Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

15 February 2011 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions from Joan Ridao about limiting autonomous communities' spending and Catalonia's fiscal deficit during a February 2011 control session.
Main themes
Autonomous communities financing, fiscal deficit reduction, Catalonia fiscal balance, inter-territorial solidarity, public spending limits, economic crisis, infrastructure investment commitments, debt capacity of regions, state financial obligations, fiscal federalism
Duration
~15 min
53rd percentile
Words
1,847
53rd percentile
Sentences
63
41st percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
13.7
64th percentile
Syntax
3.31
83rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 78%71%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Institutional 9%8%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

63 sentences in 29 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joan Ridao, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana-Izquierda Unida-Iniciativa per Catalunya Verds

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Ridao.- Does the Government intend to limit the spending capacity of the Autonomous Communities and, consequently, limit their contribution to inter-territorial solidarity as an element to eliminate the negative fiscal balance?

President.- Mr. Ridao, the Government adheres to the model agreed upon in the financing system and approved by this Chamber. It is a system that has provided additional resources to all Autonomous Communities and that allows us to respond to the needs of Public Administrations, also to meet the intended objective of reducing the public deficit.

The Government shares this commitment with the Autonomous Communities and assumes the responsibility of guaranteeing it, in accordance with the agreements and plans presented by the Ministry of Economy and Finance, and approved by the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy.

In short, Mr. Ridao, the Government has no intention of modifying the recent system of autonomous financing in any of its aspects, and the Government will ensure, in accordance with current regulations, that all Public Administrations strictly meet the deficit target that corresponds to them.

Mr. Ridao.- It is well known that Catalonia presents a very significant public deficit situation. This has much to do, Mr. President, not only with the dreadful drop in public revenues as a result of the crisis but also with the failure, by the way, to meet the State's financial commitments. For example, regarding investment in infrastructure from the additional provision three of the Statute, it amounts to approximately 2.3 billion since 2007; or from the new financing, there are 1.45 billion from the Competitiveness Fund that is owed to us; or from the laws that are approved here, which you impose on us and that we pay for, such as the Dependency Law: we cover 70 percent of the cost of its implementation.

But it has to do, above all, with that negative fiscal balance, with that serious fiscal deficit, which, according to the Government's own fiscal balance, ranges between ten thousand and fourteen thousand million euros. Catalans pay 22 percent more than the average. By the way, this model ends in 2013.

In this context, Mr. President, your economic vice president suggested the other day that we raise taxes. You said in the company of Mrs. Merkel that perhaps we should limit the spending capacity of the Autonomous Communities, and it is clear that the price of Spain's non-intervention by the European Union is to burden the Autonomous Communities. What you perhaps did not tell Mrs. Merkel is that Catalonia is to Spain what Germany is to Europe; that is, if we sink, everyone sinks; that without a fiscal deficit we would not have to go into debt and that, above all, we are an exhausted locomotive. We are fiscally fatigued. You burn all our coal, 10 percent of our wealth, and on top of that, you demand that the train arrives punctually at the station, that we do not generate a public deficit, and that, furthermore, we do not go into debt.

Look, the other day the President of the Generalitat came to see you at the Palace of La Moncloa to ask for more rope to tie our hands and feet to go into debt, and on top of that, he was accused of privileges, and they did it, hold on, not only to those of the Economic Concert but even to those of the PER.

The question is, Mr. President, are you going to pay what you owe us? Second, is the State also going to go on a diet? And third, are you going to put any brakes on that contribution to inter-territorial solidarity, as, for example, they do in Germany: 4 percent of GDP so that the richest and most efficient do not end up...?

President.- Mr. Ridao, I believe that we had this debate and resolved it when we reformed the autonomous financing model, and moreover with your agreement, because the autonomous financing model that we have and that has been in effect for a short time is being applied and complied with. You cited some examples, such as the Competitiveness Fund, which, according to the current agreed and approved model, will be settled in 2013 and will be settled. And the Additional Provision is being fulfilled, and its compliance is agreed upon with the bodies that the Statute of Autonomy provides for bilaterally.

It happens that we are in a situation of fiscal crisis for all Administrations as a result of the economic crisis, and all must meet their deficit reduction target. That is indeed a solidary attitude. And I say all. Solidarity is from all to all: from Catalonia to the whole, from the whole to Catalonia, and from the State, of course, to all Autonomous Communities. That is the situation.

The Government of the Generalitat has presented a deficit reduction plan that it must comply with so that, just as happens with all Autonomous Communities, debt issuances are authorized. This is how, rigorously, we will recover more fiscal capacity and more financial capacity for all Autonomous Communities, and, of course, also for Catalonia in the financing model agreed upon by all and that we are not going to review every four days due to one circumstance or another.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Parliamentary Group of the Popular Party

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, confidence is a basic factor for the recovery of the economy and the creation of jobs. For there to be confidence, among other things, it is required that the Government acts with clear criteria, that it provides certainty, and that it does not change its mind every day. I fear that this is not the case with your Government.

I will refer to three current issues. First, labor reform. You said at one time that it was not necessary; then, in 2009, you said that it was, but in agreement with the unions and without touching dismissal; you did it without agreement with the unions and touching dismissal, but you did not want to touch collective bargaining and did not accept our proposals, and now it seems that you want to reform collective bargaining.

Regarding Savings Banks, in 2008 you said that Spain had the best financial system in the world and did nothing while everyone else proceeded with the reform and restructuring of it, and in 2010 you yourself said that the reform of the financial system was key to dispelling doubts about Spain's economic solvency. You have brought here five Royal Decree Laws regarding Savings Banks, and now you announce a sixth that has generated great controversy, great confusion, and I hope that you rectify the initial announcements of your Vice President.

In terms of energy, you made a regulation of photovoltaics and premiums without foreseeing the results, which were significant increases in electricity prices and an increase in the tariff deficit. Now you rectify affecting legal certainty and have the courts filled with lawsuits.

Regarding nuclear power, I no longer know where we stand, because you have said one thing, the opposite, and the opposite of one thing and the opposite. What I hope is that today you announce, in light of the latest doctrine, that Garoña will not be closed in 2013.

President.- I sincerely believe, Mr. Rajoy, that what happens is that you understand few things or have understood few things. It is true that I have seen you in this intervention as a chronicler of facts more than as a political leader because it is true that one can change criteria, of course, in politics depending on the circumstances; what is quite unusual is that one never has a criterion. One can change one's opinion, but what is striking is that one does not have an opinion on one thing or another.

You have referred to the financial system. Just like in most developed countries and in Europe, the Government has faced a crisis in the financial system, and we can say today, despite the difficulties, that indeed, our financial system has held up well, unlike what has happened in other European countries where there have been bankruptcies and, as you well know, massive public sector interventions to sustain it. The Government has been taking measures from day one to sustain, support, and strengthen, depending on the circumstances, the importance that the financial system has in our country.

Mr. Rajoy, I must remind you, although you never want to enter that debate because you think it goes well for you, what the International Monetary Fund has said recently. Two things that seem important to me for the debate between us, if it can be calm, of course always polite: first, that the crisis was not foreseen even by the most important international organization in the economic field, which is the IMF; second, that the crisis has had waves and different manifestations: it started as a financial crisis, then it became a crisis of the real economy, and then a debt crisis in some eurozone countries. In the face of each circumstance, a response has been given based on the instruments that a Government has.

That is the reality, but you only want to have a broad-brush debate without ever thinking or talking about the financial system, or the real estate sector, or what has happened in the overall international economy, nor, of course, will you ever talk about --I hope you have read it-- the report from the International Monetary Fund.

Mr. Rajoy.- All of that is very well, Mr. President, but Spain has double the unemployment rate of the European Union, and Spain has double the youth unemployment rate of the European Union, at 42.5 percent.

Mr. President, you, four hundred euros in the IRPF yes and no; "baby check" yes and no; tax cuts were leftist and now you raise taxes; you go from boasting in Rodiezmo to freezing pensions, 426 euros to the unemployed yes and no... You reproached me for freezing civil servants' salaries, said you would never do it, and now you have done it. Mr. President, I previously asked you to make a plan, and now I tell you that you are beyond repair and that you have led Spain to a lamentable situation in economic matters, generating more unemployment than any country in the European Union.

President.- As we will have the opportunity to have a debate on social policy, I refer to it regarding the things you mentioned in the last part of your intervention. Simply, regarding the debate on the economy and the policies that have had to be applied based on the circumstances, I will tell you one thing that serves as a general conclusion of this debate in this question: the economy does not remain still, unlike some political leaders who only know how to remain still and do nothing.

Thank you.