Press conference with the President of the Government and the German Chancellor following the Spanish-German Summit
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero addressed a joint press conference with Chancellor Merkel in Madrid on 2 February 2011, following the Spanish-German bilateral summit focused on Eurozone stability and economic reform.
- Main themes
- Euro stability and Eurozone crisis, Spanish-German bilateral relations, European competitiveness pact, economic reforms, sovereign debt crisis, stability pact, EU economic coordination, social model and welfare state, labour market adaptation, innovation and technology investment, trade union and business cooperation
- Duration
- ~36 min
- Words
- 4,316
- Sentences
- 158
- Readability
- 48
- Grade
- 13.1
- Syntax
- 3.25
- Vocabulary
- 1.97
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
158 sentences in 69 paragraphs
President of the Government .- Good afternoon. Thank you very much.
Firstly I would like to express my satisfaction at this bilateral Summit between Spain and Germany; satisfaction which above all relates to my gratitude to Chancellor Angela Merkel, to the delegation of ministers from the German Government who have participated in this Summit alongside their Spanish counterparts, and specifically to the representatives of Spanish and German business leaders and the representatives of the German trade unions and the Spanish trade unions CC.OO and UGT, as well as a significant number of chairmen of leading companies in the two countries who have contributed in a such an enriching manner to this Summit in dialogue and talks, that have taken place during lunch.
As you are aware, Spain and Germany have strong bilateral relations and a reciprocal history of sharing the European project, aspirations of prosperity and well-being, a social model and each of the main events that have forged the successful history of the European Union, the European Monetary Union and the Euro.
Europe, the situation of the Euro, has taken up a significant part of our dialogue; a dialogue that, above all, has had one fundamental objective, namely to share an idea; the idea that the Euro, the Eurozone, is the most ambitious political and economic project that Europeans have ever undertaken; that the Euro is strong, but that we are going to strengthen the single currency even further, and that this strength has to come from the task at hand, after a tough year's fight against the financial crisis and the crisis of the sovereign debt in certain countries in the Eurozone, and from two main cornerstones: the Stability Pact and the strengthening of the Stability Pact, already committed to by the European Union; and the Competitiveness Pact.
For decades, Europe has been the most competitive economic space with the highest levels of well-being, and neither Europe nor the countries of the Eurozone are going to renounce their status as the most competitive, or as among the most competitive, in this globalised world, with new very important players, nor indeed are we going to renounce prosperity.
In order to maintain these two great objectives we need to see change, reforms, innovation and adaptation to new times. This is what has always characterised Europe. To talk about Europe is to talk about innovation. In itself, the European project is a great innovative project, which unites countries and flags, and which has created a single currency for so many countries. We are a great laboratory of innovation, in other words, of creativity, of talent, of being the best.
To that end, the single currency and the countries of the single currency should know today that, if we want to maintain these possibilities, we have to do more to be competitive; we have to do more to invest in technology, in talent, in innovation, in research, and we have to adapt our financial structures, our Welfare State and our labour market so that we all concur in this objective of increased productivity that makes us more competitive.
Furthermore, we need to do this employing a common language, the European language; by spreading the common European rules, by coordinating our economic policy, by harmonising the requirements and objectives of the way the economy operates.
This is our shared objective.In this shared objective, whether during a crisis or not, the European Union and the single currency is a union of rights and obligations; a union that generates benefits and brings responsibilities.
Let me reiterate today, as I said to Chancellor Merkel, that Spain is a country of commitments, of responsibilities, which complies with its duties. To that end, we have set in motion an ambitious plan of reforms, which furthermore, as of yesterday, has the strong support of the collaboration of the reformist and innovative will of business leaders and trade unions. Or, what is the same, behind the objective that Spain aspires to, with the levels of productivity and competitiveness that we should have, among the best in Europe, behind this great objective is the Government, business leaders and the trade unions, each one making its own sacrifices and efforts. We also trust that this is supported by the majority of the political parties.
I would like to thank the Chancellor, before giving her the floor, for her support, not without its difficulties and in a tough year, for the Euro and for Europe. I am fully aware of the difficulties the Chancellor faces as the principal leader of the leading country in the European Union and the Eurozone, which Germany is. And hence our gratitude, which, by the way, we have always expressed to Germany, which is the main cornerstone on which the European Union is built - at other times there were decisive moments in which Germany played this role - our gratitude to Germany for its continued support, which is fundamental for the Euro; and we have the same level of sincerity and recognition as regards its strength in the future.
And so, Chancellor, thank you for this Summit and thanks to the business leaders and the trade unions. My assessment is that this Summit, which has awoken so much expectation, as can be seen in this press conference, is a Summit of affirmation, of confidence, of credibility and of strength in ourselves, in what we are as Europeans, in what we have been able to do for prosperity and in the conviction that we are also able to overcome difficulties through solidarity whereby each member assumes their responsibility.
Thank you very much Chancellor
Mrs. Merkel .- Ladies and gentleman, I would like, for my part, to thank the President of the Government for this warm welcome to our delegation today in Madrid, and also for the opportunity to be granted an audience with His Majesty the King, accompanied by José Luís Rodríguez Zapatero where we exchanged our opinions.
There will be a series of important visits; the German Federal President will come to Spain next week and, the King will travel to Germany in April and in fact tomorrow we will see each other in Brussels.
When we took the decision to organise this Spanish-German Summit in the middle of last December, to take place at the beginning of February, we knew that we still had to make some significant headway.
Our bilateral relations are very good and we have come here as friends today. I would also like to say that personally, for my part, great things have been done in Spain recently, great achievements have been made and major reforms have been carried out which have enabled Spain's course change positively. Much of that has been achieved with the cooperation of industry, of the trade unions, of employers' associations, which of course, also improves the level of acceptance of all the measures adopted.
I believe that these measures are not only due to political orientation, but also that they are measures that are necessary from an objective point of view. And, as the president of the Government has also stated, it is necessary to strengthen competitiveness in Europe; we are not only doing this as an objective in its own right - because we are so fond of talking about competitiveness, but rather this policy is adopted for the good of our people. We will only be able to guarantee well-being in Europe by carrying out these reforms.
Change is never easy, but the world around us is changing at a giddy speed, and the question is not whether there is solidarity in Europe or whether at the same time we are losing some of our power, but rather what is important - as a result of our solidarity and competitiveness - is that we are able to continue to be a continent in which there is competitiveness and innovation. That is what we are aiming for and working towards.
Europe is our continent of origin, we are five hundred million European citizens in total and we are able to defend our interests in the world, and we see this at many conferences. Many countries in the European Union share the same currency, the Euro, and the Euro is just that, a common currency but it is also a common political project.
I have said many times over the past few months that, if the Euro fails, Europe fails. This is about Europe and of course Germany backs the Euro. We need solidarity, but at the same time, we need the will to coordinate better and hence increase our competitiveness.
I believe we are on the right track looking at the measures overall but, of course, each one of us has to do our homework. I have said that the Spanish reforms deserve our full respect, but other European countries have also carried out reforms in the past, in the same way as Germany had to. It is not that we have fewer problems in Germany; there are areas, such as for example the important area of innovation, in which Germany is not the leader in Europe, but in fact the Scandinavian countries lead the way, but our objective has to be to be amongst the best.
I believe that today's talks have once again shown that Spain and Germany, together with all our other European partners, still have to take some important strides between now and the end of March, above all, in strengthening the Stability and Growth Pact, as well as the Competitiveness Pact. If we do this, it will be an important sign and I believe that we will then be able to say with full confidence in ourselves, as Europeans, that we have overcome a challenge we were facing as a result of the international economic and financial crisis. We have known how to overcome the challenge and we have demonstrated that we have the political will to adopt the necessary reforms.
Of course, the reforms will not take effect in two or three days. These reforms, of course, will take effect over the course of the years, but I am certain that they will take effect. And when I say "effect", I mean that jobs will be created which is just what we want to achieve.
And to achieve this, there are many steps to be taken, both in Germany and in Spain, and the fact that we can count on the trade unions is a very positive message. For that reason, today's Summit has had a new format, because it has not only been a meeting at a ministerial level, but also at a social level, of part of society, and this also helps bring this European project close to our societies.
Thanks you for your hospitality.
Q .- Madam Federal Chancellor, if I understand you correctly, in Europe or in the Eurozone, we are now on the path towards certain coordinated economic policies, or rather economic governance, which are guided, above all, by German stability criteria. Where do you want to start? Where can you count on the support of President Rodríguez Zapatero and President Sarkozy to establish the bases for this initiative at the European Council in Brussels?
Mrs. Merkel .- I relieve that Europe is a project which will always be progressive. We made great strides with the Lisbon Treaty which brought new areas of policy to within European competency; for example, the EU Common Space on Freedom, Security and Justice that we are establishing step by step.
But we shouldn't rest on our laurels following the Lisbon Treaty, nor should we sign a new treaty. We say that there is a domestic market for twenty-seven members, the European Union has competency in many matters and we have the Directives of the EU. There is no German pact on stability and growth, but rather a European Pact on Stability and Growth, which has become tougher; the corresponding Directives are currently being drawn up. If we respect these, I believe that we will be in a much more secure position than before, because in the past, let's be honest, we have had a Stability and Growth Pact, but it wasn't always respected.
We have now changed the order of things in order to have to respect them more, because we have seen where the lack of respect of the pact has led us, and this is a European project, as I said.
Many European observers are now saying, where are we heading? Because it is not enough to have a single currency, or a domestic market, or perhaps common monetary and fiscal policy.
Of course, when talking about competitiveness, investors also play a role, as do innovation, national insurance systems, unitary labour costs or the taxable base for corporate income tax, and I could give you twenty more examples. All of these fall under national competency at the moment; but when you live in an area with a single currency, we should all be prepared to react in a similar way.
Spain, France and Germany, for example, have said that we have to react to the demographic situation, and to that end, we are going to gradually increase retirement age. When you live in an area with a common monetary policy, the ideal situation would be that this were carried out by all seventeen countries, not just three, each one according to its demographics.
We are going to discuss all of these matters, not tomorrow; tomorrow we are going to talk about the principle. Then between now and March, we are going to establish the details and set some objectives. Of course, a more extensive debate is necessary. In other words, no specific measures will be taken tomorrow, but rather we will be discussing the basic principle.
Q .- I have a question for each of you. For the President of the Spanish Government, I would like to ask if you would be prepared to encourage, within the framework of the collective bargaining that will now start in Spain, the disassociation of salaries and inflation; if you would be prepared, furthermore, to establish a legal limit on the deficit, both for the State and for the autonomous regions, and if you think it would be a good idea to harmonise corporate income tax in the way just expressed by Mrs. Merkel, who believes it would be appropriate to do so.
For the Chancellor, I would like to ask her if she believes there is any risk that Spain will have to be bailed out by the European Fund at any time, if she believes that it complies with the conditions of an economic examination or that further reforms are necessary.
President of the Government .- As regards the first question, let's leave collective bargaining to itself, and to the parties, business owners and trade unions, who have already established a principle of commitment; collective bargaining which, at its core, has not been reformed for three decades but which we are now going to become very familiar with. But let's leave the parties to get on with their work; that should be the Government's role.
Secondly, we already have budgetary stability legislation at a national level and it is positive that this is also transferred to the autonomous regions. You are aware that the autonomous regions governed by the Socialist Party have undertaken to legally set a ceiling on annual expenditure and this would seem to me to be one of the steps that we must take.
I should remind you that my Government, and beyond my Government, Spain as a whole, has always been a firm defender and complier with the Stability Pact and as such, of fiscal consolidation policy. If we make a review going back to the start of the Stability Pact, we can see that Spain is one of the countries that has least been in breach. We hold up well to scrutiny and hence, the principle of budgetary stability - the principle of deficit control and the reduction of the public debt is fundamental in our system. Of course, this is fundamental for the Government of Spain, for the European Union and for the stability of the Euro.
The Government of Spain will of course always head in the direction of everything aimed at strengthening the fundamental idea of the Stability Pact and the domestic Stability Pact.
Corporate income tax. Here I believe that we should be heading towards harmonisation even as regards corporate income tax. It would seem appropriate that in certain aspects of fiscal policy, in an area that shares a single currency, that there should be harmonisation, which will certainly mean establishing new criteria, a bracket within which the tax rates may range, for example, in this case for corporate income tax.
As regards this Competitiveness Pact, Chancellor Merkel has made a note of certain lines of action, and I believe some of these are very useful and spring from common sense, such as if we share a single currency, we should also have common economic criteria and certain criteria in the core areas that affect productivity and competitiveness in a country.
Mrs. Merkel .- I don't want to comment on the things that could be possible. When we talk about a competitiveness pact, this means that those indicators that really have economic importance for competitiveness should, of course, come under this common policy.
As regards corporate income tax, Europe has been working on this for years. How can we first define the tax base and then harmonise it for corporate income tax? In other words, a tax on what? We haven't spoken about rates here, and that has been on the back burner for a long time now. I believe that we all have to accept some degree of responsibility because we all have our own corporate income tax system that we want to maintain, and Germany will also have to make some sacrifices. But what we need to do first is harmonise the tax base.
I should also remind you that, as regards VAT, we have managed to establish a tax bracket in Europe; instead of allowing there to be ten different VAT rates, there are only two. This was considered reasonable.
But let's not stop there, we should continue along this path step by step, and we have to show this beyond our borders despite being twenty-seven nations. I suppose that the vast majority seek to be members of the Eurozone. We don't follow each one with our policy but rather in order to take advantage of the Euro, we gradually need greater harmonisation, step by step, which may come through coordination between governments, policies or through European competencies. I am not talking about increased competencies, but about better coordination.
Q .- Madam Chancellor, we are seeing dramatic events unfold in Egypt. What should or must Europe do? Perhaps you have discussed this in your talks today. Will Europe speak as one?
Mrs. Merkel .- Yes, Europe will speak as one. I believe the situation is as follows: the President and the Egyptian Government have to assume responsibility so that people can demonstrate peacefully and so that there is free information emanating from Egypt, because the journalists are working under very difficult circumstances.
Secondly, the attacks on demonstrators must stop right now. The Egyptian Government is also responsible for this and those responsible for the attacks that took place yesterday and those that may take place today must be brought to justice as soon as possible.
What is important now is that Egypt begins political dialogue as soon as possible with all those who wish that those people who seek democracy and liberty are heard out.
I also spoke with the Egyptian President and asked him to begin this dialogue process. I believe we all see this in the same way; millions of Egyptians have expressed their desires in the last few days, and I believe that no-one can think that things should continue as before. Egypt needs a new start, and there must be a new path, a true transformation because, if not, these people are not going to be satisfied. I truly believe this.
Q .- Madam Chancellor, although you have indicated that tomorrow will not produce results but will rather only establish a principle, I would like to know what the key joint proposals are that Germany and France will present in the European Council tomorrow. I would like to know the fundamental content of these proposals.
Mr. President, along the same lines, against this background of the discussions on the European Monetary Stability Fund, would Spain accept new and more profound fiscal conditions and sanctions in the event of a breach.
Mrs. Merkel .- What is true is that Germany and France have been discussing this Competitiveness Pact, but of course we will speak with all parties involved. Tomorrow, during lunch, we will talk about the situation in the Eurozone with the twenty-seven members.
Furthermore, we can say that, apart from toughening up the Stability and Growth Pact, we are also going to talk about the Permanent Crisis Resolution Mechanism, which will be completed between now and the end of March. We are also going to work on the Competitiveness Pact.
Of course, I am pleased with the support received from Spain today. We will have to speak with our other partners to see if they are also in favour. The idea is that the members of the Eurozone commit to this Pact, but then we are going to open up the Pact to members which perhaps wish to join the Euro next year. We don't want to remain isolated, we want to give them the opportunity to participate in this.
The true objectives will be discussed with the affected countries and, of course, tomorrow we will speak about the principle, as I already mentioned. I hope we will receive unanimous support for this principle. We will present the content of our work on a pact of this nature at the European Council of the twenty-seven in March.
Of course, we first need coordination at the heart of the Eurogroup and then this invitation can be expressed to our other partners. And between now and the European Council in March it will be clear who does what.
I believe that what is important is to avoid a five-year debate on the matter, and set some clear and realistic objectives now for the year ahead, and we can then report on them, because this underlines the political will. It is clear that there will be more harmonisation.
President of the Government .- As regards fiscal conditions, there is no forecast for setting any fiscal conditions and, consequently, no position on any possible sanctions. We are faced with a process in which the countries have committed to a reduction of the public deficit. Spain is complying with this reduction of the public deficit, as is well-known; we continue to comply with it and there will be no further news in this respect.
Q .- Madam Chancellor, I would like to go back to an earlier question. Please clarify whether you rule out any possible bailout of Spain.
I also wanted to ask whether the reforms that our Government has undertaken on the financial system, specifically regarding the savings banks, make them more attractive as regards German banks investing in them.
And for the President of the Government, if you will allow me, I wanted your opinion on what is happening in Egypt, because you, together with some other European leaders, have signed a document supporting the democratic movements. I would like to know whether you believe, you specifically, that President Mubarak should abandon power now.
Mrs. Merkel .- Yes, exactly, I haven't answered that question. Spain has really done its homework and that's why I believe that Spain is on the right track. When the President of the Government also speaks about these matters, I am sure this will also give a good impression. The path Spain has set out on is very positive. It is really very satisfying that this has not taken place in conflict with the trade unions, the employers' associations and, in part, with the opposition party; this creates great confidence in the future. That's why I believe that Spain is truly on the right track and I believe that there is no need for any type of speculation.
Furthermore, I relieve that, in general, all these speculations and so much talk is really neither positive nor useful. I believe that each one has to do its homework, and in the case of Spain, I say that with all my conviction, the markets will take note of this, with a great deal of interest, and moreover, they will approve of it.
President of the Government .- As regards Egypt, I agree with the position of the Chancellor and with the position of the European leaders. Furthermore, when this aspiration is expressed so forcefully, with such majority support from the people, it makes it more urgent still.
Furthermore, we want democracy to come peacefully and with consensus. That obligation falls on the Government of Egypt: to know which conditions have to be complied with for a national agreement that avoids internal conflict and that opens the door to democracy in all its facets. This responsibility lies with President Mubarak and his government, according to the internal circumstances and the position of the opposition and the different people's movements.
Any other consideration could be interpreted - and not exactly a favourable one, and even a counterproductive one - as a type of interference. But we want democracy to come quickly in Egypt through a process of agreement, of consensus, and peacefully. Democracy can arrive in this way, which is something we understand very well in Spain.
Thank you very much.