Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

18 October 2005 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on the Canary Islands fiscal regime renewal and regional financing reform during a Spanish parliament control session on 18 October 2005.
Main themes
Canary Islands Economic and Fiscal Regime, EU negotiations 2007-2013, regional tax incentives, Financial Perspectives of the European Union, regional autonomy and financing, Spain's decentralization, outermost regions policy, regional development, fiscal co-responsibility, Spanish regional statutes
Duration
~17 min
59th percentile
Words
2,075
59th percentile
Sentences
79
52nd percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
13.4
61st percentile
Syntax
3.04
53rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
52nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 58%57%
  • Economic 26%25%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

79 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Response to the question posed by Mr. Paulino Rivero, of the Canary Coalition Parliamentary Group

Mr. Rivero.- Mr. President, you have always expressed yourself as a firm and determined defender of the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands. Negotiations will soon begin to renew the authorization from Brussels for the period 2007-2013. With what will and with what firmness does the Government you preside over face the defense of the essential aspects of the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands?

President.- Mr. Rivero, indeed, the specific tax incentives recognized by the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands expire, as you know, on December 31 of this year. The Government is currently negotiating in the community institutions the extension of these incentives, and the first objective that guides our negotiation is that the set of measures contained in Title 4, Chapter 2, of the 1994 Law of the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands maintain their validity in the current terms until December 31, 2006, that is, to extend them for one year in everything, and that the set of general changes being contemplated bear fruit.

From there, Your Honor, as you know, the European Commission has proposed a modification of the Regional Aid Agreement for the period 2007-2013. Therefore, we are currently setting that temporary objective for next year.

Mr. Rivero.- Mr. President, the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands has enabled the consolidation of a Canarian business fabric over the last few years, with what that has meant for generating wealth and, therefore, employment.

The geographical situation of the Canary Islands requires measures that allow overcoming the handicap of what distance means for both Canarian companies and citizens. A large part of those measures that enable this approach or strengthening of the Canarian business, overcoming that handicap for citizens, is contemplated in the current Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands.

Of course, we took the extension for granted; the extension for the year 2006 will be a reality. What we are talking about here is to align with the new Financial Perspectives of the European Union 2007-2013. To have a position in the negotiation before Brussels, it is essential that the State Government has a clear position, a firm position, and in that sense, my Group proposes that, with the same conviction, the same interest, and the same firmness with which you have defended on various occasions the need to maintain the essential aspects of the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands, that will is expressed for the negotiation that lies ahead, which is difficult and complicated, within the European Union.

President.- Mr. Rivero, regarding the period 2007-2013, the treatment given to the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands is linked to the final outcome of the global negotiation of the Financial Perspectives.

I can assure you that the Spanish Government, as it has done on all previous occasions, will make every effort, with all determination, so that the Canary Islands, in its condition as an outermost region and, therefore, unique and of high strategic significance in matters of special sensitivity for the whole of the EU, continues to have a specific economic and fiscal regime that favors and promotes its development; an economic and fiscal regime that, in addition to doing justice, allows it to continue improving its income levels, which are, of course, at least, in line with the average of the European Union of Fifteen.

Response to the question posed by Mr. Francisco Rodríguez, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

Mr. Rodríguez.- Mr. President, we ask you the following question with the aim of de-dramatizing, rationalizing, and positioning ourselves regarding the new Statutes that entail a new financing system, to make it clear that we are not facing the problem of Spain disintegrating, but rather the issue of a current financing system of undeniable ideological function that wants to maintain a fiction, the fiction that it is the Spanish State that supports us all, it is the idea of Spain that supports us all, and, even in some versions, the capital, which is Madrid.

However, you know, Mr. President, that we cannot cover expenses with participation in the current tax basket. We have neither financial autonomy nor financial sufficiency. We are with self-governments that have the paradox of having decentralized expenses, having to take responsibility for expenses, but the revenues are centralized; and, therefore, it should be clear that the Spanish State is the only sovereign and that there are no political identities that constitute it. This is a lack of transparency and co-responsibility, so that the Spanish State is a great myth and the rest of us are something like dwarfs. And I will not even mention the case of Galicia, where they have condemned it to say that it is a subsidized country, that we are fed by others.

Therefore, our proposal, indeed, to reverse that reality is that there should be territorialization of taxes, own tax agencies, and that we create the idea that the Spanish State is a product of all. From this perspective goes our question.

President.- Mr. Rodríguez, the model of autonomous financing in our country has undergone various reforms since the State of Autonomies was launched following the Spanish Constitution of 1978. These reforms have shown that we need to improve and perfect the autonomous financing model.

What are, from my point of view, the three essential elements of a good autonomous financing system? Financial sufficiency of the Autonomous Communities and the State; secondly, maximum fiscal responsibility and, therefore, the defined fiscal spaces of the State and the Autonomous Communities; and, thirdly, the maintenance of the principle of cohesion or solidarity for all Autonomous Communities and, of course, for all Spanish citizens.

I believe it is necessary and convenient that we address reforms in the autonomous financing model, as we have done in the financing model with the needs of health financing. It is perhaps a good example of what we have had to do in Health to understand that our model surely needs reforms.

And, beyond an ideological issue of who contributes more or who contributes less, I believe we should approach the problem with a realistic vision and good functioning of the State and the Autonomous Communities. I believe that is what should be done, and, of course, the Government will work in that direction.

Mr. Rodríguez.- Mr. President, it is clear that any financing system must be based on responsibility, on the political will of self-government, and also on the capacity we have to develop. In this regard, I want to tell you that the current system cannot only be solved through the IRPF, but must take into account more taxes, precisely to ensure that it is a balanced system for all Autonomous Communities, particularly for those that are given the image that they are not capable of facing their expenses.

I give you a piece of data. Galicia, with the current system, only poorly covers 50 percent of the expenses of the Autonomous Community; the rest, the other 50 percent, appears as if it is given to us generously. However, the tax collection in Galicia is 7.662 billion euros, while the expenditure is 5.717 billion euros. I believe we must cover that expenditure one hundred percent and any model that does not...

President.- Mr. Rodríguez, with respect to the position you maintain, as could not be otherwise, I reiterate what I believe are the principles that should lead us to the reform of the financing model and that in the face of that reform we should approach it without prejudice, with a realistic vision and guaranteeing what is the principle of autonomy, which incorporates a principle of revenue autonomy, a principle of fiscal responsibility of the Autonomous Communities and, of course, a technical operational principle when establishing and determining which taxes can be in the hands of the Autonomous Communities and to what extent their regulatory capacity can be established so that the system, the market unity, and the principles of an economy that must function are in accordance...

Response to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, in countries with normal Presidents, Governments deal with the real problems of the people. Sometimes they get it right, sometimes they get it wrong; but Governments have objectives, they have projects, they distinguish the important from what is not, and, of course, they do not play with the fundamental.

Unfortunately, yours is not this case. You do not deal with real problems, and we have seen some things in recent days, but the worst is that you play with the essential and your frivolity is starting to be unprecedented, and we had warned you about something.

Can you tell me why you promoted this reform of the Catalan Statute? Why did you vote for it? How are you going to fix it, if you are the promoter and you voted for it? Do you remember that you promised you would vote for anything agreed upon by the Parliament of Catalonia? What are you going to fix? Why did you vote for it if you knew you had to fix it?

Mr. President, do you want to deceive someone? Are you somewhat ashamed of what you are doing in these last days?

President.- I must confess, Mr. Rajoy, that I am surprised, because your question referred to the problems of Spaniards and you have returned to the Catalan Statute of Autonomy.

I am going to talk about the problems of Spaniards and I will tell you what we are doing at this moment. Since we have been in Government, problems of Spaniards: unemployment, 900,000 more jobs, 200,000 fewer unemployed. Since we have been in Government, an 11 percent increase in the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, which has recovered the purchasing power that had been lost with the previous Government. Since we have been in Government, an increase in minimum pensions double that of pensions, recovering minimum pensions and gaining purchasing power, which are the pensioners who most need the effort of solidarity, which is what this Government does. Problem of Spaniards: housing, 70,000 more homes that have assistance with this Government; with the previous Government, there were aids for 110,000 homes and with this Government, for 180,000 homes a year.

That is solving, attending to, and being close to the problems of Spaniards.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, I do not ask you for knowledge, nor ideas, nor patriotism, because I do not ask for impossible things; nor do I ask you to say that Spain is a nation, nor to realize that the Statute of Catalonia is an important issue, which, apparently, it is not for you. But what I would like to ask you is to have your feet on the ground and a minimum of responsibility.

You have generated a lot of tension, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero. You have managed to make even in front of two Heads of State, in an embassy of a foreign country, Presidents of Autonomous Communities fight with a Minister of your Government.

You are the President of the Government of Spain. Now they use Mr. Maragall as a scapegoat, but you are the responsible one, Mr. President. What are you going to fix? Are you going to fix the nation issue? The confederation? The rupture of sovereignty?

Mr. President of the Government, you behave like an irresponsible person. There is no right to what you are doing to Spaniards and, in the meantime, keep making jokes in the magazine. What a level for the President of the Government of Spain, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero! What a level!

President.- I reiterate before the Chamber and before the citizens that, once again, Mr. Rajoy has not raised, despite it being his question, any of the real problems of the daily life of Spaniards, none. Not employment, not housing, not education, not health.

I will simply tell you to continue sliding down that slope of exaggeration, of announcing catastrophe, and of alarmism. It will happen to you as it has on all occasions. There will be a Statute, it will be reformed, things will continue to function well in this country, and you will be left without a discourse, because you do not have one, and without a project, because you have never had one.