Press conference of the President of the Government to assess the first year of Government.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

14 April 2005 · Press conference of the President of the Government to assess the first year of Government

Context
Zapatero held a press conference on 14 April 2005 to review his government's first year in office, outlining key policy achievements and priorities.
Main themes
First year in government assessment, democratic governance and dialogue, economic policy and competitiveness, citizens' rights and freedoms expansion, social policy and welfare improvements, fight against terrorism and ETA, international and European cooperation, education and scholarships, housing costs and job insecurity, cultural policy, road safety and citizen security, budgetary stability
Duration
~69 min
97th percentile
Words
8,232
97th percentile
Sentences
284
95th percentile
Readability
40
37th percentile
Grade
14.8
74th percentile
Syntax
3.38
88th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

284 sentences in 130 paragraphs

President.- As we complete this first year of our Government, I would like to highlight that during this time our political action has been guided by two principles: to follow the will of the citizens and, therefore, to fulfill the electoral program, which, being supported by a majority, represented a change of Government, but also a change of policies within the Government; and, secondly, to serve the interests of society by seeking the best future for Spain.

We have changed the course of some policies because this was decided by the citizens with their vote; but we did not want to make changes out of a desire to start from scratch. The best example, as you know, is economic policy. We are promoting reforms to increase the productivity and competitiveness of our economy, and we are trying to correct the most negative aspects of our growth model: the rising cost of housing, job insecurity, and the need for a technological strengthening of our productive system.

We have maintained principles that have worked well for the Spanish economy: the principle of budgetary stability, which favors investment and job creation, with very good results, by the way, this year.

However, we have wanted to fundamentally change the way of governing, because at this point the mandate of the citizens was very evident; a mandate by virtue of which they demanded a Government respectful of institutions, a Government that responded permanently in Parliament and returned to it the centrality of political life; a Government that made dialogue the norm of behavior, and for this we have sought agreement, we have practiced continuous dialogue, and undoubtedly, we have listened to everyone when the differences have been substantial.

There has also been a change in the approach to the rights and freedoms of citizens. Spanish society has changed a lot in recent years and could not pretend to ignore the plurality of cultures, ways of life, or try to constrain them, even with the best intentions, within norms that in practice deny the rights of many citizens or maintain inequalities that are no longer only unjustifiable, but above all incomprehensible and unacceptable. We have therefore strived to expand the rights and freedoms of citizens, trying to build a society in which everyone can feel comfortable, have the same opportunities, and advance the principle of equality and individual freedom enshrined in our Constitution.

In charting the course of our policies, we have not looked back, but forward.

In our international policy, we have sought to restore what has historically been the consensus of Spanish democracy. We believe that cooperation with Europe, as a top priority, and the defense of peace are perfectly compatible and beneficial with our alliances in defense of freedom and democracy. We are working along these lines and will continue to do so.

This Government has also prioritized the collective security of Spaniards, citizen security, road safety, and above all, the fight against terrorism. Therefore, from the very first moment of our taking office, we have reinforced the number of members of the State Security Forces and Corps, as well as the resources and means dedicated to combating all types of terrorism. The results are moving in the right direction, both in citizen security and in road safety, another priority objective of the Government. In the fight against terrorism, the work of the Police and the Civil Guard has provided significant successes in the goal of weakening the terrorist group ETA during this year.

Many citizens voted for us just over a year ago because they felt that deficiencies and delays were accumulating in fundamental aspects for our society. One of the most evident was culture in a society with so much creative potential and in which, moreover, the industries linked to culture have significant economic weight and will increasingly have more. We have therefore wanted to give a new prominence to culture, with more support, and also to the diverse cultures of Spain.

But above all, we have wanted to correct the deficits that had accumulated in the areas of social policies and education. It is easy to understand that this is the case. A socialist Government identifies with the improvement of pensions, with the improvement of education, and with the improvement of the purchasing power of those who live from their work. Therefore, we have raised minimum pensions above the average increase in pensions; we have increased the Minimum Interprofessional Wage by 13 percent and will reach the committed figure of 600 euros in this legislature; we have increased scholarships, both in number and in the amount of social spending on scholarships during this year.

Our policies have sought, therefore, to be attentive to the improvement and well-being of the most vulnerable sectors of our society.

In short, we are trying to build the best future for Spain, and that means more and better growth, more and better employment, more democracy, because we have more civil rights and individual freedoms for all, quality education, and increasingly dignified salaries and pensions. You have heard me say this on other occasions, so allow me to repeat it: peace, citizenship, with the extension of rights, and dialogue represent our hallmarks as a political project.

But before concluding this introduction, I want to emphasize that, beyond making this balance of the year of Government of the Socialist Party, I also wish above all to talk about the coming year, or rather, the year we are heading towards.

During the second year of the legislature, the Government has three crucial appointments: the first appointment, an appointment with the economy, with employment, and with stability in employment; another, with the autonomous model; and the third, with the people who are in a situation of dependency in our country.

In economics, we will lay the foundations for more and better growth, for more and better employment, and for that employment to be of higher quality every day; stable employment, therefore. For this, we rely on the decisive contribution of the social dialogue process between employers and unions.

Secondly, we will undertake the updating of our autonomous system as it reaches a quarter of a century.

And thirdly, we will extend public attention to the most forgotten members of our society, the elderly and people with disabilities.

So far, the introduction, and from here, we will move to the question-and-answer session, which today has, logically, a uniqueness, because you can ask about everything, about what represents current events, the year, the future, and with the breadth that you deem appropriate.

Q.- I would like to refer to the second point of the coming year, which is the updating of the autonomous model. I would like to know if, after a year of management and relations with the main opposition party, you consider that the Popular Party is closer or further away than a year ago from participating in the territorial consensus, both in statutory reforms and in the Constitution.

President.- You know that I have a weakness for making predictions, but I believe I should not make predictions about the attitude of the opposition. What I do want to emphasize is that the Government, for the territorial reforms we have ahead, which a part of them, fundamental, are reforms of the Statutes of Autonomy of various Autonomous Communities that will presumably enter the Chamber this year and will be debated; for the reforms of the Statutes, the Government maintains its entire willingness for dialogue, consensus, and agreement with all political forces and, of course, with the main opposition party. We believe it would be very beneficial for our autonomous model and for the updating, for this modernization that is going to take place and that undoubtedly represents an opportunity to improve what is the whole action of the governments of public services.

As you also know, within the chapter of constitutional reform, the initiative has been taken by the Government by sending it to the Council of State so that during this year it can issue an opinion on it and propose well-considered, analyzed, and discussed formulas, from the high wisdom and counsel that undoubtedly exists in that institutional body. When the Council of State issues that opinion, my will, the will of the Government, is also to try to forge an agreement with the vast majority of political forces; of course, giving evident priority to the Popular Party as the main opposition party.

We have time ahead, I suppose that time is always a good channel for calm, and when the moment arrives, that will be the attitude that the Government will develop.

Q.- For this second year of the legislature, Mr. President, as you are new in the position, we do not know if you are accustomed to maintaining Governments or not. Are you going to make changes? Are you not going to make them? I would like to know something about that.

Secondly, following up on what is happening at the "Severo Ochoa" Hospital in Leganés, you already spoke yesterday, to some extent, on the matter; but I would like to know if these events lead you to reflect on the issue of euthanasia and on the Executive's decision not to decriminalize it. Do you think this debate has opened in a timely and appropriate manner or do you think it has erupted in an irregular way?

President.- First of all, I must tell you that there is no forecast of changes in the Government team.

Secondly, I already expressed myself yesterday, indeed, about the situation that has occurred at the Leganés Hospital, with two considerations, which I reiterate today: the first, we must be prudent. There is an ongoing investigation by the Prosecutor's Office and actions by the Autonomous Community. I believe that prudence in a sensitive, serious matter is the best principle for expressing oneself.

Secondly, I want to express my full confidence in our public health system, in the professionalism of our doctors and all the personnel who provide services in public health. We have a good public health system, with a principle of universality, with a principle of gratuity, and which provides and is an essential pillar for the well-being of Spaniards. We have a health system in which we must always insist on making the best efforts for its improvement. Therefore, we have ahead of us the debate, negotiation, and dialogue regarding what affects the model of health financing.

Lastly, I reiterate what the Government has stated. The situation in Leganés does not warrant, nor is there any forecast, in that area you raise, of any legislative modification of the Penal Code.

Q.- In this balance you have made today, and in the balance you also made a couple of days ago in the Congress of Deputies, we have only been able to hear the positive side of the scale. I suppose there must also be some error that we can place on the negative side, some error that you can acknowledge here today, before us; an error of your Government.

President.- You will agree with me that there are true specialists in what is the debate of public and political opinion to highlight errors. In any case, I believe I have expressed on some occasion that the Government would rectify when necessary. Citizens know that the Government has rectified on some occasions and, above all, these have been rectifications in relation to statements that could indicate some lack of coordination or some proposal that did not fit the electoral program and the political project of the Government. Therefore, to rectify is to acknowledge an error, and there have been some.

I sincerely believe that, in what is the action of the Government, in what is the management of the Government, in what are the economic lines of action, of the balance, of how the country is one year later, taking into account the economic data, taking into account the employment data, taking into account social improvements, the extension of rights, and a position in the world in line with what Spaniards want, there may be some management failure.

I believe everyone will remember that in response to one of the snowstorms we had this winter, I publicly expressed, after a meeting with the team, that we needed to react earlier and more effectively to prevent citizens from having a very uncomfortable situation on our roads. I believe that was useful, that it served, because in the subsequent ones, which have been several, waves of cold and very significant snowfalls that we have had this year, I believe the response of the Government and other Administrations was more effective.

Q.- Could you elaborate on these economic measures and those for the improvement of employment that you have outlined, regarding the first point of your objectives?

Regarding the second point, the Popular Party has said that it will not accept to participate in the reform of the Constitution if you do not also accept that they participate or that the reform of the Statutes is agreed upon. And the question is direct: do you consider it necessary to have a pact on both aspects?

President.- I consider it advisable, starting with the last question, that there be maximum consensus both on the constitutional reform, which includes a part that is a reform of our territorial organization model, and on the reform of the Statutes. I reiterate that we will not spare any effort. Furthermore, in the constitutional reform, as is known, the acceptance and support of the Popular Party is not only convenient but essential. Therefore, the Government is obliged to make the utmost effort. I also consider this very advisable in the reform of the Statutes.

I believe we must give time to time. When the moment for reforms arrives, which, I insist, will be several in light of what is happening in different Autonomous Communities, it will be the time to intensify that dialogue process.

Therefore, both in the reform of the Constitution and in the reform of the Statutes, the Government considers that dialogue and understanding are very advisable.

Measures aimed at improving economic growth; a growth that, as you already know, was 2.7 percent last year, better in the second half, thus higher than in 2003, and in this year 2005 we are going to grow around 3 percent. We have a good pace of economic growth, we have a good pace of job growth—400,000 more jobs this year—more than half a million affiliations to Social Security and a reduction in unemployment of more than 40,000 people; but we want to improve the basic patterns of our economy. That means improving productivity and strengthening our technological capacity and innovation to be more competitive.

There has been a first Economic Dynamization Plan with many liberalizing measures and improvements in public sector management; there will be a Support Plan for Business Promotion, there will also be the first presentation of the National Program of the Lisbon Strategy, focused on Research, Development, and Innovation, and, of course, with a very clear projection in the Budgets that we will present to the Chamber for the year 2006.

In addition to that, a tax reform program has been announced, as you know; in addition to that, we have the Infrastructure Plan, a plan that will be approved by the end of summer and is currently in the debate process, which represents a significant volume of investment in the next fifteen years, both in roads and in railways, which will undoubtedly help improve economic growth.

But the essence and the fundamental factor for growing even more than that 3 percent, which is already a high level of economic growth, is that we have more research, more development, more innovation, more technological strength, and an educational system that improves in quality every day.

Q.- Mr. President, I wanted to know if you are going to address pension reforms, as many international organizations are requesting.

President.- We have established and stated that we currently have a solid Social Security system. In the last year, the Fund, the reserve fund of Social Security has increased by 50 percent. We have 23 billion euros in the Social Security Reserve Fund; we have a very high month-to-month growth in Social Security affiliations, which will also see a significant increase as a result of the normalization process of immigration and the irregular work that we had at such a high level in our country.

Therefore, we have a situation, from the health perspective, for the present and for the immediate future, that is reasonable for Social Security. In the medium term, the effort to strengthen what represents a public system guaranteeing universal pensions and improving those pensions, especially minimum pensions, is open in the social dialogue process, although I want to say that there is no forecast for it to be addressed during the next year, the second year of the legislature.

Q.- I wanted to ask you if you believe that in this past year the territorial cohesion of Spain, the unity of Spain, is better than it was before, because it seems that many citizens are seriously concerned about this situation: first, the arrival of the Ibarretxe Plan, with sovereign demands, which have been rejected in the Congress of Deputies; the news coming from the reform of the Catalan Statute, for example, saying that those who pay more must receive more, have more rights; facts such as, for example, that you have put yourself, let’s say, at the forefront of those reforms proposing a referendum and a new Statute in the Basque Country or saying that what is agreed in the Catalan Parliament will be approved in Madrid by a broad majority; and on the other hand, the monitoring commission that was to be established between the Government and the Popular Party after a meeting that took place here, in La Moncloa, has not worked either.

Truly, the horizon of cohesion in Spain with these elements does not seem to have an easy solution. The Popular Party maintains its reluctance to change Statutes, its support will be needed in the constitutional reform, and the unease caused by the messages coming from Catalonia means that this debate could become the central issue of the Legislature. I wanted to know your opinion on all this.

President.- Briefly, I will tell you that, from my point of view, the cohesion of Spain is strong; that the updating of our autonomous model will strengthen the cohesion of our country; that it is a mistake, which some have committed since practically the democratic transition, to alert about the inconvenience of reforms in our territorial model and that those who have made those mistakes have later accepted territorial reforms, and that the Ibarretxe Plan was born, not precisely with the Government I preside over, but was born at another time. And as I have said these days, and today I reiterate, the Ibarretxe Plan has no future or viability. Therefore, I consider it forgotten.

From the perspective of the rest of the reforms, I believe we have the opportunity, I insist, to improve self-government—therefore, to bring decisions and services closer to citizens—and that has been very positive in autonomous Spain over these twenty-five years, while we also have the opportunity to strengthen cooperation mechanisms for the governance of the whole State.

Therefore, from my point of view, we have strong cohesion in Spain.

The Catalan Statute, as I have explicitly stated many times, needs broad consensus in Catalonia, and it is also statutorily required. As happens in a mature and advanced democracy, we will dialogue about the Statute and we will, in my opinion, reach a satisfactory agreement for Catalonia and for the whole State.

Q.- I had a question about the European Union Budget. There has been much talk lately about Spain seeking the creation of a fund to compensate for the funds it will lose in the new Budget. Can you please tell me the amount that Spain is seeking for such a fund? And I would like you to explain a bit how it is expected to function.

A second question, if I may: when do you estimate that Spain will become a net contributor to the Union and how long do you think it is possible to delay that situation?

President.- First of all, regarding what the Financial Perspectives represent, whose negotiation we have ahead for the period 2007 to 2013, Spain has established and the Government has established clear criteria: one, there must be a progressive reduction of what has represented a very significant volume of aid, based on the principle of cohesion, to the countries that until now were the main beneficiaries, and now those main beneficiary countries will be the countries of enlargement. First, progressive reduction.

Second, from the perspective of what is, at this historical moment, cohesion, the need for Europe for its economy, for its growth, and for its development, for us the pillar of what is technological development, and therefore Research, Development, and Innovation, must be part of one of the important chapters of the entire cohesion model.

Evidently, I cannot answer your question about who, when, or how it will be a net contributor, because that depends on the evolution of the economy and the evolution of the whole of the European Union. What I do want to reiterate is that today Spain needs cohesion to strengthen its technological system, especially to continue incorporating infrastructures, while I say that Spain, of course, accepts and understands that these aids must be reduced based on the process of enlargement and, above all, the great economic growth that our country has had and fortunately has, which is largely the result of the aid, of the cohesion, of the European funds.

Q.- Yes, but I would like to know if Spain is seeking the creation of that fund.

President.- We are seeking the creation, or strengthening, or new conception, of instruments that already exist or the creation of some other new ones. I believe we are in the midst of an intense dialogue process; a dialogue that, as you know and I have explained many times, will be a complicated dialogue, because whenever we have ahead the distribution of the Funds, the setting of the European Union budget, the percentage in relation to its Gross Domestic Product, leads to a complicated scenario. But I believe we will reach a satisfactory agreement for all.

Q.- Mr. President, I wanted to know, first of all, if you believe that the reports from the National Intelligence Center do not provide relevant data that push the Government to let the Supreme Court decide, as mandated by the Law of Political Parties, on the relationship of Batasuna with the Communist Party of the Basque Lands.

Then, I wanted to know if I interpret correctly in saying that the Government will not regulate euthanasia during this legislature.

Next, I wanted to know if you could comment a bit on the calendar of the State of the Nation Debate and the Conference of Presidents, and if it will be in Barcelona.

Finally, I wanted to know the possibilities of transferring to Euskadi the competencies for the control of the financial entities based there.

President.- I will avoid the topic of competencies. We have elections in Euskadi the day after tomorrow, and the time will surely come to talk about competencies, transfers, and I hope about a reform of the Statute with broad consensus for Euskadi, because I do want to tell you that I have an optimistic view of the time that will open from next Sunday in the Basque Country; an optimistic view. I believe we will have a new time, characterized by agreement, by consensus, and by understanding, which is what the Basques want and deserve.

Regarding the process surrounding the candidacy of the Communist Party of the Basque Lands, I reiterate what I have said: the Government has had the elements regarding that candidacy that are publicly known and has had the report from the Legal Advisory, which considered that there were not sufficient arguments to initiate any action before the Supreme Court, a report that coincided with that of the Attorney General of the State. We have acted respecting the Rule of Law and, to this day, with the data we have had, it is evident that there was no reason to initiate a process of illegalization.

I do reiterate that regarding euthanasia there is no forecast of legislative modification, as I just expressed in response to another question.

I must say that the State of the Nation Debate will take place no earlier than around mid-May, around those dates. I have already consulted it at the time with the leader of the opposition and, depending on the calendar we have, after the elections in Euskadi and some international commitment I have, around those dates, although it is not yet closed. The month of May, but around mid-May.

My intention is to hold the Conference of Presidents in June, at the end of June.

Q.- Mr. President, at one point you mentioned that you consider the Ibarretxe Plan forgotten. I wanted to know if you have sufficient elements to know if the current acting Lehendakari also considers the Ibarretxe Plan forgotten.

Then, regarding the decision not to act against the candidacy of the Communist Party of the Basque Lands, reports from the Civil Guard have been made public. I do not know if you consider, despite those reports, that it is difficult to catch them; but, in any case, yesterday there were insinuations from the leader of the first opposition party that this responded to dialogue between the PSOE and Batasuna, between the PSOE and ETA. I wanted to know what you think of those statements.

President.- Simply, I believe it is best not to respond to false insinuations. And I will stick to that qualification.

Regarding the Ibarretxe Plan, yes, from my point of view, from the political and legal perspective, it is forgotten. It has been rejected by a broad majority in the Congress of Deputies and, in my opinion, Lehendakari Ibarretxe, regardless of the outcome of the elections next Sunday, should exercise realism and sensibility. That Plan has not been any solution; that Plan has divided Basque society; that Plan has blocked the political situation in Euskadi, has caused concern, and has generated insecurity. Therefore, I hope that he democratically considers it forgotten.

P.- I wanted to ask you what analysis you make of the first papers of the Statute of Catalonia that are already on the table, if you consider that they are going in the right direction.

President.- I believe we must have the patience for the parliamentary process in Catalonia to take place: Drafting Committee, Commission, Plenary. As you know, we have a procedure for reforming Statutes that has two instances, which are the regional parliament, in this case the Parliament of Catalonia, and the Parliament of Spain. We are still in a very early phase, and it will surely take hours of work and hours of dialogue.

I have expressed on more than one occasion my full willingness for the new Statute of Catalonia to come to fruition, while it is also known that this Statute must be in accordance with constitutional provisions and in accordance with the reasonableness of a deeply decentralized State, but one that maintains essential principles, such as solidarity, cohesion, and loyalty.

P.- Mr. President, I wanted to ask you if you think that this legislature and the Basque legislature will be the legislature of peace and also on what you base your optimism ahead of the elections on Sunday.

President.- I believe that on April 17, this Sunday, there will be a political change in Euskadi, and in fact, that change is already taking place. That change is occurring because the campaign has been very different from that of four years ago. We have had a campaign without tension, and we have had a campaign with different positions, with substantive political debate, but without tension. We have had a campaign where it has seemed evident that the only political proposal that the Basque Government has had during this time is a political proposal that has no way out.

Therefore, these two elements lead me to think that, beyond the result, which I hope will be positive for the Socialist Party, there will be a change in the political climate, and we will have to work differently in Euskadi, in the Parliament of Euskadi.

On some occasions, I have also said, and I reiterate today: I believe we have one of the best opportunities in history to advance towards the end of violence and towards peace. That is a very firm commitment from Patxi, that is the most felt need by all Basques, and, of course, it is a firm, daily, continuous commitment from the Government of Spain: to see the end of violence and to see peace, concord, and understanding in Euskadi. From my point of view, we have one of the best opportunities in history since this country has suffered the terrifying drama of the action of violence.

P.- I wanted to know, in the balance you make of this first year, what assessment you make of the Anti-Terrorism Pact, which I believe has met once since you have been in power, or twice at most; if you plan to reconvene it after the Basque elections and what assessment you make of the health of that Pact.

I also wanted to know if in the chapter you call rectifications you would include foreign policy, given the recent reforms regarding the reform that has been made.

President.- Regarding the Pact for Liberties and against Terrorism, I have expressed that this Pact has been positive. The fight against terrorism cannot be a weapon in political debate. Loyalty among democrats and the main leaders of the democratic parties in our country in the fight against terrorism must be continuous. I believe I can affirm that this has been my trajectory: loyalty and permanent support for the Government in the fight against terrorism when I was the leader of the opposition. That is the attitude I wish to see from those who are now in the opposition; I want to see it day by day, and as I wish to see it, I want to have patience and prudence regarding some of the things that have been said.

The Pact has met on two occasions, and of course, it will meet again. The health of the Pact is improvable.

I do not know if making an administrative modification to facilitate one of the requirements that produces or requires regularization can be considered a rectification. It seems to me that perhaps it would be elevating it to an excessive category. What I do want to say is that the process of regularization, of normalization, of immigrants is functioning very adequately; that it will have a very positive and clarifying final result; that I believe it is absolutely convenient that in Spanish society there is no one working illegally, that there is no one being exploited, that there is no one without rights, and that there is no one who does not contribute and pay taxes, both from the business perspective and from the worker's perspective.

If in this country there is work for people from outside, as is becoming evident and notorious, it is normal that we put order where there was disorder and that we put legality where there was illegality. This is being done with a series of requirements, all of which -- I want to emphasize -- have had and have the full agreement of employers, unions, and non-governmental social organizations. Furthermore, I want to emphasize that the attitude of employers is being very positive and that, evidently, this process will be positive for things to function as they should in a country in relation to the people who work in it, and it will also be very positive, without a doubt, from an economic perspective.

P.- Mr. President, I wanted to ask you a question about balance and another about current affairs. In the balance question, I wanted to ask for your opinion on how the agreement or relationship with parliamentary partners has functioned this year, especially because today, for example, the Law of the Salamanca Archive has been approved, and there are accusations of excessive concessions to those parties.

On the other hand, does the fact that in these days or months a somewhat more stable pact is being negotiated imply a rectification or dissatisfaction with the decision to govern in a minority without a stable agreement? In your opinion, how far should that agreement go in terms of content and time?

Regarding current affairs, I wanted to ask you if starting Monday, as it seems, according to the polls, this candidacy of the Communist Party of the Basque Lands were to obtain a seat in the Basque Parliament, would the Government and you yourself take it as a valid political interlocutor or not?

President.- Regarding what represents the balance of stability in the year we have been in the legislature, the Government is satisfied. The initiatives, the part of the electoral program, of our political project or of the Investiture Debate that we have launched have had the support of those who gave us the investiture at the time.

I want to emphasize that the investiture, in our parliamentary system, represents a fundamental agreement on a political project and represents an attitude of continuous dialogue so that that social majority translates into a parliamentary majority. Therefore, stability, dialogue, and understanding with those who have been supporting the Government is a day-to-day task, and as the legislature progresses, stability is naturally reinforced. That is the scenario that, from my point of view, has existed and the desirable scenario for the next time, for this second year of the legislature.

But I can say that the relationship, communication, and capacity for dialogue, for approximation, with the minority political forces that normally support the Government is a good capacity for dialogue and communication. And, of course, I want to thank from here the support they have been giving to the Government.

Secondly, the political forces that run for Parliament must express their political positions once the elections are over. I can tell you that the positions I have heard and the documents that have given rise to that political force are surely at the antipodes of what many of us think. Therefore, that marks, let’s say, from the outset a serious attitude of reserve.

P.- From what you just said about immigrants, should we understand that there will be more amnesties or more regularization processes?

President.- I believe that "amnesty" is precisely not an accurate term. It is about ordering situations that a serious, organized, effective, and modern country cannot tolerate. It cannot tolerate that there are thousands and thousands of people working without being legally recognized. I believe that this is negative from all points of view. A country must allow, if there is work, which is the essential bond and relationship, that people from other countries can work here with rights, openly, and in what is a normal relationship with the Administrations.

I insist, what we have done is work effectively against the neglect and disorder we have found in immigration in our country.

P.- But will there be more processes?

President.- No, there is no provision. There is no provision for new processes.

P.- You said earlier that a pact with the main opposition party on territorial reforms would be advisable. My question is whether you consider it necessary and indispensable, or would you be willing to make those territorial reforms alone or with minority groups.

On the other hand, your Secretary of State for Finance, Miguel Ángel Fernández Ordóñez, has described the proposals of the Financial Perspectives on the table as "unacceptable." I would like to know if you share that assessment.

Also, your Minister of Defense, José Bono, said yesterday that what his body was asking for was the illegalization of the PCTV. I would like to know if you also feel that way.

One more thing. You said in an interview that lowering taxes is also a leftist thing. I wanted to know if you can commit today that in the next tax reform there will be a tax cut.

And a balance question: what is your assessment of your relationship with the Church this year?

President.- I will start with the last one, which is recent. The political and communication relationship with the Episcopal Conference has been a normal relationship. I want to say that the last interview I had with the recently elected President of the Episcopal Conference was a meeting, from my point of view, very positive; a dialogue that I believe was sincere and constructive, and an attitude that I value in a singular way.

The Government has said about this on several occasions, and I have no objection to reaffirming it, that it has two principles: the scrupulous respect for the constitutional values that mark the secular nature of the State, and a singular collaboration and cooperation with the Catholic Church. For this reason, we have agreements with the Catholic Church, which we maintain, and for this reason, we develop a legislative program where faith, any faith, with our respect, should not mark what are the values of social coexistence.

If you notice, there has been no relationship problem regarding the first angle of the issue: we maintain relations, we scrupulously comply with constitutional principles. What has occurred are discrepancies from the ecclesiastical hierarchy regarding certain legislative initiatives; specifically, the reform and modernization of divorce or what represents the modification of the Civil Code in the aspect of marriage concerning the possibility of same-sex couples marrying. We respect that they do not agree with this, just as everyone else, in a secular state and in a democratic society, must respect that the Government fulfills its programmatic commitments to citizens. This is what a normal relationship should be.

Now ahead, we will have a dialogue regarding education, and we will have a dialogue on all those issues that may be of interest to both the Catholic Church and the Government. But I do want to reiterate that my attitude is one of respect and dialogue, and my attitude is also one of commitment to the Spaniards who voted for an electoral program and who have the right to demand it from the Government.

I do not like to talk about what my body asks for, nor in this matter. I will tell you that in a democracy, the Government must do what reason dictates, and reason is expressed in values, in principles, of the rule of law that, for me, must be respected scrupulously every day, every minute, and every second. You will not be surprised, because I have reiterated it many times, that the best defense of the rule of law is the most thorough compliance with the rule of law; that the best defense of democracy is the practice with the best guarantees of democracy, both internally and in the realm of international relations. It is a matter of deep convictions and essential principles of functioning in a democracy.

Indeed, I confirm that we have underway, with the calendars we have expressed, a reform of the Personal Income Tax. This reform will entail a reduction in the tax burden on the IRPF and will particularly benefit workers' incomes in a progressive manner. When that is done, progressive politics is being carried out. Therefore, lowering taxes or reducing certain elements of the tax burden can be progressive. I think this is important for what is the vision and political action of a leftist Government, and a regressive reform would not be. It would evidently be conservative, as there are some aspects of the reforms we have had in recent times that have a regressive character, and that is what we want to correct essentially.

President.- Continuing with the economic topic, in the report you presented today and in the one you made the other day before the Parliamentary Group, you have somehow avoided two important problems of the economy, such as inflation and the external deficit. I would like to know to what extent you are concerned about them and how the Government plans to address them.

Secondly, if I may, in the assessment of this first year that the first opposition party has made, they have criticized what they call "an increase in political interventionism in private enterprise." I would also like to know your opinion on this and perhaps you are in a position to provide some examples to contradict this argument.

President.- Regarding the second question, for the Popular Party to speak of interventionism in companies after what they did throughout the privatization process and the appointment of people of absolute trust in those privatized companies seems to me, quite simply, a joke that is hardly acceptable.

The Government has maintained from day one a principle of collaboration with all companies, of collaboration and respect, and the best proof of this is that the vast majority, if not practically all, except one, at the initiative of a financial entity, specifically, La Caixa... But all the Presidents of privatized companies during the time of the Popular Party, where their presidents were appointed as people close to the Government itself, continue in their tasks, in their functions, continue working, and the Government works with them, because this is indeed a Government that respects and does not intervene in companies.

These are not evaluations, they are facts and data. Review the main companies and who are their presidents, who were there and how they came to preside over those privatized companies.

Regarding some aspects of the economy, specifically the external sector, I must recall some data that may go unnoticed, but our exports grew by 6.9 percent in 2004. We are not losing market share and we are experiencing a 7 percent growth in our total markets. We are the second best European country in export growth; the rest of the European countries have had significantly lower growth, such as Germany, France, Italy, or the United Kingdom. And we have reasonable future expectations, as the European Commission's export order book survey has improved by 50 percent since March. Therefore, these are the data.

That said, we need to improve the potential of our external sector and for that, the Ministry of Industry, Tourism and Trade is carrying out various specific sectoral plans for dynamization, business promotion, and competitiveness, some of which have been made public in recent days.

President.- A question about immigration. Due to the change that has occurred in allowing other documents regarding registration, why not extend the deadline? Once it is recognized, let’s say, that it is necessary to allow for other types of documents, wouldn’t it be more coherent to allow for an extension of the deadline, since it is a short period and there is less than a month left for the process to end?

Secondly, yesterday Cuba was condemned in the United Nations Human Rights Commission and Cuba has already threatened to break dialogue with the European Union. How do you assess this? What would you do if it breaks, because it would be a blow to the foreign policy that your Government has championed?

President.- Regarding the first point, the Government considers that the deadline set for the normalization process is a reasonable period, including the modification regarding the supporting documentation that has just been reformed. I must reiterate that the process is functioning well and that the daily pace of procedures for that normalization has been increasing, and I believe that we will reach, within the established timeframe, the objective or reasonable estimate that the Government had.

Regarding the second point, what I believe the Government of Cuba should do is listen to what is expressed by the International Community, and in my opinion, the Government of Cuba should not go down the path it may have hinted at yesterday after learning of the United Nations formulation.

President.- I also have a question about the assessment and another one about current affairs, although both are more or less interconnected.

You have expressed your opinion on the cohabitation, relationship, or coexistence of your Government with the Catalan Government, the Catalan tripartite, which has often been presented as a black beast, and even as a means of attack by the main opposition party against you and the party you lead. Last week you had a brief meeting with the President of the Generalitat, Pasqual Maragall. I wanted to know if you talked about this, how you see him, and how you see the relations at this moment. Are they fluid? Is there a "feeling"?

The next day -- and here current affairs come more into play -- the President gave a conference here in Madrid, where he expressed complaints and, we could even say a certain bitterness regarding what he interprets as a grievance of Catalonia and other Communities regarding the general financing regime compared to the foral ones. This provoked some intense reactions within the Socialist Party. I would like to know what you think about all this and if you believe that all these factors can be reconciled and lead to a financing model that is truly satisfactory for all parties.

President.- That is the Government's objective: to work so that our autonomous financing model covers two essential principles, and if it requires introducing some reform, we are willing. That is the commitment and the dialogue that we already have open: financial sufficiency of the Autonomous Communities -- and Catalonia, as is known, has some financial insufficiency, fundamentally regarding healthcare -- and the principle of solidarity of the country. That principle must be present in the autonomous financing model, but also in the overall policies carried out by the Government, which are reflected in the General State Budgets.

Is that compatible? Of course, it is compatible. The financial needs, depending on the evolution of social reality, especially immigration, and the demographic evolution of many Autonomous Communities determine that there are public services that need to improve their financial position; it is not only Catalonia. Just as there are other Communities that need, above all, productive investment, infrastructure, or technology. These are those Communities that have demographic problems, that have less economic growth, that have fewer young people, and where immigration does not go because there is much less economic activity and job opportunities.

We must act in both directions: Communities and territories that have more economic strength, more demographic evolution, and more immigration, which puts pressure on essential public services. We must tackle and assist the Autonomous Communities with that problem; but there is another part of the country that needs development, needs infrastructure, and needs growth, and the Government is also doing that. That is why we have had specific plans this year for the West, the Galicia Plan, or the Extremadura Plan.

By the way, I wanted to tell you that the meeting with Pasqual Maragall was practically just a cordial greeting, as he was coming to give a conference. I was with him for about twenty minutes, and you can understand that in twenty minutes it would be very difficult to address the density of the entire journey of autonomous financing and the reform of the Statute that we have ahead.

President.- Mr. President, the opposition complains that in Parliament you do not respond to them in the control sessions. And in this press conference, after a year, the truth is that it is difficult to get a headline from you based on the experience we are seeing. But I wanted to ask you...

President.- In that, there will be a shared responsibility, I imagine.

President.- Of course, it is our fault. But, in any case, there is one question that remains pending, which is the relations with the United States. At this moment it seems that the sale of arms or ships to Venezuela has once again strained relations with the United States, and I would like you to assess what the situation is at this moment, please.

President.- I believe that in the relationship with the United States we must move beyond the phase of adjectives or evaluations and go to the facts. It is known that in the coming months there will be a series of ministerial-level meetings where specific issues are being addressed, cooperation and collaboration (Ibero-America, the Middle East, the fight against terrorism), where we have had a dialogue process among the ministerial officials of both Governments and improvement of what is cooperation in the fight against terrorism. Those are the facts. And there is a principle, which I have expressed on more than one occasion, which is respect for what represents one foreign policy and another foreign policy, which will coincide in many things and may not coincide in some.

But the relationship of the Governments, the working relationship on specific issues, what is visible and known, as I said before, works and works as it should between two allied countries.

Thank you.