Interview with the President of the Government on Antena 3

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

16 April 2007 · Interview on Antena 3

Context
Zapatero was interviewed by journalists Alfredo Urdaci and Juan Pedro Valentín on Antena 3 television in April 2007, addressing terrorism and the failed ETA peace process.
Main themes
ETA terrorism and ceasefire, peace process failure, rule of law, Batasuna electoral participation, De Juana Chaos controversy, anti-terrorism policy, Basque Country political situation, state security forces, dialogue and violence
Duration
~45 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,448
93rd percentile
Sentences
233
92nd percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
11.5
38th percentile
Syntax
3.08
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

233 sentences in 103 paragraphs

I am joined, as they did on the night we interviewed the opposition leader, Mariano Rajoy, by two journalists, former news directors, Alfredo Urdaci and Juan Pedro Valentín. Good evening to both of you for joining me, and to you, Mr. President, welcome. Good evening.

President. - Good evening.

G. Lomana .- Before we begin, I want you to clear up a doubt for me, because you recently said that you felt more comfortable with citizens than with commentators. Does this mean that you are feeling a bit uncomfortable tonight?

President .- It means that I usually talk to journalists. I speak a lot with you, you subject me to interviews, I sometimes have coffee with you, and I have fewer opportunities to have a debate and be subjected to questions with citizens, as I had in a program that was recently held on public television. That is the reason. It always seems more novel, more attractive. But I am sure I will be comfortable with you here.

G. Lomana .- I’m glad.

We begin, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, with terrorism. Europol has said that ETA has taken advantage of the truce to rearm. Are we facing another trap truce?

President .- We must be very cautious when making an assessment of ETA's strength or weakness. What we must do is prevent, combat terrorism, and do everything possible to seek an end to violence.

It is true that during the ceasefire period there was, as is known, a significant theft of pistols, but it is no less true that there have also been a very significant number of arrests; the latest ones, of great significance, such as the entire structure in Guipúzcoa. Therefore, the Rule of Law and the services responsible for the anti-terrorism task have always been attentive to what this threat represents.

G. Lomana .- Do you fear an attack, by the way?

President .- We must always have the utmost prevention against terrorism, against any type of terrorism. Of course, I can assure you that all the State Security Forces and Corps, the means we support in their hard task, are always, logically, in that effort to try to prevent and avoid any violent action.

G. Lomana .- Batasuna has said that it will participate in the elections, because otherwise there will be deaths, just like with De Juana Chaos. Does this mean that if there are no attacks, some name from your environment will have slipped in?

President .- I do not know if those are the expressions used by some leader of the so-called abertzale left or the illegalized Batasuna, in that way. What I can tell you is that the Law of Political Parties will be strictly enforced and that those formations or candidacies that do not fully respect the Law of Political Parties will not be in the electoral call for the regional elections in Navarra and the municipal elections throughout Euskadi and throughout Spain, by the way.

Alfredo Urdaci .- The truth is that you took the step towards that peace offer with ETA in a brave, also risky way, and you entered with a lot of optimism. Since then we have seen many things. We have seen that little importance was given to the shipments of seized letters in which revolutionary blackmail was demanded; we have seen how it took a long time to recognize that it was ETA that had stolen that cache of weapons you referred to; we have seen, for example, and we know these days, how days after you verified in May 2006 that ETA was serious about this offer, the ETA member Lerín crossed the border to reorganize the "Comando Donosti"; we have seen how, after you showed your optimism before 2007, ETA blew up part of the T-4 and murdered two people; we have seen the controversial change in the prison status of De Juana Chaos, and the measures to withdraw charges against Otegi, and we do not have a clear explanation from you about what has happened during this time, because we feel that all of this has been for nothing.

President .- There are two fundamental elements in anti-terrorist policy that I want to highlight and remember. The first of them is that the Rule of Law must prevent, combat, and seek an end to violence. During the more than thirty years in a democratic period, there have been expectations of a possibility of ending violence through dialogue. All, historically, corresponding to various governments, did not end in the desired port, in a good port. Now we have lived through another similar process, a process that ETA broke, of dialogue, of peace process, with the attack, which I recalled, on the T-4, which unfortunately cost the lives of two people.

That is what has happened: ETA has once again denied what will inevitably be in the future: that its only destiny is the end of violence.

Meanwhile, if you allow me, the Rule of Law has continued to function with respect to the principles, logically, set by the Constitution, which marks legality, also making a political commitment that the desire in the Basque Country, of the vast majority of the citizens of the Basque Country, to see the end of violence would become a reality.

It would have been desirable, it is desirable, for today and for tomorrow, that everything that represents anti-terrorist policy, everything that represents the defense of the State, of people, of freedom, against terrorism, and of course the search for the struggle for an end, is done with the unity of all parties. That is the fundamental objective for me. There was unity in the previous Legislature, because I gave full support to Mr. Aznar's government from day one to fight against terrorism; unity that existed during the truce of 1998, because the Socialist Party gave full support and that I would have liked to count on now.

Thinking about the future, which is what citizens undoubtedly demand of us and what interests the whole country, my desire is that we recover that unity and my desire is that we return to have the maximum democratic understanding, especially of the two major parties and especially of one party, the Popular Party, which has not supported the Socialist Party in anti-terrorist policy.

A. Urdaci .- Are you telling me that you are going to make a new offer to the Popular Party?

President .- The offer is permanent. What I do intend is, again, to call Mr. Rajoy for June, fulfilling the commitment I have to hold a meeting every six months with the leader of the opposition. Of course, the issue of the anti-terrorist struggle will again be on the table in that dialogue and I hope we can recover an understanding.

The government must make every effort, and I will do so despite the intense tension we have had in recent months and in the last two years, but what is important is that we can be together again in anti-terrorist policy.

Juan Pedro Valentín .- Mr. President, the terrorist group ETA is the one that proposes the truce and the government has the obligation to verify whether that proposal is true or not. You said that you had verified that the terrorist group ETA intended to leave violence. However, with the data we know today, that verification was really a failure, because ETA was reorganizing its commands, was following possible targets, was stealing pistols, and continued with its blackmail. Who made that verification? Wasn't that verification a mistake? Is there any kind of responsibility?

President .- I return to what I stated at the beginning: we must be very cautious with the information about what ETA was doing or not doing, about strength and weakness; very cautious. And I want to stay there, because I believe it is my obligation.

The verification was, above all, a check that there was a possibility and, of course, a permanent ceasefire. Certainly, the information that the government had was that that will could exist. But all peace processes, which is where the big problem lies, the serious error and the intolerable action that invalidates the peace process, all peace processes or many peace processes have had a characteristic, and that is that terrorist organizations seek to dialogue while maintaining some type of violence. This is unacceptable, and from my point of view as President of the Government, there can be no dialogue with violence in any case.

For this reason, I have reiterated on more than one occasion: to talk about peace, violence must be left behind; to be in institutions, legality must be respected, and especially the Law of Political Parties; and to want to talk about politics, violence must have been overcome and, of course, all legality must have been respected.

Honestly, any government in the fight against terrorism and in the search for an end to terrorism, if it sees that there is a possibility of reaching an end to this scourge that we have had for more than thirty years, and that we have, must try. This is something, in my opinion, that all governments have done and citizens understand, while maintaining the principles of the Rule of Law and legality. Of course, at the moment ETA has wanted to negotiate with violence, the government has said: point, end, it’s over.

Certainly, we only contemplate in the future a possibility of a real, total, definitive end to ETA's violence and we will continue, logically, to combat. I hope that we can carry out that combat with the unity of the Popular Party. That would be desirable, because the unity of the two major parties, the support that I have called for from the opposition, from the Popular Party, is not just something that interests the government or the President of the Government in strictly political terms; it is something that interests the country and interests the State. And we must have that attitude that, despite what has happened, I insist, I hope we recover.

G. Lomana .- I ask you, Mr. President, for shorter answers, because there are many questions we have for you tonight.

President .- The question from Alfredo included six or seven topics, six or seven questions, and I had to respond.

G. Lomana .- There it was. I was going to tell my colleagues to moderate their questions as well.

I will ask you a question before moving on to another topic, to see if you can answer it almost with a monosyllable.

Is your government going to prevent the holding of the referendum that Lehendakari Ibarretxe has announced for this Legislature?

President .- This is an idea that Ibarretxe has raised for years, even with the modification of the Penal Code. Mr. Ibarretxe knows that popular consultations are those that are provided for in the Constitution and in the Statutes, only on the occasion of reforms, and therefore, I believe it will simply be an idea.

G. Lomana .- We change the subject. I mentioned that we were going to talk about another terrorism. We are also very concerned about Islamist terrorism. Al Qaeda reappeared last week, also on another 11th, by the way, very close to Spain and has claimed Al Andalus. Is there a risk of another 11-M in Spain? Are we once again in the crosshairs?

President .- The threat of radical Islamist terrorism, and I emphasize radical, because we cannot confuse it with what represents an entire culture, an entire religion, and a whole set of countries that obey the Islamic faith. It is a global threat. There have been attacks in London, there were attacks in New York, we had the tragedy of 11-M in 2004; but also in Islamic countries or Arab countries. These days we have seen in Algeria and we have seen in Casablanca.

Therefore, we must always be prepared, we must always have the maximum capacity for response. The 11th of March forced us to raise our capacity for prevention, investigation, control, and pursuit of what could be radical Islamist activity in our country. We have made decisions in that direction. When we came to power, there were 150 police and civil guards specialized in Islamist terrorism; now there are a thousand, we have increased by nine hundred. There were five agents specialized in translating Arabic, which is fundamental in this matter, and now there are seventy. We have created the National Anti-Terrorist Coordination Center and we have increased cooperation with the United States, with Europe, and, very specifically, with the Maghreb, with Morocco and Algeria.

We are better prepared, with better intelligence information, undoubtedly, to guarantee the maximum possible security.

G. Lomana .- And the risk? Greater?

President .- The risk always exists and, logically, the obligation of a government is to try to put all means in place to avoid any possible action. But from day one we have had the decision, in addition, there was a parliamentary debate as a result of the Investigation Commission and a mandate to establish a goal of preventing Islamist terrorism. Now, specifically, with the trial of 11-M precisely, we have decided to raise the level of prevention from the day the trial began, which seems reasonable. It is the most important trial being held against a radical Islamist terrorist attack and, therefore, it is logical that we are like this.

I can assure you that the dedication and professionalism of the intelligence services, the police, and the Civil Guard are exemplary in anticipating these existing risks.

A. Urdaci.- However, Mr. President, despite all the observers and experts in international terrorism and Islamic terrorism warning that Spain is a preferred settlement location, police action allowed for the arrest of 92 terrorists of this kind in 2005, 49 in 2006, and so far this year, in 2007, there have only been 12. On the other hand, many of the recommendations from the 11-M Commission, for example, the creation of a specialized Prosecutor's Office, have not been fulfilled. You speak of good collaboration with the United States, and I am a bit surprised that you say this when the relationship with the United States... What is your strategy to combat Islamic Jihad?

President.- The relationship between the intelligence services, the Ministry of the Interior, and the Prosecutor's Offices, which play a fundamental role, is very good; magnificent. Just as there is a cooperative relationship among all the countries of the European Union and, especially, also with the Maghreb countries. Morocco and Spain fully collaborate, and our intelligence services work together in the detection, investigation, and prevention of activities by Islamist radicals.

We have not stopped our efforts to pursue and dismantle cells throughout the country in recent years, and I can assure you that the level of prevention and resources against the risks that exist— I insist, exist in Spain, exist in England, exist in France, exist in Italy, and exist in most countries— is, logically, of a preferential attention to which we have dedicated, as I have just explained, a multiplication of resources, and we will continue to do so, because the first obligation of a government is to guarantee, as much as possible, the security of its citizens.

J.P. Valentín.- You accused the previous government of José María Aznar of lack of foresight in this matter, in the issue of preventing Islamist terrorism, and yet, when you were in opposition, I remember you spoke of the "Dixán Command," with that command that was later convicted by the judges. Are you not making too much of an opposition to the opposition on this matter and also with the issue of 11-M, wearing down the opposition, even recalling what happened four years ago?

President.- I must clarify that the issue of lack of foresight was a debate that was settled in the conclusions of the Investigation Commission, and the Socialist Party has not held anyone responsible for lack of foresight.

J.P. Valentín.- With the opposing vote of the Popular Party, obviously.

President.- It has not held anyone responsible for lack of foresight, because any terrorist attack can occur under certain circumstances. Unfortunately, that is the case.

J.P. Valentín.- Your Secretary of Organization said it on Saturday.

President.- What we have said is that from the 11th to the 14th, the things that were said were not what was happening, and what I have heard these days is Mr. Rajoy saying that we should tighten security measures, that we were weak, that the Alliance of Civilizations was useless... Come on! I think I can ask the Popular Party for a bit of prudence when giving advice on the risks of radical Islamist terrorism. I think it is reasonable for it to be so.

What I can say is that we are better prepared, with more resources, we know the risks better, and it would be absurd if it were not so after March 11. And it would also be desirable that in this matter we had what represents an understanding between the Popular Party and the Socialist Party; but I cannot fail to say that regarding 11-M during these three years, now that we are seeing the trial, the Popular Party has continued to develop a whole theory about what happened or did not happen, whether there were conspiracies, whether it was ETA... Fundamentally, it has been the Popular Party.

I hope that the trial, with the sentence, puts an end to the political diatribe. It was a terrible tragedy for Spain. The only real victims were those who lost their lives, their families, and that we can, as a country, as we have known, overcome that hard blow and be, logically, prepared and, as much as possible, united in the face of this type of threat.

G. Lomana.- Mr. President, what do you say to those who think that ETA at least provided logistics for this massacre?

President.- We are in a trial, and there will be a sentence from the judges. I believe that this is a trial that is being held, as it could not be otherwise, in a State of Law with absolute rigor, that there has been a thorough investigation, that there are a very high number of responsible parties, and that so far, so far, clearly in the instruction, in the facts that are the subject of controversy, debate, deepening, investigation, and contrast among witnesses, ETA has not appeared. The sentence will say.

Simply a call to common sense, as it leads only to absurdity, to confusion, and has also led to some political tension, I do not know for what reason to construct a thesis that has no foundation whatsoever and that for the vast majority of citizens, and I am convinced that with all due respect to what is the sentence and the decision of the Court, will demonstrate that 11-M was a brutal attack by radical Islamists, by terrorism, followers of Islamic Jihad.

J.P. Valentín.- Let's change the subject: elections. Mr. President, if you do not win in some of the Communities where you do not govern or do not win in any of the important capitals, will it be a failure for you, an electoral failure?

President.- Let's not make predictions.

J.P. Valentín.- Where do you set the bar for failure and success?

President.- The bar is to win the elections, to have more votes, more councilors, to improve mayors... That is the bar. What is the objective of a major party like the Socialist Party? To win the elections.

J.P. Valentín.- In terms of number of votes?

President.- In number of votes, councilors...

J.P. Valentín.- And if you do not win, for example, either of the two Madrids, that is, neither the Community nor the City Council, or Valencia, the capital and the Community?

President.- We are going to respect the candidates, first, because these are elections for mayoral candidates and candidates for regional presidents, and we are going to respect the campaigns, the debate, and the results.

As a global objective, I must express that objective: that the Socialist Party that night is the most voted party in Spain.

G. Lomana.- And if it is not so? If the PP gets one more vote or one more councilor, will you feel defeated?

President.- Well, the Popular Party will have won. No, these are municipal and regional elections, they are not primaries; they are certainly not. Primaries are usually internal party elections. They are not primaries for the Socialist Party, I do not know if they are primaries for the Popular Party. Given some movements, perhaps; but I do not know.

G. Lomana.- Your caravans are quite something, huh! The electoral caravans of the leaders are quite something, one rally per day.

President.- But it is always like that. I reviewed in the previous municipal elections how many events President Aznar had done at that time, and I, as leader of the opposition, also had a very high number, because it is necessary to go to support the candidates for mayors and regional presidents. It is normal.

A. Urdaci.- You have taken the electoral battle to the field of the economy. Allow me to say that you had an "Aznarist" day yesterday, one of those "Spain is doing well" days. The economy is doing well, but, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, which economy is doing well because, with 60 percent of families struggling to make ends meet and with mortgages that have risen by 8 percent in recent months, you were not very conservative yesterday, I mean very self-satisfied?

President.- Alfredo, I understand that it is hard for you to forget certain things; but certainly, for me to have something "Aznarist" will not be very credible to those who see us and listen to us.

A. Urdaci.- I don't know. I had my suspicions.

President.- The economy is doing better than when it was said that Spain was doing well, and it has reached many families, many people. Why? I will only provide you with some data: because since we have been in government, 2,300,000 jobs have been created, that is, there are 2,300,000 people who are working and were not working, who have a salary and did not have one. In fact, we are at a time when there are more households where at least one person works.

By the way, when we started the Legislature, in addition to ensuring that the economy continued to grow and improved growth—we were at 4 percent in the last quarter of 2006—we set the objective of combating precariousness and instability in employment. We had a process of social dialogue, an agreement with the unions, which came into force on July 1, and today I can provide a piece of data that is extraordinarily important for all those who see us and listen to us, and that is that from July to this month of April we will have one million temporary contracts that have been converted into permanent contracts and nine hundred thousand more permanent contracts; from July to April 2007.

This represents, for many people, having more stability in employment; it represents, logically, a better salary possibility and better contribution bases in Social Security. But, in addition, we have made a very notable effort for some social sectors, perhaps those in which a government of the orientation that I represent should focus.

For example, since we came to government, we have increased the Minimum Interprofessional Wage by 25 percent, we have raised it in three years more than it was raised in the eight years of the Popular Party government: 110 euros per month, 25 percent. And we must continue to raise the Minimum Wage, which had been frozen.

For example, those with the lowest incomes, who are the pensioners receiving a minimum pension, which are three million, have had a 25 percent increase in these three years of the Socialist government. They still receive a low pension, but the effort that has been made, concentrating the pension increase, thanks to the good performance of Social Security, has been very notable. In the three years of this government, we have increased minimum pensions more than in the eight years of the Popular Party governments.

Therefore, of course, it has an effective translation into people, into families, into young people, who did not have jobs and now do, especially women, because of those 2,300,000 more workers we have, 60 percent are practically women. And today we are at the lowest unemployment rate in democracy.

Is that all we have as an objective? No. Of course, we must continue to win the battle against labor precariousness, creating more stable employment; we must improve the productivity of the economy, but in a country that in 2006 grew more than Germany, than Italy, than England, than France, than the United States, and than Japan, and that has created more jobs than these countries, it is logical that we can feel secure about the future and secure about the course we have, to be able to make this economic growth intensify in what is an essential objective for me: that this prosperity reaches everyone and, especially, families with less purchasing power and, in a very singular way, young people.

J.P. Valentín.- But in the economy there are also controversies and scandals; for example, the OPA scandal. The European Commission has taken the Government of Spain to court because it believes that it has not been sufficiently well regulated in this matter, and right now we are witnessing how the President of the National Securities Market Commission, no less, is also at odds with the policy that the Government has made in this matter. You spoke of national champions, but in the end, what has come out of here has been criticized by all the media, including foreign ones.

President.- I have a different opinion. One thing is the noise and another the nuts, because throughout the OPA process, which has been complicated due to the great attractiveness of our electric companies, and that is why there has been a whole competition to try to take over Endesa, the result, with the agreement between E.ON, Acciona, and ENEL, the Italian company, has been the following: the result has been that shareholders have gained a lot, because in the entire OPA process, they reached 41 euros per share; shareholders have gained; consumers are going to gain, because competition has increased or is going to increase because there will be more actors in the electricity system, and do not say that it has also been something I heard from the leader of the opposition because a few days after the agreement of the OPA between these three actors, the Stock Market reached its historical maximum.

Therefore, one thing is the noise and another the facts, and the facts are that the market, the Spanish Stock Market, responded extraordinarily favorably. This is the reality.

And in relation to Manolo Conthe, the President of the National Securities Market Commission, he will appear in Parliament. He has decided to resign, it is his free will, and of course, he will explain everything he deems appropriate, because that is how it is in a country where we must respect the rules, everyone, first the President of the Government and also the president of the CNMV, who goes to Parliament when Parliament says he should go, because that is how a parliamentary democracy works.

G. Lomana.- Do you fear that he will make revelations that compromise the Government, by the way?

President.- Not at all.

G. Lomana: We are running out of time and we are rushing the last three minutes. I ask you and my colleagues to be brief in order to ask small questions. For example, Mr. President, will the general elections be on March 16, the fifth anniversary of the Azores, of the photo of the Azores?

President: The truth is that I haven't thought about it. In other words, you have given me an idea. But I hadn't thought about it until now. What I have decided is to exhaust the Legislature, and exhausting the Legislature means, approximately, that it will be in the month of March; but I have not decided the day.

J.P. Valentín: There is a book by one of your collaborators, from which I have been reading some paragraphs, and it says that without the mobile phone, your leadership system does not work. Is that so?

President: I believe that the mobile phone today is essential for everyone, whether you are dedicated to political activity, I won't say anything about journalistic activity, or any activity in society... It is true that I use the mobile phone and, moreover, I think it is an extraordinarily useful element.

A. Urdaci: In 2006 you promised a definitive solution to the water problem. With all that we have thrown into the Ebro, we are still waiting for that solution.

President: The truth is that the steps indicate one thing: we have had three years of drought and with the effort of the A.G.U.A. Program, which has meant savings, more efficiency, and the implementation of desalination plants, there have been no restrictions in the most sensitive area, which is the area of Murcia, Alicante, and part of Valencia.

Certainly, fortunately, this year is going to be better, it is being better; fortunately, we are going to complete a good part of the investments in water matters and we must continue to be very demanding as a society. The Government must promote maximum savings in water matters, as in electrical and energy consumption, because we have climate change there. Fortunately, today there has been good news, which is that this country, despite growth, has reduced CO2 emissions by four points.

That is the way: renewable energies, efficiency in water, desalination, which represents territorial balance and, of course, attending to and investing more in those areas that have water difficulties.

G. Lomana: We are finishing, Mr. President. I am going to ask you two questions that can be answered with monosyllables. The first: Mr. Rajoy, when will you meet with him?

President: In June. That is my idea. I have the commitment, and I am going to fulfill it, I have always fulfilled it, to have a meeting with the leader of the opposition every six months, at the end of the session period. Therefore, June will be a month, if he deems it appropriate, because this must be done, logically, in agreement; but I think it is very important that we have those meetings, that dialogue.

G. Lomana: When he was here, by the way, the leader of the opposition, on March 13, I asked him if he would accept a face-to-face debate with you when both are candidates. He said yes. I need your answer.

President: I am delighted that he has changed his mind, because in the 2004 elections he did not accept a debate with me, and I asked for it in all media. Of course, I will accept a debate with Mr. Rajoy and of course, surely, all the media...

G. Lomana: The question is: can I... on Antena 3?

President: I will make the effort to ensure that all media are satisfied. This will undoubtedly be a matter that the party leaderships will negotiate, but I will make every effort. What is important for citizens, I know that for Antena 3 it is very important, is that we have that debate which will be a sign of democratic health, where we will take positions...

G. Lomana: It could be that or those debates; in any case, can that debate be held on Antena 3, Mr. President?

President: We will have to negotiate it. The important thing is that there is a debate when the time comes. I have the best disposition, Gloria, I tell you seriously, that clearly, and at the right moment we will be able to verify it.

G. Lomana: You leave me without a headline, Mr. President.

President: I have always been in favor of debates and the more scenarios, the more media... Today, fortunately, there are more media, more pluralism; today, fortunately, Televisión Española is more independent, it is more plural. That is very good for democracy and I will contribute as a candidate, if the party gives me the support to be a candidate, logically, to be President of the Government again, to that, by having debates with Mr. Rajoy.

G. Lomana: Both will be welcome in this house, if they wish.

We are done. Our time is up. Thank you very much for being with us. Good night.