Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

27 October 2009 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero addressed the Spanish parliament on October 27, 2009, responding to questions about the government's handling of the hijacking of the tuna vessel Alakrana by Somali pirates.
Main themes
Alakrana fishing vessel hijacking, Somali piracy, government crisis management, Operation Atalanta, armed security on vessels, hostage families, Spain-EU anti-piracy cooperation, parliamentary accountability, private security regulations, Spanish Armed Forces deployment
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,537
68th percentile
Sentences
79
52nd percentile
Readability
35
26th percentile
Grade
16.0
83rd percentile
Syntax
3.43
91st percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 26%25%
  • Economic 22%22%
  • Institutional 22%22%
  • Geopolitical 18%18%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

79 sentences in 48 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josu Iñaki Erkoreka, of the Basque Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, today marks twenty-seven days since the tuna fishing vessel "Alakrana" was hijacked 423 miles off the coast of Somalia. Unfortunately, this event did not surprise anyone, because it was predictable, and, being predictable, it was also avoidable; however, it was not avoided, and the hijacking occurred, among other things, because the Government you preside over resisted adopting a series of measures that could have prevented it. This Chamber is witness to all of this.

A few days later, some French tuna fishing vessels were subjected to a similar attack in the same area, but they were luckier. They managed to repel the aggression, and they did so because they had onboard the security measures that your Government refused to adopt for Spanish-flagged vessels. The digital versions of the French newspapers that reported this event during those days included sarcastic comments, noting that this remains a difference between the north and south of the Pyrenees. Everyone, Mr. President, realized that your Government failed in prevention.

But prevention has already failed, the hijacking has occurred, and now we are in the phase of recovery, of liberation. That is why I pose the question that appears on the agenda: How do you assess the management carried out by the Government regarding the hijacking of the tuna fishing vessel "Alakrana"?

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, I wish, first of all, to express my support and solidarity, of course, to the kidnapped sailors and to the families of the crew members of the "Alakrana."

The Government is doing everything within its power to achieve the release and return home of our compatriots. That has been, from the very first moment, the task of the Government and also the priority we have given to the fight against piracy. I must remind Mr. Erkoreka that the Government has been a driving force behind "Operation Atalanta" in the framework of the United Nations and the European Union, which has prevented many other attacks on fishing vessels.

You know very well what the difficulties in the area are and the possible threats in such a vast area. I must remind you, as a comment on your introduction, that at this moment there are seven vessels hijacked, and in the last year there have been hijackings and attempts to board ships flying the French, German, American, Belgian, or Italian flags, to mention a few. Just yesterday, a British yacht was hijacked.

Therefore, we must do everything within our reach in the international arena and also in the internal arena. The Council of Ministers, as you know, has sent a Royal Decree to the Council of State that will modify the Regulations on Private Security and on the Use of War Weapons to allow Spanish vessels operating in the Indian Ocean to carry armed personnel with a deterrent effect against pirates.

What we have done so far, in relation to security and the use of our Armed Forces, is what is advised by the availabilities and laws of our country, the availabilities and laws in the opinion of the General Staff and in light of our conditions in the area to carry out such a task. I must remind you of this, and we should be prudent when making comparative judgments with the availabilities and capabilities in the area of the Armed Forces of other countries, even if they are neighbors, of course friends, and, in this case, also members of the European Union.

I reiterate, Mr. Erkoreka: the Government is willing to do everything within its power for the release and to continue fighting against piracy, and under the Spanish Presidency of the European Union, we will promote an International Conference on piracy to act...

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, I want to act responsibly. While the hijacking lasts, I will not raise debates that could cloud the negotiation or that could be counterproductive for the release of the vessel and its crew. To avoid doing so, I will not even make critical comments regarding this absurd farce that has been presented with the detained pirates, an absurd farce that is an inexplicable cocktail of incompetence, carelessness, and vanity.

There will be time for all of that, Mr. President, but in the meantime, there are the families, families who do not want their men who are detained there to be forgotten; families who have the impression that their Government is trying to conceal this matter from public opinion and are witnessing this situation with tension, concern, and anguish.

In a desperate cry, the sister of the captain said last week, listen to me, and I quote literally: "We want them to come home, we wish this story would end now; we cannot go on like this."

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran.- How does the President value the Education Pact?

President.- Mr. Duran, I value the Education Pact as a fundamental proposal, a project for our country and its future, because, as we well know, our level and evolution in the general education of the country will be decisive for our well-being, our growth, and our development, especially when we have to face a period of great collective effort for economic recovery.

That is why we are working with the main Group in the Chamber to achieve this Pact, and that is why we want this Pact, if it has a favorable horizon, to include, of course, all political groups and focus on the following points: first, a reduction in school dropout rates; second, a thorough change and improvement of Vocational Training; third, quality education accessible to all that recognizes the role of teachers; and fourth, in summary, to position some of our Universities among the best in Europe.

For this task, the Minister of Education is making a great effort in dialogue, which will, of course, extend to all Groups, and I hope that together we can successfully achieve this great agreement on Education. An agreement on Education is an agreement that lasts beyond a political cycle, that lasts beyond a Legislature, and we should have the greatness, the broad vision, and the collective generosity to try to achieve it and overcome what may be our differences. It would do the country a lot of good, it would do the economy a lot of good, and we would fulfill our duty.

Mr. Duran.- Our question does not intend to put the Government in any predicament; it simply aims to express our position regarding the Education Pact and, at the same time, to convey to the Chamber a reflection, logically our own, on this issue.

We have repeatedly spoken, Mr. President, about the need for structural reforms, for a State Pact to carry them out, and for a pact on productivity. Among them, I highlight as one of the main, not the only one, the educational reform, therefore, the Education Pact.

We are not only in favor and do not simply want to be participants in that Pact, but I want to remind the Chamber that the first intervention that was precisely made in its first Legislature on education was as a result of an interpellation from this Parliamentary Group, which I had the honor of defending, requesting and demanding this Pact that provides stability and quality to the educational system. While each Government comes with its own Education Law, we are denying that quality and that, in any case, stability to the system.

It is true that the Minister has had a first meeting with our Parliamentary Group, as he has with other Parliamentary Groups. The Minister's general lines coincide with ours, and it cannot be otherwise because they are very general lines; but we understand that we must urge this Education Pact. Society demands it from us. We are talking about the training of the future of the person, which is the main capital for the future.

We understand that among the contents of that Pact, its main skeleton must be Article 27 of the Constitution, harmonizing the right to education, to creation, to ideology, to the freedom of parents, and to gratuity. Without gratuity, there is no education. When the last Law was approved, we agreed to form a commission to study the modules of concerted education, and that has not yet been done.

We also believe, Mr. President, that the example of Catalonia is something to be followed and taken into account. And precisely for a Parliamentary Group like ours, what can never be asked of us is for consensus to be based on withdrawing competences precisely where we have been able to agree.

And fundamental values must be introduced into the educational system, both in Education and Vocational Training, as well as in the University, such as effort, authority, and discipline.

Once the points have been seen and diagnosed, it is not necessarily about making a law, but, in any case, modifying the laws that are appropriate at present.

President.- Mr. Duran, I appreciate your constructive stance that responds to the interest that your Group has always shown on this matter, and especially you.

The objective of the Government and the Minister of Education is to achieve an agreement that does not focus on ideological issues, but rather that we center the reforms, the agreements, and the impulses on what makes our education more productive to generate more training, to generate higher quality training, and, therefore, to make a great contribution to the economy of the country.

And, of course, I must reassure you in the sense that the pact will not, under any circumstances, seek to diminish or undermine autonomous competences.

I encourage you in that constructive task, just as I encourage all Groups because it is the great endeavor of this Government.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, the issue I am asking you about is an important one in the short, medium, and long term.

The European Commission published a report two weeks ago that evaluates the sustainability of public accounts in the various member states of the Union. It classifies countries into four groups; Spain is included in the fourth group, the one with the highest risk, and the Commission states that Spain has a high risk of unsustainability in its public finances in the long term; but it also refers to the short term, saying that it could become unsustainable much sooner and could leave the Government without room to finance the Welfare State, particularly health care and pensions in the short term.

I would like to know your opinion on this report and what measures you will adopt to prevent the inconveniences outlined in it.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, of course, the Government reads the Commission's report attentively. I would like to clarify: the report is based on the year 2009 for all countries, which is the year, as a consequence of the severe economic crisis, when public accounts are under very evident strain. This explains why, for the first time in history, twenty of the twenty-seven countries in the Union are subject to a procedure for excessive deficit.

However, specifically, regarding the more substantial issues, concerning health care, I must remind you that our public health system is in very good health and we dedicate 6 percent of GDP to it. Regarding Social Security, the horizon of the Commission's report is the year 2060, and I must remind you that at this moment, even with the severe economic crisis, we are going to have a substantial surplus this year 2009 in Social Security, that the Reserve Fund has increased in the last five years from 15,000 to 58,000 million euros, and that the ratio of contributors to pensioners is at its highest in the history of our democracy, even higher than in 2004.

To improve and consolidate our Social Security and pension system, we have the Toledo Pact. Of course, we must progressively implement reforms for its sustainability among all, because we are talking about a long-term policy that goes far beyond any Legislature.

Regarding public accounts, of the State in general, the Government has implemented two principles: one, to improve revenues to achieve sustainability and comply with the Stability Pact in 2012; the other, austerity. We will continue in these years 2009, 2010, 2011, and 2012 to reach the 3 percent deficit of the Stability Pact, which is the great objective.

Therefore, yes, we are fully aware of the situation and we will adopt measures, I hope, with the maximum consensus on all fronts of the sustainability of public accounts, in which we firmly believe.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, you say you are aware, but it is evident that you are not acting accordingly.

I am going to tell you what the Commission recommends, which is the same as what everyone else recommends and, of course, the Popular Parliamentary Group: first, a broad fiscal consolidation program to reduce the public debt deficit, and I remind you that the Commission states that the adjustment necessary in the structural deficit is 11.8 percent of GDP, which is double the average of the European Union; second, reforms in the social protection system are recommended, an issue on which we have seen nothing here, nor any initiative from your Government; and third, to implement policies that allow for the recovery of growth rates and policies that improve the productivity and competitiveness of our economy.

That is what many Groups in this Chamber, many experts in Spain, many international organizations, certainly the European Commission, have asked of you, and you are doing nothing. You are doing exactly the opposite: you continue to increase the public deficit, and yesterday we learned the data for the month of September, which represents a new historical record; in two years, you have increased public debt by two hundred billion euros, which is 33 trillion of the old pesetas; therefore, public debt continues to rise; the only measure you have taken is a tax increase, which is exactly the opposite of what should be done in a situation like this, and, of course, you are not proposing any structural reform.

I tell you this with absolute frankness, and I am not the only one saying it: either you take measures, or you are putting at risk the basic pillars of the Welfare State in our country, which took so much effort to achieve.

President.- Next week, the Government will send the plan for the consolidation of our public accounts to the European Commission.

I remind you that the Toledo Pact is working, therefore, to maintain the sustainability of our public accounts; that our public debt is twenty points lower than the average of the European Union and that, of course, this country will maintain the Welfare State and we will bet on a way out of the crisis with growth, not with paralysis…