Opening session of the International Colloquium for the universal abolition of death penalty

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

8 December 2009

Context
Zapatero addressed an international colloquium in Spain on December 8, 2009, advocating for universal abolition of the death penalty, coinciding with the 61st anniversary of the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Main themes
Universal abolition of death penalty, human rights, Spain's foreign policy commitment, UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights anniversary, international cooperation, fight against terrorism, kidnapping of Spanish citizens, dialogue and peaceful conflict resolution, global human rights values, non-intervention vs. human rights tension
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,842
84th percentile
Sentences
114
69th percentile
Readability
34
23rd percentile
Grade
16.7
87th percentile
Syntax
3.44
91st percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
32nd percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 39%39%
  • Geopolitical 21%21%
  • Institutional 19%19%
  • Ceremonial 18%18%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

114 sentences in 61 paragraphs

President of the Republic of Benin; Director General of the Centre for Political and Constitutional Studies; Ms. Simone Rozès, Honorific President of the International Society for Social Defence; Judicial and Academic authorities; representatives of the non-governmental organisations; Minister; Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration; ladies and gentlemen,

I would like to express, in the first place, my gratitude for having been invited to take part in the opening session of this debate for the universal abolition of Death Penalty, organised by the Centre for Political and Constitutional studies and by the Institute on European Criminal Law of the University Castile-La Mancha.

I am grateful, mainly, because I have been given the chance to confirm one of the most beloved compromises of the foreign action of my Government: the achievement of the universal deferment of death penalty by 2015, which will be the first step before we attain the definitive universal abolition. I am also grateful because I am here, before you, Spanish, European and Latin American experts, and also experts from other continents, who, during three days, will talk and exchange points of view on this common goal, which I support fully.

On June 2008, I announced my intention; I did it publicly and in the best forum: the General UN Assembly. It was also there, on September, that very year, that I asked those countries whose law still contemplates the death penalty to support the deferment and to take part in a process to reflect on the meaning of this sort of punishment inflicted by the State.

But the thing is that this International Colloquium coincides with the 61st anniversary of the Universal Declaration on Human Rights approved by the United Nations the 10 December 1948, and this did not happen by chance for this anniversary is an excellent chance to advocate for the principles defended by the Declaration, once more. This is what many collaborators do all over the world, with their dedication and efforts and also with their generosity.

And I would like to mention, in particular, Alicia Gámez, Roque Pascual and Albert Vilalta, their families, mates and friends. They are the main concern of public opinion and the target of the action of the Government.

We have already started to do our best to find them so that they may be liberated. We have the support of the country in which they were kidnapped, a country with which we have forged a sound, good bilateral relationship over the last few years, and we also have a strong presence in Western Africa; a presence that has resulted from a very important effort in favour of understanding, cooperation and collaboration.

Those who say that defending dialogue between Governments and international institutions in favour of understanding and the peaceful solution of conflicts is a sign of weakness should understand that these instruments provide safety for the future, particularly in a country such as Spain, for which Africa is a necessary point of reference.

But this kidnap is making us face a terrorist organisation for which the most developed countries; the most powerful countries are the main target, the target of their actions and attacks against their citizens, when they travel to countries in which the members of that terrorist organisation have squads.

There are no short ways to fight terrorism. There must be a firm action, prudence, international cooperation, social isolation and we must make our best. This is what we are doing and also what we will keep doing with Minister Moratinos.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Since 10 December 1948 international relations have changed significantly. In a globalised world the principles and values of human rights have extended progressively to the four corners of the world, which is surely enough the best way to create a real social order.

Right now, no one doubts that Human Rights are universal for they form part of the human nature, taking humans individually, regardless of their identity and of their cultural differences.

Thus, they are not the result of the imposition of a series of values. They do not belong to anyone, neither to the West nor to the East, neither to the North nor to the South; they are the culmination of the dignity of humans as such. They are universal values that all Nations must protect in their territories; they must protect them and denounce the non-compliance with them according to International Law.

No country or leader defending them can ignore the tension between the principle of non-intervention in the internal matters of a Nation - which has been recognised as an international essential one by the Charter of the United Nations - and the universal need to respect Human Rights. And this is a good moment to defend this publicly, once more, here, from Spain.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Spain works sternly in favour of Human Rights, to protect them, and we are characterised by a public awareness of their value, as we have assumed their extension to all human beings, cultures and civilisations as our political priority.

But let me tell you that the implementation and the improvement of the system of rights in a country depends on the daily commitment of its public authorities and of its citizens, since it is proved that when Human Rights cease to be defended they can become weaker.

Today, for the first time, Human Rights have become one of the structural axes of Spanish foreign politics. It is not an easy thing, it demands coherence and a clear mind, and also an efficient diplomatic action, based upon dialogue and, on occasions, upon discretion.

Thus, it was not by chance that my speech on international politics at El Prado Museum by the beginning of this Legislature was entitled "On the interests of Spain and in favour of commitment in foreign politics". Our Government is firmly committed with Human Rights and one of its clearest proofs is the Plan on Human Rights passed by the Council of Ministers last 12 December 2008. This Plan has followed the recommendation of the 1993 World Conference of Vienna, which proposed for each Nation to consider the possibility to elaborate a National Plan contemplating the necessary measures to improve the promotion and protection of Human Rights.

The Spanish Plan is intended to guarantee efficiently these rights in a coordinated, systematic way, adapting our internal laws to the different international compromises and setting up bonds between public and private agents in order to defend them. The Plan structures our national actions from the conviction that it is possible to link the defence of the national interests and the construction of a fairer, more supportive global society. And the Plan contemplates different aspects of our international action in favour of these rights, aspects based upon the main principle that gives them a meaning and a sense of unity: human dignity.

In Spain and from Spain we want to contribute to the growing efficiency of freedom and equality, as is wisely stated in our Constitution. In Spain and from Spain we want to turn Human Rights into a living reference of our experience as a society, and also into a sign of our identity. In Spain and from Spain, thinking of our present, we want to work with others and look on to the general future, extending our supportive actions and helping all those that suffer the consequences of totalitarianism, violence, discrimination, hunger and poverty all over the world.

2015 is a landmark in this future and in the fight for human dignity. By 2015 we will review the Millennium Goals, and, mind you, there are only five years to go and we are living a worrying situation. We intended to reduce world hunger by half, yet, a few days ago, the FAO informed us that over the last three years the number of people starving in the world passed from 850 to 1,020 millions. We are not getting any closer to the Millennium Goal, in fact, we are even further.

The contrast between this reality and our current scientific, technological and productive capacities is the most outrageous sign that we are living in an unacceptably unfair, unequal world, yet, luckily enough, we are able to get together in order to avoid a global financial crack, and still we are lazy and unwilling to provide a global definitive answer to the challenges of climatic change, and we are even more passive in the fight against hunger and extreme poverty.

As I said during my speech in 2008, the UN Declaration on Human Rights became a living proof of the firm willingness of building a better world for the generations to come, better than the one in which our parents lived, for their generation suffered and had to fight the consequences of totalitarianism and that document contemplates their longing for freedom and prosperity; the Millennium Goals must reflect our firm willingness to face, finally, extreme poverty so as to leave the next generation a world in which hunger and extreme poverty do not make millions of humans suffer anymore.

Both intentions, the confirmation of respect for Human Rights and the achievement of the Millennium Goals, are possibly the noblest, most committed ones in the History of Mankind, from the point of view of human dignity. Either if we think of the Millennium Goals or if we think of Human Rights, we draw the same conclusion: at least we have moved on as far as awareness rising regarding the need to enforce them is concerned, yet, this is far from being the culmination of our desires.

There is also a lot to do in the fight against death penalty. The right to live is a supreme one, as the Committee on Human Rights has just stated, because, if it is not efficiently guaranteed, all the other rights will remain meaningless. This seems rather obvious yet, should it be so simple, we would not have to be constantly demanding the public authorities all over the world to be fully coherent with the unconditional, inviolable character of human life and with the right of humans not to be applied cruel, inhuman, humiliating punishments.

The abolition of death penalty issues from these Human Rights, from the stern defence of human dignity. Thus, the recognition of these rights by the International Community has served to spread the reasons in favour of the eradication of death penalty all over the world.

Over the last decades, there has been an evident progress, mainly thanks to the development of a powerful international movement in favour of the abolition, promoted by international and regional organisations, by political representatives and by relevant agents of civil society. Although sixty years ago, abolition had started to be considered in a limited number of countries, now it is in force in nearly two thirds of the members of the United Nations.

As a result of this progress, the international consensus on the fact that death penalty is incompatible with Human Rights is getting progressively consolidated; as well as the idea that it must be abolished at a universal level. This incompatibility was clearly perceived in Spain when we achieved democracy. For our society, our country had a dark history of more or less institutionalised executions, all of them unnecessary and cruel, and we were able to understand that renouncing to this type of punishment had to form part of our efforts to leave behind the dictatorship and that it also had to be confirmed by the democratic State we were starting to build.

The monopoly of force, which gives meaning to a State, legitimating it when the State exerts it according to law and to the due warranties, must culminate with prudence, rejecting murder, cold blooded murder, because only then legitimacy can become a wall against murders and in particular against terrorists; a wall and a mirror too, unveiling them and showing them to the world. Rejecting murder therefore becomes an efficient tool to fight those who are willing to do what goes beyond moral principles: killing a fellow being.

With the Constitution of 1978, Spanish citizens recovered our dignity as a society in this regard and in many others, as free citizens; and the Law 11/1995 came to complement this task, doing away with the death penalty also in times of war.

We have ratified all the international treaties that promote the abolition of death penalty. Once we receive the authorisation of the Parliament, we will present the ratification document concerning Protocol no. 13 on the European Convention on the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, in the context of the Council of Europe, which, as you all know, establishes the abolition of death penalty under all circumstances, according to our laws.

At present, with the support of the Council of Europe, the OSCE and the EU, nearly the whole European continent rejects death penalty; but there is a universal reason to eradicate death penalty and there has been a parallel progress all over the world.

We can also say that it is a sign of identity for Latin America. In Latin America, where most countries are abolitionists, the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights limits the application of death penalty and states that it shall never be re-established in those countries in which it has already been abolished, which is a very significant progress. One of the Protocols to this Commission, passed by the OAS in 1990, contemplates the total abolition of death penalty, although it still allows its member States to apply in times of war in case a declaration in this regard was made prior to its ratification.

In Africa, a positive evolution is taking place and it is necessary to promote it. Thus, it is important to point out the recent call by the African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights for its member States to set up a deferment prior to its abolition.

In 2009 new countries have joined the group of abolitionist states and Governments; in particular, the State of New México in the United States, Burundi and Togo. We are happy about it and, of course, it was a honour for me to be given the chance by the authorities of Togo to address their National Assembly this year the very day they decided to abolish the death penalty; and it is also a great honour to be here today, with the President of the Republic of Benin, Mr. Yayi Boni, whom I would like to congratulate on the constitutional reform that will enable the abolition of death penalty in his country. I hereby congratulate him and thank him for the firm support of his Government to this initiative in favour of the universal abolition of death penalty.

I would also like to thank him for having attended this International Colloquium on the abolition of death penalty, which means a lot to us, as it is an example in favour of this cause. President Boni is proving his clear commitment with Human Rights. This is one of the main axes of the political actions of his Government, apart from the moralisation of public life and the eradication of poverty. Thus, his Government has started an ambitious programme of social and economic reforms, attaining important achievements over the last few years.

I understand the consequences that the crisis might have upon this policy, and thus I hereby invite President Boni to make a greater effort in this programme for the reduction of poverty and for the promotion of growth. I want to tell him I support his policy and I am willing to cooperate with Benin, in particular, through the different Summits between Spain and the Community of West African States.

In fact, last June, in Abuja (Nigeria), the Heads of State and Government of the fifteen countries forming part of the Community of West African States and Spain decided to strengthen cooperation at all levels.

West Africa is now a priority for our country and with today's initiative, Benin joins the African States that have decided to enrich their fight in favour of the dignity of human beings fighting poverty, exclusion or illiteracy, and with their efforts to keep spreading the respect for Human Rights and to abolish death penalty.

Dear President, you are now an example for Africa and for the world and you will have the support of my country and of the European Union so that others may follow your steps.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Each step at a national level, just as happens with Benin today, is a step forward for all of us, yet, in spite of this, the death penalty is still in force in too many countries. Thus, the International Community must make a greater effort and this is why meetings such as today's are so meaningful.

The World Coalition against the Death Penalty has just launched an international campaign to ratify the 2nd Facultative Protocol, the 1989 one, of the international Covenant on Civil and Political Rights passed in 1966.

This Protocol is particularly relevant for it is the only legal instrument with an international scope contemplating the total abolition of death penalty in its member states. So far, it has only been ratified by 72 countries, although this International Covenant has 164 member States. Spain supports this initiative and we will cooperate with it firmly so that the 2nd Protocol may become the main binding instrument forbidding death penalty in International Law.

Also in the context of the United Nations, the approval by the General Assembly of two Resolutions, on December 2007 and on December 2008, promoting the establishment of a deferment regarding death penalty in those countries in which it is still in force prior to its abolition, has also been a new landmark. Both Resolutions were passed by a wide, growing majority, including most countries, and although they are not binding, they have become two useful tools to encourage the countries in which death penalty is still in force to join the majority of abolitionist countries, either de facto - cancelling their executions - or by law - excluding death penalty from their legislation-.

What this initiative by the Government of Spain concerning death penalty seeks for is contribution to strengthen that growing international movement in favour of the spread of abolition. We have already made the first move to create, during the second semester of 2010 an International Committee against Death Penalty, which will act as a promoter and which will support all the efforts made in order to reach this goal by the International Community.

This International Committee will be formed by important personalities from different world regions working in the area of Human Rights, and it will follow two main action lines: first, its aim will be advocating for the implementation of a 'de facto' universal deferment by 2015 before it is completely abolished.

And this will happen in 2015, again, and not by chance. The fight to confirm human dignity must take place at all levels at the same time since it is as irrevocable as dignity itself. We have decided to attain the Millennium Goals by 2015 too, so, that is the best of dates to attain the universal deferment we propose. Yet, certain situations cannot wait for a deferment. The International Committee we will create will have to advocate for a second line of action, namely, the universal, immediate abolition of death penalty in the cases contemplated by International Law and which restrict its application already, namely, in the case of children under 18, pregnant women and mentally disabled people, given their vulnerability, on the moment of committing the crime.

During the Spanish EU Presidency during the first semester of 2010, the universal abolition of death penalty will be a priority for us as far as Human Rights are concerned, and we will follow and promote the guidelines approved by the EU in 1998, which have been updated recently.

Thus, we will intensify all the initiatives set forth by the previous EU Presidencies and, hence, we will attend the international forums, in particular the International Congress in Geneva next year, and we will elaborate the corresponding documents to spread this; we will promote cooperation projects to enhance reforms affecting the legal systems of the countries in which death penalty is still in force and we will encourage the ratification o the international instruments promoting the abolition of death penalty.

We will do our best and we will work co-ordinately with the agents of civil society which, just as this international academic network, are making a great work in this area.

Still, I would like to say something more. I am going to promote the incorporation to these tasks of the new European Foreign Service, which will be operative in a few weeks' time, as a provider of legal and diplomatic collateral and complementary assistance, should it be necessary, to Member States and to European citizens facing a death penalty sentence. I think that the status of European citizen must be enriched with this additional guarantee: the protection of the Union against the risk of death penalty in any country.

Also from the European Union we will coordinate the action of the Member States to promote together with countries from different world regions the approval of a new Resolution of the UN General Assembly, by the end of 2010, about the deferment concerning the application of death penalty, which will be more ambitious and which will have a wider support as compared to 2007 and 2008.

Thus, we are going to make a great effort in order to reduce the application of death penalty in the world. We will do it as a country in all the international forums and we will do it particularly during our EU Presidency.

As you all know, last October we appointed an Ambassador on special mission for these tasks, Rafael Valle, who will surely contribute to make this come true.

Ladies and gentlemen, I conclude.

Mankind keeps moving on towards the future and it is our responsibility to build it up, and that future can only be built one way, just one way, and, luckily enough, this meets the desires of most communities in the world. And it is this willingness that makes it necessary for us to bring to an end the conflicts that threaten peace; to refuse firmly the fact that half of our fellow beings must fight to subsist and succumb while trying when this can be avoided; it is this willingness that urges us to find a definitive answer to the consequences of climatic change and to refuse violence against humans, the breach of their rights or their deliberate execution in those countries where death penalty is still in force.

It is that willingness, which speaks so many languages in favour of human dignity, that gives full civic meaning to initiatives such as the one put forward by the President of Benin or to the participation in meetings such as this one. To all of you, congratulations and have a nice meeting.

Thank you very much.