Speech by the President of the Government at the ABC Forum (Includes subsequent discussion)

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

29 September 2004 · ABC Forum

Context
Zapatero addressed the ABC Forum in Madrid on September 29, 2004, outlining his government's policy agenda five months after taking office.
Main themes
Government policy overview, economic and budgetary policy, productivity and competitiveness, social policies, democratic revitalization, civil rights expansion, institutional reforms, European integration, territorial pluralism, political mandate and electoral change, participatory democracy, Spain's modernization
Duration
~61 min
96th percentile
Words
7,269
96th percentile
Sentences
276
94th percentile
Readability
41
38th percentile
Grade
14.0
67th percentile
Syntax
3.19
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 44%43%
  • Geopolitical 22%21%
  • Economic 18%18%
  • Social 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

276 sentences in 130 paragraphs

I want to begin by expressing my gratitude to Grupo Vocento, to the newspaper ABC, and to Deloitte for the invitation they have extended to me to participate in this Forum, where I have had the opportunity to speak in previous years as the leader of the opposition.

In the presentation I will develop for you next, I hope you will see that my institutional position has changed and my responsibilities have varied significantly, but I still maintain the objectives and the line of proposals for which I sought, at that time, in this act as in any other, the support and trust of Spanish society.

Last week marked five months since the formation of the Government I lead. This is a relatively short period of time, barely exceeding one-tenth of the Legislature; a time still brief for presenting assessments of a management, but long enough for the orientation of a policy and the firmness of its course to be perfectly visible and distinguishable, and for some significant specifics of this direction to be clearly perceived.

In this intervention, I intend to share with you, albeit succinctly, some of the most relevant axes of the Government's action; particularly those related to economic and budgetary policy, its commitment to social policies, advances in the democratic revitalization of our country, the expansion of civil rights, the process of institutional reforms, and our conception of politics and the way to exercise it in an advanced, plural, deliberative, and participatory democracy, as this act is a good example.

Allow me, before proceeding to develop these axes, to convey some more general considerations about the meaning of the political action we are undertaking.

On March 14, the Spanish people decided to give way to a new majority. In doing so, they not only voted for a change in government but also issued an explicit mandate for an alternative policy to be implemented in the new stage; the proposal contained in our electoral program, which we had been offering and defending from the opposition.

In a mature country, and ours is one, new stages are not characterized by proclaiming a tabula rasa, by reversing everything that has been done in previous periods. They do not fall into the temptation of trying to change everything when many things are functioning correctly. But fulfilling the will and democratic mandate consists of making real in the new stage what citizens have deemed preferable, possible, and desirable.

Pre-election opinion studies showed that a broad majority of Spaniards wanted change, wanted another policy, another way of carrying it out, other priorities. Subsequent studies, including the most recent ones, show considerable social support for the decisions the Government has been making in the new direction.

The objective of this new political stage is not, however, just a goal of the Government, nor of its party or parliamentary group, nor is it intended to respond only to the voters who supported it. It is a goal for all of Spanish society, and we want it to be shared by all.

That objective is none other than to place Spain at a higher level than it currently occupies: higher in the modernization of its productive system, fairer and more supportive in social policies, more firmly established in European politics, more respectful and committed to international legality, more plural and integrated in the territorial sphere, and more advanced in institutional and democratic structures and practices.

I now turn to the sections I mentioned at the beginning of my intervention.

The month of September each year is characterized not only by the resumption of the political course with the formulation of new projects but, above all, by the submission to Parliament of the General State Budget Project for the following year. As is often said, this is the Government's policy expressed in figures.

The Budgets we have prepared are modern Budgets that lay the foundations and bet on a new economic model based on productivity, budgetary stability, and transparency, and they are also Budgets with a visible social content. In short, they are serious and social Budgets.

This Budget guides us towards a productive economic model that seeks to enhance the competitiveness of our economy; a terrain of balanced, lasting growth focused on improving productivity; that introduces greater competition in goods and services markets; that increases the independence and quality of regulatory bodies, and that reorients public spending in a way compatible with stability. It is perfectly possible to generate employment and increase productivity, to grow in both senses, and that is the objective of our economic policy.

The Government is, indeed, determined to promote productivity. If we grow along this path, the competitiveness of our companies will improve, there will be a simultaneous increase in wages and employment, consumer goods will become cheaper, and inflation will decrease. Increasing productivity is essential, in the long term, to strengthen the pension system and to deepen the Welfare State.

As you are well aware, our economy has grown satisfactorily over a sustained cycle, but it has shown a weakness that has progressively worsened. In the last eight years, productivity grew only by 0.7 percent annually compared to an average of 1.7 percent in the previous fifteen years. If we had maintained the pace of the previous two decades, we would have reached a per capita income level higher than 95 percent of the community average, ten points above the current level.

Having successfully overcome the stage of entry into the euro, which has been so beneficial for our economy, and having achieved reasonable macroeconomic stability, Spain now needs to face the new challenge of productivity. To this end, in the Budgets we have presented, Research, Development, and Innovation, education, and infrastructure will grow preferentially. Research, Development, and Innovation will grow by over 25 percent; infrastructure by 9 percent, and education by 7.9 percent.

The second axis of the economic model whose foundations we are laying consists of dynamizing and liberalizing the economy. The Government will launch a Business Promotion Plan in 2005 to strengthen the current business fabric, to create new companies, and to make all of them more competitive. The Government can and must set a goal, provide the means, and establish incentives for it, but it needs the collaboration of all to achieve it.

We reaffirm, therefore, our belief and commitment to budgetary stability throughout the cycle, which is also a key axis of our economic policy. Stability ensures better foundations for social policy and is more equitable and just for future generations. The General State Budgets for 2005 will be approved with a surplus for all Public Administrations of 0.1 percent of Gross Domestic Product.

Our commitment to transparency consists of presenting public accounts with precision, rigor, and speed, with the most complete and understandable information, not only about the expenses that are committed but also about the risks that are assumed for the future. A symbol of that transparency is the renunciation of the so-called Accompanying Law, as is the inclusion in the Budget, for the first time, of all adjustments of National Accounting.

The Budgets for 2005 are social Budgets. Social spending accounts for just over half of them: 50.1 percent. The new Budgets will particularly address fundamental aspects for the well-being of citizens such as employment, security, justice, housing, education, health, and pensions.

Total spending on pensions will increase by 7.1 percent, and within that, minimum pensions will have preferential growth, for which the State will increase its contribution by 33.1 percent. This will benefit nearly two and a half million pensioners. All this with scrupulous respect for the strengthening of the Social Security Reserve Fund.

Active employment policies will grow by 7 percent; continuous training by 26.6 percent, and scholarships and study aids by 10.5 percent. This will allow for the granting of more than 380,000 scholarships, with an increase of more than 9,000 for secondary education and more than 16,000 for university education.

Aid for access to housing will increase by 32.5 percent, benefiting especially young people and those with the lowest incomes.

In short, as I pointed out, these are the first Budgets of the new stage, which already mark the lines of the new orientation of economic policy; a policy that we want to be less short-term oriented, aimed at building more secure foundations for the future, the foundations of greater productivity, modernization of the system, better management of public resources, greater social integration, and a clear and determined commitment to welfare policies.

The modernization of Spanish society and the leap in level we want to promote do not, of course, end in the economic or budgetary sphere. We want a society in which the space for civil rights and freedoms is expanded and in which democratic participation is intensified.

For this reason, we have contributed to revitalizing debates in Parliament, we have facilitated the incorporation of politically relevant decision-making into the Chambers, such as the sending of troops abroad, or we have created a committee for the reform of public media, which will be a priority objective from the beginning of next year, 2005.

For this reason, my Government has already approved a series of regulations aimed at protecting and expanding freedom, such as the comprehensive fight against gender violence or the new divorce regulation, and will immediately approve, tomorrow Friday, in the Council of Ministers, the reform of the Civil Code to allow marriage between same-sex individuals.

These are decisions for freedom, so that free people can decide freely. They do not seek to confront any moral position. They belong to the civil sphere that determines the legitimate will of the majority of citizens.

When we promote the Law against Gender Violence, when we expedite divorce proceedings, when we recognize same-sex marriage, we are not acting against anyone; we are working to protect women who suffer violence, we are facilitating life for the separated, and we are ending an unjustifiable discrimination that millions of homosexuals have suffered for centuries. The Government does not act against anyone; it works to recognize and extend citizens' rights without imposing moral choices.

Regarding international policy, my Government is committed to supporting multilateralism, defending peace and security with full respect for legality, and, of course, to development cooperation as a means of fighting and overcoming hunger and poverty that plague our planet.

From this perspective, and from the first day we gained confidence in Parliament, we have been working to renew the firmly Europeanist commitment of Spanish society and we have been working for a better functioning of the mechanisms of the United Nations, as the great institution, the only institution, that can guarantee an international order of law, supporting its process of institutional reforms and defending, as it must be, the Resolutions emanating from this High Institution.

The fight against international terrorism is, of course, a priority concern, and we remain and will remain firm against this scourge. We must confront it firmly, but also rationally, avoiding making mistakes that feed it rather than weaken it. On the other hand, if we truly want to win peace, a stable and lasting peace, a reduction of violent conflicts in the world, we must promote dialogue between peoples, between cultures, and between the different ways of structuring societies.

In this sense, I proposed at the United Nations to deepen the political, cultural, and educational relationship between the West and the Muslim world, because we must avoid at all costs that religious, cultural, and belief differences lead us to hatred and misunderstanding, and raise a new dividing wall in the world.

The world will not be more stable and secure if we do not come together, decisively, against inequality and misery. This deep conviction has led me to promote, along with other leaders, the Summit against Hunger and Poverty. As the Declaration states, which has recently been signed by 113 countries at the United Nations, "the greatest scandal is not that famine exists, but that it persists when the means to eliminate it are available."

Spain's active participation in European construction, as I emphasized earlier, is a fundamental objective of the Government. We find ourselves at an exciting moment in which the European Union has completed its enlargement to twenty-five members and a draft Constitutional Treaty has been approved.

This Constitution represents a qualitative step for the European Union, encapsulates the basic aspirations of citizens, and will allow for a fairer and more supportive Union. The Government wants to make a serious effort to ensure its ratification, explaining its significance and impact on the lives of citizens.

We also have ahead of us the negotiation of the new Financial Perspectives for the period 2007-2013 within the Union. We will approach it rigorously, with a constructive spirit and convinced of our reasons. We believe that this debate should consider gradual transitional formulas to avoid traumatic consequences in the regions that have been receiving community funds.

The Government also intends for Spain to play a prominent role in the development of the so-called Area of Freedom, Security, and Justice. We advocate for the strengthening of common foreign and security policy in all its dimensions, from the new neighborhood policy of the European Union, the relaunching of the Barcelona Process as a dialogue with the Mediterranean area, the special importance for us of EU-Latin America relations, and the extension of European development cooperation policy.

But the European Union must not only be capable of creating structures for dialogue and cooperation in peaceful regions, but it must also demonstrate its capacity for mediation and dialogue in international crises such as the Middle East peace process and the situation in Africa.

Politics is not only about decisions but also about the way they are made. In this sense, the novelty of this stage that we are now opening is even more significant. On the day the Spanish Parliament granted me its confidence, I announced as a priority objective the renewal of public life. I foresaw a new time for politics; a time of citizenship, respect for the opponent, dialogue, tolerance, and transparency.

I honestly believe that in these five months of Government, it has been demonstrated that it was not just empty words. The political climate has relaxed, institutional dialogue has been reestablished, and democracy is being revitalized.

You know that I hold the conviction that in democracy, forms are essential, just as much as content. Moreover, forms and content usually complement each other or, even more, are in a relationship of reciprocity. This was the case under the PP Government, and it is happening now.

Our way of governing is based on three pillars: citizen protagonism, transparency, and dialogue. We govern by facing the citizens and not turning our backs on them; we govern attentive to their opinions, values, needs, and problems.

The democratic spirit is also based on transparency. Transparency requires that Governments do not use public media to distort reality and that they permanently respect all private media, which provide truthful information about the state of public accounts and contribute to revitalizing controls in Parliament, which is "the house of the opposition."

The democratic spirit does not ignore the conflicts of all kinds that exist in society; rather, it contributes to resolving them or, at the very least, to mitigating them and, of course, does not exacerbate them or allow for taking advantage of their intensification.

The willingness for political dialogue would be the language in which the spirit is expressed; but dialogue, in addition to presupposing the awareness that reason, or part of it, may reside in the other, obliges each one to explain and justify their points of view. If we now think about the important role that institutional dialogue is called to play in this legislature, I must recall that we decided to promote it and that we clearly delineated the framework in which we believe it should develop.

Thus, we have defined the specific aspects to discuss constitutional reforms and respect for the Constitution itself as a firm condition for supporting statutory reforms. I have reiterated that both must garner a very broad consensus in order to prosper, and I have met with the Presidents of all Autonomous Communities and the leaders of all political parties represented in Parliament — in some cases, already on two occasions, as I have done with Mr. Rajoy, the leader of the Popular Party — to explain my availability and to learn about theirs.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Success in politics, as you know, consists of earning the trust of citizens. The Government I lead will try to earn that trust in two ways: by striving to be faithful to the democratic style and the values we profess, but also by being rigorous and effective in managing public affairs. I have always believed that these are not alternative goals, that effectiveness in management must be imbued with political meaning, with principles, both from an instrumental and a teleological perspective. That is to say, it must be carried out under the parameters of the democratic spirit and only makes sense if its purpose is connected to the social well-being of citizens. The task is arduous, but the enthusiasm and will to tackle it, believe me, are almost uncontainable.

Thank you very much.

DIALOGUE WITH THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT AFTER HIS INTERVENTION AT THE ABC FORUM

Q.- We are before an audience fundamentally made up of personalities from the business and financial and economic system of Spain, and there are several attendees who are relatively concerned about the diagnosis that the International Monetary Fund has just issued regarding Spanish growth, which seems a little less optimistic than what your Government says. Can you reassure them?

President.- Honestly, I have to say that I do not see the concern in the Spanish business community. The first thing I have seen since the moment I became President of the Government is, I believe I can say without exception — and I want to emphasize it here today, taking advantage of this question — a permanent attitude of cooperation and collaboration with the Government of Spain and an absolute willingness from day one. I want to highlight this because I think it is fair to recognize that we have, I believe, a business community with a clear commitment to the country, to its economy, and to its future beyond political vicissitudes.

Secondly, I believe that the IMF report in its forecast places growth for next year at 2.9 percent. Our budgetary estimate is at 3 percent, and I think the difference is almost negligible. We are going to work to achieve 3 percent, and hopefully we will exceed that growth. But the feeling, the data we have, the impression, is that the horizon for economic growth is a positive one for Spain.

We are working to improve productivity and to enhance the competitiveness of our economy. I believe we must constantly strive to reduce inflation — today there has been a good inflation figure — and I hope that the growth and productivity increase objectives set by the budget can be met.

Certainly, the information and direct evidence is that Spanish companies are looking to invest. There is investment in capital goods, and this is very important. I believe that employment will continue to evolve positively, and therefore, I would convey a message of confidence and optimism, knowing that the Government will fulfill its duties. Regarding budgetary stability, I believe no one will doubt that, having Pedro Solbes as Economic Vice President, who has a proven commitment to this principle, and it is a firm commitment. And we will certainly focus our efforts on what represents economic stimulus, that change in orientation, to gain in productivity and, therefore, in competitiveness for our companies.

Q.- We were talking for a moment during lunch about the American elections, and there is a diner who suggests whether you would bet on the outcome of those elections.

President.- It is a delicate issue. I do not want to make a prediction so as not to confuse it with a wish. From the first day I became President of the Government, I expressed that I would not intervene in electoral processes of other countries. Here we have lived different situations, and there have been center-right leaders or Presidents who have supported the Popular Party. I, of course, will not support any political party in any country nor will I express my preference for anyone. I want enormous respect for what the American people vote, an enormous respect, just as I undoubtedly want and demand for my country regarding what the Spanish people have voted.

Q.- But you have not said who you think will win. Not who you want, but who you believe will win.

President.- I think it will be very close. But, I insist, I do not want a prediction to be confused with a wish, because automatically, if I gave my prediction, the conclusion would surely be that it is my wish. So, I prefer to be very prudent.

Q.- Forgive me for insisting, but in any case, given the disagreement that has existed in recent years between the Socialist Party and the American Government, how do you think a possible victory for Bush could affect Spain-United States relations?

President.- As much as in recent years... It will be in recent months, right? Since the Socialist Party Government, fulfilling an electoral commitment, a will of the citizenry, decided to withdraw from the Iraq war. The American Government, evidently, supports this military intervention and was not satisfied with our exit. But this is what happens between allies who are true allies: they say things as they think and make decisions autonomously.

I cannot understand any other way the respect that American society, and of course the Government of the United States, has for the decisions of the Spanish Government. Being a country that is the cradle of democracy and freedoms, I believe it is the country that is best positioned to understand what a decision of a democratic Government is, committed electorally.

Is there a disagreement on this point, which is not minor? Certainly. Therefore, from there arises the disagreement on how to tackle the fight against terrorism. Today it is a fight against terrorism; when the military intervention was promoted, it was the serious risk of weapons of mass destruction that it was said would give Iraq, the regime of Saddam Hussein, a military potential like that of the Nazi regime. I simply say: after what has happened and after what we are experiencing, after so many months of military intervention in Iraq, of what is happening in Iraq and what we are seeing in other parts of the world as a consequence of it, the question is: who should reflect on successes or failures?

That is the question, and I believe that with each passing day, I am absolutely convinced, Spanish society, but also a good part of the International Community, the vast majority of the International Community, and also many Governments that at the time supported the military intervention, are engaged in a deeply self-critical reflection.

Certainly, the objective of the Government of Spain is not for anyone to say: "I was wrong." No, the objective of so many people who thought that was a mistake is simply to channel an international order with other principles. I have always had the intuition that, by violating international legality, the result of that action would be a negative one, because maintaining principles is not only, from an ethical point of view, exigible; it is that maintaining principles is effective. Upholding the rule of law every minute is not only ethically giving superiority to the countries that do so; it is also effective for the functioning of society.

Therefore, if we have conquered the aspiration that free, advanced nations live in a rule of law, we must achieve the aspiration that the world order is an order of law, and I believe that when we achieve that — for that the United Nations was born — we will undoubtedly see more time of peace and more time of balance in the world and in many regions. And what happened in Iraq was a setback.

I believe the lesson should be to change the course of some of the doctrines that here, in Spain, by the way, were explained with considerable intensity and that have represented a notable error. I aspire that some who wanted to take us out of the corner of history can simply emerge from their error. That would be enough.

Q.- I was going to ask you, Mr. President, if you still maintain in this sense the advisability of a general withdrawal from Iraq, despite the UN Resolution.

President.- I still maintain that it was a correct decision by the Spanish Government. I have expressed myself on many occasions with respect to the countries that are there, in coherence with the respect I want for the decision made by the Government of Spain, and I do have the conviction that, sooner or later — and my impression is that sooner — the United Nations will have to debate again about the situation in Iraq and take some initiative.

I believe it is premature to make a unilateral formulation, and I think there should be a sincere dialogue and debate among the entire International Community, certainly very decisively the European Union and the United States; but from here I dare to suggest that something will have to be done, and not too long from now, to reorient the situation in Iraq. I hope this is done quickly and I hope it is done in the United Nations Security Council. If an attempt is made to do something outside the United Nations Security Council, a mistake will be made again.

Q.- If it comes to that, would you maintain Tunisia's suggestion that all countries withdraw from Iraq?

President.- I have already expressed on many occasions that my conviction, when I made the decision, is that withdrawing the troops was not only an electoral commitment, but something positive. I will not ask anyone to do what they do not want to do out of respect, but I do say, from here and very clearly --as I expressed in the previous question-- that something will have to be done, and I fear that sooner rather than later.

Q.- A fellow journalist wants to know if you approve of governments negotiating and paying to achieve the freedom of hostages in Iraq.

President.- I have no evidence that would lead me to affirm that such negotiations and payments are taking place. Therefore, I cannot make a statement. This simply leads me to a reflection. Today I saw, when I was coming here, that there were another ten hostages, that there have been dozens and dozens of deaths, and it leads me to the previous reflection: the orientation on Iraq must change, because it is not possible that for much longer we continue to see horror and widespread violence, and, of course, the negative effects this provokes in many countries where there is deep concern that we are facing a scenario, as I mentioned before, of confrontation of cultures, of civilizations. The dynamics must change soon.

Regarding what governments do, I believe that a government must do everything in its power to save human lives, while maintaining principles; but I believe that prudence compels me not to comment on facts that are not yet confirmed.

Q.- One of our diners wants to know, and cites Manuel Azaña, if Spain has ceased to be Catholic.

President.- Spain is a democracy that has its sovereignty in Parliament, which emanates from the will of the citizens and makes laws that, logically, regulate social life. I have a deep respect for the feelings and religious convictions of all citizens, and, of course, above all, for the religious convictions of Catholics, because it is objective and notable that there are many Catholics in our country. I have a deep respect and, because I have that respect, I precisely have the deep conviction that even in the best spirit of what the doctrine of the Catholic Church is, there is a clear principle of separation between the public, civil space, determined by citizenship and its legislators, and the space of intimate, personal, and religious convictions.

This is good for the state, it is good for society, and it is also good for religious confessions. The worst periods in history have been when there has been confusion between what is a religious institution and what is the civil and political institution of the state.

Q.- Are you and your government sure that there is enough social consensus in Spain to open the door to same-sex marriages and adoption by these same couples?

President.- I believe that there is a very broad majority today that is in favor of eradicating a discrimination that homosexual people experience. We all know them; they are friends, coworkers, or relatives. They are people to whom we impose obligations, those of all citizens, and we deny them rights. Well, what the government wants to do with the law that it will approve tomorrow, Friday, is for these citizens to stop being second-class and have full rights, and that full right includes, from each one's sexual option, the ability to form a family and to develop the activities and commitments that occur in a family.

Regarding adoption, I will simply say two things: first, a marriage or a single person can adopt, and no one asks that single person what their sexual orientation is to adopt. There are studies that show that the educational development, the formative development, of children in a couple or in a family of heterosexuals or homosexuals is a similar development; among them, a study, by the way, commissioned by Mr. Alberto Ruíz Gallardón, who is obviously not from the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party.

What is important is that an adopted child lives in a good family that provides the conditions for their development. That is what is important and does not determine the sexual orientation of the people who provide an education.

But notice how powerful the law that the government is going to approve is that even the Popular Party has started to change. Mr. Zaplana presented a civil unions law yesterday, not to call it "marriage," already recognizing practically all the rights for what the traditional institution of the union between a man and a woman means, equating it in this case to homosexual union. With the government having announced the law, the PP has already changed after having rejected a similar law thirty-one times that they announced yesterday.

And I tell you from here: they will accept, sooner or later, the content of the law that the government will send to Parliament. It will be a matter of one year, two years, or three years. It has always happened in the Spanish right: it happened with divorce, it happened with voluntary interruption of pregnancy, it happened with the State of Autonomies. It has happened with all the advances of social modernization, of recognition of rights and freedoms, that the right in our country has always arrived late. In the end, it arrives, but it takes a lot of time for progress and for what is a natural and normal advance in society as a whole.

Q.- However, President, most of the countries from which children for adoption in Spain come do not accept same-sex marriage or adoption by homosexuals. How will that difficulty be resolved?

President.- It is a topic we are studying. Logically, as some legislation establishes, recognition is only established for the adoption of children from the home country. We are studying it, and undoubtedly, there will have to be some reference in the law to that situation. But it is true that it is a problem.

Q.- Another of our discussants asks if the recent episodes of contradictions between ministers of your government or ministries are due to a lack of coordination among them or a lack of clarity in the projects.

President.- If there is no example of contradiction, it is difficult to take a stance.

Q.- I do not know which one he is referring to, but I could show you some: speed limits, regional license plates, textbooks, commercial hours, abortion deadlines, plus the issue of immigrants...

President.- I believe that in none of those cases is there a contradiction; what there is is an announcement that may have a specific timeline depending on the government's legislative policy. It is true that sometimes, when a minister says that something is going to be done, one has the temptation or the feeling that it is already in the Official State Bulletin, because today public and private media have so much power that it is almost like what appears in the Official State Bulletin. Let’s say there is a calendar of objectives, both in legislative policy and in social policy, that the government will be fulfilling.

I must say that there is a new government; that there is a government that has been in office for six months; that there is, as is logical and normal, a permanent informative interest in the development of what each ministry's proposals are, and that sometimes produces some information that needs to be rectified.

I said on election night, and some will remember, that this government has no problem rectifying. We have rectified some things in these six months, and I believe that is the normal exercise of a government that is willing not to believe that it is always in possession of the truth or that it gets it right every minute in every announcement. That time has passed; we lived a few years with a government with that temptation, and I believe that citizens, in the end, were not very much in agreement with that attitude.

I say it and I reiterate it today: when the government has to rectify any information or the content of something, it will do so, and, of course, it will have no problem in recognizing it.

Q.- Why is a qualified majority necessary to elect judges, while a simple majority suffices in the 11-M Commission?

President.- Because it has absolutely nothing to do with each other. The provision of bodies of the importance of the Magistrates of the Supreme Court or the Presidents of the Superior Courts of Justice I believe requires that they be elected by an aggravated and qualified majority. This happens with the Magistrates of the Constitutional Court, it happens with the members of the Nuclear Safety Council, the Court of Auditors, and even the Council of Spanish Radio and Television, whose competencies and functions we are all aware are not precisely of great strength in their compliance; and in this last case, even two-thirds.

Therefore, what is an anomaly, in my opinion, and an evident gap of these twenty-five years is that the responsibility of Magistrates of the Supreme Court and Presidents of the Superior Courts of Justice is not elected in the scope of the Council of the Judiciary by an aggravated majority of three-fifths. That always strengthens the legitimacy of the election, without a doubt, and strengthens independence, and prevents any majority, of whatever sign, from trying to impose.

This is not a norm for now; it is for tomorrow, and therefore, it is a norm to ensure that responsibilities as important as being a Magistrate of the Supreme Court enjoy broad consensus within what is the normal plurality that exists and will exist in the Council of the Judiciary.

What is surprising is that the goodness of a norm that seeks consensus is questioned, a norm that seeks agreement to elect Magistrates of the Supreme Court, a norm that makes the Magistrates of the Supreme Court stronger, and normally, when a person is elected by three-fifths, that leads to a situation where more qualified people are elected.

It is a rule, that of the aggravated majority, that we have for our institutional functioning in high responsibilities, and I believe it is very positive that we also have it in the Supreme Court.

Q.- And why not in the 11-M Commission? I understand that the second part of the question was why that consensus rule does not apply.

President.- Because aggravated majorities, in our democracy and in all, are for two basic issues: the election of people --there the aggravated majority works; I have just reiterated a series of cases: people for high responsibilities-- and, two, significant reforms that affect the political status, whether it be the Constitution or the Statutes of Autonomy.

But laws normally have, at most, the threshold of an absolute majority; normally a simple majority if they are not organic. There are no aggravated majorities in what is a usual political decision, neither an absolute majority nor three-fifths. And in investigative commissions, of course, much less.

Q.- Another question in the same vein. Do you think someone is missing from that Commission?

President.- The Popular Party was the one who requested the Investigation Commission, and once requested by the main opposition party, the government said automatically: yes, go ahead.

There have been many appearances in the Commission, and, of course, I believe that the political groups intend to propose some more appearance.

In this regard, I believe we must respect three things. The first is that there is a judicial procedure underway in the National Court. I believe it will be a judicial procedure that will determine the responsible parties and the circumstances, because I believe we must trust, and I certainly have full confidence, in the Justice of our country.

Second, there must be political conclusions in Parliament. The government's desire is that those political conclusions would be future-oriented and in agreement. As a government, I have to think about what may concern citizens the most. And what concerns citizens about the parliamentary work of the 11-M Commission? That it serves to try to prevent another possible international terrorist action, which makes us stronger. I believe that is the most important thing in the political conclusions.

And third, my opinion, and I believe it is also the opinion of a large part of the citizenry, is that the facts and the tragedy of March 11 are very clear in light of everything that has been known and learned so far. That is my opinion. It does not mean that the Commission should stop working for as long as it wants.

This is the attitude of a government that can rely on a relatively comfortable majority to make decisions in this area in Parliament. I want the opposition to be fully satisfied with the work of the Commission.

Q.- When you say that the facts are very clear, should it be understood that you have no doubts?

President.- I have no doubts, none.

Q.- Is the government going to privatize a chain of Televisión Española? All or in part?

President.- There is a pending report from the Committee of Wise Men or Experts that the Government has constituted, which will be ready by the end of the year, and we will begin to debate it in January, which will ultimately translate into a Bill for the reform of public media. I must not prejudge what the report says, because the people on that Committee are working freely. Furthermore, I am committed to respecting and conveying the report and its contents to Parliament through the appropriate legislative reforms.

But the objective we have set for the Committee of Experts is twofold: the first objective is plurality and independence of the media, and it is foreseeable that we will be led to a new model for the election of the Director General of Televisión Española; I believe it is more than foreseeable that this model will require an aggravated majority in Parliament for such an important position, which is a model I have defended and that would prevent a temporary majority from imposing that name. And second, the report must address the public media model we want in our country, both from the perspective of funding and from the perspective of the size of that public model.

I simply want to reflect: the Government believes that we need to reorient the situation due to the debt that Radiotelevisión Española represents for Spanish society as a whole. It is a very high debt, which would allow us to carry out important social policies, and I believe that society as a whole must consider this.

That said, I am not advocating for one model today or another, nor for one response or another; but it is a pending debate, and the Government is determined to face it, of course, just as I make a point of separation: the Government considers that there is space, a greater space, to promote plurality in the television media, in the private media, of our country; that there is space for plurality, that there is space for greater competition.

Q.- Another channel or others?

President.- I do not want to prejudge. But that is the reflection that, of course, the Government is carrying forward.

Q.- Luis del Olmo wants to know if the Government has plans regarding digital radio and when. This is the last question I ask about communication.

President.- Yes, the Government is convinced that the entire process of digitalization is a process that needs to be intensified, that needs to be accelerated, and that it is, without a doubt, the future in the realm of the determining elements of communication, both in the television field and in the radio field.

Q.- The last question. Would you maintain the promise you made to Pasqual Maragall in the Catalan elections to respect the type of Statute that comes out of the Catalan Parliament within the limits they set?

President.- No, within the limits of the Constitution, of course, and I have no doubt that the Statute that Pasqual Maragall and the Socialist Party of Catalonia sign will be a reformed Statute within and within the limits of the Constitution. And, secondly, that Statute must have the greatest possible consensus: the greatest consensus there, because it also requires an aggravated majority for its reform and, therefore, we must count on Convergència i Unió, and hopefully also with the Popular Party, and the greatest possible consensus in the Parliament of the nation. Of course, I believe it would be very important, from my perspective, that the Popular Party is also part of that consensus. But the Statute that the Parliament of Catalonia will approve as a reform of the Statute will respect the Constitution.

I do want to emphasize that reforming a Statute of Autonomy is to live within what the Constitution represents and that reforming a Statute of Autonomy is to live within the Statute. This is enormously important for perhaps some inflexible positions to reflect.

But, well, I do not want to make another prediction; I already did that before with the extension of civil rights. I am convinced that it will be a matter of time, but the Popular Party will also be involved in the reforms that affect the improvement of the functioning of the State.

Q.- When you say "what the Constitution represents," do you mean what the Constitution says?

President.- Yes, of course.

Q.- Mr. President, thank you very much for your appearance among us, and we hope to see you here relatively soon.

President.- Thank you very much.