Press conference of the Prime Minister after the European Council meeting.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

8 December 2011 · European Council meeting (press conference after)

Context
Zapatero addressed press following the December 2011 European Council meeting, reporting on key agreements reached by eurozone leaders on fiscal integration and debt stabilization.
Main themes
European fiscal pact, sovereign debt crisis, eurozone stabilization mechanisms, European Stability Mechanism, budgetary golden rule, fiscal consolidation, private sector participation, eurozone institutional strengthening, intergovernmental treaty, Greece exception
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,293
88th percentile
Sentences
155
82nd percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
13.6
63rd percentile
Syntax
3.38
88th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
22nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

155 sentences in 62 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. I appear before you to report on this important European Council that has just concluded. I will briefly outline the main agreements reached by the heads of state and government of the euro area; agreements that reflect a determined political will from the seventeen countries that make up the euro to advance towards greater economic integration that supports the functioning of the Monetary Union.

We have decided to strengthen both the institutional architecture of the European Union and the monetary union, as well as the stabilization mechanisms against the sovereign debt crisis. These are additional substantial steps to those we have been taking over the last eighteen months since the acute onset of the debt crisis in European markets in the spring of 2010.

Regarding the institutional strengthening of the euro area, I want to highlight what is already known as the "fiscal pact." This pact has one objective: to improve the effectiveness of fiscal supervision, ensure fiscal consolidation processes, and seek budgetary balance, fiscal balance, so that in the future there will be no more problems with the sovereign debts of the countries in the euro area.

From that fiscal pact, I would highlight two major measures. The first is the incorporation of the so-called "golden rule," that is, the principle of budgetary stability that will be incorporated into national constitutions or laws of equivalent rank, as we have already done in Spain through a constitutional reform process, which you are aware of, with the agreement of the two major parties and which, without a doubt, is a factor of confidence, guarantee, and compliance with this new fiscal pact for the euro area.

Secondly, there will be greater automaticity in the excessive deficit procedure to ensure greater control, greater supervision, and ultimately, also greater foresight to avoid excessive deficits.

The other major block, alongside the institutional strengthening of the Monetary Union, alongside the institutional strengthening through the fiscal pact I just referred to, pertains to the stabilization mechanisms or, if you allow me, defense mechanisms—some have called them firewalls—to combat the risks of crises or problems arising from sovereign debt.

We have always defended this principle and have always argued that Europe should progressively and steadily establish a sufficient mechanism that guarantees the sustainability of the debt for all countries in the euro area and also to prevent possible attacks on it.

To this end, we have decided on some relevant measures. First, to bring forward the operational start of the European Stability Mechanism to July 2012, the definitive mechanism, that is, the European financial safety net, which will be permanent, replacing the facility that has currently acted to address the crisis in Greece, Portugal, and Ireland, and which will have an effective lending capacity of five hundred billion euros.

We have therefore agreed to expedite its decision-making process to make it more effective, moving from the rule of unanimity to that of qualified majority, with 85 percent of the representation of the countries to make it effective, to apply it at each specific moment.

And the most important thing, from my point of view, is that we have reaffirmed, in a forceful manner, the exceptional nature of the Greek case regarding the participation of the private sector. On some occasions, in this room and elsewhere, you have heard me state that the consequence of the so-called Deauville Summit, which opened the door to the participation of the private sector in the processes of addressing sovereign debt crises, the restructuring of private debt had undoubtedly been a decisive factor for that extension or systemic situation that we have largely experienced and continue to experience in the sovereign debt of the countries in the euro area.

Hence, I want to highlight in a particular way, because this is a fundamental message, that Greece is an absolute exception, that this will not be contemplated again, and that, therefore, it must be a factor of confidence for investors regarding the commitments that the various countries in the euro area have concerning our sovereign debt.

The political agreement on these relevant issues is based on the seventeen countries of the euro area, the seventeen countries that make up the common currency; but it is not limited to the seventeen countries. The reasonable expectation is that the vast majority of the other ten countries will join this political agreement, which will be translated into an intergovernmental agreement and must be made and completed before March 2012 regarding its specific content. In fact, in the next two or three weeks, there will already be a first approach, a first definition, of the content of that fiscal pact that will be taken to an intergovernmental treaty of the seventeen, surely, and, most likely, of the vast majority of the other ten countries of the European Union.

These are the two major agreements we have achieved at this Council. They are two agreements that must sustain confidence; that reaffirm the commitment of the euro area to itself, of all countries with the common currency; that provide more security regarding the financial support instrument available to all countries, and that give more confidence in the medium and long term because, without a doubt, the euro area will be a zone of fiscal strength, of guarantee of public accounts, of sustainability, both through the commitment of each of the countries in the euro area and through the additional, fundamental commitment of guaranteeing the entire euro area, in collaboration with European institutions.

Allow me to also refer to some other aspects that are in the Resolutions and that are important, affecting the enlargement policy and the foreign policy of the European Union; specifically, Croatia. Today we welcomed Croatia after the signing of its Accession Treaty; furthermore, an important step has been taken, a positive outlook, regarding the possible candidate status of Serbia, a topic that is undoubtedly also fundamental for the future and stability in the Balkans, and the perspective of opening accession negotiations with Montenegro in June 2012 has been considered.

Iran. The Council has also conveyed and received the text of conclusions on Iran adopted by the Foreign Affairs Council on December 1. In this way, the European Union expresses again, as it has done through the Council and the entire group of countries, its rejection of the events that occurred with the British Embassy in that country; its concern and monitoring of Iran's nuclear program and, of course, in close coordination with international partners, the adoption of additional measures, which include those that may affect the Iranian financial system, transportation, and the energy sector, in response to Iran's attitude.

These are perhaps the three fundamental issues concerning the non-economic part of the European Council. I must add something in this Council and in this press conference that has some unique characteristics, as you undoubtedly know well.

The first of these is that we have worked in full coordination with the Popular Party, as is appropriate, given that it is a caretaker government, with the party that will govern Spain. Specifically, I have had a permanent dialogue with Mr. Rajoy, most recently this morning, about the development of the Council, about exhaustive information on what the positions maintained have been, and, above all, about the task that, as you may have deduced from the information I have just referred to, we have ahead of us as a country in the coming weeks and months, especially to consolidate that intergovernmental treaty.

Therefore, I express my satisfaction with the degree of collaboration, with the degree of coordination, which simply demonstrates how a serious country, a member country of the European Union and the euro area, such as Spain, should work.

This is the last European Council I attend as Prime Minister, as you well know. I believe I have attended 44 European Councils and EU Summits; therefore, it is a sufficiently high number to convey some conclusion, some feeling, from that experience.

The first is that it has been an immense honor to represent my country in a forum like this in Europe.

The second is that I have always worked thinking that strengthening the European Union was strengthening Spain; the future, the well-being, and the desires of the Spanish people.

The third is that I arrived here with all my European vocation, with my European conviction, and after this time and after the last two years, which have been of difficult decisions and intense debates, some even until the early hours of the morning, like yesterday's, my European vocation, my conviction, is even firmer. The present and future of Spain, its well-being, and its economic recovery depend, to a large extent, on the strength, determination, and political will for unity that we Europeans have.

Finally, I wish to sincerely thank all of you, who have regularly followed me in these press appearances, for your attitude, your tone, and your intelligent questions, from which I have undoubtedly learned on many occasions. I hope that your work continues to go as well as possible and that you renew and maintain that European faith.

Q.- You mentioned the Deauville agreement as one of the key moments in the debt crisis of recent months. Do you think that things, beyond that misstep, could have been done differently? Could Europe have supported other economies that initially should not have been affected by the crisis and did not do so? Do you have any reproach to make to any of your European colleagues?

President.- We probably lack perspective to make or elevate that conclusion definitively. Let us start from a fact that is clear and indisputable: the European Union has faced the toughest, most serious, most difficult crisis since its inception. It is a great test. We must overcome it. In my opinion, we still have half the journey ahead.

If you were to ask me, "What have you done in these three years?" we have tried to respond, with successes and mistakes, which there have been; we have covered half the journey, and we have the other half left to guarantee the sustainability of the debt, to guarantee economic recovery, which is the objective, and job creation, and to perfect the entire architecture that, without a doubt, the Monetary Union needed to perfect when it was launched. We have debated many times that a common currency, without a fiscal union, without a common defense mechanism, suffered from problems.

Therefore, we lack perspective.

What I can state is that, since April-May, since the spring of 2010, the effort has been enormous and, although it is true that the debt problems have spread to several countries, we cannot forget that it is the first time in history that a political union, that a region, that an economic union faces this challenge and where a good part of the countries in the euro area, and also of the Union as a whole, have to explain to their citizens that they are lending money to other countries. This was not in the design of the Europeanists, nor of the founding fathers, nor of those who created the Monetary Union; it was not there, and we have had to build it, yes, with successes and with mistakes.

You recalled, because I have stated it, that the moment to open the door to the participation of the private sector for Greece was a very difficult moment. One can argue in favor of that decision the enormous volume of Greek debt and the difficulty of assuming that enormous volume because, certainly, given what Greece represents in terms of GDP and population, the volume of its public debt commitments has reached levels... Just one example: for the IMF, the program with Greece is the largest program in its entire history in which it has participated. Therefore, let us put it into perspective.

The fundamental issue at this moment is that the light, even if it is still far away, can be seen at the end, and the first step is the recovery of confidence among international economic actors, among investors, because if the tension in the markets regarding sovereign debt continues indefinitely, the economic recovery, which is key to creating jobs and to being able to pay off our debts and what we have had to finance, will be much more difficult.

Q.- Two questions. First, yesterday the Popular Party made it known that it wanted to increase the votes needed to activate the new rescue fund from 85 percent to 90 percent. I would like to know if that request was conveyed and why it was not deemed appropriate to include it.

A second question. After 44 Summits, you are leaving; Europe is dominated by the center-right; austerity is perhaps not the only, but the guiding principle of this Europe, and intergovernmentalism has also advanced. I wanted to know, in that context, what you believe has been the main achievement in the European policy of the Spanish Government and also what decision or measure, if there is a specific example, you would have liked to see decided and it has not been possible.

President.- Regarding the qualified majority --I explained it very briefly before so that we understand what we are talking about--, when the rule of unanimity was established, countries like Spain, and some others --you can easily imagine which countries; it would be easy to make the list--, we expressed our concern, because it is a very strict rule when it comes to that fund being able to lend money, to intervene. It is an important step that the rule of unanimity is not present.

It is true that this raised a derivative that, in my opinion, has another dimension, which is that moving from 85 to 90 percent meant that Spain alone could veto. But the objective of a country like ours, more than vetoing, is to facilitate the possibility of having that mechanism act.

Therefore, I understand the request, and I have shared it, I have proposed reaching 90 percent --I proposed it on two occasions: yesterday, mainly, at night and in the early morning--; but there was a criterion, which was the one that has been followed, for the 85 percent and it is to follow the same rule as the IMF. There was a clear consensus on that. It has a basis, the 85 percent is what the IMF requires, and it has been maintained at 85 percent.

I have already explained this to Mr. Rajoy this morning and I believe he understood it perfectly. Although we would have liked that 90 percent, to have, let’s say, that possibility, which we surely would never have used because, by nature, our country in this situation is favorable to the application of the Stability Mechanism, as is natural.

Who have been the ones who have had to come to this position? Germany, the Netherlands, Finland..., the countries that are always much more demanding in this context and at this historical moment when it comes to applying all the funds that are put in place to safeguard, to act as a firewall, against sovereign debt problems.

As for the achievement, that corresponds to others, to you, who are the ones who evaluate and analyze. I believe that Spain, throughout this time and in all the trajectory since our incorporation, has been characterized by being a country faithful to constructive Europeanism. That is the line I have followed, that I have maintained, and I believe it is what suits Spain.

Q.- It seems that a strict fiscal discipline is now imposed. I wanted to know how it can favor economic recovery, specifically, in Spain. Do you perhaps miss a commitment to some kind of stimulus? Can the return to economic growth slow down?

President.- Also in this we should have a bit of perspective. Is fiscal discipline or fiscal rigor, the search for budgetary balance, being reimposed? From 2004 to 2008 Spain had a budget surplus. The Government I presided over understood that this was good for the Spanish economy. It is true that, when you face a crisis of the magnitude, severity, or dimension that this one has had, you inevitably have to resort to fiscal stimuli. That was the decision, clearly, at the end of 2008, of Europe and the G-20, until those fiscal stimuli generated a problem in sovereign debt as a consequence, especially, of Greece and its possible systemic effect.

Anyone who approaches how public budgets should be managed reasonably supports that revenues and expenditures must be balanced; that there are exceptional circumstances where one can act, with limits, depending on the economic cycle; but that what is known as structural deficit must be strictly controlled because, if it is not strictly controlled, when an economic recession arrives, a drop in revenues, the problem regarding debt falls with great virulence, putting many things at risk: putting at risk the fiscal capacity of the State and also the economy.

What is the stimulus that the economy needs at this moment? The fundamental stimulus is that tensions in the markets decrease, that liquidity returns to the banks. That is the greatest stimulus.

Look, if we observe what has happened since May 2010 to now in our country, there are almost two parallel lines in that, when market tensions have flared up, our economy has immediately suffered, and employment. Why? Because banks find it harder to finance themselves, because companies find it harder to have liquidity, it is harder for them to ask banks, their investment plans are cut, they have to reduce costs and it affects the economy.

Therefore, the most important stimulus that the eurozone needs at this moment, and particularly the Spanish economy, is confidence, credibility, sustainability. That it does not cost us to finance ourselves as an economy as much as it costs us at this moment, that there is liquidity in banks so that they can lend money to SMEs, so that they can create jobs and so that, by creating jobs, the spending capacity of Spaniards and demand increases; that is the fundamental stimulus. Then, some reforms that remain pending, as is natural, although many of them have been made.

In short, the capacity for financing and credibility for the financing of the entire economic system of the eurozone and of Spain, that is the greatest stimulus. When we recover this, there may be other stimuli, which may be of different nature: fiscal, monetary..., but this is the most important today.

Q.- President, I have not heard you --perhaps I missed it-- give an assessment of the agreements of this Summit. It is evident that we leave here with an agreement, but with an intergovernmental agreement, outside the community procedure, which is the one that Spain has always defended. I wanted to ask you what assessment you make.

I also wanted to ask you what assessment you make of these results in light of what you have just raised. That is to say, do you think this agreement will restore confidence in the sovereign debt of euro countries and will contribute to easing market pressure? Does the fact that all euro countries, and some more, have accepted very firm and strict commitments to fiscal and budgetary discipline serve to activate other mechanisms? For example, can the European Central Bank intervene with more freedom, as other central banks in other countries do? Can we expect this now as a complement to budgetary discipline?

Finally, indeed, you have said it, it is your last European Council. I do not know if you have had the opportunity to say goodbye to some of the leaders with whom you have shared, if not all 44, at least a good part of the European Summits.

President.- There are many questions. It is almost a press conference in itself.

Assessment? My assessment is positive, but we have experiences from European Councils, and the positive assessment is consolidated when the whole of the economic actors --I am not only referring to investors-markets, but I am referring to the great economic powers, to the great international organizations, such as the IMF, the United States, China, emerging countries-- support, back, and see that these are decisions that go in the right direction. We will see that in the next 24 or 48 hours. As always, we have experience from Councils and, therefore, I reserve that final assessment.

Second, the vast majority of countries, if not almost all but one, would have opted for a treaty, for a reform of the treaties. It could be with more scope or less scope, accompanied by more derived law or not; but there has been one country, and since this is with twenty-seven, that is Great Britain, that said "no." It said "no" because it was asking for other parallel things, but that is another issue. But for one, this will not stop, it is evident, and, as we have a reasonable, solid alternative, which is the intergovernmental treaty, especially because the countries of the eurozone need it, it is very positive that we are going to advance in that direction.

European Central Bank. We must respect what the Central Bank does, what the Central Bank says. The day before yesterday it took very favorable measures for the liquidity of the banks and, even, some are unprecedented in the limits that have been set. I have no doubt that the European Central Bank knows it has to contribute to the stability of the monetary area; but it acts independently and makes its own decisions, with its own evaluations and its own analyses.

Regarding future proposals, there was quite a bit of debate yesterday about eurobonds. Although it seems that this has not been picked up, there was quite a bit of debate about eurobonds. I believe that --I will no longer be in that discussion-- next year this will undoubtedly be discussed, and it will continue to be discussed, and my impression is that the space will expand.

Finally, yes, of course, I have said goodbye to all my colleagues and to some with whom I have been, logically, for several years here. In particular, I was with the President of the Council, Herman Van Rompuy, this morning. I have had a few words with everyone. You know that in these proceedings people are extraordinarily affectionate, right? That has been the case.

Q.- I wanted to ask you precisely about your conversation with Mariano Rajoy. Did you discuss the issue of eurobonds, because you say that it will continue to be discussed and it is assumed that Spain will continue to defend it? Did you talk to Mariano Rajoy about this specific issue?

How was that request received, if you made it, for the European Central Bank, while maintaining its independence, to be more flexible in helping countries in trouble like Spain to overcome the debt crisis? It has already done so, but has the rest of the countries accepted that Spanish request well, if it has been made?

President.- Regarding the issue of eurobonds, I did not specifically talk about it with Mr. Rajoy today; but undoubtedly I will talk, because I am going to give him as exhaustive a report as I can about the development of the Council to know the different positions and why I said that we will talk about eurobonds next year.

Regarding the European Central Bank, this is one of the great debates. I have explained on some occasions --I did so yesterday during the lengthy dinner-- that if one looks at the major economic areas of the world, one observes something significant, which is that the eurozone has less debt and less deficit than the United States, the eurozone has less debt and less deficit than Great Britain, and the eurozone has less debt and less deficit than Japan, and yet it has much higher interest rates: the average interest rate of the eurozone is in the one and a bit-two for others and for us, an average rate of five. So, that is surprising. Less deficit, less debt and higher interest rates paid to finance.

Then, you compare other parameters, and what do you observe? That the eurozone is the one where its Central Bank has, by far, less public debt outstanding. Compare it with the United States, with Great Britain, which has the most, or with Japan.

There we enter the eternal debate --I say "eternal" because this has been debated many times-- that is that the European Central Bank in the Treaties has the mandate it has, it is true: guarantor of inflation. And it does not have that other mandate. Fundamentally, there is a clear debate that is more conceptual, economic, about what the response should be to a serious economic crisis that affects the stability of public accounts and the need for debt: a proactive policy, which some would qualify as inflationary, or a policy, let’s say, more passive, which may have other advantages. There are many examples throughout history of responses in one direction or another. Sometimes, expansive policy has worked, a monetarist policy, a policy, as it is said, of injecting liquidity, and sometimes it has not worked.

Therefore, I believe that we will continue to have that debate, because it is a debate of all economic schools and of all known experiences. As almost always happens, surely none of the extreme positions is the correct one, but rather a balanced position, where central banks act in certain circumstances, but that they do not excessively monetize the debt, because we know that this in the short or medium term is inflation and that generates problems also for economic growth and, surely, for employment.

Thank you very much. Until next time.