Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

23 March 2010 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to opposition leader Rajoy's questions during a parliamentary control session in Spain on March 23, 2010, defending his government's fiscal consolidation plan.
Main themes
Public deficit reduction, fiscal consolidation plan, European Commission credibility assessment, Spain's economic crisis response, government austerity measures, autonomous communities fiscal responsibility, revenue forecasts and spending cuts, financial system restructuring, tax fraud prevention, public employment reduction, political accountability
Duration
~14 min
47th percentile
Words
1,629
47th percentile
Sentences
52
34th percentile
Readability
41
38th percentile
Grade
14.8
74th percentile
Syntax
3.45
92nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
51st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 89%77%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Institutional 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 13%

52 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, I have a question for you on an important matter.

In 2009, you budgeted a deficit of 1.9 percent of GDP, and the actual figure was 11.2 percent. This year, you have already revised your deficit forecast upwards, and in that context, you present a Stability Plan in Europe, regarding which the European Commission states the following: "The fiscal adjustment plan proposed by the Government lacks credibility and does not guarantee the stability of public finances." It provides several reasons, which I summarize as follows: first, the revenue forecasts are overly optimistic; second, the restructuring of the financial system is progressing very slowly; third, the fiscal adjustment lacks concrete measures; and fourth, there are no structural improvements to enhance productivity and competitiveness. It concludes by stating that the plan you present does not guarantee the deficit target.

I would like to know your opinion on this matter and whether you believe that you will indeed reduce the public deficit to the terms you set out in that Stability Plan.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, as you well know, and as a consequence of the international financial crisis and the economic crisis, twenty out of the twenty-seven countries in the European Union have incurred excessive deficits. In response, the Government, at the request of the Commission, like the other governments, has presented a Fiscal Consolidation Plan until 2013 to reach a 3 percent deficit, and we have already taken steps in that direction; credible steps that, with everyone's cooperation, will help us achieve that goal.

For example, for this budgetary exercise of 2010, the Government has already established the non-availability of five billion euros and the reduction of the Public Employment Offer this year to 10 percent of the replacement rate of the effective rate. Similarly, we have approved a Plan for the Prevention and Correction of Tax Fraud; likewise, with the collaboration of all the Autonomous Communities, in the Sectoral Health Conference, we have already approved a plan to reduce pharmaceutical spending and save costs through cooperation in the healthcare system; and, likewise, last Monday, a plan and a commitment to contribute to the reduction of the deficit assumed by the Autonomous Communities were established in the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council held two days ago, as I mentioned. And I hope that all the Communities will fulfill that commitment, as the State will.

Furthermore, I can announce that in the first half of April, the Government will present a plan to reduce structures and public companies of the General State Administration.

And finally, I would like you to take a more measured reading of the report that the Commission has made on the fiscal plan of the countries as a whole because, if you do that more measured reading, you will see that, comparatively, the plan presented by Spain is one of the best rated by the European Commission in terms of reduction and fiscal consolidation.

Mr. Rajoy.- You talk about plans and credible steps, but no one believes them. Neither analysts, nor the markets, nor the majority of the parties in this Chamber believe them, and neither does the European Commission, which states verbatim "lack of credibility."

At the beginning of the year, you revised the public deficit forecast upwards, from 8.1 in December to 9.8 percent. The measures you adopt are insignificant: you say, and you have reminded us here, that you will reduce public spending by five billion this year, but you increased it in December by twenty-seven billion. All the spending reduction is postponed to 2012 and 2013.

You talk about the Autonomous Communities, but 48 hours ago you authorized them to incur a debt of 3.2 percent for 2010 and 4.2 percent for 2011, and then you say to reduce spending by ten billion in 2012 and 2013.

But the most serious issue is the data we learned yesterday, Mr. President. The State's deficit in January and February stands at 7.759 billion euros, revenues fall by 7.1 percent and your forecast was for a 3 percent increase, while expenditures increase by 22.8 percent. This loss of deficit, Mr. President, means loss of reputation, loss of confidence, more taxes, less credit, less employment, and a worse economic situation.

I ask you to heed the European Union because it will be good for you. We did it in 1996, and it was good for Spain.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, the Government has a firm commitment to reducing the deficit and to maximum austerity at this stage. I ask you, Mr. Rajoy, that, to the extent of your political responsibilities where you govern, you contribute to that national objective.

The steps we are going to take and the agreements we are making are credible, and I urge you, for the last time, to read the Commission's report and the comparison with other countries more thoughtfully, and you will see how the evaluation of Spain's Plan is...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antonio Duran i Lleida, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran.- Mr. President of the Government, as you know, the current 2000E Plan, with a budget allocation of one hundred million, is valid for vehicle purchases until the end of September of this year 2010 or until operations for the purchase of two hundred thousand vehicles are completed.

In light of this Plan, the private sector already pointed out, in mid-March, that in spring, the funds allocated for the Plan would likely be exhausted, and on the other hand, the Minister recalled that it would be in June. From this perspective, in a recent interpellation in the Senate, the Minister of Industry, Tourism and Trade stated verbatim: "We are going to continue the 2000E Plan"; session of March 9. However, on other occasions, he has stated differently, saying that "when the funds run out --I mean-- they are finished," after recalling that European countries are already withdrawing the incentives to the economy.

From this perspective, Mr. President, this Parliamentary Group considers it necessary and essential that the continuity of these funds not only be maintained but that it could also be incorporated as one of the economic agreements in the context of the discussions that were initiated at the well-known Zurbano Palace.

Therefore, Mr. President of the Government, the question is: in your opinion, what are the prospects for the duration of the aids of this Plan, and do you really believe that it could be incorporated into this set of economic agreements?

President.- Mr. Duran, as you know, the aid plan for the sector, in this case for car purchases, has received support from the State of 140 million in 2009 and 100 million in 2010. These 100 million in 2010 should logically help around two hundred thousand cars because, as you know, the amount of aid is five hundred euros concerning the Government. Logically, this Plan and this measure of one hundred million will end when that number of vehicles is covered.

I am surprised that Mr. Duran does not make a positive assessment of what the Plan has meant. The Plan has been very positive, it has greatly stimulated the purchase of cars and has also undoubtedly helped production, which is linked to the entire Competitiveness Plan of the Automotive Sector that the Ministry of Industry has launched, which has guaranteed the presence of our main car production plants and also the possibility of future viability, having incorporated the planning of new vehicles.

That is the situation, and regarding what will happen when the aids end, I must tell you that we are in a European context, and I must tell you that most countries are already withdrawing, and some have already withdrawn, the aids because we must remember that they have an extraordinary character due to what has been a severe economic crisis.

Mr. Duran.- Do not be surprised, Mr. President of the Government, that I do not make a positive assessment of the Plan. Implicitly, it is in my question. To the extent that I request you to extend that Plan, it means that I value it positively, and it is a first reason for me to ask you that, once the planned aids are over, as it is so vital for vehicle sales, and I believe for an important sector like automotive with all that it entails for auxiliary industry and component industry, it is evident that this is a first piece of data, a first reason, for which I reiterate and insist that the Government incorporate the continuity of these aids into the Zurbano agreements, because they will run out sooner than expected by the Ministry, as I reflected in previous data.

On the other hand, do not doubt that the increase in VAT will have a negative effect and will mean 400 or 450 euros per vehicle; it is another reason to help them.

It is not yet time to withdraw the aids because overcoming the economic crisis is still nothing. Therefore, Mr. President, incorporate into Zurbano and reiterate...

President.- I am glad, Mr. Duran, that you value the dialogue process known as the "Zurbano Process."

I have taken note of your request; the three Ministers who are part of the Commission are here, and I am sure that in the dialogue process you will receive an adequate response. We take note of your request, although you know the Government's position: that the aids must have an extraordinary character; but I am sure that the so-called "trident" will provide an adequate response in the dialogue process we have open in Zurbano.