Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

16 February 2010 · Parliamentary control session · Madrid, Spain

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions in Spain's Congress on February 16, 2010, regarding the governance and merger of Galician Savings Banks.
Main themes
Savings Banks governance, Galician financial identity, FROB restructuring, political vs. technical economic decisions, Autonomous Communities rights, financial sector solvency, Galicia-central government relations, banking mergers
Duration
~18 min
60th percentile
Words
2,121
60th percentile
Sentences
77
50th percentile
Readability
41
39th percentile
Grade
14.3
70th percentile
Syntax
3.19
71st percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
44th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 38%38%
  • Economic 23%23%
  • Ceremonial 17%17%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 8%8%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

77 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Francisco Xesús Jorquera, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Jorquera.- Mr. President of the Government, does the Government believe that the transfer of the governing centers of the Savings Banks to Madrid is the solution to the economic crisis and its impact on the financial sector?

President.- The truth is that the Government does not decide anything at all regarding the decision-making centers of the Savings Banks. The Government strives to be scrupulously respectful of the processes that the Banks decide; the Government understands that the Governments of the Autonomous Communities must also be respectful of the processes that occur within the financial entities, credit unions, in their territory; the Government, with the favorable report of the Council of State, has filed an appeal regarding the Law of Savings Banks of Galicia, and the Government, as always, has initiated a dialogue with the Government of Galicia to seek a meeting point in light of the discrepancies in the interpretation of some contents of the Law of Savings Banks.

But the Government, as I said before, calls for us not to make the financial system and the Savings Banks an element for political and partisan confrontation. The call is to everyone, and I include all Groups and, of course, my own first, because we are talking about something else, and the financial system requires measures and responses of a technical nature, of solvency and security, because there are very important decisions at stake.

Mr. Jorquera.- Mr. President, it is evident that the merger must have the consent of the Savings Banks. The Galician Law of Savings Banks does not intend anything else; it simply establishes the mandatory authorization of the Autonomous Community for any merger operation, as do other existing Savings Banks laws.

But, if I may add a nuance, the future decision of the Savings Banks does not depend solely and exclusively on their current executives. One problem with the current situation of the financial sector is that some executives have made Savings Banks, which are of a social nature, their private estate. That is why the Law of Savings Banks also establishes criteria for the renewal of the governing bodies so that they truly reflect Galician society and make their future decisions based on the interests of Galician society.

But what I do not share at all is your view that politics should be distanced from this decision. Defending the Galician identity of the Savings Banks to ensure that the savings of Galicia are invested in Galicia and contribute to our development is a political position, but it is also an economic position. We do not agree with the divorce between the economy and politics. We believe that different economic policies are possible depending on the interests that one wishes to defend.

And, if we are talking about politics, Mr. President, keep in mind that the FROB, which is driving this process of concentration in the Savings Banks sector, is a political decision adopted by this Chamber.

And, if we are talking about politics, keep in mind that your Government's attitude of using different standards, applying the funnel law to Galicia when measuring the constitutionality of a Law of Savings Banks or its compliance with the LORCA; behaving, ultimately, as if there were first or second-class Autonomous Communities in this matter, is also a political position.

How can it be understood that practically all the articles challenged in the Galician law coincide with those established in other autonomous laws, some of them established very recently and once the FROB was instituted? This is a political position; therefore, do not disguise a political position that seeks to hinder the merger of the Galician Savings Banks to favor their absorption by entities from outside with technical arguments. We are talking about credit entities, Mr. President, and if we are talking about credit, believe me, you are gambling with your credit and the credit of your Government and your party before Galicia. That is why we ask you to rectify.

President.- Mr. Jorquera, I believe it is easy to understand that the Government... And personally, I see with all the sympathy in the world that Galicia has good financial entities, solvent and solid, that are Galician and that channel Galician savings. It would only be missing! I see it as a proposal and as a reasonable policy, but with a nuance: it is the Government's responsibility, and above all the Bank of Spain's, to guarantee the solvency of any restructuring or merger process because, if not, the consequences, do you know what they are, if there is no solvency, for the future? That all citizens have to face a situation of insolvency. That is the limit and that is reasonable. That is neither political nor anti-political; it is common sense.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Gaspar Llamazares, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana-Izquierda Unida-Iniciativa per Catalunya Verds

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Llamazares.- Mr. President of the Government, do you intend to withdraw the proposal to raise the retirement age, considering the unanimous rejection of the Spanish population and also considering the rejection of the trade union organizations and the vast majority of the Parliamentary Groups in this Chamber?

President.- Mr. Llamazares, I have already referred to this issue before. The Government is fulfilling a mandate, a request from the Chamber and makes a proposal, which includes the extension of the retirement age, regarding the future of the pension system to have a calm national debate, because we can have a calm one. We are not in a hurry regarding the solvency and solidity of the Social Security system.

That debate is necessary. Not having it is irresponsible and not telling citizens that in twenty-five years we may have problems in Social Security due to the aging population and because we want to maintain good pensions and better pensions every day for all those who reach retirement age would be irresponsible. We are going to do it.

Our proposal, as it cannot be otherwise, is a proposal for consensus, I have said it, in the Toledo Pact with the parties and with the social agents. We are open to other proposals, to discuss them, to put them on the table and to seek the best one from our principles, from our analysis and from our position.

That is why I told you to go to the Table, explain and reason alternative proposals. We are going to listen, and, as the national interest and as I consider that Social Security and the pension system are above any other circumstance, my desire and my fundamental commitment is a great national agreement on the future of the pension system. That is the position of the Government.

Mr. Llamazares.- As a supporter of deliberative democracy, this response is striking, because it is tantamount to saying that you want enlightenment, I don't know if divine or otherwise; that you are convinced that the only salvation of the pension system is your proposal and that, therefore, you couldn't care less what the vast majority of citizens think, what the Parliamentary Groups think, and what the trade unions think.

I believe you should rectify and allow for a dialogue without strings attached within the framework of the Toledo Pact Commission. Your proposal is a string attached; your proposal is a proposal that creates uncertainty about our pension system, when until now you had been defending its viability; your proposal creates division in the Toledo Pact and among political forces, when until now there had been dialogue, and your proposal, moreover, is an unjust proposal, Mr. President.

It is unjust in a country where the actual retirement age is close to 65 years to propose a retirement goal beyond 65 years, because that is not our main problem — it may be for other countries, but it is not our main problem and it is also unjust because you do it by calculating life expectancy and not calculating the evolution of productivity.

At this moment we spend 9 percent of the Gross Domestic Product, three points less than the European average, on pensions; therefore, it is not that we are extravagant with pensions. And at this moment the average Spanish pension is 65 percent of the average pension in the European Union.

Therefore, there is no justification for this measure on the part of the Government. This measure on the part of the Government creates uncertainty in public pensions and hides something very important, which is that private pensions have lost 20 percent of their value. And the consequent question to the Government is: are you not benefiting private pensions with these proposals and harming the public pension service?

President.- What characterizes a deliberative democracy is the right to propose and, if it is also accompanied by the commitment to seek the agreement of all, it is even more deliberative, more constructive, and more positive. What cannot be and what goes against a deliberative democracy is not to tell the truth about things and the problems we have. That does not go with deliberative democracy.

I will tell you that the retirement age in Spain is 63 years, 63 years and a few months; the real one. We are the country in Europe with the highest life expectancy, fortunately, and that poses a specific problem for us. And, moreover, we are a country that deserves to improve pensions and we will do so if we all make an effort, because there are very low pensions and, above all, because there will be problems for retirement for those who have lost their jobs in this process, who will have to retire with a decent pension.

In that commitment we are and in that we want to work.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, I am going to make a deliberative proposal as well, and that is that you come here to deliberate on an important matter.

As you know, throughout almost all of last year, especially in the last months, there has been a very intense international debate on the redefinition of the strategy in Afghanistan. Furthermore, as you also know, we now have many more soldiers, when you said in 2008 that you would not send more soldiers to Afghanistan; then there were 220, then the electoral battalion — it is true that it has already returned — and now you intend to send 500 more soldiers to Afghanistan.

On the other hand, the operability of our Army today is greater and it is obvious that we are facing a war scenario. It is logical, therefore, that once things have changed and, since you have not debated this issue here in the Cortes since 2004, you come.

Therefore, the purpose of this intervention is to tell you that you must come here, because it is an important issue for the world but also for Spain and also for the Spaniards, to explain the nature of the mission, the cost, the security, and, above all, the future prospects. I ask you to come here and I already announce to you, in case there is any doubt, which I am sure there is not, that I will support, and my Group will also, the sending of 500 more soldiers to Afghanistan. But I believe that the Spaniards should know exactly, as the citizens of other countries who are in Afghanistan have known from their Heads of State or Government, the issues I have referred to.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I appreciate your commitment. In this you have a coherence that you have maintained over time, in supporting the sending of troops to Afghanistan, which the Minister of Defense will explain today in Committee. You have been consistent.

I believe that the Government has appeared on many occasions, but it is an important issue for our country. It is the most difficult mission we have, and in the interest of a good climate, I will heed your request. I will appear before this Chamber in a Plenary that, of course, I hope will be set by the whole of the Groups on a reasonable date in light of the calendar and the agenda that, as a result of the European Presidency, we have in this period; but I am sure that the Groups will reach an agreement.

With this — these things happen rarely — I give you satisfaction. Mr. Rajoy, yes, I will heed your request and I will appear in the Chamber on Afghanistan.