On the Correct Handling of Contradictions Among the People

China Mao Zedong · Chairman of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China

27 February 1957 · Eleventh Enlarged Session of the Supreme State Conference

Context
Mao addressed an enlarged state conference on February 27, 1957, distinguishing contradictions among the people from those with the enemy and arguing that the former be resolved by democratic persuasion, not coercion.
Main themes
Two types of contradictions, contradictions among the people versus contradictions with the enemy, people's democratic dictatorship, democratic centralism, unity-criticism-unity method, lessons of the Hungarian events, suppression of counter-revolutionaries, agricultural co-operation, national bourgeoisie, economy and opposing waste, path of China's industrialisation, learning from the Soviet Union
Duration
~125 min
99th percentile
Words
14,955
99th percentile
Sentences
675
99th percentile
Readability
41
39th percentile
Grade
13.0
57th percentile
Syntax
2.98
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from Chinese Source: GitHub qinglee/maoxuan (毛泽东选集) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 35%33%
  • Institutional 34%33%
  • Economic 17%16%
  • Geopolitical 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

675 sentences in 83 paragraphs

On the question of correctly handling contradictions among the people: this is the general topic. For convenience of exposition it is divided into twelve sub-topics. The question of contradictions between ourselves and the enemy will also be mentioned here, but the emphasis is on discussing contradictions among the people.

I. Two Different Types of Contradictions

Our country is now united as never before. The victory of the bourgeois-democratic revolution and of the socialist revolution, together with the achievements of socialist construction, has rapidly changed the face of old China. An even better future for the motherland lies before us. The situation of national division and chaos that the people detested is gone for ever. Our country's six hundred million people, under the leadership of the working class and the Communist Party, are united in carrying out great socialist construction. The unity of the country, the unity of the people and the unity of the various nationalities within the country: these are the basic guarantee that our cause will surely triumph. But this does not mean that there are no longer any contradictions in our society. The idea that there are no contradictions is a naive idea that does not accord with objective reality. Before us there are two types of social contradictions, namely contradictions between ourselves and the enemy and contradictions among the people. These are two types of contradictions of entirely different nature.

In order to recognise correctly these two different types of contradictions, those between ourselves and the enemy and those among the people, we must first make clear what is meant by the people and what is meant by the enemy. The concept of "the people" has different contents in different countries and in different historical periods of each country. Take the situation in our own country. During the War of Resistance to Japan, all classes, strata and social groups that opposed Japan came within the category of the people, while the Japanese imperialists, the traitors to China and the pro-Japanese elements were all enemies of the people. During the War of Liberation, the US imperialists and their running dogs, namely the bureaucrat-bourgeoisie and the landlord class, as well as the Kuomintang reactionaries who represented these classes, were all enemies of the people; all the classes, strata and social groups that opposed these enemies came within the category of the people. At the present stage, the period of building socialism, all classes, strata and social groups that approve, support and take part in the cause of socialist construction come within the category of the people; all social forces and social groups that resist the socialist revolution and are hostile to or sabotage socialist construction are enemies of the people.

The contradictions between ourselves and the enemy are antagonistic contradictions. Contradictions among the people are non-antagonistic as between the working people; as between the exploited class and the exploiting class, apart from their antagonistic aspect there is also a non-antagonistic aspect. Contradictions among the people did not first arise now, but they have different contents in each revolutionary period and in the period of socialist construction. Under the conditions in our country today, what we call contradictions among the people include the contradictions within the working class, within the peasantry, within the intelligentsia, between the working class and the peasantry, between the workers and peasants on the one hand and the intellectuals on the other, between the working class and other working people on the one hand and the national bourgeoisie on the other, within the national bourgeoisie, and so on. Our People's Government is a government that truly represents the interests of the people and serves the people, but it too has certain contradictions with the masses of the people. These contradictions include those between the interests of the state and of the collective and the interests of the individual, between democracy and centralism, between leadership and the led, and between the bureaucratic style of work of certain personnel of state organs and the masses. These contradictions are also contradictions among the people. In general, contradictions among the people are contradictions on the basis of the fundamental identity of the interests of the people.

In our country, the contradiction between the working class and the national bourgeoisie is a contradiction among the people. The class struggle between the working class and the national bourgeoisie in general belongs to the class struggle among the people. This is because the national bourgeoisie of our country has a dual character. In the period of the bourgeois-democratic revolution, it had a revolutionary side and also a side that was prone to compromise. In the period of the socialist revolution, it has a side that exploits the working class to obtain profit and also a side that supports the Constitution and is willing to accept socialist transformation. The national bourgeoisie is different from the imperialists, the landlord class and the bureaucrat-bourgeoisie. Between the working class and the national bourgeoisie there exists the contradiction of exploiter and exploited, which is by nature an antagonistic contradiction. But under the concrete conditions of our country, if this antagonistic contradiction between the two classes is handled properly, it can be transformed into a non-antagonistic one and can be resolved by peaceful means. If we do not handle it properly, that is, if we do not adopt a policy of uniting with, criticising and educating the national bourgeoisie, or if the national bourgeoisie does not accept this policy of ours, then the contradiction between the working class and the national bourgeoisie will turn into a contradiction between ourselves and the enemy.

These two types of contradictions, between ourselves and the enemy and among the people, are different in nature, and the methods of resolving them are also different. Put simply, the former is a question of distinguishing between enemy and friend, the latter a question of distinguishing between right and wrong. Of course, the question of the enemy is also a kind of question of right and wrong. For example, the question of who is right and who is wrong as between us and the reactionaries at home and abroad, the imperialists, the feudalists and the bureaucrat-capitalists, is also a question of right and wrong, but it is another kind of right and wrong, different in nature from questions among the people.

Our country is a people's democratic dictatorship led by the working class and based on the alliance of workers and peasants. What is this dictatorship for? Its first function is to suppress the reactionary classes and reactionary elements within the country and those exploiters who resist the socialist revolution, to suppress those who try to wreck our socialist construction; that is, to resolve the contradictions between ourselves and the enemy within the country. For example, to arrest, try and sentence certain counter-revolutionaries, and for a specified period of time to deprive landlords and bureaucrat-bourgeoisie of the right to vote and the freedom of speech: all this comes within the scope of the dictatorship. To maintain public order and the interests of the broad masses of the people, dictatorship must also be exercised over thieves, swindlers, murderers, arsonists, hooligan gangs and other bad elements who seriously disrupt public order. The second function of the dictatorship is to protect our country from subversive activities and possible aggression by enemies from outside. When such a situation arises, the dictatorship takes on the task of resolving externally the contradiction between ourselves and the enemy. The aim of the dictatorship is to protect all the people so that they can work in peace and build our country into a socialist country with modern industry, modern agriculture and modern science and culture. Who is to exercise the dictatorship? Naturally the working class and the people under its leadership. The system of dictatorship is not applicable within the ranks of the people. The people cannot exercise dictatorship over themselves, nor must one section of the people oppress another. Lawbreakers among the people will also be punished according to law, but this differs in principle from the dictatorship exercised to suppress the enemies of the people. Among the people, democratic centralism is practised. Our Constitution provides that citizens of the People's Republic of China enjoy freedom of speech, of the press, of assembly, of association, of procession, of demonstration, of religious belief, and so on. Our Constitution also provides that the organs of state practise democratic centralism, that they must rely on the masses of the people, and that their personnel must serve the people. This socialist democracy of ours is the broadest democracy, of a kind no bourgeois state could possibly have. Our dictatorship is called the people's democratic dictatorship, led by the working class and based on the alliance of workers and peasants. This means that democracy is practised within the ranks of the people, while the working class, uniting all who enjoy civil rights, in the first place the peasants, exercises dictatorship over the reactionary classes and elements and those who resist socialist transformation and socialist construction. By enjoying civil rights we mean, politically, enjoying the rights of freedom and democracy.

But this freedom is freedom with leadership, and this democracy is democracy under centralised guidance, not anarchy. Anarchy does not accord with the interests or wishes of the people.

After the events in Hungary, some people in our country were glad. They hoped that an event like that would also occur in China, with tens of thousands of people taking to the streets to oppose the People's Government. This hope of theirs runs counter to the interests of the masses of the people and cannot win the support of the masses. A section of the Hungarian masses, deceived by counter-revolutionary forces at home and abroad, mistakenly used violence against the People's Government, with the result that both the country and the people suffered. The few weeks of disorder caused economic losses that will take a long time to make good. Another group of people in our country wavered over the Hungarian question because they did not understand the concrete situation in the world. They thought there was too little freedom under our people's democratic system and that it was not as free as the parliamentary democracy of the West. They demand the Western two-party system, with one party in office and the other out of office. But this so-called two-party system is only a means of upholding the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie; it can never guarantee the freedoms and rights of the working people. In reality, there is in the world only concrete freedom and concrete democracy, and no abstract freedom or abstract democracy. In a society where there is class struggle, once there is freedom for the exploiting classes to exploit the working people, there is no freedom for the working people to be free from exploitation. Where there is bourgeois democracy, there is no democracy for the proletariat and the working people. Some capitalist countries also allow the Communist Party to exist legally, but only within the limit that it does not endanger the fundamental interests of the bourgeoisie; beyond that limit it is not tolerated. Those who demand abstract freedom and abstract democracy regard democracy as an end and do not recognise that it is a means. Democracy sometimes seems to be an end, but in fact it is only a means. Marxism tells us that democracy belongs to the superstructure and to the realm of politics. That is to say, in the last analysis it serves the economic base. The same is true of freedom. Both democracy and freedom are relative, not absolute, and both arise and develop in history. Among the people, democracy is the counterpart of centralism, and freedom the counterpart of discipline. These are two contradictory aspects of a unity; they are contradictory and also united, and we should not one-sidedly stress one aspect and negate the other. Among the people, we cannot do without freedom, nor can we do without discipline; we cannot do without democracy, nor can we do without centralism. This unity of democracy and centralism, of freedom and discipline, is our democratic centralism. Under this system the people enjoy broad democracy and freedom; at the same time they must restrain themselves with socialist discipline. The broad masses of the people understand these principles.

Our advocacy of freedom with leadership and of democracy under centralised guidance does not in any sense mean that ideological questions among the people, or questions of distinguishing right from wrong, can be settled by coercion. Attempting to settle ideological questions and questions of right and wrong by administrative orders and by coercion is not only ineffective but harmful. We cannot abolish religion by administrative order, nor force people not to believe in it. We cannot force people to give up idealism, any more than we can force them to believe in Marxism. All questions of an ideological nature and all controversial questions among the people can be settled only by democratic methods, only by discussion, criticism, persuasion and education, and not by coercive, high-handed methods. In order to carry on production, study and an orderly life effectively, the people require their government, the leaders of production and the heads of cultural and educational bodies to issue various appropriate administrative orders of a binding character. Without such administrative orders, public order could not be maintained; this is understood by common sense. It is complementary to settling contradictions among the people by persuasion and education; the two are aspects that supplement each other. Administrative orders issued for the purpose of maintaining public order must also be accompanied by persuasion and education, since administrative orders alone will in many cases get nowhere.

In 1942 we embodied this democratic method of resolving contradictions among the people in a formula: "unity—criticism—unity". To put it in more detail, it means starting from a desire for unity, resolving the contradictions through criticism or struggle, and arriving at a new unity on a new basis. According to our experience, this is a correct method of resolving contradictions among the people. In 1942 we used this method to resolve contradictions within the Communist Party, that is, the contradictions between the dogmatists and the broad mass of Party members, and between dogmatist ideas and Marxist ideas. The method of inner-Party struggle formerly adopted by the "Left" dogmatists was called "ruthless struggle and merciless blows". This was a wrong method. In criticising "Left" dogmatism we did not use this old method but adopted a new one, namely starting from a desire for unity, distinguishing right from wrong through criticism or struggle, and arriving at a new unity on a new basis. This method was used in the rectification campaign of 1942. After a few years, when the Chinese Communist Party held its Seventh National Congress in 1945, the aim of unity of the whole Party was indeed achieved, and the great victory of the people's revolution was thereby won. Here the first requirement is to start from a desire for unity. For if there is no subjective desire for unity, then once the struggle begins it is bound to throw things into confusion and get out of hand; would that not be "ruthless struggle and merciless blows"? What unity of the Party would there be then? From this experience we found a formula: unity—criticism—unity. Or, in other words, learn from past mistakes to avoid future ones, and cure the sickness to save the patient. We extended this method beyond the Party. In all the anti-Japanese base areas, we used it in handling the relations between leaders and the masses, between army and people, between officers and men, between different sections of the army, and between different groups of cadres, and we achieved great success. This question can be traced back much further in the history of our Party. Ever since 1927, when we began to build revolutionary armed forces and revolutionary base areas in the south, this method was used in handling relations between Party and masses, army and people, officers and men, and other relations among the people. But in the anti-Japanese period we placed this method on a more conscious basis. After the liberation of the whole country, we also applied the method of "unity—criticism—unity" to the democratic parties and to industrialists and businessmen. Our task now is to continue to extend this method throughout the ranks of the people and to apply it better, and we require that all factories, co-operatives, shops, schools, offices and organisations, in short all six hundred million people, use this method to resolve their internal contradictions.

Under ordinary circumstances, contradictions among the people are not antagonistic. But if they are not handled properly, or if we lose our vigilance and become careless and complacent, antagonism may arise. In a socialist country such a situation is usually only a local and temporary phenomenon. This is because the system of man exploiting man has been abolished in a socialist country and the interests of the people are fundamentally identical. The fairly widespread antagonistic actions manifested in the Hungarian events came about because counter-revolutionary factors at home and abroad were at work. This was a special and also a temporary phenomenon. The reactionaries inside a socialist country collude with the imperialists, exploit contradictions among the people, sow discord and stir up trouble in an attempt to carry out their plots. This lesson of the Hungarian events deserves everyone's attention.

Many people feel that the proposal to use democratic methods to resolve contradictions among the people is a new question. This is not so. Marxists have always held that the cause of the proletariat can only depend on the masses of the people, and that Communists working among the working people must use democratic methods of persuasion and education and must on no account adopt a commandist attitude or coercive means. The Chinese Communist Party faithfully abides by this principle of Marxism-Leninism. We have always advocated that under the people's democratic dictatorship, two different methods, dictatorship and democracy, be used to resolve the two types of contradictions of different nature, those between ourselves and the enemy and those among the people. This point has been made many times in many documents of our Party in the past and in the statements of many of its leading members. In my article "On the People's Democratic Dictatorship", written in 1949, I said: "The combination of these two aspects, democracy for the people and dictatorship over the reactionaries, is the people's democratic dictatorship", and in solving problems among the people "the method used is democratic, that is, the method of persuasion, not of compulsion". In my speech at the Second Session of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference in June 1950 I said: "The people's democratic dictatorship has two methods. Towards the enemy, it uses the method of dictatorship, that is, for as long as necessary it does not allow them to take part in political activity, and compels them to obey the laws of the People's Government, to engage in labour and through labour to be transformed into new men. Towards the people, on the contrary, it uses not the method of compulsion but the method of democracy, that is, it must let them take part in political activity, and not compel them to do this or that, but use democratic methods to educate and persuade them. This educational work is the self-education of the people, and the method of criticism and self-criticism is the basic method of self-education." In the past we have spoken many times about using democratic methods to resolve contradictions among the people, and in our work we have basically done so, and many cadres and people have in practice understood this question. Why, then, do some people now feel that it is a new question? It is because in the past the struggle between ourselves and the enemy at home and abroad was very sharp, and contradictions among the people did not yet attract attention as they do now.

Many people cannot clearly distinguish between these two types of contradictions of different nature, those between ourselves and the enemy and those among the people, and tend to confuse them. It must be admitted that these two types of contradictions are sometimes easily confused. We too have confused them in our past work. In the work of liquidating counter-revolutionaries, good people were mistaken for bad. This happened before and still happens now. That our mistakes have not been magnified is because our policy provides that we must distinguish between enemy and friend and that wrongs must be redressed once they are found.

Marxist philosophy holds that the law of the unity of opposites is the fundamental law of the universe. This law operates universally, whether in nature, in human society or in men's thinking. Opposites in contradiction are both united and in struggle, and this impels things to move and change. Contradiction is universal, but its nature differs according to the nature of the thing. For any concrete thing, the unity of opposites is conditional, temporary and transitory, and hence relative, while the struggle of opposites is absolute. Lenin explained this law very clearly. In our country more and more people have come to understand it. But for many people, to recognise this law is one thing, and to apply it in examining and handling problems is another. Many people dare not openly admit that contradictions still exist among our people, although it is precisely these contradictions that push our society forward. Many people do not admit that there are still contradictions in socialist society, and as a result they are timid and passive when confronted with social contradictions; they do not understand that in the process of continually and correctly handling and resolving contradictions, the unity and solidarity within socialist society will grow ever stronger. It is therefore necessary to explain this among our people, first of all among the cadres, to guide people to recognise the contradictions in socialist society and to understand how to handle such contradictions with correct methods.

The contradictions in socialist society are fundamentally different from those in the old societies, for example in capitalist society. The contradictions in capitalist society find expression in acute antagonisms and conflicts, in sharp class struggle; such contradictions cannot be resolved by the capitalist system itself, and can be resolved only by socialist revolution. The contradictions in socialist society are another matter; on the contrary, they are non-antagonistic and can be resolved continually by the socialist system itself.

In socialist society the basic contradictions are still the contradiction between the relations of production and the productive forces, and the contradiction between the superstructure and the economic base. It is only that these contradictions in socialist society are fundamentally different in character and condition from the contradictions between the relations of production and the productive forces and between the superstructure and the economic base in the old societies. The social system of our country today is far superior to that of the old days. If it were not superior, the old system would not have been overthrown and the new system could not have been established. When we say that the socialist relations of production are more suited than those of the old days to the development of the productive forces, we mean that they permit the productive forces to develop at a speed unknown in the old society, so that production expands continually and the constantly growing needs of the people can be met step by step. Under the rule of imperialism, feudalism and bureaucrat-capitalism, the development of the productive forces in old China was extremely slow. In the fifty-odd years before liberation, steel production in the whole country apart from the Northeast stood at only tens of thousands of tons a year; including the Northeast, the highest annual output in the country was no more than some 900,000 tons. In 1949 the country's steel output was only a little over 100,000 tons. But in just seven years since the liberation of the whole country, steel output has reached over four million tons. Old China had almost no machine-building industry, still less an automobile or aircraft industry; these have all been established now. When the people had overthrown the rule of imperialism, feudalism and bureaucrat-capitalism, where was China to go? Towards capitalism or towards socialism? Many people were unclear in their minds on this question. The facts have answered it: only socialism can save China. The socialist system has promoted a leap forward in the development of our productive forces, and even our enemies abroad cannot but admit this.

But our socialist system has only just been established; it has not yet been completely built and is not yet fully consolidated. In the joint state-private industrial and commercial enterprises, the capitalists still draw a fixed rate of interest, that is, there is still exploitation; as regards ownership, such enterprises are not yet completely socialist in nature. Some of the agricultural producers' co-operatives and handicraft producers' co-operatives are still semi-socialist in character; in the fully socialist co-operatives there are still certain questions of ownership to be resolved. The interrelations of production and exchange among the various branches of the economy are still being gradually established in accordance with socialist principles, and suitable forms are being gradually sought. In the economy of ownership by the whole people and the economy of collective ownership, and between these two forms of socialist economy, the distribution of accumulation and consumption is a complicated question and cannot easily be settled in a completely rational way all at once. In short, the socialist relations of production have been established and they are in harmony with the development of the productive forces; but they are still far from perfect, and these imperfections are in contradiction with the development of the productive forces. Besides this situation of both harmony and contradiction between the relations of production and the development of the productive forces, there is also a situation of both harmony and contradiction between the superstructure and the economic base. The state system and laws of the people's democratic dictatorship, and the socialist ideology guided by Marxism-Leninism, have played a positive role in promoting the victory of socialist transformation and the establishment of the socialist organisation of labour in our country; this superstructure is in harmony with the socialist economic base, that is, the socialist relations of production. But the existence of bourgeois ideology, the existence of a bureaucratic style of work in some state organs, and the existence of defects in certain links of the state system are in contradiction with the socialist economic base. In future we must continue to resolve these various contradictions in accordance with the concrete conditions. Of course, after these contradictions are resolved, new problems and new contradictions will emerge and will have to be resolved in turn. For example, the contradiction between social production and social needs, which will long exist objectively, needs to be regulated from time to time through state planning. Every year our country makes an economic plan to arrange a suitable proportion between accumulation and consumption and to achieve a balance between production and needs. Balance means the temporary, relative unity of contradictions. After a year, taken as a whole, this balance is broken by the struggle of contradictions, this unity changes, balance becomes imbalance and unity becomes disunity, and a balance and unity for the second year has to be worked out. This is the superiority of our planned economy. In fact, every month and every quarter this balance and unity are being broken in part, and partial readjustments have to be made. Sometimes, because the subjective arrangements do not correspond to objective conditions, contradictions arise and the balance is upset; this is what is called making a mistake. The constant emergence and constant resolution of contradictions is the dialectical law of the development of things.

The present situation is this: the large-scale, turbulent, mass class struggles of the revolutionary period have in the main come to an end, but class struggle has not yet completely ended; the broad masses welcome the new system, yet they do not feel quite accustomed to it; government personnel are also not yet rich enough in experience, and on certain questions of concrete policy we must continue to examine and explore. That is to say, our socialist system still needs a process of continued establishment and consolidation, the masses of the people still need a process of getting accustomed to the new system, and state personnel also need a process of learning and gaining experience. At such a time, it is highly necessary that we put forward the demarcation between the two types of contradictions, those between ourselves and the enemy and those among the people, and put forward the question of correctly handling contradictions among the people, so as to unite the people of all nationalities in the country to wage a new war, a war against nature, to develop our economy and our culture, to enable all the people to pass through the present transition period with relative smoothness, to consolidate our new system and to build our new country.

II. The Question of Suppressing Counter-Revolutionaries

The question of liquidating counter-revolutionaries is a question of the struggle between ourselves and the enemy. Among the people, there are also some differences in views on this question. There are two kinds of opinion that differ from ours. People with Right-leaning ideas do not distinguish between enemy and friend and take the enemy for a friend. Those whom the broad masses regard as enemies they regard as friends. People with "Left" ideas magnify the contradictions between ourselves and the enemy, to the point of treating certain contradictions among the people as contradictions with the enemy, and of regarding as counter-revolutionaries certain people who are not counter-revolutionaries at all. Both views are wrong; neither can handle the question of suppressing counter-revolutionaries correctly, nor assess our work in this field correctly.

To assess our work of suppressing counter-revolutionaries correctly, we may look at the effect of the Hungarian events on our country. After the Hungarian events there was some unrest among a section of our intellectuals, but it stirred up no great waves. What was the reason? It should be said that one reason was that we had eliminated counter-revolutionaries fairly thoroughly.

Of course, the consolidation of our country is not due first of all to the suppression of counter-revolutionaries. The consolidation of our country is due first of all to our having a Communist Party and a People's Liberation Army tempered by decades of revolutionary struggle, and working people tempered by decades of revolutionary struggle. Our Party and army have taken root among the masses and have been steeled in the fires of long revolution, and they have fighting strength. Our People's Republic was not set up suddenly, but developed step by step from the revolutionary base areas. Some democrats have also been tempered to varying degrees and have shared hardships with us. Some intellectuals have been tempered in the struggle against imperialism and reactionary forces, and many have gone through the ideological remoulding since liberation aimed at distinguishing between enemy and friend. In addition, the consolidation of our country is due to the fundamental correctness of our economic measures; the life of the people is stable and is gradually improving; our policies towards the national bourgeoisie and other classes are also correct; and so on. But our success in suppressing counter-revolutionaries is undoubtedly one of the important reasons for the consolidation of our country. Because of all this, although many of our university students still come from families that are not of working people, with few exceptions they are patriotic and support socialism, and they did not waver at the time of the Hungarian events. The same goes for the national bourgeoisie. To say nothing of the basic masses of workers and peasants.

After liberation we eliminated a number of counter-revolutionaries. Some counter-revolutionaries who had committed serious crimes were sentenced to death. This was entirely necessary; it was the demand of the broad masses; it was done to liberate the broad masses who for so long had been oppressed by counter-revolutionaries and tyrannical landlords of all kinds, that is, to liberate the productive forces. Had we not done so, the masses of the people could not have raised their heads. Since 1956, the situation has changed fundamentally. For the country as a whole, the main force of the counter-revolutionaries has been eliminated. Our fundamental task has changed from liberating the productive forces to protecting and developing the productive forces under the new relations of production. There are some people who do not understand that our policy today is suited to today's situation and that the policy of the past was suited to the situation of the past; they want to use today's policy to reverse past verdicts and to deny the great achievements of past work in suppressing counter-revolutionaries. This is entirely wrong, and the masses of the people will not allow it.

In our work of suppressing counter-revolutionaries, the achievements are primary, but there are also mistakes. There have been excesses, and there have been omissions. Our principle is: "Suppress counter-revolutionaries wherever they are found; correct mistakes wherever they are found." The line we follow in this work is the line of the masses suppressing counter-revolutionaries. Having adopted the mass line, there will of course be defects in the work, but they will be fewer and the mistakes will be easier to correct. The masses have gained experience in the struggle. Where they did it correctly, they gained the experience of doing it correctly. Where they made mistakes, they gained the experience of making mistakes.

In this work, for all the mistakes that have been discovered we have taken or are taking steps to correct them. For those not yet discovered, we are prepared to correct them as soon as they are discovered. Wherever the mistake was made, the rehabilitation should be announced within the same scope. I propose that this year or next year a comprehensive review of the work of suppressing counter-revolutionaries be made, to sum up experience, to promote healthy tendencies and to strike down unhealthy ones. At the central level it should be conducted under the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress and the Standing Committee of the CPPCC, and at the local level under the provincial and municipal people's councils and CPPCC committees. In the course of the review, we should not pour cold water on the broad mass of cadres and activists but should help them. It is wrong to pour cold water on the broad mass of cadres and activists. But when mistakes are found they must certainly be corrected. This attitude should be adopted by all the public security, procuratorial and judicial departments, the prisons and the authorities in charge of reform through labour. We hope that members of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress, members of the CPPCC and people's deputies will take part in such reviews wherever possible. This will help to improve our legal system and to handle counter-revolutionaries and other criminals correctly.

The present situation regarding counter-revolutionaries can be described in these two sentences: there are still counter-revolutionaries, but not many. First, there are still counter-revolutionaries. Some say there are none any more, that all is peaceful under heaven and that we can pile our pillows high and sleep. This does not accord with the facts. The fact is that there are still some (of course this does not mean that every place and every unit has them), and we must continue to struggle against them. It must be understood that the hidden counter-revolutionaries who have not been eliminated will not resign themselves to defeat and are bound to make trouble when they get the chance. The US imperialists and the Chiang Kai-shek clique are still constantly sending secret agents here to carry out sabotage. Now that the original counter-revolutionaries have been liquidated, some new ones may still appear. If we lose our vigilance, we shall be badly taken in and suffer heavily. Wherever counter-revolutionaries appear and make trouble, they should be resolutely wiped out. But for the country as a whole, there really are not many counter-revolutionaries left. To say that there are still many counter-revolutionaries in the country is also wrong. If this estimate were accepted, it too would end in confusion.

III. The Question of Agricultural Co-operation

Our country has an agricultural population of over five hundred million, and the condition of the peasants bears greatly on the development of our economy and the consolidation of our state power. I believe the situation is fundamentally good. Co-operation has been completed, and this has resolved the great contradiction between our socialist industrialisation and the individual agricultural economy. Since co-operation was completed so quickly, some people worried whether something would go wrong. Fortunately, there have been some defects, but they are not great and the movement is basically sound. The peasants are very energetic in production; although last year's floods, droughts and storms were greater than in any of the past few years, grain output in the country still increased. Now, however, some people are saying that co-operation is no good and has no superiority, and a small typhoon has blown up. Does co-operation have superiority or not? Among the documents distributed at this meeting today there is one on the Wang Guofan co-operative in Zunhua County, Hebei Province; you may all take a look at it. The place where this co-operative is located is hilly, and has always been very poor, depending year after year on grain shipped in by the People's Government as relief. When the co-operative was started in 1953, people called it the "poor-as-a-beggar's-staff co-operative". After four years of hard struggle it has got better year by year, and the great majority of its members have become households with surplus grain. What the Wang Guofan co-operative can do, other co-operatives should also be able to do under normal conditions, or in a somewhat longer time. From this it can be seen that the arguments that co-operation is no good have no basis.

It can also be seen from this that co-operatives must be built up through hard struggle. The growth of any new thing has to go through difficulties and twists and turns. In the socialist cause, to expect to avoid difficulties and twists and turns, to make no great effort, to have everything go smoothly and success come easily, is only an illusion.

Who are those who actively support the co-operatives? They are the great majority of poor peasants and lower-middle peasants, who make up over seventy per cent of the rural population. Most of the rest also place hope in the co-operatives. Those truly dissatisfied form only a very small minority. Many people have not analysed this situation and have not made an overall examination of the achievements and shortcomings of the co-operatives and of the roots of the shortcomings; they take the partial and one-sided for the whole, and this has blown up among some people a small typhoon to the effect that the co-operatives have no superiority.

How much time will it take for the co-operatives to be consolidated and for the talk that they have no superiority to die down? Judging from the experience of the development of many co-operatives, it will probably take five years, or somewhat more. At present the majority of the co-operatives in the country have a history of only a little over a year, and it is unreasonable to demand that they be so good already. In my view, it will be very good if the co-operatives are set up in the period of the First Five-Year Plan and consolidated in the period of the Second Five-Year Plan.

The co-operatives are going through a process of gradual consolidation. There are still some contradictions in them that need to be resolved. For example, there are contradictions to be resolved between the state and the co-operatives, within the co-operatives, and between one co-operative and another.

We must constantly attend to handling these contradictions through questions of production and questions of distribution. On production, on the one hand the co-operative economy must be subject to the leadership of the unified economic plan of the state, while retaining a certain flexibility and independence within the state's unified plan and its policies and decrees; on the other hand, the families that belong to the co-operatives, apart from their private plots and certain other individually run sidelines, which they may plan appropriately for themselves, must all be subject to the overall plan of the co-operative or the production team. On distribution, we must give consideration to the interests of the state, the collective and the individual. The relations among the state's taxes, the co-operative's accumulation and the peasants' personal income must be handled properly, and the contradictions among them constantly regulated. The state needs accumulation and the co-operatives need accumulation, but neither should take too much. We must as far as possible enable the peasants, in normal years, to increase their personal incomes year by year from increased production.

Many people say that the peasants have a hard life. Is this opinion right? In one respect it is right. That is to say, because our country was oppressed and exploited by the imperialists and their agents for over a hundred years and became a very poor country, not only is the living standard of the peasants low, but the living standard of the workers and intellectuals is also still low. It will take several decades of arduous effort to raise the living standard of all the people step by step. To speak of "hardship" in this sense is appropriate. In another respect it is wrong. That is to say, to claim that in the seven years since liberation the peasants' life has not improved and only the workers' life has improved. In fact, the life of the workers and peasants, apart from a very few, has improved somewhat. Since liberation the peasants have been freed from exploitation by the landlords and production has developed year by year. Take grain as an example: in 1949 the country produced only a little over 210 billion jin, and by 1956 grain output reached over 360 billion jin, an increase of nearly 150 billion jin. The agricultural tax levied by the state is not heavy, only over 30 billion jin a year. Grain purchased from the peasants each year at normal prices is also only over 50 billion jin. The two items together come to over 80 billion jin. More than half of this grain is sold in the countryside and in the market towns near the countryside. From this it can be seen that one cannot say the peasants' life has not improved. We plan, within a few years, to stabilise the quantity of grain levied and purchased at roughly the level of over 80 billion jin, so that agriculture develops, the co-operatives are consolidated, and the small number of grain-short households now in the countryside are no longer short of grain, so that, apart from some households specialising in industrial crops, all become households with surplus grain or self-sufficient ones, so that there are no poor peasants left in the countryside and all the peasants reach the living standard of middle peasants or above. As for simply comparing the average annual income per peasant with the average annual income per worker and saying that one is low and the other high, this is not appropriate. The labour productivity of the workers is much higher than that of the peasants, and the cost of living of the peasants is much lower than that of the urban workers, so it cannot be said that the workers are especially favoured by the state. The wages of a small number of workers and of some personnel of state organs are somewhat high, and the peasants have reason to be dissatisfied when they see this; it is necessary to make appropriate adjustments in the light of circumstances.

IV. The Question of Industrialists and Businessmen

In the reform of our social system, besides agricultural co-operation and handicraft co-operation, the transformation of private industry and commerce into joint state-private enterprises was also completed in 1956. That this was done so quickly and smoothly is closely connected with our having handled the contradiction between the working class and the national bourgeoisie as a contradiction among the people. Has this class contradiction been completely resolved? Not yet. It will take a considerable time to resolve it completely. But now some people say: the capitalists have already been remoulded to be almost the same as the workers and need no more remoulding. Some even say that the capitalists are a bit better than the workers. Others say that if there is to be remoulding, why does the working class not remould itself? Are these arguments right? Of course not.

In the process of building a socialist society everybody needs remoulding: the exploiters need remoulding and the working people also need remoulding. Who says the working class does not need remoulding? Of course the remoulding of the exploiters and that of the working people are two kinds of remoulding of different nature and must not be mixed up. The working class, in the class struggle and in the struggle against nature, remoulds the whole of society and in so doing also remoulds itself. The working class must keep on learning in the course of its work and gradually overcome its own shortcomings, and must never stop. Take people like ourselves: many of us make some progress every year, that is to say, we are being remoulded every year. I myself used to have all sorts of non-Marxist ideas; Marxism I accepted only later. I learnt a little Marxism from books and made a preliminary remoulding of my thinking, but it was mainly in the long class struggle that I was remoulded. And in future I must keep on learning in order to make further progress, otherwise I shall fall behind. Are the capitalists really so clever that they no longer need remoulding?

Some say that the Chinese bourgeoisie no longer has a dual character, only a single one. Is this a fact? It is not. On the one hand, bourgeois elements have become managerial personnel in the joint state-private enterprises and are in the process of changing from exploiters into working people who earn their own living; on the other hand, they still draw a fixed rate of interest in the joint state-private enterprises, which means that the roots of their exploitation have not yet been removed. There is still no small gap between them and the working class in thinking and feeling and in habits of life. How can it be said that there is no longer a dual character? Even when they no longer draw the fixed interest and the label of bourgeois has been taken off, a considerable period will still be needed for continued ideological remoulding. If it is thought that the bourgeoisie no longer has a dual character, then the task of remoulding and studying for the capitalists would also disappear.

It should be said that this opinion not only does not accord with the actual situation of the industrialists and businessmen, but also does not accord with the wishes of the majority of them. In the past few years most industrialists and businessmen have been willing to study and have made notable progress. The thorough remoulding of industrialists and businessmen must take place in the course of work; they should work together with the staff and workers in the enterprises and make the enterprises the base for their self-remoulding. But it is also important to change some of one's old views through study. The study of industrialists and businessmen should be based on voluntariness. Many industrialists and businessmen studied in training classes for several dozen days, and on returning to their factories they had more in common to talk about with the workers and the representatives of the state, and the conditions for working together improved. They have learnt from personal experience that continuing to study and to remould themselves is beneficial to them. The opinion just mentioned, that there is no need for study and no need for remoulding, does not represent the opinion of the majority of industrialists and businessmen; it is only the opinion of a few.

V. The Question of Intellectuals

The contradictions among our people have also appeared among the intellectuals. The several million intellectuals who served the old society have now turned to serving the new society, and here there is the question of how they are to adapt to the needs of the new society and how we are to help them adapt. This too is a contradiction among the people.

The majority of our country's intellectuals have made notable progress in the past seven years. They have expressed approval of the socialist system. Many of them are studying Marxism diligently, and some have become Communists. This group, though still a minority at present, is gradually increasing. Of course, there are still some among the intellectuals who now doubt socialism or do not agree with it; they are only a minority.

The arduous cause of socialist construction in our country needs as many intellectuals as possible to serve it. We should trust all intellectuals who are truly willing to serve the socialist cause, fundamentally improve our relations with them, and help them solve the various problems that have to be solved, so that they can actively bring their talents into play. Many of our comrades are not good at uniting with intellectuals; they treat them in a stiff manner, do not respect their labour, and interfere improperly in scientific and cultural work in matters in which they should not interfere. All these shortcomings must be overcome.

Although the broad mass of intellectuals have made progress, they should not be complacent on that account. In order to adapt fully to the needs of the new society and to be united with the workers and peasants, intellectuals must continue to remould themselves, gradually discard the bourgeois world outlook and establish the proletarian, communist world outlook. The change of world outlook is a fundamental change, and it cannot yet be said that the majority of intellectuals have completed it. We hope that our intellectuals will go on forward, gradually establish the communist world outlook in the course of their work and study, gradually master Marxism-Leninism, and gradually become one with the workers and peasants, and that they will not stop halfway, still less retreat; retreat leads nowhere. Because the social system of our country has changed and the economic base of bourgeois ideology has in the main been eliminated, there is not only a need for a great number of intellectuals to change their world outlook but also a possibility of their doing so. But a thorough change of world outlook takes a very long time, and we should do our work patiently and not be impatient. In fact there are bound to be some who will never in their thinking be willing to accept Marxism-Leninism and communism; we should not be too demanding of this group; so long as they obey the requirements of the state and engage in normal labour, we should give them opportunities for suitable work.

Among intellectuals and young students, ideological and political work has weakened in the recent period and some deviations have appeared. In the eyes of some people, it seems that politics, the future of the motherland and the ideals of mankind are of no concern. It seems that Marxism was fashionable for a while and is not so fashionable now. In view of this situation, ideological and political work now needs to be strengthened. Intellectuals and young students alike should study hard. Besides studying their specialties, they should make progress ideologically and politically, and for this they need to study Marxism and current affairs. To have no correct political viewpoint is like having no soul. The ideological remoulding of the past was necessary and achieved positive results. But in method it was somewhat crude and hurt some people, which was not good. This shortcoming must be avoided in future. All departments are responsible for ideological and political work. The Communist Party should take charge, the Youth League should take charge, the competent government departments should take charge, and school principals and teachers should take charge even more. Our educational policy should enable those being educated to develop in moral, intellectual and physical respects and become cultured working people with socialist consciousness. We should advocate building the country with diligence and thrift. All young people must be made to understand that our country is still a very poor country, and that this state of affairs cannot be fundamentally changed in a short time; it depends entirely on the young people and all the people uniting and striving over several decades to create with their own hands a rich and powerful country. The establishment of the socialist system has opened up for us a road to the ideal state, but realising that ideal state still depends on our hard work. Some young people think that once socialist society arrives everything should be fine and that they can enjoy a ready-made happy life without effort; this is an unrealistic idea.

VI. The Question of National Minorities

Our national minorities number over thirty million. Although they make up only six per cent of the country's total population, they live over a vast area, about fifty to sixty per cent of the country's total area. So relations between the Han people and the national minorities must be put right. The key to this question is overcoming Han chauvinism. Among those minority nationalities where local nationalism exists, local nationalism should be overcome at the same time. Both Han chauvinism and local nationalism are detrimental to the unity of the various nationalities; they are a kind of contradiction among the people that must be overcome. In this respect we have done some work, and in most minority areas relations between nationalities have greatly improved compared with the past, but some problems still remain to be solved. In some areas both Han chauvinism and local nationalism still exist seriously, and adequate attention must be paid to them. Through the efforts of the people of all nationalities over the past few years, democratic reform and socialist transformation have in the main been completed in the vast majority of our national minority areas. In Tibet, because conditions are not yet ripe, democratic reform has not yet been carried out. According to the Seventeen-Article Agreement between the Central People's Government and the local government of Tibet, reform of the social system must be carried out, but when it is carried out can be decided only when the great majority of the Tibetan people and their leading figures consider it practicable; we must not be impatient. It has now been decided not to carry out reform during the period of the Second Five-Year Plan. Whether to carry it out during the Third Five-Year Plan can be decided only by looking at the situation at that time.

VII. Overall Consideration and Suitable Arrangements

By overall consideration is meant overall consideration for the six hundred million people. In making plans, in doing things and in thinking about problems, we must proceed from the fact that our country has six hundred million people, and we must never forget this. Why raise such a question? Is there anyone who does not know that our country has six hundred million people? They know it, to be sure, but when it comes to doing things some people forget it; it seems that the fewer people the better and the smaller the circle the better. People with this small-circle mentality resist the idea of mobilising all positive factors, uniting all who can be united and, as far as possible, turning negative factors into positive ones to serve the great cause of building socialist society. I hope these people will broaden their horizons and truly recognise that our country has six hundred million people, that this is an objective fact and that this is our capital. That our country has many people is a good thing, though of course there are also difficulties. Our construction in every field is developing vigorously and the achievements are great, but in the present transition period of great social change there are still many difficult problems. Both development and difficulty: that is contradiction. Every contradiction should be resolved, and every contradiction can be resolved. Our policy is overall consideration and suitable arrangements. Whether the problem is grain, famine, employment, education, intellectuals, the united front of all patriotic forces, national minorities, or any other, we must proceed from the viewpoint of overall consideration for all the people, consult people in all quarters in light of the actual conditions possible at the time and place, and make suitable arrangements. We must never complain that there are too many people, that people are backward, or that matters are troublesome and difficult, and push them out the door to be rid of them. In saying this, do I mean that the government should take everybody and everything under its wing? Of course not. Many people and many matters can be dealt with by social organisations finding ways, or by the masses directly finding ways; they are capable of devising many good ways. This is also included in the policy of overall consideration and suitable arrangements, and we should guide social organisations and the masses in various places to do so.

VIII. On "Let a Hundred Flowers Blossom, Let a Hundred Schools of Thought Contend", Long-Term Coexistence and Mutual Supervision

How did the slogans "let a hundred flowers blossom, let a hundred schools of thought contend" and "long-term coexistence and mutual supervision" come to be put forward? They were put forward on the basis of China's concrete conditions, on the basis of recognising that various contradictions still exist in socialist society, and in response to the country's urgent need to develop its economy and culture rapidly. The policy of letting a hundred flowers blossom and a hundred schools of thought contend is a policy for promoting the development of the arts and the progress of science, a policy for promoting a flourishing socialist culture in our country. Different forms and styles in art can develop freely and different schools in science can contend freely. To use administrative power to impose one style or one school and to ban another, we believe, would be harmful to the development of art and science. Questions of right and wrong in art and science should be settled through free discussion in artistic and scientific circles and through practice in art and science, and not by crude methods. In order to judge what is correct and what is wrong, a period of testing is often needed. Throughout history, new and correct things at first often fail to win recognition from the majority and can develop only through twists and turns in struggle. Correct things and good things are often at first not recognised by people as fragrant flowers but are instead regarded as poisonous weeds. Copernicus's theory of the solar system and Darwin's theory of evolution were both once regarded as wrong and both went through hard struggles. There are many such examples in Chinese history too. Compared with the old society, the conditions for the growth of new things in socialist society are fundamentally different from the past and much better. But the suppression of new forces and of reasonable opinions still often occurs. Even without deliberate suppression, failure to discriminate clearly can also hinder the growth of new things. Therefore we should maintain a cautious attitude towards questions of right and wrong in science and art, advocate free discussion, and not rashly draw conclusions. We believe that adopting this attitude helps science and art to develop relatively smoothly.

Marxism too has developed through struggle. At the beginning Marxism was attacked in all kinds of ways and regarded as a poisonous weed. Even now it continues to be attacked in many parts of the world and is still regarded as a poisonous weed. In socialist countries the position of Marxism is different. But even in socialist countries non-Marxist ideas still exist, and anti-Marxist ideas also exist. In our country, although socialist transformation, so far as ownership is concerned, has in the main been completed, and the large-scale, turbulent, mass class struggles of the revolutionary period have in the main ended, the remnants of the overthrown landlord and comprador classes still exist, the bourgeoisie still exists, and the petty bourgeoisie is only just beginning to be remoulded. Class struggle has not ended. The class struggle between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie, the class struggle between the different political forces, and the class struggle between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie in the ideological field will still be long, tortuous and at times even very sharp. The proletariat seeks to transform the world according to its own world outlook, and the bourgeoisie also seeks to transform the world according to its world outlook. In this respect the question of who will win, socialism or capitalism, has not really been settled. Whether among the population as a whole or among the intellectuals, Marxists are still a minority. Therefore Marxism must still develop through struggle. Marxism can develop only through struggle, not only in the past and the present, but inevitably also in the future. What is correct always develops in the course of struggle against what is wrong. The true, the good and the beautiful always exist by comparison with the false, the evil and the ugly, and grow in struggle with them. When a certain wrong thing is universally discarded by mankind and a certain truth is universally accepted, newer truths again struggle against new erroneous opinions. This struggle will never end. This is the law of the development of truth, and of course also the law of the development of Marxism.

The struggle in our country between socialism and capitalism in the ideological field, over who will win, will take quite a long time to settle. This is because the influence of the bourgeoisie and of the intellectuals who come from the old society will long continue to exist in our country, and, as the ideology of a class, will long continue to exist. If we have an inadequate understanding of this situation, or none at all, we shall make very serious mistakes and neglect the necessary ideological struggle. Ideological struggle is unlike other struggles; it cannot use crude, coercive methods but only the method of painstaking reasoning. Today socialism has favourable conditions in the ideological struggle. The basic strength of state power is in the hands of the working people led by the proletariat. The Communist Party has great strength and very high prestige. Despite shortcomings and mistakes in our work, every fair-minded person can see that we are loyal to the people, that we have the determination and the ability to build the motherland well together with the people, that we have already achieved great successes and will go on to achieve still greater ones. The overwhelming majority of bourgeois elements and of intellectuals from the old society are patriotic; they are willing to serve the socialist motherland, which is flourishing day by day, and they understand that if they depart from the socialist cause and from the working people led by the Communist Party, they will have nothing to rely on and can have no bright future.

People ask: in our country Marxism has been accepted by the majority as the guiding ideology; can it then be criticised? Of course it can be criticised. Marxism is a scientific truth and does not fear criticism. If Marxism feared criticism, if it could be demolished by criticism, then Marxism would be of no use. In fact, are the idealists not criticising Marxism every day in all sorts of forms? And are those who hold bourgeois and petty-bourgeois ideas and are unwilling to change not also criticising Marxism in all sorts of forms? Marxists should not be afraid of anyone's criticism. On the contrary, Marxists want to temper themselves, develop themselves and extend their positions amid people's criticism, amid the storms and rains of struggle. Fighting against wrong ideas is like vaccination: after the action of the vaccine, the body acquires stronger immunity. Things raised in a hothouse will not have strong vitality. Carrying out the policy of letting a hundred flowers blossom and a hundred schools of thought contend will not weaken the leading position of Marxism in the ideological field; on the contrary, it will strengthen it.

What policy should be adopted towards non-Marxist ideas? As for outright counter-revolutionaries and those who sabotage the socialist cause, it is easy to deal with them: just deprive them of their freedom of speech. The case is different with wrong ideas among the people. Is it permissible to ban these ideas and allow them no chance of expression? Of course not. In dealing with ideological questions among the people and questions of the spiritual world, using crude methods will not only fail to be effective but will be very harmful. If wrong opinions are not allowed to be expressed, the result is that wrong opinions still exist. And if correct opinions are raised in a hothouse, if they have never seen wind and rain and have not acquired immunity, they cannot win battles when they meet wrong opinions. Therefore only by the methods of discussion, criticism and reasoning can correct opinions really be developed and wrong opinions overcome, and the problem really be solved.

The ideology of the bourgeoisie and petty bourgeoisie is bound to be reflected. They are bound to manifest themselves stubbornly by all sorts of means on political and ideological questions. It is impossible to make them neither reflect nor manifest it. We should not use suppression to prevent them from expressing themselves, but should let them express themselves and, at the same time, debate with them when they do so and make appropriate criticism. Without doubt we should criticise all kinds of wrong ideas. It is certainly not right to refrain from criticism, to look on while wrong ideas spread everywhere and let them take over the market. Where there are mistakes they must be criticised, and where there are poisonous weeds there must be struggle against them. But such criticism should not be dogmatic, should not use the metaphysical method, and should strive to use the dialectical method. There must be scientific analysis and full persuasiveness. Dogmatic criticism cannot solve problems. We are against all poisonous weeds, but we must carefully distinguish what are truly poisonous weeds and what are truly fragrant flowers. Together with the masses we must learn to distinguish carefully between fragrant flowers and poisonous weeds, and together use correct methods to struggle against poisonous weeds.

While criticising dogmatism we must at the same time pay attention to criticising revisionism. Revisionism, or Right opportunism, is a bourgeois trend of thought, and it is more dangerous than dogmatism. Revisionists and Right opportunists also hang Marxism on their lips, and they too attack "dogmatism". But what they attack is precisely the most fundamental things in Marxism. They oppose or distort materialism and dialectics, oppose or try to weaken the people's democratic dictatorship and the leadership of the Communist Party, and oppose or try to weaken socialist transformation and socialist construction. After the basic victory of the socialist revolution in our country, there is still a section of people in society who dream of restoring the capitalist system. They will struggle against the working class in every field, including the ideological field. And in this struggle the revisionists are their best helpers.

The two slogans "let a hundred flowers blossom" and "let a hundred schools of thought contend", looked at literally, have no class character; the proletariat can make use of them, the bourgeoisie can make use of them, and others can make use of them too. As for what are fragrant flowers and what are poisonous weeds, each class, stratum and social group also has its own view. Then, from the standpoint of the broad masses of the people, what are the criteria by which we distinguish fragrant flowers from poisonous weeds today? In the political life of our people, how should we judge right and wrong in our words and actions? We think that, on the basis of the principles of our Constitution, the will of the overwhelming majority of our people and the common political positions proclaimed on various occasions by our political parties, these criteria can be broadly defined as follows: (1) they help to unite the people of all our nationalities, and do not divide the people; (2) they are beneficial to socialist transformation and socialist construction, and not harmful to them; (3) they help to consolidate the people's democratic dictatorship, and do not undermine or weaken this dictatorship; (4) they help to consolidate democratic centralism, and do not undermine or weaken this system; (5) they help to strengthen the leadership of the Communist Party, and do not shake off or weaken this leadership; (6) they are beneficial to socialist international unity and the international unity of the peace-loving people of the world, and not harmful to this unity. Of these six criteria, the most important are the socialist road and the leadership of the Party. These criteria are put forward in order to help the people develop free discussion of various questions, and not to hinder such discussion. Those who do not approve of these criteria can still put forward their own views and argue. But when the majority have clear criteria, criticism and self-criticism can proceed along the right lines, and these criteria can be used to judge whether people's words and actions are correct, and whether they are fragrant flowers or poisonous weeds. These are political criteria. To judge whether scientific arguments are correct or wrong, or what the artistic standard of a work of art is, other, specific criteria are of course also needed. But these six political criteria are applicable to all scientific and artistic activities. In a socialist country like ours, can any beneficial scientific or artistic activity possibly run counter to these political criteria?

The views stated above all proceed from the concrete historical conditions of our country. The circumstances of different socialist countries and different Communist Parties are not the same. Therefore we do not think that they must or should adopt the Chinese way of doing things.

The slogan "long-term coexistence and mutual supervision" is also a product of the concrete historical conditions of our country. It was not put forward suddenly; it had been maturing for several years. The idea of long-term coexistence had existed for a long time. By last year, with the socialist system basically established, these slogans were put forward explicitly. Why should the democratic parties of the bourgeoisie and petty bourgeoisie coexist for a long time with the party of the working class? It is because we have no reason not to adopt a policy of long-term coexistence towards all parties that genuinely devote themselves to uniting the people in the socialist cause and have the trust of the people. In my speech at the Second Session of the CPPCC in June 1950, I already said: "So long as anyone is willing to serve the people truly, has really helped at a time when the people were in difficulty and done good, and does so consistently without giving up halfway, then the people and the people's government have no reason not to want him, no reason not to give him a chance to live and a chance to serve." What is said here is also the political basis on which the various parties can coexist for a long time. That the Communist Party should coexist for a long time with the democratic parties is our wish and also our policy. As for whether the democratic parties can continue to exist for a long time, that is not decided by the wishes of the Communist Party alone; it also depends on the conduct of the democratic parties themselves and on whether they win the trust of the people. The fact of mutual supervision among the parties has also long existed, namely the parties making suggestions to each other and criticising each other. Mutual supervision, of course, is not one-sided; the Communist Party can supervise the democratic parties, and the democratic parties can also supervise the Communist Party. Why let the democratic parties supervise the Communist Party? Because a party, like a person, needs to hear different voices in its ears. As everyone knows, those who mainly supervise the Communist Party are the working people and the Party membership. But it is of still greater benefit to us to have the democratic parties. Of course, the suggestions and criticisms made among the democratic parties and the Communist Party can play a positive role in mutual supervision only if they accord with the six political criteria we spoke of earlier. Therefore we hope that all the democratic parties will pay attention to ideological remoulding and strive to coexist and supervise each other in the long term together with the Communist Party, so as to adapt to the needs of the new society.

IX. On the Question of Minor Disturbances

In 1956, in a few places, there were incidents in which small numbers of workers and students went on strike or boycotted classes. The immediate cause of these disturbances was that some material demands were not met; some of these demands were ones that should and could be met, while others were improper or excessive and could not be met for the time being. But a still more important factor in the outbreak of the disturbances was bureaucracy on the part of the leadership. Some of these bureaucratic errors must be attributed to higher organs, and the blame cannot be put wholly on those below. Another cause of the disturbances was a lack of ideological and political education for the workers and students. In 1956 there were also a few cases in which a small number of co-operative members made trouble over their co-operatives; the main cause was again bureaucracy in the leadership and lack of education for the masses.

It must be admitted that some of the masses are apt to pay attention to immediate, partial and personal interests, and fail to understand, or do not fully understand, long-term, national and collective interests. Many young people, because they lack political experience and experience of social life, are not good at comparing old China with new China, and find it hard to understand deeply through what hardships and struggles our people threw off the oppression of imperialism and the Kuomintang reactionaries, and what long and arduous labour it takes to build a good socialist society. Therefore lively, practical political education needs to be carried out constantly among the masses, and the difficulties that arise should always be explained to them truthfully, and ways of overcoming them should be studied together with them.

We do not approve of disturbances, because contradictions among the people can be resolved by the method of "unity—criticism—unity", while disturbances always cause some losses and are detrimental to the development of the socialist cause. We believe that the broad masses of our people support socialism, that they are very disciplined and reasonable, and will never make trouble without cause. But this does not mean that there is no longer any possibility of mass disturbances in our country. On this question, we should note the following: (1) To eliminate the causes of disturbances at the root, we must resolutely overcome bureaucracy, strengthen ideological and political education well, and handle the various contradictions properly. If we do this, disturbances will in general not occur. (2) If, because our work has been done badly, disturbances do occur, we should lead the disturbing masses onto the right path and use the disturbances as a special means of improving our work, educating cadres and masses, and solving problems that were not solved in ordinary times. In handling disturbances we should do painstaking work, not use crude methods, and not "call off the troops in a hasty way". The ringleaders of disturbances should not be lightly dismissed, except for those who violate the criminal law and active counter-revolutionaries, who should be dealt with according to law. In a big country like ours, it is nothing to be alarmed about if a small number of people make trouble; it can rather help us to overcome bureaucracy.

In our society there are also a few people who disregard public interests, are utterly unreasonable, and commit violence and break the law. They may exploit and distort our policies, deliberately put forward unreasonable demands to incite the masses, or deliberately spread rumours and make trouble, to disrupt the normal order of society. We do not approve of indulging such people. On the contrary, they must be given the necessary legal sanctions. Punishing such people is the demand of the broad masses of society, and failing to punish them would be contrary to the wishes of the masses.

X. Can Bad Things Be Turned into Good Things?

As I said above, in our society disturbances by the masses are a bad thing and we do not approve of them. But after such incidents occur, they can again move us to learn lessons, overcome bureaucracy, and educate cadres and masses. In this respect bad things can also be turned into good things. Disorder has a dual character. We can look at all disorders from this viewpoint.

The Hungarian events were not a good thing, as everyone knows. But they too had a dual character. Because the comrades in Hungary handled matters correctly in the course of the events, the Hungarian events were turned from a bad thing into a good thing. Hungary is now more consolidated than before, and the countries of the socialist camp have all learnt lessons.

Likewise, the worldwide anti-communist, anti-people storm that arose in the latter half of 1956 was of course a bad thing. But it educated and tempered the Communist Parties and working classes of all countries, and so became a good thing. In many countries a number of people left the Party in this storm. That some Party members withdrew and the Party's numbers fell is of course a bad thing. But there is also some good in it. Those vacillating elements did not want to carry on and drew back, and the great majority of firm Party members are better able to unite and struggle: why is that not good?

In short, we must learn to look at problems from all sides, seeing not only the front of things but also the reverse. Under certain conditions a bad thing can lead to good results, and a good thing can lead to bad results. Lao Zi said over two thousand years ago: "Disaster is what fortune leans on; fortune is what disaster lies hidden in." When Japan attacked China, the Japanese called it victory. Large areas of China were occupied, and the Chinese called it defeat. But within China's defeat there was victory contained, and within Japan's victory there was defeat contained. Has history not proved this?

People all over the world are now discussing whether a third world war will be fought. We also need to be mentally prepared on this question and to analyse it. We stand for peace and oppose war. But if the imperialists insist on launching a war, we shall not be afraid. Our attitude on this question is the same as our attitude towards all "disorders": first, we oppose it; second, we are not afraid of it. After the First World War, the Soviet Union emerged, with a population of two hundred million. After the Second World War, the socialist camp emerged, with a total population of nine hundred million. If the imperialists insist on launching a third world war, it can be asserted that the result will certainly be that many hundreds of millions more people will turn to the side of socialism, and imperialism will have little ground left, and it is also possible that the whole imperialist system will collapse completely.

Of two contradictory opposites struggling with each other, each without exception is transformed into the other under certain conditions. Here conditions are important. Without certain conditions, neither of the struggling sides will be transformed. The people in the world most willing to change their position are the proletariat, followed by the semi-proletariat, since the one has nothing at all and the other has not much. The present situation in which the United States manipulates the majority of votes in the United Nations and controls many parts of the world is only temporary, and some day this situation is bound to change. China's position as a poor country and its position of having no rights internationally will also change: the poor country will become a rich country, and the rightless will become rightful, a transformation in the opposite direction. Here the decisive conditions are the socialist system and the united struggle of the people.

XI. On Economy

I should like to say a few words here about economy. We are to carry out large-scale construction, but our country is still a very poor country; this is a contradiction. Practising economy in all fields and over the long term is one way of resolving this contradiction.

In the "three-anti" campaign of 1952 we opposed corruption, waste and bureaucracy, with the emphasis on opposing corruption. In 1955 economy was advocated, the emphasis being on opposing excessively high standards in non-productive capital construction and on saving raw materials in industrial production, and the results were great. At that time the policy of economy was not yet seriously carried out in all branches of the national economy, nor seriously carried out in ordinary offices, the armed forces, schools and people's organisations. This year we ask that economy be advocated and waste opposed in all fields throughout the country. We still lack experience in construction work. In the past few years there have been great achievements, but there has also been waste. We must gradually build a number of large-scale modern enterprises as a backbone; without this backbone our country cannot become a modern industrial power within several decades. But most enterprises should not be like that; we should set up more small and medium-sized enterprises and make full use of the industrial base left over from the old society, strive to economise, and do more with less money. Since the Second Plenary Session of the Party's Central Committee last November put still greater emphasis on the policy of practising strict economy and opposing waste, effects have begun to appear over the past few months. This campaign for economy must be carried through thoroughly and for the long term. Opposing waste, like criticising other shortcomings and mistakes, is like washing one's face. Does not a person have to wash his face every day? The Chinese Communist Party, the democratic parties, democrats without party affiliation, intellectuals, industrialists and businessmen, workers, peasants and handicraftsmen, in short all of our six hundred million people, should practise increased production and economy and oppose extravagance and waste. This has great significance not only economically but also politically. Among many of our personnel there is now growing a dangerous tendency of being unwilling to share weal and woe with the masses and of being fond of reckoning personal fame and gain; this is very bad. In the campaign for increased production and economy we call for streamlining offices and sending cadres down to lower levels so that a considerable number of cadres return to production, which is one way of overcoming this dangerous tendency. All cadres and all the people should be made to think constantly that our country is a big socialist country but also an economically backward and poor one; this is a very great contradiction. To make our country rich and strong will take several decades of hard struggle, which includes carrying out the policy of building the country with diligence and thrift by practising strict economy and opposing waste.

XII. The Path of China's Industrialisation

The question of the path of industrialisation spoken of here refers mainly to the relationship among the development of heavy industry, light industry and agriculture. Our economic construction is centred on heavy industry; this must be affirmed. But at the same time full attention must be paid to developing agriculture and light industry.

Our country is a big agricultural country, with over eighty per cent of the population living in the countryside; the development of industry must go hand in hand with the development of agriculture, for only then will industry have raw materials and a market and be able to accumulate more funds for building a powerful heavy industry. As everyone knows, light industry is very closely related to agriculture. Without agriculture there is no light industry. That heavy industry must have agriculture as an important market is something that people do not yet see very clearly. But as the technical transformation of agriculture gradually develops and agriculture becomes more and more modernised, the machinery, fertilisers, water conservancy works, power construction, transport construction, domestic fuel, building materials for civilian use and so on that serve agriculture will increase day by day, and the fact that heavy industry has agriculture as an important market will become easier for people to understand. During the Second and Third Five-Year Plans, if our agriculture can develop more, enabling light industry to develop correspondingly more, this will be good for the entire national economy. When agriculture and light industry have developed, heavy industry will have a market and funds, and will develop more quickly. In this way the pace of industrialisation may seem somewhat slower, but in reality it will not be slower, and may even be faster. After three Five-Year Plans, or somewhat longer, our steel output may still grow from the highest annual output before liberation, over 900,000 tons in 1943, to twenty million tons or somewhat more. Then people in both town and country will be happy.

I do not intend to say more about economic questions today. We still lack experience in economic construction, since we have been at it for only seven years, and experience needs to be accumulated. We also had no experience of revolution at the start; we took tumbles and gained experience, and only then came the victory in the whole country. We hope to gain experience in economic construction in a shorter time than it took to gain experience in revolution, and also not to pay so high a price. A price is always needed; the hope is that it will not be as high as the price paid in the revolutionary period. It must be understood that there is a contradiction on this question, namely the contradiction between the objective laws of economic development in socialist society and our subjective understanding; this needs to be resolved in practice. This contradiction will also appear as a contradiction between people, that is, between those who reflect the objective laws more correctly and those who reflect them less correctly, and so it is also a contradiction among the people. All contradictions exist objectively, and our task lies in reflecting them and resolving them as correctly as possible.

In order to turn our country into an industrial country, we must seriously study the advanced experience of the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union has been building socialism for forty years, and its experience is extremely valuable to us. Look around: who designed and equipped so many important factories for us? Did the United States give them to us? Did Britain? They gave us none. Only the Soviet Union was willing to do it, because it is a socialist country and our allied country. Besides the Soviet Union, some fraternal countries of Eastern Europe have also given us some help. It is quite right that we should learn from the good experience of all countries, whether socialist or capitalist; that is certain. But the main thing is still to learn from the Soviet Union. There are two attitudes towards learning. One is the dogmatic attitude, bringing everything over, regardless of conditions in our country, whether it is applicable or not. This attitude is not good. The other attitude is to use our heads when we learn, learning what suits the conditions of our country, that is, absorbing experience that is useful to us; this is the attitude we need.

To consolidate our unity with the Soviet Union and with all socialist countries is our basic policy and where our basic interests lie. Next, there are the Asian and African countries and all peace-loving countries and peoples, with whom we should consolidate and develop unity. With the unity of these two forces, we are not isolated. As for the imperialist countries, we should also unite with the people there and strive for peaceful coexistence with those countries, do some business, and prevent a possible war, but we must never harbour any unrealistic ideas about them.