a fundamental disagreement, like the one the Lehendakari currently has with the government, which we maintained in that meeting, it is important to talk and to dialogue, because surely in the future we will never be able to try to reach an agreement if we do not talk.

I received the Lehendakari for the same reasons that I reject the Plan: for democratic convictions, for institutional respect because he is the Lehendakari who represents all Basques. The conversation was interesting and positive for me. We talked about the situation in Euskadi, and I explained in detail why I oppose the Ibarretxe Plan; not only the constitutional reasons but also the reasons for coexistence, that Euskadi needs a great meeting, that it can have more self-government, that this is a modern Spain, that this is a plural Spain, that this is a European Spain, that Euskadi's position within the state can be an accepted and agreed position by all, and that we should work in that direction.

We will never be able to work on the premise that a majority, even if it is 51 percent, in Euskadi says "this is the new institutional framework," beyond the fact that it does not respect the Constitution. And I believe that dialogue was fruitful.

J. González Ferrari .- Did the Lehendakari talk to you about a truce?

President .- No, he did not talk to me about a truce. We talked, of course, about the situation of violence, about how to share more tasks, more collaboration, to see the end of violence, to see the end of terror, to see the end of ETA. I believe that is a desire that the Basque government has just as the national government has and just as the vast majority of Spaniards have.

But, I insist, dialogue is essential in democracy; dialogue is the essence of democratic politics, and I believe we must preserve, even if there is a fundamental disagreement, that capacity to talk. It is the only key to understanding the future.

Nativel Preciado .- My question is about the meeting with the King. You, the President of the Government, and Mr. Rajoy were with the King, talking for an hour. You speak of dialogue, and indeed, it is fundamental. Nationalists and Izquierda Unida have complained a lot about that meeting, about that dialogue, between the two major parties, the main parties in Spain. Is that dialogue extendable to others or is it exclusive?

President .- Since I have been in the Presidency of the Government, I have maintained a dialogue absolutely with all political forces and with all the presidents of Autonomous Communities. I believe this is the fourth time in nine months that I have met, I have a dialogue, with Mr. Rajoy. I have met with all political forces, with all leaders. I will continue to meet, and in the coming days, I will have more meetings.

I sincerely believe that nationalist forces or any other force should not be bothered that the President of the Government meets with the King, which he does regularly; that the King also has a meeting with Mr. Rajoy as he has meetings with other political, economic, and social leaders. He fulfills a function as Head of State. That we had a meeting there, that we talked, I believe falls within the normality of democracy knowing, as we know, that we have a King, a Head of State, open to dialogue with all political forces and with all of society.

I believe that is easy to understand, and I hope it does not cause them any discomfort, because there are no reasons for it.

Charo Zarzalejos .- In response to the question posed by Lorenzo Milá regarding ETA, you used the exact term: "work for hope." Do you not think that when it comes to such a serious matter, when there is an established state of opinion in the Basque Country in which there is a certainty determined by some very important political sectors and by the citizenry in general that something is happening, that the government did not find out by chance about Otegi's letter, nor much less about ETA's letter...? And today Otegi has said that you are more prudent than others who call for the dissolution of ETA.

Mr. President, as I know these things generate hope, I would like, as far as possible, for you to tell us if there is really something more than what we are seeing in the newspapers, among other reasons, because if there is, I would prefer to find out, if possible, from the government and not from ETA, which, as you well know, tells everything.

President .- I believe I said in response to the first question that we must work for hope; without getting our hopes up, but working for hope.

C. Zarzalejos .- Is work being done?

President .- Certainly, working for hope means, first of all, maintaining firmness in the fight against terrorism; secondly, carrying out a political task of extending the conviction, throughout Basque society, that violence, besides being a horror, besides having caused enormous pain to so many people, is useless; that democracy has extraordinary greatness and that only words, only politics, allow us to defend ideas.

The government, of course, does not have more information than the facts. The government does not have more information or more elements than the facts that occur.

From day one, from my investiture and during the electoral campaign, I said that my absolute priority in this country would be to see the end of ETA, to end ETA, and today I reiterate: if there is a minimal opportunity, as other governments did, undoubtedly the current government will try to make that fruitful and possible. But I do not move beyond facts and the information that the government has, which logically must have a framework of discretion and a framework of responsibility. I reiterate: we should not get our hopes up, but we must work for hope.

José Antich .- It seems that in this first round, the word "hope" is the one that occupies, let’s say, the center of our initial interventions.

I was reading, while listening to my colleagues ask you questions, a phrase of yours said last Saturday in San Sebastián that said: "hope in Euskadi has begun." It was one of the important phrases of your speech in San Sebastián. I have the impression that the whole of Spanish society is a bit disoriented because it does not know exactly where we are. Everyone is so eager for it to end that they do not know if we are on Thursday with the interview with Ibarretxe; on Friday the scenario was completely radical and it was announced that a commission of the Popular Party, the Socialist Party, and the government would be created to oversee all institutional reforms; on the same Friday we were with Otegi; on Saturday we were at your rally in San Sebastián extending a hand to Otegi; on Sunday we were in something else; on Tuesday we were with the bomb...

I do not know if the whole of Spanish society knows exactly where we are at this moment; at least, I do not know where we are, Mr. President.

President .- I believe we can put a bit of perspective, indeed, because the events have been very intense in the last week, mainly following the full session of the Basque Parliament on December 30.

We have carried out twenty-five brilliant years in our country. An earlier generation brought about the birth of democracy, the recovery of freedoms, Europe, progress, and modernization. If we were to look back, we would realize that there are two final stages missing for the journey that began in the transition to reach the goal of "absolute success." Those two final stages are the end of violence, the end of terrorism, and, secondly, in order of importance, having a time of territorial stability, a time of cohesion, of full integration, that addresses some of the issues that have directly and indirectly occurred this week.

That is why I say it is a time of hope, because I believe that Spanish society, I believe that the government, I believe that all political forces are today in a position to address and successfully carry out those two final stages. The first great segment completed, carried out by a first generation to whom we must pay tribute every day, because it is almost unthinkable that what was achieved in Spain could be accomplished, has been carried out. And now there is a second generation that I believe has the obligation, the duty -- I feel that duty -- to resolve, to fulfill, those two final stages: the end of violence, the end of ETA, and territorial stability in our country.

J. Antich.- You added "territorial stability." Of course, "territorial stability" is a phrase that admits many nuances at times when, for example, you know that different Autonomous Communities, particularly Catalonia, are drafting a new Statute to request more powers, which links to what you also said in San Sebastián about the possibility of negotiating higher levels of self-government.

President.- Indeed, I believe there is a demand for several statutory reforms; not only Catalonia, although it is perhaps the one that is most talked about, but also Andalusia, also the Canary Islands. Twenty-five years after the autonomous state, are reforms possible? Yes. Have things changed in reality? Yes. Are there new experiences in how the relationship between the central Government and the autonomous Governments has functioned? Yes. Do we have a European Union that is increasingly important in our decisions? Yes. Therefore, it is possible, and the Government supports a process of reforms.

Regarding the Statute of Catalonia, there is a demand from society and a demand from political forces to create a new Statute in Catalonia. I have the commitment, and I reiterate it today, to support a new Statute for Catalonia. I hope, and I believe it will be achieved, that this Statute comes from the Parliament of Catalonia with broad consensus— a wide majority is required— and that in the national Parliament, that Statute coming from the Catalan Parliament will be the fundamental basis, and we can have, in this Legislature, in a reasonable time, what is a new Statute of Catalonia that gives us stability in that vocation for more self-government, which I respect and believe there are spaces for more self-government.

The other Community where we need to achieve territorial stability in this time, and what I would call a definitive position, is Euskadi: a definitive position of Euskadi in the Spanish State; a definitive position that, of course, must be the result of a renewed agreement.

There was a very broad, majority agreement with the Statute of Gernika, and now we need to renew a great agreement for that definitive position of Euskadi within the State. Can it be achieved? My opinion is that yes, it can be achieved. Let us look at what the generation of the transition was capable of. The challenge was immensely more difficult, and they had the generosity, political intelligence, and historical vision to achieve it, and now I believe that the will of the vast majority of political forces is to achieve it.

L. Milá.- Mr. President, would you approve that reform of the Statute of Catalonia if the Popular Party rejects it? By the way, can you give us any more details about your meeting with Mariano Rajoy on Friday?

President.- It was a positive meeting. The leader of the opposition said in Moncloa that he left satisfied. I did not attend, as it is not usual; but I can also say today that I left that meeting satisfied for two reasons: the first, because I saw a willingness to dialogue from Mr. Rajoy, from the Popular Party, and a willingness to dialogue about reforms.

Until now, it seemed that the Popular Party maintained a rather distant, critical attitude towards the possibility of making reforms to the Constitution or making reforms to the Statutes of Autonomy. I think it is very important that the Popular Party is now in this attitude, among other things, because constitutional reforms, the four that I have proposed (regarding the Crown, the incorporation of the name of the Autonomous Communities, the incorporation of the European Constitution, and the Senate as a territorial Chamber), can only be made if there is an agreement with the Popular Party.

The others? In my opinion, like the Statute of Catalonia, it is very convenient, absolutely convenient, for the Popular Party to support the reform of the Statute. Today, the Popular Party is working on the report in the Parliament of Catalonia. If that agreement is forged there, also with the support of the Popular Party, we will have a very important path made.

Certainly, the Government's will is to reach an agreement on this matter, as well as on autonomous financing, which are the three points we outlined. Why? Because these are issues that affect state policy, they are issues that affect the institutional development of our territorial organization, and therefore, the agreement must be one that seeks to encompass the majority of political forces, and certainly, the first opposition party has notable importance.

This is different from what a government program is, a change majority, a program that is supported by the investiture; that is backed by progressive forces, to whom I thank for that support; that carries out change policies, for example, in foreign policy, in the defense of peace—hence the support I had in the withdrawal of troops from Iraq; that carries out a change policy in the expansion of citizens' rights, in equality between men and women, such as the Comprehensive Law against Gender Violence, like the Law that will begin to be debated in Parliament on the right of marriage for homosexuals... In short, expanding the concepts of citizenship. Or in social policies, as we have done with the increase in minimum pensions, or as it has been the recovery of the purchasing power of the Minimum Interprofessional Wage.

In short, there is a Government program, supported by an investiture, backed by Parliamentary Groups that complement—and I reiterate my gratitude—the 164 deputies that the Socialist Party has. I want to remind you: we had broad popular support and we are a dozen short of completing that majority in what is the task of the Government, the task of parliamentary stability. But, as this is a legislature of reforms, as this is an ambitious legislature, as it touches on state aspects and institutional development, in my opinion, and I have always expressed it this way, it is very convenient, and in some cases absolutely essential, that the Popular Party is involved.

J. González Ferrari.- Among those groups that support the Government is Esquerra Republicana de Cataluña. I seem to remember that in the agreement of the Catalan tripartite it was explicitly stated that that tripartite agreement was not compatible with any agreement that you, the Socialist Party, maintained with the Popular Party or subscribed to with the Popular Party, not only in the territorial scope of Catalonia but in the rest of the Spanish State. It is a complicated balance, because you were satisfied, Rajoy left satisfied—you were satisfied and he left; but, of course, how can you reconcile Esquerra Republicana telling you "hey, with these gentlemen, no way" and "you should not reach agreements with the gentlemen of the Popular Party," and reaching agreements with the gentlemen of the Popular Party? It is a complicated balance, you won't tell me it isn't.

President.- It is what requires reforms in the institutional areas that affect state policy.

I am convinced that any political group in the Catalan Parliament or those present in the Congress of Deputies will not oppose the Popular Party supporting the new Statute of Catalonia. The task is one of dialogue, negotiation, and listening.

If they made the Constitution—nothing more and nothing less than the Constitution!—and Carrillo and Fraga agreed, and we came from where we came, how now in something that does not have the scope of what the constitutional pact was, but rather is the reform of an Autonomous Statute, although it is important for a Community like Catalonia, or that is crucial for the whole State for its economic development and for that territorial stability, are we not going to work and not going to have the hope of achieving that great agreement?

I, of course, will work for it, and I am convinced that, I insist, all political groups will want to see or will be more satisfied if they see that a new Statute for Catalonia has the unanimous or practically majority support of the Chamber.

N. Preciado.- To reach that exciting final stage you speak of, Mr. President, we must not forget the others, those who do not dialogue, and now it seems they are asking for a very strange dialogue. Do you see that exciting moment approaching when, for example, Otegi condemns violence, when—this is what we all dream of—ETA hands over its weapons, when we know what will happen with the prisoners and that this end arrives in a plausible way?

President.- The precedents are what they are from these twenty-five or thirty years of ETA. They are not precisely such that one can feel even minimally optimistic, but very realistic.

N. Preciado.- But everything has an end.

President.- Indeed. What I reiterate is that we must work seriously for that hope; that this fundamentally depends on a strong struggle, as has been maintained, in defense of the rule of law and support for all that represents measures to prevent violence, to combat violence, and to repress those who practice violence; but it also depends on political action, on the action of increasingly accompanying more people in Euskadi who say that they cannot continue killing people for nothing, neither for an idea nor for anything; that this has no place in democracy, that it has no place in reasonable coexistence.

I believe that if that feeling is increasingly powerful; if, as I believe, the vast majority of Spaniards, and especially of Basque society, know that they are called to coexistence, that we cannot allow that to be divided between nationalists and non-nationalists, we will have worked to see that end. One should not and cannot make a prediction, but we must put everything within our reach to culminate that final stage.

C. Zarzalejos.- I just wanted to know if the President can explain to us what has happened since a few days ago when you said, and I believe I remember textually, that the PP was not necessary or that it was even not necessary to push forward some Statutes. What has happened from that moment to Friday when Mr. Rajoy left delighted and your Spokesperson, the Vice President, also showed the Government's satisfaction? What has happened for suddenly...? Some of your Ministers like to say that the only thing that has happened is that Mr. Rajoy has had an attack of sensibility; but it seems to me that that is to belittle the matter, isn't it?

President.- I am not going to enter into evaluations of what Mr. Rajoy's attitude or strategy is, and I have always expressed respect whenever we have had the opportunity, and I want to have an open, sincere dialogue with him, because I think it is important for this country and because, among other things, it is the main opposition party, representing millions of Spaniards.

I have reiterated here, and I have said it on many occasions, that the institutional reforms that affect the development of autonomy, the Statutes, and, of course, the Constitution need the agreement of the Popular Party. In the Statutes, it is not essential, but it is very convenient. I have expressed this at all times, in the Investiture Debate, and my willingness to dialogue.

It is true, and I emphasize, as I expressed before, that the Popular Party was not very inclined towards the task of those reforms, perhaps because we had not spoken deeply enough. The other day we spoke in depth, and today what matters to me is that we are already in the stage of dialogue and being able to reach understandings on all those reforms, which I consider necessary and positive for the functioning of our institutional model.

J. Antich.- To this Commission that will oversee the institutional reforms, between the Government, the Popular Party, and the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, will you invite, for example, Gaspar Llamazares to join, and then Esquerra Republicana? Will it be a broad Commission or is this Commission not the framework for these things?

President.- All political groups will be in the debate in the Parliament of Catalonia, and all political groups will be in the debate, if applicable, in the Cortes Generales on Statute reforms and constitutional reform. That will be the place for dialogue for all, for debate for all. There are a number of Groups, those that support the Government, among others the ones you mentioned a moment ago, with whom we have continuous, permanent, and fluid communication.

Until this moment, the scenario had only not been opened with the Popular Party regarding the reforms; now that dialogue scenario has been opened, but it does not oversee anything. I have heard these days say that this was an attempt to recover a kind of LOAPA. It is quite the opposite; the study and dialogue are about reforms to advance: to advance in self-government and to advance in what represents an update of our Constitution in accordance with the state model we have established.

For me, it is positive, I insist, and I will make every effort for dialogue and every effort for understanding, that the Popular Party is involved in those reforms that, of course, in any case, as I have expressed on many occasions, will be reforms that will only carry the endorsement of the Government and the Socialist Party if they are reforms that fit within the principles and within the constitutional architecture we have at this moment.

L. Milá.- Let us move forward, let us move towards Europe, and let us talk about the European Constitution. More minutes have passed than you might have imagined, so let us make an effort to synthesize in your questions, and surely the President will do so in his answers, because there are many important things left to discuss.

President, in a few days a referendum will be held in Spain. What would be the minimum participation for you, the Government, to consider it representative?

President.- The important thing is that we have a referendum on a matter of great significance, where we can demonstrate our power to the whole of the European Union by marking a path for the future of the European Union, voting on the Constitution, expressing ourselves. I believe it is the responsibility of each citizen to decide whether or not to vote, and it is our responsibility to provide arguments, explain, and suggest what stage we are opening with the Constitution of the European Union.

But for me, this stage is also a certain stage of hope. Europe has been very good for Spain. With Europe, we have consolidated democracy; with Europe, we have progressed economically. Some specific data is worth recalling: four out of ten kilometers of our current roads have been built with European funding, and it can be estimated that 300,000 jobs are created each year thanks to European aid.

We therefore have a very positive balance, and now, with the Constitution, we are making a more united and stronger Europe. A more united Europe is a Europe that guarantees the principle of peace and coexistence among different nations and peoples, and that becomes more effective in such a large Europe. A stronger Europe is one that will guarantee a social model that is the most just in the world, where we dedicate the most money to social policies and where we allocate the most resources to aid, cooperation, and development with the peoples where there is misery, hunger, and poverty. It is the region that dedicates the most money to development cooperation, double that of the United States, for example. Maintaining that social model and making a strong Europe will also be a factor of peace, of peace in the world, because those are the values that the European Union transmits and develops.

It is good for Spain to support the European Constitution, it is good for Europe, and it is also good for the world.

L. Milá.- You are aware, President, that this may be a referendum in which many people watching us right now may not feel particularly motivated, although we all know that the Government is making an effort to try to extend and explain what a European Constitution is. But the question was: what is the minimum you would consider representative?

President.- There is no representative minimum. There is what represents and what implies the responsibility and the free will of each citizen to go vote or not to go vote—I ask that people go vote—and to vote "yes" or vote "no," which will also be a free act.

I simply make a reflection, a consideration: Europe, I insist, is a great project that is growing. All the countries that have joined the European Union have progressed economically, politically, and socially. The European Union consists only of countries that want to join this great project of union that it represents. It is a project that also has an anthem, has a flag, has a currency, a motto—"United in Diversity"—and allows, moreover, all flags, allows all signs, integrates everything that represents a magnificent project of coexistence.

From my point of view, when on February 20 the citizens can go to the polls and take their ballot, they will have in their ballot a weapon of mass construction for a great project with the European Constitution.

N. Preciado.- However, President, the fact that nationalists like those of the PNV support the Constitution and nationalists like those of CiU are against this Constitution adds to the confusion.

J. Antich.- The CiU are not against it.

N. Preciado.- Sorry, I meant Esquerra.

President.- I find it positive that the Basque Nationalist Party and Convergència i Unió support the European Constitution because, without a doubt, Europe is a space that promotes the values of coexistence and integration; but not the fifty-one percent, but projects of all. All countries in the European Union ultimately have a voice. Majorities do not count as much; what matters is the will to agree, the will to walk together.

That is why I think it is positive, although I respect the political forces that propose "no."

J. Antich.- President, can there be a majority of two speeds, the day-to-day one, with which you govern, which is Esquerra Republicana and Izquierda Unida, with which you push forward all the initiatives you have explained to us, and the General State Budgets, which you have not mentioned, but also; and then another majority of another speed that also pushes forward very important issues? We are talking about the European Constitution or, for example, the opposition to the Ibarretxe Plan. There may be those who believe it is a fragile majority and others who see it as a governmental inconsistency. It seems like a majority of two speeds, where in one issue they are with some and in another issue they are with others. I do not know if that is a cruising speed for an entire legislature.

President.- There is parliamentary stability. The Government feels, and it is verifiable, a parliamentary stability. The Government has the support of the Groups to carry out a program of economic, political, and social reforms. And there are circumstances in which that majority on institutional issues expands. Can it be expanded, should it be expanded? Of course, and I believe everyone knows that my will—this was already my will as leader of the opposition, and it is also as President of the Government—is to forge the maximum number of political agreements.

Political agreements are good for democracy in general, and they are good for Spanish democracy.

C. Zarzalejos.- President, can we imagine that Morocco, in one way or another, integrates into Europe?

President.- It is a difficult task to imagine at this moment, a difficult objective.

C. Zarzalejos.- But the King's speech hinted at it, right? He spoke of an advanced Statute.

President.- Yes, we can indeed see a very high level of relationship and cooperation among various countries, including Morocco and North Africa, the Maghreb with the European Union.

There are two natural areas of relationship and communication, one of which is very sensitive for Spain, within the European Union: one is Central Europe and the other is North Africa and the Mediterranean. Europe has an interest, and especially Spain within the Union, in seeing progress, in seeing development, in seeing modernity, and in seeing the fight against immigration in all that the Mediterranean represents, especially in North Africa. Certainly, I believe that one of the elements that helps that progress and modernization is cooperation and a relationship with the European Union.

This year we will have precisely in Barcelona the opportunity to hold a Euro-Mediterranean Conference in accordance with what was the beginning of the Barcelona Process ten years ago, and to reaffirm all that is the linkage of the European Union with the Mediterranean.

J. González Ferrari.- Will King Mohammed VI, who is now very friendly with Spain, manage to stop illegal immigration that leaves from his coasts, the mafias of the boats that leave from his coasts, or will we have very good words as we have had on other occasions and in the end nothing, President?

President.- The data we can offer at this moment shows a slightly positive evolution. In 2004, compared to 2003, there were fewer boats, although there were many and many of them with very dramatic consequences; there were fewer people, fewer immigrants who died, and Morocco has reinforced and is reinforcing immigration control in its country. It is reinforcing it with a task in many cases together with Spanish teams, with Spanish means, and we have, therefore, it is essential for us to promote that good relationship, to help in the provision of means and in the provision of infrastructure to Morocco to control illegal immigration.

I insist, the trend is a slight reduction. It cannot leave us satisfied at all, but I believe that the moment of cooperation with Morocco in which we are will make the results increasingly positive.

N. Preciado.- The rapprochement with King Mohammed and cooperation with Morocco unfortunately imply sidelining the Sahrawi people, not taking into account the position defended by the Sahrawi people and Algeria, with which we are also very interested in maintaining relations? I believe the Kings are going to Algeria this year.

President.- We have a very good relationship with Algeria. It is also an important country, it is part of the stability of the whole Maghreb, we have economic interests, and soon we will have here in Spain a High-Level Meeting with Algeria.

The Sahara has been without a solution for thirty years: thirty years the Sahrawi people without seeing an expectation that can satisfy their rights, thirty years with strategies that have not yielded results. The position of the Government of Spain is very clear in this regard: the only solution to the Sahara problem, for the rights of the Sahrawi people and for what all the legislation and Resolutions in the United Nations framework have meant, must be an agreement, and in that agreement there are two main parties: Morocco and the Sahrawi people. The rest of us must work to seek that agreement. Spain works to seek that agreement. It will be the only way to a solution. If there is no agreement, there is no solution. Other European countries work for that agreement, all of them led by the United Nations.

But, I reiterate, thirty years without seeing a solution to the Sahara issue and to the Sahrawi people, whom all Spaniards have practically in our skin, in our hearts. Let us give time to what this new scenario represents, let us give a reasonable time to see if we reach that agreement that will undoubtedly be the only possible solution.

J. Antich.- President, you just spoke of Europe as a magnificent project of coexistence. On the other side of the planet, in the United States, in the coming hours a President will take office who is also part of another magnificent project of coexistence, such as the United States. George Bush will take office for his second term, after relations that have been what they have been since you have been in Moncloa, and it cannot be said that they have been excellent to date, and to use a bit of the sports jargon you know well, a few kicks in the shins have been given from Spain.

What do you expect from this second term, especially in light of the statements of the new Secretary of State, Condoleezza Rice, about more diplomacy, more dialogue, more relations with Europe, and more consideration for allies?

President.- We can speak clearly here, in this context. I understand that President Bush has been upset by the decisions my Government has made. I was openly against the war in Iraq. I withdrew Spanish troops from Iraq because it was the overwhelmingly majority will of the Spaniards and because it responded one hundred percent to my convictions.

My desire is to have a good relationship with the American Administration. Recently, yesterday and in the last few weeks, I have seen positive signals: Condoleezza Rice's speech talking about a stage of dialogue and not monologue, and also in recent weeks the recognition by the Bush Administration that there were no weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. By the way, a recognition made by the Bush Administration that some of those who solemnly asserted it in Spain have not made.

Let us hope, and I wish, that Iraq, as an element that has been central in the debate we have had with the United States, can hold its elections on January 30. I believe that is the best that could happen in Iraq, that there are elections and that this opens a stage of recovery of its sovereignty, of recovery of its coexistence, and of a certain reduction of violence.

L. Milá.- But, President, has President Bush returned your call yet or not?

President.- I believe I have been explicit in the answer I gave to Mr. Antich. I understand, I insist, that he is upset because the decisions that my Government has made freely and sovereignly, responding to principles, values, and commitments, have not pleased him.

C. Zarzalejos.- So, he has not called you.

President.- Indeed. You are correct.

J. González Ferrari.- If I may return for a moment to the European Constitution, we are seeing the institutional campaign about the referendum and there is a strong emphasis on the issue of freedom of expression. At the beginning of this interview, Lorenzo Milá himself recalled that I had something to do with this house, obviously, as I worked here for six years, I am very proud and I was frankly happy working in this house. I must acknowledge one thing, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, as President of the Government: you are one of the few candidates who promised that you would undertake the reform of public broadcasting and you fulfilled it immediately after taking office, creating the Commission of Experts that will give its report next month, in a few days.

You said more, you said: after this it will be time to address an Audiovisual Law to bring a little order to the audiovisual framework. That gave the sector quite a bit of confidence, but on December 30, you released a Draft Law to promote digital terrestrial television in the Council of Ministers, which is the direction all of Europe is heading, but which, in reality, said nothing about that promotion. What it clearly stated is that there could be more analog televisions, which seems, at first glance, a contradiction.

Will there be more analog televisions because more pluralism is needed? Because in Spain we have five operators, while in the rest of Europe, in the surrounding area, they do not exceed two. There can be many channels, but they are in the hands of two or three operators, at most. Will there be new channels? You already know that people can be quite suspicious, and some think that there is something fishy going on. A friend told me today: "maybe there is an encrypted cat, not a trapped one."

President.- I thank you very much for asking me these two questions; the first, because it affects public media and commitments, which are very important to me as Prime Minister.

Indeed, there is a "commission of experts" that will produce a report on the future of the public media model. That report will translate into legislative reform. For what purpose? To have public media that are increasingly a public service that brings us closer to Europe.

But I believe that some things have already changed in the current model of public media. Without wanting to enter into any debate, I believe that today there are news programs produced by the news directors, and I believe that today there are debates on political issues on television, plural programs where all parties are represented and where there are representatives from all media. For example, Mr. Rajoy was here for an interview three days after being elected leader of his party; it took me three years to have a television interview when I was leader of the opposition. Now I am in this first interview, nine months after becoming Prime Minister.

Plurality and freedom of information are also part of what I have expressed on many occasions as a project to extend citizens' rights.

And in the realm of private media, I also have commitments. The commitments are to extend plurality there as far as it fits within the technical spectrum. I don't care whether we are talking about televisions, cable, or any other media that produces that relationship with citizens. More plurality, advancing what is the digital television project, the "analog switch-off," and opening up possibilities. Those are the objectives.

More media, more plurality, more freedom, better information. And, with better information for citizens, undoubtedly, they have more possibilities to form an accurate opinion about what is happening. That is the commitment.

J. González Ferrari.- Will there be more analog televisions, then?

President.- Therefore, the Law has just been approved by the Council of Ministers. Let it go to Parliament, let it be debated, let it be approved, and that will be the time to make decisions. But I believe I have clearly expressed that this country can have more media, and that the Government is simply facilitating it.

As for what has been operations to promote or shape media, perhaps we should look back to a different era. That will not happen in the future. We want more plurality and more freedom, as is currently the case in public media.

L. Milá.- Let's talk about the economy. Prices have risen quite a bit, more than expected; especially housing, according to the data. Unemployment fell last year, but for many experts, one of our most serious economic problems is that we are losing competitiveness against other countries. To make it understandable, within our borders there is sufficient demand, but we have weak, complicated exports. What are you doing to correct that?

President.- The first thing we have to say is that the economy is doing better at the end of 2004 than at the beginning of 2004. Economic growth for the year 2004 will be around 2.7 or 2.8 percent. We started from below, we started at 2.5 percent, which was last year's growth.

Employment has also changed its trend. In the first quarter, jobs were lost in this country, and in the last two quarters, jobs have been created in our country. We still have the major problem, which is the decisive, fundamental task that we are going to address, of excessive precariousness in employment, which mainly affects young people. I hope there will be a great social agreement to combat precariousness in favor of job stability, an agreement in which the Government will put all resources and means so that our young people have more stable jobs.

Inflation continues to have a difficult trend to control. This requires more competitive measures and also requires, as you pointed out, improving productivity and competitiveness in our economy. And I can announce that in the coming weeks, the Ministry of Economy will present a plan to improve productivity, a plan to support businesses and improve business competitiveness.

But I want to say: the prospects for the Spanish economy are positive. Employment has a very favorable trend, we are at a record level of affiliation to Social Security, and the two major problems we have are: improving our competitiveness, which is mainly about improving productivity; and, of course, addressing the problem of precariousness in employment that particularly affects the youngest.

N. Preciado.- Regarding immigration. At the same time that we welcome immigrant workers with the best intentions, who are necessary in our country, is there any possibility of closing the borders to criminals and terrorists who also come through the same routes? I mention this in light of a recent incident that demonstrated that Criminal Records Certificates are being violated in the countries of origin.

President.- The fight against terrorism, organized crime, and mafias must cover all fronts, and, of course, international cooperation is crucial. Europe has made great strides in this, and now we need to expand those steps of judicial cooperation and police cooperation with all the countries we can, including Morocco, which is essential. We are also increasing the material and human resources in terms of personnel for controlling illegal immigration and combating organized networks.

I believe that the value of collective security is a value that the Government extends to all areas. We are starting to have better figures for reducing citizen security issues, we are starting to have better figures for reducing fatal traffic accidents, which is one of the most significant scourges we have, and I believe that by strengthening our security structures and our international cooperation in the case of terrorism and organized crime, we will also reduce the risks that undoubtedly come with all these types of activities.

J. González Ferrari.- Housing. If young people have precarious jobs, they can hardly access housing, especially at the prices that continue. It is true that housing prices have partially decreased, but they remain prohibitive. The land is there, and new housing needs to be built. There was a promise of a significant number of housing units. How many housing units or how many housing solutions, as Minister Trujillo likes to say?

President.- There will be more possibilities to access housing. There are already more possibilities to access housing today, because as soon as we took office, we implemented a Shock Plan increasing budgetary resources for public housing financing. Therefore, today there are more citizens who can access housing with public assistance, both to purchase it and to rent it.

That plan will last for four years. Next year, in 2006, we will create the new Housing Plan. We will multiply, as I expressed in the electoral commitment, the assistance by two, which has represented the assistance, and the number of people who can access housing either in ownership.

I fully agree. There has been a recent report on Spanish youth, and the major problem we have in this country, the most important social problem alongside dependency, with assistance for the elderly and dependent persons, is the enormous difficulty our young people have in becoming independent, in living on their own. In this, we have precarious employment and access to housing as major objectives and, of course, major commitments of the Government. We have a pending debt with the current generation of young people, and, of course, the Government will not spare efforts in these two areas.

C. Zarzalejos.- Mr. President, I return to the beginning and in a very succinct manner. Besides working for peace, which you have said you want to work for, and so we do not have to focus so much on Otegi and more on you, which seems reasonable because you are the Prime Minister, I want to know -- I no longer know how to ask you, but I feel obliged to do so -- if we are on the path to a peace process.

President.- We must work to be on the path to a peace process.

C. Zarzalejos.- I ask you if we are already on the path to a peace process.

President.- I reiterate, the background does not allow us to be optimistic or to have illusions. But I will tell you one thing that goes beyond what can be the usual political reflection or response. It is a reflection, the most intimate I have, what touches me the most every day I carry out the task of Prime Minister, and it is the cry that was made to me on election night: "do not fail us!" The "do not fail us" I summarize in two things: first, to exit the war in Iraq, to have a country that defends peace in the world; and second, to see that this legislature is a legislature in which we put an end to ETA violence. Therefore, I will work firmly to seek peace, without getting my hopes up.

C. Zarzalejos.- Has power changed you, Mr. President?

President.- Others should say that. Personally, I believe not.

J. Antich.- I will conclude with the economic topic. Mr. President, there is a promise of tax reform. It is true that you have only been in office for nine months and it has not been a priority; but I imagine that work is being done on it and that both the economic Vice President and the different Ministries are working on it. Could you advance anything in two directions: one, where it might go; and then, when will we know something?

President.- The commitment, and we will fulfill it, is that the tax reform will be presented in the second year of the Legislature, that is, this year, in 2005.

The reform will aim at very clear objectives: first, we need to simplify our tax system, both in what affects the Personal Income Tax and the Corporate Tax; secondly, as a country, we can maintain sufficient public revenue if we reduce the tax burden on labor income, which is what contributes the vast majority of revenue, and we can also slightly reduce the Corporate Tax rate.

We need to create a tax system that encourages productivity, that encourages the entrepreneurial spirit, and we can have a country -- the data I can provide on how the 2004 fiscal year will close, in terms of deficit, are frankly favorable -- that has sufficient revenue; that spends, as this Government will do, only what it receives and that, in addition, has a tax burden that is lighter, that is simpler and that, of course, favors that productive economy, that economy of entrepreneurs, of many self-employed individuals that we need in this country, of many business creators, and alleviates some segments of labor income that are the ones that inevitably contribute the majority of public revenue.

J. Antich.- With a single bracket for the Personal Income Tax, Mr. President?

President.- That will be subject to debate. What I can say is that the objective of the reform and the approach that will be opened to debate -- and I think it is good that it is opened to social debate, among economic agents, social agents, and political forces -- is to reduce the brackets in the Personal Income Tax.

(TVE includes a brief report on a humorous view of events related to the Prime Minister)

L. Milá.- What do you think? Politics can also be seen this way.

President.- Of course. Moreover, it is essential to have irony in political life; otherwise, it would surely be unbearable. It is already quite tough for citizens, and therefore, a little irony is very important.

L. Milá.- By the way, how does a politician, a Prime Minister, protect himself from the adulation of his immediate surroundings?

President.- They are not usually flatterers; besides, they know that I do not like it. I have been fortunate to have a team of collaborators, even since my time as Secretary General of the PSOE, who are capable of criticizing me because, evidently, mistakes are made very often. I believe it is extremely important to know how to listen to criticism; it is one of the best ways to learn. We will also agree that there are critics, and I listen to them. I listen to those who criticize me because one always learns from people who criticize.

L. Milá.- Thank you very much, Mr. President, for being here with us tonight.

President.- Thank you very much.