Press conference of the President of the Government after the extraordinary European Council.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

10 February 2010 · Extraordinary European Council

Context
Zapatero addressed press after an extraordinary European Council on February 10, 2010, covering the EU 2020 Strategy and the Greek financial crisis response.
Main themes
EU Economic Strategy 2020, Greek debt crisis and eurozone stability, European economic governance, fiscal consolidation, EU solidarity and support mechanisms, economic recovery and growth, Spain's role in EU, Haiti humanitarian crisis, climate change postponement, eurogroup coordination
Duration
~25 min
76th percentile
Words
3,052
76th percentile
Sentences
90
58th percentile
Readability
39
34th percentile
Grade
16.1
84th percentile
Syntax
3.64
97th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

90 sentences in 42 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. I want to inform you about the development and outcome of this informal European Council which, as you know, was convened to analyze and evaluate the fundamental principles of what the Economic Strategy 2020 that the European Union will adopt this semester entails, and which has the fundamental objective of working towards economic recovery, improving the potential growth of the European economy, and strengthening cooperation, coordination, and what we have come to call European economic governance, based on the conviction that the sum of efforts and the integration of our economic policies strengthen our competitiveness and the achievement of our goals.

The President of the European Council, President Van Rompuy, and the President of the Commission, Durao Barroso, have presented two documents that have received very positive feedback and have led to a broad debate, which will undoubtedly allow the content of the 2020 Strategy, which will be approved in a first instance at the European Council next March, to be enriched, set objectives, establish monitoring mechanisms, and concentrate the energies of the entire European Union on relaunching our economic growth and generating employment in the medium term.

But, as you know, coinciding with this European Council, all the institutions of the Union and the twenty-seven countries had to respond to the situation in Greece; a response that involved and accepted two challenges: first, the stability of the eurozone and, second, the Union's own capacity to provide a solution, a European proposal that would guarantee a path of tranquility and stability for the eurozone, and also for Greece.

The solution you know is a European solution and, therefore, a pro-European solution, where the commitment of the Twenty-Seven and the European institutions to each and every one of the countries of the Union, in this case Greece, has been made evident, and, in particular, from the countries of the eurozone.

As you know, the European Council has decided, on the one hand, to assume the commitment of responsibility of Greece in complying with the fiscal consolidation plans that imply a reduction of four percentage points of its GDP deficit for 2010 and, at the same time, to establish the guarantee of support and solidarity, if necessary, for Greece. It is a positive solution, a solution of commitment from Greece and the entire Union that should facilitate the stability of the eurozone and, therefore, should guarantee what the European Union represents.

I must say that, from Spain's point of view, it fully responds to our objective, to the objective that had already been expressed through the work of these last days, especially in the Eurogroup, with the work that the Ministers of Economy and Finance carried out yesterday, and also with the expression that I conveyed this morning in the meeting we held with the President of the Permanent Council, the President of the Commission, the President of the Central Bank, and the President of the Eurogroup to address what should be an appropriate response from the European Council.

We are convinced that the Papandreou Government will fulfill its responsibility, we are convinced that Greece deserves the trust and support of the European Union, and we know that the Greek Government faces a difficult task ahead; but it must know that all the technical support from the Commission, the European Central Bank, and the European institutions is by its side, and that in this reasonable balance between responsibility and solidarity, the European Union today sends a message of tranquility and confidence about its system of operation and, in particular, in this case, about the eurozone.

Finally, the European Council has postponed its analysis on the issue of climate change and there has been a call from the High Representative, Catherine Ashton, regarding Haiti; a call regarding the situation in Haiti that, as you know, has been a special concern for Spain. It is a singular commitment of our country, where we are pouring resources of all kinds, and the call consists of the situation that nearly one million citizens of Haiti are currently facing, a situation of practically absolute difficulty in having shelter, in having accommodation. The response we must give as European countries to this grave situation, beyond the reconstruction plan and beyond the urgent aid plan, now represents a priority for the European Union, as we agreed in the Council meeting.

In short, the European Council has fulfilled its task, has been up to the circumstances, difficult, for the stability, in this case financial, of a country of the Union and of a country of the eurozone, and we are convinced that, ultimately, today is the first time that one of the objectives of the 2020 Strategy, which is economic cooperation among the Twenty-Seven and coordination in their decisions on economic policy, stability, security, and confidence, is being put to the test. Therefore, I believe we can be reasonably satisfied.

Q.- I wanted to raise two issues with you. On the one hand, I wanted to know, in your opinion, to what extent what has happened today represents a qualitative leap, and now with no turning back, around that idea of economic governance that you proposed as central to this semester's program, and also whether the documents that have been discussed include elements related to a possible European fiscal harmonization and to incentives or sanctions for those countries that do not meet the objectives set.

And, if you allow me, in a more domestic context, I wanted to know what possibilities you see for a national State Pact with all political parties to face the crisis; if in that scenario you foresee calling the leader of the opposition and if, as an alternative, you consider a more stable pact for what remains of the Legislature with CiU, as it has been the promoter of this initiative.

President.- Regarding the first question, indeed, I believe this is an example of the need for economic governance of the European Union. Moreover, I will tell you that this issue of economic governance has focused a good part of the debates and, as it was a debate of ideas, where all the leaders of the twenty-seven countries intervened, there have been references to fiscal harmonization; there have been references to the methods we must establish to be demanding in meeting the objectives; several ideas have been raised, diverse ideas, and also, for example, the need to open a debate around the future of the pension system, of our social protection systems, within the European Union.

As President Van Rompuy has expressed, there has also been the convenience or the idea of the convenience of holding more frequent meetings of the European Council to address economic governance, economic policy, economy. I believe it highlights that objective, which we fully share and which we have proposed, to increasingly turn the European Council into the great body that guarantees the economic governance of the European Union. There is, in my opinion, a clear climate in favor of that position.

When I speak of economic governance of the European Union, I am not only referring to economic governance in relation to the Twenty-Seven, but to economic governance in relation to the challenges of the economy in the global arena and the positions that the European Union must have on decisive issues for the future, such as the regulation of financial systems, the regulation of raw materials, or climate change; absolutely transcendental issues that must be discussed with other major international actors, with other major economic powers. Therefore, it has been an evident qualitative step.

Secondly, regarding agreements on economic policy in the face of the crisis, the Government has always been proposing in the initiative to promote agreements; we have done so in Parliament in all the initiatives, and there have been many, that we have had to face the crisis. Many of our initiatives have received broad parliamentary support and I hope that this capacity for dialogue that we have demonstrated can be intensified.

The Spokesperson for the Socialist Parliamentary Group has made it clear today that he will conduct a round of conversations with all groups to seek common elements in the fight against the economic crisis. Certainly, the Government sees it as a very good initiative and we will work together to try to strengthen, open, new spaces for agreement on economic matters in the fight against the crisis in our country.

Q.- President, in recent days, especially in the last week, the attacks on the Spanish economy have been quite harsh, especially from some international media. Moreover, we have been continuously compared on many occasions with Greece. I would like to know if you have had the opportunity, when you have seen all your European partners, to explain to them, to justify to them, or to give them details of what the real situation of the Spanish economy is.

President.- It seems to me that at this point it is quite evident that that attempt we experienced, particularly last week, to consider that our stability in public accounts was at some risk had no basis. It is possible that there were missing elements of judgment in some of the opinions, a more in-depth analysis of our reality regarding public accounts, or that there were other types of reasons. But if there was any decisive moment to know that none of that corresponds to reality, it was this European Council where, obviously, the objective has been to support Greece and where all countries have been involved in supporting Greece, and of course Spain first.

I hope, and there have been statements not only from the realm of opinion or the media, but from rating agencies, that in light of the intense debate that has taken place, they have clarified things. They have said what the Government has been saying, what it said last week, when, as a result of a drop in the stock market, a great debate was opened about the emergency. It was not true and I believe that, as the days have passed, few days, by the way, the solvency, the strength of our country's public accounts, and moreover, the credibility that the Government has to carry out the Fiscal Consolidation and deficit reduction Plan have become quite clear.

Therefore, I hope that this debate is now overcome, despite so many voices that decisively bet that we were like Greece. But that is how it sometimes happens and it would be advisable for us to prioritize other matters.

Q.- High Representative Ashton has raised the need to approve a aid plan for Haiti. What is Spain's position regarding the military mission there and what is that of the other members of the European Union?

What do you think about the rejection today by the European Parliament of the Swift agreement regarding the request for data by the United States? Could it affect relations with the United States?

President.- In response to the request from the High Representative, Catherine Ashton, there has certainly been a good receptivity. I have explained that it was a serious but very specific issue, which is the situation in which hundreds of thousands of Haitians find themselves without having anywhere to be. They have lost their homes, there are not enough means for them to be in a situation of minimal dignity, and, of course, Spain will evaluate the possibilities to help these citizens of Haiti through the means it already has deployed in the area or those it can deploy.

Regarding the Swift agreement, the Parliament has rejected it. We will need to open a period of reflection, of dialogue, with the United States, to renew this project and this attempt, because I believe it is important in the fight against terrorism.

It is likely that the path to this point has had, regarding the action and role of the European Parliament, a situation that needs to be improved and that can be improved. In my opinion, it should not affect the relationship with the United States; but I understand that an agreement between Europe and the United States in the fight against terrorism, in this case regarding the financing of terrorism, is important and we must work to achieve it.

Q.- Two questions, President. One, the stock market and the euro are falling after this political statement. Don’t you think that perhaps the European Council should have been a bit more specific about what kind of aid can be given to Greece?

Secondly, is Spain in a position or condition to buy Greek debt bonds if necessary?

President.- Regarding the first question, if we understand that every time the stock market goes up or down a point or two points it is due to political statements, we will have to convert a new discipline, which is the interpretation of the markets and politics, every day. We must have a little perspective and a broader view. Yesterday it went up and I don’t know if there were political statements, there was no informal Council, and maybe tomorrow it goes up. I think we need to have a broader perspective.

Certainly, what the European public, the Greek citizens, the markets, and the investors can know is that the European Union will support any country that is facing serious difficulties in its situation, in this case Greece, and that if the situation were to evolve towards the urgent need for assistance, the countries of the European Union would help Greece, and, of course, Spain as well.

It is true that for some who expressed their opinions last week about the situation in Spain, it would be strange, but since they are mistaken, Spain, of course, as well. We always assume our share of responsibility in the European Union, just as on many occasions the countries of the European Union have assumed their share of responsibility towards Spain, and they would do so if necessary.

Q.- I wanted to ask you a previous question that I believe has gone unanswered. Are you going to call Mariano Rajoy, the leader of the opposition, within that effort of the Government, as you have said, to promote dialogue, or will you wait for José Antonio Alonso to finish that round with the political groups? I remind you that you had planned to meet with Rajoy before the end of last year, and that meeting has not yet taken place. That on one side.

On the other hand, within the prudence that we have always been asked for, apparently there has been a new report today regarding the three Spanish aid workers kidnapped in Mali. I would like to know if you have any updates that can be shared.

President.- Regarding the first point, I must say that if I decide to call Mr. Rajoy, the first one to find out will be him. It seems to me that it is a matter of logical courtesy in political dialogue, which I always strive to maintain.

Regarding the second point, I must say that I have learned of the news. We must be prudent, especially at this time. The Government continues to work intensively with all the means at its disposal so that we can soon see the release of the hostages, and conveying, within the situation, which is delicate, a message of calm and reasonable confidence, although we are always in a territory, as you can well understand, that is difficult to manage.

Q.- You have said that Spain is not in the same situation as Greece. When Commissioner Almunia spoke on Tuesday about serious, grave risks of contagion from the situation in Greece to other countries in the Eurozone, which countries was he referring to?

President.- I am not in Mr. Almunia's thoughts. He should answer that, as is natural.

Certainly, what I have said and reiterate is what the situation of Spain is, but it has not been the Government that has said it; some rating agencies have just stated it, and the data is quite objective: we have twenty points less debt than the average of the European Union, we have less public debt than most of the major European economic powers, and we have a plan for reducing the deficit.

The other day I said it in Parliament, and I reiterate it today: Spain is issuing ten-year debt at a lower price, at a lower cost, for our country than in February 2004. The data is significant. Do we have work to do? Without a doubt. Reduce the deficit, as we have committed to do. But we have a very clear strength, and I hope that everyone begins to understand that it is so, that the analyses are made correctly, and that we do not give rise to, because it has an effect, without a doubt it has an effect, on the markets themselves or on investors that can be of concern.

Q.- Why has Spain, specifically the Spanish Presidency, been absent from the last meeting before the start of the Summit, which seems to have been decisive for the agreement reached today, where France, Germany, etc., were present, but not Spain?

President.- Allow me to make a somewhat ironic comment: last week we were like Greece, and today we are out of the problem of Greece. Each week has its own effort.

But I will tell you that today, from eight-thirty to ten in the morning, we have been working monographically, as the rotating Presidency, with the Permanent President of the Council, with the President of the Commission, with the President of the Eurogroup, and with the President of the Central Bank to seek a solution to the Greek issue. Then there was another meeting, which the Permanent President of the Council deemed necessary, to make the final effort, the necessary effort, for the agreement. But the strategy was set in the meeting at 8:30, and, as is natural, the President of the Council and the President of the Commission know very well whom they need to convince and whom they need to ask for support in the end so that the agreement, which had already been outlined yesterday among the members of the Eurogroup, would be the agreement that today the entire European Council ratified, as it has been, of which we should be pleased.

Thank you.