Beat Back the Attack of the Bourgeois Rightists

China Mao Zedong · Chairman of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China

9 July 1957

Context
Mao addressed Party cadres in Shanghai, apparently on July 9, 1957, a hundred days after his March talk, reviewing the anti-Rightist struggle and urging continued rectification and the mass line.
Main themes
Anti-Rightist struggle, bourgeois Rightists, criticism of Party shortcomings, trust in the ninety percent majority, rectification of the Party, big-character posters, transformation of intellectuals, the mass line, democratic parties' rectification, the proletariat's leadership, Rightists as negative teachers
Duration
~57 min
95th percentile
Words
6,838
95th percentile
Sentences
428
98th percentile
Readability
63
92nd percentile
Grade
8.5
7th percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
49th percentile

Translated from Chinese Source: GitHub qinglee/maoxuan (毛泽东选集) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 45%42%
  • Social 41%38%
  • Geopolitical 6%5%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 2%2%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

428 sentences in 27 paragraphs

In March I gave a talk here to some cadres within the Party. From that time until now, a hundred days have passed. In these hundred days, the situation has changed greatly. We have fought a battle with the bourgeois Rightists, and the people's political consciousness has risen, and risen quite considerably. Back then we already anticipated these things. For example, I said here that when people start to criticize, that is, when the fire starts to burn, won't it hurt? You have to brace your scalp and hold firm. This part of a person is called the head, and the head has a skin, called the scalp. Bracing your scalp and holding firm means that when you criticize me, I brace my scalp and listen, listen for a period of time, and then analyze it and reply to it, accepting what is said correctly and criticizing what is said incorrectly.

We must always believe that, whether in the whole world or in our China, the majority of people are good people. By the majority, I do not mean fifty-one percent of people, but more than ninety percent. Among our country's population of six hundred million, the workers and peasants are our basic masses. In the Communist Party, in the Youth League, in the democratic parties, among students and intellectuals, the majority are always good people. Their hearts are always kind, they are honest, they are not cunning, they do not have ulterior motives. This should be acknowledged. Every movement has proved it. Take this time, for example, take the students: Peking University has more than seven thousand people, and the Rightists are only one, two, three percent. What does one, two, three percent mean? It means the resolute core elements, the ones who are constantly stirring up trouble, turning heaven and earth upside down, have only ever been some fifty-odd people, less than one percent. Another one or two percent are those who applaud them and support them.

Setting fire to oneself is not easy. Now I hear that some comrades here have regrets, feeling that they did not open things up fiercely enough. I think Shanghai has opened up just about enough, only it was a bit insufficient, it didn't quite go far enough to really satisfy. Had we known it would turn out so wonderfully, why not open up in a big way? Let those poisonous weeds grow, let those ox-demons and snake-spirits come on stage, what are you afraid of? Back in March I said don't be afraid. Some comrades in our Party are just afraid of great disorder under heaven. I said these comrades are utterly loyal, devoted to the Party and the country, it's just that they haven't seen the overall situation, they haven't reckoned on the great majority, that is, the ninety-odd percent of people who are good people. Don't be afraid of the masses, they are with us. They may curse us, but they don't hit us with their fists. The Rightists are only a tiny minority; as I just said about Peking University, only one, two, three percent. That's speaking of students. When it comes to professors and associate professors, it's somewhat different, there are about ten percent Rightists. The Leftists are also about ten percent. The two sides are evenly matched. The middle elements make up about eighty percent. What is there to be afraid of? Some of our comrades have that sort of fear, afraid the house will collapse, afraid the sky will fall. Since ancient times there has only been "the man of Qi who worried about the sky," that is, that man from Henan who was afraid the sky would fall. Apart from him, no one has ever been afraid of the sky falling. As for the house, I don't think this house will collapse; it was only built not long ago, how could it collapse so easily?

In short, no matter where, ninety-odd percent of people are our friends and comrades, don't be afraid. How can you be afraid of the masses? Being afraid of the masses makes no sense. What is a leading figure? Group leaders, squad leaders, branch secretaries, school principals, Party committee secretaries are all leading figures, and there's also Comrade Ke Qingshi, and I count as one too. All of us have some political capital, namely that we have done some things, more or less, for the people. Now the fire is set and burning, and more than ninety percent of people hope that it will burn our comrades into better shape. Every one of our comrades has some faults; who has no faults? "Man is not a sage; who can be without fault?" One is bound to say some wrong things and do some wrong things, things like bureaucratism. These things are often unconscious.

We must "set fires" periodically. How shall we do it in future? Do you think we should burn once a year or once every three years? I think at the least it should be like leap years and leap months: one go-round in three years, another in five, at least twice within each Five-Year Plan. Sun Wukong became even better after being tempered in the Eight Trigrams Furnace of the Supreme Lord Lao. Isn't Sun Wukong a formidable figure? People call him "the Great Sage Equal to Heaven," yet he still had to be burned in the Eight Trigrams Furnace. Don't we talk about tempering, duanlian? Duan means hammering, lian means smelting iron in a blast furnace and smelting steel in an open-hearth furnace. After steel is smelted it must be forged. Nowadays forging is done with a steam hammer. That forging is fierce indeed! We people need tempering too. Some comrades, if you ask them whether they're in favor of tempering, they're very much in favor: "Ah, I have shortcomings, I'd very much like to go and get some tempering." Everyone says they want to be tempered. Talking about tempering in ordinary times is very comfortable, but when it comes to real tempering, when you really take a steam hammer and pound him, he won't have it, he's scared off. This time was a tempering. For a while heaven and earth were dark, and the sun and moon gave no light. Two winds were blowing: one was the great majority of good people, who put up big-character posters saying the Communist Party has shortcomings and must correct them; the other was the tiny minority of Rightists, who were attacking us. The attacks from both sides came from the same direction. But the attack by the majority was proper, they attacked correctly. This was a tempering for us. The Rightists' attack was also a tempering for us. Speaking truly of tempering, this time we really must thank the Rightists. For our Party, for the broad masses, for the working class, the peasants, the young students, and the democratic parties, the Rightists provided the greatest education. Every city has some Rightists, and these Rightists want to overthrow us. As for these Rightists, we are now encircling and suppressing them.

Our revolution is a people's revolution, the revolution of six hundred million people led by the proletariat, it is the cause of the people. The democratic revolution is the cause of the people, the socialist revolution is the cause of the people, socialist construction is the cause of the people. Well then, are the socialist revolution and socialist construction good or not? Have there been achievements? Are the achievements primary, or are the mistakes primary? The Rightists deny the achievements of the people's cause. That is the first point. The second point: which direction do we go? Going this way is socialism, going that way is capitalism. The Rightists want to reverse this direction and take the capitalist road. The third point: if we are to build socialism, who will lead? Will the proletariat lead, or will the bourgeoisie lead? Will the Communist Party lead, or will those bourgeois Rightists lead? The Rightists say we don't want Communist Party leadership. I think this time is a great debate, a great debate on these three questions. Having a debate is good. These questions had never been debated.

The democratic revolution went through a long period of debate. From the end of the Qing dynasty through the 1911 Revolution, the opposition to Yuan Shikai, the Northern Expedition, and the War of Resistance Against Japan, there was debate all along. Should we resist Japan or not? One faction held the theory that weapons decide everything, saying China did not have enough guns and could not resist; another faction said there was nothing to fear, people are still primary, and though our weapons were inferior to theirs, we could still fight. The War of Liberation that followed also went through debate. The Chongqing negotiations, the old Political Consultative Conference in Chongqing, the Nanjing negotiations, all were debates. Chiang Kai-shek would not listen to any of our views or the people's views; he wanted war. The result of the fighting was that he lost. So that democratic revolution went through debate, went through a long period of mental preparation.

The socialist revolution came in a hurry. Within six or seven years, the socialist transformation of capitalist ownership and of the individual ownership of small producers was basically completed. But as for the transformation of people, although some have been transformed, there is still a shortfall. Socialist transformation has two aspects: one is the transformation of the system, the other is the transformation of people. The system is not just ownership; there is also the superstructure, chiefly the organs of political power and ideology. Newspapers, for example, belong to the sphere of ideology. Some people say newspapers have no class character, that newspapers are not instruments of class struggle. That is not correct. At least until imperialism is eliminated, newspapers and all kinds of ideological things will reflect class relations. School education, literature and art are all ideology, all superstructure, and all have class character. Natural science has two aspects: natural science itself has no class character, but who studies and uses natural science does have class character. In the universities, the Chinese department and the history department have the most idealism. Among those who run newspapers, there is the most idealism. Don't think that there's a lot of idealism only in the social sciences; there's also a great deal of idealism in the natural sciences. Many people who work in natural science have an idealist world outlook. If you ask what water is made of, they are materialists: water is made of two elements, they act according to the actual facts. If you talk about how to transform society, they are idealists. We say the rectification is meant to rectify the Communist Party and make it better; some of them say it should eliminate the Communist Party. This time such things were exposed.

When the Rightists were attacking, our policy was this: only listen, don't speak. For several weeks we braced our scalps, stretched our ears a bit longer, and just listened, without saying a single word. Moreover, we did not notify the League members, did not notify the Party members, did not notify the branch secretaries, did not notify the branch committees; we let them fight a free-for-all, each making up his own mind. Some enemies had sneaked into the Party committees and general branches of the schools; there were enemies among the members of the Party committee of Tsinghua University. As soon as you held a meeting here, he would tell the enemy. These are called "defecting elements." Don't we have defecting generals? These are "defecting literati." Both the enemy and we were pleased about this. On the enemy's side, seeing Communist Party members "defect," and the Communist Party about to "collapse," they were very pleased. How many collapsed this time? I don't know about Shanghai; in Beijing's schools, about five percent of Party members collapsed, a bit more of the League members, perhaps ten percent or a bit more. This kind of collapse, I say, is perfectly just. Ten percent is fine, twenty percent is fine, thirty percent is fine, forty percent is fine; in short, when they collapse I'm extremely pleased. Your head is full of bourgeois ideas, full of idealism, and you've wormed your way into the Communist Party and the Youth League, communist in name but in fact anti-communist, or a vacillating element. So on our side, when we see people "defect," we are pleased too. In what year was a purge of the Party and the League ever this clean? They ran off by themselves, we didn't have to clean them out. But now the situation has changed, it has reversed. Once we surrounded the Rightists, and many people who had links with the Rightists but were not Rightists themselves stood up and exposed them, they stopped "defecting." Now it's hard for the Rightists to muddle along, and some Rightists have defected. In the hundred days since I spoke here in March, the situation has undergone such a great change.

The nature of this anti-Rightist struggle is mainly a political struggle. Class struggle takes various forms; this time it is mainly a political struggle, not a military struggle, not an economic struggle. Is there an element of ideological struggle? Yes, but I think the political struggle is the main component. The ideological struggle will come mainly in the next stage, and that must be like a gentle breeze and mild rain. The rectification of the Communist Party and the rectification of the Youth League are ideological struggles. We must raise ourselves a step and really learn some Marxism. We must truly help one another. What shortcomings do we have? Is there a bit of subjectivism or not? Is there a bit of bureaucratism or not? We must really use our brains and think, write some notes, do this for a few months, and raise our level of Marxism, our political level, and our ideological level a step higher.

The counterattack against the Rightists may take several more tens of days, another month or so. If Rightist statements kept being published in the newspapers like this, published this year, published next year, published the year after, that would make it hard to get things done. There are only so many Rightists, and their statements have been just about all published; there isn't that much left to publish. From now on we'll publish a bit in the shade and a bit in the sun, publish some when there is some, and not publish when there isn't. I think July will still be a tense month of counterattacking the Rightists. The Rightists like violent storms best and like gentle breezes and mild rain least. Don't we advocate gentle breezes and mild rain? They say gentle breezes and mild rain are like the plum rains falling every day: the seedlings rot, and there will be famine, so violent storms are better. Didn't someone here in Shanghai write an article called "The Crow Caws in the Daytime"? That "crow" put forward this view. They also say: you Communists are unfair; in the past when you rectified us it was violent storms, now when you rectify yourselves it's gentle breezes and mild rain. In fact, when we carried out thought reform before, including the criticism of Hu Shi and Liang Shuming, the directives we issued within the Party all called for gentle breezes and mild rain. Things in the world are always tortuous. Walking a road, for example, you always go winding this way and that. Have you been to Mount Mogan? Going up and coming down there are eighteen hairpin turns. Social movements always advance in a spiral. Now the Rightists still have to be dug out, we cannot slacken, it is still violent storms. Because they started a violent storm, it seems as if we are retaliating against them. Only at this point do the Rightists realize the merits of gentle breezes and mild rain. Wherever he sees a blade of grass he wants to grab it, because he's sinking. Like a man about to drown in the Huangpu River, he wants to grab even a single straw. I think that "crow" now very much welcomes gentle breezes and mild rain. Now it's the rainstorm season; once July is past, by August we can have gentle breezes and mild rain, because there won't be much left to dig out.

The Rightists are very good teachers by negative example. In our China it has always been so: there are teachers by positive example and teachers by negative example. People need education from both the positive and the negative sides. Japanese imperialism was our first great teacher by negative example. Before that there were also the Qing government, Yuan Shikai, the Beiyang warlords, and later Chiang Kai-shek; all were very good teachers by negative example for us. Without them, the Chinese people could not have been fully educated; the Communist Party alone acting as positive teacher would not have been enough. It's the same now. There are many things we say that they won't listen to. When I say they won't listen, who won't listen? Many middle elements won't listen, and especially the Rightists won't listen. The middle elements half believe and half doubt. The Rightists simply won't listen; we've told them many things, but they don't listen, they go and do things their own way. For example, we advocate "unity—criticism—unity," and they won't listen. We say the achievements of the campaign to suppress counter-revolutionaries are primary, and again they won't listen. We say we must have democratic centralism, must have the people's democratic dictatorship led by the proletariat, and again they won't listen. We say we must unite with the socialist countries and the peace-loving peoples of the whole world, and they won't listen to that either. In short, we've said all these things, and they won't listen to any of them. There's another thing they particularly won't listen to, which is that poisonous weeds must be hoed out. Let the ox-demons and snake-spirits come out, then put them on display, and after the display everyone will say the ox-demons and snake-spirits are bad and must be knocked down. Let the poisonous weeds come out, then hoe them out; once hoed down they can be used as fertilizer. Did we say these things or not? Didn't we say them? The poisonous weeds still had to come out. Every year the peasants tell those weeds the same thing, that is, every year they hoe them several times, but the weeds simply don't listen, they still grow. Hoe for ten thousand years, and the weeds still grow; for a hundred million years, they'll still grow. The Rightists weren't afraid of hoeing, because when I spoke, I only talked about hoeing weeds and didn't actually start hoeing; moreover, they thought they themselves were not poisonous weeds but fragrant flowers, and that we were the poisonous weeds; they weren't the ones to be hoed out, but rather they wanted to hoe us out. They never thought that they were precisely the things that ought to be hoed out.

Now we are debating those three questions I spoke of above. The socialist revolution came in a hurry, and the Party's general line for the transition period was not fully debated, not fully debated within the Party, nor fully debated in society. Like a cow eating grass: first it gulps it down, stores it in a pouch, and then brings it back up and chews it slowly. In our system, first in the ownership of the means of production and second in the superstructure, whether the political system or ideology, we carried out the socialist revolution, but without a full debate. This time, through the newspapers, through forums, through mass meetings, through big-character posters, the debate is being unfolded.

The big-character poster is a good thing; I think it should be passed down. Confucius's Analects have been passed down, the "Five Classics" and the "Thirteen Classics" have been passed down, the "Twenty-Four Histories" have all been passed down. Shouldn't the big-character poster be passed down? I think it must be passed down. For example, when rectification is carried out in the factories in future, should there be big-character posters? I think it's good to use big-character posters, the more the better. Big-character posters have no class character, just as language has no class character. The vernacular has no class character; when people like us give speeches we speak the vernacular, and Chiang Kai-shek speaks the vernacular too. Nobody speaks classical Chinese anymore, nobody says "Is it not a pleasure to learn and to practice what one has learned at due times?" or "Is it not a joy to have friends come from afar?" The proletariat speaks the vernacular, and the bourgeoisie speaks the vernacular too. The proletariat can use big-character posters, and the bourgeoisie can use big-character posters too. We believe the majority stand on the side of the proletariat. Therefore the big-character poster as a tool favors the proletariat and does not favor the bourgeoisie. For a time, two or three weeks, heaven and earth were dark and the sun and moon gave no light, and it seemed to favor the bourgeoisie. When we talked about bracing our scalps and holding firm, it was those two or three weeks, when we couldn't sleep and couldn't eat. Don't you talk about tempering? A few weeks of not being able to sleep or eat, that's tempering; it's not that you have to be stuffed into a blast furnace and burned.

Many middle elements wavered a bit, and that's also very good. By wavering a bit, they gained experience. The characteristic of the middle elements is wavering; otherwise why would they be called the middle? At this end is the proletariat, at that end is the bourgeoisie, and there are many middle elements, small at both ends and big in the middle. But the middle elements are, in the final analysis, good people; they are allies of the proletariat. The bourgeoisie also wants to win them over as allies, and for a time they did look a bit like it. Because the middle elements criticized us too, but theirs was well-intentioned criticism. When the Rightists saw the middle elements criticizing us, they came and stirred up trouble. Here in Shanghai, it was people like Wang Zaoshi, Lu Yi, Chen Renbing, Peng Wenying, and also a Wu Yin, Rightist figures like these who came out to stir up trouble. As soon as the Rightists stirred up trouble, the middle elements got confused. The ancestors of the Rightists are Zhang Bojun, Luo Longji and Zhang Naiqi, and the place of origin was Beijing. In Beijing, the more chaotic the better, the more thoroughly chaotic the better. That is one lesson of experience.

What I just said about big-character posters is a question of method, a question of what form of combat to adopt. Big-character posters are one of the weapons of combat, like rifles, pistols, machine guns and other light weapons. As for aircraft and artillery, those are probably the likes of the Wenhui Bao, and also the Guangming Daily, and some other newspapers as well. For a time, the Communist Party's newspapers also published Rightist statements. We issued an order that all Rightist statements must be published exactly as they were. By using this method and various other methods, we enabled the broad masses to receive education from both the positive and negative sides. For example, the staff of the Guangming Daily and the Wenhui Bao received a very profound education this time. In the past they could not tell what a proletarian newspaper was and what a bourgeois newspaper was, what a socialist newspaper was and what a capitalist newspaper was. For a time, their Rightist leaders turned the newspapers into bourgeois newspapers. These Rightist leaders hate the proletariat and hate socialism. Rather than guiding the schools in the proletarian direction, they want to guide them in the bourgeois direction.

Should the bourgeoisie and the intellectuals who came over from the old society be transformed or not? They are extremely afraid of transformation; they say transformation produces a certain feeling, called an "inferiority complex," and the more they are transformed the more inferior they feel. This is a wrong way of putting it. It should be that the more they are transformed the more self-respect they have; it should be a feeling of self-respect, because they themselves have become aware of the need for transformation. Those people have a very high "class consciousness"; they believe they themselves need no transformation, but on the contrary want to transform the proletariat. They want to transform the world in the image of the bourgeoisie, while the proletariat wants to transform the world in the image of the proletariat. I think the majority, more than ninety percent of people, after going through a process of hesitation, consideration, reluctance and vacillation, will in the end come to be willing to be transformed. The more they are transformed, the more they will feel the need for transformation. The Communist Party is still being transformed; rectification is transformation, and there will be further rectifications in the future. Do you think that after this rectification there won't be another? That after this rectification there will be no more bureaucratism? Give it just two or three years and he'll have forgotten all about it, and the bureaucratism will be back. People have that trait: they forget easily. So every so often there must be a rectification. If even the Communist Party needs rectification, does it mean that the bourgeoisie and the intellectuals who came over from the old society don't need rectification? Don't need transformation? They need rectification all the more, and transformation all the more.

Aren't the democratic parties now carrying out rectification? The whole of society should carry out some rectification. What's wrong with rectifying the style of work a bit? And it's not about rectifying trivial chicken-feather and garlic-skin matters, but about rectifying big matters, rectifying questions of line. The focus of the democratic parties' rectification now is on the question of line, on rectifying the counter-revolutionary line of the bourgeois Rightists. I think that's correct. The focus of the Communist Party's rectification now is not the question of line but the question of work style. For the democratic parties, the question of work style is secondary for now; the main thing is which line to follow. Is it to follow the counter-revolutionary line of Zhang Bojun, Luo Longji, Zhang Naiqi, Chen Renbing, Peng Wenying, Lu Yi and Sun Dayu, or some other line? This question must be made clear first; the three questions I've spoken of must be made clear: the achievements of the socialist revolution and socialist construction, are the things hundreds of millions of people have done good or not? Do we take the socialist road or the capitalist road? If we are to build socialism, which party is to lead? Is the Zhang-Luo alliance to lead, or the Communist Party? Let's have a great debate and make the question of line clear.

The Communist Party also has a question of line; with regard to those "defecting elements," the Rightists within the Communist Party and the Youth League, it is a question of line. Dogmatism is not at present a question of line, because it has not taken shape. In our Party's history there were several questions of dogmatist lines, because they took shape as systems, as policies, as programs. Present-day dogmatism has not taken shape as systems, policies or programs; it does have some rigid elements, but now, with this blow of the hammer and this burning by the fire, it has softened a bit. Aren't the leaders of the various organs, schools and factories "coming downstairs"? They no longer want that Kuomintang style and lordly airs, they no longer play the official and the lord. Cooperative chairmen till the fields together with the masses, factory directors and Party committee secretaries go into the workshops and labor together with the workers, and bureaucratism has greatly decreased. This rectification will have to continue in the future. There should be big-character posters and forums, and the problems that should be corrected and the problems that should be criticized should all be sorted and resolved. Further, we must raise ourselves a step and learn some Marxism.

I believe that the majority of us Chinese are good people, that our Chinese nation is a good nation. Our nation is very reasonable, very warm-hearted, very intelligent, very brave. I hope to bring about this kind of situation: one with both centralization and unity and liveliness and vitality, that is, with both centralism and democracy, both discipline and freedom. Both sides, not just one side; not only discipline, only centralism, sealing everyone's mouths, not allowing people to speak, not even allowing criticism of things that are actually wrong. Speaking out should be encouraged, things should be lively and vigorous. Whoever puts forward criticism in good faith, the speaker is not to be blamed; no matter how sharp you are, no matter how roundly you curse, there's no crime, you won't be punished, you won't be given tight shoes to wear. Tight shoes are uncomfortable to wear. Now whom shall we give tight shoes to wear? Now we'll give them to the Rightists. It is necessary to give the Rightists some tight shoes to wear.

Don't be afraid of the masses; be together with the masses. Some comrades are afraid of the masses just as they are afraid of water. Do you swim or not? I promote swimming everywhere. Water is a good thing. If you just learn for an hour every day, without interruption, going today, going tomorrow, for a hundred days, I guarantee you'll learn to swim. First, don't hire a teacher; second, don't take a rubber ring; if you use that rubber ring you'll never learn. "But my life matters, I can't swim!" Then swim in the shallow water first. If you're learning for a hundred days, spend thirty days in the shallow water and you'll have learned. Once you've learned, then whether you go to the Yangtze or to the Pacific, it's all the same, it's just water, just that same stuff. Some say that if you go under in a swimming pool they can pull you out right away and you won't die, but swimming in the Yangtze is terrible, the current is so swift, if you sink where will they look for you? They use this argument to scare people. I say these are the words of laymen. Our swimming heroes, the instructors and professors at the swimming pools, originally didn't dare go into the Yangtze, but now they all dare. Aren't there people swimming in your Huangpu River now too? The Huangpu and the Yangtze are swimming pools that don't cost a cent. To use a metaphor: the people are like the water, and leaders at every level are like swimmers. You must not leave the water, you must go with the water, not against the water. Don't scold the masses; the masses must not be scolded! The working masses, the peasant masses, the student masses, the majority of the members of the democratic parties, the majority of the intellectuals, you must not scold them, you must not set yourself against the masses, you must always be with the masses. The masses can also make mistakes. When they make mistakes, we should reason with them properly; if they don't listen when we reason properly, wait a while and speak again when there's a chance. But don't cut yourself off from them, just as when we swim we must not leave the water. When Liu Bei got Kongming, he said it was "like a fish getting water"; this really happened, it's not only written that way in the novel, it's written that way in history too, and it's just like the relationship between fish and water. The masses are Kongming, the leaders are Liu Bei. One leads, the other is led.

All wisdom comes from the masses. I have always said that intellectuals are the most ignorant. That is putting it thoroughly. When intellectuals cock their tails up, they're longer than the tail of Sun Xingzhe. Sun Xingzhe had seventy-two transformations, and in the end he turned his tail into a flagpole, that long. When intellectuals cock their tails up, it's really something! "Even if I'm not number one under heaven, I'm at least number two." "What are workers and peasants? You're just 'A Dou,' you can't even read many characters." But questions of the overall situation are not decided by intellectuals; in the end they are decided by the laborers, and moreover by the most advanced part of the laborers, that is, the proletariat.

Does the proletariat lead the bourgeoisie, or does the bourgeoisie lead the proletariat? Does the proletariat lead the intellectuals, or do the intellectuals lead the proletariat? Intellectuals should become proletarian intellectuals; there is no other way out. "With the skin gone, what can the hair attach to?" In the past this "hair," the intellectuals, was attached to five "skins," that is, they lived off five skins. The first skin was imperialist ownership. The second skin was feudal ownership. The third skin was bureaucrat-capitalist ownership. Wasn't the democratic revolution about overthrowing the three great mountains? That is, overthrowing imperialism, feudalism and bureaucrat-capitalism. The fourth skin was national-capitalist ownership. The fifth skin was the ownership of small production, that is, the individual ownership of peasants and handicraftsmen. Intellectuals in the past were attached to the first three skins, or attached to the last two skins, attached to these skins to make a living. Do these five skins still exist now? "The skin is gone." The imperialists have run off, and their properties have all been taken over. Feudal ownership has been eliminated; the land all belongs to the peasants, and now it has been collectivized as well. The bureaucrat-capitalist enterprises have been nationalized. National-capitalist industry and commerce have adopted joint state-private ownership and have basically (not yet completely) become socialist. The individual ownership of peasants and handicraftsmen has become collective ownership, though this system is not yet consolidated and will take several more years to consolidate. These five skins are all gone, but they still influence the "hair," still influence these capitalists, still influence these intellectuals. In their heads they always remember those few skins, they remember them even in their dreams. People who came over from the old society, from the old tracks, always hanker after that old life and those old habits. So the transformation of people takes even longer.

Now, what skin are the intellectuals attached to? They're attached to the skin of public ownership, attached to the proletariat. Who feeds them? The workers and the peasants. Intellectuals are teachers hired by the working class and the laborers. You teach their children, yet you don't listen to your master, you want to teach your own stuff, teach the eight-legged essay, teach Confucius, or teach that capitalist stuff, and turn out some counter-revolutionaries; the working class won't stand for it, they'll dismiss you, and next year they won't send you a letter of appointment.

A hundred days ago I said here that the intellectuals who came from the old society now have no foundation; they have lost their original social and economic foundation, that is, those five skins are gone, and they have nowhere to land unless it's on the new skin. Some intellectuals now are like fifteen buckets drawing water from a well, seven going up and eight going down. They fly about in mid-air, not reaching heaven above nor touching the earth below. I say these people are "gentlemen on the beam." They fly about on that beam; they want to go back, but over there it's empty, those skins are gone, they can't go back to their old home. Their old home is gone, yet they are not willing to attach themselves to the proletariat. If you want to attach yourself to the proletariat, you have to study proletarian thought a bit, have some feeling for the proletariat, make friends with workers and peasants. They won't; they also know that it's empty over there, but they still long for that thing. What we're doing now is urging them to wake up. After this great criticism, I think they will wake up to some degree.

Those intellectuals in the middle state should wake up, and not cock their tails up too high; your knowledge is limited. I say such people are intellectuals and also not intellectuals; it's more appropriate to call them semi-intellectuals. Because your knowledge only goes so far, and when you talk about the big principles you make mistakes. I won't talk now about those Rightist intellectuals; they are reactionaries. The mistake made by the middle-of-the-road intellectuals is vacillation, not seeing the direction clearly, losing their bearings for a while. With all that knowledge of yours, why did you make mistakes? With you being so formidable, with your tail cocked up so high, why did you vacillate? A clump of grass on top of a wall bends whichever way the wind blows. This shows you don't have all that much knowledge. In this respect, the ones with much knowledge are the workers and the semi-proletarians among the peasants. Things like Sun Dayu's stuff, they see at a glance that it's wrong. Look who has high knowledge? It's those who can't read many characters; their knowledge is high. To decide the overall situation, to decide the general direction, we must turn to the proletariat. I'm just that kind of person: when I want to do something, when I want to decide some major plan, I absolutely have to ask the worker and peasant masses, talk with them, consult with them, consult with the cadres close to them, and see whether it will work or not. This requires running around to various places. Squatting in Beijing is no good at all; Beijing doesn't produce anything! There are no raw materials there. The raw materials all come from the workers and peasants, they all come from the localities. The Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party is like a processing plant: it takes these raw materials and manufactures them, and it must manufacture them well; if it manufactures them badly it makes mistakes. Knowledge comes from the masses. What does it mean to correctly handle contradictions among the people? It means seeking truth from facts, the mass line. In the final analysis it comes down to the words "mass line." Don't cut yourselves off from the masses; our relationship with the masses is like the relationship between fish and water, between a swimmer and water.

Should the Rightists be beaten to death with a single blow of the club? Giving them a few blows of the club is very necessary. If you don't give them a few blows they'll play dead. With such people, shouldn't you attack them, shouldn't you pursue them? Attacking is necessary. But our aim is to attack them so that they turn back. We use various methods to attack in earnest, to isolate them completely, and then it's possible to win them over; not all of them, but we can always win some of them over to change. They are intellectuals, some are major intellectuals, and winning them over is useful. Once they are won over, let them do some work, more or less. Moreover, this time they've been a great help, they've served as teachers by negative example and educated the people from the negative side. We don't intend to throw them into the Huangpu River; we still take the attitude of curing the sickness to save the patient. Perhaps some people are unwilling to come over. People like Sun Dayu, if he's very stubborn and unwilling to change, then so be it. We have many things to do now; if we attacked every day, attacked him for fifty years, how could we manage that! If there are some people who refuse to change, then you take it with you into your coffin to meet the King of Hell. You tell the King of Hell: I am a defender of the five skins, I have great "backbone," the Communist Party and the masses of the people struggled against me, but I never submitted, I resisted all the way through. But you know, the King of Hell has been replaced too. This King of Hell: first is Marx, second is Engels, third is Lenin. Now there are two hells; the King of Hell of the capitalist world is probably still the old one, but in the socialist world these people are the Kings of Hell. I think the incorrigible Rightists will still be dealt with even a hundred years from now.