Statement by President Lula during a meeting with governors

Brazil Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva · President of Brazil

4 November 2024 · Meeting with governors on public security

Context
Lula convened a meeting with Brazilian governors, judiciary leaders, and legislators on November 4, 2024, to discuss a proposed constitutional amendment on public security.
Main themes
Public security reform, constitutional amendment proposal (PEC), organized crime, federative pact, prison system, judicial accountability, inter-institutional cooperation, state governors' role, municipal guards, criminal identity tracking, legislative coordination
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,518
68th percentile
Sentences
106
66th percentile
Readability
55
76th percentile
Grade
11.5
39th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from Portuguese

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 61%57%
  • Social 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 18%17%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

106 sentences in 32 paragraphs

The presence of the governors, the presence of the vice governors and vice governors. And also the presence of the governor. It seems to me that Fátima Bezerra [governor of Rio Grande do Norte] is not present. And our governor of Pernambuco is traveling. And the vice is present, the vice of Pernambuco, the vice of Brasília, the vice of Pará, and there is one more vice here, one more vice present.

I wanted to say the following: I had already told you that, at some point, we would invite the governors to discuss the issue of public security. Later, my colleague Lewandowski [Ricardo Lewandowski, Minister of Justice and Public Security] began to work on the presentation of a PEC that does not discuss the entirety of the problems of public security, but discusses some problems that are important.

And I told Lewandowski that we could not send the PEC to the National Congress before having a conversation with the governors. And later, Lewandowski had a meeting that had been called by the governor of Brasília, and Lewandowski said: “President, I think you don’t need to call a meeting anymore, because the governor of Brasília is calling the meeting with all the governors, and I will present the PEC there to them.” The fact is that this meeting did not happen, and I called my colleague Lewandowski and asked him if it was not time for us to call the governors, and not just the governors, but to call the Supreme Court, call the Superior Court of Justice, call the Office of the Comptroller General of the Republic, the Federal Public Ministry, the National Council of the Public Ministry. In other words, invite the state security secretaries to participate. Invite all the institutions that, directly or indirectly, have something to do with it.

I don’t know if the presence of Deputy Lira [Arthur Lira, President of the Chamber of Deputies] and Senator Pacheco [Rodrigo Pacheco, President of the Federal Senate] has been confirmed, because the idea was also to summon the Legislative Power to participate, and here are some leaders, some important mayors, who will participate, because this discussion also involves the role of municipal guards. And it is a meeting in which we will not solve all the problems of public security in just one meeting.

But we want my colleague Lewandowski to start the discussion by presenting the PEC proposal that will be sent to the National Congress, but we want to hear the governors and we would like the governors to talk about other problems that involve public security. Above all, there are governors who have many complaints, you know, about the Judiciary in the states, because many times the police arrest the criminal and, the next day, he is free.

And sometimes it happens that the criminal wants to stay where he wants, and he even chooses the prison he wants to stay in, and, many times, in the state, the judge who will make the decision sends the criminal to the prison he wants to stay in.

We know that the issue of public security today is not a question as it was in other decades, but we know that, since the 1980s, public security has been growing, day by day, in each state. There are times when we hear that one state is better, the following year it gets worse. Because organized crime today is no longer the common criminal we were used to dealing with. Today it is a powerful organization that is involved in all sectors of society, including at the international level.

I have been concerned about public competitions, because, soon, organized crime will be participating in competitions, it will be appointing judges, it will be appointing prosecutors, it will be appointing politicians, it will be appointing candidates. And this is something that is almost uncontrollable if we do not establish a Federative Pact that involves all the Powers of the Federation, all the powers that are directly involved in this, and that we can build a process that discusses everything from the prison system to the registration system that each state has.

In other words, it is necessary that there is a systematic, organized training, because we cannot continue to allow a criminal in Paraná to hide by going to São Paulo and getting another identity, or he commits a crime in São Paulo and goes to hide in the Northeast state. It is necessary that we have something very, very organized, and we are willing to discuss, as many hours as necessary, as many meetings as necessary, through our secretaries, through our representatives in the Judiciary, so that we can present a definitive proposal to combat the so-called organized crime that is now spread throughout the national territory, which is spread in states that, 20 years ago, they were not and now they are.

I know that each governor has their problems, each governor has their solutions, but what we are effectively noticing is that organized crime is growing, organizations in prisons are growing. We see, from time to time, talk about Comando Vermelho, talk about PCC, and they are in almost all states running for elections, electing councilors, you know. And, who knows, appointing people to hold important positions in Brazilian institutions.

I would like this meeting to be a meeting in which the governors had no concern about saying what they think they should say. It is a meeting in which there is no censorship, there is no impediment for each one to say what they think, what they believe to be true. And, above all, also to make some proposal for a solution so that we can move forward on this issue. That is why the presence of the Judiciary is important here, it is important the presence of my colleague Flávio Dino [Minister of the Supreme Federal Court], who was Minister of Justice until recently, and who had a lot of concern about this. But now we will pass the word to my colleague Rui Costa [Minister of the Civil House]. Then we will pass the word to my colleague Lewandowski to present the PEC, and then we will open the debate for all the Powers, all the governors, all the vice governors and vice governors, so that we can start.

It is important to remember, I would like to reiterate: the presentation of this PEC is the beginning of a great discussion that we want to have about public security in this country, about the creation of a Unified Public Security System. And we start by sending it to the two Houses where the debate should really take place, which is in the National Congress. So, with the floor to my colleague Rui Costa and then to my colleague Lewandowski.

[...Statements from the governors and other authorities...]

The first thing I wanted to say, not to say it is the last thing. First, it is to thank you, the governors, the people who came representing the National Congress, the Judiciary, the state security secretaries, because this was a meeting that needed to be held. I don’t know if you know, but I think that in the history of Brazil, there has never been a president who had as many former governors as ministers as I do. It is not a governor of one term, no.

I have here the experience of 16 years of government, here the experience of 16 years of government, Wellington [Dias, Minister of Development and Social Assistance, Family and Combatting Hunger]. No, 20 will be now, Wellington with 16 years of government, Flávio Dino with 8 years of government. Who else? Camilo [Santana, Minister of Education] with 16 years of government experience. Waldez [Góes, Minister of Integration and Regional Development] with 16 years. In other words, Renan [Filho, Minister of Transport] with 8 years. In other words, everyone has a lot of experience. And when my colleague Lewandowski raised the idea of making the PEC, I told him: “The first thing we will do is call the ministers who were state governors, so that we can hear from them the experiences they have in dealing with the issue of public security. Because the concrete data is that it is a very complicated situation throughout Brazil.

I had the opportunity to get to know today the only state that has no security problem, which is the state of Goiás, which I ask Lewandowski to go there to investigate, because it can be a reference for all other governors. Instead of me calling a meeting, it was Caiado [Ronaldo Caiado, governor of Goiás] who should have called the meeting to guide how to behave to solve the security problem in each state.

When I called this meeting, I wanted you to know that there were people who thought that the press should not cover the entire meeting, because people might speak against the PEC, or disagree with the government’s idea. I said that we would open it up, because the meeting was for us to learn and the meeting was for people to express their views on the issue of public security.

The PEC is not a finished product, it is just the key that is opening a door for a debate that, if the issue is as serious as all of you have said, is the main theme to be found a solution. A solution that will involve changes in law, that will involve changes in behavior, that we will take the democratic institutions out of their glass boxes in which each one is separated, each one thinks they own the truth, each one thinks they know everything. And we will have to make people talk. I have not yet heard from the mayors, because I cannot imagine how a medium or large-sized city hall does not have its own police to decide to do the things that need to be done in the city. And the crimes are as diverse as possible. And different in each region, different in each state.

And we have to learn this so that we can find a definitive solution. I miss, Alckmin [Geraldo Alckmin, Vice President of the Republic and Minister of Development, Industry, Commerce and Services], the time when I lived in Vila Carioca, in São Paulo, when the biggest, most famous criminal in Brazil was a guy named Meneghel, you know, who did not kill anyone, he robbed, he just jumped walls, robbed houses and left. He was the most dangerous guy in São Paulo. This was in the 50s and 60s. Today, that is over. It is over. Crime is sophisticated, intelligence is sophisticated, weapons are sophisticated, often better than all the arsenal of state policies. Sometimes, better than the Armed Forces themselves, and sometimes, it is the weapons of the Armed Forces themselves that are stolen.

So, this is a theme that will require patience so that we can discuss, first, among ourselves. Among ourselves. The Federal Government has never been so concerned about debating the issue of public security because of autonomy. Because who takes care of the police is the state, who takes care of the Civil Police is the state. And not always does the state want the Federal Government to assist. Not always.

Not every crime that happens in the state can we send the Federal Police to intervene. Because people do not want, people are owners. What we want to do is the following: we want to unify procedures, information.

Imagine if we all had Caiado’s methodology, we would possibly already have many more solutions. But we do not know. The Federal Government may not have all the information, you may not have all the information, and we do not have it from each state.

There are governors who withhold information about crime investigations. There are governors who withhold the number of people who died, who still do not know why they died. In other words, each one produces the information that interests them, and often it is what interests the police chief who is in charge, often the colonel who commands the battalion.

So, what we want is the following: to make this issue of public security a more civilized matter, so that society knows what happens in each state, what happens at the federal level, what happens in each municipality. To see if we can inhibit or make organized crime disappear. The ills with which they kidnap society. Because you have major crime, heinous crime, but you have the guy who, to get a gas cylinder, has to pay the criminal. It is this thing that works, because you have, from high-level crime, to the theft of a cell phone.

The guy who has the courage to rob an 80-year-old lady who is talking on her cell phone. The guy comes and robs and leaves. Obviously, this guy does not need to be killed by the police, but there has to be a specific treatment for that, so that we can reduce it.

So, I want to thank you, from the heart, I want to thank you for what you said freely, for the ideas you suggested, and I want to remind you: this is just the beginning of a great debate that will happen in this country.

As long as I am president of the Republic, we will not be afraid to have any debate. We want to discuss education with you, we want to discuss the PAC with you, we want to discuss public security with you. And that you have the same right to speak. My colleague Lewandowski is willing to travel to any state, to discuss with any forum, this PEC and other measures that we have, discovering in this debate.

So, from the heart, I want to thank the governors, the vice governors and vice governors, the public security secretaries, the Representative Power, the Judiciary, our mayors, my colleague Mário Campbell [Mauro Luiz Campbell Marques, General Inspector of the Federal Justice], who came here at our invitation.

It is a shame that not everyone was able to speak, but I want to thank you for being here sitting for four hours. I don't know if at any other moment in the republican history of Brazil, there has been the patience of governors and the patience of a president to spend four hours together, not at a party, because at the beach it is easy for us to spend four hours together, you know? Anywhere, but in a meeting...

And you see: I also doubt that at any moment in republican history a president served as much food to you as I served at this meeting here. I don't know, Caiado, I don't know if a piece of pamonha reached you, but this pamonha that I ate here, it came last night from Goiás, because I received it as a gift. Pamonha and the famous empadão de Goiás.

So, folks, thank you very much, thank you very much.

We are available to discuss these and other topics.