Interview with the President of the Government on the program "Los Desayunos de TVE"

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

30 January 2011 · Interview on the program "Los Desayunos de TVE" · Televisión Española

Context
Zapatero was interviewed on the Spanish TVE breakfast programme on 30 January 2011, addressing Spain's 20% unemployment rate and government reform efforts.
Main themes
Unemployment crisis, labor market reforms, economic recovery, social protection for the unemployed, temporary vs permanent contracts, structural unemployment in Spain, construction sector job losses, active employment policies, medium and long-term reform effects
Duration
~83 min
98th percentile
Words
9,961
98th percentile
Sentences
452
98th percentile
Readability
55
78th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
5th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

452 sentences in 195 paragraphs

Ana Pastor.- Good morning, Mr. President.

President.- Good morning.

Ana Pastor.- Thank you for speaking with Televisión Española.

First of all, an unemployment rate of 20 percent. There are many people watching you right now, looking at your Government. Are the reforms working?

President.- The reforms have a medium- and long-term scope, and a good part of them aim to prevent that, when we have a new period of crisis, the unemployment rate, as has always happened in Spain, does not rise to those unacceptable figures.

The most urgent issue regarding unemployment, which is undoubtedly the most serious social problem and the concern and anguish of people who have lost their jobs and are unemployed, is that we implement the part of the social agreement related to active employment policies as soon as possible, immediately, to provide more opportunities, to have more direct attention to each unemployed person, and, logically, also in the expectation that economic recovery will allow companies to create more jobs, that we generate enough confidence for employers to decide to hire, because their expectations are more favorable.

Ana Pastor.- I insist on that terrible figure, because you will understand that there are people listening to you who may think that the Government is perhaps not doing enough, seeing that there are over four million unemployed in Spain.

President.- I must remind you of two things: the first is that the unemployment rate in our country always has, approximately, a structural character that makes our unemployment higher than the European average. In fact, when we reached the lowest unemployment rate in our history, in 2007, at 8 percent, the perception that the Government had was that we were practically at full employment. In fact, the workers that the economy and companies needed all came from abroad. We must remember that in the last ten years, five million people have come to work in Spain. And whenever we have had an economic crisis, our basic problem has been an excessive, unacceptable rise in the unemployment rate.

First consideration, then: it is structural, and now we are trying, with these reforms, as I said before, to prevent it from happening again and that we end up like other European countries that, when there is an economic crisis, which we will have again in certain years, do not experience such a rise in the unemployment rate.

Second consideration, it is true that we have a very high unemployment rate, but it is also true that we have the highest unemployment protection rate in history. Seventy-five percent of unemployed people in Spain are receiving benefits. I know that this is not what they prefer and that they would prefer a job, but I also know that this benefit, which represents a very important economic effort from society, undoubtedly provides significant support and demonstrates the social cohesion that our country is capable of instilling.

Ana Pastor.- You mentioned the reforms you are carrying out and the labor reform. I insist on this as well, because it is true that there is talk of protection for the unemployed, but you said that this labor reform is being done to generate employment in Spain. The data we have is that employment is still not being preserved.

President.- I understand the anxiety, but I will say two things: first, the labor reform is a reform that will have its most powerful effects when the economy returns to a growth rate that is at least 1 percent or above 1 percent; second, the labor reform is already having some effect, little by little, and that is that there are increasingly more permanent contracts and fewer temporary contracts. In fact, among the data from the EPA last Friday, regarding that very high unemployment rate that rose by five tenths — it is true that the last quarter is usually seasonally worse than the third and second — there was one piece of data, which is the reduction in the temporary employment rate, which stood at 25 percent.

We have said that we have two fundamental problems regarding our labor market: one, of course, the first, to reduce unemployment, to generate more jobs; second, that this employment is increasingly permanent and less temporary. And in this, the labor reform is already yielding results.

But, I insist, things are not going to change overnight. We must be absolutely sincere. It will be very difficult to reduce the unemployment rate. More than two million jobs have been destroyed; 70 percent are linked to construction due to the excess we had. And giving the opportunity back to all the people and many young people with little qualification who were in the construction sector will be a very great effort for the country, for society as a whole, of course for the Government of Spain, first of all, and for all the Governments; but it will happen, and we will gain more opportunities every day, this year and in 2012, undoubtedly, for young people and for people who are in that situation of unemployment.

Ana Pastor.- You have mentioned many things, and I will pick up on some of them. It is true that the temporary employment rate is decreasing, which is a figure provided by the Government; but there is also a figure provided by the Government that says that the number of objective dismissals is increasing. You know that this reform was accompanied by a headline for a long time, and to this day, which is that the Government is making dismissals cheaper. Do those figures confirm it? Is that so? Is it easier to dismiss now?

President.- The time of the highest number of dismissals we have known in history was 2009, before the labor reform. It was the express dismissal that was used and that, in essence, is a perversion of what labor relations mean and should mean, because if there are economic reasons, it should, as its name indicates, resort to an objective dismissal and not seek the loophole that the Law — by the way, the reform of 2002 that Aznar made and that originated a general strike — has allowed.

Therefore, if the conditions for dismissal are more rational, which is what the labor reform has sought, that represents a stimulus for hiring; it should represent a stimulus for hiring. When the causes for dismissal are reformed, it is sought — and for that, logically, the complicity of employers is needed, which is another area — that the employer can make plans and have a certain peace of mind that, if their business activity is not going well, they have a reasonable way to let go of some workers and not close the company, which is letting go of everyone, which is what has happened to us in many cases during 2009.

Notice that in 2009 we had two striking data regarding what the serious knots of our labor market are that need to be untied and reformed: first, there was only 20 percent of objective dismissals in 2009, with a very strong economic crisis. That is to say, were there no economic reasons that justified letting go of workers to avoid closing companies? Yes, there were. Second data, in 2009 we are the country in the European Union that lost the most jobs, and at the same time, we are the country in the European Union where salaries increased the most, by 3.6 percent.

That is to say, our economic adjustment occurs entirely through employment. What happens in other countries? We take the example of Germany, and that is why the labor reform exists, and there were many companies in Germany in 2009 where workers and companies agreed to do what? Reduce salaries, reduce hours, and not reduce jobs.

Ana Pastor.- But they also had higher salaries. You know that this is something that is said on the street: here salaries have risen because in Spain salaries are also lower compared to Germany or other countries.

President.- I must remind you that our per capita income at this moment is above the European average and the per capita income is not very distant from the per capita income of Germany; the per capita income. I must say that our salary evolution in recent years has been one of maintaining or slightly gaining purchasing power.

We need to link salaries to productivity. We cannot talk about salaries in general, and we must look at them sector by sector. The most productive sectors are the ones that have the most salary gains. Even in the severe economic crisis, there have been sectors, such as telecommunications, research, innovation, and renewable energy, that have not lost jobs; they have gained jobs and also gained salary positions.

Therefore, everything depends on the capacity for productivity, and for the improvement of productivity is what we are doing the reforms because, if we do not gain productivity in a part of the economy, we will not have that capacity, first, to have a reasonable horizon of salary evolution; second, to have sufficient income to maintain all the advances of the Welfare State, of the social policies we have made.

Ana Pastor.- I return to another figure you provided, that of youth unemployment. You said you were concerned. Last Wednesday, in the control session, Mariano Rajoy asked you, and I ask you too, about youth unemployment. There is a part of a generation here in Spain that looks to the future with uncertainty. What can the President of the Government say to them?

President.- That we are taking all measures so that this uncertainty becomes an opportunity in the shortest time possible. What is the expectation, the confidence, that we can have? Confidence comes from two arguments. The first is that we have a generation of young people, say what you will, with training, and what we can say to those who have lost a job and are young, or to those who are looking for a job and are young, is that they should not lose the desire to continue training and requalifying, because that will give them many more opportunities and more guarantees. In active employment policies, we are now going to strengthen all that is training for unemployed people, where we are at a certain distance from European countries.

Second consideration, we need to see and each individual person, in addition to the public authorities, needs to know which sectors are going to create jobs in the immediate future, which are not the ones that have been linked to construction.

Notice, one of the serious problems we have had and that we have, which we are now going to change with active employment policies, is that 60 percent of the places we offer through the workshop schools, which is one of the classic training and employment activities in our country; 60 percent is aimed at training people to work in construction where jobs are not going to be created and where, in addition, there are already many trained people who have come out as a result of the construction crisis.

The sectors that are going to create jobs in the immediate future are linked to professional services, because in Spain we have great potential — that is to say, unemployed people who have a degree in important professional sectors are going to have opportunities — they are the sectors linked to new technologies, they are the sectors linked to renewable energies, and they are the sectors linked to the fight in favor of the environment. All those sectors are going to be the sectors that drive, that are the engines, of job creation.

Ana Pastor.- Listening to you speak, and surely many people at home are thinking the same, when, Mr. President? Because one of the criticisms made to the Government is that it has been correcting its own forecasts. When is employment going to be created, because one does not really know what to hold on to anymore? Which semester? Which year? When are we going to see that job destruction ends?

President.- You always make me make some comment. We could make a table of forecasts from all international organizations and a table of forecasts from the Government, since 2008 or 2009, and we would see that the one that is getting closest to the data with its forecasts is the Government. This table can be made at any time; moreover, I invite you to do so.

Ana Pastor.- We will do it. Tell me, when will Spain create jobs?

President.- All the estimates we have, all the analyses, indicate that we will create net jobs in the second half of this year if the economy continues that trend towards gradual recovery. We would all like it to be faster, but we have to solve a fundamental problem, which is the restructuring of the financial system, of the savings banks, because if the financial system is not solid, it cannot provide sufficient credit to companies; if companies do not have financing, they cannot make investment plans, and if they do not make investment plans, they cannot create jobs.

Therefore, in the second half of 2011, we will have an expectation of net job creation; moderate, still. We also know that there are months that are better than others. Normally, the better months will be the months when spring begins, which are always more favorable for employment. And 2012 will be a net job creation year.

We need to create a lot of jobs to recover all that we have lost in this very tough crisis.

Ana Pastor.- I note that, Mr. President. The Popular Party says that you have been entangled in your succession or non-succession, and that you are not concerned about those four million unemployed. What do you have to say to that criticism?

President.- I find it quite sad. Everyone knows that the Government is, above all, focused and dedicated to the economic crisis and the set of significant reforms that we have initiated. I can tell you that in recent weeks we have practically spent the whole day or a large part of the day and part of the night working to achieve the economic and social agreement with employers and unions on pensions, active policies, and all the issues we have incorporated.

That is what we have been dedicated to, and I suppose the Popular Party will be dedicated to its issues; but what is evident does not need demonstration, and we have been seen hours and hours working on something as important as that agreement, which generates trust and will create social peace and commitment from economic actors to the reforms.

This is a qualitative leap. Why? Because in a country, a Government can make reforms, and we have made them, such as labor reform; we can bring them to the Official State Gazette, turn them into laws, undoubtedly, and they have effects; but when those reforms are made with the will to reform from the whole country, from employers, from workers, and I hope from the rest of the parties, I hope; that, without a doubt, has much more strength, objectives are achieved sooner, and it gives a very important content of trust and hope to the people.

Ana Pastor.- I will get to that topic; you have gotten ahead of me. Linked a bit to what we were talking about regarding the step towards that reform, the pension reform is an important one, and it is the third in the entire history of our democracy. There are some young people, because we are talking about the long term, who may wonder how they will contribute for 38 and a half years, which is the period set for 65 years, if it is increasingly difficult to find a job in this country. Also, address those people who have those doubts.

President.- All the estimates we have are that the working career, which is currently on average above 35 years and is precisely at 38 or 39 years, will even increase a bit in the coming years and then will slightly decrease. But it is quite reasonable to think that by 2030, 2040, or 2050 we will be in a situation, in terms of working career time, similar on average to what we are today.

The phenomenon that will occur is that there will be fewer very long working careers, and today there is still a high percentage of long careers that exceed forty years of contributions, and there will also be a shortening, a reduction, of very short careers. That is to say, it will concentrate on a middle term that will reasonably be around 38 or 39 years, which will be the average contribution. That is the forecast that exists, and I must say that the forecasts regarding Social Security are very accurate. Why? Because we have a good database and we know exactly how many people will retire in 2015, in 2020, and in 2030. Those are not estimates; we know the people who are there, we know the workers, and we know their resumes and their working lives.

Look, for a person to be able to retire with 38 and a half years of contributions at 67 years old, they could have perfectly started working at 29 years old, which is not an excessive age either. Let us not forget that our labor market has a characteristic, which has a high level of temporality, it is true...

Ana Pastor.- That is what I am getting at, the continuity in the 38 years.

President.- ...of 25 percent; but that continuity is a continuity that does not affect all workers at the same time. Let’s say that there are many people, which is what we are trying to correct with labor reform, who enter and exit the labor market. I must say that the Law provides mechanisms to cover those contingencies and that it is computed, that it is counted, for people who at a given moment leave the labor market.

For example, the reform incorporates two major innovations. The first is one that many young people have been affected by, by this situation.

Ana Pastor.- Interns.

President.- Exactly. Research interns, interns in companies, something that was not previously taken into account, do not contribute to Social Security. Now what are we going to establish? Retroactively, we will compute it for up to two years as if they have been...

Ana Pastor.- Backwards.

President.- Yes, backwards, from the time it comes into effect. In the future, companies, research centers will have to make contracts and agreements with Social Security for their contributions. Therefore, that was an unjust situation for many young people who had years of research careers in companies or in public centers as interns and had not contributed.

Now we give that new opportunity, that right, just like to women. We are joining the more advanced countries where the time dedicated to caring for children will count as contribution time, nine months per child and up to two years depending on the number of children they have had.

Ana Pastor.- Mr. President, we have learned that you spoke with Mariano Rajoy the morning the agreement was already something official. Tell me, did you get the sense that the PP is going to support this agreement? Because, listening to statements from leaders of that party, I am not very sure what we can expect. Did he commit to support you?

President.- Yes. I hope they support us.

Ana Pastor.- Yes or do you hope?

President.- Yes, I hope they support us. Whenever I have spoken with Mr. Rajoy about pension reform, I have found him reasonable. I believe he shares most of the arguments that the European Commission, all the experts, or what Social Security and the unions say: that reforms must be made because we have a great challenge in twenty years, and that is that there will be many more retirees, and therefore, as retirement will also be collected for a longer time, we must make reforms if we do not want to lower pensions. And, since what we do not want is to lower pensions, but rather to work a little longer, because that is enough, we have opted for that.

Rajoy understands this.

Ana Pastor.- But I was asking if in the phone call he said, "Yes, President, the Popular Party is going to support this reform," or not.

President.- "We are going to be constructive," I believe was the phrase he used. Certainly, with an agreement, moreover, backed by unions and employers, it would be really unusual for him not to support it, in my opinion.

But it is true that in the Popular Party, if you notice, for a while Mr. Rajoy would go up to the podium and say: "reforms, reforms, reforms." When the Government did something more than a year ago, in December 2009, it made its Sustainable Economy Strategy, which contained all the reforms we have made during 2010 and what has been done in 2011 --it was announced on December 2 in Parliament; what happens is that normally this is not remembered, but the one who does it does remember--; from there, Rajoy, in each reform that has come, some of which are difficult, but we have done them, such as labor reform, such as deficit reduction or financial system reduction, in most of them he sidesteps. That is, he asks for reforms, but then it is very difficult for him to get involved, it is hard for him to commit.

Ana Pastor.- But here you do believe there will be support.

President.- Yes. But, look, for a party that intends to be an alternative Government, as it seems the Popular Party intends and even believes they will surely be the Government...

Ana Pastor.- All the polls say so, Mr. President. It is not just the Popular Party that says it; the polls say it.

President.- Polls are not what gets someone to La Moncloa, you know! It is the ballot boxes. And between polls and ballot boxes, for someone with a bit of political experience, I will tell you that there is a notable difference.

But what I was getting at, what surprises me, as a party of Government that they intend to be, is that they have not put their proposal on the table regarding pensions, which they have not proposed. Do you agree with 67 years or not? They have said: "Well, no, we have to...". Come on, just one concrete proposal. What about labor reform? Neither. There are times in party debates I have heard people say "Rajoy has a hidden program." And I say: Program? Rajoy has no hidden program. That is my opinion. I think he is waiting to see what sounds best at each moment, etc. And I hope now they support this reform.

Ana Pastor.- I do not want to focus on the Popular Party because there is no member of the Popular Party here to rebut these arguments, and because I think that, perhaps, it will also be difficult or more difficult for him with the left.

President.- Because they focus quite a bit on me every time they come out in an interview.

Ana Pastor.- That is your business; I will focus on mine. The left: a few days ago, Cayo Lara, in the "Desayunos," told us that you are a neoliberal. I do not know if it coincides with Rajoy's discourse, but certainly it does not seem that there is much support from the left, is there?

President.- I must make a clarification. The majority left...

Ana Pastor.- United Left, I will say.

President.- Ah!

Ana Pastor.- It is an important party within Parliament.

President.- Yes, it has two deputies. It is very important. We have...

Ana Pastor.- You say that with a bit of irony, Mr. President.

President.- No, no. I say it because sometimes I hear Llamazares in the chamber, whom I have great respect for... I find him a coherent person, I have great respect for him, and he is a good parliamentarian.

Ana Pastor.- He is one of those two deputies you referred to.

President.- Exactly. When Llamazares goes up to the podium, he always says "the left of the Chamber," and of course, I look at him and...

Ana Pastor.- They are the left, Mr. President; not all the left.

President.- Yes, but when it is said the left, come on, let’s start with the Socialist Party, which has 169 deputies and, therefore, is the majority force and the historically most important left party in this country.

Ana Pastor.- But in your party, they have not called you neoliberal, as far as I know or as seen in the news, and they have called you that in United Left.

President.- Yes, Cayo Lara has called me that, and, sincerely, with all the appreciation and respect I have for Cayo Lara, I think he should review the ideological approaches of what neoliberalism is and what my Government has been and is; a government that has increased social spending by 40 percent, which is the largest increase in social spending in six years in the democratic period; a Government that has doubled investment in scholarships, which has created the Dependency Law as the fourth pillar of the Social State, which has doubled housing aid or established the insertion income for the first time for young people; a Government that has invested in healthcare to the point that we have practically increased public spending on healthcare by 30 percent and that has made the reconciliation of family and work life an objective, increasing maternity leave, establishing paternity leave...

Ana Pastor.- I would have to ask Mr. Cayo Lara to come so that... I hope he is listening to this response.

President.- These are social policies. Now, with the crisis, we have had to halt the progress of the major developments of social rights that we made in the previous Legislature, as is reasonable, because the crisis impacts public accounts very strongly; but our project is a social project, of social rights and social conquests. At the same time, I would tell Cayo Lara --by the way, I will have an interview with him in the coming days-- that it is also a project that does not renounce and does not hide from the changes that an economy needs, and makes the necessary reforms.

Ana Pastor.- But, Mr. President, after hearing this list of things you have mentioned that your Government has done, tell me if during all this time of crisis you have ever had to put your socialist convictions in your pocket or take these measures while holding your nose, because there are those who say that some of the measures you have taken are not very socialist.

President.- I have to tell you no. I have neither felt that I was betraying my convictions, nor have I had to take anything to make decisions. Why? Because a sense of responsibility prevails, and --I must say this very clearly-- in the explanation I can give at all times of the coherence of what my main policies have been, which, I insist --I have provided a battery of examples-- have been about the development of social rights and the expansion of social benefits.

Even in the tough times of the crisis, for example, one of the things that has been most debated is the non-revaluation of pensions; but it is forgotten that this has not affected minimum pensions, which is where social sensitivity is measured, to which the Government I preside has made sure that they have gained, from 2004 to now, purchasing power by 27 percent. This is very important to me. For example, widow's pensions for those over 65 years have been increased by 85 percent in just five years, and all minimum pensions have been increased by 30 percent.

This is having social sensitivity, this is having and making social policy; these are not speeches, they are facts and resources that have been put in solidarity in favor of those with the least income and the least rents in a country, which are the minimum pensions that have been and are low in Spain because for years we were a poor country, and workers with fewer resources contributed very little to Social Security. In this, I have poured and we have poured our concern, just as during our Government's term the Minimum Interprofessional Wage has grown more than in any other period, and we have made it gain purchasing power. When we have been able to, in times of prosperity, it has gained quite a bit of purchasing power, with a Minimum Wage that we have low. This has been our concern; we have maintained it, as much as we could rationally, during the crisis, and undoubtedly, as the crisis is overcome, we will return to our social commitments.

Ana Pastor.- I ask you, Mr. President, for brief answers as I have many questions to ask you.

For example, pensions for deputies and senators. Shouldn't the current deputies and senators have the same conditions as the rest of the people on the street?

President.- I basically agree. Moreover, it is true that this was an agreement from 2006 that does not establish, I must remind you, a pension for parliamentarians but rather a pension supplement and it was made thinking of some people who, due to the circumstances of our history, of what the dictatorship and exile had been, could objectively not be in a situation to access a pension. It will be addressed, I believe we will fix it, and I think it is clear that it should be a situation in which there are neither privileges nor detriments.

Ana Pastor.- Is it a privilege that a former president of the Government in this country can receive a private salary and a public pension? Do you like that?

President.- I have always had great respect for former Presidents and I must say only in this regard that we must maintain consideration for all the former presidents of the Government that we have had in our country, who have done their job, their work; who have also taken on the enormous responsibility of governing Spain with the vote of the citizens, let us not forget, and that in all sensible, democratic, advanced European countries, they have a certain recognition, beyond their function, and that they have surely been able to and can, which is something that in my opinion we should consider in our country, continue to serve the country, the public, when they are former Presidents.

We have not achieved that. One sees that in other countries… Of course, the United States, where on many occasions former presidents have a task assigned to them by the President, particularly in international politics, but also in other major issues, and they fulfill it because that impressive accumulated experience of being the president of the Government I believe should be reverted to your country, to a large extent. That should not lead us to think that someone who has been president of the Government and is presumed to have certain capabilities cannot have private activity. I must remind you that former presidents of the Government what they have, more than a pension, as it is said, is an allowance to cover expenses that…

Ana Pastor.- It is about eighty thousand euros, I believe I remember.

President.- Yes. I do not know exactly.

Ana Pastor.- I say this because on the street, you know, these are figures that obviously attract attention.

President.- It is perfectly comparable to any allowance that a former President of any other country has.

Ana Pastor.- Well, if you agree, let’s also talk about the Autonomous Communities. Can we afford the "coffee for all"? Can we afford seventeen Ombudsmen, seventeen many things that exist in this country with the cuts that have to be made and that, for now, do not exist in that sense?

President.- Look, all Administrations must make an effort of austerity, especially in this time - we are doing it -- to cut expenses and be more efficient. The Government of Spain is doing it, but so are the Autonomous Communities. The spending that the Autonomous Communities make is, above all, education and health, and we have decided together to entrust it to the Autonomous Communities; that is, it is not that they spend on education and health, it is that they manage the spending on education and health because we have entrusted it to them through laws. By the way, spending on education and health that we have already reached and is practically at the percentages of the European average.

To highlight something so important, our health system is one of the best in the world. The satisfaction figures of citizens, the life expectancy figures and the functioning of the health system say that it is one of the best in the world and is managed…

Ana Pastor.- But I suppose no one is considering cutting there, are they? Because today I read that they are considering or may consider health copayment; I read it in the newspaper "El País" and it is said by one of your Treasury secretaries.

President.- It is not, it is a recurring debate. Regarding health copayment, I will say that I have studied it thoroughly and we have studied it thoroughly. It is not worth it.

Ana Pastor.- Do you have it ruled out?

President.- I have ruled it out. The potential savings we could have is not worth it. It is a very small saving, as demonstrated by the countries that have implemented it and that generates disincentives to health. Another thing is that we still have very high pharmaceutical spending in our country. That, at some point… In relation to the European average, it is not so much health spending; it is pharmaceutical spending where the figures are above the European average that forces us to reflect.

But, returning to the Autonomous Communities, look, in the history of Spain the moments where there have been crises in the Public Treasury have all been moments of greater centralism, of greater centralism. I said it yesterday in Zaragoza: what has been expensive and inefficient in Spain has been centralism and thanks to the Autonomous Communities we have guaranteed that citizens have first-rate services and public services are practically the same in all territories. It was unthinkable in this country without Autonomous Communities that in Extremadura they could say that they have health equal to or better than in Madrid, unthinkable, and that is because there are Autonomous Communities, just as it was unthinkable that, if there were no Autonomous Communities, high-speed rail would reach all the Autonomous Communities of the Peninsula.

Ana Pastor.- But, President, I say do not tell me because there have been some leaders, like Bono, Duran and the very Fernández Vara, the President of Extremadura, who have said that: that seventeen of everything cannot be sustained right now although the cut, as you have said, will not go in education and health.

President.- As in everything, reforms must be made because almost everything can be improved and when, as now, we know that we have to make public spending more demanding, what can they do? They can make more homogeneous regulations in economic matters or they can do things together in R&D investments; for example, one of the concerns that I must confess I have as president of the Government.

We know that research and innovation are key for the economy to have a more effective productive model. We have many technological centers in Spain. We are in a proliferation of technological centers and that proliferation has a lot to do with the Autonomous Communities. Each Autonomous Community, and it is normal, has developed or wants to start several technological centers; but a technological center, in most subjects, to have efficiency, to have strength and to truly generate innovation, must have size, critical mass, a number of researchers… a power. And, if we have in some subjects many small ones, we will not meet the objective.

I believe that this is one of the issues that the Autonomous Communities must address: to join efforts, to add and integrate in the field of technological research and then, of course, reduce all expenses.

Ana Pastor.- Provinces, for example? Are you in favor of reducing or eliminating them?

President.- The Provinces have been losing role, it is true; but it is no less true that they are recognized and that the province is recognized in the Constitution. Then, knowing the skin of this country, it is easy to say "we must eliminate the Provinces," but the provincial fact counts and weighs in the vast majority of the Autonomous Communities. People feel Extremaduran, yes, but from Cáceres or Badajoz; or people feel, yes, Castilian-Manchegan, but they also feel from Albacete, Ciudad Real, Cuenca or Toledo.

Ana Pastor.- But they can feel that way without the existence or not of the Province.

President.- Yes, but the institutional representation of the provincial fact is the Province and my prediction, my forecast, is that if someone tried to eliminate the Provinces just like that, they would encounter a strong social backlash, because I think there is an identity, an identification and a provincial feeling still very widespread in Spain. Another thing is that the Provinces have to reduce and integrate their role with the Autonomous Communities, but the attention to small municipalities, of which there are many in Spain, is done by the Provincial Provinces.

Ana Pastor.- So I deduce that I see you are not planning to get into that mess, of eliminating the Provinces.

We have little time and I want to ask you about the reform of the Savings Banks. We have talked about labor reform and pension reform. Are we going to pay for the reform of the Savings Banks, the citizens?

President.- Well, no. This is a question that, sometimes, I think that no matter how much we explain it, we will not achieve it, because there is a presumption that the Government has given money to the banks and, however…

Ana Pastor.- The Government can give money to the banks. Another thing is whether it is reintegrated, which is what you are going to tell me now, or not?

President.- It is that the Government is making money… The public sector, the citizens, because the money is not the Government's, it is the citizens'; the citizens are making money with the loans and with the support we gave to the banks.

Ana Pastor.- But you understand that people on the street do not think that.

President.- But why should I say otherwise, if it is so and demonstrable? If what we have done is guarantee the emissions they made to obtain financing abroad or buy assets from them that they then buy back from us, and in those two operations we charge them interest. In other words, we do with the banks the same thing that the banks do with the citizens.

Ana Pastor.- There I go and that is why people think that, because credit is not reaching them.

President.- The result is that we --we will provide the data during this year and, moreover, this year we are going to receive a significant amount of the interest we charge-- that is, the citizens, through the public resources managed by the Government, not only have we not given money to the banks, but we are going to obtain benefits from those loans.

Ana Pastor.- Yes, but it is difficult to understand for the reasons I tell you. It is good that the banks have reintegrated, even, the money with interest; but you know that people on the street complain that the banks have been helped, but credit is not reaching families or the self-employed. It is a demand that is there.

President.- Let’s clarify. Credit is being given a lot of credit in Spain, even now. What happens is that we came from years where credit, for example, in 2006 and 2007, grew by 20 percent. We were the country in the world where credit grew the most. Why? Because we were the country in the developed world where the most housing was being built or, for example, in some years the country in the world where the most vehicles were purchased. All of that was done with credit that the banks generously provided, that is, they induced there to be mortgages, to the mortgage for a higher percentage of the price of the housing…

Everything was financing facilities, money was relatively cheap and that has generated a very strong debt; debt that families have with the banks who bought homes or second homes, or bought new vehicles; and debt that banks have with large international investors, because the money that has been given for the mortgages of citizens, which increased significantly, is money that banks, in turn, obtain from abroad, obtain from other large banks or from other large investment funds, and that they have to repay.

Now a crisis comes, as a financial crisis has come; the financing difficulties are much greater, and, as there has been a crisis that has seriously affected the real estate sector, they also have more difficulties because the price of land has fallen, because there are many unsold homes, banks have to maintain their solvency because the solvency that we require banks to maintain is at stake the savings of citizens. Therefore, since that is absolutely a priority, we have to demand solvency from them.

To the banks now, especially to the savings banks, which are in a restructuring process because they need to be smaller given that the financial market in Spain has shrunk, we have demanded two things. The first is that they must capitalize, that they will have to capitalize; that is to say, they will have to seek investors, private capital; not public, private capital. When we have said that, approximately, the savings banks and some banks need twenty billion, what we are doing is mandating them to seek private capital. They must find it. It is likely that not all of them will succeed, through the new formulas that they must create structurally and legally.

Ana Pastor.- And then?

President.- Those that do not succeed but must reach the capital that we have set for them, the quality capital, to have solvency and not have risks, will be able to turn to public capital, to the FROB, as it is called; public money. But if public money has to be put into any savings bank that does not reach that solvency capital, the State will take action and, therefore, we will participate and decide in the control. Why? So that this savings bank or these savings banks have adequate management and, of course, we will then put it back on the market.

This is an operation in which the Government, the public sector, public resources, do not have to lose money. Moreover, it is likely that they will make money as has been done with some private banks in the history of Spain, with which, once control was taken by the Government -- and we are talking about large banks -- once cleaned up and sold, the Government obtained returns again.

Consequently, I must insist, in a forceful manner, that the public resources that are being used in relation to banking are used to guarantee solvency and, therefore, the savings of citizens so that banks and savings banks can provide credit; but it is not costing money to the public sector. It is not costing money to citizens; rather, so far, we are obtaining higher returns.

This is very important, because I know that people think that money is being given to banks and that is not true.

Ana Pastor.- We are out of time, Mr. President, but I have several questions to ask you and I do not want you to leave without answering them.

Merkel, is she putting stones in the path of Spain or the European Union because she is thinking of her territory, of what she has there, in Germany, and is going to come here in a few days?

President.- Germany is a fundamental country in the European Union. Germany underwent an important period of reforms, had a period of reforms and two very important reforms, mainly at the end of the 90s and in the 2000s, until 2005 or 2006, and today it is growing and being a very competitive country. As it is the country with the most wealth, with the highest GDP, in Europe, it has to finance many European policies and, as is natural, it wants Europe and the eurozone countries to function properly.

That will now imply changes; that reflection that I have just made, which I fully share, will lead us to a much more powerful European economic governance; we will move towards harmonization in tax matters, in retirement age and in labor matters, and that will give the euro the other pillar it lacks. Alongside the monetary policy carried out by the Central Bank, it will have the pillar of convergence, of competitiveness, of the different economies.

Ana Pastor.- Yesterday I also heard you, Mr. President, speaking at that rally in Zaragoza about a peaceful and more democratic transition in Egypt; but tell me, where have we been during this time? Where have this Government, the European Union, and the West been, because Mubarak has been there for thirty years and suddenly it seems we are surprised by what is happening in Egypt and Tunisia?

President.- Yes, these days I was jokingly commenting with a friend and colleague whether there has been any "think tank," any government, or any media that predicted that this was going to happen in the Arab countries. No. Why do I say this?

Ana Pastor.- At least, they have not said it publicly.

President.- No. Neither publicly nor privately. Neither the intelligence services, and I, as President of the Government, have the obligation to read and be very informed about things… No one predicted that what happened in Tunisia or what is happening now in Egypt would occur in almost twenty-four hours. Therefore, once again it is demonstrated that events in History are very contingent and, to a large extent, are not predictable.

What is the European response? There I have heard voices saying "it is true that Europe has not gone further" or "that Europe should have said…?" Regarding that consideration, I would ask for a more measured reflection because, without a doubt, and our history is a good example, the process of change towards a democratic scenario in a country, and more in the singularity of Arab countries, must be a process, above all, that is born, grows, and consolidates from within. Any position or action that could be interpreted as interference would be a risk for a process of that nature.

Therefore, we must support it in its consolidation, in the democratic changes; but let us not forget that, when we are talking about these countries, we have two different planes: one plane, that of the democratic aspiration, the aspiration for freedom, and the other plane, which we cannot overlook, is the plane of the great influence of religion and of one religion in particular. These are two planes that are crossing, that will cross, and it remains to be seen which one will have predominance over the other. Hence the prudence, the desire, and the support for democratic changes, of course peaceful -- no one should be surprised that we wish it to be so and that we regret the violence -- but prudence.

Ana Pastor.- Prudence that should not be at odds, I say, with speed, at least, in the statements as well, because it has also been said that the European Union has taken too long. Today the Foreign Ministers are going to take this issue there, in Brussels.

President.- Yes, but the events have been very rapid and, I insist, we do not yet have the perception or the clear definition of what the outcome will be. We all feel close to the young people who have taken to the streets, who have shouted "freedom," "democracy," and who want a rule of law; but we also know that there are other forces that are acting, most likely.

The other day I read a news item about a religious orientation group in Tunisia that was manifesting against a demonstration that was being promoted by women to defend equality between men and women. And within what were, let us say, the groups that had provoked the democratic contestation and the democratic revolt, there was that position against a demonstration of men and women in Tunisia for equality. This is there and we cannot overlook it.

Ana Pastor.- Let us talk about the future of the Socialist Party and the President. Yesterday I heard you say, and we all heard it, "let us talk about the future of Spain and not about the future of the Socialist Party." Were you thinking of any of those in front of you or not? Did you not put a face to the reflection?

President.- The truth is that the reflection was more generic, because I must say that this is not always, I do not know if it is very easy to convey to citizens. We do not usually talk about these issues, that is the truth. What happens is that…

Ana Pastor.- But, Mr. President, I cannot believe that no leader of the Socialist Party has asked you. Do only journalists ask you?

President.- Exactly. The issue is not that we talk, the Socialist Party leaders, the issue is that journalists ask about this.

Ana Pastor.- And the leaders may not respond.

President.- My colleagues do not ask me.

Ana Pastor.- Has no one asked you?

President.- They do not ask me, because there are…

Ana Pastor.- Incomprehensible.

President.- No. It is quite comprehensible because everything has its time and whoever has the responsibility to lead the Socialist Party, as is my case, for more than ten years now, and with results that I believe are reasonable for the Socialist Party, also has or must have the capacity to decide when we have to talk and address the candidacy for 2012.

Ana Pastor.- And when, Mr. President?

President.- As the when is also part of getting the decision right, we must be cautious and I said yesterday: "let us work and talk about what concerns citizens." I can assure you that citizens are concerned, above all, about unemployment, about the economic situation, and about the guarantees of the pensions that we have consolidated with this agreement. That is what they are concerned about.

Ana Pastor.- But they will also want to know…. I am a journalist, but I am also a citizen, and I also want to know.

President.- Journalists and politicians tend to think that citizens are also paying attention to the elections when there is still time until the elections… Even those in May, even…

Ana Pastor.- Mr. President, but this debate has occurred in many parties.

President.- This party, the Socialist Party, is a very strong party, it is a solid party and it is a party that will demonstrate, once again, its maturity in this very difficult period, with this serious economic crisis, and it will demonstrate its maturity in the decisions it has to make. Therefore, if they say "they only talk about succession…

Ana Pastor.- It is compatible. You can even talk about football here. There is time for everything.

President.- But I must say: if it is talked about and if colleagues talk…

Ana Pastor.- And they talk a lot. You know that.

President.- No. It is that you ask a lot.

Ana Pastor.- But one can choose not to respond.

President.- I must say that no party leader, on their own initiative, wants to bring up this topic. That is my opinion.

Ana Pastor.- In recent days there is some example. But tell me when. Do not confuse me. Do you already have a clear idea of when you are going to announce it?

President.- I just said that this is also part of what is the logical option and that it is not time. It is that no, there is still a lot of time left.

Ana Pastor.- And what do you say to the barons who ask you to do it sooner, ahead of the elections in May?

President.- Do you see? For example.

Ana Pastor.- They say it publicly. Fernández Vara told us in this program.

President.- No, but then he said something else.

Ana Pastor.- Well… He told us, and our audience, that before May.

President.- Well, very well. I respect him, but the when will be something that I decide, listening to other people, eh! But I am going to tell you, to make the analogy as clear as possible, that I have a series of important folders open in my office; 80 percent of all of them are related to the issues of the economic crisis and the folder for the candidacy for 2012 I have not even taken out of the cabinet. It is there and there is still time for me to take it and think about it.

Ana Pastor.- That is why we have dedicated an hour to many other topics and a few minutes to this one. By the way, who do you consult, because you said you have to consult and listen to other people? Are we talking about family or who?

President.- Naturally, yes, of course, to family and to the colleagues who have the most important responsibility in the leadership. But, I reiterate, and I have said on some occasion, that it is the convictions that will explain the decision; not the circumstances, it is the political and personal convictions.

Ana Pastor.- There are three candidates that have sounded very strong in recent times: Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba… You know that it is an expression from someone in your party. Is he one of those people you say you are going to talk to, who has a lot of responsibility? You just said it.

President.- I talk with Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba…

Ana Pastor.- About this topic, Mr. President, has he not asked you either?

President.- I talk several times a day with Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba. Everyone can understand that, being the Minister of the Interior and First Vice President, it is normal that he is one of the people in the Government with whom I talk the most. Moreover, I must say that I talk about many other things, not just about the strict task of the Government because I have a very good relationship with him. I have great confidence in him and I believe he is a person with very uncommon political qualities. He has outstanding political qualities.

Ana Pastor.- And would he be an outstanding candidate?

President.- I have already said that we are not going to say anything about the candidate today.

But what can I think of Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba? I do not need to say much: I appointed him First Vice President of the Government. Many people… There are many other members of the Government who are also very valuable and I am glad that it is said. I appointed Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba and others as well.

Ana Pastor.- Mr. President, is the decision or not, in any case, linked to the General Secretariat of the party? That is to say, will what you announce have to do with whether or not you leave the party, or does it have nothing to do with it and that will happen later? If you stop being Secretary General, I am not saying the party.

President.- No, I am not yet in that reflection.

Ana Pastor.- You have not even entered there.

President.- No. Moreover, that will be…. The most important things, and this is an important one, regarding the candidacy for 2012 and the party, that will be…. Everything will be very quick. Just as I like to make government changes quickly, decisions like these as well; just as when I announced my candidacy for the General Secretariat, etc.

Ana Pastor .- The other day, citizens asked President Obama questions through YouTube, and one of the questions, with which we closed, was what is the best and the worst part of being President. What is the best and the worst part of being President for Rodríguez Zapatero?

Presidente .- The best part is that you can change things and people's lives. I always remember and will always remember citizens… For example, with the Gay Marriage Law, there have been many homosexual people who have approached me and thanked me: "We will never forget it, you have changed our lives, you have made us happy."

What is the worst? The worst is not being able to give a minimally satisfactory answer to someone who you know is, for example, currently unemployed and in distress, and who looks to you, legitimately, as the President of the Government. That is, without a doubt, the worst.

Now, the worst in general, as President of the Government, is when you look into the eyes of the mother of a soldier, a police officer, or a civil guard who has been killed in a terrorist attack, and her gaze is one in which, filled with pain and sometimes compassion as well, even towards the President of the Government, you discover that she looks at you as if to say: "I know that you cannot bring my son back to life." And those are very difficult moments.

Ana Pastor .- The best and the worst of being the President of the Government. What do you think could be the best and the worst of being a former President of the Government, returning to the previous topic?

Presidente .- It is true that I haven't thought much about it, but I imagine there will be a multitude of feelings. On one hand, one thing I think, and I have thought about this a few times, is how you can be useful by sharing everything you have learned, everything you know, and everything you are familiar with. How to make a transfer of data of all the background, of everything you have incorporated and everything you have learned?

Secondly, I imagine I will also have a certain sense of more tranquility when you no longer feel directly responsible for the things that happen, for the serious things, because inevitably, if you are the President of the Government, you feel responsible. You know that in many of them you are not, and in many of them citizens imagine that you are not; but you feel responsible for things. When I stop being President, I imagine that the degree of feeling of responsibility or, if you will, of guilt for the things that happen or do not happen will drop significantly.

Ana Pastor .- I thank you very much, Mr. President. I don’t know if we will have the opportunity to see you again on Televisión Española depending on that decision. I thank you very much for attending this program this morning, this program "Los Desayunos." Hopefully it will be on "Los Desayunos." Thank you very much, Mr. President.

Presidente .- I’m sure we will. Thank you very much to you all.