Speech and subsequent discussion by the President of the Government before the American Business Council.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

20 October 2009 · Speech and subsequent discussion before the American Business Council

Context
Zapatero addressed the American Business Council in October 2009, outlining Spain-US economic ties and Spain's response to the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Spain-US economic relations, foreign direct investment, global financial crisis, real estate bubble, job creation, trade flows, G-20 response, fiscal stimulus, growth model reform, renewable energy, Spanish economic recovery
Duration
~51 min
94th percentile
Words
6,107
94th percentile
Sentences
216
91st percentile
Readability
35
25th percentile
Grade
15.3
78th percentile
Syntax
3.36
86th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 54%54%
  • Social 22%22%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Institutional 7%7%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

216 sentences in 104 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

Our economies have long been closely integrated. In 2008, Spain exported nearly 7.7 billion euros to the United States and imported goods worth 11.17 billion euros. The United States is the largest investor in Spain, with an investment stock of 43 billion euros, accounting for 17 percent of the total foreign direct investment in our country, an American investment that has increased by 11 percent since 2004, and we welcome it.

The presence of American companies in our country has, as you know, a long history and always with a commitment to permanence. These are investments in strategic industrial sectors, such as automotive, petrochemical, pharmaceutical, financial, and information and communication technologies, as well as business services, among others. These investments have created wealth and jobs: there are currently about 650 American companies established in Spain, employing more than three hundred thousand people. They are fundamental investments for the industrial and technological development of the Spanish economy.

In 2008, new investment projects from American companies created more than 1,400 jobs, and the latest available data, corresponding to the first eight months of 2009, show that, despite the crisis, American investments maintain their confidence in the potential of the Spanish economy, with more than thirty new investment projects, mainly from companies with a high technological profile.

On the other hand, although the importance of Spain as a foreign investor in the United States is relatively smaller, the dynamism of our investment has increased spectacularly. At the beginning of the 1990s, Spanish investment in the United States was hardly significant, ranking twelfth among the countries of the European Union. But by 2008, Spain was already the sixth largest investor in the United States among EU countries and the tenth in the world, with its investment stock multiplying sevenfold since 2004. And in 2009, the latest known data not only confirm but also reinforce this growing weight of Spanish investments, focused on strategic sectors such as renewables, transport infrastructure management, and the financial sector. The Minister of Industry, who is with us today, will travel next week to the United States as part of the "Made in Spain-Made by Spain" program to continue promoting this process.

The United States and Spain have been hit by the worst global crisis in decades, a crisis that has undermined the very foundations of the financial system, severely damaged business confidence, and for the first time in a long time, retracted global trade.

However, in this very adverse context, I want to highlight that the flows of investment and trade relations between our two countries are showing that great strength I just referred to. We have not stopped sharing this mutual confidence, and that is not the only thing we share in this difficult period.

Here and across the Atlantic, we are very aware that we are suffering not only from a sharp growth crisis but also from a crisis of the growth model. This is evidenced by the disproportionate development we have experienced in the construction sector, with the consequent indebtedness, which is no less disturbing, of the private sector.

Since the year 2000, housing prices in Spain and the United States have doubled. In our country, the real estate bubble reached even greater proportions, incorporating an extraordinary increase in new housing. If in 2007 more than 1,300,000 homes were started in the United States, in Spain, with one-seventh of the population, there were more than 600,000.

Precisely the strong adjustment in the construction sector explains, to a large extent, the significant job destruction experienced by both countries: in the United States in the last year, 4 percent; in Spain, 6 percent.

Moreover, this real estate boom has absorbed a significant amount of financial resources that could not be allocated to other productive activities. The mortgage debt of households in Spain has reached, as a result of this process, 90 percent of their gross disposable income; in the United States, it has reached 95 percent.

And the drain of resources from abroad has also been very considerable: in the United States, the current account deficit has exceeded 6 percent of GDP, while in Spain it climbed to 10 percent, although, fortunately, it is decelerating very significantly.

In the face of a global crisis like the one we are experiencing, the major economies of the world have acted together within the framework of the G-20, first, to stabilize the international financial system; then, to implement fiscal stimulus plans to halt the decline in investment and employment, and also to lay the foundations for a new governance of the global economy that incorporates elements of control, supervision, and early warning to try to prevent the repetition of crises like the one we are currently enduring.

Regarding fiscal stimulus measures, and according to estimates from the International Monetary Fund, in the United States this stimulus has represented 1.1 percent of its Gross Domestic Product during 2008 and will account for 2 percent in 2009; in Spain, 1.9 percent and 2.3 percent, respectively.

In the area of measures to support the financial sector, the United States has committed 81 percent of its GDP to sustain intermediation in the markets and the activity of credit institutions. The Spanish state, with a financial system that has weathered the severe storm well, has only needed to provide support of less than 22 percent of its Gross Domestic Product.

The result of these financial support measures and fiscal stimulus has already begun to be seen, first, with clear signs of stabilization of activity starting in the second quarter of this year and now, with other more incipient signs of recovery that should be confirmed in the coming months.

There is a certain recovery of global trade, an improvement in the confidence of various economic agents, and a more favorable evolution of different financial indicators, but we must continue to be very cautious when making any predictions. Neither economic recovery is assured, nor is its speed, especially if we think about the speed necessary to create jobs.

We do not have that certainty yet. It is even possible that for a few months the data confirming the recovery of the economy, the recovery of growth, may coexist with stagnation in job creation, or, if you will, with slower growth in job creation.

Therefore, we do not have certainty about when we can say "It's done!" We do not have that certainty either in Spain or in the rest of the major economies, but we do have another. We do have another certainty: that the definitive solution for the future does not lie in a mechanical return to the past, in the application of the recipes that have led us to the crisis that has us all in its grip. It is the certainty that we cannot act as if nothing has happened here, as if it were a small storm without consequences; it is the certainty that it is up to the administrations to simultaneously fight against the most harmful effects of the crisis and lay the foundations for a new growth model; a task in which, moreover, success will only come through a deep complicity between governments, economic agents, companies, and workers.

This task is none other than to continue promoting reforms that place our economies in a framework of sustainable growth, which is tantamount to being competitive and innovative in an increasingly globalized context.

Bridging again the distances in terms of volume and development of our two economies, I believe that the perspective projected on this horizon in the United States and in Spain can be, to a large extent, a shared perspective.

Allow me to briefly remind you what we are doing, the Government of Spain.

The perception of the need to change the foundations of our growth model dates back to the very moment we came to power in Spain in 2004. Since then, the volume of resources dedicated to education in Spain has doubled; investment in Research, Development, and Innovation has nearly tripled; investment in the Information Society has more than tripled, with excellent results, and 6.3 billion euros have been allocated to promote renewable energies. This, to give just a few examples related to the vectors of the sustainable economy.

Thanks to this effort, which is a collective effort of all Spanish society, we are now in a position to conceive and take a new leap in the modernization of our country; precisely the leap required to overcome this crisis.

This reformist push, which has been projected in other areas, such as the progressive reduction of administrative burdens or the reforms initiated in sectors such as energy or telecommunications, has been accentuated over the last year.

Thus, within the framework of the Spanish Plan for the Stimulus of the Economy and Employment, which we have called Plan E, modernization plans have been adopted for sectors as relevant to our economy as tourism or automotive. In the latter case, avoiding the permanent destruction of a very competitive productive fabric and preparing it for a recovery based on the production of more ecological and innovative vehicles.

Reforms have also been undertaken to improve competition in ports, which will result in a reduction of logistical costs, and an ambitious package of reforms has been presented to reduce bureaucratic obstacles in the services sector, including retail trade.

Another key measure this year has been the solution to the problem of the electricity tariff deficit, which guarantees a stable framework for investment in the energy sector, and a rationalization of the renewable energy subsidy system to ensure its financial development.

The Sustainable Economy Law, whose draft will be presented in the coming weeks, will consolidate and promote this reformist process in three areas:

As you know, in service of the objectives of the Law, there will be two Funds to promote the financing of investments: one, managed by the Official Credit Institute, with the participation of the financial system, which will make twenty billion euros available to private initiative; and another, to promote public investment, endowed with five billion euros and managed by local entities, as new actors in the participation of that modernization and technological innovation process.

Furthermore, the new Law will be supported by the basic decisions of the 2010 Budgets, as could not be otherwise, such as maintaining substantially, and despite the crisis, productive investment and social protection spending; and preserving the sustainability of public accounts within the framework of the Stability Pact and following the indications of the European Commission, through measures of austerity and moderate increases in a tax pressure that will remain clearly well below the European average.

The Government believes that a collective effort is essential to promote the renewal of the productive system. Therefore, we have raised the need to generate a debate and possible agreements around the contents of the Sustainable Economy Law in three scenarios: the parliamentary one, during the processing of the Law; with the Autonomous Communities, within the framework of the Conference of Presidents, and with social interlocutors in the framework of social dialogue.

I would like to briefly refer to this last one.

The Government is aware of the need to adapt the labor market to the needs of a new productive model and the importance of the labor market for attracting foreign investment. In this area, a salary agreement for 2010 is a priority, as the representatives of workers and employers are currently trying to achieve. It is a necessary agreement to support confidence in our economic institutions and halt job destruction. Also, why not say it, it is a necessary agreement to generate confidence and new spaces for dialogue between social interlocutors, a confidence that suffered greatly with the rupture that occurred last July.

Once progress is made in this process, our "roadmap" for improving the labor market involves enriching our collective bargaining system, with a push for so-called internal flexibility of companies, in the organization of working conditions and in the adaptation and allocation of human resources. These reforms in the area of collective bargaining must arise from bipartite negotiations between social interlocutors to achieve a more efficient structure and functioning of the same.

On the other hand, the Government considers it very appropriate for social interlocutors to contribute to reviewing active employment policies, adapting them to new labor demands and promoting the necessary sectoral reassignment of employment.

Therefore, we are firmly committed to a more sustainable economic model, which will be reflected in all areas, including the modernization of the labor market.

As I mentioned, this strong commitment to a more sustainable development model is also shared by the United States. The aim is to increase productivity through greater investment in Information Technologies and transportation infrastructure. Hence, the interest in high-speed trains as a more efficient and lower-emission alternative.

This is a commitment to productivity that takes environmental needs into account, as it also promotes investment in energy efficiency and clean energy, and the promotion of an emissions trading system similar to the European one, which will set national reduction targets.

The strategy for exiting the crisis in the United States also has an important social dimension. Thus, the Obama Administration has increased investment in education, is fighting to ensure the broadest possible and financially sustainable long-term healthcare coverage; and is also encouraging the necessary training of workers in new activities.

It is a shared vision, therefore, regarding some of the strategic elements for exiting the crisis, which should also bear fruit in the business sector of our two countries.

The Spanish Government believes, for its part, that it can contribute to this by strengthening legal security and the effectiveness of its Justice Administration. Spain's position as the seventh largest recipient of foreign direct investment worldwide and the fourth in the European Union, and the fact that this investment has remained stable in 2008 despite the crisis, are a true reflection that we already have an investment protection framework with sufficient guarantees.

But we want to improve it, and there are aspects that can be enhanced, such as those concerning the protection of intellectual property rights. This is a matter of concern to the U.S. Administration and is also a concern for the Spanish Government.

The creative sector represents 4 percent of our country's Gross Domestic Product, making it the fourth largest cultural industry in the world. In this sense, we positively value the dialogue maintained by telecommunications network operators and content creators in seeking a consensual solution that simultaneously respects property rights, an essential issue for the future of any economy, and promotes the development of the Information and Knowledge Society. On the other hand, the Council of Ministers has recently approved the creation of a Commission that must present a satisfactory proposal on this matter before the end of the year.

Another element that could help boost investment between both countries would be the updating of existing tax mechanisms to eliminate double taxation. In this regard, within the framework of bilateral relations between both States, and sensitive to the interest shown by companies from both countries, I want to highlight the Spanish Administration's willingness to initiate the process of reviewing the current Agreement, which dates back to 1990.

Well, to advance on these and other issues, we have agreed with the Obama Administration to study the creation of a large bilateral investment and economic collaboration forum where representatives of both Governments, the main American companies investing in Spain, and the main Spanish companies investing in the United States will be present. We are already working on defining this framework for meeting and enhanced cooperation, and I take this opportunity to request the collaboration of both the American Business Council and the American Chamber of Commerce in Spain in the form of proposals to which we will give the utmost consideration.

Among the sectors that will receive preferential attention from the Forum will be those with the greatest potential for development in both countries: renewable energies, energy efficiency, transportation, Information and Communication Technologies, the aerospace sector, biotechnology, and health sciences.

The goal, which gives meaning to the initiative I am talking about, is to generate a new major investment cycle from the United States in Spain and to consolidate the investment cycle from Spain in the United States, all for the benefit of increasing employment in both countries.

The Spanish and U.S. Administrations are willing to make every effort to ensure this happens, but our success will ultimately depend on our ability to count on your support and initiative, that of American and Spanish entrepreneurs.

I conclude, ladies and gentlemen,

Economic crises are always untimely, but they also generate opportunities, and we must seize them.

For Governments, the opportunity now lies in increasing the speed and depth of reforms, to open new spaces for investment and job creation for economic agents from the public powers.

And for them, for you, the opportunity lies in knowing how to fill these spaces by investing; investing in a timely manner, with vision, with audacity, anticipating the future, a future that will be one of well-being, that will be of greater well-being for all, if both sides, here and there, manage to do what is required of us. For this reason, events like today make perfect sense.

Thank you very much.

DIALOGUE WITH THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT

------------------------------------------------------------------

Q.- The truth is that some of the questions have been quite answered, but they are somewhat linked to the conclusions of our Summit. The first is: do you consider that the Government is doing enough to promote entrepreneurship and business initiative in our civil society?

President.- I will refer to the main actions and policy lines that we have been implementing in various areas, and that we are currently fulfilling, and those that we have planned in favor of an entrepreneurial spirit, in favor of business.

First, I would highlight the broad modification of the regulatory framework to reduce administrative burdens; I say this because it will be a very profound change. You know that it is the adaptation of the Services Directive and you know that in this the Administration plays a fundamental role, that we have parliamentary processing; but it will be a profound change. This is a country that has been building a system of excessive administrative burdens for business activity.

Second, we have made a great effort to support businesses, especially small and medium-sized enterprises, in the face of the financial crisis, in the face of the serious credit problems that practically all companies have experienced. This effort has materialized with an unprecedented allocation in the Official Credit Institute in our country, which has responded to and supported more than two hundred thousand companies and which for this year 2009 has a disbursement volume of more than forty billion euros.

We know that the ICO lines have traditionally functioned with business backing, with business satisfaction; we also know that in this crisis situation there are opinions and voices that would wish for greater access, greater ease, to the lines of the Official Credit Institute, and we know, you all know, that it is through the financial system that the Government channels public resources via ICO to facilitate credit. But for the first time, we have managed to facilitate credit lines for what is known as working capital.

Thirdly, business support. We are the first Government in democracy to lower the Corporate Tax by five points, both for large companies and for SMEs, to logically facilitate the entrepreneurial spirit and business investment. I must emphasize that at this moment the Budget Bill also includes a provision for a five-point reduction in the Corporate Tax for those SMEs that maintain or create jobs.

Finally, perhaps the most important commitment that the Government has made in favor of the entrepreneurial spirit, which is the most structural, the most decisive, and also the most long-term, is the significant increase in investment in Research, Development, and Innovation. We have tripled public resources for R&D&I in just five years, and today we have already positioned ourselves with public spending on R&D&I slightly above the European average; not in private spending on R&D&I.

A good part of that increase in resources for R&D&I has been made with a philosophy of public-private collaboration, with the Ingenio 2010 Program, which is yielding great results and in which a very significant number of Spanish companies participate, undoubtedly facilitating the best entrepreneurial spirit, which is the spirit that has the support to create, to innovate, and to have an advanced commitment from the perspective of competitiveness.

Is there still ground to favor business activity, the entrepreneurial spirit? Without a doubt, there is a key area in which the Government is very committed, which I consider fundamental to favoring economic activity, which is the modernization of Justice.

Surely, all of us here remember that there has not been a Government in democracy that has not made a proclamation or a commitment, and has presented a plan for the modernization of Justice. However, it remains a public service that requires intense change, that is not up to the demands of Spanish society, of a modern society, also economically.

We have a very firm commitment to the modernization of Justice. It will favor the entrepreneurial spirit, the business spirit.

Finally, and this is no longer a matter of measures, but rather a matter of social culture, of civic culture, we must stimulate in the educational field, at all levels of the educational system, of course in the University, that spirit to undertake. If you allow me, we must also teach how to undertake. This is not part of a deep tradition in our country, no; this is part of a culture that, fortunately, has been expanding, has been spreading, but still has much ground to cover. For example, the lack of social censorship or criticism against the failure of a business project, because business successes almost always have a previous stage of attempts and failures. I believe this is a matter, I insist, more of social consideration, but it is also worth reiterating and repeating from the public powers.

Q.- The second question, President, I think you have already touched on a bit, right?, and it is linked to what you started to touch on earlier. What are the only priorities that an educational system should have to prepare our youth for their future integration into a more globalized professional world? What is your personal opinion?

President.- This is a central issue, especially from the perspective of reducing our unemployment rates. Unemployment is the main concern of Spanish society and the Government, and we maintain a constant since the democratic transition, which is to have unemployment rates substantially higher than the European average.

Perhaps we should reflect on what moment we have the educational system, where we come from, and what our country, beyond Governments, has done in the last thirty years, which I believe is the period that should be taken as a reference.

I would like to remind you that we come from a country, comparatively in access to education, very far or at a very notable distance from the main European countries, which are now our reference. We all know what the causes are; the causes were, logically, our isolation under the previous regime and a notable delay in educational matters.

I believe that democracy has achieved a great objective and still has another objective to achieve in educational matters. The great objective is that it has undoubtedly been the best lever for equal opportunities and social mobility that Spanish society has had in the last thirty years. The commitment to the extension of education, the commitment to the free provision of education, the obligation until the age of sixteen, access to the University, and the extension of a number of Universities present in all provinces has placed us among the most equitable educational systems in the world.

We always emphasize the critical part of our educational system, but we have a very equitable educational system, and I draw attention to the value that this has. It has great value for social cohesion, it has great value for equal opportunities, and it has great value for social mobility, which has historically also cost our country.

What is the second objective that Spanish education needs and that I say has been achieved only partially? To progress with as much intensity in the area of equal opportunities as in the area of qualitative extension, as we could call it. What do I mean? I mean, fundamentally, three aspects, three specific points: first, that there is a higher percentage, by ten to fifteen points, that brings us closer to the European average, of young people who have and hold a higher education than compulsory education.

The paradoxes occurring in economic evolution have made our significant economic growth and our substantial job creation a focal point for many young people entering the labor market without having completed or remained in the educational system beyond compulsory education. This is the first major challenge we face.

There has been an agreement between the Government and the Autonomous Communities to reduce school dropout rates, and at this moment, there are already moderately positive data regarding the evolution, slightly positive, of a reduction and, therefore, a perspective of gradually reaching, although it will be difficult, the percentages of young people who have training beyond compulsory education.

Second, we need to reform and socially value Vocational Training. This is underway with new qualifications and a vision much more adapted to the changes occurring in the market. But it is not only about making regulatory reforms and providing investment; it is about socially valuing Vocational Training, which in this country has not received sufficient recognition from society as a whole.

And the third factor that seems fundamental to me in education. I previously mentioned that the expansion of universities throughout the country has been a great lever for equal opportunities and social cohesion, but we need a core, a sufficient number of large universities from the perspective of their qualifications and from the perspective of their research and technological potential.

There we need to recover lost time. We need to see some Spanish university among the top one hundred in the world. This is fundamental. And the great circumstance is that we are indeed in scientific and research potential within the ranking that corresponds to us. We are the ninth scientific power in the world; however, our universities are not within the group where they should be. This is a great collective driver for companies, for society, and for the economy, promoting research and fostering the technological transfer from universities to businesses, which has been another of the great challenges.

Consequently, those are the three points we need to work on. If we could do this with a great national pact on Education, which would give us regulatory stability in the educational field, which Minister Gabilondo is committed to, dialoguing especially with the main opposition party, I believe we could tackle those three major needs with greater possibilities.

Q.- There is a question that is very much in line with what you also started to touch on. There is talk of changing the productive model, but what can be done, specifically, to translate our science and research into improving our productivity? How can what is done in universities be applied?

President.- I believe this is a central issue. The first thing we need to say is that we must try to ensure that our universities produce more scientific output thinking about businesses and thinking about the sectors that are clearly the future, the most innovative sectors; and that this greater scientific output, greater research output, can be transferred to businesses. How? We need to make businesses more present in universities and universities more present in businesses; we need to continue increasing the Torres Quevedo Program of "Doctors in Companies," which has increased significantly, and we need to continue in the public-private collaboration of large business projects where universities are involved, and universities must participate in the management, in the large national management, of what the technological transfer process is.

To the extent that we have some universities that act with that leadership, and there is a plan from the Ministry, from Minister Gabilondo, to position fifteen universities in excellence, we will undoubtedly achieve that this has a much more direct impact on businesses. And we must also urge the Spanish business sector, because there is a large part that is, to a part of the Spanish business sector to be more in contact with universities and to have more stimulus, more interest, and more plans to incorporate innovation than we have had so far.

For example, there has been a great change, a transcendental change, in the incorporation of ICT into businesses, another of the determining factors. It is evident that, fortunately, we have overcome that subject because today the data on the Information Society in businesses and households in Spain is very reasonable.

Well, that has also been costly for a part of SMEs and for a part of businesses. There has been a great public stimulus, which is the Avanza Plan, and, of course, we need to fine-tune and provide all the necessary instruments for that rebirth, that impulse, of more concern and more support for research and for the technological transfer from universities to businesses.

Q.- A somewhat more complicated question. Earlier we talked about social stability, which you recognized in your speech as vital. There are some companies that we have managed to achieve this, but can you tell us something about how the social dialogue process is going and what perspectives can be expected from it? Or is it not the right time?

President.- Yes, it is the right time. I will make a very brief initial consideration in response to the question. I have great confidence in social dialogue. In the last Legislature, we signed twenty agreements with employers and unions on very different matters: in labor health, in incentives for stable employment, for self-employed workers, with the Statute of the Self-Employed, the entire immigration regulation process… A broad chapter, up to twenty agreements. It is part of the DNA of our Government to bet on social dialogue.

I believe that both employers and unions know very well that in our government action in the labor and business field, all decisions have had a phase of consultation and, as far as possible, of accompaniment and cooperation.

Until July, we had a dialogue that aimed to create a global agreement that incorporated objectives of all kinds, fundamentally incentives for businesses, aid, in a word, to businesses and entrepreneurs, and also guarantees, stability, and protection for workers. That agreement was not possible. It was not possible to reach a large agreement that encompassed all the major issues because the CEOE put on the table a topic of entering at that moment into a labor reform, into the study of labor reform in depth, which the unions did not consider appropriate or convenient.

Now there is a two-sided social dialogue, which the Government supports, stimulates, and desires, for income agreements, salary agreements. My wish would be for it to be an agreement that covered more than a year; that would be a great factor of confidence and stability and, from there, to be able to talk about collective bargaining and active employment policies, because we need to review them. I include bonuses and all the policies and resources that are being allocated to active employment policies.

When I ask employers how this phase is going, they tell me reasonably well; when I ask unions, they tell me it is regular. We will wait a certain time and, of course, the Government would put on the table everything necessary for that agreement to happen.

We have made an agreement with public employees for three years, very reasonable, of wage restraint in the most difficult year, which will be 2010, and of reasonable maintenance of purchasing power depending on the circumstances. That could be an interesting reference for the CEOE, UGT, and CCOO to reach an agreement.

In my time as President of the Government, I have had the collaboration of both organizations, from the business side and the union side; that is the truth. They have a high degree of responsibility. It is also true that it is understandable that in such a severe economic crisis, in a recession we have not experienced in sixty years, there are more difficulties in reaching agreements.

In any case, I believe that social stability, the social peace with which we are going through such a severe crisis, is a great collective asset. It is a capital of the country that we must preserve because, without a doubt, it allows us to… Sooner or later, there will surely be an impetus from social dialogue, which will decisively help economic recovery.

Q.- And the last question we have here, Mr. President, is linked to what we talked about regarding corporate social responsibility in the area of the environment with climate change. I imagine that in your meeting with President Obama and looking ahead to the European Presidency, something has been discussed, and soon there will be the meeting in November in Copenhagen. Can you anticipate, specifically, what initiatives your Government plans to take regarding climate change?

President.- Two things about climate change and the Copenhagen Summit. First, in the Government's view, an agreement in Copenhagen is fundamental. If the world does not face climate change with the necessary degree of responsibility and, therefore, the progressive change of the energy model, we will have a horizon of great difficulties. This must be stated clearly, not only because of the impact of climate change but also because today we need to make transformations in our energy model.

In this specific matter, we can say, fortunately, that there is a European position and that there will be a European position in Copenhagen. We have agreed: 20-20-20. Europe will carry a common position for financing countries that have more problems in reducing emissions, and in this we are fully in tune with the entire European Union. Moreover, as is known, the European Union would be willing to go beyond that 20-20-20 if other countries, such as the United States and emerging countries, make real commitments.

If you ask me what the prospects are for Copenhagen, the task is very difficult to reach a large agreement; it is difficult. As is understandable, there are many reasonable interests, a good part of them, at stake, and we hope that at least a sufficient political agreement will be reached to face a minimum reduction of emissions and also to stimulate what is intended and must be that change of energy model that, of course, we in Spain are going to promote with two basic instruments: the Sustainable Economy Law, the Energy Efficiency Law, and, of course, support for renewable energies. It is a great transformation, but it is a great source of innovative future.

The two sectors that will surely mark in the coming decades the greatest capacity to create innovative wealth and to be more productive are those linked to everything we can say about the chapter of savings, energy efficiency, and energy changes. As has always happened in economic history, the great cycles and major economic changes have occurred, to a large extent, due to major changes in energy models.

And, secondly, the other great source, the other great area, that will mark the difference between countries and between continents is everything related to health sciences and biotechnology.

Countries and societies that decisively bet on these two great engines of change and productive modernization will have a horizon of wealth creation and well-being; just as the countries that at the beginning of the 1990s decisively bet on the innovation of ICT, Communication Technologies, have largely set the economic pace of the last two decades, as we have known, until this crisis.

But the lever, the way out of the crisis, those who will be the first to set off in the race for the next decades until another economic cycle will be the countries that do their job best in the field of energy change and health sciences. And we must try, as a country, to be in a good starting position for these two major issues.

Q.- Thank you very much for joining us at the closing of our Conference, of our Summit. Thank you very much, Mr. President.