Press conference of the President of the Government after the meeting of the European Council.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

26 October 2005 · Informal European Council under the British Presidency

Context
Zapatero addressed a press conference following an informal European Council meeting under the British Presidency on October 26, 2005, summarizing key discussions on the economy, immigration, and foreign policy.
Main themes
European Council outcomes, globalization and economic competitiveness, research and development and innovation, Lisbon Strategy, energy policy and interconnection, alternative energies, immigration policy, illegal immigration control, EU-Africa cooperation, EU Common Foreign and Security Policy, EU budget and funding instruments
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,234
87th percentile
Sentences
140
78th percentile
Readability
34
24th percentile
Grade
15.9
82nd percentile
Syntax
3.36
87th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
15th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

140 sentences in 59 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. First of all, I would like to assess the development of this informal Council, under British Presidency, and I consider its balance to be clearly positive. The willingness and the atmosphere to put Europe back on track has characterized the development of the day.

As you know, we have focused our work on three main topics. First, Europe's response to globalization, with the aim of strengthening our economy, making it more productive and, therefore, more competitive in a globalized world. For this, there has been a general consensus that Research, Development, Innovation, and the university system of the European Union are undoubtedly the two main levers to improve our economies and make them more competitive. All of this is, without a doubt, a fundamental element of the Lisbon Strategy and the National Reform Programs, and it aligns with the direction that the Government of Spain is pursuing in its economic policy in our country. As you know, and I want to remind you, already in the 2005 Budget, and also in the 2006 Budget that is currently in Parliament, we have made the decision to increase public spending on Research + Development + Innovation by 25 percent.

In addition to the importance of Research, Development, and Innovation, Education, and Universities, a new frontier has been considered in what could be the common policy of the European Union; a new frontier basically related to energy policy, and I want to say that I find it of extraordinary importance. Undoubtedly, energy is also a determining element of the expectations for economic growth, and certainly, the European Union can pursue a policy of greater unity and greater synergy in the energy needs of all the countries of the Union, especially in two areas: the first is to expedite, commit to, and strengthen all the potential for energy interconnection in the Union; the second is to strengthen and increase Research, Development, and Innovation in the business sector for this new field of alternative energies, where undoubtedly many of the countries of the European Union are being pioneers, and to have a much more diversified energy horizon.

Secondly, immigration has occupied a good part of the Council's debates.

As you know, I have made, and I had announced, a proposal to the Council to strengthen the common policy of the European Union on immigration; first, to control illegal immigration, aware as we are that illegal immigration, although it directly affects some countries in a singular way, undoubtedly impacts the policy of the entire Union. Therefore, the European Union must lead the control of illegal immigration with great strength, while also increasing and dedicating many more resources to what represents development and to what represents the ultimate cause of the phenomenon of illegal immigration, which is the wealth gap, poverty, and misery that exist in so many countries, especially in Africa, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa.

To this end, I have reiterated a set of concrete proposals on immigration policy that will be reflected in the European Council in December. This has been the will expressed overwhelmingly by the leaders and by the Commission. Proposals that range from the technical improvement of border control that the Union must promote through integrated systems at the European level, such as the one that Spain and Greece are implementing for the control of maritime borders in the Mediterranean; secondly, to promote and incentivize the signing of readmission agreements between the European Union and neighboring countries and between these and the countries of origin; and thirdly, the proposal includes the need to establish new funding formulas within the existing community instruments to assist our neighbors and third countries on immigration issues, countries that also face direct pressure from illegal immigration.

We will be able to specify, as I said, a program that will have a budget of 400 million euros, which means doubling the amount that the Union currently dedicates to these policies and that will be integrated into the European Neighborhood Fund and the European Development Fund.

In particular, the proposal also includes a reference, a special aid, to sub-Saharan countries to increase opportunities in that area for growth, employment, and education, all with the idea, which I have suggested again today, of holding a conference between Europe and Africa, within the dialogue of Europe and Africa, specifically on immigration.

Thirdly, the Council has received a report from Javier Solana on the Common Foreign and Security Policy, a report that has been received very positively and where many actions that the European Union is undertaking in the field of peace and security have been specified with great effort. Javier Solana has called for more resources, more means, for the European Union to increase its role in the world as a decisive factor in peace and security processes. The Council has also received, I believe with clear support, both the management and the proposal that Javier Solana has formulated.

In short, these three have been the fundamental topics: how to ensure that Europe meets the challenge of globalization and how to ensure that our economy remains productive and competitive in a new international scenario, while maintaining a social model; how to address a more decisive policy of the Union on immigration; and, thirdly, what represents the Common Foreign and Security Policy.

I want to express my satisfaction with the development of this Council. I want to express, in a very special way, my gratitude to both the British Presidency and the Presidency of the Commission and to the leaders of different countries who have positively received and supported the proposal on immigration that I have formulated in the Council. I believe that this will guarantee us more security, I believe that it will ensure a more orderly immigration, and that, moreover, full awareness has been regained of an urgent, essential, and just need, which is Development Cooperation in Africa, and especially in sub-Saharan Africa.

Q.- I know it wasn't on the agenda today, but we must talk about the Financial Perspectives. Tony Blair has confirmed that he is committed to presenting a proposal in December and that he will present a preliminary document in November. Since it cannot differ much from what was offered and rejected in Luxembourg, I wanted to ask you, President, if Spain would be satisfied with the same amount it would receive in the Luxembourg proposal, with a little less, or with a little more.

On the other hand, since the Summit was held in a castle famous for its ghost stories and doors that open and close by themselves, I would like to know if you have detected any paranormal phenomena; that is, if Mr. Chirac or Mr. Blair have agreed on anything.

President.- Regarding the second question, the atmosphere has been clearly positive. I would say it has been characterized by two things, and the first of these is that there has been an affirmation of confidence in the European Union, in what this great project represents. I want to emphasize, moreover, that this affirmation of confidence in the European Union project has been particularly highlighted by the countries we call the enlargement countries or that we have been calling enlargement countries, and of course with evident enthusiasm from countries that are already very close to us, such as Bulgaria, Romania, and also, at the moment they were present, Turkey and Croatia, which was during lunch. Therefore, reaffirmation of confidence. Secondly, the initiation of concrete actions aimed at economic perspective, immigration, and security.

The atmosphere I have seen at all times in relation to President Chirac and Prime Minister Tony Blair has been absolutely cordial, which has characterized, moreover, the entire meeting.

Financial Perspectives? I believe that all European leaders, all Heads of State and Government, wish for the Union's Budget to be approved in December. It is convenient for the functioning of the European Union and would also represent, without a doubt, a political signal of high value, of recovery of initiative, of recovery of consensus, and of determination of the clear objectives that the Union must have at this moment, especially to face globalization.

Spain will go into this new negotiation, which will have to start from a new proposal because the previous one from the Luxembourg Presidency was rejected, with a willingness to defend its positions, which are known: we believe that what represents enlargement, from the point of view of bearing the financial effort, must be distributed equitably, and we believe that it is essential, in coherence with the debate we have had today regarding the challenges of globalization, that Research, Development, and Innovation occupy a much more important role in what the new Budget of the European Union should be. With these two premises, we will go into the negotiation and, of course, with a constructive willingness, because I believe that is what corresponds to a country like Spain, which is a deeply pro-European country.

Q.- We know, because we have heard it, that President Chirac has expressly supported your proposals on immigration, and Prime Minister Tony Blair has done so here a little while ago; but when Blair went to specify the few concrete things he said about the proposal, he talked about things like creating databases of the identities of those who cross illegally, coordinating judicial processes. At no time did he mention the 3 percent of certain funds, nor did he even talk about more resources, nor did he talk about Development Aid either. So, the question is: to what extent is his message supported in a very generic way, but, as we move towards December, when things are to be agreed upon, could it happen as with the agreement reached in Seville, to launch a common immigration policy that, as we know, went nowhere?

President.- I am fully convinced that the initiatives I have just specified, which have been part of the proposal, will be reflected and approved in the European Council in December. It has been a will, as I have previously stated, clearly majority, if not unanimous, expressly highlighted by several interventions from Heads of State and Government, referring to the substantive issue, illegal immigration, and to the specific proposal I have formulated in the Council. Of course, in the European Council in December, we will have the concrete instruments that I have just formulated.

Q.- President, a clarification in line with what has just been asked. I wanted to know if the budget for the program, the four hundred million, is contingent on the approval of the new Financial Perspectives or if it can be launched independently of that approval beforehand, in case no agreement is reached on the financial package.

A second question, President. A report from the Foundation chaired by former President Aznar warns or has raised the alarm that the Statute, among other things, could lead to opening the doors to polygamy. I would like to ask you what you think of such reports and if at this point you believe there is anything in the Statute that you think might appeal to the PP in light of the upcoming debate.

President.- Regarding the first, it is not essential, obviously, because the Union has its instruments and can perfectly make adjustments and make decisions in that direction regarding the allocation of funds, although, obviously, it would be very desirable for this to occur within the framework of the new Financial Perspectives and for them to be approved.

Regarding the second question, I believe that so many things are being said with so little sense about what could be a political debate and a debate on the future of the Autonomous State, of the reforms, or specifically, of the Statute of Catalonia, that it certainly exposes those who use these arguments as absurd, unusual, and that the only thing they can provoke, which is also good to introduce some element into the debate, is a long smile, not to say an intense laugh.

Q.- Apparently, in addition to support for the proposal on illegal immigration, you would also have received support from your European partners on the issue of aid to areas that have suffered natural disasters, such as Central America. I would like to know if you can elaborate more on that topic.

President.- Indeed, there has been a proposal that initially contained a reference to aid to Pakistan and, subsequently, at the proposal of the Government of Spain, it has been logically incorporated, the attitude that the European Union is having and must have in support and solidarity for the reconstruction of the areas affected in Central America by natural disasters, specifically by Hurricane Stan. It has been supported by the Council, which I believe is good news because, in addition to the efforts that Spain, as is known, has committed, the European Union is also willing to commit more to the reconstruction of the areas devastated by hurricanes in Central America.

P.- The European Union has issued a very strong statement regarding Iran, and Tony Blair, before you appeared here, has made perhaps the strongest condemnation ever made by a British Prime Minister, stating that Iran should not think that because the world is distracted elsewhere — referring to Iraq — it will be able to take actions of the kind you might be thinking. I would like to know if you, who have been so resistant to supporting intervention in Iraq, are as tough as the European Union's statement, and specifically the British Prime Minister's, regarding the possibility of taking action against Iran.

Secondly, a curiosity that I was discussing with my Spanish colleagues. In a context like this of discussion in a globalized world, how does a person who defines themselves as "leftist" feel in a world without a concrete ideology and globalized?

President.- The second question seems very interesting to me. I do not think that the fact that the world is globalized, which I see as positive, has anything to do with each person having their ideological position. I believe that, fortunately, pluralism, which is the essence of democracy, not only allows but encourages the recognition of the different ideologies that each person has.

Regarding the first question, I fully endorse the Resolution that the Council has approved concerning the statements made by Iran. They are simply unacceptable in relation to Israel.

P.- Would you agree to support military intervention in Iran?

President.- I suppose you would like to go further than what it is. I refer back to what I just said: Iran's statement about Israel is unacceptable, unacceptable.

P.- This week in "The Guardian," there is an article in which you spoke about a European Union-Africa conference on immigration. Could you tell me if any progress has been made in this area? Could you tell me if the amnesty you recently granted to illegal immigrants has had any impact on relations between Morocco and Spain? Finally, are you doing anything with African governments to discourage illegal immigration?

President.- Regarding the first point, I must tell you that the proposal I have made regarding illegal immigration includes a conference or a meeting within the framework of the Europe-Africa dialogue on immigration. I believe it would be extraordinarily positive to engage Europe and Africa in legally managing immigration. Ordered and legal immigration primarily benefits those who expect to be or need to be immigrants.

Secondly, Spain has carried out a process of normalizing immigrants who existed in our country over the past year, who had entered illegally in numbers exceeding a million in previous years and who were working outside the law, causing negative situations for the economy and for businesses, and, what is more important to me, for the rights of the immigrant workers themselves who were in a normalized situation. This normalization has had very positive effects. Today there is more legality, less irregular economy, and more people with rights. Obviously, all the countries that have or had many illegal immigrants in Spain, such as Morocco and all those from Latin America, have appreciated this normalization process.

Just as we said we would normalize those people who were working informally or irregularly in Spain, we said that immigration could only be legal and orderly. We will maintain that principle so that immigrants can continue to come to our country to strengthen our economy and improve the future prospects of their lives.

There are pathways. The pathways are to do it through the agreements we have with several countries and that we want to sign with new countries so that the employment needs that exist in our country can be met by people coming from abroad. But it must be done in an orderly manner, while also increasing the commitment, with words and actions, to Development Aid and the expectations of so many countries in the world, especially Africa. I say with words and actions because the Government has done it with words and actions, because since we have been in Government, in the two budgets we have brought to Parliament, Spain's Development Aid has increased by one billion euros.

P.- A clarification and a question. The amount you mentioned of 400 million, for what time period would that be, or is it only until the Financial Perspectives are approved? I wanted to clarify when it is for.

Then, do you believe that with this Iranian Government, some type of understanding can be reached in terms of alliance or dialogue of civilizations?

President.- Regarding the first, logically the period would be the budgetary period of the Financial Perspectives adopted by the European Union itself.

Secondly, the Alliance of Civilizations project is a project aimed at bringing together peoples, cultures, religions, and different ways of life or understanding life that exist in what we have come to call civilizations.

Undoubtedly, this project, which will kick off in what represents the work of the High-Level Group agreed upon by the United Nations in a few weeks, can represent and must represent a useful instrument so that we do not have future scenarios in which only reaction or the use of force can be the response to conflicting or difficult situations.

P.- There is a widespread consensus at this Summit, and that is why it has been held, that we must advance and incentivize investments in new technologies, R&D, industry, services, and education. Ultimately, we are talking about investing more in the future as the only way to get the European Union out of the situation it is in. When it comes to advancing, it is always said that to advance, something must be left behind. So, I ask you: the way it is being done is investing in the future, but what could happen to the current productive force? That is, could we be living in a situation similar to what was experienced, say, in the last major industrial reconversions in the 1980s?

President.- From my point of view, no, because a good part of our industrial sectors are not in that phase that we could call mature industry, which would require a significant restructuring process. What we have is, above all, to increase the technological capacity of the country, of the countries, of Europe, and to enhance the personal training of workers. Each country has these specific challenges. Spain has a very specific challenge in the education system, which is to substantially raise the percentage of young people who finish high school or vocational training. Reaching 80 or 85 percent of those young people is crucial for having an economy with possibilities.

Secondly, increasing technological capital, that is, dedicating much more public spending to Research, Development, and Innovation, and, moreover, doing many more projects jointly with the private initiative; that is the program we have presented in our country, the program known as Ingenio. And one of the things that has been debated in the Council is how to create a much more integrated space for European Universities, for European basic research, to work with the private sector in research.

I believe that Europe cannot miss the opportunity that represents integrating its university system much more in the field of research, and I am convinced that this will be a very prominent part of the new Financial Perspectives proposal. We need universities of excellence, and excellence in research today is achieved to a large extent, not only with resources but by working as a team. Europe has a wide array of good universities and good researchers, and if efforts are combined, which so far have been combined little from my point of view, progress can be made in that direction.

P.- The Commission's proposal on the next Financial Perspectives establishes that 60 percent of the Cohesion Funds be dedicated to R&D. Would Spain be willing to do that?

On the other hand, tomorrow you were scheduled to attend a conference on the dialogue of civilizations, but it seems you will not be able to attend. I would like to know why.

Finally, today in the debate, much emphasis has been placed on the issue of energy, specifically nuclear energy. It is assumed that this is a kind of shift in European policy, once again, towards nuclear energy, except for some countries that have said no, like Germany. I would like to know if Spain also plans to return to this issue.

President.- I must make a clarification because nuclear energy has been referred to at some point in the debate, but the two basic lines regarding the strengthening of the common energy policy are the two priority lines I referred to earlier: one, to accelerate energy interconnection within the Union, and two, to increase efforts and prioritize, therefore, efforts in Research, Development, and Innovation in what we know as alternative and renewable energies.

Regarding the proposal on Financial Perspectives and the Cohesion Funds, I do not know if the figure you provided is correct. In any case, we will wait to know in the negotiation process what the Cohesion Fund represents and what the increase in R&D&I represents, which, I insist, is essential for Spain.

Regarding the last question, I will tell you that I have other commitments that do not allow me at this time to attend that event tomorrow.

P.- There has been talk of creating a globalization fund to cope with this new stage. It is a fund that would be opposed, among other countries, by Germany. I would like to know Spain's position. On the other hand, is this not another way to finance industries that are going under?

President.- I believe there are two clarifications to make: The proposal for the globalization fund has indeed led to quite a debate within the Council. If the globalization fund is a fund for globalization intended for workers who may lose their jobs as a result of the effects of globalization and, therefore, of the lack of competitiveness; if it is for workers, so that they have more resources in the perspective of finding a new job, which will surely require training and other mechanisms, Spain is in favor, obviously; if it were in another direction, as you pointed out, it would not make sense. If it is for workers, yes.

P.- You have mentioned that one of the challenges is globalization and that to address it, we must improve the competitiveness of the economy. You have said that for this, we must invest in R&D and improve business excellence. I would like to know if there has been any discussion at the meeting about flexibilizing the labor market and about deflating the Welfare State. In any case, whether it has been discussed or not, what is your point of view on this?

President.- Yes, the importance of having a modern labor market suited to the needs of a productive economy has been discussed. Although it does not directly form part of the Commission's report, I will tell you that from my point of view, we need to have a flexible labor market and we need to have a strong protection system against unemployment. That is my position, and as we are immersed in a social dialogue, it is best that the labor market framework is the result of an agreement, especially between employers and unions.

Regarding the last question, absolutely not. If we have to carry out a continuous policy of initiatives, reforms, and actions for the economy to grow, to grow strongly, it is above all to maintain strong social policies.

At this moment, Spain is growing at 3.4 percent, well above the European average; we are creating jobs at a very accelerated pace, and we also have the prospect that this will be the first year in history in which there is a fiscal surplus. What do these good macroeconomic elements allow us? To increase investment in R&D&I by 25 percent, to raise minimum pensions twice as much as average pensions, to increase spending on scholarships and education by 10 percent, and therefore to strengthen the Welfare State, as we have recently done with the financing agreement in health, giving the system three billion euros that the Autonomous Communities manage.

Growing as the Spanish economy grows, creating jobs as Spain creates jobs, and having exemplary public accounts as Spain has, is how it is possible to have social policies that strengthen and improve the Welfare State.

Thank you very much.