Press conference by the President of the Government following the G-20 Summit
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero addressed journalists in Seoul on November 11, 2010, following the G-20 Summit to report on outcomes for the international economy and Spain.
- Main themes
- G-20 Seoul Summit outcomes, global financial system reform, Basel III agreements, IMF governance reform, Spain's increased IMF representation, macroeconomic cooperation, fiscal stimulus, economic recovery, Doha Round and free trade, international financial institutions reform, financial crisis response
- Duration
- ~40 min
- Words
- 4,841
- Sentences
- 170
- Readability
- 45
- Grade
- 13.9
- Syntax
- 3.08
- Vocabulary
- 2.07
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
170 sentences in 62 paragraphs
President of the Government . Good afternoon. I would like to inform you about this latest meeting of the G-20. Allow me to begin that information about the content of this Summit here in Seoul by making a general assessment of what the G-20 means today for the international economy and what it represents for Spain.
Including this one in Seoul and with those in Washington, London, Pittsburgh and Toronto, the leaders of the G-20 have now held 5 Summits since November 2008, the time when this most serious crisis in the financial system since the Great Depression began, a crisis in the financial system that lead to a serious economic crisis.
At these 5 Summits, including Seoul, a stable and institutionalised forum has been consolidated for the first time in history for international cooperation between the countries that represent 85% of global GDP and the international organisations that are decisive for the smooth running of the financial system and the economy in general: the United Nations, the International Monetary Fund, the World Trade Organisation, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, the International Labour Organisation and the Financial Stability Fund.
There has never before been such representative participation in a cooperation programme at a financial and economic level to reach balance, development, growth, and consequently, well-being. I would remind you, because it is important, that the G-20 gave an initial response to the financial crisis, an initial response that consisted of rescuing and saving the financial system on the understanding that, if the financial system had gone under, the prejudice for those citizens with savings and for the economy in general would have been devastating.
But there was not just a commitment to rescue by using public funds, but also a commitment to reform the financial system. And we have to conclude that as a result of this meeting - this Summit in Seoul - significant progress has been made in reforming the financial system; progress that is articulated through increased regulation and greater supervision. Perhaps the most representative and most important aspect has been the Basel III Agreements to demand much greater levels of capital and many more guarantees from financial entities. As a result this reform of the financial system driven by the G-20, we should never again have to suffer a crisis of the financial system such as the one we have just gone through.
Together with the rescue of the financial system and the reform of the financial system, we are undertaking to reform the international financial institutions: the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. And this reform has been completed.
The reform of the International Monetary Fund is particularly important in two senses: the reform of governance of the International Monetary Fund, of representation in the governing body, and the capacity of the International Monetary Fund to prevent and respond to situations where States are suffering financial difficulties. This has also taken place.
Furthermore, the reform of the International Monetary Fund, as regards governance and representation, positively affects Spain because, as you know, we will now increase our representation from 1.4% to 2%. We gain in weight, we gain representation and we gain importance in the International Monetary Fund which, at the same time, has gained in strength and increased its role in the international monetary system. And it is clear that this progress regarding Spain's representation is related to our participation and presence in the G-20.
As well as responding to the financial crisis, to reforming the financial institutions and reforming regulation of the financial system, the G-20 has also been the driving force behind macroeconomic political cooperation; initially through a coordinated response, for the first time ever with fiscal stimuli to tackle the economic recession; fiscal stimuli that have been successful because they stopped the recession and enabled us to now be in a situation of growth globally, albeit weak growth, especially in certain economic areas.
Together with fiscal stimuli, the G-20 is working on macroeconomic balances in general and, of course, also on correcting the fiscal deficits and fiscal stability of countries, a message which was of particular importance at the Toronto Summit.
But the scope of its action and the agenda of cooperation in the international economy have not only included the financial system, which is important; or the reform of the financial institutions, which has been decisive; or the regulation of the operation of the banks and other credit institutions, which was undoubtedly of particular importance, but it has also extended into other areas.
Trade. We have devoted a large part of the debate to the Doha Round, convinced as we are that extending free trade, removing barriers and reducing protection is a source of growth and employment. This is particularly true for countries like Spain, where an increase in our export capacity is going to be decisive in the coming years in order to create employment and grow economically. That is why we are particularly interested in the Doha Round reaching completion and it particularly interests us that this spirit, which fortunately has been maintained, of rejecting protectionism on the part of the G-20, continues to be maintained and moves in the right direction.
Other economic areas, as I said. Together with trade, development. The G-20 has reached a conclusion: the policy of development is part of economic policy. Opening up new sources of growth, new poles of economic activity to include countries, regions and sectors in the economy means a general benefit for the world economy and for capacity for growth. One of the areas touched upon has been food security, the capacity to generate infrastructures in the farming sector and the fulfilment of the Millennium Development Goals.
Within these new fields, together with trade and development, are energy and the fight against climate change, which is one of the major issues for the balance of the world economy: a commitment to energy saving and efficiency, a commitment to renewable energies, in short, a commitment to energy changes which we are already decisively undergoing and which will represent a great potential for employment.
In conclusion, the G-20 has a broad agenda for the international economy. It has obtained agreement and reforms, long-term cooperation and vision in these last two years, and it has been consolidated as a fundamental institution for development and well-being in the coming decades. I will now move on to the second part of this speech regarding the consolidation of Spain's participation in the G-20.
Allow me to assert that, given the evolution and the configuration of the growing role, strength and representation of the G-20 in the world, the fact that Spain forms a part of the G-20 is the most important fact in the foreign policy of our country over the last decade.
Many countries have supported Spain's reasonable aspiration to participate in this forum and, of course, Spain must respond responsibly and with the capacity to make proposals and contribute to the G-20. We have done this at this Summit and the Government will continue to do this to enrich all the tasks, which are increasingly important, of the G-20; tasks which next year, as you are aware, are awaited with great expectation under the French Presidency. Those issues deriving from today's debate for the French Presidency are already of great importance and we fully trust, of course, in the role to be performed by the French Presidency.
I would like to end by expressing my gratitude to South Korea, to President Lee and to the South Korean Government for the organisation and development of this Summit which, of course, from an organisational point of view, has been a model of efficiency, of South Korean efficiency as everyone can see and as has been pointed out, by the way, by many countries here.
Q . With respect to the Summit, one of the first sections of the final communiqué talks about continuing imbalances and that the global recovery remains imbalanced, whilst also warning about the danger of looking for unilateral solutions. In this respect, the Summit has taken place just when there seem to be two crises at least, on which all attention is focused: one is foreign exchange and the other is debt, mainly of Ireland, which is also extending to other countries, such as Spain and Portugal.
I wanted to ask you if the G-20 has discussed this last issue and if there has been any kind of common stance on the matter, because the messages we are receiving are somewhat contradictory. Angela Merkel states that she is in favour of helping Ireland, while at the same time insisting that the creditors should assume some of the cost of adjustments as of 2013, which is what seems to have caused this crisis. I wanted to know if you could clarify this a little. President of the Government. There is a long list of matters that have been tackled by the G-20. I have summarised the agreements being put in place by the previous Summits, the reform of the financial system and, in particular, the reform of the financial institutions which were far-reaching and tremendously important. The G-20 is now faced with other issues of great significance which I hope will culminate in agreements and decisions in 2011; among others, as I mentioned, trade and the Doha Round.
Of course there is a desire and increasing commitment - that is how I would define it - for global economic cooperation to amount to cooperation at a financial level - and we have taken far-reaching steps of great historic importance - and to cooperation in the field of energy - and steps have indeed been taken, but there are many more to take - and to cooperation at a monetary or exchange rate level. The debate has started, and this debate will certainly continue into 2011. In the same way as there have been at least two or three G-20 Summits to establish the profile and define the reform of the whole financial system and the reform of the financial institutions, I am convinced that we will continue the debate on cooperation regarding monetary policy in the knowledge that it is a matter where there are very significant conflicting interests.
The same applies to trade. It has taken ten years to culminate Doha. Why? Because there are conflicting interests between the emerging countries and the developed countries. It seems that there is now a determination to conclude this great trade agreement which will generate economic growth and employment.
And my reflection is the same: the G-20 is a fundamental element to make progress in this agreement, to assist in increased cooperation in monetary policy or to achieve cooperation in financial policy.
As regards the situation of certain countries in the Eurozone, specifically Ireland, you know that the European Union has implemented a prevention mechanism for crisis situations of sovereign debt for certain countries and it is then the responsibility of said country and of the International Monetary Fund, as the case may be, to decide if this applies.
As regards other considerations, I will say - once again, it seems that time will tell whether this information is irrefutable - that Spain is in a sound position, aside from - as has occurred on other occasions - when there exists a certain concern or situation in the Eurozone, as happened to Greece or could happen at some other time to another country - us being affected as regards the differentials and the risk premium of our sovereign debt. But I repeat that we are in a sound position and we are solvent.
Secondly, as regards the presence or the role of the private sector in a crisis management situation and a possible restructuring of private debt, I should remind you of two things: firstly, that this should under no circumstance affect the current debt of a country, as is well-known; and secondly, there is a mandate from the latest European Council for the President of the Council, Herman Von Rompuy, to assess, after consultation with the different countries, the possibility of private debt playing a role in tackling the crisis. I expressed myself at the time and I will reiterate this; for the time being, during this consultation process, Spain's position is opposed to this hypothesis.
Q . Going into further detail on the last question, you informed us a few months ago about a possible return to tranquillity in the debt market which, unfortunately, seems to not to have transpired. I would like to know if the Member States of the European Union which agreed in their day on this rescue mechanism are not a little disappointed because it hasn't borne the desired fruit in the sense that the markets have again gone for another country that they see as a weak link in the chain, a link which while having made the most draconian of adjustments in the whole Eurozone, appears not to have appeased the markets.
Along these lines, I would like to know whether, during the G-20, you have felt under pressure or felt the need to once again defend the strength of Spanish debt.
And secondly, as regards the G-20, has Spain needed to adopt a stance at any time on monetary policy?
President of the Government . If we approve a response mechanism to a possible crisis it is because this hypothesis cannot be discarded, since the worst that could happen in the markets is that the situation of a country reaches a limit whereby it is unable to comply with its payment obligations, with its debts, without having, as a Eurozone country, a support and response mechanism to this situation. I believe that this mechanism gives an element of tranquillity, of stability.
It is not the markets in this case that cause a given situation. The situation is that a country has a deficit of 30% vis-à-vis its GDP and a serious problem with its financial system. That is a reality and what we should expect is that if the mechanism needs to be applied that this generates confidence. To whom? To the creditors of the debt who, in summary, are those who generate the volatility in the markets when they perceive or anticipate a situation whereby a country finds it difficult to comply with its payment obligations.
As regards whether I had to make some kind of effort, my reply is that no-one has asked me about the country's situation, and hence this hasn't taken place.
I said that it would be appropriate… In my opinion, the debate has been at a fledgling stage. I think that we have been talking about it over the last few weeks, but given its magnitude, in order to have effective cooperation we are going to need more time and, above all, the major powers are going to need more time.
You know that the Government has announced its decision. We understand that monetary policy must respond to the fundamentals of an economy in the same way as for foreign exchange policy. Hence, some countries must make an effort in a certain direction and other countries in the opposite direction in order to reach a greater balance of the monetary system as a whole, which is highly desirable. Certain currencies will clearly need a higher value while others don't need to follow a protectionist trend to compete with these currencies which are clearly undervalued.
Q . Mr President of the Government, I have a couple of questions. Still on the subject of the G-20, what level or degree of confidence do you have in this agreement, albeit a fledgling agreement that you have reached in the G-20 regarding the fact that there will be no unilateral devaluation of currencies, taking into consideration the coming events regarding the actions taken by the US Federal reserve or what China has done with the Yen ? That's my first question.
If you will allow me to ask a question of a domestic nature; the second day of the trial against Arnaldo Otegi is about to start today and the President of the Basque Socialist Party, Jesús Eguiguren is going to give evidence. Are you worried about this evidence, about what Eguiguren might say and how the Popular Party might respond; they have already asked you, or the Socialist Party, or the Government to clarify the statements made by Otegi himself yesterday in the Central Criminal Court where he stated that the Socialist Party or the Government itself knew about the holding of the event in Anoeta beforehand?
President of the Government . There is still much to do to achieve cooperation on monetary policy. This is quite clear and, of course, the Government of Spain wants this path to be followed and that we achieve cooperation. As of today we have a fledgling agreement to seek cooperation, but this is not real cooperation and it would be very positive it we could achieve this. Of course, for us, as a Eurozone country, it can be understood that certain movements that we have seen in the last few months have had certain clearly worrying elements, although if we wish to achieve cooperation on monetary policy some day, we should be careful today and not point the finger or raise our voices against anybody because, in short, all countries at some time or another have played or manipulated to seek an advantageous position, albeit short term, because, in summary, we are almost always talking about short-term advantages.
Just look at how we have managed to avoid protectionist policies in this crisis, that is extremely important, and we have to try to achieve this level of cooperation in monetary policy. In relation to your question about the Popular Party, the latter is perfectly aware of the great effort and the highly positive results we have achieved in the war on terrorism and it knows, and we have mentioned this on many occasions, what this task has represented since 2004. And the Government knows that each time a statement is made by a member of Batasuna, the Popular Party asks about it.
Since the PP normally helps, we won't make any comment, but I believe that what it should always do is help. And you know that each one of these questions asked doesn't really serve any purpose since I don't really know what it hopes to gain, what it is after. The democratic parties have a common objective - the PP, the PSOE and the Government - and that is to put an end to ETA as soon as possible, to guarantee liberty and to impose democracy once and for all in the Basque Country. And, since moreover there is a good relationship and stability between the Basque Regional Government and the Popular Party, I would like you to look no further than that, and may we maintain that since it's important.
Q. Are you worried by what Eguiguren might say? President of the Government. No, I'm not worried. I know Jesús Eguiguren well, he will say what he believes and we will respect his opinion. We will have similar viewpoints and of course we will respect each other. I hope that everyone behaves prudently and that we don't make propaganda out of this process of exalting terrorism in which various members of the outlawed Batasuna are charged. Let's not make propaganda for those who don't deserve it.
Q . As you are aware, Morocco has announced the expulsion of three Cadena SER journalists who were in El Aaiún reporting on the events unfolding there. I would like to know how you assess the actions of Morocco in this case and also if your Government is thinking about entering into negotiations or taking any kind of action against the Government of Morocco in light of the events of the last few weeks in which there have been various violations of the freedom of the press as regards Spanish journalists.
President of the Government . Yes, we are negotiating on an ongoing basis with Morocco so that the right to information can become a reality in El Aaiún and everywhere. We are doing this through dialogue with Morocco, with an attitude of cooperation with Morocco and also from a standpoint of concern for and direct, personal support to the journalists themselves. This is being carried out by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and will continue.
The Government has made a statement on the serious events that have taken place in El Aaiún expressing its concern, its deep concern, above all, seeking continued dialogue between Morocco and the Polisario Front, that both sides make the maximum effort - this is the key - and that the investigation announced by the Public Prosecutor's Office in Morocco is set in motion and manages to clarify the events that have taken place. The Government of Spain is also ready to commit itself and to commit the European Union to give a response of a social nature to the people, to the many people who are in difficulty.
Let's remember that the origin of the camp derives from a social demand, beyond the fact that this was later expressed as a political demand, but in reality it is a social demand. The Government of Spain is ready and willing to commit itself, I insist, together with the European Union.
Finally, on a general note as regards this matter, the Government is going to tackle this question with Morocco at an international level and at an EU level with a full sense of responsibility, in the knowledge that our relationship with Morocco is a priority relationship for Spain; in the knowledge that this is a matter that we could classify as a matter of State - and hence in the understanding that the Popular Party must take a responsible stance - and, of course, always seeking to reach agreement between Morocco and the Polisario Front. Why? Because it is the only solution to this serious conflict that has had deep negative consequences for the last thirty years for many people and for political stability.
Of course, we hope that the dialogue that has been initiated, that has restarted will result in substantial progress this time. Meanwhile, the events need to be clarified. We will give all the support to the Spaniards and other people affected, and, of course to the journalists whom we wish - and we have conveyed this to Morocco - to see being able to exercise the right to information. I insist that this whole task is being done though sincere, open and on-going dialogue with Morocco.
Q . Regardless of the deficit problem suffered by Ireland, it seems that part of the situation taking place in the markets with debt, not only of Ireland but of other countries, is related to this debate, which you alluded to, of the hypothetical possibility that in the future, private lenders could be obliged, let's say, to a deduction in the money loaned. What I am wondering is whether, when coordinating economic policies, this would possibly need to start by coordinating this type of debate and avoiding debates which are hypothetical having a real effect on the situation of the markets, debates which are always driven by the same country, by the way.
One of the priority issues for Spain in the G-20 Summit is employment. I don't know if this issue has really come up and to what extent the issue of employment has been debated in the G-20.
President of the Government . It is true that this is one of the possible interpretations, that the tension and volatility we have seen in the markets in the last few days is related to the debate on the possible effect of a crisis and rescue situation of sovereign debt of a country on private debt through a restructuring process. It is true that this is out there and it is also true that the debate exists. Things are what they are.
A certain country has brought up this possibility in the heart of the European Union, not for the current situation, but rather as a mechanism for the future - that should be made clear, and hence, the markets shouldn't feel affected by this at present and show any sensitivity thereto - a permanent mechanism for the future to be approved in 2013. The government of Spain is not in agreement, we do not agree with this proposal, and consequently it is unlikely to prevail.
That is what I wanted to say, but the debate is taking place because the party that has proposed it is fully entitled to open a debate, logically, and for reflections to be made on it. The European Union is a democratic organisation and that is how it operates.
Employment has indeed been the object of analysis in practically all of the chapters of the fundamental issues of the G-20. Why? Because trade and exports are, above all, a source of employment. For each 10% increase in Spanish exports, there is a 1.5% increase in employment and for each billion euros of exports, 7,500 jobs are created in Spain.
Employment has been an ever-present issue in the whole debate on the new energy model, on "green energy", on renewable energy and the electric car; the whole chapter that includes the so-called "green" economy. And employment was also a matter included in one of my speeches, where I asked President Sarkozy, as President of the G-20 in 2011 to call a Summit of Employment Ministers to talk expressly about employment, about active employment policies, about training and skills, because this is undoubtedly the most serious social problem caused by the economic crisis and it is undoubtedly the important challenge faced by countries where there has been a very serious impact on unemployment, as is the case of Spain.
Q . I would like to come back to the subject of the Sahara. I have some queries. Firstly, and above all, I would like to know if the Government has any information on the possible death of a Spanish citizen there.
Secondly, when you spoke about Spain wishing to support, or being willing to participate in the social response of the European Union to the situation, I would like to know how that could be arranged.
On another note, Moratinos went to Algeria and I don't know with what mandate or in what capacity he went, and I would like to know if you don't fear that the participation of the former minister in this case somewhat undermines the authority of the new Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Finally, taking into account that in Spain we are quite susceptible to whether we should be worried about, or regret or condemn acts of violence, I don't know whether due to our shared history with the Sahrawi people, our response as a Government is too weak because we talk about concern, about deep concern; but I don't know if the events will lead us to raise the intensity a notch.
President of the Government . I should say two things about this: starting with the last question, the first thing is that we need to have the full facts about what has taken place. You will agree with me that we have received a lot of information, sometimes contradictory information. I believe it is prudent to wait until we have the whole picture.
Secondly, the Government's response is, from the perspective of the Executive, what it should be: responsible, sensible and prudent as regards the solution to the conflict and for the interests of Spain. The interests of Spain are what the Government has to place at the forefront. Therefore, it is the most appropriate response to resolve the conflict and, consequently, for the Sahrawi people and for the interests of Spain.
As regards the mission of Moratinos, I should say that the mission was intended to make an assessment in various countries on the situation of the Summit of the Union for the Mediterranean. It has nothing to do with the events that have taken place in El Aaiún; the crisis meant that an immediate response on the part of the Minister was necessary. They are wholly unrelated and hence, any interpretation… If you will allow me, it seems a little strange to me that a decision to ask Moratinos to manage this issue, because everyone knows his importance and influence in the Middle East, when the decision is mine, that it could be thought of or could have the effect of undermining the Minister for Foreign Affairs. The way it has been interpreted… I am not going to say what it seems to me.
As regards the possible death of a Spanish citizen, we are trying to obtain information about this. We are working through the diplomatic channels and the Consular services, and when we know something we will obviously let you know.
Thank you very much.