Press conference by the President of the Government after the NATO Summit
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero addressed press following the NATO Lisbon Summit on 19 November 2010, reporting on key decisions including NATO-Russia cooperation and the Afghanistan transition plan.
- Main themes
- NATO summit outcomes, NATO-Russia cooperation, European anti-missile defence system, Afghanistan security transition, collective security, war on terrorism, fight against piracy, Spanish armed forces, Obama's diplomatic leadership, ISAF mission, Afghan security transfer, failed states
- Duration
- ~23 min
- Words
- 2,790
- Sentences
- 110
- Readability
- 49
- Grade
- 12.7
- Syntax
- 3.05
- Vocabulary
- 2.05
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
110 sentences in 44 paragraphs
President of the Government . Good afternoon. I am appearing here before you to report on the results of this transcendental North Atlantic Treaty Organisation Summit which has just concluded; it is a transcendental Summit because decisions have been taken here and new steps have been taken for the collective security of the countries that make up NATO, for the collective security of Europe in general and for the collective security of the whole world.
We have just attended a meeting of the NATO-Russia Council, which is a veritable milestone in relations between NATO and Russia. This opens up a field of cooperation and expectation previously unheard of between the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation and the political and military might that is Russia; cooperation that will extend to areas such as the war on terrorism, the stabilisation process in Afghanistan, the fight against piracy and also, and this undoubtedly constitutes a novelty of great magnitude, the European anti-missile defence system; a European anti-missile defence system which, with the cooperation of NATO and Russia, will include all European airspace right across to the Urals, in a project, which as you can appreciate, is of a great magnitude, and is a clear demonstration of the extent to which things have changed in the world in the last few decades.
I can assure you that attending this Summit and hearing the unity of voices that are the United States, Russia, Germany and Poland cooperating on collective international security is undoubtedly a historic milestone, as I said, but above all it is an extraordinary piece of news.
Working together in this direction undoubtedly means having many more weapons to guarantee collective security, the defence of our countries and in the war on terrorism, against piracy and the threats of failed States or the difficulties of drawing in failed States.
I would like to highlight that the fact of holding this Summit between NATO and Russia is, to a great extent, thanks to the political determination of President Obama. You are aware that only two years ago relations between NATO and Russia had cooled as a result of the events in Georgia, but President Obama had the vision and the lucidity to rescue this relationship and worked intensively to reach where we are today. I would like to extend these congratulations to President Medvedev, who was up to responding to this challenge and pointed relations between NATO and Russia in the right direction.
Together with what, for me, has been the highlight of this Summit, we have gone over the main aspects currently faced by the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation. Afghanistan is undoubtedly the greatest challenge, the main task at hand, the main undertaking of NATO at present. As you are aware, we are carrying out, through ISAF, work on consolidating a new Afghanistan and creating a stable Afghanistan that is progressively more democratic, with greater well-being and expectations for its people; an Afghanistan free of terrorists or groups that back Al Qaeda's terrorism.
Conclusions on Afghanistan: firstly, progress has been made in the last few months, we have taken the initiative. Following a situation in which for a certain period it was thought that the insurgency had regained the imitative, we can say today that NATO forces have regained the initiative, the insurgency is losing numbers and our military forces, led by General Petraeus, are progressively consolidating. This doesn't mean that there aren't still major challenges ahead of us or that it won't be difficult to conclude what we set out to do in Afghanistan.
I should say that we have attained the objectives set out in Afghanistan. As of next year, 2011, the process of transferring control of security to the Afghan authorities will commence, province by province, district by district, a process we calculate will take until 2014. But NATO will not wash its hands of Afghanistan, and NATO will continue supporting security in Afghanistan.
As I have asserted on other occasions, the dates we have planned, from a strategic and situational perspective, are merely guidelines, while the objectives are absolute, although we do feel that for the process to last 3 years between 2011 and 2014 is a reasonable guideline.
As regards our troops, I reiterated in the NATO Summit my recognition of their work, my recollection to the soldiers that Spain has suffered losses defending liberty, peace and stability in Afghanistan, and the commitment of the Spanish armed forces to continue with this work, today, above all, through training and instruction, both of the Afghan armed forces and of the police, with the great collaboration, as you are aware, of the Guardia Civil.
I will add in respect to Afghanistan that during the transfer process the Afghan authorities should also incorporate the standards necessary for the transfer of development; in other words infrastructures, basic equipment, institutes, schools, hospitals and drinking water. Without security there can be no development but without development there is no security. Hence, both aspects need to go hand-in-hand.
Finally, as you are aware, NATO has approved a new strategy, a strategy aimed at consolidating this open dimension of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation; of an organisation that has progressively increased its membership and is looking at modernising its operating structure, at specialising, at thinking about the risks and conflicts that we could be facing, and consequently thinking about operating capabilities closely tied to its capacity to have maximum mobility and closely tied to defence in the face of risks of conflicts from international terrorism, from piracy, and of course, thinking about more intense and increased cooperation in intelligence. In short, a wide range of new operating challenges so that NATO can continue modernising.
In short, two conclusions: this Summit, with a more modern and open NATO, especially due to its new cooperation with Russia, will be a more effective NATO, whereby our citizens can feel its effects more directly. You are well aware that by enlarging the perspective of policies and cooperation is the way to avoid conflict; it is a sounder way to guarantee stability. In addition there is a commitment, as my second conclusion, as regards Afghanistan with dates that will of course be met.
I am now ready for any questions, but not too many as we have already been here for many hours. Just a couple…
Q . Mr. President of the Government, I would like to ask you about something we were told by the Minister for Foreign Affairs this morning. She considered, in her meeting with Hillary Clinton, the possibility that the Group of Friends of the Sahara maintain some form of meeting at a level higher than a technical level, at a top political level, in order to coincide with and drive the talks forward that are currently being held by the parties. I would like to know whether you believe that this meeting should be at a ministerial level and whether, moreover, this meeting, aside from being merely coincidental, should raise some kind of initiative or a calendar to encourage the parties to conclude the negotiations being carried out.
President of the Government . It seems a very appropriate question to me, because we have been talking very intensely over the last few days about the Sahara and I am convinced that sometimes that prevents us from noticing what is really important.
What we need in the Sahara is a political agreement that is permanent; this is what has been unsuccessfully worked on for the last thirty years. Both Morocco, and of course the Sahrawi people need a political agreement, as does the international community.
The United Nations is leading the dialogue with a representative from the Secretary General.
What needs to be done? Those of us who are close by, we feel and care about the Sahara and dialogue and understanding with Morocco; we seek to support, motivate and drive the parties to dialogue more than ever before and we want to see the international community make its best effort to support this dialogue that should be led by the United Nations.
If you will allow me, the level of the meeting is somewhat secondary. What is important is the commitment from governments and that the United Nations makes its best effort and that Morocco and the Polisario Front are well disposed to dialogue. That is what we need to achieve. Is it difficult? Yes, extremely difficult, but there have been other equally or more difficult conflicts in the last few decades that have found the path to a solution.
And the governments - note that I am saying "the governments", and not the countries, nor the media, nor the parties, I am saying "the governments" - what is our role in all this? Responsibility, prudence and moderation are what should be required of us. And it is with responsibility, prudence and moderation the Government of Spain is going to endeavour to contribute to the political dialogue on the Sahara.
Q . Mr President of the Government, I simply wanted to refer back to the last question. Have you had the opportunity at this Summit to speak about the matter of the Sahara with any of your four colleagues, who aside from yourself, make up the Group of Friends; specifically France, who we understand is the country opposed to there being an objective or impartial report?
On another note, regarding the withdrawal of Spanish troops from Afghanistan, I wanted to ask you whether, despite your saying that the dates are not final but need to be respected, we can say that the Spanish troops are going to transfer their scope of responsibility to the Afghan authorities before the end of 2012, a date that has been much talked about. Can you confirm the precise dates?
President of the Government . As regards your first question, this is a NATO Summit with a specific agenda, and that agenda is what the Heads of Government and Heads of State have been following, as you will appreciate. The agenda was important and it was, as it should be, the Minister for Foreign Affairs who, as was reported earlier, in her talks with Hillary Clinton and other talks, has tackled this specific matter.
As regards the transfer process and withdrawal, it is not strictly the same. The process of transferring authority and the withdrawal of troops is not exactly the same. It is true that, to the extent that the transfer of authority takes place, the doors to a progressive withdrawal are opened. When will this take place? Let's wait and see. You asked me if in 2012 or before. This is likely but, as I have said on many occasions, the dates should be taken as a guideline, as an indication. It is not gospel that this transfer will take place in 2012 or even in 2011 in certain aspects.
Q . Mr President of the Government, I would like to make a comment regarding the opening up of NATO. I have understood you as saying that the incorporation of Russia in the anti-missile shield will lead to a wider security zone. Has something changed?
President of the Government . No, nothing has changed.
Q . Is it the Pacific or the Urals?
President of the Government . The operational aspect, as I said earlier, and don't think that the anti-missile defence system is a closed matter due to today's cooperation, has a long path of dialogue ahead of it, the joint system, the cooperation system, and consequently, we must wait, both as regards the geographical limits and the technical characteristics because there are many matters still to tie up.
What is true is that, in political terms, which is the expression I used, since we are always talking about the Urals, the security and collective defence zone is being hugely enlarged and we hope that it will not be the last enlargement.
Yesterday, in the dinner we held, I expressed that NATO was totally right in this vision of dialogue that goes beyond what represents its natural scope of territory, the territory of the countries that comprise it, and that in the immediate future we will have to open up this dialogue in matters of security to emerging countries who will certainly play an important role in collective security, despite not having played a role in recent times.
Q . I wanted to ask you two questions. Firstly, what arguments do you intend to use to convince the Group of Friends of the Sahara for them to become more politically involved in reaching a solution to this conflict?
And, if you will allow me, a question about domestic politics. The President of the Regional Government of Catalonia, José Montilla, has announced that this will be the last time that he runs in the Catalan elections. I would like to know if you consider this to be the right decision, announced barely one week before the elections, and if you share this decision.
Furthermore, Montilla also said that the PSOE should take note of what takes place on 28 November, and not only the PSC. I would like to know what note the PSOE should take after these elections.
President of the Government . What Montilla says and does is fine by me. And hence I have answered your question.
As regards your other question, with what arguments? The arguments seem obvious to me. We have spent years, the last few years in unsuccessful dialogue. Spain, on more than one occasion, has urged the United Nations and the Secretary General to take up dialogue again, to try a new plan and to appoint a new representative so that Morocco and the Polisario Front can make progress in this dialogue. It now seems reasonable that, if this opinion is widely held, is more forceful and shared by various countries, among which are the powers that we have just been mentioned, we can suppose that it could contribute, be useful or motivate this agreement between Morocco and the Polisario Front, which is what we are all working towards, especially those of us who are responsible for the Government.
I have said this on more than one occasion: a government must try to be useful to solve problems and to solve a conflict between parties you need to have the capacity for dialogue and to mediate between parties. This is the position that the Government of Spain maintains, this is the right position, this is the responsible position and what is most clear is that this is the position held by all great countries, all the great democracies and the United Nations.
Q . Mr President of the Government, we were informed that yesterday, in your Speech at the Summit, you said that after the rapprochement with Russia, the objective, the great challenge, is the Mediterranean and the Summit to be organised in Barcelona.
Do you think that it is more complicated to try to hold this Summit on the Union for the Mediterranean and confirm…?
President of the Government . NATO has opened up dialogue on the Mediterranean and that has been endorsed in this Summit. What I asked for was to intensify this dialogue, that dialogue on the Mediterranean should be a priority. Given that dialogue with Russia, towards the East, is bearing fruit, we should intensify this dialogue in the direction of the Mediterranean.
You are completely right. The difficulties in holding the Summit on the Union for the Mediterranean at the heart of the European Union respond to the most serious problem, the most serious conflict faced by the international community for many decades, which is the conflict between Israel and the Palestinian people which, as I have expressed on more than one occasion, is the primary tumour of many conflicts, of many difficult situations in the world. Of course a consolidated peace process in the Near East would certainly make stability and definitive security in Afghanistan much easier; it would certainly change the situation in Pakistan and it is likely that it would also make the fight against the spread of Al Qaeda much easier, for example, in North Africa.
That is why NATO can contribute to dialogue in the Mediterranean and why, furthermore, it can be asserted that the most important challenge to peace faced by the international community continues to be the Middle East, it continues to be Israel and Palestine.
Let's hope that we can receive some good news in the coming weeks, that mean dialogue has been taken up again. We all know, and the Government of Spain knows this, that President Barack Obama is very insistent on this matter, and I hope and trust that we will see results.
Thank you very much.