Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

8 February 2011 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions from opposition leaders Rajoy and Duran i Lleida during a government control session in Spain's parliament on February 8, 2011.
Main themes
Economic crisis impact on Spanish families, household purchasing power and financial wealth, unemployment in Spain, inflation and rising prices, government economic policy defense, tax policy and social spending, opposition criticism of economic management, per capita income trends, oil prices and core inflation, youth unemployment, pension and wage freezes, RENFE and energy price increases
Duration
~14 min
47th percentile
Words
1,621
47th percentile
Sentences
58
38th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
13.8
65th percentile
Syntax
3.26
79th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 52%50%
  • Institutional 27%26%
  • Ceremonial 11%10%
  • Geopolitical 7%7%
  • Social 4%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

58 sentences in 28 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President of the Government, I ask you about a matter that constitutes a fundamental concern for millions of Spaniards, regarding their purchasing power and their level of well-being and wealth. The latest report from the Bank of Spain, the Economic Bulletin for January, states that the net financial wealth of families has fallen by 20 percent since the beginning of this Legislature and that disposable income has decreased by 9 percent in nominal terms and by 14 percent when taking into account the rise in prices since the onset of the crisis in the last quarter of 2007. These are figures —you and everyone else are well aware— very harsh.

I would like to know your assessment of these figures and your view on the fact that the level of well-being of Spaniards has decreased during your time in government and on the effectiveness of your economic policy.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I must remind you, regarding that statement you made in the last part of your intervention, that the per capita income of Spaniards since 2003 is 4,300 euros higher. Therefore, regarding the standard of living and income during the overall period of this Government's action, you must introduce that nuance, which I assume will be recognized by Your Honor.

In relation to the repercussions of the crisis on financial wealth, it is evident that in our country and in all countries that have suffered the crisis originating from the financial system, that effect has occurred, and we hope that, with recovery, the new economic model, productivity, and the gains we expect in competitiveness for our country, we will recover in a reasonable timeframe.

Finally, I will tell you that regarding the evolution of prices and inflation, which was also implicit in your question, I must remind you that inflation, which has seen a worrying increase in recent months, is the result of the evolution of oil prices and the evolution of raw materials, because core inflation is absolutely controlled and remains at reasonable levels.

As you also know, the Bank of Spain has just stated that it is reasonable to expect that by the end of 2011, inflation could be around 1.7 percent, which would place us at the average levels of 2010, provided that the price of oil remains at the current 97 dollars. Therefore, it is reasonable to think that as the year progresses, we will see a moderation in the evolution of prices.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President of the Government, Spaniards are paying the consequences of your mistakes: an economic policy that has led us to unemployment levels above 20 percent, more than 4.7 million Spaniards want to work and cannot, and more than 40 percent of young Spaniards under the age of twenty-five cannot find work.

You have raised taxes, those on labor income, savings, and consumption; you have increased VAT and Special Taxes; you have eliminated transfers to families, the "baby check," and deductions for home purchases, and you have reduced non-contributory benefits for dependent children. You have frozen pensions, you have lowered the salaries of civil servants, you have increased regulated prices —the price of electricity has risen by 49 percent under your mandate, as have gas prices, and last year the price of butane gas increased by 19 percent, and by 3 percent so far this year— and, in addition, you have raised RENFE fares by 16 percent in this Legislature. And the inflation figure, Mr. President, is 3.3 percent with negative economic growth last year.

These are the consequences of your mistakes in managing economic policy. You have not been up to the circumstances, you have not managed the Spanish economy well, and the consequences of a misguided policy, of which you were warned in this Chamber and outside of it on numerous occasions, are being paid for by millions and millions of Spanish citizens.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, it is evident that you think the Government is responsible for the rise in oil prices, and one day we will hear you say that it is responsible for Hurricane Katrina, based on your reasoning.

I will remind you that the tax burden today is lower than it was six years ago in Spain, that we have eliminated the Wealth Tax, lowered the Corporate Tax, and lowered the Income Tax, which you do not remember, and that social spending is 40 percent higher than when we came to power and we maintain it despite the crisis. You did nothing in social spending or social benefits.

How can you now talk about the "baby check" if you did not even support the Dependency Law, nor scholarships, nor housing assistance...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran.- Yesterday the Government informed, albeit late, almost a week later, about the content of the Economic and Social Agreement signed with the unions and employers. Does the President of the Government consider that this Agreement can be valued as a State Pact?

President.- Mr. Durán, the Government values it as a social and economic pact of great importance. Then, each one can assign the qualification they deem appropriate.

Why? First, because it represents an act of collective responsibility, a sum of efforts for economic recovery, for job creation, and for the long-term stability of public accounts. This is of great importance for generating trust and credibility in Spanish society and beyond our borders. And, specifically, because very few countries in Europe have seen a long-range pension reform, like the one that has been made here, occur with the agreement of social agents.

It is of great importance, it is a great testimony of collective responsibility, and I hope that the Parliamentary Groups will value and appreciate this circumstance and join an agreement that undoubtedly represents a guarantee of public pensions, of Social Security, and of our strength in the social protection system for Spanish society. I am convinced that your Group will do so.

Mr. Duran.- Parliament should not just join in; Parliament should be the protagonist of any agreement.

But, in any case, I would like to briefly comment on our position regarding the contents of that Economic and Social Agreement. We obviously share the basic framework of the pension agreement, and I have highlighted this. We have publicly congratulated the unions for the effort that this represents, in that positive sense under the prism of development and external projection that you have just outlined.

But we understand, and we explained this to the Government yesterday, that this agreement also lacked the participation of political forces, and I believe that a great opportunity has been lost: the opportunity for all parliamentary political forces to also subscribe, not simply join, but intervene in the negotiation of the agreements that accompany, fundamentally, the pension agreement. The pension agreement, obviously, has an origin, which is the very conclusions of the Toledo Pact developed by this Chamber, and, moreover, Mr. President will recall that the particular vote that we agreed upon with the Socialist Group was fundamental and allowed for a flexibility that was well utilized by the social agents.

I reiterate: we find the lack of participation of political forces in that sense to be regrettable in order to truly be that State Pact that this Parliamentary Group has requested since the beginning of the Legislature.

In those matters that are not pensions, especially in energy, the Agreement provides for a Commission to follow a series of conditions, which the Agreement itself stipulates with unions and employers; among them, the future energy mix. Here there is a variation: in the Subcommittee, a mix was approved until the year 2020, and now it is extended to 2035. The Socialist Group did not want to talk beyond the year 2020 because we would enter into discussions about nuclear energy. Does this mean, Mr. President, that extending that mix to the year 2035 means you are changing, in line with the changes you have made recently, your position also on nuclear energy? I believe that this is the great pending issue, and I would like, once and for all, for you to tell the Chamber what your position is on this matter.

President.- Mr. Durán, I cannot agree with your first statement. On more than one occasion, your Group and other Groups have demanded that the Government take responsibility and make decisions. We have done so with the Agreement, informing before, during, and after the Economic and Social Agreement to the groups. So much so that some union, Mr. Durán, has recognized its role. So, how is it possible that a union recognizes its constructive role in favoring the agreement and then you say that it has not had a leading role? Of course it has had, but… Yes, Mr. Durán.

And I want to tell you that the Government has exercised its responsibility, has provided information, and has achieved an important agreement that has all the parliamentary translation and protagonism in its development, as it has always been. I know it is difficult to sometimes recognize things; but this Agreement has been a very good political action and an important exercise of responsibility from all. We should recognize it, and I hope that your Group will be up to what this Agreement represents, as it has been on other occasions, and work on the content.

Finally, regarding any issue that the Agreement contains, the Government is always flexible in seeking consensus. We do not have positions…