Interviews given by the President of the Government to the German media (press) on 2 February 2011
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero addressed German media correspondents on 1 February 2011 ahead of a summit with Chancellor Merkel and an EU Council meeting, discussing Spain's reforms and European integration.
- Main themes
- European economic integration, Spain's economic reforms, German leadership in the Eurozone, Eurozone debt crisis, pension system reform, labour market flexibility, confidence in Portugal and Greece, euro stability, unemployment and growth, Egypt and North Africa unrest, Spanish-German bilateral relations, bailout fund debate
- Duration
- ~36 min
- Words
- 4,326
- Sentences
- 224
- Readability
- 49
- Grade
- 11.2
- Syntax
- 2.97
- Vocabulary
- 2.27
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other224 sentences in 75 paragraphs
The President of the Government in Spain calls for a leading role by Germany in European integration.
In the words of José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero, the Socialist Party President of the Government, Spain is "strong, solvent and doing its homework". During a conversation with German correspondents on the eve of the signing of a "great social pact" with the trade unions on Wednesday to increase the retirement age and a meeting with the German Chancellor Angela Merkel on Thursday in Madrid, Zapatero also called for confidence in Portugal and Greece. Merkel's visit is expected to be a direct boost for stronger EU economic integration. He has announced he was "very concerned" about the situation in Egypt and possible subsequent turmoil in the neighbouring states of North Africa: "We have to activate all the alarm systems."
With respect to the financial crisis, Zapatero called the meeting with the Chancellor on the eve of the European Council meeting on Friday "one of the most important Spanish-German summits of recent years," because "Spain should contribute with its firm commitment and responsibility to the tasks still pending in the European project. At the same time, Germany should confirm its commitment to Europe and the Eurozone. For me this means that Germany should take another step forward in economic integration. We want Germany to assume the leading role that it must take in Europe. We do not want Germany to only play in defence, but also in an offensive midfield position."
In this "symbolic week", Zapatero praised the agreement with trade unions and employers on the reform of the pension system and announced further steps to make the labour market more flexible and ensure progress in energy and industrial policy, following the example of the "2010 Agenda" of the former Social-Democrat Chancellor, Gerhard Schröder. This will ensure a decisive increase in confidence of the international financial markets in Spain and in its competitiveness over the next two years. The reforms will form the basis for renewed growth and a reduction in unemployment (currently at 20.3%).
On the question of whether he believes that Greece will emerge from its debt crisis, that Portugal will resolve its problems without the "bailout fund" and whether Spain will be capable of avoiding the danger of contagion, Zapatero said: "I am confident about Portugal. It is still too soon to talk about the future of Greece. But in any event, we should give a vote of confidence to the Greek government, which won the elections in particularly difficult circumstances and took over power. We will see whether the country can remain on its feet by itself with the assistance it has received. If not, we will increase it. Spain is strong, solvent and doing its homework by introducing reforms to recover its economy."
In the long term, the stability of the Euro, which according to Zapatero "will survive and will always be stable," depends above all on the harmonisation of European economic policy in all the main areas: taxes, the labour market and pension systems. This is more important than all the debates about the extension of the bailout mechanism, which he does not consider necessary because Spain can overcome its difficulties by itself. In response to the point that two-thirds of Germans oppose extending the fund and in general contributing any more payments to countries in crisis, the President of the Government commented: "Spain is also helping Greece and Ireland. Germany contributes a fifth or a quarter while Spain contributes 12%, which corresponds to the size of our country. I understand the debate in Germany whereby it appears that Germans are paying for everything. But they are only paying the amount that corresponds to them."
Despite the guarded forecasts for this year, Zapatero appeared optimistic regarding the question of future growth and employment. According to him, they will come from exports, which will enjoy "double digit" growth, "with food leading the way, and through sectors such as financial services, telecommunications and renewable energies, in which we are as competitive as Germany; and naturally through tourism as well. The construction sector has taken up an excessive proportion of the GDP. In ten years we have constructed as many homes as we should have done in twenty. Some 70% of the unemployed come from the construction sector. In short, everything can be explained by the property bubble."
Zapatero avoided the question of whether he will stand as a candidate in 2012 and only stated that "It will depend on convictions, not on circumstances." He was optimistic with respect to the prospects for the Socialist party, which could be punished in the upcoming regional and local elections in May: "The party is very strong in Spain. It demonstrated this at the period of democratic transition and it is the party that has governed longest in Spain by far. When I first made my bid for government, I also won with a majority of a million votes against the Popular Party, which was in government and had an absolute majority.
Zapatero is paying close attention to developments in neighbouring North Africa, including the uprising in Egypt. He does not rule out economic consequences for Spain and Europe (the oil price), and considers it "desirable that the international community and the EU should take up a firm position in favour of democratic reforms" in the Arab world. The support for "peaceful reforms" should be accompanied by a willingness to provide economic support. "This is the fundamental problem that has led to this situation," he explained. "The danger is that these countries can now be dragged into an even more serious economic position. It is therefore urgent for the EU, the United States and the Gulf States, at least, to evaluate the possible consequences. We have to activate all the alarm systems."
Zapatero rejects the impression that has been extended above all by some Spanish media that the German Chancellor is coming to Madrid as a "boss" who will submit him to an "examination on the reforms". This is "absolutely" not the case. He also does not feel under pressure from Berlin in any way. "I have always informed the Chancellor about what we are doing, to ensure that she maintains her confidence in us. Just as I do with Misters Sarkozy, Barroso, van Rompuy and Trichet."
ZAPATERO WANTS A "MORE GERMAN" EUROPE
Interview with the President of the Government, José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero. J AVIER CÁCERES. Süddeutsche Zeitung, Germany, 2/2/2011
On the eve of Angela Merkel's visit, the President of the Government of Spain is calling on Berlin to play a role in the vanguard to overcome the crisis of the Euro.
"The boss is coming!" announce the Spanish media before German Chancellor Angela Merkel's visit tomorrow on Thursday to Madrid. On mentioning this to her host, José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero, the Socialist President of the Government, answers with a smile. In a conversation with representatives of four German dailies in La Moncloa, Zapatero insists that he "absolutely" does not see the Chancellor as a "boss". Anyone who sees "Germany in the role of a demanding teacher" and German-Spanish relations as the "relationship between an examiner and a pupil" has a "very superficial" vision. However, Germany must assume the role of captain in Europe, it must wear the number 10 shirt. "We do not want Germany only to play in defence, but rather in an attacking midfield position", he said.
"Berlin must harmonise fiscal and social policy even more."
Zapatero believes that government consultations with Germany are "perhaps the most important German-Spanish summit" in recent years. According to Zapatero, Merkel is visiting Spain in "a very symbolic week". Spain has initiated reforms in the financial sector and in pensions; previously, the Zapatero government had already remodelled the labour market and consolidated the budget. Had he waited too long?
"I have asked myself that question," he said, and refers to a conversation he had on Monday with the former Chairman of the Federal Reserve, the economist and Obama advisor Paul Volcker. "With the experience of five crises, he told me that reforms are always undertaken, for better or for worse, when they become urgent."
"We have to make reforms," stresses Zapatero and mentions, among other things, collective bargaining, which has remained untouched for 30 years. The reforms pending are not as substantial as those already undertaken, but they are still important. Meanwhile, "Germany must ratify its commitment to Europe and the Eurozone by taking a further step towards harmonisation of fiscal and social policy." This is "even more important than the bailout mechanisms" created by Europe to combat the crisis. It is also more important than the extension to the bailout fund, currently at 440 billion euros. "The implementation of harmonisation would generate more confidence in the financial markets" than any "debate on flexibility, rigidity or the size of the fund".
Zapatero has no problem with a "more German" Europe. "It does not bother us, provided that we have a European Germany."
Zapatero was understanding about the fact that Germans are concerned about having to pay the costs of the European debt crisis.
All the heads of government in the Eurozone are aware of the public debate in Germany. "In fact, we even know the dates of the elections in the Länder," says the Spanish Socialist, referring to the possible strategy by the Federal Government. At the same time he asks the Germans to qualify their view of the situation.
First, Spain (as corresponds to its size) has also made money available for Greece and Ireland: "We all assume responsibility in the current situation." Second, we should not forget that Germany benefits from the lending market in the sense that Berlin can finance its public sector relatively cheaply because interest rates are low. German bonds have become a safe haven for investors, says Zapatero, who stresses expressly that this does not mean that Germany is benefiting from the crisis.
Zapatero also points out that Germany is Spain's biggest import partner. "It is clear that Germany contributes a great deal. But Europe also buys a lot from Germany. The point is that there should be a balance, that everyone should win." If we try to apply addition and subtraction, we suck the soul from the European project."
Following the reforms, Zapatero also sees Spain on the path to recovery. Unemployment is still at 20 per cent and growth is weak. "The key is to increase productivity," he says. What is not taken into account is that in many sectors Spain is actually as productive or even more so than the EU average: the financial sector, telecommunications, renewable energies, tourism. The bursting of the property bubble, responsible for 70 per cent of the new jobless, continues to weigh heavily: "Without the construction sector, the Spanish economy would have grown by 1.6 per cent in 2010."
The notable spread at which Spain has had to pay its bonds has therefore not been the result of fundamentals in Spain. It is rather a case of Spain suffering due to the problems of other States such as Greece or Ireland.
"Spain is strong, Spain is solvent and Spain is doing its homework to ensure that its economy is more competitive in the shortest possible time," says Zapatero. And Spain is not in favour of a more flexible bailout fund "because we believe that we can finance ourselves."
It is still too early to talk about the prospects for Greece, but Zapatero is convinced that "if we have to increase aid, we will do so." He is "extremely confident" about Portugal. In general he shows an almost excessive optimism about the future: "The Euro is surviving and will always survive."
"GERMANY SHOULD NOT PLAY DEFENSIVELY"
Interview with the President of the Government, José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero by ANNE GRÜTTNER. Handelsblatt, Germany 2/02/11
The President of the Spanish Government is convinced that without closer coordination of economic policy, the rescue of the Euro will be in vain. Anne Grüttner talked with José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero. The Chancellor is travelling to Madrid on Thursday to the German-Spanish summit.
Q .- How can Spain and Germany contain the debt crisis?
This summit is probably the most important one between Spain and Germany in many years. Spain now has to increase its productivity and competitiveness with the measures it is applying. Germany has to make more concessions in economic integration, harmonisation of fiscal policy, the labour market and the retirement age. The summit could lead to decisive progress in this respect. We do not want Germany to only play defensively, but also in an offensive midfield position. Currently there are three decisive countries: Germany, France and Spain. If Spain does its homework, Germany and France have to push for a more perfect economic union.
With a view to the rescue of the Euro, most Germans would probably not say that they have played in defence, but that it has been expensive for them.
All the countries are helping Ireland and Greece. Germany assumes 20 per cent, Spain 12 per cent, as corresponds to the economic power of each country. In addition, Germany benefits from this crisis: it receives finance at very low cost, given that its government borrowing is currently a safe haven for investment, which is naturally the result of sound productivity and the strength of German exports.
Q .- Do you consider that sometimes in the debate about the Euro there are comments with a certain tone of arrogance?
No, what happens is that a lot has to be explained: How big our debt really is, where our risks are, what reforms we are carrying out - and in fact, the reforms are similar to those of the 2010 Agenda in Germany.
Q .- So is Europe becoming increasingly German in its economic policy if the reforms are carried out according to the German model?
That does not bother us, provided that we have a European Germany. But it is a question of cycles. Just like the German economy had problems at the start of the 1990s, carried out its reforms and is now extremely competitive, tomorrow France or another country could have problems. The best antidote is to strengthen the Stability Pact and complete the pact for competitiveness. The Euro is supported by joint monetary policy, but there is a pillar still missing: we have to converge in our policy on competitiveness. This is just as important, or even more so, than the rescue mechanism.
Q .- Do you believe that Greece can pay its debts and that Portugal will emerge from the crisis by itself?
I am confident about Portugal, it has reduced its deficit quickly and its financial system is in a relatively good position. It is too early to talk about the future of Greece, but I am convinced that the EU, the countries in the Eurogroup, will provide more aid for Greece if necessary.
Q .- I there still danger of contagion for Spain?
Spain is strong, Spain is solvent and it is doing its homework. It is carrying out reforms to ensure that its economy recovers and is more competitive as soon as possible.
Q .- How far have you gone so far in your reform agenda?
We have reformed the financial system, implemented measures for budget consolidation and the Services Directive, as well as agreeing a reform of the labour market and energy reform. Now we have just reached an agreement with the trade unions and employers to raise the retirement age to 67, and to increase the calculation period for pensions by ten years, from fifteen to twenty-five years. This is the most profound reform of the pension system ever undertaken in Spain - and it has the approval of the trade unions, unlike the German pension reform, which we have in fact studied in detail.
Q .- Where will future economic growth in Spain come from?
From exports, which are growing at double-digit rates. In financial services, the telecommunications sector, renewable energies, and of course tourism, we are more productive than the European average.
Q .- The U.S. economy grew more last year than expected. Does this mean that the policy of making savings in expenditure, for example in Spain, has probably been a mistake?
If the markets had not experienced the turmoil they did, we would certainly not have had to make such a radical adjustment. But the U.S. has a great debt problem that is beginning to concern many analysts.
Q .- Various options are being debated to reduce the Greek debt burden, such as for example its restructuring, or for Greece to repurchase its debt on the market. Which do you prefer?
We have to be very cautious, above all when the issues are so sensitive. We've already seen that, haven't we? The very word "restructuring" already sets off heated reactions, If something has to happen, it should be the result of an agreement, a debate at the European Council. We need more European government, fewer dissenting voices and swifter decisions. The prime ministers cannot all be contributing to generating confusion.
Q .- Has Germany made mistakes in the crisis?
At the moment of truth, Germany has always been where it should be. The crisis was not only a new situation for Germany, but for us all. Who would have thought two and a half years ago that it would have had to lend money to one of us? There was no protocol for this crisis. The word of Germany and France was always key, but we have all had to yield at some time. However, all the prime ministers know the public opinion in Germany very well, and we all know when the elections in the German federal states are being held.
Q .- According to surveys, most Germans are against making the bailout mechanism for the Euro more flexible. What is your opinion?
We believe that we can finance ourselves. But I understand that Germans equate more flexibility with more money. It is interesting that in Spain this is not an issue, although we have paid proportionally the same amount of money to Greece and Ireland as Germany, even though we are in a difficult budget situation.
Germany has contributed a great deal to the EU structural funds, but Europe buys a lot from Germany; there is a balance. If we begin to calculate separately, we will suck the soul from the European project. We cannot maintain the process of economic integration if we only look at who wins and who loses. We must see that the common market, which has to be continuously extended, favours everyone, and that whoever works and produces better gains positions.
Q .- Should the bailout fund be increased or should it perhaps have a ceiling?
Before concerning ourselves with the fund we have to lay the foundations for the competitiveness pact.
The very fact that the project is being pushed forward and that the big countries: Germany, France, Spain and Italy back it fully will generate greater confidence in the markets than the whole debate on the flexibility or the size of the bailout fund. On Thursday I will be talk about this issue with Angela Merkel.
Information box
A party stalwart. A graduate in Law, José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero, now, 50 years old, joined the PSOE party when he was 19. In 1988, he became the youngest ever member of the Spanish Parliament. In the summer of 2000 he was appointed Secretary General of the PSOE party after his predecessor, Joaquín Almunia, suffered a serious defeat in the elections.
He became President of the Government in 2004, when just after the terrorist attack in Madrid, the PSOE achieved an absolute majority. One of the first measures he took as President of the Government was to withdraw Spanish troops from Iraq. In 2008, he was re-elected, but lost his absolute majority. His critics accuse him of having underestimated the economic crisis for a long time. At the worst moment of the debt crisis in the EU, in May 2010, he began to implement a wide-ranging reform agenda.
ZAPATERO AIMING TO DRAW CLOSER TO MERKEL
STEFANIE BOLZEN. Die Welt, Germany 2/02/11
The President of the Spanish Government is promoting a coordinated economic policy; the Chancellor wants the same
Spain does not consider the rescue mechanism for the Euro as the most important measure to emerge from the crisis. The President of the Government, José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero, is more committed to the extension of a coordinated economic policy. "Before talking about extending the bailout mechanism or making it more flexible, we should create the foundations for the planned pact for greater competitiveness," said Zapatero in a conversation with the German media in which Die Welt took part.
On Thursday, Zapatero will meet the German Chancellor Angela Merkel (CDU) in Madrid for Spanish-German consultations. "The priority is the major steps taken in the direction of harmonisation and economic convergence for the Eurozone countries; harmonisation of fiscal policy, the labour market, pension policy: that is what is important," says Zapatero.
The fact that the big Euro countries such as Germany, France and Spain want to join this project, that "they declare themselves decidedly in favour of it, will be a means for instilling confidence in the markets, in both the medium and long term, and this will be more powerful than all the debates on increasing the flexibility and size of the bailout mechanism." At the start of 2010, Zapatero proposed the implementation of a "European economic government" as a solution to the crisis, but he no longer uses this term. Nevertheless, he energetically promotes his ideas of an economic policy coordinated between the Member States of the EU and wants to put it at the core of his meeting with Merkel. He will find the doors open.
The Chancellor's office itself has formulated a draft for an agreement between the States in the Eurozone, which includes "specific commitments to improve competitiveness". The Finance Minister Wolfgang Schäuble (CDU) is also in favour of specific coordination of economic and social policy in favour of greater competitiveness, which is above all lacking in the problematic southern countries in the Union. These measures, together with the toughening of the Stability Pact and the remodelling of the bailout mechanism, should be part of a "complete package" for the Heads of State and Government of the EU to agree at their summit at the end of March at the latest.
Spain is considered a determining factor for the success or failure of the common currency. As the fourth largest economy in the EU, it would have disastrous consequences for the Euro if the country depended on financial aid. Zapatero rejects any speculation in this respect. "We have not made any proposal to make the bailout mechanism more flexible because we believe that we can finance ourselves." At the same time he insists on his "great confidence in Portugal", which is considered a candidate in difficulties.
Zapatero bases his optimism on the "swift reduction of the deficit and the sound situation of the financial system."
The Socialist head of government, who has been in office since 2004, accused Germany of a lack of composure. "We do not want Germany to only play in defence, but also in an offensive midfield position." In the past, this is how Germany has grown and has won esteem, and this will also happen with the EU. Crises determine development. Either we take a step backwards in exhaustion or we take a step forward," says Zapatero, who was critical of the debate on the Euro in Germany. "All the countries have helped Ireland and Greece, not only Germany. Spain contributed 12 per cent of aid." In addition, the German government will benefit from the crisis, given that "the costs of financing are currently very low." Zapatero even suggested there could be an additional provision in terms of payment: "If Europe has to increase aid for Greece, we will do so."
With respect to the initiative of attracting qualified Spanish unemployed workers to Germany, Zapatero indicated the fact that the same number of Germans work in Spain as vice versa: about 40,000. Even so, the Spanish media have reported on the queues at the Goethe Institutes, and of a significant increase in people enrolling on German courses. Surveys demonstrate that Germany is held in high esteem by Spanish people. Merkel has recently been chosen as the most popular international leader; the German press call her "the boss".
Zapatero has stressed that he does not feel "absolutely any pressure from Germany." The two have always maintained a sincere dialogue. "This is not a dialogue between an examiner and student, but between allies."
Zapatero, whose popularity has for some time been at rock bottom, once more appears to be showing political self-confidence, probably as a result of the reforms introduced in recent days and weeks. "We are now carrying out in Spain many of the things on the 2010 Agenda introduced by Chancellor Schröder to gain productivity and competitiveness. The difference is that we are doing it over two years, with an intensity of reforms that has been unknown until now, given that the crisis has affected us very seriously." The Government has raised the retirement age to 67. Additional reforms will be undertaken shortly in the labour market; these are certainly necessary: the rate of unemployment reached an all-time high in January of 20.3 per cent.
Given the demands of Berlin that the bailout of affected States in the Eurozone has to be linked to major reforms and measures to make savings in the countries affected, Zapatero has declared: "If we see a Germanisation of Europe, we have no problem with that, as long as we also see a European Germany." Spain is strong and solvent and is doing its homework. "It was the crises in other countries which made our risk premiums shoot up."