Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

13 March 2007 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on anti-terrorism policy and Spain's position on the Western Sahara conflict during a March 2007 congressional control session.
Main themes
Anti-terrorism policy, peace agreement, ETA violence, political unity, victims' rights, rule of law, Western Sahara conflict, Spain-Morocco relations, self-determination, parliamentary debate
Duration
~16 min
55th percentile
Words
1,915
55th percentile
Sentences
59
39th percentile
Readability
38
31st percentile
Grade
15.8
82nd percentile
Syntax
3.42
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
49th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 47%46%
  • Geopolitical 38%37%
  • Social 9%8%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

59 sentences in 31 paragraphs

Mr. President, our recent history, that of this Legislature, is a tale of fury and noise. The fury of the agonizing violence of ETA and its resistance to leaving our lives, but also the noise, the political noise of division, the noise of those who from the beginning of the Legislature have been intent on instrumentalizing anti-terrorist policy as party policy, on claiming ownership of the victims and of the rule of law itself; in short, on their fear of peace.

However, the majority of citizens, aware, do not resign themselves to the noise and fury nor do they wait for calm to arrive on its own, because the vast majority of sensible citizens, even if they sometimes disagree, recognize the legitimacy of the Government and its leadership in anti-terrorist matters. The vast majority of good people, even if they sometimes do not understand us, desire a united response from the political forces and institutions; they want us to be flexible and strong against terrorism.

Mr. President, as important as it is to explain the measures adopted is to lead the future, the future of anti-terrorist policy, a future that also has the support of the parliamentary political forces of this Chamber, except for the one that has decided from the outset to fly solo. Therefore, with humility but also with conviction, we propose that you lead a pact for peace and against terrorism, based on commitment and solidarity with the victims and not on their instrumentalization; an agreement that unites political forces without exclusions; an agreement for the fight against terrorism and in favor of peace from the rule of law without shortcuts; an agreement that also allows political action to integrate into the democratic game those who renounce violence.

Mr. President, today the best way to prepare for peace is an agreement for peace.

President.- Mr. Llamazares, I want to first thank you for the attitude you have maintained throughout the Legislature regarding anti-terrorist policy, because it has always been a constructive attitude, always supportive of the Government. And I know that you maintain some disagreement on those principles that the Government has expressed regarding anti-terrorist policy, particularly regarding the consequences or the product of the Pact for Liberties and against Terrorism and, in particular, the Law of Political Parties.

That is the position, in my opinion, useful, serious, responsible, and that shows that there are leaders and parties willing to put the general interests first, who love their country and defend the nation above their short-term party interests.

Mr. Llamazares, I want to make that public acknowledgment.

Secondly, I want to tell you that I am always open. All governments desire maximum unity in the fight against terrorism and to achieve peace, or to achieve peace and in the fight against terrorism. Of course, in any initiative, and keep in mind that yours always has value for me in favor of an agreement in this matter, the Socialist Party, without a doubt, and the Government will be working, building, and collaborating. There is nothing more worthwhile, having political responsibilities and leading a political formation, than to contribute decently to putting in what we can to achieve peace and see the end of terrorism.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Román Rodríguez, of the Parliamentary Group of Coalición Canaria-Nueva Canarias

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rodríguez.- Mr. President, the purpose of the question is for you to clarify whether there are modifications in the traditional position of the Government of Spain regarding the conflict in Western Sahara that a part of public opinion has perceived in recent times.

President.- The question is a consequence of what has been the High-Level Meeting between Spain and Morocco. I want to remind you of some of the things that were established there and exactly the content of what was the joint declaration; a joint declaration that states as follows: "The Spanish side has welcomed with interest and considers that it could generate a new dynamic of dialogue to overcome the current impasse and progress on this basis with the aim of achieving a resolution to this dispute that ensures the principle of self-determination." With "welcomes with interest," it is evident that it refers to the autonomy plan presented or to be presented by Morocco to the United Nations.

In short, Spain maintains its traditional position and adds a new element to that position, which is to acknowledge that Morocco is going to provide a plan, which has been outlined to us in its general lines, to respond to the conflict in the Sahara; a conflict that, as I have expressed on many occasions, has only one path to resolution, which is an agreement between the parties. And that is the position, moreover, maintained by the United Nations.

In that position and in that only exit, Spain has to act as a constructive country, that forces and contributes to achieving that agreement. That is the fixed position, because it has not changed, of the Government of Spain in this matter.

Mr. Rodríguez.- Mr. President, I am glad that the Government of Spain does not modify the minimum position we have established in the last twenty-five or thirty years regarding this conflict.

Fortunately, yesterday also, and for the umpteenth time, this Congress of Deputies unanimously approved two Non-Legislative Propositions, one from Eusko Alkartasuna and another proposed by Izquierda Unida, where a unanimous position regarding the conflict is reiterated, respectful of international legality and human rights.

But, Mr. President, it does not escape you that the acceptance by the Government of Spain of the Moroccan proposal for political autonomy for Western Sahara generates confusion and rejection; rejection before the Spanish public opinion, rejection before the other party in the conflict, and I would also say that yesterday it was evident in all the spokespersons of the Parliamentary Groups, except for that of the Socialist Group.

And it makes sense. The proposal of the Government of Morocco is not acceptable because it violates two basic principles of the legal-political acquis that the United Nations has established regarding this conflict: the first, that proposals cannot be unilateral, and this one is, and it has also been flatly rejected by the other party in conflict; secondly, because it de facto denies the right to self-determination, which is also a condition of that legal-political acquis that has been built over the years.

If we add to that, Mr. President, some decisions such as the sale of arms to Morocco, which we do not know what impact it will have on the conflict where there is currently a ceasefire supervised by MINURSO, or the timidity regarding the denunciation of human rights violations in the occupied territories, one can conclude that there is a change in position.

I must recognize that the position of the Heads of State yesterday in Algiers, the position of the Congress of Deputies, and your clarification today point in the clearest direction that Spain must play a role in defending international legality on this issue and I ask you...

President.- Just to clarify two issues in this regard. You referred to some examples that could cast doubt on our position, but you forgot some: for example, that this Government has tripled the aid to Tindouf, to the camps where a good part of the Sahrawi people are, it has tripled the aid; secondly, that we have been thirty years without a solution to the conflict, thirty years, and therefore, in this regard, no one should look at previous examples for the fruits they have yielded, because they have not existed; thirdly, the Government, as it is convinced that only an agreement can provide the solution...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

-----------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, on Saturday many Spaniards took to the streets in a serene, exemplary, civic, responsible, and serious manner to ask you to rectify the decision to give preferential treatment to De Juana Chaos. They asked you to rectify that decision and your anti-terrorist policy. Will you do it?

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I have the utmost respect for all the people who express their free opinion through the channels that citizens are constitutionally guaranteed. The anti-terrorist policy that the Government has been defending has three objectives: to prevent, to combat, and to work for the end of terrorism. It is a state policy, it has been so since the democratic transition; a policy in which the Government should count on the support of all political groups and which deeply regrets that since the beginning of the Legislature, regardless of the case of De Juana Chaos or any other, the Party... regrets that it has never had even a single day in any single decision the support of your Group to fight against terrorism and see the end of violence.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, there was a pact between parties, you signed it, it had the support of the majority of Spaniards and weakened ETA like never before. You included it in your electoral program; what you are doing was not in your electoral program. I also included it in my electoral program. You broke the Pact and, despite that, I supported you after the truce until you did the only thing I asked you not to do; the only thing.

You have made many wrong decisions: you declared that De Juana Chaos was in favor of the peace process; you described Otegi as a man of peace; you were kinder to Batasuna than to the Popular Party; the last decision, and I hope it is truly the last, was that of De Juana Chaos. They said it was an intelligent and humanitarian decision, and yesterday we learned what we all knew: a blackmail was accepted.

What happens now when Batasuna says it wants to go to the elections? I ask you to say here that Batasuna will not go to the elections. I ask you to say here that you will not make a pact in Navarra with those who want Navarra to stop being Navarra. You are going against the vast majority of Spanish society. You are forcing your party and many people who have given you their vote and support, who do not believe in what you are doing.

It seems, Mr. President, that at this point in the Legislature you only have two topics on your political agenda: the first is the peace process, as you call it, which has you subjected to the blackmail of a terrorist organization, and the second point, the global disqualification of the opposition. I do not know if that is good for you, but it is certainly bad for Spain and bad for the Spaniards.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, there may be Spaniards, and there are, who disagree with the decision we have made regarding De Juana Chaos, but there is not a single Spaniard who can say that you have supported me in the fight against terrorism since the beginning of the Legislature or in any matter.

Secondly, Mr. Rajoy, neither blackmail nor setup. This Government does not accept blackmail from anyone, neither from a terrorist nor from anyone, nor does it cower before the setup of lies from the Popular Party in anti-terrorist policy. This Government makes decisions within the law and makes them out of a sense of state and responsibility to guarantee the security of all.