Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

24 May 2011 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions from Convergència i Unió's Duran i Lleida on May 24, 2011, addressing dependency care funding and collective bargaining reform.
Main themes
Dependency Law and care for dependent people, public spending and social spending, welfare state sustainability, employment and collective bargaining, fiscal relations with Autonomous Communities, Catalonia financing disputes, economic recovery, labor reform
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,492
68th percentile
Sentences
83
54th percentile
Readability
40
35th percentile
Grade
14.3
70th percentile
Syntax
3.42
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 56%53%
  • Social 20%19%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 8%7%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

83 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran.- First, I would like to express, on behalf of our Parliamentary Group, our condolences to the family of the former Governor of the Bank of Spain, Luis Ángel Rojo.

This is the first question, Mr. President, that is posed after the municipal elections. Logically, perhaps, I should ask you about what is being debated; whether it is a question of confidence, a motion of censure, or early elections. What concerns this Group, however, is what is going to be done in the coming months and, in this regard, we are particularly concerned about two issues: one, public spending and also social spending, and the other, employment.

In this sense, Mr. President, and linked to social spending and public spending, the exact question is: How does the Government plan to care for more dependent people with less money in 2011 without passing the bill to the Autonomous Communities?

President.- Mr. Duran, I want to join, on behalf of the Government, in expressing condolences to the family of the former Governor of the Bank of Spain, Luis Ángel Rojo, whose memory we all honor.

Regarding the question you have asked me, indeed, we have fundamental challenges ahead to achieve economic recovery and to consolidate the Welfare State and social policies. You specifically refer in your question to the Dependency Law, and I must tell you that so far we have managed to care for 720,000 people; that the total volume of spending this has entailed amounts to 5.35 billion for the entire State, 854 million euros in Catalonia; that the Government has fulfilled its financing commitments and that where there are discrepancies, as there certainly are with the Government of Catalonia, we are, as you well know, working with a group to try to address them.

In any case, without a doubt, to continue maintaining and deepening what the Welfare State and the Dependency Law are, we must continue with the reforms. Some of them are currently in the process of social dialogue and are very important, such as collective bargaining, and I hope we will have fruitful results on this very soon.

Mr. Duran.- Starting from May 11, a new group will be incorporated, Mr. President, that will be the subject of aid under the Dependency Law, as you well know, which is moderate dependency Level-2; specifically, 152,742 people. The Royal Decree Laws, in their explanatory memorandum, consider that this does not incorporate new spending to the extent that they understand, something we do not quite share, that, as before the benefit started from the day it was requested and now from the day the file is resolved, the longer the Administration takes, the more savings there will be.

However, for Convergència i Unió, this saving is not enough to care for these 152,000 plus new people who will be the subject of attention under the Dependency Law. Consequently, it would only be possible if the deficit were once again passed on to the Autonomous Communities, which is what is currently being done, as you have just indirectly acknowledged by saying that there is a conflict and we do not share.

This compels me, Mr. President, to once again urge you to reflect calmly on the Dependency Law. We need to start from scratch to reflect on two basic issues: first, to guarantee sustainable financing without passing it on to the Autonomous Communities, and second, to generate employment. The Dependency Law should have generated greater employment.

And, speaking of employment, Mr. President, I am very interested in the reference you made to collective bargaining because, already, by mandate of the labor reform law, included by amendment from Convergència i Unió, this should already be finalized by the social agents and, if it is not finalized, as is the case, you should face it. In this context, Mr. President, I suggest that you do it as soon as possible, that you include ultra-activity, that you include internal flexibility, that you include the disengagement of companies, that you include salary increases, and that you also include labor absenteeism.

President.- Mr. Duran, I reiterate that the Government has fulfilled its commitments so far and that we are trying to resolve the discrepancies with the Government of Catalonia, which are more related to the financing model than to the count of the number of dependents. Of course, we must make the greatest effort in this Law for its efficiency. It has been fulfilled and has been a great success: since 2006, 700,000 people have been cared for.

Regarding the last part of your question, I will tell you that the reform of collective bargaining is fundamental. Yesterday there was substantial progress in the negotiation between employers and unions, which includes internal flexibility, which includes ultra-activity, which includes wage disengagement, and which also includes labor absenteeism. I am confident that we can have that agreement on the table in a short time and, immediately, the Government will translate it into the appropriate regulatory provision to bring it to this Chamber and complete a fundamental reform to convey confidence and contribute to economic recovery.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joan Ridao, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana-Izquierda Unida-Iniciativa per Catalunya Verds

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Ridao.- Mr. President of the Government, this Sunday while the left took to the squares, the right filled the ballot boxes. I am not going to ask you for an early election, among other things, because we do not wish for the return of the right to power. I have no hurry, nor any anxiety; in any case, what I ask is that one of these days the left returns to the Government, which is a very different thing.

We are also not in a position to support a motion of censure, because it would be relatively easy for all of us to unite against you; but what is almost impossible is for us to support Mr. Rajoy, which greatly narrows the margin, Mr. President. And I want to ask you if you are going to change your policy and, specifically, if you are going to turn to the left.

President.- Mr. Ridao, I do not know if you were going to ask me about mortgages today, but I can answer you regarding a turn around mortgages. The assessments of the electoral result I believe correspond, sincerely, to the respective parties; I can tell you that the assessment I make of the electoral result is one of profound respect and, moreover, a recognition that there has been a wide electoral participation, which, against some discourses, seems very important to me.

Regarding the policy concerning the problems of mortgage payments by citizens facing difficulties, I must tell you two things: first, we must maintain legislation that is balanced between the solvency of financial entities, the possibilities of obtaining a mortgage, and the difficulties that citizens encounter in being able to pay a mortgage.

However, I must remind you that the delinquency rate for mortgage payments in Spain is 2.6 percent, only in free housing, and below 1 percent in protected housing.

In any case, and we have discussed this on more than one occasion, there is a circumstance that we are trying to address and that is why a subcommittee has been approved in the Congress of Deputies, which I hope will be set in motion as soon as possible so that we can see measures that should focus more on protection and on the possibilities that exist in our legal framework to support people who have difficulties, beyond what we have already done.

Mr. Ridao.- Mr. President, I was not asking about mortgages. What I was asking, specifically, last week and today is whether this Government plans to change its policy, because certainly this Government has faced the worst crisis since 1929 that has wiped out up to twelve Governments in Europe in the last two years, because the first one to turn the other cheek is the first one to receive the slap. But as true as that is, it is also true that your economic policy has consisted of satisfying the markets, saving the banks without any kind of compensation, and embarking on a frantic race to reduce the deficit and, therefore, undertaking an anti-social economic policy.

The movement of the "Indignados," and do not see any opportunism in it because, evidently, they do not feel represented by any party, expresses that concern. They are not people who are against the system; they think the system is against them, and this has a lot to do with your economic policy.

Therefore, the question, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that I ask you specifically is whether you plan to recover your minimum social-democratic program with which you presented yourself for election or continue sweeping the house to the right; that is, whether you plan to prioritize the trust of citizens or that of the markets. For example, by making effective the dación in payment of mortgages, tightening the screws on banks to ensure credit flows, betting on a secular state, deepening historical memory, and also on transparency and democratic regeneration.

That is what I ask you if you are going to change or not, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero.

President.- Mr. Ridao, I have expressed it in the Chamber on many occasions: the fundamental objective of the Government in the face of the most serious economic crisis we have experienced in decades is to achieve recovery and maintain the financial stability of Spain, which is an indispensable condition for our recovery and for the central objective, which is to create jobs again. I do not know if it is a turn or not; but what we are going to do is with all responsibility and putting the interests of Spain above any other, as I have said on more than one occasion.

Thank you very much.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, good morning. I ask you about what I think is the most important problem facing Spain today: youth unemployment. The latest data from the European Union says: March 2004, Spain, 24.6 percent; today it is already 45.39 percent; the European Union, 20.7 percent and the eurozone, 19.8 percent; that is, we have double the youth unemployment of the European Union. 28 percent of the unemployed under twenty-five years in the eurozone are Spanish, and since March 2008, 60.8 percent of the new unemployed under twenty-five years in the eurozone are also Spanish.

The question, Mr. President of the Government, is: how do you assess that Spain has the highest youth unemployment rate in all of Europe?

President.- Naturally, I assess it negatively, very negatively. Undoubtedly, the most important social problem we have is unemployment and, of course, within unemployment, youth unemployment and also the unemployment of older people who have many difficulties in finding employment again.

We are all aware that this high unemployment rate is the result of a serious economic and social crisis. Therefore, with concern and with responsibility. With responsibility because we know very well that we will only create jobs if economic activity recovers and that to recover economic activity, reforms and the containment of public spending are essential, and, in addition, to implement policies that affect employability and the incentive for hiring. Regarding employability, all the policies we are implementing in the educational field are fundamental, and regarding hiring, we have launched many measures to incentivize the hiring of young people, and I hope we can continue doing so.

Therefore, concern, responsibility, measures, recovery, and stability of the economy.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, when you came to power, the youth unemployment rate was half of what it is today, and during your time it has doubled. It was five points above the European average, and now it is twenty-four points above. I asked you about this issue, for the last time, because I had already done so before throughout the Legislature, on January 26, that is, four months will be completed tomorrow, and then the rate was 43.60 percent and now it has risen to 45.39 percent.

You told me that you had implemented a series of measures, and you cited the labor reform and the modification of incentive and bonus programs for employment and training, and then you said that this was a structural problem that you were going to solve. Today you have told me practically the same thing, and the truth is that every time I ask you about this issue, instead of getting better, everyone—the Chamber, you and I, and everyone—notes that things are getting worse.

We have presented here a youth employment plan that encompasses various aspects, and you have voted against it. But the main problem, Mr. President of the Government, is no longer whether you vote for or against the proposals made by the opposition; the main problem is that there is something that is key to the economy and is decisive for investment to occur, and therefore for jobs and wealth to be generated, and that something is called confidence. Your Government inspires neither confidence, neither within nor outside of Spain, and it is no longer possible for it to recover that confidence.

Therefore, I want to tell you that the main problem in addressing youth employment and many other issues in the Spanish economy is the distrust that your Government generates among the general public and economic and social agents. And you must think about this in the general interest of the Spanish people.

President.- Of course, confidence is a generic, indeterminate concept that applies to any circumstance because, when Spain reached the lowest unemployment rate in history, it was with this Government, which I do not know if generated a different kind of confidence than it can now, or rather that the circumstances were radically different because there was a period of international economic prosperity and now we have experienced the most severe economic crisis in the last eighty years. Confidence has not changed; the circumstances have changed. That seems objective, given that it was us who brought the unemployment rate to the lowest in the history of Spain in 2007.

Beyond that, I completely agree that economic agents need confidence to hire. That confidence implies economic stability, reform of the financial system to ensure credit, and improvement of the labor framework. We have acted on all fronts, and we have acted by making difficult decisions and with responsibility. They will yield results, in the short and medium term, although the task is immense.

That is the conviction and confidence we have about the future of what we are doing.

Thank you very much.