Press conference by the President of the European Council, the President of the European Commission and the President of the Government following the session of the European Council
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero, Van Rompuy, and Barroso addressed press at the March 2010 European Council summit in Brussels, presenting outcomes on Greece, the EU 2020 Strategy, and climate change.
- Main themes
- EU 2020 Strategy, economic growth and employment, Greek debt crisis, Eurozone financial stability, climate change negotiations, G-20 Toronto summit, social market economy, poverty reduction, Research & Development, energy policy, education targets, European Council outcomes
- Duration
- ~34 min
- Words
- 4,089
- Sentences
- 163
- Readability
- 45
- Grade
- 13.3
- Syntax
- 3.04
- Vocabulary
- 2.08
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
163 sentences in 70 paragraphs
Mr Van Rompuy. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen. This is the second time we are here talking to you in less than twenty-four hours but I am very pleased to be doing so.
Prime Minister Rodríguez Zapatero, rotating President of the Presidency of the European Union, the President of the European Commission and I are here today to present the results from yesterday's and today's sessions of the European Council.
We will talk no further about the agreement that was reached yesterday on the badly-named Greek "problem". We have spoken about the 2020 Strategy; the Strategy to boost employment and economic growth. This morning, we also spoke about an agenda for the G-20 meeting to be held in June in Toronto.
President Rodríguez Zapatero, President Durao Barroso and I will be attending that highly-important G-20 meeting. We also spoke about the much-needed talks on climate change.
Let me start with the 2020 Strategy. President Durao Barroso will provide more details on this issue and I must limit myself to providing a brief introduction. Our objective was clear before this Council met: the objective was for the European Council to sign up to the five main objectives; the objectives that mark out the guidelines for the measures we need to adopt over the next ten years, the period covered by the 2020 Strategy.
It could be said that those objectives represent something like a summary of the European model; the European model we have inherited and that we seek to strengthen. We are talking about a social market economy model with a strong focus on the environment. We want a solid economy but an economy that also considers environmental and social factors. Therein lies the added value of our policy and that is what today's Europe wishes to leave behind for future generations, that is what makes the European model stand out when compared with the rest of the world.
We therefore need strong economic growth, but growth that respects the characteristics of the social model while also respecting the environment, which is something very European.
Therefore, this first part of the European Council was devoted to gaining approval for those five objectives, which I believe to be the most important achievement at the moment.
In terms of the fight against climate change, we are not giving up on our ambitions but we are indeed aware that, following the Copenhagen Summit, there is a need for a more gradual approach. We are going to try and encourage a more dynamic approach to the talks over the coming months, first in June in Bonn with a meeting of forty countries and later, towards the end of the year, in Cancun.
We have a series of ambitious targets but we are aware that not everything can be achieved immediately; progress must be achieved step by step.
Over the coming weeks and months, we are going to contact the mayor players on issues related to the environment in order to regain confidence and thus get closer to our goals.
Those are the three issues that were discussed: the 2020 Strategy; preparations for the G-20 meeting in June in Canada; and the steps to be taken, or the position to be adopted, for the high-level talks on climate change. I think this has been a very significant European Council, especially after what was achieved at yesterday's session.
Now I will give the floor to my colleagues so they can provide further details on the issues that most affect them.
Mr Durao Barroso. This Summit has done what all European Councils should do: respond to the needs of the moment and work on the long-term future of Europe.
I would like to add my weight to what President Van Rompuy has just said. This has been a very successful Summit; not only because of the historic agreement we reached on Greece and in favour of financial stability in the Eurozone (the agreement will be applied to the Eurozone), but also because of the long-term challenges we have discussed today: the G-20; climate change; and also the new Strategy for sustainable growth and job creation, the 2020 Strategy.
On the issue of Greece, I would like to stress the following: I hope now that the financial markets will act on facts and not on fiction. I think the decision adopted by the Eurozone yesterday was a very important one.
In terms of the 2020 Strategy, I am extremely pleased that we have an agreement based on the proposals made by the Commission. We have now defined the agenda for an inclusive, sustainable and intelligent Europe. We are basing ourselves on five specific objectives that focus on: employment; Research & Development; energy and climate action; education; and poverty and the fight against social exclusion.
We are all agreed to keep working between now and June on education and the goal to reduce poverty because what we want is, in June, for us to not only have global European objectives but also national objectives that will, of course, have to be coherent with the European objectives.
It is also very important to reach a specific agreement on these two objectives; education and the fight against social exclusion, because they also present the social approach required by our common Strategy.
I am also very pleased with our progress on climate change issues because we have managed to achieve widespread consensus on maintaining climate change in our agenda and enjoyed highly-productive debate on how to continue dealing with this issue. In fact, we are already in contact with the majority of our most important partners. Investigation is under way and I believe we will be able to work on the results of that investigation for Europe to continue leading the way, to maintain its leadership on such an important topic.
President Van Rompuy has asked that I present the situation regarding our preparations for the G-20 meeting. Basically, the European Union has been the group that has given impetus to the G-20 and presented its ideas at that forum. It is a process that began with the initiative of the European Union and I believe that the unity of all G-20 members is fundamental. We must also represent the twenty-seven Member States of the European Union.
Regarding the agenda of the G-20, I will speak about openness and cooperation in a situation of equality, of support for global recovery and of setting the financial markets on the solid foundations they need; everything is in the interests of Europe and the global community.
Therefore, before Toronto, we must agree on such fundamental aspects as financial issues and banking capital. It is also important to agree on a supervision package so that the authorities can be up and running and operational from 2011. I think it is very important for Europe to do its homework, finish its work, so that we can go to Toronto and show our partners what we have achieved, what we have done, on the issue of regulation and supervision so we are in a position to create a situation of equality at a global level.
At the same time, it is very important for the leaders of the G-20 not to dilute or reduce their ambitions. We have seen signs of this happening. Since the crisis has not been as acute as it was a short while ago, there is probably no longer the same level of commitment from all sides when it comes to promoting financial reform, supervision, the establishment of that level of equality, that situation of equality, and to combating protectionism.
So, I also believe it is important to have new ideas, ideas that we are currently working on. I believe we must drive the G-20 and tackle the question of banking recovery, the issue of banking tariffs and the issue of derivatives. These are things that the European Union is well-positioned to provide fresh ideas on.
For the European Commission, these have been the most important aspects of this European Council and I would like to offer my sincere congratulations to Herman Van Rompuy on the manner in which he has led this European Council; extremely important work that led to the success we achieved yesterday and today.
President of the Government. I would like to express my satisfaction with the conclusions from this Council because we had set a target for these six months to tackle, above all, the economic future of the European Union, to contribute towards the recovery of the European economy and job creation, and to define the main objectives for the next ten years.
The various committees of the Council have been working hard so that this Council would be able to approve the major guidelines for the 2020 Strategy and commit itself to having, by June, developed that 2020 Strategy for the European economy over the next ten years. We have achieved that; job done.
I must congratulate the Commission on having drafted the strategy and the President of the Council for knowing how to manage and integrate the conclusions that define the main economic objectives for the European Union over the coming years.
However, I must emphasise the essential ideal that exists in the conclusions, supporting the 2020 Strategy; the ideal of coordination, union for a coordinated economic policy, union for the economic governance of the twenty-seven Member States. This is a massive leap forward.
Today, we have approved our collective task, the task to be undertaken by the twenty-seven Member States as a whole. In June, we will also have to approve the task to be undertaken by each one of the twenty-seven individual Member States because, as the Commission well knows, the credibility of the 2020 Strategy will be in its implementation. Therefore, the working methodology strengthens the demands on all countries, gives the Commission more powers and commits the European Council, which is basically where we can find the individuals most responsible for each one of the countries in the Union.
I am particularly satisfied that the objectives are specific objectives and that they tackle the main problems faced by the Union in terms of its economy for maintaining stable growth and improving its growth potential: education, research, innovation and the fight against climate change. I believe that we can therefore congratulate ourselves on the work we have done.
We can also congratulate ourselves on the commitment the Council has made for there to be a debated and common position ahead of the G-20 meeting in Toronto, because the economic future of the European Union will not only depend on what we do in Europe but will also depend on the general rules of the international economy: rules to deal with existing imbalances and rules on the financial system and climate change.
We would be unable to discuss all aspects of an economic strategy in depth if Europe, as it has been doing until now, does not maintain its initiative in the field of international economics at the G-20. We have made a commitment to that and also to remain loyal to our position on climate change.
Finally, I would like to mention one other thing. Although it has not been an issue directly related to talks by the Council, I would like to mention the conflict between Switzerland and Libya; an issue that occupied many hours of diplomatic work, especially for the Minister for Foreign Affairs.
I would like to say that we are pleased to see the lifting of restrictions on the entry of Libyan citizens into the Schengen area and we hope that the Libyan authorities will take immediate action to lift restrictions on the entry of European citizens into Libyan territory. We regret the problems that may have been experienced by the Libyan citizens affected by this measure. We hope that a solution can be found to this conflict quickly and that the Swiss citizen can return to his country as soon as possible.
The Spanish Minister for Foreign Affairs and Cooperation continues to work towards finding a solution to this contentious issue and will travel to Libya tomorrow, Saturday.
Q. A question to the two Presidents, basically about the objectives of the fight against poverty appearing in the 2020 Strategy. I believe there was a series of numeric targets proposed by the Commission regarding a 25% reduction in poverty. These numbers have disappeared from the conclusions. Why is that? Why do the Heads of State and Government not accept the proposal made by the Commission? Do the Heads of State and Government think that the fight against poverty is perhaps not so important? Do you not think it strange to send this message this year in particular; the European Year on Combating Poverty?
Mr Durao Barroso. We did indeed speak a little about this issue and I made it quite clear that the European Union must also tackle the issue of poverty and the fight against social exclusion. I'll be frank with you; certain concerns were put forward, not because some people are against the fight against poverty, because, logically, by definition, the entire world is against poverty, but because there is a problem of competency. Is it a national issue or is it something for Europe to tackle? So I consulted the Lisbon Treaty and the Treaty on the functioning of the European Union has an entire section devoted to Social Policy.
Article 151, in fact, mentions the fight against exclusion as one of the most important objectives. Article 153, I quote, states: "With a view to achieving the objectives of Article 151, the Union shall support and complement the activities of the Member States in the following fields…". There then follows a list of fields that includes the fight against social exclusion. So, let it be clear that there is national competency on combating poverty and social exclusion but it is also something within the powers of the European Union because the European Union shall support and complement the activities of the Member States in this field.
That is an important point; very important, in fact, because there are some national policies that consider, due to the issue of subsidiarity, that the European Union should not get involved in the fight against poverty.
So, what is the conclusion? We are going to keep working on the objective but the truth is that no agreement has been reached for now on quantification.
More work needs to be done and work must be done on the indicators. I think it is a very honest way of putting it, because we want the Member States to be there and to know exactly what they are going to do, if they agree of course.
In fact, the conclusions make it quite clear: there are common objectives, based on the five main objectives, and one of them is to promote social inclusion, above all through the reduction of poverty. That is what was agreed today; a common objective for the European Union: to promote social inclusion, above all through the reduction of poverty. And we added the need for more work on the appropriate indicators. The European Council will discuss this issue again at its meeting in June 2010.
We must keep working on the quantification, we accept that and we are working on that; but I think we have made good progress because all Governments unanimously agree that the fight against poverty and the promotion of social inclusion is a common objective.
Mr Van Rompuy. A quick answer. You should realise that we have the five main objectives of the Economic Strategy and that we have today included the fight against poverty. It seemed essential to us because it forms an integral part of the European model in our opinion, the European model as we know it today.
So, we have a series of mainly economic objectives, other mainly ecological objectives and one objective that is essentially social in nature. Both the President of the Commission and the Spanish Prime Minister have fought extremely hard over these last few days and hours for this objective to be included among the main objectives of the 2020 Strategy.
As the President of the Commission has already said, there is a problem of competency for some people while others understand that the Commission can play an active role in the issue of social inclusion; there was also a statistical problem regarding how poverty is measured, on which there are also different opinions; and then we have a problem that is almost of a conceptual nature: creating more jobs is already fighting against poverty, so if creating jobs is already one of the objectives, why do we need an additional objective of fighting poverty if we already have one for creating jobs?
Not everyone was convinced but, fortunately, this objective now forms an integral part of the objectives for the 2020 Strategy. We will keep working in that direction. In June, specific numbers will be proposed and I am convinced that full consensus will be reached. In other words, in three months time, you will have the objectives for the fight against poverty, which is what you want and what we want too.
Q. A question for President José Luís Rodríguez Zapatero. I would like to know whether you feel Spain is referred to or reflected by the passage contained in the Conclusions that calls on the countries with the greatest losses of competitiveness and with the largest current account deficits to take steps to correct those imbalances. How are you going to respond to that call from the European Union, which seems aimed squarely at the southern countries? Do you not believe that, while talking about imbalances, it would also be necessary to mention the commercial surpluses of some countries or the low domestic consumption of others, as was suggested by the French Minister, Christine Lagarde, in regard to Germany?
President of the Government. On the issue of competitiveness, the Council in its final Conclusions included a paragraph that reads: "the European Union must focus itself on the pressing challenges of competitiveness and progress on the balance of payments. The European Council will again discuss this issue in June 2010". That is what it says, literally.
I must say that the debate we will have in June 2010 at the Council, coinciding with the approval of the 2020 Strategy guidelines, is a debate of extreme importance. Yesterday, Felipe González and Jean-Claude Trichet both introduced this debate brilliantly; Felipe González in the part referring to the economy of the Report on the reflection of the future for Europe, which will be presented in May. He invited President Van Rompuy to the dinner and the truth is that the two Reports contained a lot of interesting information.
However, I should point out that the debate on competitiveness has many different angles when it comes to establishing the criteria for competitiveness.
Why? For example, Spain appears in the reports with a loss of competitiveness since we joined the Euro, but it is no less true to say that Spain is one of the few countries in the Eurozone and the European Union that has maintained its international market share over this period; Spain has not lost market share. The majority of other countries have lost market share in terms of international trade, Spain has not.
That is something that would need further examination and, therefore, we have a debate pending on the topic of competitiveness; an essential debate. In my opinion, the leadership and initiative of President Van Rompuy, who has placed particular emphasis on the issue of competitiveness as one of the keys to the economic future of the European Union, are spot on.
We are going to analyse the whole and the individual problems of each country. That is coordination and coordination is good. The Commission will set the pace and provide supervision, it will make demands and, of course, Spain will do everything it possibly can, with guidance from the Commission, to improve competitiveness as we have been doing until now.
But, I insist, this issue requires more in-depth debate from an economic point of view about what it represents and the impact of competitiveness.
Q. I would like to ask the President of the Spanish Government for some clarification or additional information about last night's dinner with the former President of the Spanish Government, Felipe González.
Felipe González said a short while ago that one of the problems with Europe is the devilishly perverse way it has of making decision. With that in mind, I would like to know what ideas were put forward last night during the dinner for economic governance or Government to be less devilish.
President of the Government. As regards the methodology, in terms of the economic decisions and economic policy of the European Union, Felipe González made a cutting remark that was the main idea he provided on the issue: "the European Council must have more leadership on issues of economic policy". That is precisely what Felipe González said last night.
This is one of the endless debates that remain unresolved but I believe we need to distinguish between two levels. I will give you my opinion: I believe that the Council should have more responsibility in economic policy or, in other words, more capacity to commit on decisions that are taken to coordinate economic policy; and we should maintain the role that the Commission basically already has.
The European method is what guarantees European progress, progress on specific decisions, on facts, and we must therefore have a reasonable balance in what, in my opinion, I understand as the responsibility of the Council. We can now add to that responsibility with the Presidency of the European Council because it is a continued, sustained, responsibility that is above and beyond the more individual responsibility of Presidents of Government or Heads of State. The Council will gain that, is gaining that, with the Presidency and also through the work done by Herman Van Rompuy.
However, it should remain clear that the powers of initiative, that the demands of the Treaties and that international representation on economic issues lie in the hands of the Commission.
Q. A question for Mr Rodríguez Zapatero regarding his statement. It seems that Switzerland is greatly affecting the solidarity of the European Union. Switzerland has now taken a large step forward and has said: we are doing away with the blacklist of Libyan citizens. Does that mean there can now be more solidarity by the Union and a better situation between Switzerland and the European Union?
President of the Government. Yes, that is the goal and I hope that it can be concluded in the next few hours or days. As I said, the Minister for Foreign Affairs will travel to Libya tomorrow and we hope to be able to resolve this conflictive situation that, without a doubt, has damaged everyone concerned. That is the objective and I believe we are very close to achieving it.
Q. A question for President Van Rompuy. I would like to know whether, outside of the Council, you have spoken with the Slovenian Prime Minister about the Brdo Conference and about the Conference held recently in Slovenia. I would like to know whether you are satisfied with the results of that Conference and whether you support a continuation of the Brdo process, a process in which attempts are being made to combine the efforts of all the countries in the region with the future perspective of Serbia also taking part in those meetings.
Mr Van Rompuy. I published a statement to the press saying that I welcomed that Conference, that gesture; that I like the main objective of the Conference, which was regional cooperation; that I wished the greatest success for that Conference, to that process; and I also announced that I was going to travel to all the Western Balkan capitals in May.
In other words, any kind of collaboration in the region seems excellent in my opinion and any Conference that helps all the countries of the region participate in the process seems a good idea to me. But I am going to visit the seven or eight capitals to convey the main message: they all have a European perspective, whether it be sooner or later but they do have a European perspective.
I have spoken with the Slovenian President, but I believe we understand each other perfectly. We are in perfect harmony.
Thank you very much.