Speech by the President of the Government at the closing of the Spanish Federation of Municipalities and Provinces Conference on the 25th anniversary of democratic local governments.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

24 November 2004 · Closing of the Spanish Federation of Municipalities and Provinces Conference on the 25th anniversary of democratic local governments

Context
Zapatero addressed the closing ceremony of the Spanish Federation of Municipalities and Provinces Cities Forum in Vitoria, marking 25 years of democratic local governments in November 2004.
Main themes
25th anniversary of democratic local governance in Spain, role of municipalities in democracy, citizenship and civic participation, quality of life in cities, women's rights and gender violence, local government leadership, Basque Country and coexistence, decentralization and proximity democracy, municipal management achievements
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,539
68th percentile
Sentences
89
57th percentile
Readability
25
9th percentile
Grade
16.8
88th percentile
Syntax
3.26
79th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
48th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 55%54%
  • Ceremonial 17%17%
  • Social 16%16%
  • Economic 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

89 sentences in 45 paragraphs

President of the Senate, Authorities, mayors, dear friends,

I am particularly pleased to participate in this closing event of the Cities Forum, with which the Spanish Federation of Municipalities and Provinces has decided to commemorate the twenty-fifth anniversary of democratic local governments.

First of all, I must congratulate you on the happy initiative of linking this commemoration to the organization of days of reflection and debate, broad days and broad debate, on the various issues raised today by the governance of cities and towns. These are days in which, as I understand, rigorous and very rich contributions have been made.

I also want to congratulate you for choosing a city like Vitoria as the venue for the Forum, exemplary in so many aspects. As you all know, based on various economic, social, environmental, and other indicators, this city is always among the top in Spain for the quality of life enjoyed by its citizens. Congratulations. Vitoria has thus become this autumn, according to the happy expression of the President of the Spanish Federation of Municipalities and Provinces, Mayor of Mayors, my good friend, Paco Vázquez, the "Main Square of all the towns of Spain"; an excellent image of citizenship, proximity, and integration.

This Forum is also being held in the Basque Country, a people proud of its history; a country full of strength, culture, and a thirst for freedom; a country, I said, proud of its history, but which together we will make feel much prouder of its future, a future that I see every day with more prospects of combining that unstoppable force of coexistence and identity.

In these days, a critical but very favorably substantial review has been made of the significant contributions that cities and the work of local governments have made to the lives of their citizens, to the quality and effectiveness of Spanish democracy in this last quarter of a century.

The balance must have been positive, because justice demands it of municipal management; a management that, with whatever particularities, has advanced the transformations that have also been fostered by other administrations; a management that has always been at the forefront of the changes that have transformed Spain.

I have always been aware that proximity to the daily, vital, immediate problems of people, those that most affect their aspirations and needs, and the most accurate knowledge of the environment in which people develop their life projects, make the local sphere a privileged space for improving their living conditions.

I have also been aware that the space of cities is the most proper for citizenship. The closeness between rulers and the ruled fosters a democracy of proximity that encourages the best and most stimulating political experiences.

The city is the best setting for civic learning and political pedagogy. Although the invocation of Tocqueville's writings may sound clichéd, it is true that the municipality is by definition a school of citizenship. That is why it is at the local level where numerous experiences of more intense and direct citizen participation are being expressed, which I encourage you to deepen, and which reach deliberation, decision, and management of the most strategic issues.

But it is no less true that we live in a moment in history where the world is increasingly a union of states; the world is a world of states; but above all, the world is a world of cities, of cities that grow and communicate, of cities that are the most primary realm of coexistence and the space where men and women develop all their possibilities.

Municipalities have also been a school of leadership. A very significant number of Spaniards, around 250,000, have represented their neighbors in local governments during this period; a very important breeding ground from which other administrations and governments have fortunately drawn. They have also been the space — it should never be forgotten — where mayors and councilors have given heroic testimony of their commitment to freedom and democracy, of their resistance to blackmail, violence, and terror. And also the space through whose streets millions of citizens have repeatedly manifested in defense of those ideals.

Local governments have also been a powerful instance for the advancement of equality and women's rights. On a day like today, I ask you, councilors and mayors, to contribute even more to the defense of women's rights and to the protection of those women who suffer the scourge of gender violence. You know that the Government of Spain will collaborate, cooperate, and help in a special way with all local governments in defense of those women who so unjustly suffer violence and, in many cases, lack protection.

Therefore, I can only agree with the favorable judgments that have been expressed during all these days regarding the balance of these twenty-five years. As President of the Government of Spain, I feel particularly proud of the work carried out by our local corporations.

Paco mentioned earlier that mayors have a reputation for asking or being beggars — I didn't want to say the word because I remembered another moment; but, in my opinion, local governments and mayors, more than asking, what you do is give. You have provided services where you had no obligation to do so; you have sought work, industry, activity, where your responsibilities did not reach; you have promoted the development of civic rights, basic rights, transformative of many social realities where it was not your task. You have dedicated yourselves; you have given to the citizens much of what others should have done.

So have no doubt: the vast majority of Spaniards feel proud of their local governments and their municipal corporations. Opinion studies demonstrate this. When asked about their assessment of the management of the different public administrations, they always place local corporations first, and, more importantly, it is an assessment that has improved over time and, even more significantly: local politics is, by far, the one that generates the most interest among citizens. And you know this well.

The best way for a President of the Government to participate in this commemoration is not only to acknowledge the vigor of that consideration and recognize the accumulated success but to look at the present and the future, fully aware that we face new problems and must propose new solutions.

There remains an important task to be undertaken for the benefit of Local Administration. As is well known, the Government intends to promote in this legislature certain, concrete, and precise constitutional reforms. Alongside this initiative from the Government, some Autonomous Communities are taking determined steps to introduce modifications to their respective Statutes.

Both reforms are logically called to occupy a prominent place on the political agenda of our country starting next year. I do not want, by the way, to miss the opportunity to reiterate, in relation to them, my firm conviction that their viability, not only legal but also political, will depend on achieving a high degree of consensus in each case and respecting the constitutional framework and the procedures established to formalize the intended regulatory changes.

Well, in this general context of institutional reforms, the pending issue of the reforms affecting the local sphere is inserted. These are issues related to their legal regime and municipal and provincial financing.

Beyond the fact that, in my opinion, the same double general condition that applies to the previous ones (high degree of consensus and respect for the Constitution and the procedures) should govern these reforms, it seems clear that we could find ourselves, that we are going to find ourselves, in fact, when addressing them, before two potential alternatives. There are those who, on one side, think that it would be better not to add to the inherent complexity of the possible reformulation of some aspects of the State of Autonomies the proposal regarding the reforms of Local Administration. Undoubtedly, there may be arguments to maintain this position; but there are also surely many who advocate the convenience of addressing all reforms jointly, incorporating a global vision of the model of territorial decentralization and thus not delaying a response to the legal and economic demands that have been made by local governments.

I believe that there will hardly be a better occasion than this and a better forum than the one we are in to announce that my criterion, as President of the Government, regarding the hypothetical dilemma I have formulated, falls within the second option. I am in favor of taking on the challenge of considering and undertaking the reforms that may affect our territorial model from a global perspective; a vision that allows for better attention to the necessary balances among all political and institutional interlocutors.

If at first, after the transition, local government awaited its regulation until the Statutes of Autonomy were approved, I believe that this time it would be very positive if, if possible, we all arrived together and on time. This would undoubtedly be the most convenient.

I express this position in the conviction that local government is the third pillar in the territorial articulation of the State, that its autonomy is political autonomy within the framework of the Constitution and not mere administrative autonomy within the framework of the Law, that its bodies are a genuine expression of popular will, and that, as the European Charter of Local Self-Government unequivocally states, municipalities must have a substantial level of competencies that allows them, under their responsibility, to promote their own policies.

The planned calendar for laying the foundations of the local reform designed by the Ministry of Public Administrations, which the Minister himself had the opportunity to explain to you a few days ago in this very forum, will allow it to be introduced into the general debate on other reforms that affect the model of the State.

As you know, it is expected that the Commission for the preparation of the White Paper on Local Government Reform, which was established at the beginning of last September, will conclude its work in February 2005. This will undoubtedly be a good starting point for narrowing down reflections and outlining the framework of a consensus that allows for the emergence of the Law of Bases of Local Government and Administration.

This Law should address all the basic aspects of this level of territorial administration to adapt them to current needs and expectations, and to provide an adequate framework that allows for the consolidation of local democracy.

The current Law of Bases of Local Regime chose not to attribute competencies to municipalities, relying in most cases on the decentralizing will of state and regional sectoral legislation. Over time, the Autonomous Communities have been very protective of the competencies acquired.

At the same time, this certain indefiniteness of the own competencies has posed an obstacle to more accurately assessing the real cost of the services provided by local governments. Perhaps we should now consider, therefore, the convenience of first identifying the specific competencies of municipalities in order to then evaluate their financing needs.

Once the competencies are clarified, it will be easier to quantify them and provide them with adequate financing from the State and the Autonomous Communities. In such a case, moreover, as derived from the European Charter, the financing should be unconditional, so that earmarked grants are an exception that the State and Autonomous Communities must sufficiently justify.

Ultimately, it is about being able to legally articulate the value of proximity through the principle of subsidiarity, which, well understood, consists of moving from the particular to the general through a process of political dialogue characterized by cooperation and institutional loyalty among the various public powers concerned.

It cannot be otherwise. The time has come to seriously consider endowing the political and financial autonomy of our local entities with content. The Government has the determined purpose of making this happen.

I am fully aware of the negative drift that has occurred over time; a drift that burdens local governments with new responsibilities or that, because they are not attended to by any other Administration, must ultimately be assumed by them, as they are the direct and immediate recipients of citizens' demands. But, at the same time, they are denied or deprived of the necessary financial means to address them.

This situation cannot continue. The time has come, therefore, to make the responsibilities and the necessary means to address them equidistant. Some modest steps have already been taken. In the upcoming Budgets, for the first time, there will be a specific allocation to support local governments in their actions derived from the reception and social policy in relation to immigration.

I do not want to conclude my words without making a special mention of the task that the municipalities have carried out so far and the one they will have to face in the future in the process of European integration, as they will play a relevant role in defining new objectives and approaches for regional policies, cohesion policies, employment policies, and the Lisbon objectives.

The new Constitution for Europe, which we will submit to a referendum on February 20, offers new possibilities for the effective application of the principle of subsidiarity and, with it, new margins of action for the municipalities. But in order to materialize these purposes in a general and more ambitious sense, we must count on the decisive participation of the Spanish Federation of Municipalities and Provinces, as well as the constructive will of the various political forces.

The Government has some projects and commitments in this regard:

- We have decided to create a Joint Commission, made up of the Government and a representation from the FEMP, to study the reform of local financing.

- We have decided to promote the incorporation of local entities, through the FEMP, into the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy.

- We have decided to establish the Sectoral Conference on Local Affairs as a cooperation body of the Government, the Autonomous Communities, and, through the FEMP, the Local Corporations.

- We have asked the FEMP to prepare an annual report on the state of provincial and municipal administration for consideration in the General Commission of the Autonomous Communities of the Senate.

- And today I want to announce that we are going to establish the annual Municipal Conference with the meeting of the President of the Government with the executive of the FEMP and the municipal representation that it deems appropriate.

All of this requires, therefore, the definitive institutionalization of the Spanish Federation of Municipalities. This legislative term is the opportunity to achieve it. I trust, and I trust fully, that we will all succeed in playing our role.

Paco, Mayor of Mayors, congratulations once again. Congratulations to all the Mayors and all the councilors who in these twenty-five years have committed their efforts to the well-being of the citizens. My special remembrance to those who cannot be with us today and my conviction that municipal life is increasingly fruitful, more creative, more active, and more dynamic in our country. This contributes exceptionally to the structuring of Spain, which is a Spain of cities and towns.

Thank you very much for this initiative. Congratulations on the twenty-five years and here’s to another twenty-five even better. Thank you very much.