Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

8 September 2009 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on the Basque Arbitral Board VAT ruling and Spain's regional financing model during a September 2009 parliamentary control session.
Main themes
Regional financing model, Basque Arbitral Board ruling, VAT dispute and appeal, Álava Provincial Council payment, state treasury interests, parliamentary accountability, autonomous communities funding, fiscal and financial policy, transparency in public spending
Duration
~12 min
43rd percentile
Words
1,467
43rd percentile
Sentences
54
35th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
13.4
60th percentile
Syntax
3.12
63rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
22nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 57%57%
  • Institutional 26%26%
  • Ceremonial 17%17%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

54 sentences in 28 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josu Iñaki Erkoreka, of the Basque Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Erkoreka.- The Arbitral Board, Mr. President of the Government, is a unique body provided for in the Economic Concert Law to resolve discrepancies that arise between the concurrent tax administrations regarding the controversial aspects linked to the application of the Concerted Regime.

Despite its youth, as it was established in April 2008, it has proven to be an agile, convenient, and effective way to address the problems that may arise in this area. In fact, during its short year and a half of existence, it has resolved seventeen cases to the full satisfaction of all parties involved.

Two months ago, on June 19 exactly, it issued a ruling in a matter that pitted the General State Administration against the Provincial Council of Álava, regarding the points of connection of VAT concerning an entity, Robert España, S.A., that operated in both territories. The amount at stake was a considerable sum of 456 million euros, and the Arbitral Board ruled in favor of the Provincial Council of Álava. However, from the Government you preside over, there was an expressed intention to appeal to the Supreme Court against that ruling.

Do you maintain this intention, Mr. President?

President.- Mr. Erkoreka has recalled the genesis and development of this discrepancy regarding a tax-related issue, which is arbitrated by the Board and which the Government, specifically the Ministry of Economy and Finance, is evaluating, proceeding with an in-depth study of the ruling for a possible appeal. A decision has not yet been made, but I must tell you that, as is natural, the State Treasury seeks to defend what it may understand to be its interests.

With this, I believe I am responding quite clearly. There is no decision; it is being evaluated, but logically, the Public Treasury will defend its interests if that is what is appropriate to do.

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, thank you for your response, but I remind you that the agreements of the Arbitral Board have executive character, which means that an appeal is possible, but the decisions must be immediately implemented. In fact, this has been the case in the instances that have occurred to date. When such situations have arisen, the corresponding Provincial Councils first paid the amounts owed to the State Tax Agency and then filed the appeal with the Supreme Court.

We ask you the same, Mr. President. If the Government decides to appeal, it has the right to do so and can promote the challenges it deems appropriate; but first, pay the 456 million euros owed to the Álava Treasury, because that is what the Law establishes, because that has been systematically done up to the present—this is the entrenched practice—and, thirdly, because the times are not right for making gratuitous waivers.

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, do not have any doubt that the Public Treasury, the Government, is evaluating that situation, analyzing the precedents, and will scrupulously comply with the Law, as it cannot be otherwise.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- The history of regional financing is a very curious story and very characteristic of you, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero.

More than three years ago, you announced a new model of regional financing; it did not come, and for a long time there were public debates among different members of your party and other parties on this issue. Then they approved a law that they said would have a new financing in August 2008, but there was no financing either. It was left for this Legislature, and in the end, there was a meeting of the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy that left us all practically as we were. And there are some Presidents of Autonomous Communities who stated the amount that corresponded to them under the new model, but that does not match the figures given by the Minister of Economy.

The Minister of Economy here did not want to explain, in August, how much each region would receive. So, it seems to me that, in the interest of transparency, so that all citizens know how their money is spent, the President of the Government, who is supposed to know the model thoroughly, should tell us what is happening with the model and how much each Autonomous Community is entitled to additionally.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, as you know, the regional financing model, agreed upon in the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy without any votes against, which is truly a merit given the style of opposition your comrades and your party have, establishes a transparent system of the total resources that will integrate that model, because it includes the amounts of the resources that are integrated into the system for all the Communities in 2009 and 2010, the figures to be distributed by the regional convergence funds, and also the distribution criteria among Communities that, unlike the current system, allow for an objective, clear, transparent, and real distribution of resources.

The only thing that happens, and we have said this several times, is that the distribution of additional resources by Autonomous Community depends on the definitive values of the distribution variables for the years 2009 and 2010; that is, on aspects such as revenue, population, or income for those years. Until all those factors are known during 2009 and 2010, the definitive data of what corresponds additionally to each Autonomous Community cannot be provided.

Each of the Autonomous Communities has made its assessment, its approximation, and we respect that figure. By the way, that did not happen in 2001, because you in 2001 not only did not provide the data for the Communities, for some and others, but you did not provide any data, with an absolute lack of transparency. That is why I find it very strange that you now come to ask anything here, if Mr. Montoro did not provide a single piece of data for any Autonomous Community when they approved the regional financing model, and now you come to ask about the specific data of the Autonomous Communities.

The truth is that we have a new model, with no votes against, and therefore, all I wish is that the position maintained by your Presidents, quite constructive in many cases, is also reflected in the parliamentary processing of the LOFCA and that we can count on your cooperation in this agreement.

Mr. Rajoy.- The system is very transparent, but we know nothing. The only thing we know is that the data provided by the Presidents of the Autonomous Communities must not be very accurate, because neither the Minister of Economy nor the President of the Government confirm them.

What we are clear about are two things: that we do not know how much each one is entitled to and, moreover, that they will receive less in 2010 than in 2009. This is what we know.

So, Mr. President of the Government, I want to know how much money each one is entitled to, and I believe I have the right to ask, and you must tell us, how much the Autonomous Communities will have to repay definitively for their errors in establishing the State's income, and mind you, we warned you, and how much less money the Autonomous Communities will receive in advance for the year 2010.

I believe I have the right to ask that, and you have the obligation to tell me, because do not tell me that you have approved a regional financing system where thousands of millions of euros are discussed without having the faintest idea of what that you have approved consists of.

Therefore, I demand that you explain to me here what the Vice President of Economy has not wanted to explain and what the Presidents of the Autonomous Communities have explained, which today we have learned is not true; you have said so.

President.- How much do the Autonomous Communities have to repay? What the Law states. Yes, Mr. Rajoy. What Law or why does the Law say that? The Law that you made. If it is the model we have to apply from your Law, which establishes that when revenues are lower, they must be repaid. And we are going to defer it to the Autonomous Communities.

Figures? We respect those given by the Autonomous Communities. We estimate that a good part of those figures are reasonable. But, of course, do not tell us, do not ask us to provide the figures of the Autonomous Communities when you did not provide any figures in 2001, neither global nor approximate, for any Autonomous Community.

Thank you very much.