Interview with the President of the Government on TV3

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

21 March 2010

Context
Zapatero was interviewed by TV3's Mònica Terribas during a visit to Catalonia for the inauguration of the Alba Synchrotron facility on 21 March 2010.
Main themes
Economic crisis response, Catalonia investment and infrastructure, R&D and innovation funding, Endesa electricity network failures, high-speed rail expansion, EU presidency, historical debt to regions, public vs private R&D spending, Spain-France energy interconnection
Duration
~76 min
97th percentile
Words
9,066
97th percentile
Sentences
418
97th percentile
Readability
51
67th percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

418 sentences in 199 paragraphs

Mònica Terribas .- Welcome to Catalonia, Mr. President.

President .- Thank you very much.

M. Terribas .- It has been a while since you last came, since the inauguration of Terminal-1. Right?

President .- Yes, indeed. Quite some time, yes. I have been quite busy with the European Presidency and a lot of international activity, which has made it difficult for me to travel around Spain.

M. Terribas .- From Terminal-1 to the Synchrotron, and you missed the snowfalls we had in Catalonia a week ago.

President, Endesa. What are we doing? Investments, what is happening with Endesa?

President .- Endesa needs to improve, but the fundamental problem we have in Girona is that it is necessary to strengthen the high voltage network, it is necessary to make the interconnection with France, which has been waiting for twenty years and is finally underway, and also to invest in medium voltage, which is planned, has some issues with responses or environmental criticism, but is essential to improve the weak network that Girona has and that, as we have seen, with a very strong and very unique snowstorm, it must be said to take into account...

M. Terribas .- Yes, of course, but, Mr. President, in the blackout of 2007 that we had in Barcelona, do you remember?, you said: "this will not happen again, because the National Energy Commission will ensure that there are more investments." But having the electric companies in the hands of the Italians is a bad deal, isn't it?

President .- It has nothing to do with it.

M. Terribas .- No?

President .- No. This company was previously only in the hands of Spaniards and things happened.

We have a structural problem, I insist, in Girona, which needs investments, which are sometimes problematic and contested, and are delayed due to environmental issues, and we need the interconnection with France. And, of course, if Endesa has failed to meet some of the requirements, it will be sanctioned by the Generalitat, which is responsible for that. I spoke about this at lunch with President Montilla, and he will do it. Knowing President Montilla, he will do it firmly.

M. Terribas .- For sure.

Mr. President, you have come from Andalusia. Have you brought us any gifts, because there they have finally settled the "historical debt": 784 million euros? Here, in Catalonia, it is very difficult to provide measures, because it seems that this loses votes in Spain, doesn't it?

President .- Today we are inaugurating the Alba Synchrotron, which is a two hundred million investment and is the most important scientific facility in the history of Spain, the one we are in, and it is in Catalonia.

I have just referred to what the investment in the expansion of El Prat airport has meant, the new Terminal; in High Speed, high speed that we are developing at full speed towards Girona and that will provide Catalonia with an extraordinarily important network of infrastructures.

M. Terribas .- This would be the new productive model we should be moving towards, right?, Mr. President; but not at the pace we should have gone according to the European Union, because the investment in R&D is three times lower than that of Defense and Interior in the 2010 Budget, and we are not advancing. It seems we will have to invest in construction again.

President .- Three times is what we have multiplied the investment in R&D+i since we have been in Government.

M. Terribas .- Yes, but that of Defense and Interior is three times higher.

President .- In Defense, we have a rather modest investment in Spain, although we also have needs, and, by the way, it contributes a lot to Research, Development, and Innovation. We must not forget that phenomena like the Internet and everything related to the development of ICT comes from military research.

But, I insist, in these years we have tripled the investment in R&D+i. In fact, in public investment in Research, Development, and Innovation, we are already at the European average. Where we are not at the European average is in private R&D+i research, and that is where we need to make the great effort, and large technological installations, like this one, undoubtedly represent an important boost.

M. Terribas .- Mr. President, do you acknowledge that in economic policy we have been meandering and misleading people?

President .- I acknowledge that we have the most serious economic crisis in eighty years -- no international organization could anticipate the magnitude of the crisis -- and that, when you have such a serious crisis and different phenomena occur, effects in the financial sector or in the automotive sector, you have to provide responses at each moment. That is what we have tried to do.

I would say, summarizing a lot, that in the first part we made a support response to mitigate the severity of the crisis. For example, you know it well here, in Catalonia, and the Catalans know it well, in the automotive sector, eight hundred million euros for the automotive industry in Catalonia. What has that allowed? It has allowed us to maintain the automotive factories in Catalonia that are very productive and that can obtain new vehicles.

M. Terribas .- But now those aids for people to obtain vehicles are going to end.

President .- No, I am referring to the companies, to the industries.

M. Terribas .- But they will not be able to continue if they do not sell, right?

President .- Yes, but over eighty percent of the cars made in Catalonia are sold abroad. So, the important thing is that they have the renewal of competitiveness, that they invest and that they plan new vehicles like, for example, the electric vehicle.

Secondly, we made a strong commitment to municipal investment to maintain employment and companies that, otherwise, in construction would have been destroyed; and thirdly, we tried to mitigate somewhat the absolute lack of credit that all the entrepreneurs listening to us know has occurred during this period through the Official Credit Institute, putting up to twenty billion in 2009.

Therefore, we have made a great effort in the face of a serious crisis and now we are in the other phase, which is the phase of achieving recovery as soon as possible, with new measures that we are trying to agree upon with the parties, and, secondly, to make our economic growth pattern change, to be more innovative, more productive, and more competitive.

M. Terribas .- Now we will go to the new measures. The citizens who are watching us now in Catalonia are already thinking about VAT, because it is going to rise; but the jobs that have been created, especially through the Town Halls, are temporary and are, logically, a result of this situation. We have four million people unemployed, Mr. President. How can we overcome this? You are renouncing to lower salaries, for example, a measure that the International Monetary Fund had recommended, and Minister Corbacho the other day in an interview on Catalunya Radio said: "I don't see it." What can we do so that we do not continue destroying jobs? What needs to be done?

President .- The first thing I must say is that it is the main problem we have, that it is the main responsibility of the Government to create jobs again, because a lot of jobs have been destroyed, and, as I have said on some occasions, I feel responsible for every job that has been destroyed.

But I must say that we have made and are making a great effort in social protection. Today there is no dilemma, until we create jobs, between employment and subsidy, as some say; no, today there is a dilemma between employment with protection or employment without protection, with economic support. Our Government has implemented the highest level of protection for the unemployed. For example, in Catalonia, there are five hundred thousand unemployed people, of whom those who are unemployed have protection, either contributory or assistance. It is 83 percent, it is an effort of solidarity. I know that many have a small, minimal benefit, which is hardly a help, but which represents, I emphasize, an effort of solidarity.

M. Terribas .- But people want jobs. Mr. President.

President .- Yes, but I will not fall into deception. Today the basic alternative, today... I hope that in a few months, in a few months, we will see how jobs begin to be created; but, in the meantime, we have to guarantee that support, that cohesion, and that social protection.

We have a horizon ahead of us, and that is that the jobs that will be created, when the economic crisis disappears, goes away, and we have recovery, will be jobs of higher quality, jobs of more stability than those we have had in a significant part of the economy, which has been very precarious employment and particularly affects the youngest, some of whom are qualified.

M. Terribas .- We have a 40 percent.

Mr. President, the first phase was an injection to the banks so that the financial system would not collapse; that was a first measure. But are the banks really responding to the effort you made? That is, are we seeing banks giving credit? Because you are now talking to me about the ICO, the Official Credit Institute, but that is not the solution, because with the volume of credit that needs to be given we need the Banks and Savings Banks to get involved in this, right?

President .- Yes. I must say that, indeed, we went out to support the Banks, because supporting the Banks is supporting the citizens. Citizens have their deposits in the Banks and we had to guarantee savings in the face of a crisis in the financial system. I will give you a fact: the support we have given to the Banks has not cost money to public revenues, it has not cost money to the citizens who, through those taxes, give money to the State; we have obtained so far 1.6 billion euros from the Banks, because what we have done is guarantee them so that they could ask for money from other Banks. With that guarantee, we have charged them an amount, so they have the backing of the State, and so far we have received 1.6 billion from the Banks.

They continue with very little capacity and very little availability to give credit for one reason: because we have gone from a situation of joy in the face of risk to a situation of aversion, of panic, to giving credit, because they understand that the economy is still not recovered and because, seeing how they have fallen all over the world, in developed countries, Banks that have gone bankrupt, financial giants, in the United States, in Germany, or in France, and now they have settled into a policy of conservatism and fear. It must be noted that it is not in our interest for our Banks to be at risk because, if our Banks are at risk, that would indeed cost us money from the public treasury.

M. Terribas .- But if they do not give money and you, through the ICO, have to be giving money to small and medium-sized enterprises so that they do not collapse, this money, if it is not repaid, will be more public deficit than we already have, which is around 12 percent.

President .- Indeed.

M. Terribas .- What do we do?

President .- We have to assume that our companies are responsible and that they have a sufficiently viable economic situation so that we can reintegrate the majority of the credit that we are going to facilitate. But we have been waiting for a few months to see if the flow of credit from the private sector recovered. Seeing that it does not recover, I have made the decision, a committed decision, to put a credit line of up to two hundred thousand euros for SMEs, where the State will assume the risk one hundred percent. We hope that, logically, this Line will give more capacity to obtain credit to many companies and also that it will produce a phenomenon, and the phenomenon is that, surely, there will be many companies that will turn to this Line and, perhaps, the Banks will feel the obligation, in that competition, to move a little, to provide more ease to companies when it comes to credit.

As a Government, we do not have another instrument. It must be taken into account that the Government cannot force a Bank to give credit; the Government has public resources that it can mobilize in the direction I have just pointed out, being prudent, because we cannot logically commit more spending and more deficit, especially when we are talking about a volume that can be a very large volume of companies, and I understand that many will turn to this credit line.

M. Terribas .- Today there was a Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy, and Minister Salgado was going to dictate the measures to the Autonomous Communities, the red lines not to be crossed and to reduce the public deficit we have, which must be at 3 percent in 2013, and you will tell me how they are going to do it. But, Mr. President, what red lines cannot the Autonomous Communities cross? What can they not do? Where should expenses be reduced? Should the salaries of civil servants be frozen? Should some public bodies be closed? What needs to be done?

President .- We need to rationalize the Administration, we need to be more efficient, and we need to seek a reduction in personnel expenses, which is not the same as the salaries of civil servants. Personnel expenses include the salaries of civil servants, but also other elements such as the Public Employment Offer, that is; the positions that are called year after year.

We have estimated that to reach that 3 percent there needs to be an effort to reduce of about fifty billion euros. A part corresponds to the Autonomous Communities, they have to present their deficit reduction plans, they have to be credible and will have all the support. Of course, there are possibilities.

What are, in the political philosophy of the Government and in the need of the Spanish economy, the red lines? In political philosophy, social protection will not be reduced, nor social policies, and we will maintain R&D+i. These are the two great red lines.

Mr. Terribas.- Well, this is positive, but negatively, are we going to reduce civil servants?

President.- No; we are not going to reduce civil servants. We are going to drastically reduce the growth of the number of civil servants, that is, the civil servants that are created to replace those who retire regularly. Therefore, this will be minimal growth. For example, the Public Offer this year will be 10 percent, which does not mean 10 percent in all sectors of the Administration, as in some it will be three and in others it will be fifteen; but a drastic reduction, because this is a great source of savings in public spending.

Mr. Terribas.- Should the exercise come from the Government itself? Seventeen Ministries; how many fewer, Mr. President?

President.- No, that is a question that has very little to do with spending. It is practically negligible, because the number of civil servants does not vary because there is one more ministry or one less ministry.

The Ministries and Ministers exist because we need people with sufficient political and public representativeness. For what? So that they can maintain a dialogue with the Autonomous Communities in a country like ours, so that they have sufficient representation in the European Union and in international politics. Ministers are not there just to have ministries; they are there because when a minister calls another minister, they are attended to, and that is fundamental at the level of interlocution. A minister, when they have to dialogue with a President of an Autonomous Community, if they are a minister, dialogues with more authority, with more representativeness.

This is the only reason for having areas that, in the opinion of the President of the Government, need representativeness. But I will tell you that the spending is absolutely minimal. We can do it, and we will do it, and we will present it in a few weeks, a plan for the reduction of public companies, for the rationalization of the Administration, for the use of common services, and for the reduction of certain agencies that will represent a part of savings.

Mr. Terribas.- Which agencies, Mr. President? Which agencies are we going to...? Tell me something. You are talking philosophically and we are not making progress.

President.- The plan is still being developed, in the final phase of development, by the Ministry of Economy and by the First Vice President, and we are going to let it be specified. But it will be noticeable, especially in public companies and in autonomous agencies. There will be a rationalization process that will involve a reduction of the management structures of what are autonomous agencies, of what are public companies, of the number of members of Boards of Directors, and we will also open the line for the joint use of certain services by several Ministries.

Mr. Terribas.- Let's see, Mr. President, VAT. Brussels says: "Well, it's not a bad measure to raise VAT, it has been done in Germany, it has also been done in the Netherlands, but not now when the Spanish economy is not recovering at the pace it should." Yesterday we interviewed four Nobel Prize winners in Economics on TV3 and they said "no, do not raise VAT now"; but Minister Salgado says "yes" and today Minister Espinosa, on TV3 as well, on "Els Matins", said that citizens will not notice this in their shopping basket. Of course we are going to notice it, right?

President.- It depends. There have already been companies that have said they will not pass on the VAT increase, which is from 16 to 18 percent. In some products—depending logically on the price of the product—it will be a practically insignificant amount; in others, a bit more, and, for example, in a vehicle, it will be very noticeable. There are companies that I congratulate in advance because they have said "we are going to absorb this more efficiently in the company and we are not going to pass it on."

I must remember three things: first, that there has not been a moment in history with a lower price increase than now and inflation is at a minimum, as we know, as a consequence of the crisis; second, that with the VAT increase to 18 percent we will still be the third country in the EU with the lowest VAT, where the average VAT is at 20 percent, and all countries with more economic power, with more welfare state and more development have it practically at 20 or above 20 percent.

If we want to reduce the deficit, and we have to reduce it, and if we want to continue making investments like this center, maintaining strength for economic recovery and guaranteeing social protection, we have to make sacrifices. This is one that we have to make and, thus, position ourselves closer to the European average in one of the taxes that collects the most. And the moment is appropriate.

Mr. Terribas.- Yes? Is the calendar not going to change? July?

President.- Yes, of course. We understand, and that is our forecast, that in June we will already be on a path of economic recovery and that the impact of what it implies, with such low inflation and with the effort that companies are going to make, will be a minimal impact on the economy.

Mr. Terribas.- Mr. President, but Brussels says, and the data supports it, and Isidre Fainé said this weekend also regarding a study they have done in their own research office, that there will be economic contraction this year and it is the only European power that in 2010 will still be below; it will not be growing, Mr. President.

President.- Let's wait. Let's wait to see the evolution. Regarding economic forecasts, I think we all have to be very cautious, because, in addition, there have been many occasions when forecasts about the growth of the Spanish economy tend to fall short of what actually occurs.

But I must remember that we are also going to make important stimuli, coinciding with this date of the VAT increase. The ICO Line, the credit line of up to two hundred thousand euros for small and medium-sized enterprises, with 100 percent coverage by the State, is a very important stimulus line. We have to continue this policy in which we do not neglect what is public deficit, because we have to reduce public deficit, and also continue to make stimuli for business activity and employment, like the ICO Line or like the housing rehabilitation policy that, for the first time, will have tax deductions, where we will reduce VAT, because we believe it is an immediate, direct source of creating quite a bit of employment.

Mr. Terribas.- Construction has partly led us to this very low level, to this very harsh level of the economic crisis. It is a sector where 970,000 jobs have been destroyed and Minister Caldera said "perhaps we will have to invest there again, because if not, we will not be able to make the change so quickly." What do we do? Construction, so that we find ourselves again with speculators?

President.- In the excess of the job loss that we have had, 60 percent is from construction, but it is better to say that it is not the fault of construction, but of the excess of construction, because something very extraordinary has happened in our country: from 1997 to 2007, in ten years, we built the number of homes that we should have built, given the size of the country we have, in twenty years, and therefore, we incorporated double the number of people into the construction sector in ten years.

That has ended, it has been a hard and abrupt end. Normally, if there had not been the financial crisis that occurred on Wall Street and the global credit paralysis, that process of excess construction would have gradually decreased.

Mr. Terribas.- Without trauma.

President.- Exactly.

Mr. Terribas.- That is what you thought when you said "there is no crisis." Did you think that?

President.- Absolutely, of course, that is reasonable, unless, of course, I had the ability, with a crystal ball, to know that Lehman Brothers was going to collapse and a good part of the great financial giants of Wall Street, banks in France, Switzerland, Belgium, or Germany. What we have experienced has been very spectacular.

And now we have to make sure that the excess we had in construction is in other sectors. That is, the excess of what we have invested as a country, the companies, the banks, and the citizens, because our savings were basically going to the sector of buying first homes or second residences, or to invest for resale; now we have to dedicate that excess to other sectors as recovery occurs, to sectors with more added value, with more competitiveness and with more innovation; and we have them. In Spain, fortunately, we have many leading sectors, as you well know in Catalonia: the agri-food industry sector, the automotive sector, the Communication Technologies sector, the biotechnology sector, or the renewed tourism sector.

We need to broaden the industrial base, we need to broaden the technological base and have a smaller construction sector.

Mr. Terribas.- Two more questions about the economic crisis, before moving on to Catalonia, and I would like you to respond to some things about what is happening here.

Labor reform, what, Mr. President? What are you going to propose? People should have an idea of you, as you have said "we are not going to make dismissal more flexible," what are you going to propose, so that people can get an idea of where the labor reform of the Rodríguez Zapatero Government is going.

President.- There should be several things in that proposal: one, there should be a proposal that unions and employers subscribe to facilitate hiring for employers without reducing workers' rights, and that is possible, as there are existing models; two, there has to be a proposal that addresses more in depth what is the reduction of hours to avoid job loss, what is the "German model."

Mr. Terribas.- Fewer hours, more jobs?

President.- Exactly. It would be good to estimate the hours of work that have been lost in Spain with the hours of work that have been lost in other countries. The comparison, perhaps, would be striking, and where our difference lies is that here the hours of work that are lost mean jobs that are lost, and there are other countries where the hours of work that are lost do not automatically mean jobs that are lost. They are very different models and we have to make changes.

And, third, we have to develop collective bargaining so that it is more flexible and incorporates something that is fundamental for our productivity and our labor and social model, and that is all the equality measures that we have established in the Equality Law between Men and Women that have to go through collective bargaining and through company plans to overcome the barriers of difficulties that many women still have in our country to work. And, as long as we do not have the same percentage of women incorporated into the labor market, we will have a higher unemployment rate than the European average and that has to do with reconciliation, with equal pay, and with equality policies.

Mr. Terribas.- Mr. President, retirement at 67; no, not at 67; voluntary no or voluntary yes, but in some sectors. We are also confused there. When are we going to retire, Mr. President?

President.- I understand that sometimes… We have to retire at an age that allows us to have a pension system where pensions are improved and, above all, the effort for the lowest pensions, which is what we have tried to do in these four years. We have raised minimum pensions, and they are still very low for what, from my point of view, they should be in a developed country, more than 30 percent.

In twenty-five years we will live longer, we will have many more people who will be older, who will be in the perspective of retirement, and there will be fewer people, therefore, comparatively, in relative terms, in the labor market. We have to address that. One of the ways, what is it? One of the ways is to raise the retirement age. It can be done, let’s say, in several ways: one, bringing the legal age closer to the real age, or vice versa, the real age to the legal age, which is what happens to us now: we have 65 years of legal age and 63 years of real age; another is to end early retirements. All of these are proposals that are in what we are doing.

Mr. Terribas.- But what is yours?

President.- Our? The one we have proposed: to raise the retirement age.

Mr. Terribas.- To 67 years? For all sectors?

President.- No, not for all sectors; of course. We know that there are very different sectors in work and there are jobs that do not allow you to reach a certain age, like being in the Police, or being on a construction site, being a bricklayer, or being a miner, which I know well, as they retire in their forties or early fifties. They are early retirees because the activity does not allow for anything else.

It is a proposal and we must assume that a Government makes laws, proposes laws, decrees, regulations, and proposals. Why do I emphasize this? I emphasize this because our Social Security model and our pension system are under an agreement called the Toledo Pact and any reform of the pension system has to be done in agreement. Consequently, from the Government's proposal there will be a dialogue with unions, employers, and political parties. The outcome will be what has the greatest consensus.

The Government has a proposal and is willing to listen to others. And we will undoubtedly reach an agreement where the Government will surely have to modify some of its proposals, and we will do so constructively.

Mr. Terribas.- Mr. President, you have been with President Montilla. Did he advise you to call for early elections so that you can know who will govern in Catalonia when you have to negotiate next year's budgets? Because, of course, since you are leading the Government with a lot of fragility in agreements, it is convenient for you to know who will be here, right?

President.- I will say three things: first, I have not spoken with Montilla today about possible early elections; second, I have great confidence that when he makes the decision to set the election date, President Montilla will get it right; and third, I have governed, both in the previous legislature and in this one, with agreements with different forces on different issues at each moment.

I must remind you that the Socialist Group is six deputies short of an absolute majority and that there are many groups with which we can reach agreements, and I will continue to reach agreements, regardless of the situation, as has been the case in Catalonia. Sometimes we have reached agreements with Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya; at other times we have reached agreements with CiU; and at other times, with the Basque Nationalist Party, and the Basque Nationalist Party is not currently in the Government of Euskadi... In other words, let us have a broader perspective that what may happen in an Autonomous Community does not automatically translate to what happens in the Parliament of Spain.

Mr. Terribas.- Certainly, the PSOE has experience in this, because in the Basque Country they make agreements with the Popular Party; in Navarra they support UPN; in the Balearic Islands they have a coalition with Unión Mallorquina, which, by the way, is dealing with corruption issues; and in Catalonia, with independents and post-communists. So, the PSOE has experience in making agreements with anyone to hold onto power in the Autonomous Communities, right?

President.- I would qualify that.

Mr. Terribas.- Qualify it.

President.- Yes, I qualify. The PSOE has the capacity to make agreements with practically all political forces because it has a central position in the political system. It has it in an evident way. We are the political force that has remained since the beginning of the democratic transition, since we made the Constitution, and the one that has been involved in all the major agreements since the constitutional pact. We remain with the same initials, with the same history, with the same, I believe, unifying role in Spanish society, and we can make agreements with UPN in Navarra if we understand that it provides stability. Although we know that our rival is the Popular Party, our main adversary, there are times when that has to take precedence.

Mr. Terribas.- Yes, but that is not going well for you in the polls, and you know it. Jesús Eguiguren accepted and admitted the other day, in "El País," that 70 percent of Basque socialists do not like this agreement with the Popular Party at all. Does that not worry you?

President.- My prediction is that the Socialist Party will have very good results in Euskadi. Better, even, than we have had.

Mr. Terribas.- So, you are not worried.

President.- When a political decision, a government project, or a strategy is made, you cannot be in doubt, because then you do not believe in it. I have a firm conviction that Patxi López, a period of change in Euskadi with a government that has shown itself to be a dialoguing government, not an anti-PNV government, nor anti any party, is extraordinarily positive for the Basque Country, and it is being so. There is political normality, and moreover, there is an ideological fight against those who continue with violence, which is greatly strengthening democracy.

Mr. Terribas.- We will talk a bit about this now, but, Mr. President, I remember that before the Basque elections you said, "Euskadi would do well with a government of broad majorities." Are we in that moment in Catalonia? Would a government of broad majorities be good for you? A "sociovergencia"?

President.- The Catalans will have to decide. What I can say is that, from my point of view, as President of the Government, and knowing the political actors, what will be good for Catalonia is for the President to be Montilla. I say this because I have seen... He was with me as a Minister in the Government of Spain, but you never know the capacity of a political leader to lead a project until they are leading a political project, until they are in the role and task of President. And I can say that since I have seen him as President of the Generalitat de Catalunya, Montilla has grown extraordinarily in his capacity to lead, in his capacity for rigor, seriousness, and solvency, which is so important in politics.

What if he is not the most voted list? We will see.

Mr. Terribas.- The polls, Mr. President, those from the CEO.

President.- I can dare to give a piece of advice: polls should be looked at from a distance and very far away when elections have not yet been called, when we do not have a campaign, when it is not even well known what parties will run or who will be the leaders of all the parties.

Citizens, as is normal, are not paying attention to political life on a day-to-day basis. When elections approach, polls have a value that must be taken into account. But even so, if a poll is difficult, the responsibility of a politician or a strong project, such as the PSC and the PSOE, is not that the polls change us, but that we change the polls; that is, to win or regain the trust of the citizens.

In Catalonia, socialists have a commitment and an appeal in favor of the citizens...

Mr. Terribas.- Don't campaign for them, Mr. President, don't campaign for them.

President.- No, I have felt it. Since I have taken the leadership of the PSOE, I have felt it here, in Catalonia, like nowhere else.

Mr. Terribas.- Your support has, of course, because...

President.- Because we have that capacity to integrate, we have that capacity to be as Catalan as anyone else and, at the same time, to have a reasonable leftist project.

Mr. Terribas.- Is Catalonia a nation, Mr. President?

President.- That was defined by the Statute of Catalonia and is now included in the preamble.

Mr. Terribas.- I ask you, Mr. President: Is Catalonia a nation?

President.- Catalonia is an Autonomous Community, from a constitutional point of view, and a nationality, as we have heard.

But I have said many times: I believe that the debate was an intense debate, and it does not cause me concern, nor did it cause me concern that this definition was made, although legally, from a constitutional point of view, it is more appropriate to say that it is a nationality and that, politically, it is an Autonomous Community.

Mr. Terribas.- Ruling of the Constitutional Court. Today we read in "La Vanguardia," for example, that it comes down to a single vote, that eighteen articles are affected, that Eugeni Gay will not give in... Mr. President, ten people ideologically divided, some of them extended, practically all extended in November, can they outweigh two Parliaments, the Catalan Parliament and the Cortes, and the ballots, in addition to a Statute that already came trimmed from the one approved on September 30? Does that make any sense that does not create a crisis?

President.- I must say that the Statute that was ratified in a referendum by the citizens of Catalonia is a Statute with a high degree of self-government; certainly, the highest in the history of Catalonia. I voted for it, I think it is constitutional, and that is why I voted for it, and that it is also yielding good results, because since the Statute has been in force, and the institutions of Catalonia, the powers, the competencies, and the financing model are functioning, we have not had any serious institutional problems; on the contrary, things are working well and there is great cooperation.

Therefore, my opinion is that it is constitutional, and I will defend it all the time throughout my life.

Mr. Terribas.- What will you do if it is not constitutional because the ruling says so?

President.- We must, first, be respectful in the forecast, because we do not know what will happen. Only the magistrates will know when they conclude their work and finish their deliberation. Then, when we see the ruling, we will decide.

Mr. Terribas.- We have been waiting four years, Mr. President; four years.

President.- There are laws that have been in the Constitutional Court for that time and more.

Mr. Terribas.- You proposed in this legislature the renewal of the Constitutional Court and the General Council of the Judiciary, and we do not have either of those, Mr. President.

President.- The Council has been renewed, but the Constitutional Court does not only depend on the Government. We necessarily have to, due to the majorities required in Parliament, reach an agreement with the Popular Party.

Mr. Terribas.- But they voted against it last week.

President.- The Popular Party has proposed names that we are not willing to support for the Constitutional Court issue; we do not consider them the most suitable, and so we have the deliberation, the negotiation, paralyzed regarding the changes that need to be made in the Constitutional Court. That is the reality.

Mr. Terribas.- So, we are talking about judicial independence, but you are exchanging names. This does not give a very good image to the citizen of the independence of the Constitutional Court, does it, Mr. President?

President.- One is independent in function, but can anyone imagine a more legitimized body to choose the members of the Constitutional Court than the Parliament of Spain, which is elected by all citizens, where we have democratic representation? Certainly not. I, as a democrat, want my representatives to choose the Magistrates of the Constitutional Court. It seems to me that it is a much more legitimized and legitimating way than if we thought that they should be chosen by, I don’t know, a body of Prosecutors? Well, no. I sincerely believe it should be that way.

Mr. Terribas.- Do you know that if the ruling is negative here, in Catalonia, the issue of consultations for independence could escalate and even be a determining factor in elections?

President.- Let us not prejudge. Moreover, when it is said that the ruling is negative, what does that mean?

Mr. Terribas.- Negative means that affected articles return, Mr. President; that they remain modified.

President.- There are articles in the Statute... One thing that is not evident is that it is not a brief Statute. It has many articles, some of greater importance; others of lesser importance, as is natural, and the Court may review some parts. I interpret...

Mr. Terribas.- Are you preparing us, Mr. President?

President.- No. I am preparing you for the fact that this is not black and white, because the Statute of Catalonia has been challenged on a number of articles by the Popular Party. Because, said all this, we are here because the Popular Party has presented the unconstitutionality appeal. It cannot be presented by just anyone; it has been presented by fifty deputies and fifty senators.

So, of all that the Popular Party has presented as unconstitutional, many articles, the Constitutional Court has to rule on all points, and logically, there will be a very high number of rulings. There may be some that, perhaps, they consider not constitutional --I am considering a hypothesis-- or that the constitutional interpretation is this and we have to see why. Let us not jump to conclusions.

Mr. Terribas.- A way to continue applying the Statute would be, for example, as Catalunya Radio learned recently, through the modification of organic laws and through direct transfers from article 150.2?

President.- My opinion, as I understand that the majority of the rulings of the Statute are constitutional, is that we will not need to reach that situation.

Mr. Terribas.- But would it be applicable?

President.- I do not see it, because the Statute has some articles for which, for their real effectiveness, for their effective validity, it is necessary to have State legislation, and that, for me, is not unconstitutional. Therefore, now I am making a legal analysis rather than a political one --from the point of view of legal analysis, I do not believe we need to reach that situation.

Mr. Terribas.- Mr. President, two questions about the role in the Presidency of the European Commission. Regarding speculative funds, you could not raise it because Gordon Brown told you: "stop, because I have electoral problems and do not raise it now." That will be a failure, right? Because you were very clear that the Directive on high-risk funds should be approved during your Presidency.

President.- And we are going to approve it. During the Spanish Presidency, it will be approved.

Mr. Terribas.- When?

President.- The ECOFIN is at the end of May, and the European Council that will approve it will be in June, the last of the European Presidency.

Mr. Terribas.- So, we will not know anything about this issue in March.

President.- It is essential that a country like Great Britain, where the activity we want to regulate represents 60 percent of the European Union, is in consensus. That seems reasonable, right? That is why we have said: we already have practically a great consensus, and there is one part left to be in the consensus of a country that is very important, which is Great Britain. And I am committed to achieving that consensus.

Mr. Terribas.- What is happening now in Brussels is that the key, I suppose, and, Mr. President, I believe everyone is going to walk towards this, is that there should be a single voice of economic governance in the European Union; that there should be a voice that ultimately represents Europe in the G-20. Would this receive the support of President Rodríguez Zapatero, despite the cost of being in the G-20? That is to say, would we give up being there so that Europe can speak with one voice?

President.- Spain will be in the G-20 and Europe will speak with one voice. They are compatible. Just as Italy will be in the G-20, and France, and Germany, and Great Britain...

Mr. Terribas.- But then, we will never go defending a single policy.

President.- ...and they will not give up being in the G-20, because the G-20 is a group of great powers, of large industrialized countries. But if we make the European Union have a single voice in the G-20, we will have made a great advance, and if we prepare the task in the G-20 together, we will have made a great advance, not only in the G-20, but in other economic forums.

Certainly, Europe needs more common economic governance, more economic cooperation, and more economic coordination, especially in the eurozone.

Mr. Terribas.- Mr. President, ETA, how has your perspective changed, from that hope you had in the first legislature for a peace process, to seeing in prison those who spoke with Patxi López, Otegui, and the other abertzale leaders? And we are only on the judicial and police path, and we are not moving from there. Do you give any value to the statement from "Gara" yesterday?

President.- No.

Mr. Terribas.- No?

President.- Knowing, as I do, the process that is taking place and the situation of ETA, I do not give it any value. The peace process in which, as everyone knows, I put a great effort to see the end of violence has been a great missed opportunity, especially for the left abertzale and for those who are engaged in that kind of debate about a democratic process and dare to tell ETA no. It was a great lost process for them.

Mr. Terribas.- But they continue to say it and they are in prison, Mr. President.

President.- Yes, of course, they are in prison because they have committed acts that Justice has deemed them responsible for in a criminal manner.

What we must clearly state is that after the peace process we led in 2006; after the effort I made, which was very great and with many criticisms, to try to get ETA to renounce violence through dialogue and start a different time; after they were not able to maintain that minimum of courage and that minimum determination, we cannot expect anything other than the definitive, global, unquestionable renunciation of violence from what remains of ETA or what today is ETA, which is increasingly less and has fewer members because it has been greatly weakened. Those who call themselves Batasuna or Izquierda Abertzale, whether or not they are in prison for their actions, can only come out and demand from ETA "no more violence, no more murders, no more deaths." From that moment on, they can be heard; but with ambiguity, no.

Mr. Terribas.- The thing is that this process is hard. Do you think that being in prison can facilitate this process of convincing the armed group; from prison?

President.- Yes, they know very well what they have to do. They know it, they are aware.

Mr. Terribas.- Mr. President. Let's move on to something easier. Barcelona Airport, have you brought us the keys so that we can decide the routes, etc., etc.? When will we know if Catalonia will be decisive in how to make this airport competitive?

President.- First of all, we have a great airport now.

Mr. Terribas.- Yes, but when will we have an agreement?

President.- With T1, with the new terminal, it has worked wonderfully. I believe we will have an agreement in a short period of time and the best thing is that we decide together, because the interest of Catalonia is intertwined with the interest of the whole of Spain, without a doubt. There is a specific interest of Catalonia, and we are going to ensure that this space of specific interest for improvement, for international projection, of Catalonia has a management capacity from Catalonia, and there is an interest that belongs to the whole of Spain, which we must respect. We will reach an agreement, as we have reached agreements on other issues, even if it takes some time; but that is how democracy works.

Mr. Terribas.- But this way we will not achieve what is requested in Catalonia, which is to decide on the companies, the flights, and the routes. Say it clearly, because we are done with the mystery.

President.- We will decide together, which is better. We succeed together and, if we make mistakes, we make mistakes together.

Mr. Terribas.- Mr. President, we are nearing the end. How can a citizen understand that they can decide how the Diagonal in Barcelona should be in a referendum, for example, that will be held here, in Barcelona, as you know, and cannot express an opinion on how they want Catalonia to relate to the State? How is that understood?

President.- The thing is that we have already expressed opinions on that many times and the last time was when the Statute of Autonomy was voted on in a referendum with a fairly broad majority.

Mr. Terribas.- But it is different, isn’t it?

President.- No. The linkage is established in a norm like the Statute of Autonomy, which is a norm that is the first norm of Catalonia and is also a norm that belongs to the whole State, to Spain, and that serves as a union, as a bridge; that emanates from the Constitution, but that needs a specific space of endorsement, of ratification, first, from the political parties here and then from the Catalan political parties that went to negotiate in the Parliament of Spain. We negotiated, we reached an agreement, and then the citizens ratified it, and now I hope that the Constitutional Court sanctifies it in its vast majority.

That has strength, that has solidity and is stable. What we cannot, really, no Community, like Catalonia, which has a huge identity that I appreciate and respect, because it is also an identity for which...

Mr. Terribas.- Because it is culé, come on!

President.- Beyond my culé nature... for which I have admiration, sincerely.

But beyond that identity, we have an organized self-government and increasingly intertwined to work together with what is the State, with what is the Government of Spain. That makes us stronger and we cannot be thinking about modifying, about altering, every little while, because that wastes a lot of time for the problems of the economy, of technology, of employment, of well-being... Of everything that means what is important for many people.

Mr. Terribas.- Mr. President, one last question that affects us on a fundamental issue, which is television, the audiovisual. The Audiovisual Law promoted by the Rodríguez Zapatero Government is a law that, basically, when you listen to the experts you hired to talk about it, benefits the large private groups (Tele 5, Antena 3, La Sexta, Cuatro), the media groups that are there forcing the situation, and weakens public service because it makes it less competitive, because it puts obstacles to certain commercial activities, etc. Why does a left-wing government support private media groups that do not comply with plurality, with protected hours? Why?

President.- Absolutely disagree, radically disagree with this opinion.

Mr. Terribas.- And why is UTECA so happy and the rest of the public sector so upset?

President.- UTECA is usually asking, demanding, and criticizing.

What have we done with public broadcasting? Two things: first, for the first time --I believe I can say this, with caution but I must say it and I want to say it-- we have a plural public broadcasting, quite independent, very neutral and not a broadcasting service at the service of the government in power, and we see it in channel 1, in the debates, in the interviews and in the daily information; and, second, we have made a law so that public television is a television that does not have advertising and that is increasingly a public service, because for me a public service in television and radio is that, it is to provide a public service, good information, culture and not just compete for the sake of competing.

And, look, by eliminating advertising and with a stable financing model that we have implemented, how the audience is doing in public television. It is getting better every day, leading in audience.

Mr. Terribas.- We are too, and we have advertising, Mr. President.

President.- It is surprising to say "a model that harms public television," when it is gaining audience and those that are losing are the private ones. So, am I with the model I have implemented that is making private televisions lose audience? Simply, it is not true.

Mr. Terribas.- We will see when it evolves a little more. It is true that it is too early to make predictions.

President.- The thing is that there are people... There is nothing that is done that does not have a criticism, but I can tell you that of the things I feel most satisfied with what we have done in these years of government is the changes in public broadcasting.

Mr. Terribas.- Mr. President, thank you very much. When is the next time you will come: for another inauguration or for a Barça match? Because Guardiola is unstoppable.

President.- Whenever I can, because I always enjoy coming to Catalonia. Guardiola is unstoppable, he is a great coach, but what a player Messi is! Messi is extraordinary with the ball, but also without the ball, because he is a person with humility and I love how he behaves towards others and his teammates. For example, yesterday I enjoyed Messi's goals like I hadn't in a long time...

Mr. Terribas.- Yes, but Barça made us suffer more yesterday than Messi. Messi made us enjoy.

President.- But he will have his day too. Yesterday you could see that he was determined, but it was a very good gesture for Messi to offer to take the penalty. I understand the wave that Camp Nou gives to Messi, because he seems to me a player of whom we have very few opportunities to have someone like Messi again.

Mr. Terribas.- And why doesn’t he ever come to the field? He has never come since he became President.

President.- I will come.

Mr. Terribas.- Are you afraid that...?

President.- No, no. I have been with Barça fans many times and it is well known that one always reaps, as is normal, applause and also many expressions of rejection.

I believe that sport is sport and politicians what we normally have to do, except on very grand occasions, is to be in our task and in our place. I usually go when we play an international competition, whatever the team.

Mr. Terribas.- Even if it is at the Bernabéu for the Champions final with Barça?

President.- I hope Barça wins the Champions this year once again. I am not going to say who I wish would win La Liga, because...

Mr. Terribas.- I am not going to make you make predictions, because making predictions is not good to do too many because, sometimes, they are wrong.

Mr. President, thank you very much for joining us, thank you very much for this time.

President.- Thank you very much.