Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

21 February 2006 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on terrorism, the Montjuïc Castle transfer, and the Catalan Statute during a Spanish Congress control session on 21 February 2006.
Main themes
Fight against terrorism, political consensus, Montjuïc Castle transfer to Barcelona, Statute of Catalonia, government accountability, opposition cooperation, historical memory, peace process
Duration
~13 min
44th percentile
Words
1,519
44th percentile
Sentences
60
40th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
12.2
47th percentile
Syntax
3.13
64th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 60%55%
  • Geopolitical 15%13%
  • Ceremonial 15%13%
  • Social 9%8%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

60 sentences in 28 paragraphs

Mr. President, this is not the time to look for where the culprits are, whether on one side of these benches or the other side of this hemicycle; it is the hour of responsibility, it is the hour to seek consensus, understanding, among the political forces to address such a sensitive and delicate issue as the fight against terrorism. Certainly, the citizens will appreciate it from the Government and the main opposition party; otherwise, they will take into account the attitude of both sides.

President.- I respect your opinion, even your assessment of what the prominence or lack thereof of a terrorist group represents. What I want to say is that, from my point of view, what we have is a recovery of the prominence, of the idea, of the expectation, of the possibility and of the will of an immense majority to see the end of violence and to achieve peace.

I said it a few days ago and I reiterate it today: for that objective, the participation of the main opposition party is very necessary. I believe I have some moral authority to say this and to ask for it, because during the time I was in opposition, I gave all my support, all my political strength, to the Popular Party Government in the fight against terrorism.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joan Puigcercós, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Puigcercós.- Mr. President of the Government, does your Government intend to fulfill the commitment to transfer the Montjuïc Castle to the city of Barcelona?

President.- I can reiterate on behalf of the Government the commitment to transfer to the city of Barcelona, to return to the city of Barcelona the Montjuïc Castle, with the aim of it becoming a Museum of Peace and Concord. Furthermore, I can announce that it will be done immediately, because this Friday the Government will approve the Bill for that return, given that, as Your Lordship knows, a legislative modification is required. Therefore, yes, and immediately.

Mr. Puigcercós.- On March 22, 2005, in response to a question from the Catalan group of the Entesa Catalana de Progrès in the Senate, your Government responded that during 2005 the Government's Bill to revoke Law 52/1960, which is the law that currently still governs the transfer of Montjuïc Castle, would enter the Cortes, and that during this year -- we are talking about 2005 -- the Government would process this Bill. Better late than never, and in this case, late; it is only two months.

You know perfectly well that Montjuïc Castle, beyond its symbolic meaning, is an important castle for the city of Barcelona, not only for the museum, in this case the Museum of Peace, that the City Council wants to establish there, but also for the project to create in Montjuïc Castle the Museum, in this case, of Local History of the city of Barcelona, in addition to the tourist and economic interest that Montjuïc Castle will have for the city.

This is important, and if that is the case, and evidently on Friday the Council of Ministers approves this Project, it is great news and, above all, it is for the City Council of Barcelona, which this Friday, in its municipal plenary, was going to approve a new requirement. I hope it is not necessary and that it is simultaneous, that your Government finally makes this Bill and that Montjuïc Castle can be for all citizens, attractive and, above all, a memory of history.

Not long ago, on October 15, 2004, the Vice President of the Government also stated there that the best tribute to memory -- and there Lluis Companys, President of Catalonia, was executed; he was murdered by the Franco dictatorship --… At that moment, the Vice President of the Government recalled that the best tribute to memory was to return the Castle to the city of Barcelona; not with the law that was made at the time by Francoism, but a law of transfer to the city that honored memory and honored history.

I believe it is great news for the city of Barcelona and for all citizens of Catalonia.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Parliamentary Group of the Popular Party

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you have created many problems, you have generated a lot of confusion and concern. It seems that in important matters you do not have things clear, that you improvise, say one thing and the opposite, and after creating the mess it seems you have to fix it at all costs, which is going to become the approach of this legislature.

Fixing things at all costs is very dangerous. I will refer to only two issues, Mr. President; first, to the Statute of Catalonia, so that we realize where we are. You agreed in September with Mr. Mas on a Statute; in January, four months later, you agreed on another; today Mr. Mas says that they do not have a closed agreement. You have generated a lot of division in Catalan society, you have broken with the Popular Party, you have created problems with your partners and you have created institutional problems for some of your Ministers with the President of the Generalitat. You say that this Statute is for twenty-five years and your partners say no way. And, above all, and most importantly, here no one is defending the general interest.

Something similar is happening in the issue of terrorism, Mr. President. You have problems not only with the main opposition party, you have them with the victims, with people from your party; Mr. Peces Barba resigns; you do things that no one understands and, in the end, you convey the feeling that you are aspiring to a truce at all costs.

I tell you that the policy of governing at all costs is not a good policy, that a ruler must have principles, clarity, commitment, and know where he is going. That is what all Spaniards, your voters, those of the Popular Party, your partners, and even your political adversaries appreciate. That is why I ask you the question that appears on the agenda and that is very clear: do you commit to not negotiate or accept the right to self-determination?

President.- Mr. Rajoy, the right to which you refer, as is well known, does not exist either in our constitutional order or in any constitutional order of democratic countries. Therefore, the question has a very easy answer: no.

What I am considering, knowing, as you know, that this is the case, is the intent behind the question; that is what I am considering. Beyond that, and after having listened to you, who have asked and made assessments on all topics, I want to say two things regarding this.

Mr. Rajoy, being untruthful is a little profitable attitude in politics. The facts and recent memory should serve you. It does not matter to talk about the Statute of Catalonia, where you have spent months saying that it broke Spain and that was completely false; it does not matter now what you are doing in your attitude with anti-terrorist policy; it does not matter what you are doing with the criticism and falsehoods towards the Government. They will all remain in their place. Do you know why, Mr. Rajoy? Because people have memory, citizens have memory.

You led us with lies to a war and now you want to put lies in the expectation of a peace that is so necessary, desired, and difficult. And you put even more lies about the stability, the future, and the cohesion of Spain, which is fully safeguarded by democracy and the will of the citizens.

Mr. Rajoy.- Bad business, Mr. President, that you have to talk again about the war.

The intent of the politics and the question is for you to be clear. I will tell you clearly: do you guarantee that you will not negotiate self-determination in the Basque Country? Do you guarantee that you will not pay a political price to the terrorists?

Mr. President of the Government, you have agreed with Mr. Mas on the concept of "nation" in the Catalan Statute and Mr. Mas has said -- I quote literally -- that "this is a pact of sovereignty recognized by the Cortes." What are you going to do?

Mr. President, in 2005, in January, I offered you an agreement, as has always been done in Spain since 1978. You did not accept. You would have been better off if you had accepted it…

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I believe I have made it clear; now, I do not know if you do not listen, do not want to listen, or are not interested in hearing what the President of the Government says. No. Do you want to hear it again? No.

Finally, Mr. Rajoy, the Statute of Catalonia is fully constitutional and, if not, go to the Constitutional Court, which is the one that has to decide.