Press conference of the President of the Government and the President of the French Republic after the Spanish-French Summit.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

6 December 2004 · Spanish-French bilateral Summit · Zaragoza, Spain

Context
Zapatero addressed a joint press conference with France's president following the first Spain-France bilateral summit, held in Zaragoza on December 6, 2004.
Main themes
Spain-France bilateral relations, European Constitution ratification, fight against ETA and international terrorism, European defense cooperation, energy and infrastructure connectivity, multilateralism, economic cooperation and innovation, anti-drug trafficking, Millennium development goals, Pyrenees cross-border communications
Duration
~47 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,592
93rd percentile
Sentences
186
87th percentile
Readability
41
39th percentile
Grade
14.7
73rd percentile
Syntax
3.32
84th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

186 sentences in 80 paragraphs

President .- We are going to begin this appearance, which aims to inform about the development of the bilateral Summit between Spain and France, a bilateral Summit that is being held in Zaragoza. I want to first express my gratitude to the city of Zaragoza, to the Autonomous Community of Aragón, and to its representatives for their hospitality, for the facilities, and for the kindness shown during the course of this bilateral Summit.

You know that this is the first bilateral Summit between Spain and France of the Government that emerged from the general elections of March 14, and we can say at this first bilateral Summit, after both Governments have already worked over these months in practically all areas, that relations between Spain and France are at an excellent moment.

The relations are positive in all areas. In the area of the vision of European construction, we are two countries, we are two Governments committed to the ratification of the European Constitution; we are two countries that will hold referendums; we are two countries that call on citizens to participate in the process of European construction.

France and Spain want a strong Europe; France and Spain want a united Europe; France and Spain want a constitutional Europe, a Europe of security and freedom, a Europe of economic stability and solidarity for Europe and solidarity in the international order; France and Spain consider it essential, for a balanced international order, in peace, with opportunities for those peoples who face the greatest difficulties, a strong and united Europe, broad, with a generous vision, with an ambitious vision of its history and its role in history. Undoubtedly, the contribution of France and Spain to that European process, which is a civilizational process without parallel, is enormously decisive.

I know that this European will will make our Governments share a common vision on 90 percent of the challenges we face on the European agenda: Stability Pact; Financial Perspectives; economic boost through knowledge and innovation; willingness to open up the European Union; an increasingly solid pillar of justice, freedom, and security; defense of multilateralism in all international instances; defense and promotion of the Alliance against Hunger, of what it means to effectively meet the Millennium goals, of opening new expectations for development and cooperation. These are great values, the values for modern societies and for a just world, and they are the values shared by Spain and France.

In the bilateral area, we have focused our common task on the following aspects: first, in the fight against terrorism, against ETA terrorism and against international terrorism.

I want to express, on behalf of the Spanish people, with all solemnity, the deep gratitude that Spain has for France, for its Government, for its President, and for its Minister of the Interior for the extraordinarily important cooperation in the fight against ETA terrorism. That task of defeating and holding accountable those who are in the world of violence would not be possible without intense cooperation from France.

The successes in the fight against terrorism that we have experienced in recent months are, to a large extent, the result of the effort, interest, and solidarity of France. I want all Spaniards to know this, because I know they are the first to have deep gratitude. There is nothing like feeling deeply supported when it comes to defending the freedom and life of citizens.

This cooperation in the fight against terrorism will be intensified: it will be intensified in the field of international terrorism with the development of joint teams, but it will also intensify that will to defend security and freedom against what organized crime and drug trafficking represent. There will also be joint research and work teams between Spain and France in this field. This, without a doubt, will yield concrete and positive results in the short term.

Alongside this, aspects related to defense, to the shared vision of promoting a European defense, to various joint military initiatives where France and Spain are participating and will participate in the construction of that European Defense Space, are also included. The strengthening that is being observed and that will increase in the field of military armament between France and Spain is also moving in the direction of strengthening the idea of European defense and, in this case, the idea of the European military industry.

The field of the energy industry has also played an important role in this Summit: the willingness to intensify, to relaunch, the electrical connection, and the willingness to work in the field of industry, in the context of an active industrial policy, as a policy before the European Union, as a shared policy before the European Union, and as a policy of bilateral cooperation.

Of course, communications on both sides of the Pyrenees have also occupied a central aspect of this Summit. As you know, the transport of people and the transport of goods are in need, in the context of the Pyrenees, in the context of the trans-Pyrenean connection, of significant efforts in transport infrastructure both by rail and by road; and complementarily, but also importantly, maritime transport, where we have opened new expectations.

I want to tell you that today’s Summit represents a thorough relaunch of the willingness for the planned connections, some of which are in development and execution, both by rail and by high-capacity roadways, to take maximum pace. But the willingness to do things that benefit, of course, Spain, but also France, in the context of that space that is the Pyrenees, which should not be a space of separation, but a space of opportunity and union for our economies and for broad regions of both countries, will continue.

We have agreed to hold a specific monographic Summit of the Spanish Autonomous Communities bordering France and the bordering regions and territorial communities in the Pyrenees on the French side. At that Summit, both Prime Ministers and representatives of both territorial instances will attend. It will serve not only to update the entire agenda of communication by road and by rail but also to explore other opportunities for working together for the development of industrial spaces, to avoid relocations, and to promote what could be new joint initiatives under the principle of cooperation.

We will hold that Summit in the first half of 2005. I suppose there will already be some offer, some proposal, to hold it in a specific location.

In short, it is an excellent moment for relations between Spain and France. I want to emphasize that this is of enormous importance for Spain, because France is Spain's first customer and second supplier, while Spain is France's second customer and third supplier. Moreover, France, after the United Kingdom and Germany, is our third tourist market, which we logically want to increase. Hence, there is a very important economic interaction between the two countries and a very significant economic dependence.

The fact that the political relationship, the European vision, and the bilateral agenda are progressing at a magnificent pace and in a tone of full harmony is, from my point of view, very good news; but above all, I want to conclude by thanking President Chirac for his constructive will and thanking President Chirac for his willingness to cooperate in the construction of the European Union. President Chirac is undoubtedly a bulwark of Europeanist principles; those Europeanist principles that have brought so much benefit, in terms of progress and freedoms, to Spain, to Spanish society; those Europeanist principles that I share and those Europeanist principles that I hope, without a doubt, will be ratified in the process of the European Constitution.

Thank you, therefore, to President Chirac, to Prime Minister Raffarin, and to the French delegation; and especially thank you, especially thank you, for your attitude in the fight against terrorism, which is so important to our country.

Mr. Chirac .- Ladies and gentlemen, first of all, I would like to express my warmest gratitude to President José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero, both for the reception we have had here and for his willingness to engage in dialogue and his desire to fully participate in the construction of Europe, with a hand extended towards France and the other countries of the European Union.

I would like to thank the Ministers who have accompanied him, and I would also like to thank the President of the Autonomous Community of Aragón, both for his welcome and for the very interesting analysis he has made on behalf of the other Presidents of the Autonomous Communities close to us, which has been particularly appreciated by the French Government and by the Prime Minister.

I would also like to thank the people of Zaragoza, because a Summit, whatever it may be, always poses many problems for the citizens of a city. Nevertheless, we have been received with great kindness. I have asked the Mayor, but I have also asked the President of the Autonomous Community and the President of the Government to convey to the people of Zaragoza our warmest esteem and recognition.

This Summit, indeed, has taken place in an excellent atmosphere; Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero said so a moment ago, and it is true. This Summit is part of a common will to act together in all areas.

On the other hand, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero has said that we agree on 90 percent of the issues, and I would add that in the remaining 10 percent we are also determined to find an agreement. This allows us, the French, to feel satisfied with this fraternity of action that has always been fundamental for us and that is justified by Spain's eminent place in European construction and in the Europe of the future.

I would like to warmly thank the Spanish Government for this willingness, a willingness that I am sure will be widely approved soon, since Spain will be the first country, not to ratify, but to ratify the Constitution through a referendum. This will be extraordinarily symbolic and will place Spain completely in the forefront of European momentum. I wish—and I do not want to interfere in Spain's affairs—that the Spanish people respond massively. I have no doubt that they will respond, but I hope they do so massively to perfectly show the way, which is the trust we must have in the Europe of the future.

Our cooperation in all areas has been mentioned by the Prime Minister, and I will not dwell on them. Regarding police and judicial cooperation, it is truly excellent. It covers all forms of criminality, whether it be ETA or other forms of terrorism, which Spain had to pay so dearly for on March 11. We are completely by your side, and it is evident that this action of cooperation without any reservations, which must be continuously improved in the technical aspect, will continue and be intensified, which everyone should know.

As for the important European issues, we have noted, first of all, our common position on Turkey. We are both in favor of Turkey's integration or, more precisely, the start of a negotiation process to see if it is possible for us to integrate Turkey. Naturally, we wish for this to be possible for many reasons, particularly because Europe, with a Turkey that adheres unreservedly to the values that characterize Europe, will logically be stronger, more powerful, and will count for more in the world of tomorrow in all aspects: political, economic, or cultural.

I have indicated that, logically, when a negotiation is undertaken, one can never be sure that it will reach a successful conclusion, that it will be Turkey that analyzes under what conditions it can adhere to the set of European values and the values of a market economy, such as democracy. I repeat it and I ardently wish it; otherwise, a solution must logically be found that allows for maintaining a very close contact between Turkey and Europe.

We have mentioned, of course, the Financial Perspectives. Here we know perfectly well that there are divergences in approach among the different European countries; we know perfectly well that each one has its concerns, and all our energy will be mobilized to reduce those divergences and find the solution that will allow us to move forward together, once again, hand in hand, in European construction while resolving, on the other hand, the budgetary problems that this entails. We are fully determined.

We have also highlighted our total convergence in the field of major international issues. First of all, public development aid and the fight against poverty, which hits the world so dramatically. Together with Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, with President Lula, and with President Lagos, as you know, we organized a meeting at the United Nations a few weeks ago, which was a great success; a meeting that allowed us to prepare for the 2005 Summit on the implementation of the Millennium commitments, particularly foreseeing the implementation of innovative means to achieve these Millennium goals.

We had, I must say, the great satisfaction of seeing the proposal of the four of us who were there approved by more than a hundred countries and endorsed by the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank.

It has been a success. I must say that we did not expect it, and it will allow us to approach the preparation for the United Nations Summit of 2005 with much more energy and will to achieve an improvement in the situation of the poorest in the world.

We have mentioned, and the President of the Government has said, the problems of the Middle East: Israeli-Palestinian, on one hand; Iraqi on the other. Here we have exactly the same approach and the same desire to see the process undertaken to achieve an improvement in the situation. We will contribute our input as intensely as possible in the political aspect to ensure that the situation improves.

We have addressed, of course, our relations with the Maghreb. It is a matter of common concern and, in particular, within the framework of the Barcelona Process and the Euro-Mediterranean Process. Here we also have the same approach and the same ambition, the same objectives, and we will express them very clearly in a meeting convened by the President of the Spanish Government, which will take place in Barcelona in 2005 to mark the tenth anniversary of the launch of the Barcelona Process, the Euro-Mediterranean partnership process; a meeting that will take place at the level of Heads of State and Government.

We have affirmed our total and restless convergence of views on the issues on the agenda of the Buenos Aires Conference regarding the dangers currently facing the planet in terms of climate and global warming. We fully share the same analysis to try to take measures, after the approval of the Kyoto Protocol, that are truly effective in protecting the environment of our planet.

Finally, we spoke today, since it is today that it happened, with friendly sympathy about the investiture of the new President of Afghanistan, President Karzai, and we also called -- we did it together -- the Secretary-General of the United Nations, Mr. Kofi Annan, to express our esteem, our friendship, and our solidarity.

Q.- I would like to ask two questions to both Presidents. Obviously, you have analyzed and assessed the recent terrorist attacks by ETA, which occur at a time when the terrorist group seemed to be on the verge of being suppressed. I would like to know how you assess these attacks, what political evaluation you make of them, and whether you think they are an inevitable accident or if there has been some failure of coordination in cooperation, or on the part of the forces on either side.

Then, returning to the international issue, for example, you called Annan with a shared viewpoint on his situation. I would like to know if this agreement also extends to the policy towards Cuba, where Spanish initiatives have recently been heavily criticized by a senior official of the State Department.

Mr. Chirac.- Do not consider that the truth necessarily emanates from the mouth of a senior official of such or such State Department. I not only have not criticized it, but I have perfectly approved the approach taken by Spain regarding Cuba and, moreover, I note that it has had positive effects, particularly regarding the release of personalities who were imprisoned.

As for the attacks, I prefer to leave it to President Rodríguez Zapatero to give his point of view, which I, a priori and in advance, endorse.

President.- Regarding the first question, the results of the actions that have taken place in recent weeks and months against the terrorist group ETA in collaboration with the French police have undoubtedly been of enormous significance. It is evident that this has resulted in a notable reduction in the operational capacity of a terrorist organization like ETA; but I want to remind you that the Minister of the Interior, like all Ministers of the Interior, has emphasized that the criminal band, the terrorist band, ETA can have the capacity to carry out an action at any moment.

ETA is much weaker, but it has the capacity to cause harm. What needs to be said to the terrorist band ETA and to all those who have remained silent in the face of violence or have looked the other way is that they have only one horizon and only one destiny: to be defeated by democracy due to its moral superiority and because violence will never, ever, succeed in changing any political architecture.

And, of course, I want to emphasize the great work that day by day the State Security Forces and Corps do, which have had, I insist, very effective actions and, even, also effective when there is a capacity to respond to bomb threats to ensure that those threats do not have painful consequences.

Secondly, regarding Cuba, I refer to the assessment made by the people who have been released. I refer specifically to the assessment made by Raul Rivero regarding the effects of one policy or another. Of course, neither my Government nor Spain wants the evident and positive results that have occurred regarding the release of people in Cuba to be credited to anyone in particular. It is the merit of all democrats, of all. What, evidently, cannot be is that it is a demerit of some of those democrats. It is for all.

Q.- I would like to ask Mr. Chirac and Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero how the initiative to speak with Mr. Kofi Annan arose, if you can give us a preview or comment on the content of the conversation, and if you are concerned that this attitude could be interpreted as a gesture of some hostility by Washington, which seems determined, in some way, to get rid of Mr. Annan, judging by the news.

Another question for Mr. Chirac. Returning to the issue of community funds, I would like to know if, in general terms, France shares Spain's claim for a gradual reduction of funds in the case of Spain.

Mr. Chirac.- Regarding the first point, I would say that everyone in Europe -- and I refer to the political leaders of Europe -- has great esteem for Mr. Kofi Annan and much recognition for the action he has carried out, without relaxation, to support peace and democracy. At a time when some voices, of which we can question the background they hide, are trying to call into question the merits and credentials of Mr. Kofi Annan, everyone in Europe, as indeed in Africa and also in Asia, has considered it legitimate to express our esteem, our recognition, and our friendship to the Secretary-General of the United Nations. With this spirit and no other, today Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero and I have called him.

You mentioned the financing of the Union. I have said it before. We have a problem here that must be resolved. I fully understand the position of Germany, the largest financial contributor in the Union, which wishes to limit spending so that it can limit its own contribution, especially at a time when it is facing budgetary difficulties. That is normal. France, for its part, also has concerns, whether regarding the financing of the Common Agricultural Policy, which for us is a very important element of European balance, or regarding regional policy, which is also important, in our view, in certain regions. France therefore expresses its concerns.

As for Spain, it is really evident that it is legitimate for it to say: be careful, logically our standard of living has increased, logically transfers cannot continue to be what they have been; but in an economic system, one cannot suddenly provoke a rupture, because that would have, of course, both economic and politically traumatic consequences.

Therefore, each one has a point of view that is perfectly explainable, and from that moment on, we have different viewpoints, we have two hypotheses: the first is to fight, which inevitably leads to failure for all; the second is to understand each other and embark on the necessary dialogue to find a solution that is collectively in line with the essential interests of each one. There is no problem that does not have a solution when there is a political will to find a solution. With this spirit, we address this problem, both the Spaniards and the Germans or the French. We have a year to resolve it, and we will resolve it, you can be absolutely sure.

President.- Just to ensure I answer the question, the support we have shown today to Kofi Annan personally is the result of a coincidence of backing for what have been the task and attitude of Kofi Annan in defense of the United Nations. As Secretary-General of the United Nations, I believe he has been a defender of the values and principles of the United Nations. Therefore, it is natural that many other governments and many other countries in the world are expressing their support to him, which, on the other hand, the Spanish Government had already conveyed to him a few days ago through a telegram.

Q.- Since Spain will be the first European country to organize a referendum on the Constitution, I would like to know if you have invited Heads of State and Government to come and campaign for the yes vote and if Jacques Chirac will come.

President.- I appreciate the question. We are facing a referendum in Spain, but it is a referendum for Europe, and therefore, the Government of Spain has a huge interest in the participation of great European bastions, of great leaders in European construction. I have invited President Chirac, and President Chirac has kindly accepted the invitation and will be, along with Chancellor Schröder, at an event on February 11 in Barcelona in defense of the "yes" to the European Constitution and, more importantly, at an event not only in defense of the "yes," but to explain the Constitution and the European project.

Mr. Chirac.- Your colleague wants to have a useless confirmation. President Rodríguez Zapatero has said it, and it is true. I will respond to your invitation with Gerhard Schröder in a pedagogical exercise that has nothing political about it and does not imply any interference in the internal affairs of any country, of course not in Spain, naturally. Therefore, I will be, at the invitation of Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, with Gerhard Schröder in Barcelona.

Q.- I wanted to ask, first of all, the French President. Since we are talking about the European Constitution and the referendum that will take place in Spain, I would like you to assess what the yes vote given by the French socialists to the European Constitution just a few days ago, on December 1, will mean for France.

And for both of you. In that 10 percent that President Chirac says are issues on which you do not agree, I would like to know if, in addition to the issue of funds, the issue of Turkey could also be one of these matters.

Mr. Chirac.- Dear Madam, I took the liberty of saying earlier, perhaps with insufficient clarity, that Turkey was an area where we were in total agreement. If you insist particularly, I can start again, which would lead me to repeat very exactly what I said before.

Regarding the campaign for the referendum, it is really essential for the future of Europe, and I wish that Spain, I repeat again, will set an example for the whole of Europe called to testify through referendum; and that it does so by demonstrating Spanish faith, Spanish enthusiasm, and whose breadth is not only, I repeat, at the level of the number of yes votes, but also of participation, is crucial. Spain's responsibility today is very great in this regard. It is fundamental that the other peoples who will follow in terms of referendum can be energized by Spain and by the will expressed by the Spanish people and their confidence in the future of Europe, of which I certainly have no doubt.

As for my participation in a campaign, this campaign for Europe should not be confused in its objective. It is about Europe, exclusively about Europe and whether new institutions are wanted that allow for a more effective Europe or not. That is the only issue, that is the question posed in the referendum, and it must be completely disconnected from the internal political concerns of the different countries and the different democracies that make up Europe. Each one, of course, has the vocation to engage politically in one way or another; but here we are formulating a clear question that implies that the campaign should be a clear campaign, that should not be tainted, let us say, by any element of internal politics, except for a certain vision of Europe.

President.- Regarding the 90 percent, which is an expression that everyone can understand, there is one thing on which we do not agree, and that is on the candidacy for the 2012 Olympic Games, although we have emphasized that it will be, on the part of our two cities, a clean contest, a contest with a great spirit.

Mr. Chirac.- Naturally, I endorse what Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero has just said; but I would just like to say to the journalist who just asked the question that he does not seem to have understood my reflection very well, which may have been poorly formulated.

I said that we had, perhaps, 90 percent of agreements and 10 percent of issues that could give rise to disagreements, but that we are determined to transform, whatever they may be, into matters of agreement, which means that, in fact, we agree on 100 percent of things. It is a political will that we have expressed clearly.

P.- I would like to ask President Rodríguez Zapatero to confirm whether it is true that the Government is planning or organizing the referendum on February 20 without the participation of the main opposition party, given the attitude of this party in recent weeks.

I would also like to extend the question to President Chirac to know what he thinks of the attitude of the Spanish conservatives and whether he believes, as they say, that the Popular Party is formally interested in a "yes," but does not have an attitude, shall we say, of explicit support for the referendum in order to undermine the Spanish Government. I would like to know if that is true.

Then, a clarification to the Spanish President. I have heard you mention the word defeat of ETA twice in your expression while discussing this issue. Does that mean that you consider any avenue opened by Batasuna to change its attitude to be closed?

President.- I have expressed myself on that issue many times. ETA has only one destination, and that is to put an end to violence; ETA has only one destination, and that is to abandon arms, and in that task, many efforts from many people, many leaders, and, above all, what is most important, from many citizens have been dedicated.

To those who have been silent, any political organization or political movement that has been silent, I simply reiterate what I have already said on some occasions: to be in the democratic game, to be in democratic institutions, one must condemn and reproach violence. That is the only way to be responsible and the only tolerable way to defend ideas, rejecting and condemning violence.

Certainly, my wish, like that of all Spaniards, is to see one day that many who today look the other way reject violence; have the courage, the political, moral, civic courage, to tell ETA to end the violence; to condemn ETA. I insist, courage. Courage is the only guarantee of freedom.

The Government has organized a campaign to disseminate the text of the Constitution to all Spaniards, and the Government is in the best position to share all kinds of events, debates, initiatives, in the social sphere with all political forces; and, of course, also the Socialist Party.

In the face of a referendum of the importance of what the European Constitution represents, each political force has its responsibility to its voters and to its political project. It is my responsibility to assess and explain the responsibility of the Socialist Party, which will be a firm and clear "yes," which will be a "yes" with arguments and which will be a "yes" with arguments for the future and for the lives of each of the citizens.

From there, I can only express respect for the positions held by other political forces. The Government has made the decision to call the referendum, and citizens positively value the existence of this referendum. Now it is up to the political and institutional forces to explain the content of the Constitution, and I can assure citizens that we will make every effort to explain what a constitutional Europe means.

But I simply refer to the word that the leaders of the Popular Party have already given, a public word, regarding their position on the referendum of the European Constitution. I can assure you that I have no reason to doubt the word of those leaders.

P.- The President of the French Republic will be in Barcelona on February 11. Will this be a way for you to launch the beginning of the campaign for the referendum in France? Does this mean that you intend to do it as soon as possible?

Mr. Chirac.- I will answer this question when the time comes. I am committed from now on to supporting the "yes." President Rodríguez Zapatero gives me the opportunity to say it in Spain; I am sensitive to this, and for this reason, I have gladly accepted his invitation.

P.- I would like to ask only one question to President Chirac. One of the first pieces of news that has emerged from this Summit has been the inclusion of the central crossing of the Pyrenees in the infrastructure plans of both countries and the commitment to start studying the possible routes next year. It is a great advance for this project, which I recall is among the priorities of the European Union's transport scheme. However, I would like to know if the President can give us any further guarantees that this project will be safe from political vicissitudes, political alternations, and budgetary difficulties, being a long-term project.

Mr. Chirac.- It is a common decision that has been agreed upon and corresponds to a genuine need for the central crossing of the Pyrenees. We are committed to that path. Naturally, we need time to prepare and execute it, but the will exists. This is, by the way, what the Spanish and French Ministers have declared on this point, and I offer you to refer to their official statement on this matter.

President.- I will add that it is a great priority for the Spanish Government in the communications policy to have a central connection. Certainly, we consider this connection to be of enormous importance for the development of the Community of Aragón and, therefore, it will have, as certified today by the Summit, a singular backing from both Executives.

P.- I suppose that references to Zaragoza's candidacy for the Universal Exposition of 2008 have already reached President Chirac today from various sectors. I wanted to ask him if Spain will have the support of France, because I assume the Mayor has already asked him.

Mr. Chirac.- The first thing President Rodríguez Zapatero spoke to me about, even before mentioning the major bilateral or international issues, was the question you have just asked me. As soon as I arrived in Zaragoza, the President of the Autonomous Community of Aragón immediately posed the same question to me, and as soon as I arrived at the City Hall, just after crossing the threshold of the door, the Mayor also explained to me all the undeniable advantages of choosing, at the same time, the candidacy of Zaragoza and also the planned program, which is essentially based on water, which is a basic element, as everyone can understand, of the life of the city.

I would not want to prejudge the outcome of the vote that will take place next week, but I am totally convinced of Zaragoza's capacity to host this Exposition in 2008. I am completely convinced of that upon returning to my home in Paris this afternoon.

President.- Thank you very much.