Speech by the President of the Government at the "Council on Foreign Relations" in New York

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

14 September 2005 · Council on Foreign Relations · Council on Foreign Relations, New York, United States

Context
Zapatero addressed the Council on Foreign Relations in New York in September 2005, outlining Spain's counterterrorism approach and advocating multilateral cooperation.
Main themes
Counterterrorism strategy, rule of law vs. security dilemma, multilateralism and United Nations, Spain's experience with terrorism, path of fear vs. path of freedom, international cooperation, extremism and its root causes, democracy and civil liberties, Islam and Western culture, global consensus on terrorism definition
Duration
~11 min
38th percentile
Words
1,285
38th percentile
Sentences
57
37th percentile
Readability
30
17th percentile
Grade
14.6
73rd percentile
Syntax
2.97
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.30
72nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 56%56%
  • Social 25%25%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

57 sentences in 23 paragraphs

Four days ago, the world commemorated the fourth anniversary of the heinous attack on the Twin Towers, which was followed, among others, by the barbaric attacks in Madrid on March 11, 2004, and in London on July 7 of this year. Terrorism threatens us all equally. Its objective is our model of coexistence. It is essential that we are united to combat it, and the first thing I wish to say is that our country will spare no effort in this cause.

There is universal agreement in valuing the fight against extremism and its offspring, terrorism, as one of the great challenges of our time. Some make this endeavor their sole international priority, relegating— in my opinion, mistakenly— the fight against hunger and misery or the defense of the environment.

In any case, let us focus on the point where the diagnoses coincide: terrorism looms as a serious threat of our time to security and peace. From this agreement in diagnosis, two paths open up that, even at the risk of oversimplifying, I will call the path of fear and the path of freedom.

One path or the other depends on the responses provided to two questions: on one hand, to defend democracy and the rule of law against terrorist aggression, can we call into question the very values we defend and violate the guarantees that inspire them? On the other hand, is the systematic recourse to military force to protect our citizens operational, or can it be counterproductive in the long term for the eradication of terrorism, to the extent that it contributes to worsening the international political climate?

The future will judge us by the response we are able to give to this double dilemma. In any case, the defense of our citizens and our values cannot be carried out with a single instrument, no matter how powerful it may be.

The reaction to the attacks is clear: we must bring the full weight of the law down on those who commit, plan, or inspire these atrocities. We cannot tolerate havens of impunity. We must provide more resources to security forces and make international cooperation in the areas of intelligence, judicial action, and the financing of terrorism more agile and effective.

With its long and painful experience of more than thirty years of firm combat against terrorism, Spain knows that it is essential to maintain unity and strictly respect the foundations and limits of the rule of law.

Against terrorism, total firmness, but with the values of freedom and democracy. This is what we are doing in Spain. We suffered the atrocious attacks of March 11, 2004, but the reaction of Spanish society left no room for xenophobia or intolerance. The Spanish people were able to perfectly distinguish religion from fanaticism and terrorists from the cultural community to which they belonged. The reaction of my government was in line with this sentiment of the Spanish people: we have not restricted rights and freedoms, but rather expanded them for women, for homosexuals, for young people: we have provided more freedom and transparency in the media and in parliamentary life.

I believe that this principle is valid both at the internal level and at the international level. We will achieve our objectives, not unilaterally, but through legal measures, with broad normative consensus.

The appropriate arena for consolidating this consensus can only be that of the United Nations. We must equip the Organization with the necessary means to lead the fight against terrorism more effectively. The creation of the Counter-Terrorism Committee (CTC) and the Al-Qaeda and Taliban Committee has marked milestones in this regard, but it is essential that states collaborate more intensively with these committees. It is imperative to adopt the Global Convention against Terrorism, which must contain a general and shared definition of the phenomenon.

To defeat terrorism, we also need a political and strategic consensus. It is not enough to win some battles. To completely defeat it, we must understand what the conditions are that generate extremism and its transformation into a strategy of terror. We must analyze this pathology in all its dimensions: first, of security, of course; but also political, economic, social, and cultural. We cannot ignore the entrenched conflicts and the enormous economic, political, and social fractures that affect many societies and serve as breeding grounds and false pretexts for terrorist violence.

We must expand the conviction that nothing justifies terrorism. No idea, however legitimate it may be or seem, can serve as an excuse for murder or barbarism. All people, regardless of their condition, nationality, culture, or religion, must understand that terrorism is the absolute negation of the values that uphold human dignity.

History shows that terrorism is not exclusive to any civilization, culture, or religion.

We must remember the valuable contributions of Islam to the formation of Western culture and its humanist character. My country is a good witness to this.

There are no valid religious justifications for terrorism. That is why what hurts terrorists the most is the condemnation from their own religious brothers.

To defeat terrorism and extremism, we must work together with the Muslim world, which is equally threatened. Only violence is absolutely unacceptable. We should not be afraid to engage in open debates, discussing the most controversial issues.

Furthermore, we leaders have the obligation to fully integrate into our societies and their values those young immigrants who, even with high economic and educational levels, are at risk of seeking meaning in their lives through religious extremism. We must convince them that they must and can defend their vision of international justice through democratic means.

We must encourage our citizens, whatever their origin, to participate politically in a much more conscious manner.

From the final document of the Summit we are holding here in New York, I want to highlight the commitment of Heads of State and Government to promote a culture of prevention, a culture of peace, through concerted action that understands that misery and underdevelopment are closely interconnected with security problems. My government unequivocally supports the broad strategy to combat terrorism presented by Secretary-General Kofi Annan.

In our effort to win the battle of mindsets, we must not only increase technical assistance to states so they can combat terrorism in their own territory, but also so they can promote democracy, human rights, and economic development that reduces social inequalities. We must increase the share of international cooperation that we allocate to institutional strengthening and pay greater attention to women by international organizations, so they can access more active roles in our societies, in the Muslim world but also in the West.

This is the idea of the Alliance of Civilizations launched by the Secretary-General of the United Nations at the proposal of Spain. We must fully involve civil society in this project. We must decisively promote the idea that tolerance and understanding between cultures are indispensable for achieving truly secure peace.

A good example, in the context of the European Union, is the Barcelona Process, which is helping the two shores of the Mediterranean to know each other better. Not in vain is the first meeting of the High-Level Expert Group, convened by the Secretary-General of the United Nations on the Alliance of Civilizations, going to be held in Mallorca in November, coinciding with the Euro-Mediterranean Summit of that Barcelona Process.

Initiatives such as that of the G-8 for the Middle East and North Africa are, fortunately, going down the same path, the path of rapprochement and dialogue. Only in this way will we create the necessary political climate for our definitive victory, which will not be, of course, just a victory for Western society, but the shared victory of all good people.