Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

6 February 2007 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on CIA rendition flights through Spain and ETA anti-terrorism policy during a February 2007 control session in the Spanish Congress.
Main themes
CIA torture flights, human rights violations, government transparency and document declassification, Spanish intelligence services, ETA terrorism and anti-terrorist policy, parliamentary oversight, European Union sovereignty, judicial cooperation
Duration
~12 min
43rd percentile
Words
1,479
43rd percentile
Sentences
48
31st percentile
Readability
41
38th percentile
Grade
14.4
71st percentile
Syntax
3.48
93rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.28
69th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 62%58%
  • Institutional 27%25%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

48 sentences in 25 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Gaspar Llamazares, of the Parliamentary Group of United Left-Initiative for Catalonia Greens

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Llamazares.- Mr. President, do you intend to declassify the documents of the National Intelligence Center regarding the "torture flights" of the Central Intelligence Agency?

President.- Mr. Llamazares, this is the third time you have raised this issue, which highlights your interest and concern about it, and I tell you that you have moral and political reasons for doing so.

On previous occasions, I have indicated that I share your concern as this matter directly affects basic human rights, and I reiterate to you now, Mr. Llamazares, that all the information the Government has regarding the illegal CIA flights in Spanish territory has been provided to Parliament. This was done on July 3, 2006, by the Director of the National Intelligence Center in the Official Secrets Commission, and the Minister of Foreign Affairs and Cooperation appeared before the corresponding Commission of this Chamber and before a special Commission of the European Parliament on September 14, 2006, where this matter was discussed.

Furthermore, I can inform you that the State Security Forces and Corps have participated and continue to participate, within their judicial police functions, in actions aimed at ensuring that the facts can be properly clarified.

And, of course, I can confirm to you, Mr. Llamazares, that the Council of Ministers next Friday, February 9, will examine this request following the necessary procedures and with the utmost willingness and availability to cooperate with Justice. All information in our possession, whether little, some, or none, will be provided for the corresponding action of the courts.

Mr. Llamazares.- Mr. President of the Government, we are facing one of the greatest scandals in the European Union of the 21st century. It affects the Union's commitment to human rights; to its sovereignty; to the sovereignty of the member states, which has been violated by CIA planes, and also to the solvency and autonomy of intelligence services.

The facts are compelling, Mr. President: hundreds of fraudulent flights, 125 at various Spanish airports; arrests and transfers by the CIA to detention centers that currently hold around fourteen thousand people; fraudulent companies and crews, companies and crews even with completely illegal passports.

Well, all of this means a violation of the Chicago Convention and a violation of the conventions against torture, the conventions signed by the countries of the European Union.

To all this, what has the Spanish Government done? We believe it has squandered the opportunity for European leadership and human rights, first, because caught between the compensatory syndrome and the inability to regenerate the intelligence services, it has refused to acknowledge reality. For almost a year, the Government has not recognized reality and has promoted the filing of proceedings; later, the Government has resisted providing all the information, has tried to localize the investigation in the Balearic Islands, and has given minimal information, in our opinion, to the Congress of Deputies.

That is why, Mr. President, when European leadership in human rights is no longer possible, all we ask is that you move from resistance to collaboration; that you cooperate with the investigation carried out by the media, that carried out by Justice, and that carried out by the European Parliament and the European Council; that you cooperate and that it cannot be said in the future, as some have said recently, that the best way to coordinate the information of our intelligence services is to hand it over to the CIA.

President.- Mr. Llamazares, I share the political judgment and, if you allow me, the moral judgment of the facts that have been the subject of investigation by many European countries; but at the same time, I must clarify. The Government of Spain has always had a collaborative attitude with Justice and with the truth in defense of human rights in this case. All the information in our possession is in Parliament and, of course, will be in the National Court. Time, evidence, and facts will make it clear and confirm that what the Government has said so far is the only truth.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Parliamentary Group of the Popular Party

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, last Saturday hundreds of thousands of Spaniards took to the streets and told you to put an end to the talks with ETA-Batasuna and that the only sensible anti-terrorist policy is a return to the policy of defeating ETA. Are you going to change your anti-terrorist policy?

President.- This is a debate that is not new in this Chamber; we have had it repeatedly. I take this opportunity to reiterate what the principles and foundations of the Government's anti-terrorist policy are: first, to defend the security and freedom of citizens as much as possible against the terrorist threat; second, to apply the Law, Justice, and the Rule of Law; third, to support the victims; and fourth, as is the responsibility of any serious and responsible Government, to seek an end to violence and terror. These are the foundations and principles of our anti-terrorist policy.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, that answer is not valid. It is no longer a time for words, for hollow phrases, or for ambiguities. What the Spaniards are asking for is clarity.

I am not going to talk about the past now, but look at what Spaniards have read today in various media: "Paris warns that ETA is hiding hundreds of explosives in safe houses"; "ETA prisoners begin a pressure campaign for amnesty and independence"; "The Prosecutor reduces the sentences by half for 52 defendants in the Ekin case, of ETA"; "Rodríguez Zapatero meets with Eguiguren to relaunch the ETA process."

After all this and after the lamentable spectacle we have seen in the last forty-eight hours with an ETA member photographed and interviewed in the foreign press, and after the brazen spectacle of ETA's youth organization, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you have the obligation to put an end to all this.

I will tell you the following: say here whether after December 30 last there has been or not any conversation with the ETA-Batasuna complex by the Socialist Party of the Basque Country or any emissary; say that there will be none in the future; say that you will do what you can to ensure that Batasuna does not run in the elections in compliance with the Law of Political Parties; say that you will initiate the process of illegalization of the Communist Party of the Basque Lands; say that you are going to bring order to the Ministry of the Interior, because the spectacle produced is certainly lamentable and, above all, stop with the ambiguities. You have the obligation to be clear and firm. You preside over a great nation of 44 million inhabitants, the eighth largest economy in the world. Act as the President of that nation, rise to the occasion, correct your policy as all sensible people are asking you to do, and return to consensus with the Popular Party.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, you have based your argument on four news items that appear in the media; you have recounted them. I can respond to one of them that directly affects me. For that one, I can respond and I can tell you that it is radically false, because I have not met with Mr. Eguiguren for anything; neither to talk about the peace process nor for anything. Therefore, since you start from premises and information that, of course, as far as I am concerned, are not true, the rest of the argument is very weak.

I want to tell you, Mr. Rajoy, that in this chamber, in the plenary debate we had, I established what the principles were that led to the end of the breakdown of the dialogue process. And now I call on you to take responsibility and to behave like a leader of the opposition in a great country.

I do not know if in your political dictionary the words "modesty," "coherence," or "responsibility" exist. Look at what your President, Mr. Aznar, said on March 5, 2000, after two ETA murders: Lieutenant Colonel Blanco and Fernando Buesa. They asked him on March 5, 2000, after the breakdown of the truce: "If ETA were to declare a truce again, what would be the Government's attitude?" "We cannot rule out that ETA will try to do the same thing it has done before; we would maintain the same attitude: to try to take advantage of opportunities."

Mr. Rajoy, I ask you for responsibility, coherence, seriousness, and rigor because, if not, after knowing what has happened in the history of this country, the narrative you are creating and what you say every day is simply a narrative of infamy.