Press conference by the President of the Government after the meeting of the European Council

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

3 February 2011 · European Council (extraordinary meeting), press conference after the meeting

Context
Zapatero addressed press after an extraordinary European Council meeting on 3 February 2011, covering energy, innovation, economic governance, and the situation in Egypt.
Main themes
European Council meeting, energy policy and market integration, economic governance and stability pact, innovation and research, eurozone competitiveness and convergence, situation in Egypt and Tunisia, freedom of information, SME financing, Digital Single Market, fiscal adjustment
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,856
73rd percentile
Sentences
76
50th percentile
Readability
29
14th percentile
Grade
18.2
94th percentile
Syntax
3.56
96th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
43rd percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

76 sentences in 36 paragraphs

President of the Government .- Good afternoon. As you are aware, in this extraordinary European Council that we have just concluded, we have principally tackled aspects relating to energy policy, innovation and the economic governance of the European Union; to give a new boost to this objective comprising the common governance of the European Union. The Council has also discussed the situation in Egypt and in Tunisia, in particular the situation in Egypt, which, as you know, is a country currently going through times of great turmoil.

The European Council has unanimously approved a statement on Egypt, in which it firstly condemns outright any violence used or propagated and furthermore appeals for a process of transition to democracy, which should take place in as ordered a manner as possible, with maximum political participation, in peace and in liberty, and in particular, guaranteeing the right to information, the freedom of information, which is undoubtedly the key to all liberties and to true democracy. To that end, I especially wish to condemn all forms of aggression and intimidation against journalists, both Egyptian journalists and foreign journalists who are carrying out their work to provide information.

As regards the specific matters that this Council was convened to tackle, there are two fundamental matters that I would like to highlight, regarding the debate and the conclusions on the matter of energy.

The first is that, for Spain, the priority is to attain the greatest and most effective integration and interconnection of the domestic energy market, to which end it is essential to develop improved energy infrastructures. To achieve that, we have appealed for full support for the interconnection projects that have been identified by the European Commission. A date has been fixed; 2015, to put an end to the energy isolation of certain Member States.

Furthermore, we have dealt with the matter of innovation at this Council, which is undoubtedly the fundamental driving force behind economic growth, and clearly the fundamental base for improving productivity and hence, competitiveness in a global economy. As you are aware, within the 2020 Strategy, a date has been fixed; 2014, which is decisive for concluding the creation of a new single area at the heart of the EU, the Single European Research Area, in order to eliminate all the barriers that still exist for the mobility of students and researchers. And before the end of 2015, we have also proposed the creation of a Digital Single Market for one of the sectors that undoubtedly generates most innovation and hence is decisive for this European perspective.

A fundamental question when talking about innovation is financing; financing that needs to count on growing public support which in turn should help encourage and mobilise private capital to finance innovation, which must get to SMEs and those innovation companies that are growing rapidly. We are going through a period of fiscal adjustment and deficit reduction but, within the budgetary priorities to maintain an emphasis on financing, on driving public investment, innovation must be prioritised as far as possible. It has to be an area that without any doubt remains unencumbered by budgetary restrictions and the essential fiscal adjustments that exist in these times.

As regards economic governance, the European Council has started the debate on an agreement, a stability pact; I say 'started' because we are still in the initial phase. The objective of the Stability Pact is to achieve better coordination and greater convergence of the economies, particularly in the Eurozone, and in its competitiveness because, as we have asserted on more than one occasion and this is a widely shared concept, in order to guarantee the strength of the Euro - the single currency - and the financial system of the Euro, this requires a converged economy and requires the economies of the Eurozone to be competitive and that they have, I insist, a high degree of coordination and convergence against this background of competitiveness.

You should not be surprised that this new phase in the construction of economic governance, which will undoubtedly culminate in greater convergence in competitiveness and better coordination, is firmly supported by the Government of Spain. It was not for nothing that the Spanish Presidency of the vigorously proposed, defended and expounded greater economic integration and greater economic coordination, primarily of the Eurozone but also of the whole of the European Union, with greater demands on compliance with the objectives proposed by the EU and the Eurozone, even to the extent of imposing sanctions, as you will recall. I remember this well because I received a deluge of criticism, but it now seems that this idea is becoming accepted and hence, it is only logical that Spain stands firmly behind this.

The fundamental step, the first step, should be taken by the Eurozone, and will be taken by the Eurozone in March in a Summit of the Heads of State and Prime Ministers of the Eurozone, where we will tackle this objective of the Competitiveness Pact and better coordination and increased convergence of our economies. The month of March will be, as a result of a decision taken today, a hugely transcendental month, of historic proportions, as a certain Head of State stated, for Europe and the Eurozone; we will also tackle the support mechanism of the Eurozone, the mechanism already in force today, the definitive mechanism to adapt it, after the experience we have gone through since it has been in force, and introduce the necessary flexibility to this European facility that contributes to the fundamental objective of financial stabilisation.

In short, we have taken an important step today, we have opened the door, and the decisive step will be taken in March, at the European Council and at the meeting of the leaders of the Eurogroup, where the main topic will be the economic convergence of Eurozone countries, together with the flexibility and strengthening of the Financial Stability Mechanism of the Eurozone.

Beyond that, although it was not specifically on today's agenda, but everyone can appreciate that the economic situation, the situation of the stability of the Eurozone and the situation of the difficulties of sovereign debt were also analysed by the members of the European Council, the Presidents of Government and the Heads of State. The assessment made by the Council, and that the main European institutions have transmitted, is that things are improving and that the situation is more stable, but we still have a lot of work ahead of us to overcome the most serious difficulties regarding the sovereign debt of the Eurozone countries, and hence regarding our financial stability.

It is true that in recent days we have seen that there is a process in which the debt differentials have relaxed somewhat, but I should state that the Government is not going to let up and that the Government is going to firmly and decisively continue with its programme of structural reforms and strict commitments to fiscal consolidation.

Considering the time I think it would be more interesting to move on directly to a round of questions.

Q .- Mr. President, I have some questions about the Competitiveness Pact. I would like to know if you consider that your Government will have to take any additional measures between now and the end of the year to comply with this Competitiveness Pact; if you have calculated, for example, whether the fact of harmonising Corporate Income Tax will mean raising or lowering it in Spain, or whether your Government would be prepared to recommend to the social stakeholders not to include the clauses on salary revisions. Although this negotiation is in their hands, could the Government recommend this or not?

President of the Government .- I know that it is inevitable. We are still at an initial phase, as I said, of the debate on the Competitiveness Pact. Various ideas have been put on the table over the course of the last few days and weeks regarding retirement which affect fiscal harmonisation and the labour market, and these will be debated before the President of the Council. The President of the Council will organise a consultation process on all these issues and the positions of the various governments.

What I can reveal, because progress has been made in the debate, is that the positions are quite disperse, quite different, at the heart of the Council, which is fairly normal in matters of this magnitude, because the socio-economic and structural characteristics of each EU country are quite different.

As regards your question about Corporate Income Tax, what has been discussed to date, rather than the tax rate, is how to reach greater homogeneity in the taxable bases. Let's say that this is the route being taken at present, this has been the subject of debate and the subject of various speeches at the Council.

Secondly, regarding the debate, a debate which I also believe is a little premature, on collective bargaining, clauses of the agreement, inflation, salaries and productivity, various different positions have also been adopted in the speeches I have heard today at the Council. I will inform you of the position of the Government: the Government's position is to defend collective bargaining. I believe that Spain has been making progress for years, improving the ability of salaries to adapt to economic circumstances, because we have moved from what was past inflation to forecast inflation, and in many cases, as we are aware, through agreement with business leaders and trade unions, we have achieved - and we have just seen an example of this - salary moderation.

In conclusion, I express my confidence in the business leaders and trade unions in their endeavours to reach an agreement and the debate doesn't only need to be about the evolution of inflation and salaries. Circumstances affect this and what is important in the evolution of salaries in a country is that they are flexible enough to be adapted to changing circumstances. That is what is really important, provided that productivity is increased, because the indication of the capacity to improve salaries is undoubtedly that the productivity of a country functions and improves.

It is a question of us adapting to each circumstance and the experience of the collective bargaining model that I defend - by the way, like many Prime Ministers and as is in effect the case in the majority of EU countries - must be to search for formulas, and they do exist, that are sufficiently flexible and maintain the purchasing power of the worker to a maximum. A rigid model is a bad model, an inefficient model, which in the end, if it doesn't have this flexibility, results in the majority of the adjustments in a time of crisis meaning the loss of jobs.

Q .- I wanted to ask you whether in the meeting you will have on Monday with the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia, Artur Más, you are going to authorise the Catalan Government to issue debt.

President of the Government .- I should stress that this is not a political decision, but rather it is a decision that has to have an economic-financial base in the forecasts and commitments that the Regional Government acquired to reduce and contain the deficit.

We are favourably predisposed to the Regional Government having reasonable financing, but, as tends to happen in these situations, there must be a joint responsibility on the part of the Regional Government that is clear and well defined regarding the deficit reduction, and specific, strict and short-term commitments.

But I hope that we can establish these bases and that then, technically at the level of the Ministry of Economic Affairs, a reasonable understanding can be reached which certainly should have a progressive outlook time-wise according to how the financial circumstances of the Regional Government itself develop. Q .- You said yesterday, in response to the proposal from Germany to include a limit on public expenditure and sovereign debt in the Constitution, that Spain already has a Budgetary Stability Act in force. I wanted to ask you whether the Government would be prepared to go beyond that in some other type of regulation, perhaps without modifying the Constitution, perhaps by means of a Ley Orgánica [Constitutional Law] so that, let's say, there is a framework that not only affects Central Government, but also the Autonomous Regions.

Another matter that was the subject of debate yesterday was the restructuring of the savings banks. The latter have been critical that they are subject to stricter demands than the banks as regards their capital for maximum solvency which leaves them in a weaker position. I would like to know your opinion of these criticisms and whether the Government has taken a decision in that respect.

President of the Government .- It is clear that if they do not go public then this is itself is an advantage and hence, it is logical that higher levels of solvency should be required of them, but I should say that I haven't heard any criticisms in this respect. The majority of well-founded opinions see these levels that are demanded as reasonable.

As regards budgetary stability, we have a Budgetary Stability Act which I believe is well founded in general and which affects all public authorities. There has been a political commitment by the Socialist-run Autonomous Regions that I would like to see extended to all the Autonomous Regions, to establish a legal expenditure ceiling each year for the Autonomous Regions. And I believe this is an important step forward.

If you ask me whether I am prepared to take further steps in our legal system to strengthen budgetary stability, to control the deficit, then I would answer yes. This will undoubtedly be the subject of debate, in this case internally, because I sincerely believe that it will not be a question that occupies a central role in the European debate; but internally it may and indeed should be a question that is subject to debate and on which, logically, it would be very positive to reach an agreement with the main opposition party which, by the way, on just this question has expressed a favourable position, on more than one occasion, regarding maximum control, from a legal perspective, of the public deficit.

Q .- Still on the subject of greater responsibility from the Autonomous Regions, would you be prepared to promulgate a law that placed limits on the general level of public expenditure and public debt of the Autonomous Regions? Is this the proposal that you are considering?

President of the Government .- The Autonomous Regions have a margin of political and financial autonomy, and we are faced with a question of great political magnitude where the crux of the initiative should lie with the Autonomous Regions. That is what we are fostering because it would undoubtedly be more useful if it stemmed from a political decision and from the political will of all the public authorities. The Government is fostering it, and it will, of course, support those that promote it, and I have just mentioned that the Socialist-run Autonomous Regions are prepared to take significant steps forward in this matter.

Q .- We know that you would be prepared to adopt legislative changes as a symbolic measure regarding what is on the table; but I would like to know if there are any further ideas that interest you in this Competitiveness Pact that you have been discussing, since you say that the Government firmly supports it. What could be interesting for Spain, which is one of the countries that suffers from this problem of the lack of convergence?

President of the Government .- I relieve that there are two main issues that affect us: one is in regard to everything to do with education and Professional Training, which will be included because it is undoubtedly where Spain has to act more quickly to gain time on the matter of convergence; the other is in regard to innovation.

These are the two core issues where our country has a differential gap in investment, principally in investment in what is private R&D, and we have to strive for innovation to also be an element in which convergence can be attained. There are many countries that invest around 3% of public expenditure in R&D+i as an essential threshold in order to achieve true innovation. Perhaps we will have to reach an agreement in Spain to attain this 3% fostered by the European Union and by the Competitiveness Pact. This is an important political decision because it means that other budgetary items of all the public authorities would need to be reduced in order to earmark a large part of public expenditure for innovation.

These are the two core issues.

There is no doubt that everything that affects our ageing population, which will also be on the agenda in the debate on this Pact, and is important as regards fiscal policies; but what is most important for Spain is not the taxable bases of Corporate Income Tax but rather everything related to professional training and innovation.

Thank you very much.