Responses of the President of the Government in the Senate during the parliamentary control session.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

15 November 2005 · Parliamentary control session in the Senate · Senate, Spain

Context
Zapatero responded to Senate questions on Canary Islands maritime territorial rights and Spain's R&D investment during a parliamentary control session on 15 November 2005.
Main themes
Canary Islands territorial waters and archipelagic status, Statute of Autonomy reform, International Law of the Sea, regional autonomy and competences, R&D investment in Spain, science funding vs. Church subsidies, Spain's innovation gap, university-business connectivity, Lisbon Strategy targets, parliamentary oversight
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,060
86th percentile
Sentences
125
73rd percentile
Readability
36
28th percentile
Grade
15.7
81st percentile
Syntax
3.58
96th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
32nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 39%38%
  • Institutional 25%25%
  • Economic 22%22%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

125 sentences in 63 paragraphs

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. JOSÉ CABRERA MENDOZA, OF THE CANARY COALITION PARLIAMENTARY GROUP

---------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Mendoza.- I ask you, Mr. President of the Government, what is the Government's position regarding the consideration of maritime and air spaces as part of the territory of the Autonomous Community of the Canary Islands, with the aim of exercising competence over them.

President.- Mr. Mendoza, first of all, I want to point out that the geographical condition of the Canary Islands and the various characteristics that derive from that condition undoubtedly constitute a determining element of their own identity. Therefore, the Government gives special consideration to the legal-political reality of the maritime and air space of the Canary archipelago.

That said, having established this affirmation of special consideration in the legal-political sphere that we are willing to address, I want to make it clear that, as Your Honor perfectly understands, this reality shapes the Canary Islands as a state archipelago, of our Spanish state, and that, therefore, due to these geographical, cultural, legal, and political characteristics, it does not fit into any other archipelagic consideration.

Mr. Mendoza.- Thank you very much, Mr. President. Thank you also because your Parliamentary Group yesterday, in a motion as a consequence of the State of the Autonomies Debate, supported for the first time the recognition of the waters surrounding the islands as part of the territory of the archipelago.

I must tell you that this is the first time in the history of the Canary Islands that the waters are recognized as part of the archipelagic territory, just as we Canary deputies intended in the reform of the Statute of Autonomy.

I understand that there are hesitations to continue advancing, but just as it has taken us many years to recognize that the waters between the islands are part of our territory, we will continue to insist that the Montego Bay Agreement, while explicitly recognizing a series of rights for state archipelagos, does not expressly deny them for state archipelagos, and therefore, we will continue to insist on our argument. In any case, I sincerely acknowledge that at this moment there is progress being made regarding the recognition of the Canary Islands as an archipelago and not as seven territories that seem to depend on who knows where.

President.- Mr. Mendoza, I want to thank you for your position, with the understanding that we are, as Your Honor knows, in a process of reforming the Statute of the Canary Islands, the final details of which before the phase that requires debate and approval, according to the Regulations, in the Congress and in the Senate are still to be developed.

I can assure you, as I stated before, that the Government has an open consideration towards the importance that all the singularity regarding its configuration as an archipelago logically has for the Canary Islands as an Autonomous Community, within what seems quite logical, evident, and responds to a basic principle of what the waters represent, sovereignty over them, International Law of the Sea… All of this is compatible with the Autonomous Community being able to extend its capacity for the benefit of the use of those waters, the progress of the land, and therefore, the benefit of all Canarians. I believe that in the Statute we will find an adequate formula.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION FROM MR. CARLES BONET I REVÉS, OF THE CATALAN PROGRESS ENTESA PARLIAMENTARY GROUP

---------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Bonet.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, I must acknowledge that in light of the episcopal and ecumenical manifestation on Saturday, I was tempted to change my question. The dilemma was: science or religion. I opted for science, I believe illuminated by the Holy Spirit, because it needs it more than religion.

In the Europe of the Fifteen, we are leading, and prominently, in subsidies to the Church; on the other hand, we are at the bottom in resources for science. Thus, we continue to be the spiritual reserve of the West, but only the spiritual, as always.

Mr. President, you know that in relation to the Europe of the Fifteen we have low investment in R&D, especially because we have very low business participation in patents, projects, investment, and research personnel in companies. Perhaps all of this is the result of the lack of connection, of connectivity, between the university sector and the economic sectors.

Thus, private and business investment in Spain barely exceeds 48 percent, in the European Union of the Fifteen it is at 55 percent, and Lisbon states 66 percent. We have an 8 percent share of the European GDP; on the other hand, we only have 1 percent in patents. This means that we have a considerable gap. And we have a significant number of researchers in the public sector, but the impact of their activities on the economic environment is minimal.

We believe that there are programs, but they mainly affect large corporations, such as the Ingenio program, and there are guidelines from the European Union that state that small and medium-sized enterprises must be more engaged. We need to effectively link small and medium-sized enterprises to research institutes and universities.

And you also said in the Debate on the Autonomies that there should be great collaboration between the State and the Autonomous Communities. Well, as of today, collaboration is scarce. There is a Science Law from 1985, and there is a Research and Development Plan that states that this collaboration must exist. The truth is that so far this interconnection is limited.

Why has the Ingenio Program, for example, not been coordinated or consulted with the Autonomous Communities? Why is there no formal proposal to decentralize the Superior Council for Scientific Research and the bodies for promoting and financing research and large facilities? There are still centralist inertia that seem to hinder it, and I assure you that no one can pretend to create fiefdoms in this matter, but neither will centralism solve anything.

Therefore, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, I would ask what measures you have to address this deficit compared to Europe.

President.- I want to thank Mr. Bonet for the question to inform him that, as you well know, and the Government has expressed on many occasions, Spain has the fundamental challenge for its economic progress and development to overcome the delay we have in Research, Development, and Innovation, in relation to the European average.

We need to considerably increase the percentage of investment over GDP, both from the public sector and from private business participation. To this end, I want to inform you of what the Government has done, the commitments it has made, and the objectives it has set in time to fulfill and overcome that situation.

We have, above all, the following problems: there is insufficient critical mass, there is weak private dimension, there is deficient collaboration between the public and private sectors, and there is significant delay in the Information Society. To address this, we have designed and launched the Ingenio 2010 Program, which is included within the National Reform Program for the Lisbon Strategy. We have made a notable effort to coordinate to correct territorial imbalances, avoid resource dispersion, and make investment more effective.

Specifically, I must tell you, regarding your concern about the Government-Autonomous Communities coordination on the map of our research infrastructures, two issues: first, that, aware of that need for coordination and joint work between the Central Government and the Autonomous Communities, the next Conference of Presidents, at the initiative of the Government, will be dedicated to Research, Development, and Innovation, fundamentally with the aim of uniting efforts, reviewing the internal territorial imbalance that Spain has, and increasing what is the coordination, not only of the Government with the Autonomous Communities, which is decisive, but also of the Autonomous Communities among themselves, because there are many lines of action and research that are being produced.

I want to remind you what the objectives of the Ingenio 2010 Program are: to double the percentage of investment in Research and Development over Gross Domestic Product, going from the current 1.05 percent to 2 percent in 2010; to increase the contribution of the private sector from 48 percent in 2003 to 55 percent in 2010, and to reach the European average of the Fifteen, in percentage of Gross Domestic Product allocated to Information and Communication Technologies, going from 4.8 percent in 2004 to 7 percent in 2010.

The Government is confident that this year, 2005, will end with significant progress in our country regarding the Knowledge Society and with the boost to the new technologies that we have been developing since day one.

In short, more resources, more collaboration, and a strong commitment to place Spain in the technological position it deserves.

I must say that the budgetary effort that this Government is making is unprecedented in the field of Research, Development, and Innovation. In budgetary terms, it translates into a more than notable increase in resources allocated to Research, Development, and Innovation, in the civil sphere of a 27 percent increase in 2005 and a 30.9 percent increase for the 2006 Budget. Excluding soft loans, the civil R&D Budget will grow by 27.6 percent in 2006, the highest figure on record. I must say that these are not opinions. Many other things are opinions; these are data, facts, and figures that are in the Budgets and are perfectly verifiable.

But I want to say that it is not only about resources, even though that is very important; it is also about focusing actions on those strategic points that allow for a significant leap, orienting towards programs of large groups and networks, addressing preferred lines of research, and financing long-term and far-reaching projects. To this end, the most significant actions will be the following:

- The national strategic research consortia that will stimulate public-private collaboration and that will soon begin to materialize, as will be publicly known.

- A fund of funds that will invest in venture capital funds that bet on technology companies, which is one of the major gaps in our system regarding Research, the lack of venture capital, as happens in those countries that have made extraordinary progress in the development of their science and research system.

- And a strategic fund for scientific and technological infrastructures.

All of this in addition to other measures to increase the critical mass of researchers in the country, such as the incorporation of nine hundred new researchers in the next three years within the program known as I3. A significant effort of convergence is also being addressed, as I mentioned earlier, in the Information Society through the Avanza Plan.

In short, in a few months, decisive advances have been made in the R&D&I strategy of our country, and I believe that this is, without a doubt, the great collective effort that Spain has ahead. Therefore, I can assure you that the Government's policy will be one of coordination and commitment with the Autonomous Communities, of support for Universities, for researchers, whom we have recently recognized with a new status and a professional career, and, of course, for all those private sectors that are decisive for the promotion, for the boost, and for Spain to also be in a position of leadership in Europe and in the world.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. PÍO GARCÍA-ESCUDERO, OF THE POPULAR PARLIAMENTARY GROUP

---------------------------------------------------------

Mr. García-Escudero.- What is the President of the Government's assessment of the demonstration that took place last Saturday against the Organic Law of Education?

President.- The Government's assessment is one of respect for what the exercise of the right to demonstrate and the right to freedom of expression means in a democratic society. Of respect and something more: of respect and sensitivity because, as Your Honor well knows, I have called a meeting with the organizations that convened that demonstration, which I will hold tomorrow, to listen and to explain what the Government's educational policy is, and what is, from our perspective, the content of the Organic Law of Education. I believe that this is the way of governing to which I committed and I try to fulfill every day.

But I do want, in light of the debate that the Organic Law of Education has produced and in light of the debate that the demonstration that took place last weekend has produced, to make a proclamation, which is not in response even to your Group, that is convenient at this moment for the entire educational system and for our country.

Spain has an educational system that has allowed our society, over the last twenty-five years, to reach a level of economic development, well-being, and democratic coexistence that is unparalleled in history. I believe it is appropriate to remind ourselves time and again, when we talk about education in our country, that thanks to the expansion of public and free education that has been consolidated up to ages comparable to the most advanced countries; that thanks to the extension, to the access, to university studies for many social sectors that historically could not; that thanks to the efforts of many teachers, many professors in this country, and many parents, and also students, we are in a position to be a country, as we are, modern, advanced, that is growing economically, that creates jobs, and that has great possibilities for the future.

This economic situation would not be understood, from my point of view, if there had not been such a positive change in education. And today, as a country that is ambitious in its goals, we have two essential problems: the extension of the number of young people who must have a high school diploma and vocational training in our country, and the fight against school failure. School failure, yes, which has increased quite a bit in recent years, indeed.

From my point of view, I must tell you that the best way to unify a country and the best way to bring progress to a country is to have an education with social cohesion at all its levels. That is the objective of the Organic Law of Education, and that is what I will logically evaluate tomorrow with the associations that have called for the demonstration held over the weekend.

Mr. García-Escudero.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, last Saturday there was a very important mobilization in our country. Very few words have come from your lips about what that day represented. Respect, of course, and little more.

"I believe that a democracy requires that the President of the Government say something more to the Spaniards who have expressed themselves in such a clear and forceful manner. I hope that this expression serves to modify your position, to listen to what the Spaniards have said." Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, these words are yours: Congress of Deputies, February 19, 2003. Today we are not talking about Iraq, although it is a topic you like when you have no arguments in a debate, but today we are talking about education.

I do not know what world you live in, but the reality is that education in our country is an absolute disaster. The reality is that the LOGSE has been an absolute failure, and various international organizations are telling us that we are at the tail end of Europe in educational matters. That is why the previous government, after a long process of dialogue with the entire educational establishment, promoted the Quality Law, a Quality Law that you, as soon as you arrived in government, forced to repeal. You were wrong then, and you continue to be wrong now with the LOE.

You have ignored three and a half million signatures against the LOE Bill, and now you say you will meet with the conveners of Saturday's demonstration. That is fine, but think about what you are going to tell them, because this is not one of those issues that can be solved just by opening the budget tap, nor with those nice photos taken at the door of La Moncloa. The way this project has been improvised hastily, with its back to the educational community, has been poor. How bad must things be that even the Council of State has told you it would have been much better to maintain the Quality Law?

Now, just a few days ago, the day before yesterday, in the Congress proceedings, you only supported your own amendments with the backing of your partners from the Tinell Pact and dismissed more than 1,300 amendments from the other Parliamentary Groups. That is to say, after Saturday's demonstration, the bad manners continue, the rush continues, and I truly do not understand why, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, because if the manners have been bad, the contents are even worse.

I believe, humbly -- you are the President of the Government and can do whatever you want -- that what you need to do in this case is rectify, what you need to do is redirect, what you need to do is reform, and what you need to do is not persist in error, because that is what the LOE brings us: more LOGSE, more ideological burden, less quality, less equality of opportunity, and less freedom of education.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, I tell you this every time we have a debate here: step out of your virtual "Matrix" world, because this is not a conspiracy of bishops. What good is it for you to send your Vice President on a pilgrimage to Rome and then threaten the Church with reprisals upon her return? What a role you make the Vice President play! Because Saturday's demonstration was not a matter of clerical collars. 839 organizations called for the demonstration, 839 where there were associations of parents, educational centers, teachers' unions, student associations… And it is not a thing of the Popular Party either. It is true that we were there, but among a million Spaniards who were demonstrating.

And it is also unacceptable, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that cascade of disqualifications that we have had to hear in recent days against the conveners and participants in the demonstration, because, of course, I still believe that the right to demonstrate and the right to freedom of expression remain common for all Spaniards.

I ask you, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, to rectify, to be sensitive to the demands of society, of those demonstrators, of that million demonstrators, to withdraw this Law and to seek agreement and not the imposition of an ideology, because on that wrong path in just a year and a half you have already earned four enormous demonstrations.

We, the Popular Party, are willing to restart with your Government and with all the Parliamentary Groups the process of educational reform, but a positive reform, that does not go against anything and does not go against anyone; a reform that can be agreed upon by all and that has stability for a long time.

President.- Mr. García-Escudero, note that, despite the fact that you have been in government for eight years, despite that, I can assure you that education in Spain is not a disaster, despite. Really, that assertion you made, after having governed for eight years, I do not know what position it leaves the Popular Party in.

I must tell you, and I have already conveyed this to you in these intense sessions of parliamentary debate and control, that exaggeration leads to making it very difficult to have a debate in terms and parameters of rationality, which I believe is what we must be especially required to do when we talk about education and we talk to a mature country, to a teaching sector that knows perfectly what is happening, what problems we have, and what we need.

Allow me to say that I have a very open attitude towards the exercise of the right to demonstrate. I have always respected them and I always try to listen to those who express concerns, claims, criticisms, or demands in the street. Of course, I have never said nor will I ever say the things you said when there were demonstrations and you were in government.

It is very recent, and it is also very fresh in the memory of Spanish society that, when the Quality Law was drafted and approved, it was done with the support only of the Popular Group; it is very recent in the memory of Spanish society that this Quality Law, just like the other great educational law, the LOU, faced widespread social opposition, and it is in people's memory that the President of the Government neither called nor received those who protested in the street against those two laws that you approved.

Therefore, allow me to feel with some authority to tell you that, certainly, in the way of responding to what is a critical debate, the exercise of rights, this Government responds with much more respect and with much more democratic sensitivity and open attitude than the disdain we usually heard when people demonstrated during your time in government.

I want to tell you regarding our educational system and the Organic Law of Education. The Organic Law of Education guarantees the freedom of choice of school by parents. The Organic Law of Education guarantees and demands the right of parents to have their children study religion, because that Law, it is worth remembering, clearly establishes the obligation of schools to offer the subject of Religion and, therefore, the right of all parents to have their children study religion. The rest are lies and falsehoods, no matter who says it.

And the best proof, Mr. García-Escudero, is that, against all the debate of slogans and exaggerations, no one is capable of going to the Organic Law of Education and saying in which article the free choice of school by parents is prohibited or in which article it is prohibited for parents to have and choose Religion as a subject for their children to study. At no time, neither you nor in the debate has that situation occurred.

What I do want to remind Mr. García-Escudero and the Popular Group is that the Socialist Party ran for election with a clear electoral commitment to reform the Quality Law and to draft a new Education Law. We are doing what we promised to the Spaniards, who supported us with eleven million votes at the polls, and we are doing it to have an educational system that provides quality and social cohesion to Spain. Social cohesion in education means defending public schools, which is the great instrument of educational cohesion, committing resources and public spending to education: making a law with an economic memory like this one, which has six billion euros, and the Quality Law had no economic memory.

Fighting against school failure is doing what this Government has done for this school year, which is to establish support and reinforcement teachers in six hundred educational centers for those students who have problems, helping them to overcome the challenges of exams and their educational curriculum. Not discriminating or segregating them, helping them from the beginning so that the vast majority can achieve academic success.

The other measure that our educational system needs is to increase the number of scholarships so that social sectors with fewer resources have the incentive and the opportunity to study just like all social sectors; increasing scholarships as this Government has increased by forty thousand more for this school year.

In short, Mr. Speaker, with dialogue, wishing that the Popular Group responds to the written proposal with contents that the Socialist Party made to you a few weeks ago, which has still not received a response; wishing that you respond, that you join in, and that you leave behind the slogans and exaggerations, I can assure you that, when this Law is approved and when the Government's educational policy with the budget increases yields its results, we will recover ground in the fight against school failure, we will raise the percentage of young people who reach high school and vocational training, and, moreover, the freedom of choice of school, all freedoms, and all rights enshrined in the Constitution will continue to be guaranteed, which are those of a secular, social, and democratic state of law.