Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

28 June 2005 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions from Puigcercós and Durán i Lleida during a June 2005 Spanish parliamentary control session on tourism policy.
Main themes
Tourism sector support, hotel industry challenges, tourist spending trends, fiscal incentives for tourism, inter-ministerial coordination, seasonal tourism, tourist infrastructure funding, competition from new markets, European VAT harmonization, innovation in tourism
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,403
66th percentile
Sentences
82
53rd percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
14.3
70th percentile
Syntax
3.26
78th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
43rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 31%26%
  • Economic 27%22%
  • Ceremonial 19%16%
  • Geopolitical 16%13%
  • Social 6%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 18%

82 sentences in 38 paragraphs

Mr. Puigcercós.- Mr. President of the Government, does the Government plan to prepare a comprehensive support plan for the tourism and hotel sector?

President.- Mr. Puigcercós, as the entire Chamber shares, the tourism sector is of great importance to our economy, it generates a significant volume of employment, and it is the Government's obligation to give it special importance.

As you know, the flow of tourists to our country continues to increase. In the first five months, a historical record of tourist arrivals has been set in our country. Therefore, the Government has been adopting measures related to the tourism sector; measures to promote greater competition in the offer, taking into account the situation of certain countries, and this has been reflected in the Budget Law for 2005, with an initiative to modernize mature tourist destinations; in the plan for the objectives of external promotion of tourism, which will be developed by Turespaña, as well as in the plans for the dynamization of tourist products that emphasize quality and a plural offer of destinations with their own values and identity.

Mr. Puigcercós.- For many years, we could make good this song that said "go, go, here there is no beach," referring to Madrid. And it was true because even the previous Government did not have a Ministry of Tourism, and there is also a very important tourism sector in Madrid; hotel, obviously.

A change must be made. The fact of having a Ministry and a Secretary of State is already a step, but we cannot stop here. There are three elements, three important challenges, not to say three risks: first, the crisis of the source markets, for example, the Federal Republic of Germany; second, new competitors, for example, Turkey, which grows steadily by 25 percent in tourist attraction every year; and stagnation.

The President of the Government referred to the record of new tourists, but look at the figures: year 2001, average spending of a tourist, 730 euros; year 2004, average spending, 695 euros. It has decreased by 35 euros. It may seem little, but if we multiply it by the number of tourists, it is a significant figure.

There are also other elements that can threaten the sector, for example, the debate on the new Intellectual Property Law -- it cannot be that each hotel room has to pay a tax for a television or for broadcasting rights--; fire safety regulations; changes in legislation, such as the bill currently being debated on tobacco or possibly alcohol; implementation of European Union Directives. Just think if we had the harmonization of European VAT. It would be devastating for the sector.

There are, therefore, challenges, and we make three proposals: improve the depreciation coefficients of the hotel and tourism sector, as is the case in the industry; provide fiscal incentives and contributions to avoid seasonality -- it cannot be that hotel facilities are open only three months a year; they need to work more -- and, thirdly, provide more advantages for supporting innovation and research to improve the efficiency of tourist and hotel facilities.

To conclude. All this and more can improve, but we make a suggestion: create from the Ministry of Industry and Tourism an inter-ministerial coordination element. There are aspects that refer to Finance, to Economy, to other Ministries, which are vital for...

President.- Mr. Puigcercós, to remind you that tourism income in 2004 increased by 3 percent. I have just referred to the figures for the first five months, which have set a historical record, with eighteen and a half million tourists, and which also represents, objectively, for the months they represent, a diversification of tourist demand in our country.

In addition to the Ministry, as you have recalled, the last Council of Ministers was dedicated especially to tourism, and we launched a series of measures, practically collected in what is known as the Fund for the Improvement of Tourist Infrastructures, which will have 107 million euros, developing the content of the Budget Law of 2005.

This initiative includes various actions, with a prominent presence of the Official Credit Institute, Local Administrations, the private sector, and dialogue with Autonomous Communities; one hundred million in soft loans directed to the Town Halls, two million for interest rates to the private sector, five for complementary study activities, and, of course, we will welcome all measures and initiatives that are of interest to the sector, guaranteeing, as it is already, coordination among the various Ministries, because it is a priority objective of this Government that tourism continues to be a great source of wealth for Spain.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. JOSEP ANTONI DURÁN I LLEIDA, OF THE CATALAN PARLIAMENTARY GROUP OF CONVERGÈNCIA I UNIÓ

Mr. Durán.- Precisely, one of the sectors, at least its representatives, that most advocate for an electrical interconnection of Spain with France, as it is necessary for the supply to the hotel and tourism facilities in Girona, is the tourism sector of Girona.

In that sense, you know perfectly well that there has been a debate in recent months in which different positions confront: different from the Government of Catalonia, different within the Government of Catalonia, and different between the Government of Catalonia and the Government of Madrid.

Convergència i Unió, in accordance with what was established at the Spring Council in 2002, in Barcelona precisely, is in favor of the connection with the European Union and, in particular, we are aware of the deficit regarding what can be and what is currently available. Convergència i Unió is in favor because we need electrical energy to supply a new High-Speed Train, for the tourist facilities and for what are new logistical installations, and we are in favor of doing it with the maximum possible dialogue, with the utmost respect for the environment and, if necessary, undoubtedly, burying some parts of that electrical network.

I would like to know what the position of the Government you preside over is, Mr. President.

President.- Mr. Durán, it is evident that the obligation of the Government is to guarantee energy supply in general and, in particular, electrical supply under conditions of quality, safety, and meeting demand.

Energetically, it is evident that we are also in Europe, and our peninsular geography allows for the optimization of resources and supplies, which means interconnection with Portugal, with France, and also with Morocco.

In this sense, a commitment was made at the Barcelona Summit in 2002 to achieve a minimum interconnection capacity with France of around 4,000 megawatts. We are very far from that figure, having, moreover, very important needs in the area of Girona and a very specific demand for electrical energy to supply the AVE. We therefore think it is necessary to advance in that commitment, and we have technical reports and very detailed projects for an interconnection with France, with which we would achieve an energy supply of 2,600 megawatts, still far from the minimum committed and necessary.

The planned option has been designed while keeping the Generalitat and the French Government continuously informed, and taking into account the route of least environmental impact, which is awaiting a response from the Ministry of the Environment.

Mr. Durán.- I see that, in general terms, you agree with our approach regarding the need for that interconnection. There is a problem, evidently. We also agree with what the Minister of Industry, Mr. Montilla, has repeatedly expressed in the same direction as the President, and the problem is that the parliamentary supports you have in this Chamber do not subscribe to that same position. Moreover, there is a specific initiative for a moratorium that would place us in 2015, which would undoubtedly not allow us to meet the commitments that this Government has just renewed in the face of the needs you have just enumerated, and which I endorse from the first to the last.

Therefore, I would like to know what the planned schedule of this Government is to execute that interconnection, as it coincides with our proposals; what line you plan to use, whether through Bescanó, whether through Vic-Baixas, and, in any case, in that same context, if the Government really contemplates, as soon as possible, not just the execution but, as I told you, what parliamentary supports it will have to carry out that need that the "gironina" regions, and Catalonia in general, have for a guarantee of greater electrical supply and higher quality in the supply they currently receive.

President.- In that sector, Mr. Durán, the demands and needs are clear, and therefore the project must be addressed. The interconnection must be made with the principles I have outlined, and this leads us to an option of a double circuit, of 400 kilovolts, with a possible route Bescanó-Figueres-French border. The final decision will be made taking into account the competencies of the Generalitat, with the agreement of the French Government and with the necessary respect for the environmental recommendations that are required, without intending to impose solutions and without having solutions imposed on us either. Therefore, I reaffirm the Government's willingness to make that interconnection, necessary for Girona and necessary for the AVE, which I believe is a demand absolutely shared by the entire Chamber and especially by Catalan society.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. MARIANO RAJOY, OF THE POPULAR PARLIAMENTARY GROUP

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you have made the words "talent" and "dialogue" the axis of your speech. In reality, it was your electoral program, and yet you have made countless decisions unilaterally, without talking, which have generated many tensions in Spanish society. There are many examples: you have repealed laws without talking to anyone and without providing alternatives; emblematic issues, such as the Salamanca Archive or the Telecommunications Market Commission; right now, not minor issues, such as decisions in the media. In social matters, you have not wanted to seek consensus, and you could have at least tried.

But what worries me most about all this is the consensus on basic issues; specifically, terrorism and the idea of Spain. I would like to know if you believe that the consensus has improved after these first fifteen months of Government on these two issues.

President.- I understand that fifteen months may seem like fifteen years to Mr. Rajoy. I can assure you that this time we have been in Government has not seemed that long to me.

Mr. President, I must tell you that the Government is fulfilling its electoral program and the investiture speech. Some of the issues and decisions that the Government has made are a strict reflection of electoral commitments. Furthermore, since taking office, we have practiced political, institutional, and social dialogue, which is undoubtedly a prerequisite for achieving consensus, and I believe that, in general terms, it maintains an attitude of respect and good manners in political dialogue that, if I may say so, was also needed in this country.

Mr. Rajoy.- My subconscious has betrayed me. I see you so worn out that I thought it was fifteen years, Mr. President.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, everything related to Spain, to our country, its social issues, and the equality of Spaniards has been agreed upon since 1978. You opened a process, and I warned you, that you do not control today. You speak of nations as if it were nothing, and I do not know if that was in your electoral program; you have provoked confrontations between numerous Autonomous Communities; you have not wanted to agree with the PP on issues such as unity, sovereignty, a viable State, the equality of Spaniards, and you have generated a very worrying institutional instability.

In terms of terrorism, you have broken the pact, without anyone knowing why, that you had signed with the Popular Party. I say this, and the victims of terrorism say it, who are very concerned, and ETA, which is pleased that you have broken it. Mr. President, the operation you have carried out in the Basque Country does not seem to lead us to a better situation than the one we lived in before.

I tell you: there has been no dialogue, nor has there been any talent; it is a lie. There has been a flight forward, and there has been no concern for essential issues, for example, the competitiveness of the Spanish economy. And you have confronted, and a lot, all Spaniards. You must rectify, because I believe you have believed it too soon, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero.

President.- I respect very much how you see me. I can assure you that I see you very well as you are. I do not see that there has been any change in that sense.

I will tell you, Mr. Rajoy, that you must recognize that the Government has practiced dialogue: political dialogue with all forces, dialogue with the main opposition group, which, of course, is infinitely superior in fifteen months to what it was in the last legislature. From the first day, the Popular Group has been anticipating events regarding what could be those issues related to territorial structure, to the territorial development of Spain, which, frankly, I believe time and events are proving you wrong.

It turns out that a Statute could not be modified, and, you see, the first one that has been implemented, with the consensus of the PP and PSOE, is the Statute of Valencia. I wish and hope that all Statutes and reasonable and positive reforms for this country are made with consensus and that they have the same attitude towards the other statutory texts that we are going to see as they have had with the Valencian Community, even if it means changing one's mind in a day.

Regarding the fight against terrorism, I do not want to engage in controversy over the fight against terrorism; you know that. My intention is for there to be the greatest democratic unity. I think this way and work this way from the very first day. And I will tell you more: it is the duty of the Government. Therefore, the only thing I want to announce to you is that I will continue to try, of course with all the groups, and also with yours and with you, because it is very important for the fight against terrorism and for the good of our country.

Thank you very much.