Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

28 September 2004 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions during a 2004 congressional control session, addressing Spain's anti-hunger commitments and budgetary development aid targets.
Main themes
Fight against hunger, development cooperation aid, Alliance against Hunger, government budget commitments, official development assistance targets, debt cancellation for developing countries, FAD credits reform, Spain's foreign aid policy, parliamentary accountability, electoral promises vs. government actions, media and regulatory body appointments
Duration
~12 min
43rd percentile
Words
1,477
43rd percentile
Sentences
46
30th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
13.6
63rd percentile
Syntax
3.41
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 67%67%
  • Economic 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

46 sentences in 25 paragraphs

Mr. Llamazares.- Mr. President of the Government, you have recently attended the Summit against Hunger; an important gesture, but we would like to know what concrete commitments the Government is making regarding the fight against hunger, specifically in the upcoming General State Budgets.

President.- Mr. Llamazares, as I had committed to the citizens, Spain has joined the quintet known as the Alliance against Hunger, along with Chile, France, Brazil, and the United Nations. Recently, as you recalled, an important meeting was held at the United Nations that concluded with a political manifesto signed by more than 113 countries, which should represent an important element of mobilization in the world in the face of what represents a lamentable situation that, of course, will not allow us to meet the goals set by the Millennium Summit to halve the number of people suffering from poverty by 2015.

The commitment that the Government has, particularly in reference to what you are asking, is very clear: to reach 0.5 percent of Gross Domestic Product in the next four years, in this legislature, and I am sure that this goal is shared by the vast majority of the Chamber.

Mr. Llamazares.- Mr. President, we are in times of gestures — we value them; we do not underestimate gestures — but we are, above all, in a time of Budgets and, therefore, what is important at this moment is to fulfill the commitments made. In that sense, our Parliamentary Group sees too much continuity and a timid change in the Budgets for next year; too much continuity in economic, fiscal, and labor policies, policies that we do not like, and a timid change in social and solidarity policies. And I say timid, Mr. President, because in contrast to the Monterrey Summit, where the proposal was to reach 0.5 percent in 2006 but to meet the 0.33 percent of Gross Domestic Product next year, however, in the draft Budgets for next year we are still far from that goal.

We believe that it is necessary to advance the changes in policies and that it is also necessary to identify the social and solidarity shifts in the budgetary policy for next year.

In that sense, it seems to us that the next Budget should be more incisive in budgetary policy so that, at least, we reach 0.3 percent of Gross Domestic Product dedicated to development cooperation in 2005; that the FAD credits be reviewed, which are credits that, more than responding to the interests of developing countries, sometimes respond to the interests of donor countries; and, on the other hand, that the cancellation of external debt to underdeveloped countries or to countries suffering from hunger and poverty be decisively addressed, and that it be canceled in exchange for investments in public services, education, and health.

These are the proposals of our Parliamentary Group, and it seems to us that the draft Budgets still remains in a position halfway between the necessary change and the continuity of outdated policies.

President.- You know that I like quiet changes, and also in what affects budgetary policy. I must reiterate what the commitment of our Government is.

I am convinced and have the political will that the Budget that this Chamber will debate and approve will represent a significant increase in aid for development cooperation, and I know that for this task, I am convinced, we will have the support of your Group.

In addition to that, I want to tell you that we are decisively involved in carrying out debt swap operations for social development initiatives, especially in primary education; that Spain will promote, both in the United Nations, as well as in the World Bank, and in the International Monetary Fund, a policy of concerted debt cancellation and that we are integrated into the technical group of the Quintet against Hunger to promote new instruments.

Believe me, Your Honor, that the commitment of this Government is firm to decisively contribute to cooperation and to victory over poverty and hunger, although some may find it naive. That is not the case with Your Honor, and I thank you for that.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. MARIANO RAJOY, OF THE POPULAR PARLIAMENTARY GROUP

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you committed — you — in your electoral program, among many other proposals, to choose the Director General of Spanish Radio and Television and the President of the EFE Agency by a qualified majority of two-thirds of the Congress, to renounce the Government's monopoly — I read your program — in the appointment of its executive members of regulatory bodies, citing the National Securities Market Commission and the National Telecommunications Commission.

Mr. President, you lied. You did not fulfill any of this. You did exactly the opposite of what your electoral program states, and yet, neither in your electoral program nor in your investiture speech was there any proposal for reform regarding the system of election of judicial vacancies by the Judicial Power Council. Here too you lied; you concealed the truth.

This is not a quiet change, as you just said. You broke the rules of the game that have governed since the existence of the Judicial Power Council. You did it for pure partisan interests and deceived us all.

And I ask you, Mr. President, what is the use of your program and what is the use of your word? Answer me.

President.- I like quiet change, a calm Government, and from experience, I can also tell you that a calm opposition is good. But, well...

In relation to the question, I will tell you, Mr. Rajoy, that the proposal of the Bill that Parliament is going to send to this Chamber responds to a set of initiatives to revitalize democracy; some have already occurred, such as, for example, that the sending of troops be voted on by Parliament; as, for example, that Parliament now — which is what it should have done before — does not have to find itself in the situation of debating a Budget Accompanying Law, which became the mechanism of lack of transparency; or, for example, the fact that the Socialist Group has renounced to ask questions to the President of the Government in this process.

There are new initiatives underway. In this session, we are going to send a law for the reform of the regulations of high-ranking officials, for greater transparency; a law on institutional advertising, to end propaganda and guarantee objectivity; and, at the beginning of the year, the reform of public media, which, as Your Honor knows, is pending the report from the Council that is carrying out this task.

Therefore, yes, indeed, this is one more measure to revitalize democracy, Mr. Rajoy.

Mr. Rajoy.- I am also in favor of a calm opposition, but, Mr. President, kicking the board and the rules of the game is an undemocratic position, and anything but calm. And that is what you have done, Mr. President of the Government.

After the answer you have given me, I have no choice but to reaffirm the words I said earlier. For now, your word is worth nothing. You lied about everything, you did not tell the truth, but we can give you an opportunity: why has the Second Vice President of the Government announced that the President of the National Securities Market Commission will be Mr. Conthe? We have presented a Proposition not of Law here, in accordance with your electoral program, for him to be appointed by the Chamber. Do you accept that the President of the National Securities Market Commission be appointed in that way or do you not accept it?

Mr. President, those are the things you have to respond to and not talk to me about propaganda, in which, possibly, not you, but your advisors, is the only thing they have given a certain lesson, unfortunately very sad, to the entire citizenry. But a President of the Government should not remain in words or in propaganda. You are not fulfilling your electoral program, you are doing things that do not appear in your electoral program and, for purely partisan reasons, you are committing...

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I remind you that all the Groups, all except yours, have supported this reform; that a qualified majority for the election of Supreme Court judges and Presidents of the Superior Courts of Justice of the Autonomous Communities is to reinforce legitimacy and independence. With three-fifths, the judges of the Constitutional Court, the Court of Auditors, the Nuclear Safety Council are elected, and two-thirds for the Boards of Spanish Radio and Television.

Mr. Rajoy, I sincerely look forward to you being able to join and welcome the collective task of revitalizing democracy, and for that, I must sincerely tell you: I hope you have a very good weekend.