Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

27 February 2007 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary control questions in the Spanish Congress in February 2007, addressing government accountability and compliance with legislative resolutions.
Main themes
Parliamentary control and oversight, government accountability to legislature, compliance with parliamentary resolutions, executive-legislative relations, Basque Parliamentary Group concerns, ministerial conduct, inshore fishing fleet policy, democratic governance, investiture commitments
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,611
70th percentile
Sentences
80
52nd percentile
Readability
34
23rd percentile
Grade
16.4
86th percentile
Syntax
3.40
89th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
30th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 64%48%
  • Economic 17%13%
  • Ceremonial 14%10%
  • Social 5%4%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 26%

80 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Josu Iñaki Erkoreka, from the Basque Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, do you consider that your Government adequately responds to the functions of promotion and control that this Chamber must exercise over its activity?

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, I believe that the Government has fulfilled the commitment made during the investiture to submit to permanent control by the Legislature in its task of political direction of the country and also to logically comply with the part that corresponds to Parliament in promoting political action by the Executive. I will remind you of some data: I have answered, as President of the Government, questions from Parliamentary Groups in Congress on 181 occasions and 57 times in the Senate, and the Government has already answered more than one hundred thousand written questions in Congress in these three years and more than 47,000 in the Senate. Therefore, in general terms, I believe we have fulfilled the commitment of the Investiture Debate.

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, it is not my intention to make a generic disqualification of the way in which the Government articulates its relations with Parliament and responds to the control and promotion activity that Parliament exercises or should exercise over the Executive; on the contrary, I believe that in this Legislature some steps forward have been taken in this regard.

But allow me to tell you, Mr. President, that the experience of my Group and other Parliamentary Groups is that not all Ministers in your Government are equally respectful of this Parliament. In some ministerial departments, they allow themselves to openly disregard and even contradict formally approved resolutions in this Chamber; ministerial departments that at times even come to despise parliamentarians by responding to their questions with inaccuracies, distortions, and even outright falsehoods. This is a very serious drift, Mr. President, that concerns me and concerns my Parliamentary Group, and I would like to denounce it here, before you and before the Chamber.

I will give you just one example, I do not have time for more, but I believe it is sufficiently eloquent and graphic of what I want to express. Look, in the last Debate on the State of the Nation, a Resolution was approved here urging the Government to protect and support the inshore fishing fleet of the Cantabrian Sea with a series of very specific measures aimed at this purpose. Well, just one month after this Resolution was approved, the Ministry of Agriculture issued a Ministerial Order in which, not only did it fail to comply with the Resolution, but it established exactly the opposite of what the parliamentary Resolution urged the Government to do. The complete opposite.

You see, we would even be accustomed to the Resolution being disregarded and we would not have raised any objection in that regard; but it put forth everything contrary to what was urged from the Chamber. It challenged, I believe quite seriously, the authority and preeminence of Parliament.

This is very serious, Mr. President. We are advancing into very dangerous territory. It is a Ministry that does not act with loyalty, with respect to Parliament; it allows itself to give responses that do not address the substance of the matter, with distortions and outright falsehoods, and it has dynamics not typical of a democratic Government, but at times, even with the affected sectors, more typical of disreputable mafia networks.

I do not doubt your democratic spirit...

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, I appreciate that you have recognized the political will and effort of the Government in the task of parliamentary control and in complying with the Resolutions of Congress and the Senate.

I have here a long list, in which your Group has been a protagonist, of parliamentary initiatives that have been successfully completed: participation of the Autonomous Communities in European Union matters; recognition of multilingualism in European institutions; measures of compensation after floods in various Autonomous Communities; development of the railway network in the Basque Country; improvement of pensions; renewal and adaptation of the Economic Concert; agreements in connection with the crisis of the Izar shipyards... In short, a long list where your Group has had a prominent role, an evident initiative, and the Government has complied.

Of course, every task is improvable, and I can assure you that the Government will make every effort to faithfully comply with what are, within the scope of its competencies and functions, the agreements of this Parliament and the initiatives of your Group. And I take note in that regard of the specific singular case, among thousands of decisions that this Chamber adopts, that you have raised to see if we can make a decision that is satisfactory for your Group.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, from the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran.- This Parliamentary Group intended to ask the President a question that was announced in terms of how the President values the last control session, but due to what happened last Friday, the 23rd, on the commuter railway in Martorell, we have been forced to change the question and ask the Government what actions the President plans to take to prevent the continuous incidents that paralyze the commuter services of Renfe Barcelona.

However, allow me, Mr. President, to say that this Parliamentary Group highly negatively values the last control session. This Parliamentary Group understands that the confrontation that is transmitted from this Chamber is not positive, and this Parliamentary Group cannot value the intervention of the Minister of Justice in the last control session positively at all. And I would like you to be able to talk about that, but I have changed the question and I ask you to talk to me about the problem of Renfe Commuter Services in Catalonia.

President.- Mr. Duran, I will stick to the content of the question. In any case, I am willing at any time to answer as many questions as you deem appropriate, as has been the practice in this Legislature.

I will start by saying that it is necessary to recognize that the operation of the commuter trains in Barcelona is not satisfactory. There are two clear causes, from the Government's point of view: the insufficient historical investment in Barcelona's commuter services and, secondly, the high-speed works in the vicinity of Barcelona, works that run parallel to the tracks over a significant stretch.

The Government, in light of this situation, has launched a plan, since November 2006, specifically for the improvement of Barcelona's commuter services, which includes a significant set of measures affecting infrastructure and passenger assistance. The objective is to reduce the number of incidents that have been occurring.

An additional annual allocation of five million euros has been assigned for the maintenance of the network; the personnel dedicated to maintenance and traffic control has been increased by 35 people; the fleet of trains has been increased, so that by the end of this year all those running during peak hours will do so in double composition; on the next 1st of March, tomorrow, six new trains will be incorporated, and throughout the year, another eight and twenty-three in 2008 will be put into service.

In relation to passenger assistance, a Passenger Assistance Unit has been created, integrated by 212 security assistants and 455 agents. An immediate response bus fleet has been made available, and a single responsible person, dependent on the Ministry of Development, has been appointed to coordinate actions of ADIF and Renfe in this regard.

That is the entirety of the plan, and we hope that in a reasonable time, the necessary and obligatory improvement of the operation of Renfe's commuter services in Barcelona will become a reality.

Mr. Duran.- Thank you, Mr. President, first of all for expressing that the service is unsatisfactory. Secondly, beyond the measures that you announce that the Government has adopted, it is evident that the effects of them are what they are. On February 23rd, last Friday, the press described it as the twelfth breakdown this year. There is a problem, therefore, that the user suffers and that has a public order projection; you know as well as I do that there was an interruption of the tracks by one hundred citizens; it has labor implications, as people arrive late to their jobs, people are fed up in this regard; it has family implications and, of course, it has produced greater traffic congestion in the city of Barcelona, which has increased by 5 percent.

It is true that investments have increased in recent years, and it is also true that in the first year, compared to the previous budget, they practically halved; but it is also true that the population has increased by one million inhabitants, with a large influx of that million in that metropolitan area.

Consequently, Mr. President, we believe that it is a problem of investment, but also a problem of management, and that it is not simply a matter of knowing whether investments were made before or not, because there were also fewer problems before than there are now. There are new circumstances that the new Government must address.

The Minister made decisions in her day: she dismissed the Director of Commuter Services. Now it is you, Mr. President, and it is the Government that must assume new responsibilities. I hope that everything you say will really have immediate positive effects, that there will be no more breakdowns, that there will be no more public order problems or impacts on users, and that, therefore, you, Mr. President, assume responsibility.

President.- Mr. Duran, it is evident that we do not deny the reality; we always try to act in the Government's task regarding the deficiencies that exist in Renfe's commuter services, and we are convinced that the plan we have launched will yield the results that citizens deserve in the medium term and that, of course, we all expect, your Group and, above all, the Government of Spain.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, from the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- In less than two years, nineteen members of our Armed Forces have lost their lives in Afghanistan; in addition, there have been numerous attacks against Spanish troops. All intelligence services warn of the risk of more attacks, as does NATO and also the Spanish Minister of Defense, who publicly raised the possibility of increasing the number of soldiers to reinforce the security of our troops, as was done in 2006.

Mr. President, do you think there is more risk and more danger in Afghanistan? Are we or are we not in a state of war? What are you going to do to guarantee the safety of Spanish soldiers in Afghanistan?

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I want to take this opportunity to reiterate the Government's support and solidarity to all members of our Armed Forces, especially those who are carrying out a mission abroad in defense of values such as peace, security, and democratic order.

I want to remind Mr. Rajoy, simply to clarify some of the things he has said, that of the fatalities we have had in Afghanistan, of those he mentioned, seventeen were due to a serious accident, just as there were sixty-two in the past due to a serious accident, which was the Yakolev 42, and that we have indeed had two casualties as a result of terrorist attacks.

Of course, the Government's objective is that our troops have the maximum security, that they have the most effective, modern, and operational means available to our Armed Forces. To that end, specifically since April 2006, as a result of the decision of the Defense General Staff, we made a significant increase in what represents new means for the protection units of the PRT, both in Qal-i-Naw and in the Quick Reaction Company in Herat.

The QRF company service from Herat has been deployed, a team for deactivating explosives, with eight personnel; two medical stabilization teams; six personnel for immediate medical attention; a CASA 295 transport plane to the Herat Base to have national means of transport and evacuation; new, more armored vehicles, the most powerful available to our Armed Forces; new ambulances; hospital means and a considerable increase in night vision equipment, improvements in protection and armor for helicopters, in accordance with the recommendations of the Operations Command, which constantly evaluates the risk indicators on the ground and proposes the measures to be adopted according to their evolution.

I reiterate that these measures were adopted ten months ago and that, of course, if the Operations Command deems it appropriate, we will continue to increase the measures to reinforce the security of our troops in Afghanistan.

Mr. Rajoy. - Mr. President, that is what they did, but I ask you what you are going to do in the future, because the Secretary General of NATO said a few days ago that, whether we like it or not, Afghanistan is a battlefield; the Chairman of NATO's Military Committee has just said that there are combat operations, and the Minister of Defense, sitting next to you, has said that the objective risk situation has increased, and he speaks of "warlords," armed groups, and the Taliban. The Spanish Army is already talking about war.

I am not going to enter into a discussion about whether it is a war, as everyone believes, or if it is what you say it is, but your obligation is to guarantee security. Indeed, in May 2006, they increased the number of soldiers by 150 to guarantee security, but now NATO is asking you for more troops to guarantee security; several countries have increased their troops to guarantee their security; the head of the Spanish Army, whom you appointed, said at a CESEDEN meeting on February 13 that more troops were necessary to guarantee security; the Ambassador to NATO has also said this recently, and the Minister of Defense raised it publicly.

I do not know if it is necessary or not, but why does everyone say one thing and you say the opposite, and say that more troops are not necessary to guarantee security? I only tell you one thing, Mr. President, it is your obligation to provide explanations in this Chamber. And I remind you that we are in Afghanistan because you wanted to be, certainly with my support. You may say that there is no war, but yesterday there was an attack against the Vice President of the United States and twenty other people have died. And, in any case, your obligation is to guarantee the safety of the soldiers.

You can no longer act as if you were in the opposition. You are the President of the Government of Spain, you must listen to the people who tell you sensible things or, if not, contradict all the people, including your Minister; all those I have referred to in this Chamber. It is your responsibility as President of the Government of Spain.

President. - Mr. Rajoy, I remind you that the first time troops were sent to Afghanistan, Mr. Trillo was the Minister of Defense and he said they were going on a peace mission. It is recorded in the minutes of this Parliament. Of course, they will have the maximum possible security that our General Staff and our Operations Command decide so that this mission to fight terrorism, for peace and stability is carried out, as honorably as they know how, by the Spanish soldiers.