- Context
- Mao set out the materialist-dialectical law of contradiction, dated 1937-08-01 in the supplied record, arguing against dogmatism in the Chinese Communist Party; the text does not state the audience, place or occasion.
- Main themes
- Law of the unity of opposites, two world outlooks (metaphysical and dialectical), universality of contradiction, particularity of contradiction, critique of dogmatism in the Chinese Communist Party, critique of the Deborin school, internal versus external causes of change, identity and struggle of contradictory aspects, antagonism as one form of struggle, stages of the Chinese democratic revolution, Kuomintang and Communist Party united fronts, one-sidedness and superficiality in analysis
- Duration
- ~123 min
- Words
- 14,713
- Sentences
- 512
- Readability
- 27
- Grade
- 16.6
- Syntax
- 3.28
- Vocabulary
- 2.33
Translated from Chinese Source: GitHub qinglee/maoxuan (毛泽东选集) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other512 sentences in 118 paragraphs
The law of contradiction in things, that is, the law of the unity of opposites, is the most fundamental law of materialist dialectics. Lenin said: "In its proper sense, dialectics is the study of contradiction in the essence itself of the object." Lenin often called this law the essence of dialectics, and also called it the core of dialectics. Therefore, in studying this law, we cannot but touch upon a wide range of aspects, and cannot but touch upon many philosophical problems. If we have clarified all these problems, we shall have understood materialist dialectics in its fundamentals. These problems are: the two world outlooks; the universality of contradiction; the particularity of contradiction; the principal contradiction and the principal aspect of a contradiction; the identity and struggle of the aspects of a contradiction; the place of antagonism in contradiction.
In the last few years, philosophical circles in the Soviet Union have criticized the idealism of the Deborin school, and this has aroused our very great interest. Deborin's idealism has had an extremely bad influence inside the Chinese Communist Party, and it cannot be said that the dogmatist thinking in our Party has no connection with the style of this school. Therefore, our present work of philosophical study ought to take the sweeping away of dogmatist thinking as its principal objective.
1. Two World Outlooks
In the history of human knowledge there have always been two views concerning the laws of the development of the universe, one a metaphysical view and the other a dialectical view, forming two mutually opposed world outlooks. Lenin said: "The two basic (or two possible? or two commonly seen in history?) views held with regard to development (evolution) are: (1) that development is decrease and increase, is repetition; (2) that development is the unity of opposites (the division of a unity into two mutually exclusive opposites, while the two opposites are in turn interconnected)." What Lenin spoke of is precisely these two different world outlooks.
Metaphysics, also called the learning of the mysterious. This way of thinking, whether in China or in Europe, belonged for a very long historical period to the idealist world outlook, and occupied a dominant position in people's thinking. In Europe, the materialism of the early period of the bourgeoisie was also metaphysical. Because the social and economic conditions of many countries in Europe advanced to the stage of highly developed capitalism, the productive forces, the class struggle and science all developed to a level never before seen in history, and the industrial proletariat became the greatest motive force of historical development, the Marxist world outlook of materialist dialectics was thereby produced. Thereupon, on the side of the bourgeoisie, besides open, extremely barefaced and reactionary idealism, there also appeared vulgar evolutionism, which came forward to oppose materialist dialectics.
The so-called metaphysical, or vulgar-evolutionist, world outlook consists in looking at the world from an isolated, static and one-sided viewpoint. This world outlook regards all things in the world, and the forms and kinds of all things, as forever isolated from one another and forever unchanging. If there is change, it is only increase or decrease in quantity and change of place. And the cause of such increase, decrease and change lies not inside things but outside them, that is, it is due to the push of an external force. Metaphysicians hold that the various different things in the world and their characteristics have been thus from the moment they began to exist. Later changes are nothing but expansion or contraction in quantity. They hold that a thing can forever only repeatedly produce the same kind of thing, and cannot change into a different kind of thing. In the view of the metaphysicians, capitalist exploitation, capitalist competition, the individualist thinking of capitalist society, and the like, can all be found even in the slave society of antiquity, and even in primitive society, and will exist forever without change. When they speak of the causes of social development, they explain them by such conditions external to society as geography and climate. They simply look outside things for the causes of development, and deny the doctrine, upheld by materialist dialectics, that things develop because of internal contradiction. Therefore they cannot explain the qualitative diversity of things, and cannot explain the phenomenon of one quality changing into another quality. This way of thinking, in Europe, was mechanical materialism in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, and in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries there was vulgar evolutionism. In China, there was the so-called metaphysical idea that "Heaven does not change, and the Way likewise does not change," which was for a long time upheld by the decayed feudal ruling class. The mechanical materialism and vulgar evolutionism imported from Europe in the last hundred years have been upheld by the bourgeoisie.
Contrary to the metaphysical world outlook, the world outlook of materialist dialectics holds that the development of things should be studied from inside things and from the relation of one thing to other things, that is, that the development of things should be regarded as their necessary self-movement within, while the movement of every thing is interconnected with and mutually influences the other things around it. The fundamental cause of the development of things is not outside things but inside them, in the contradictory nature within things. There is this contradictory nature inside any thing, and therefore the movement and development of things are aroused. This contradictory nature inside things is the fundamental cause of the development of things, while the interconnection and mutual influence of one thing and other things are the secondary cause of the development of things. In this way, materialist dialectics forcefully opposes the theory of external causes, or the theory of passivity, of metaphysical mechanical materialism and of vulgar evolutionism. This is clear: a merely external cause can only give rise to the mechanical motion of a thing, that is, changes in scope and size and increases and decreases in quantity, and cannot explain why things are qualitatively so vastly different and change into one another. In fact, even mechanical motion pushed by an external force must pass through the contradictory nature inside things. The mere growth of plants and animals, their quantitative development, is also due mainly to internal contradiction. Likewise, the development of society is due mainly not to external causes but to internal causes. Many countries, under more or less the same geographical and climatic conditions, display very great differences and unevenness in their development. Take one and the same country: under circumstances in which geography and climate have not changed, the changes in society are nevertheless very great. Imperialist Russia became the socialist Soviet Union, and feudal Japan, closed off from the world, became imperialist Japan, yet the geography and climate of these countries did not change. China, long ruled by the feudal system, has undergone great changes in the last hundred years, and is now changing in the direction of a new China of freedom and liberation, yet China's geography and climate have not changed. The geography and climate of the whole earth and of its various parts are also changing, but compared with the changes in society their changes appear very slight; the former manifest their changes in units of tens of thousands of years, while the latter manifest their changes within a few thousand years, a few hundred years, a few decades, or even a few years or a few months (in periods of revolution). According to the viewpoint of materialist dialectics, changes in nature are due mainly to the development of contradictions internal to nature. Changes in society are due mainly to the development of contradictions internal to society, that is, the contradiction between the productive forces and the relations of production, the contradictions between classes, and the contradictions between the new and the old; because of the development of these contradictions, society is pushed forward, and the supersession of the old society by the new is pushed forward. Does materialist dialectics exclude external causes? It does not exclude them. Materialist dialectics holds that the external cause is the condition of change, and the internal cause is the basis of change, and that the external cause operates through the internal cause. An egg changes into a chick because it gets the proper temperature, but temperature cannot change a stone into a chick, because the basis of the two is different. Mutual influence among the peoples of various countries exists constantly. In the era of capitalism, and especially in the era of imperialism and proletarian revolution, the mutual influence and mutual stimulus among countries in politics, economy and culture are extremely great. The October Socialist Revolution not only opened a new era in the history of Russia, but also opened a new era in world history, influenced the internal changes of countries throughout the world, and likewise, and especially profoundly, influenced the internal changes of China; but these changes came about through the regularity internal to the various countries themselves and internal to China itself. When two armies contend, one wins and one is defeated; the reason for victory or defeat is in every case decided by internal causes. The victor wins either because it is strong or because its command is without error; the vanquished is defeated either because it is weak or because its command is inappropriate; the external cause produces its effect through the internal cause. In 1927 the big bourgeoisie of China defeated the proletariat, and this operated through the opportunism inside the Chinese proletariat (inside the Chinese Communist Party). When we had liquidated this opportunism, the Chinese revolution developed anew. Later, the Chinese revolution again suffered severe blows from the enemy, because adventurism had arisen inside our Party. When we had liquidated this adventurism, our cause again developed anew. From this it can be seen that if a political party is to lead the revolution to victory, it must rely on the correctness of its own political line and on its organizational consolidation.
The dialectical world outlook arose in ancient times, whether in China or in Europe. But ancient dialectics bore a spontaneous and naive character; in the light of the social and historical conditions of the time, it could not yet have a complete theory, and therefore could not fully explain the universe, and was later replaced by metaphysics. Hegel, the famous German philosopher who lived in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, made a very important contribution to dialectics, but his dialectics was idealist dialectics. It was not until Marx and Engels, the great activists of the proletarian movement, synthesized the positive achievements of the history of human knowledge, and in particular critically absorbed the rational part of Hegel's dialectics, and created the great theory of dialectical materialism and historical materialism, that an unprecedented great revolution took place in the history of human knowledge. Later, through Lenin and Stalin, this great theory was further developed. As soon as this theory was transmitted to China, it caused extremely great changes in Chinese intellectual circles.
This dialectical world outlook teaches people, above all, to be good at observing and analyzing the movement of contradiction in all kinds of things, and, on the basis of such analysis, to point out the methods of resolving contradictions. Therefore, to understand concretely this law of the contradiction in things is very important for us.
2. The Universality of Contradiction
For convenience of exposition, I shall here speak first of the universality of contradiction, and then of the particularity of contradiction. This is because Marx, Engels, Lenin and Stalin, the great creators and successors of Marxism, discovered the world outlook of materialist dialectics, have already applied materialist dialectics to many aspects of the analysis of human history and of natural history, and to many aspects of the transformation of society and the transformation of nature (for example, in the Soviet Union), and have achieved extremely great success; the universality of contradiction has already been acknowledged by many people, and therefore only a few words are needed to make this problem clear; whereas, as to the problem of the particularity of contradiction, there are still many comrades, especially the dogmatists, who are not clear about it. They do not understand that the universality of contradiction resides precisely in the particularity of contradiction. Nor do they understand what important significance the study of the particularity of the contradiction in concrete things at present has for our guiding the development of revolutionary practice. Therefore, the problem of the particularity of contradiction ought to be studied with emphasis, and explained at sufficient length. For this reason, when we analyze the law of the contradiction in things, we first analyze the problem of the universality of contradiction, then emphatically analyze the problem of the particularity of contradiction, and finally return again to the problem of the universality of contradiction.
The problem of the universality or absoluteness of contradiction has two meanings. One is that contradiction exists in the process of development of all things; the other is that in the process of development of each thing there exists a movement of contradiction from beginning to end.
Engels said: "Motion itself is contradiction." The definition Lenin gave of the law of the unity of opposites is that it is "the recognition (discovery) that all phenomena and processes of nature (including both mind and society) contain mutually contradictory, mutually exclusive and mutually opposed tendencies." Are these views correct? They are correct. The mutual dependence and mutual struggle of the contradictory aspects contained in all things determine the life of all things and push forward the development of all things. There is nothing that does not contain contradiction; without contradiction there would be no world.
Contradiction is the basis of the simple forms of motion (for example, mechanical motion), and still more is it the basis of the complex forms of motion.
Engels explained the universality of contradiction in this way: "If simple mechanical displacement itself contains contradiction, then the higher forms of the motion of matter, and especially organic life and its development, contain contradiction all the more. ... Life consists above all in this: that a living thing at every instant is itself, and yet is something else. So life, too, is a contradiction, existing in things and processes themselves, which constantly produces itself and resolves itself of its own accord; the moment this contradiction ceases, life likewise ceases, and death thereupon arrives. Likewise, we have seen that within the sphere of thought we also cannot avoid contradiction, and we have seen that, for example, the contradiction between man's internally unlimited capacity for knowledge and the actual realization of this capacity only in individual people who are externally limited and also limited in respect of knowledge is resolved in the endless succession of human generations — endless, at least for us, and in fact endless — and in endless forward movement."
"One of the principal foundations of higher mathematics is contradiction..."
"Even elementary mathematics is full of contradiction...."
Lenin also explained the universality of contradiction in this way: "In mathematics, plus and minus, differential and integral.
In mechanics, action and reaction.
In physics, positive electricity and negative electricity.
In chemistry, the combination and dissociation of atoms.
In social science, the class struggle."
Attack and defense, advance and retreat, victory and defeat in war are all contradictory phenomena. If one side is lost, the other side ceases to exist. The two sides struggle and yet are linked, compose the totality of war, push forward the development of war, and resolve the problems of war.
Every difference in men's concepts should be regarded as a reflection of objective contradiction. Objective contradiction, reflected into subjective thought, composes the contradictory movement of concepts, pushes forward the development of thought, and ceaselessly resolves the problems in people's thinking.
The opposition and struggle of differing ideas within the Party occur constantly; this is the reflection, inside the Party, of the class contradictions of society and of the contradiction between new and old things. If there were no contradiction within the Party and no ideological struggle to resolve contradiction, the life of the Party would cease.
From this it can be seen that, whether in simple forms of motion or in complex forms of motion, whether in objective phenomena or in phenomena of thought, contradiction exists universally, and contradiction exists in every process; this point has already been made clear. But does contradiction also exist in the initial stage of every process? Does the process of development of every thing have a movement of contradiction from beginning to end?
It can be seen from the articles in which Soviet philosophical circles criticized the Deborin school that the Deborin school had a view of this kind: they held that contradiction does not appear in a process from the very beginning, but must wait until the process has developed to a certain stage before it appears. Then, before that time, the cause of the development of the process would not be an internal cause, but an external cause. In this way Deborin went back to the metaphysical theory of external causes and to mechanism. Applying this view to the analysis of concrete problems, they saw that under Soviet conditions there were only differences, and no contradiction, between the rich peasants and the peasants in general, and they fully agreed with Bukharin's opinion. In analyzing the French Revolution, they held that before the revolution, within the Third Estate, jointly composed of workers, peasants and the bourgeoisie, there were likewise only differences and no contradiction. Views of this kind held by the Deborin school are anti-Marxist. They do not know that contradiction is already contained in every difference in the world, and that difference is contradiction. Between labor and capital, from the time the two classes came into being, there has been mutual contradiction; it has merely not yet become acute. Between workers and peasants, even under the social conditions of the Soviet Union, there are also differences, and their differences are contradiction; they merely will not become acute and turn into antagonism, and do not take the form of class struggle, differing from the contradiction between labor and capital; they form a firm alliance in socialist construction, and gradually resolve this contradiction in the process of development from socialism toward communism. This is a question of the distinctness of contradictions, not a question of the presence or absence of contradiction. Contradiction is universal and absolute; it exists in every process of the development of things, and also runs through every process from beginning to end.
What is the emergence of a new process? It is the old unity, and the opposite components that compose this unity, giving place to a new unity and the opposite components that compose this unity, whereupon the new process emerges in place of the old process. The old process is completed, and the new process emerges. The new process again contains new contradictions, and begins its own history of the development of contradiction.
As to the movement of contradiction from beginning to end in the process of development of things, Lenin pointed out that Marx made a model analysis of this kind in Capital. This is a method that must be applied in studying the process of development of any thing. Lenin himself also correctly applied it, and carried it through all his writings.
"What Marx first analyzes in Capital is the simplest, most ordinary, most fundamental, most commonly seen, most commonplace relation in bourgeois society (commodity society), a relation encountered hundreds of millions of times — the exchange of commodities. This analysis, in this simplest phenomenon (in this 'cell' of bourgeois society), exposes all the contradictions of modern society (and the germs of all contradictions). The subsequent exposition then shows us the development, from beginning to end, of these contradictions and of the sum of the various parts of this society (both growth and motion)."
After saying the above, Lenin went on to say: "This ought to be the method of exposition (and of study) of dialectics in general...."
The Chinese Communists must learn this method before they can correctly analyze the history and the present condition of the Chinese revolution and infer the future of the revolution.
3. The Particularity of Contradiction
That contradiction exists in the process of development of all things, and that contradiction runs through the process of development of every thing from beginning to end, is the universality and absoluteness of contradiction, which has already been spoken of above. Now let us speak of the particularity and relativity of contradiction.
This problem should be studied in several kinds of circumstances.
First, the contradictions in the various forms of motion of matter all bear particularity. Man's knowledge of matter is knowledge of the forms of motion of matter, because apart from matter in motion there is nothing in the world, and the motion of matter must take definite forms. With regard to each form of motion of matter, attention must be paid to the points it has in common with the other various forms of motion. But what is especially important, and what becomes the basis of our knowledge of things, is that attention must be paid to its particular points, that is, attention must be paid to its qualitative distinction from other forms of motion. Only by paying attention to this point is it possible to distinguish things. Any form of motion contains within itself its own particular contradiction. This particular contradiction constitutes the particular essence that distinguishes one thing from other things. This is the internal cause, or what is called the basis, of why the various things in the world are so vastly different. In nature there exist many forms of motion; mechanical motion, the production of sound, the emission of light, the production of heat, electric current, decomposition, combination, and so on, are all such. All these forms of the motion of matter are mutually dependent, and are also essentially mutually distinct. The particular essence possessed by each form of the motion of matter is determined by its own particular contradiction. This situation exists not only in nature; it likewise exists in social phenomena and in phenomena of thought. Every social form and every form of thought has its particular contradiction and its particular essence.
The distinctions of scientific research are made according to the particular contradictory nature possessed by the objects of science. Therefore, the study of a certain kind of contradiction peculiar to a certain realm of phenomena constitutes the object of a certain branch of science. For example, positive numbers and negative numbers in mathematics, action and reaction in mechanics, negative electricity and positive electricity in physics, decomposition and combination in chemistry, the productive forces and the relations of production and the mutual struggle of classes and class in social science, attack and defense in military science, idealism and materialism and the metaphysical view and the dialectical view in philosophy, and so on, all constitute different objects of scientific research because they possess particular contradictions and particular essences. True, if one does not recognize the universality of contradiction, one has no way of discovering the universal cause or universal basis of the movement and development of things; but if one does not study the particularity of contradiction, one has no way of determining the particular essence that distinguishes one thing from other things, no way of discovering the particular cause, or particular basis, of the movement and development of things, and thus no way of distinguishing things and no way of distinguishing the realms of scientific research.
As regards the order of the movement of human knowledge, it is always from knowing individual and particular things and gradually extending to knowing things in general. People always first know the particular essences of many different things, and only then is it possible to go further and carry out the work of generalization and know the common essence of the various things. Once people have known this common essence, they take this common knowledge as a guide and continue to study the various concrete things that have not yet been studied, or have not yet been studied in depth, and find out their particular essences; only in this way can this knowledge of the common essence be supplemented, enriched and developed, so that this knowledge of the common essence does not turn into something withered and rigid. These are two processes of knowledge: one is from the particular to the general, and one is from the general to the particular. Human knowledge always proceeds in this way, in recurrent cycles, and each cycle (so long as it is strictly in accordance with scientific method) can raise human knowledge a step higher and make human knowledge continually deepen. The error of our dogmatists on this problem is that, on the one hand, they do not understand that one must study the particularity of contradiction and know the particular essences of individual things before it is possible fully to know the universality of contradiction and fully to know the common essence of the various things; and, on the other hand, they do not understand that after we have known the common essence of things, we must still continue to study those concrete things that have not yet been studied in depth, or that have newly emerged. Our dogmatists are lazybones; they refuse to do any arduous work of studying concrete things; they regard general truth as something that appears out of thin air, turn it into a purely abstract formula that people cannot grasp, and completely deny and reverse this normal order of man's knowing truth. Nor do they understand the interconnection of the two processes of human knowledge — from the particular to the general, and again from the general to the particular; they do not understand the Marxist theory of knowledge at all.
Not only must one study the particular contradictory nature of the form of motion of matter of every large system, and the essence determined by it, but one must also study the particular contradiction, and its essence, of every process in the long course of development of every form of motion of matter. Within every real, non-fictitious process of development of every form of motion, things are qualitatively different. Our work of study must lay stress on this point, and must begin from this point.
Qualitatively different contradictions can be resolved only by qualitatively different methods. For example, the contradiction between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie is resolved by the method of socialist revolution; the contradiction between the masses of the people and the feudal system is resolved by the method of democratic revolution; the contradiction between the colonies and imperialism is resolved by the method of national revolutionary war; the contradiction between the working class and the peasant class in socialist society is resolved by the method of agricultural collectivization and agricultural mechanization; contradictions within the Communist Party are resolved by the method of criticism and self-criticism; the contradiction between society and nature is resolved by the method of developing the productive forces. When the process changes, the old process and the old contradictions disappear, a new process and new contradictions emerge, and the methods of resolving contradictions also differ accordingly. The contradictions resolved by the February Revolution and the October Revolution in Russia, and the methods by which they resolved contradictions, are fundamentally not the same. To use different methods to resolve different contradictions is a principle that Marxists-Leninists must strictly observe. The dogmatists do not observe this principle; they do not understand the distinctions among the various revolutionary situations, and therefore do not understand that different methods ought to be used to resolve different contradictions, but only indiscriminately use everywhere one formula which they regard as unchangeable, forcing it on, and this can only cause the revolution to suffer setbacks, or turn things that were originally being done well into something very bad.
In order to expose the particularity of the contradictions in the process of development of a thing in their totality and in their interconnection, that is, in order to expose the essence of the process of development of a thing, one must expose the particularity of each aspect of the contradictions in the process; otherwise, exposing the essence of the process becomes impossible. This, too, is something we must pay very close attention to in doing our work of study.
A large thing, in its process of development, contains many contradictions. For example, in the process of China's bourgeois-democratic revolution, there is the contradiction between the various oppressed classes of Chinese society and imperialism, the contradiction between the masses of the people and the feudal system, the contradiction between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie, the contradiction between the peasants and the urban petty bourgeoisie and the bourgeoisie, the contradictions among the various reactionary ruling groups, and so on; the situation is very complicated. These contradictions not only each have their particularity and cannot be treated uniformly, but the two aspects of each contradiction again each have their characteristics, and likewise cannot be treated uniformly. Those of us who are engaged in the Chinese revolution must not only understand the particularity of each contradiction in its totality, that is, in the interconnection of the contradictions, but only by setting out to study the various aspects of a contradiction is it possible to understand its totality. What is called understanding the various aspects of a contradiction is understanding what particular position each aspect occupies, what concrete form each uses in entering into a relation of mutual dependence and mutual contradiction with the other, and, in mutual dependence and mutual contradiction, and again after the dependence has broken, what concrete method each uses in struggling with the other. To study these problems is a matter of very great importance. Lenin said: the most essential thing in Marxism, the living soul of Marxism, lies in the concrete analysis of concrete conditions. This is what is meant. Our dogmatists violate Lenin's instruction; they never use their brains to analyze any thing concretely, and when they write articles or make speeches it is always an empty eight-legged-essay tone, creating an extremely bad style inside our Party.
In studying a problem, one must avoid subjectivity, one-sidedness and superficiality. What is called subjectivity is not knowing how to look at problems objectively, that is, not knowing how to look at problems from a materialist viewpoint. This point I have already spoken of in the essay On Practice. What is called one-sidedness is not knowing how to look at problems all-sidedly. For example: understanding only the Chinese side and not the Japanese side, understanding only the Communist side and not the Kuomintang side, understanding only the proletarian side and not the bourgeois side, understanding only the peasant side and not the landlord side, understanding only the side of favorable circumstances and not the side of difficult circumstances, understanding only the side of the past and not the side of the future, understanding only the side of the individual and not the side of the whole, understanding only the side of shortcomings and not the side of achievements, understanding only the plaintiff's side and not the defendant's side, understanding only the side of the secret work of the revolution and not the side of the open work of the revolution, and so on. In a word, not understanding the characteristics of each aspect of a contradiction. This is called looking at a problem one-sidedly. Or it is called seeing only the part and not the whole, seeing only the trees and not the forest. In this way, one cannot find the method of resolving contradictions, cannot accomplish the tasks of the revolution, cannot do well the work one is charged with, and cannot correctly develop the ideological struggle inside the Party. Sunzi, discussing military affairs, said: "Know the other and know yourself, and in a hundred battles you will not be endangered." What he spoke of was the two sides in combat. Wei Zheng of the Tang dynasty said: "Listen to both sides and you will be clear-sighted; trust only one side and you will be benighted." He, too, understood that one-sidedness is wrong. But our comrades, in looking at problems, often carry one-sidedness with them, and such people often meet with rebuffs. In Water Margin, Song Jiang thrice attacked Zhu Family Village, and twice, because the situation was unclear and the methods were wrong, he was defeated in battle. Later he changed his method and began by investigating the circumstances, and thus became familiar with the twisting paths, broke up the alliance of Li Family Village, Hu Family Village and Zhu Family Village, and also arranged troops lying hidden in the enemy's camp, and, using a method resembling what is called the wooden-horse stratagem in foreign stories, won the battle the third time. There are many instances of materialist dialectics in Water Margin, and this thrice attacking Zhu Family Village may be counted the best of them. Lenin said: "To know an object truly, one must grasp and study all its aspects, all its connections and 'mediations.' We shall never completely achieve this, but the demand for all-sidedness will keep us from errors and from becoming rigid." We should remember his words. Superficiality is not looking at the characteristics either of the totality of a contradiction or of the aspects of a contradiction, denying the necessity of going deep inside things and meticulously studying the characteristics of contradiction, merely standing there and looking from afar, seeing in a crude way a bit of the form of a contradiction, and then wanting to set to work to resolve the contradiction (answer questions, settle disputes, handle work, direct war). Such a way of doing things never fails to lead to trouble. The reason our dogmatist and empiricist comrades make mistakes is that their way of looking at things is subjective, one-sided and superficial. One-sidedness and superficiality are also subjectivity, because all objective things are originally interconnected and possess internal laws; if people do not reflect these circumstances as they are, but only look at them one-sidedly or superficially, and do not recognize the interconnections of things and do not recognize the internal laws of things, then this method is subjectivist.
Not only must we pay attention to the characteristics of the movement of contradiction throughout the whole process of the development of a thing, in its interconnections and in the circumstances of its various aspects, but in the various stages of the development of the process there are also characteristics, and attention must also be paid to them.
The fundamental contradiction of the process of development of a thing, and the essence of the process determined by this fundamental contradiction, will not disappear until the day the process is completed; but the various stages of development in the long process of the development of a thing are often again mutually distinct in their circumstances. This is because, although the nature of the fundamental contradiction of the process of development of a thing, and the essence of the process, have not changed, the fundamental contradiction takes a gradually intensified form at the various stages of development in the long process. Moreover, among the many large and small contradictions determined or influenced by the fundamental contradiction, some have become acute, some have been temporarily or partially resolved, or have been eased, and some again have arisen; therefore the process displays its stages. If people do not pay attention to the stages in the process of development of a thing, people cannot properly handle the contradictions of the thing.
For example, when the capitalism of the era of free competition developed into imperialism, at this time the nature of the two fundamentally contradictory classes, the proletariat and the bourgeoisie, and the capitalist essence of this society, did not change; but the contradiction between the two classes became acute, the contradiction between monopoly capital and free capital arose, the contradiction between the metropolitan countries and the colonies became acute, and the contradiction among the capitalist countries, that is, the contradiction aroused by the state of uneven development of the various countries, manifested itself with particular sharpness, and therefore a special stage of capitalism was formed, the stage of imperialism was formed. The reason Leninism became the Marxism of the era of imperialism and proletarian revolution is that Lenin and Stalin correctly explained these contradictions and correctly worked out the theory and tactics of proletarian revolution for resolving these contradictions.
Take the circumstances of the process of China's bourgeois-democratic revolution, beginning with the Revolution of 1911: there have also been a number of special stages. In particular, the revolution in the period of bourgeois leadership and the revolution in the period of proletarian leadership are distinguished as two greatly different historical stages. That is: because of the leadership of the proletariat, the face of the revolution was fundamentally changed, a new disposition of class relations was brought about, a great arousing of the peasant revolution, the thoroughness of the revolution against imperialism and against feudalism, the possibility of passing from the democratic revolution to the socialist revolution, and so on. All these were things that could not appear in the period when the bourgeoisie led the revolution. Although, throughout the whole process, the nature of the fundamental contradiction, and the nature of the process as a democratic revolution against imperialism and against feudalism (its reverse side being a semi-colonial and semi-feudal nature), did not change, yet in this long period of time, through such great events as the failure of the Revolution of 1911 and the rule of the Beiyang warlords, the establishment of the first national united front and the revolution of 1924 to 1927, the rupture of the united front and the bourgeoisie turning to counter-revolution, the new warlord wars, the agrarian revolutionary war, the establishment of the second national united front and the War of Resistance against Japan, and so on, several stages of development were passed through in the course of more than twenty years. In these stages there were contained such special circumstances as that some contradictions became acute (for example, the agrarian revolutionary war and Japan's invasion of the four northeastern provinces), some contradictions were partially or temporarily resolved (for example, the Beiyang warlords were eliminated, and we confiscated the land of the landlords), and some contradictions arose anew (for example, the struggle among the new warlords, and the landlords taking back the land again after the loss of the various revolutionary base areas in the south).
In studying the particularity of the contradictions at the various stages of development in the process of development of a thing, one must not only look at them in their interconnection and in their totality, but must also look at them from the various aspects of the contradictions in the various stages.
For example, the two parties, the Kuomintang and the Communist Party. On the Kuomintang side, in the period of the first united front, because it carried out Sun Yat-sen's Three Great Policies of alliance with Russia, alliance with the Communist Party, and assistance to the workers and peasants, it was revolutionary and full of vigor; it was an alliance of the various classes for the democratic revolution. After 1927, the Kuomintang changed to the opposite of this and became a reactionary bloc of the landlords and the big bourgeoisie. After the Xi'an Incident of December 1936, it again began to turn toward stopping the civil war and uniting with the Communist Party to oppose Japanese imperialism in common. These are the characteristics of the Kuomintang at the three stages. The formation of these characteristics, of course, had all sorts of causes. On the side of the Chinese Communist Party, in the period of the first united front, it was a party in its infancy; it heroically led the revolution of 1924 to 1927; but in respect of its understanding of the nature, tasks and methods of the revolution, it displayed its infancy, and therefore the Chen Duxiu-ism that arose in the later period of this revolution was able to play a role and caused this revolution to suffer defeat. After 1927, it again heroically led the agrarian revolutionary war and founded a revolutionary army and revolutionary base areas, but it also committed the error of adventurism, causing both the army and the base areas to suffer very great losses. After 1935, it again corrected the error of adventurism and led the new anti-Japanese united front, and this great struggle is now developing. At this stage, the Communist Party is a party that has been tested by two revolutions and has rich experience. These are the characteristics of the Chinese Communist Party at the three stages. The formation of these characteristics also had all sorts of causes. If one does not study these characteristics, one cannot understand the special mutual relations of the two parties at the various stages of development: the establishment of the united front, the rupture of the united front, and the establishment of another united front. And to study the various characteristics of the two parties, one must, still more fundamentally, study the class basis of these two parties and the opposition, formed thereby in the various periods, of their contradictions with other sides. For example, in the period when the Kuomintang first united with the Communist Party, on the one hand it had a contradiction with foreign imperialism, and therefore it opposed imperialism; on the other hand it had a contradiction with the masses of the people at home, and although in words it promised to give the laboring people many benefits, in fact it gave only very few benefits, or gave nothing at all. In the period when it waged the war against the Communists, it cooperated with imperialism and feudalism to oppose the masses of the people, wrote off at one stroke all the benefits the masses of the people had originally won in the revolution, and intensified its contradiction with the masses of the people. In the present period of resistance against Japan, the Kuomintang has a contradiction with Japanese imperialism; while it wants to unite with the Communist Party, at the same time it does not relax its struggle against and oppression of the Communist Party and the people at home. The Communist Party, in whichever period, stands together with the masses of the people and opposes imperialism and feudalism; but in the present period of resistance against Japan, because the Kuomintang has expressed resistance to Japan, it has also adopted a policy of easing toward the Kuomintang and the feudal forces at home. Because of these circumstances, there has resulted either the alliance of the two parties or the struggle of the two parties, and even in the period of alliance of the two parties there has been the complicated situation of both alliance and struggle. If we do not study the characteristics of these aspects of contradiction, we not only cannot understand the relations of each of these two parties with other sides, but also cannot understand the mutual relations between the two parties.
From this it can be seen that, no matter what kind of characteristics of contradiction one studies — the contradictions of the various forms of motion of matter, the contradictions of the various forms of motion in their various processes of development, the various aspects of the contradictions of the various processes of development, the contradictions of the various processes of development at their various stages of development, and the various aspects of the contradictions at the various stages of development — in studying the characteristics of all these contradictions, one cannot carry any subjective arbitrariness, but must carry out a concrete analysis of them. Apart from concrete analysis, one cannot know the characteristics of any contradiction. We must constantly remember Lenin's words: make a concrete analysis of concrete things.
This kind of concrete analysis was first given us as a very good model by Marx and Engels.
When Marx and Engels applied this law of the contradiction in things to the study of the process of social history, they saw the contradiction between the productive forces and the relations of production, saw the contradiction between the exploiting classes and the exploited classes, and the contradiction, produced by these contradictions, between the economic base and the superstructure of politics, thought and so on, and saw how these contradictions inevitably lead, in the various different class societies, to various different social revolutions.
When Marx applied this law to the study of the economic structure of capitalist society, he saw that the basic contradiction of this society lies in the contradiction between the social character of production and the private character of the system of appropriation. This contradiction manifests itself in the contradiction between the organized character of production in the individual enterprises and the unorganized character of production in society as a whole. The class manifestation of this contradiction is the contradiction between the bourgeoisie and the proletariat.
Because the scope of things is extremely vast, and development is unlimited, what is universality in a given case becomes particularity in another given case. Conversely, what is particularity in a given case becomes universality in another given case. The contradiction, contained in the capitalist system, between the socialization of production and the private ownership of the means of production is something common to all countries in which capitalism exists and develops; as far as capitalism is concerned, this is the universality of contradiction. But this contradiction of capitalism is something belonging to the development of class society in general at a definite historical stage; as far as the contradiction between the productive forces and the relations of production in class society in general is concerned, this is the particularity of contradiction. Yet, once Marx had dissected the particularity of all these contradictions of capitalist society, he at the same time also went further, more fully and more completely, in elucidating the universality of this contradiction between the productive forces and the relations of production in class society in general.
Because particular things are linked with universal things, and because the inside of every thing contains not only the particularity of contradiction but also the universality of contradiction, and universality exists in particularity, therefore, when we study a given thing, we ought to discover these two aspects and their interconnection, discover the two aspects of particularity and universality inside a thing and their interconnection, and discover the interconnection of a thing with the many things outside it. When Stalin, in his famous work The Foundations of Leninism, explained the historical roots of Leninism, he analyzed the international environment from which Leninism arose, analyzed the various contradictions of capitalism, which under the conditions of imperialism had already developed to the extreme, and how these contradictions made proletarian revolution a question of direct practice and created favorable conditions for a direct assault on capitalism. Not only that: he also analyzed why Russia became the place of origin of Leninism, analyzed how tsarist Russia at that time was the point of concentration of all the contradictions of imperialism, and the reasons why the Russian proletariat was able to become the vanguard of the international revolutionary proletariat. In this way, Stalin analyzed the universality of the contradictions of imperialism, and explained that Leninism is the Marxism of the era of imperialism and proletarian revolution; and he also analyzed the particularity possessed by tsarist Russian imperialism within these contradictions in general, and explained that Russia became the homeland of the theory and tactics of proletarian revolution, while within this particularity the universality of contradiction was contained. This analysis of Stalin's provides us with a model for knowing the particularity and universality of contradiction and their interconnection.
Marx and Engels, and likewise Lenin and Stalin, whenever they applied dialectics to the study of objective phenomena, always guided people not to carry any subjective arbitrariness, but to see, from the concrete conditions contained in the actual objective movement, the concrete contradictions in these phenomena, the concrete position of the various aspects of the contradictions, and the concrete mutual relations of the contradictions. Our dogmatists, because they do not have this attitude of study, get nothing right. We must take the failure of dogmatism as a warning, and learn this attitude of study; apart from this there is no second method of study.
The relation between the universality of contradiction and the particularity of contradiction is the relation between the common character and the individual character of contradiction. Its common character is that contradiction exists in every process and runs through every process from beginning to end; contradiction is motion, is things, is process, and is also thought. To deny the contradiction in things is to deny everything. This is a truth common to all; in ancient and modern times, in China and abroad, there is no exception. Therefore it is common character, it is absoluteness. Yet this common character is contained in every individual character; without individual character there is no common character. If all individual character is removed, what common character remains? Because each contradiction is particular, individual character is thereby created. All individual character exists conditionally and temporarily, and is therefore relative.
This truth of common character and individual character, of the absolute and the relative, is the essence of the problem of contradiction in things; not to understand it is tantamount to discarding dialectics.
4. The Principal Contradiction and the Principal Aspect of a Contradiction
Within the problem of the particularity of contradiction, there are two further circumstances that must be specially brought forward for analysis; these are the principal contradiction and the principal aspect of a contradiction.
In the process of development of a complex thing, there exist many contradictions, among which there must be one that is the principal contradiction, and by its existence and development it determines or influences the existence and development of the other contradictions.
For example, in capitalist society, the two contradictory forces, the proletariat and the bourgeoisie, are the principal contradiction; the other contradictory forces, for example, the contradiction between the residual feudal class and the bourgeoisie, the contradiction between the peasant petty proprietors and the bourgeoisie, the contradiction between the proletariat and the peasant petty proprietors, the contradiction between the free bourgeoisie and the monopoly bourgeoisie, the contradiction between bourgeois democracy and bourgeois fascism, the contradictions among the capitalist countries, the contradiction between imperialism and the colonies, and other contradictions, are all determined and influenced by this principal contradictory force.
In a semi-colonial country such as China, the relation between the principal contradiction and the non-principal contradictions presents a complicated situation.
When imperialism wages a war of aggression against such a country, the various classes inside this country, apart from some traitors, are able temporarily to unite and wage a national war to oppose imperialism. At this time, the contradiction between imperialism and this country becomes the principal contradiction, and all the contradictions among the various classes inside this country (including this principal contradiction between the feudal system and the masses of the people) temporarily drop to a secondary and subordinate position. China's Opium War of 1840, the Sino-Japanese War of 1894, the Boxer War of 1900, and the present Sino-Japanese War all have this circumstance.
Yet under another circumstance, the positions of the contradictions change. When imperialism carries on oppression not by war but in the comparatively mild forms of politics, economy, culture and so on, the ruling class of the semi-colonial country will capitulate to imperialism, and the two will form an alliance and jointly oppress the masses of the people. At such a time, the masses of the people often adopt the form of civil war to oppose the alliance of imperialism and the feudal classes, while imperialism often adopts an indirect manner of aiding the reactionaries of the semi-colonial country in oppressing the people, and does not take direct action, displaying the particular sharpness of the internal contradiction. China's revolutionary war of 1911, the revolutionary war of 1924 to 1927, and the ten-year agrarian revolutionary war after 1927 all have this circumstance. There are also the civil wars among the various reactionary ruling groups of semi-colonial countries, for example the warlord wars in China, which also belong to this category.
When the domestic revolutionary war develops to the point of fundamentally threatening the existence of imperialism and of its running dogs, the domestic reactionaries, imperialism often adopts methods other than those mentioned above in an attempt to maintain its rule: either splitting the inside of the revolutionary front, or directly sending troops to aid the domestic reactionaries. At this time, foreign imperialism and the domestic reactionaries stand completely and openly at one extreme, and the masses of the people stand at the other extreme, becoming a principal contradiction, and determining or influencing the state of development of the other contradictions. The aid given by the various capitalist countries to the Russian reactionaries after the October Revolution is an example of armed intervention. Chiang Kai-shek's betrayal in 1927 is an example of splitting the revolutionary front.
Yet however that may be, in the various stages of the development of a process, only one principal contradiction plays the leading role; of this there is no doubt at all.
From this it can be known that if any process has a number of contradictions existing in it, among them there must be one that is principal, playing the leading and decisive role, while the others are in a secondary and subordinate position. Therefore, in studying any process, if it is a complex process in which more than two contradictions exist, one must use one's whole effort to find its principal contradiction. Once this principal contradiction is grasped, all problems are readily solved. This is the method that Marx's study of capitalist society tells us. When Lenin and Stalin studied imperialism and the general crisis of capitalism, and when Lenin and Stalin studied the economy of the Soviet Union, they also told us this method. Thousands upon thousands of scholars and men of action do not understand this method, and the result is that they are as if lost in a vast sea of smoke, cannot find the center, and thus cannot find the method of resolving contradictions.
One cannot treat all the contradictions in a process equally; one must distinguish them into the two categories of principal and secondary, and lay stress on grasping the principal contradiction, as has already been said above. But among the various contradictions, whether principal or secondary, can the two contradictory aspects again be treated equally? That, too, is not possible. In whatever contradiction, the development of the aspects of the contradiction is uneven. Sometimes they seem evenly matched in strength, yet this is only a temporary and relative circumstance; the basic form is unevenness. Of the two contradictory aspects, there must be one aspect that is principal and the other aspect that is secondary. Its principal aspect is the aspect in which the contradiction plays the leading role. The nature of a thing is determined mainly by the principal aspect of the contradiction that has obtained the dominant position.
Yet this circumstance is not fixed; the principal and non-principal aspects of a contradiction transform into each other, and the nature of the thing changes accordingly. At a given process or a given stage of the development of a contradiction, the principal aspect belongs to side A and the non-principal aspect belongs to side B; when another stage of development or another process of development is reached, they exchange their positions. This is determined by the degree of increase or decrease in the strength of the struggle of the two sides of the contradiction in the development of the thing.
We often say the phrase "the new supersedes the old." The supersession of the old by the new is a universal and eternally irresistible law in the universe. According to the nature and conditions of the thing itself, and through different forms of leap, one thing is transformed into another thing; this is the process of the new superseding the old. Inside any thing there is the contradiction of its two aspects, the new and the old, forming a series of tortuous struggles. The result of the struggle is that the new aspect changes from small to large and rises to become the dominant thing, while the old aspect changes from large to small and becomes something that gradually goes to its doom. And once the new aspect has obtained the dominant position over the old aspect, the nature of the old thing changes into the nature of the new thing. From this it can be seen that the nature of a thing is determined mainly by the principal aspect of the contradiction that has obtained the dominant position. When the principal aspect of the contradiction that has obtained the dominant position changes, the nature of the thing also changes accordingly.
In capitalist society, capitalism has been transformed from its position as an appendage in the era of the old feudal society into a force that has obtained the dominant position, and the nature of society has accordingly changed from feudal to capitalist. In the era of the new capitalist society, the feudal forces have been transformed from a force originally in the dominant position into an appendage force, and accordingly have gradually gone to extinction, as in such countries as Britain and France. With the development of the productive forces, the bourgeoisie has been transformed from a new class playing a progressive role into an old class playing a reactionary role, until finally it is overthrown by the proletariat and transformed into a class deprived of the privately owned means of production and stripped of power, and this class, too, will gradually go to extinction. The proletariat, far more numerous than the bourgeoisie, growing up at the same time as the bourgeoisie, but ruled by the bourgeoisie, is a new force; from its early position of being appended to the bourgeoisie, it gradually grows strong, becomes an independent class playing the leading role in history, and finally seizes political power and becomes the ruling class. At this time, the nature of society is transformed from the old capitalist society into the new socialist society. This is the road the Soviet Union has already traveled and that all other countries must inevitably travel.
As far as the circumstances of China are concerned, imperialism occupies the principal position in the contradiction that forms the semi-colony, and oppresses the Chinese people, while China has changed from an independent country into a semi-colony. Yet things will inevitably change; in the situation of the struggle of the two sides, the force grown up by the Chinese people under the leadership of the proletariat will inevitably change China from a semi-colony into an independent country, while imperialism will be overthrown, and the old China will inevitably become a new China.
The change of the old China into a new China also contains the change in the situation between the old feudal forces and the new forces of the people at home. The old feudal landlord class will be overthrown and change from ruler to ruled, and this class, too, will gradually go to extinction. The people, under the leadership of the proletariat, will change from the ruled to the rulers. At this time, the nature of Chinese society will change, from the old semi-colonial and semi-feudal society into a new democratic society.
Such mutual transformation has had its experience in the past. The Qing empire, which ruled China for nearly three hundred years, was overthrown in the period of the Revolution of 1911; while the Revolutionary Alliance led by Sun Yat-sen once achieved victory. In the revolutionary war of 1924 to 1927, the southern revolutionary forces of the alliance of the Communist Party and the Kuomintang changed from a weak force into a powerful one and won the victory of the Northern Expedition; while the Beiyang warlords, who had dominated for a time, were overthrown. In 1927, the forces of the people led by the Communist Party, having suffered the blows of the reactionary forces of the Kuomintang, became very small; but because the opportunism inside themselves had been eliminated, they again gradually grew strong. Inside the revolutionary base areas led by the Communist Party, the peasants were transformed from the ruled into the rulers, while the landlords underwent the opposite transformation. The world is always thus, replacing the old with the new, always thus the new superseding the old, discarding the old and laying out the new, or pushing out the old to bring forth the new.
At certain times in revolutionary struggle, the conditions of difficulty exceed the conditions of smoothness; at such times, difficulty is the principal aspect of the contradiction, and smoothness is its secondary aspect. Yet, through the efforts of the revolutionaries, the difficulties can be gradually overcome and a new situation of smoothness opened up, and the situation of difficulty gives place to the situation of smoothness. The circumstances after the failure of the Chinese revolution in 1927, and the circumstances of the Chinese Red Army on the Long March, were both like this. In the present Sino-Japanese War, China is again in a difficult position, but we are able to change this situation and bring about a fundamental change in the circumstances of both China and Japan. Under the opposite circumstances, smoothness can also be transformed into difficulty, if the revolutionaries have made mistakes. The victory of the revolution of 1924 to 1927 turned into failure. The revolutionary base areas that developed in the southern provinces after 1927 had all failed by 1934.
When one studies, the contradiction between not knowing and knowing is also like this. When we have just begun to study Marxism, the state of ignorance of Marxism, or of knowing little of it, and knowledge of Marxism are in mutual contradiction. Yet, through diligent study, one can be transformed from ignorance to knowledge, from knowing little to knowing a great deal, and from blindness with regard to Marxism to being able to apply Marxism freely.
Some people feel that certain contradictions are not like this. For example, in the contradiction between the productive forces and the relations of production, the productive forces are principal; in the contradiction between theory and practice, practice is principal; in the contradiction between the economic base and the superstructure, the economic base is principal: their positions do not transform into each other. This is the view of mechanical materialism, not the view of dialectical materialism. It is true that the productive forces, practice and the economic base in general manifest the principal and determining role; whoever does not admit this is not a materialist. Yet the relations of production, theory and the superstructure, these aspects, under certain conditions, in turn manifest their principal and determining role; this, too, must be admitted. When the productive forces cannot develop unless the relations of production are changed, the change in the relations of production plays the principal and determining role. When, as Lenin said, "Without revolutionary theory, there will be no revolutionary movement," the creation and advocacy of revolutionary theory play the principal and determining role. When a certain thing (and any thing is the same) is to be done, but there is as yet no orientation, method, plan or policy, the determination of the orientation, method, plan or policy is also the principal and determining thing. When the superstructure of politics, culture and so on obstructs the development of the economic base, renovation in politics and in culture becomes the principal and determining thing. In saying this, are we violating materialism? No. Because we recognize that in the overall development of history it is the material that determines the spiritual, and social being that determines social consciousness; but at the same time we recognize, and must recognize, the reaction of the spiritual, the reaction of social consciousness upon social being, and the reaction of the superstructure upon the economic base. This is not violating materialism; it is precisely avoiding mechanical materialism and upholding dialectical materialism.
In studying the problem of the particularity of contradiction, if one does not study the two circumstances of the principal contradiction and the non-principal contradictions in a process, and of the principal aspect and the non-principal aspect of a contradiction, that is to say, if one does not study the distinctness of these two situations of contradiction, one will fall into abstract study, be unable to understand concretely the situation of the contradiction, and therefore also be unable to find the correct method of resolving the contradiction. The distinctness, or particularity, of these two situations of contradiction is in both cases the unevenness of the forces of contradiction. There is nothing in the world that develops in absolute balance; we must oppose the theory of balance, or the theory of equilibrium. At the same time, this concrete situation of contradiction, and the changes of the principal aspect and the non-principal aspect of contradiction in the process of development, precisely manifest the force of new things replacing old things. The study of the various situations of unevenness of contradiction, and the study of the principal contradiction and the non-principal contradictions, and of the principal aspect of a contradiction and the non-principal aspect of a contradiction, become one of the important methods by which a revolutionary party correctly determines its strategic and tactical orientation in politics and in military affairs, and are something that all Communists ought to pay attention to.
5. The Identity and Struggle of the Aspects of a Contradiction
After understanding the problems of the universality and particularity of contradiction, we must go on to study the problem of the identity and struggle of the aspects of a contradiction.
Identity, unity, coincidence, mutual permeation, mutual interpenetration, mutual dependence (or interdependence), mutual connection or mutual cooperation — these different terms all mean one thing, and speak of the following two circumstances: first, the two aspects of every contradiction in the process of development of a thing each take the aspect opposed to it as the precondition of its own existence, and the two sides coexist in a single unity; second, the two contradictory sides, according to certain conditions, each transform toward their opposite aspect. These are what is called identity.
Lenin said: "Dialectics is a doctrine of this kind: it studies how opposites can be identical, and how they become identical (how they turn into the identical) — under what conditions they transform into each other and become identical — why the human mind ought not to regard these opposites as dead and frozen things, but ought to regard them as living, conditional, changeable and mutually transforming things."
What is the meaning of this passage of Lenin's?
The contradictory aspects in every process are originally mutually exclusive, mutually struggling and mutually opposed. In the processes of all things in the world, and in people's thinking, there are contained such aspects bearing a contradictory nature, with no exception. A simple process has only one pair of contradictions; a complex process has more than one pair of contradictions. Between the pairs of contradictions, they again become contradictions to each other. In this way are composed all the things of the objective world and people's thinking, and they are pushed into motion.
This being so, they are only extremely not identical and extremely not unified; how can one again say that they are identical or unified?
As it turns out, the contradictory aspects cannot exist in isolation. If there were not the contradictory side opposed to it, this side of its own would lose the condition of its existence. Just think of all contradictory things, or of contradictory concepts in people's minds: can any one aspect exist independently? Without life, death is not seen; without death, life is not seen either. Without above, there is no such thing as below; without below, there is also no such thing as above. Without misfortune, there is no such thing as good fortune; without good fortune, there is also no such thing as misfortune. Without smoothness, there is no such thing as difficulty; without difficulty, there is also no such thing as smoothness. Without the landlord, there is no tenant peasant; without the tenant peasant, there is also no landlord. Without the bourgeoisie, there is no proletariat; without the proletariat, there is also no bourgeoisie. Without the national oppression of imperialism, there are no colonies and semi-colonies; without colonies and semi-colonies, there is also no national oppression of imperialism. All opposite components are like this: because of certain conditions, they are on the one hand mutually opposed, and on the other hand again mutually connected, mutually interpenetrating, mutually permeating and mutually dependent; this quality is called identity. All contradictory aspects, because of certain conditions, possess non-identity, and are therefore called contradiction. Yet they also possess identity, and are therefore mutually connected. What Lenin called dialectics studying "how opposites can be identical" speaks precisely of this circumstance. How can they? Because they are each the condition of the other's existence. This is the first meaning of identity.
Yet is it enough merely to have said that the two sides of a contradiction are each the condition of the other's existence, that there is identity between the two sides, and that they are therefore able to coexist in a single unity? It is still not enough. The matter is not finished with the mutual dependence of the two sides of a contradiction; what is more important still lies in the mutual transformation of contradictory things. That is to say, the two contradictory aspects inside a thing, because of certain conditions, each transform toward the aspect opposite to themselves, transform toward the position occupied by their opposite aspect. This is the second meaning of the identity of contradiction.
Why is there identity here too? Look: the ruled proletariat, through revolution, is transformed into the ruler, while the bourgeoisie, which was originally the ruler, is transformed into the ruled, transformed into the position originally occupied by the other side. The Soviet Union has already done this, and the whole world will also do this. If there were not, under certain conditions, connection and identity in between, how could such a change occur?
The Kuomintang, which at a certain stage of China's modern history played a certain positive role, because of its inherent class nature and the inducement of imperialism (these being the conditions), was transformed after 1927 into counter-revolution, and again, because of the sharpening of the contradiction between China and Japan and the united-front policy of the Communist Party (these being the conditions), was compelled to approve resistance to Japan. In this contradictory thing changing from one into the other, a certain identity is contained.
The agrarian revolution we have carried out has already been, and will still be, such a process: the landlord class possessing land is transformed into a class that has lost the land, while the peasants, who had lost the land, are transformed into small private owners who have obtained the land. Between having and not having, between gain and loss, there is mutual connection because of certain conditions, and the two possess identity. Under socialist conditions, the private ownership of the peasants will again be transformed into the public ownership of socialist agriculture; the Soviet Union has already done this, and the whole world will also do this in the future. Between private property and public property there is a bridge from this to that, which in philosophy is called identity, or mutual transformation and mutual permeation.
To consolidate the dictatorship of the proletariat, or the people's dictatorship, is precisely to prepare the conditions for abolishing this dictatorship and going on to a higher stage at which every state system is eliminated. To build and develop the Communist Party is precisely to prepare the conditions for eliminating the Communist Party and every party system. To build a revolutionary army led by the Communist Party and to wage revolutionary war is precisely to prepare the conditions for forever eliminating war. These many opposite things are at the same time complementary things.
Everyone knows that war and peace transform into each other. War is transformed into peace, for example the First World War was transformed into the peace after the war, and China's civil war has now also stopped, and peace within the country has appeared. Peace is transformed into war, for example the cooperation of the Kuomintang and the Communist Party in 1927 was transformed into war, and the present situation of world peace may also be transformed into a second world war. Why is it so? Because in class society such contradictory things as war and peace possess identity under certain conditions.
All contradictory things are mutually connected; not only do they, under certain conditions, coexist in a single unity, but under certain conditions they also transform into each other; this is the whole meaning of the identity of contradiction. What Lenin called "how they become identical (how they turn into the identical) — under what conditions they transform into each other and become identical" means precisely this.
Why "ought the human mind not to regard these opposites as dead and frozen things, but ought to regard them as living, conditional, changeable and mutually transforming things"? Because objective things are originally so. The unity, or identity, of the contradictory aspects in objective things is originally not dead and frozen, but living, conditional, changeable, temporary and relative; all contradictions transform toward their opposite according to certain conditions. This situation, reflected in people's thinking, becomes the Marxist world outlook of materialist dialectics. Only the reactionary ruling classes of the present and of history, and the metaphysics that serves them, do not regard opposite things as living, conditional, changeable and mutually transforming things, but regard them as dead and frozen things, and propagate this erroneous view everywhere, confusing the masses of the people, in order to attain their purpose of continuing their rule. The task of Communists lies in exposing the erroneous thinking of the reactionaries and of metaphysics, propagating the dialectics inherent in things, promoting the transformation of things, and attaining the aim of revolution.
What is called the identity of contradiction under certain conditions means that the contradiction we speak of is real contradiction, concrete contradiction, and that the mutual transformation of contradiction is also real and concrete. The many changes in mythology, for example "Kuafu Chasing the Sun" spoken of in The Classic of Mountains and Seas, "Yi Shooting the Nine Suns" spoken of in Huainanzi, Sun Wukong's seventy-two transformations in Journey to the West, and the many stories in Strange Tales from a Chinese Studio of ghosts and foxes changing into people, and so on — this mutual change of contradiction spoken of in such mythology is a childish, imagined and subjectively fantastic change aroused in people by the mutual changes of innumerable complex real contradictions, and is not the concrete change manifested by concrete contradiction. Marx said: "All mythology conquers the forces of nature, dominates the forces of nature, and gives form to the forces of nature by means of imagination and with the aid of imagination; hence, as these forces of nature are actually dominated, mythology also disappears." The endlessly changing stories in such mythology (and also in fairy tales), although, because they imagine people conquering the forces of nature and so on, they are able to attract people's liking, and the best mythology possesses a "permanent charm" (Marx), yet mythology is not constituted according to the definite conditions of concrete contradiction, and therefore they are not a scientific reflection of reality. That is to say, the aspects that constitute contradiction in mythology or fairy tales are not concrete identity, but only fantastic identity. What scientifically reflects the identity of real change is Marxist dialectics.
Why can an egg be transformed into a chick, while a stone cannot be transformed into a chick? Why do war and peace have identity, while war and a stone have no identity? Why can a human being beget a human being and not beget other things? There is no other reason than that the identity of contradiction requires certain necessary conditions. Lacking certain necessary conditions, there is no identity whatever.
Why were the bourgeois-democratic revolution of February 1917 in Russia and the proletarian socialist revolution of October of the same year directly linked, while the French bourgeois revolution was not directly linked to socialist revolution, and the Paris Commune of 1871 ended in failure? Why was the nomadic system of Mongolia and Central Asia again directly linked with socialism? Why can the Chinese revolution avoid a capitalist future, be directly linked with socialism, and not have to travel again the old historical road of the Western countries, and not have to pass through a period of the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie? There is no other reason; it is all because of the concrete conditions of the time. Once certain necessary conditions are present, the process of development of a thing gives rise to a certain contradiction, and this contradiction, or these contradictions, are mutually dependent and also mutually transforming; otherwise, everything is impossible.
Such is the problem of identity. Then, what is struggle? What is the relation between identity and struggle?
Lenin said: "The unity (coincidence, identity, equalness) of opposites is conditional, temporary, transitory, relative. The struggle of mutually exclusive opposites is absolute, just as development and motion are absolute."
What is the meaning of this passage of Lenin's?
Every process has a beginning and an end; every process is transformed into its opposite. The constancy of every process is relative, but the changeability of one process being transformed into another process is absolute.
The motion of whatever thing takes two states, the state of relative rest and the state of marked change. The motion of both states is aroused by the mutual struggle of the two contradictory factors contained inside the thing. When the motion of a thing is in the first state, it has only quantitative change and no qualitative change, and therefore displays an appearance of seeming rest. When the motion of a thing is in the second state, it has already, from the quantitative change in the first state, reached a certain highest point, aroused the breaking up of the unity, and produced a qualitative change, and therefore displays an appearance of marked change. The unity, solidarity, alliance, harmony, balance of forces, stalemate, deadlock, rest, constancy, equilibrium, cohesion, attraction and so on that we see in daily life are all appearances manifested when things are in the state of quantitative change. And the breaking up of the unity, and the destruction of the states of solidarity, alliance, harmony, balance of forces, stalemate, deadlock, rest, constancy, equilibrium, cohesion, attraction and so on, changing to the opposite state, are all appearances manifested when things are in the state of qualitative change, in the change of one process passing over to another process. Things are always ceaselessly transformed from the first state into the second state, while the struggle of contradiction exists in both states, and through the second state reaches the resolution of the contradiction. Therefore it is said that the unity of opposites is conditional, temporary and relative, while the mutually excluding struggle of opposites is absolute.
Earlier we said that between two opposite things there is identity, and therefore the two are able to coexist in a single unity and are also able to transform into each other; this speaks of conditionality, that is, it says that under certain conditions contradictory things are able to be unified and are also able to transform into each other; without these certain conditions, they cannot become a contradiction, cannot coexist, and cannot be transformed either. It is only because of certain conditions that the identity of contradiction is constituted, and therefore it is said that identity is conditional and relative. Here we say again that the struggle of contradiction runs through the process from beginning to end and makes one process transform toward another process; the struggle of contradiction is present everywhere, and therefore it is said that the struggle of contradiction is unconditional and absolute.
Conditional and relative identity combined with unconditional and absolute struggle constitutes the contradictory movement of all things.
We Chinese often say: "Opposites complement each other." That is to say, opposite things have identity. This saying is dialectical, and is contrary to metaphysics. "Opposing" means the mutual exclusion, or mutual struggle, of the two contradictory aspects. "Complementing" means that under certain conditions the two contradictory aspects are mutually connected and obtain identity. And struggle resides in identity; without struggle there is no identity.
In identity there exists struggle; in particularity there exists universality; in individual character there exists common character. In Lenin's words, this is called "within the relative there is the absolute."
6. The Place of Antagonism in Contradiction
Within the problem of the struggle of contradiction is contained the problem of what antagonism is. We answer: antagonism is one form of the struggle of contradiction, and not every form of the struggle of contradiction.
In human history there exists class antagonism; this is a special manifestation of the struggle of contradiction. The contradiction between the exploiting class and the exploited class, whether in slave society, in feudal society or in capitalist society, is such that the two mutually contradictory classes coexist for a long time in one society and struggle against each other, but only when the contradiction between the two classes has developed to a certain stage do the two sides take the form of external antagonism and develop into revolution. The transformation from peace to war in class society is also like this.
Before a bomb explodes, it is a time when contradictory things, because of certain conditions, coexist in a single unity. Only when a new condition (ignition) appears does the explosion occur. All phenomena in nature which in the end must take the form of external conflict in order to resolve an old contradiction and produce a new thing have circumstances similar to this.
To recognize this circumstance is extremely important. It makes us understand that in class society revolution and revolutionary war are inevitable, and that without this the leap in the development of society cannot be accomplished, the reactionary ruling class cannot be overthrown, and the people cannot obtain political power. Communists must expose the deceptive propaganda of the reactionaries to the effect that social revolution is unnecessary and impossible, and so on, uphold the Marxist-Leninist theory of social revolution, and make the people understand that this is not only entirely necessary but also entirely possible; the whole history of mankind and the victory of the Soviet Union have all proved this scientific truth.
But we must concretely study the circumstances of the struggle of various contradictions, and ought not inappropriately to fit the formula spoken of above onto all things. Contradiction and struggle are universal and absolute, but the method of resolving contradiction, that is, the form of struggle, differs because the nature of the contradiction differs. Some contradictions possess open antagonism; some contradictions are not like this. According to the concrete development of things, some contradictions develop from what was originally not yet antagonistic into what is antagonistic; and there are also some contradictions that develop from what was originally antagonistic into what is non-antagonistic.
The contradiction between correct thinking and erroneous thinking inside the Communist Party, as said earlier, is, while classes exist, the reflection inside the Party of class contradiction. This contradiction, at the beginning, or on individual questions, does not necessarily manifest itself at once as antagonistic. But with the development of the class struggle, this contradiction may also develop into an antagonistic one. The history of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union tells us: the contradiction between the correct thinking of Lenin and Stalin and the erroneous thinking of Trotsky, Bukharin and others did not at the beginning manifest itself in the form of antagonism, but subsequently developed into antagonism. The history of the Chinese Communist Party has also had such circumstances. The contradiction between the correct thinking of many comrades in our Party and the erroneous thinking of Chen Duxiu, Zhang Guotao and others also did not at the beginning manifest itself in the form of antagonism, but subsequently developed into antagonism. At present, the contradiction between correct thinking and erroneous thinking in our Party has not manifested itself in the form of antagonism; if the comrades who have made mistakes are able to correct their own mistakes, then it will not develop into something antagonistic. Therefore, the Party on the one hand must wage a serious struggle against erroneous thinking, and on the other hand must fully leave the comrades who have made mistakes an opportunity to awaken of themselves. Under such circumstances, excessive struggle is obviously inappropriate. But if the person who has made a mistake persists in the mistake and enlarges it, this contradiction also contains the possibility of developing into something antagonistic.
The economic contradiction between town and countryside, inside capitalist society (where the cities ruled by the bourgeoisie cruelly plunder the countryside), and inside the Kuomintang-ruled areas of China (where the cities ruled by foreign imperialism and the native comprador big bourgeoisie plunder the countryside with extreme savagery), is an extremely antagonistic contradiction. But inside a socialist country, and inside our revolutionary base areas, this antagonistic contradiction changes into a non-antagonistic contradiction, and when communist society is reached, this contradiction will disappear.
Lenin said: "Antagonism and contradiction are utterly different. Under socialism, antagonism disappears, but contradiction exists." That is to say, antagonism is only one form of the struggle of contradiction, and not all its forms, and this formula cannot be applied everywhere.
7. Conclusion
Having spoken to this point, we may sum up and say a few words. The law of contradiction in things, that is, the law of the unity of opposites, is the fundamental law of nature and of society, and is therefore also the fundamental law of thought. It is the opposite of the metaphysical world outlook. It is a great revolution in the history of human knowledge. Looked at from the viewpoint of dialectical materialism, contradiction exists in the processes of all objective things and of subjective thought, and contradiction runs through every process from beginning to end; this is the universality and absoluteness of contradiction. Contradictory things and each of their sides each have their characteristics; this is the particularity and relativity of contradiction. Contradictory things have identity according to certain conditions, and therefore are able to coexist in a single unity, and are also able to transform into the opposite aspect; this again is the particularity and relativity of contradiction. Yet the struggle of contradiction is uninterrupted; whether when they are coexisting, or when they are transforming into each other, struggle exists, and especially when they are transforming into each other, the manifestation of struggle is more marked; this again is the universality and absoluteness of contradiction. When we study the particularity and relativity of contradiction, we must pay attention to the distinction between the principal and the non-principal in contradictions and in the aspects of contradiction; when we study the universality and the struggle of contradiction, we must pay attention to the distinction among the various different forms of struggle of contradiction. Otherwise we shall make mistakes. If, through study, we have truly understood the above essential points, we shall be able to smash those dogmatist ideas that violate the basic principles of Marxism-Leninism and are unfavorable to our revolutionary cause; and we shall also be able to enable comrades who have experience to sort out their own experience, make it bear a principled character, and avoid repeating the mistakes of empiricism. These are some simple conclusions of our study of the law of contradiction.
The original Chinese. The tags above are read on the English translation's sentences.
事物的矛盾法则,即对立统一的法则,是唯物辩证法的最根本的法则。列宁说:“就本来的意义讲,辩证法是研究对象的本质自身中的矛盾。”列宁常称这个法则为辩证法的本质,又称之为辩证法的核心。因此,我们在研究这个法则时,不得不涉及广泛的方面,不得不涉及许多的哲学问题。如果我们将这些问题都弄清楚了,我们就在根本上懂得了唯物辩证法。这些问题是:两种宇宙观;矛盾的普遍性;矛盾的特殊性;主要的矛盾和主要的矛盾方面;矛盾诸方面的同一性和斗争性;对抗在矛盾中的地位。
苏联哲学界在最近数年中批判了德波林学派的唯心论,这件事引起了我们的极大的兴趣。德波林的唯心论在中国共产党内发生了极坏的影响,我们党内的教条主义思想不能说和这个学派的作风没有关系。因此,我们现在的哲学研究工作,应当以扫除教条主义思想为主要的目标。
一 两种宇宙观
在人类的认识史中,从来就有关于宇宙发展法则的两种见解,一种是形而上学的见解,一种是辩证法的见解,形成了互相对立的两种宇宙观。列宁说:“对于发展(进化)所持的两种基本的(或两种可能的?或两种在历史上常见的?)观点是:(一)认为发展是减少和增加,是重复;(二)认为发展是对立的统一(统一物分成为两个互相排斥的对立,而两个对立又互相关联着)。”列宁说的就是这两种不同的宇宙观。
形而上学,亦称玄学。这种思想,无论在中国,在欧洲,在一个很长的历史时间内,是属于唯心论的宇宙观,并在人们的思想中占了统治的地位。在欧洲,资产阶级初期的唯物论,也是形而上学的。由于欧洲许多国家的社会经济情况进到了资本主义高度发展的阶段,生产力、阶级斗争和科学均发展到了历史上未有过的水平,工业无产阶级成为历史发展的最伟大的动力,因而产生了马克思主义的唯物辩证法的宇宙观。于是,在资产阶级那里,除了公开的极端露骨的反动的唯心论之外,还出现了庸俗的进化论,出来对抗唯物辩证法。
所谓形而上学的或庸俗进化论的宇宙观,就是用孤立的、静止的和片面的观点去看世界。这种宇宙观把世界一切事物,一切事物的形态和种类,都看成是永远彼此孤立和永远不变化的。如果说有变化,也只是数量的增减和场所的变更。而这种增减和变更的原因,不在事物的内部而在事物的外部,即是由于外力的推动。形而上学家认为,世界上各种不同事物和事物的特性,从它们一开始存在的时候就是如此。后来的变化,不过是数量上的扩大或缩小。他们认为一种事物永远只能反复地产生为同样的事物,而不能变化为另一种不同的事物。在形而上学家看来,资本主义的剥削,资本主义的竞争,资本主义社会的个人主义思想等,就是在古代的奴隶社会里,甚至在原始社会里,都可以找得出来,而且会要永远不变地存在下去。说到社会发展的原因,他们就用社会外部的地理、气候等条件去说明。他们简单地从事物外部去找发展的原因,否认唯物辩证法所主张的事物因内部矛盾引起发展的学说。因此,他们不能解释事物的质的多样性,不能解释一种质变为他种质的现象。这种思想,在欧洲,在十七世纪和十八世纪是机械唯物论,在十九世纪末和二十世纪初则有庸俗进化论。在中国,则有所谓“天不变,道亦不变”的形而上学的思想,曾经长期地为腐朽了的封建统治阶级所拥护。近百年来输入了欧洲的机械唯物论和庸俗进化论,则为资产阶级所拥护。
和形而上学的宇宙观相反,唯物辩证法的宇宙观主张从事物的内部、从一事物对他事物的关系去研究事物的发展,即把事物的发展看做是事物内部的必然的自己的运动,而每一事物的运动都和它的周围其它事物互相联系着和互相影响着。事物发展的根本原因,不是在事物的外部而是在事物的内部,在于事物内部的矛盾性。任何事物内部都有这种矛盾性,因此引起了事物的运动和发展。事物内部的这种矛盾性是事物发展的根本原因,一事物和他事物的互相联系和互相影响则是事物发展的第二位的原因。这样,唯物辩证法就有力地反对了形而上学的机械唯物论和庸俗进化论的外因论或被动论。这是清楚的,单纯的外部原因只能引起事物的机械的运动,即范围的大小,数量的增减,不能说明事物何以有性质上的千差万别及其互相变化。事实上,即使是外力推动的机械运动,也要通过事物内部的矛盾性。植物和动物的单纯的增长,数量的发展,主要地也是由于内部矛盾所引起的。同样,社会的发展,主要地不是由于外因而是由于内因。许多国家在差不多一样的地理和气候的条件下,它们发展的差异性和不平衡性,非常之大。同一个国家吧,在地理和气候并没有变化的情形下,社会的变化却是很大的。帝国主义的俄国变为社会主义的苏联,封建的闭关锁国的日本变为帝国主义的日本,这些国家的地理和气候并没有变化。长期地被封建制度统治的中国,近百年来发生了很大的变化,现在正在变化到一个自由解放的新中国的方向去,中国的地理和气候并没有变化。整个地球及地球各部分的地理和气候也是变化着的,但以它们的变化和社会的变化相比较,则显得很微小,前者是以若干万年为单位而显现其变化的,后者则在几千年、几百年、几十年、甚至几年或几个月(在革命时期)内就显现其变化了。按照唯物辩证法的观点,自然界的变化,主要地是由于自然界内部矛盾的发展。社会的变化,主要地是由于社会内部矛盾的发展,即生产力和生产关系的矛盾,阶级之间的矛盾,新旧之间的矛盾,由于这些矛盾的发展,推动了社会的前进,推动了新旧社会的代谢。唯物辩证法是否排除外部的原因呢?并不排除。唯物辩证法认为外因是变化的条件,内因是变化的根据,外因通过内因而起作用。鸡蛋因得适当的温度而变化为鸡子,但温度不能使石头变为鸡子,因为二者的根据是不同的。各国人民之间的互相影响是时常存在的。在资本主义时代,特别是在帝国主义和无产阶级革命的时代,各国在政治上、经济上和文化上的互相影响和互相激动,是极其巨大的。十月社会主义革命不只是开创了俄国历史的新纪元,而且开创了世界历史的新纪元,影响到世界各国内部的变化,同样地而且还特别深刻地影响到中国内部的变化,但是这种变化是通过了各国内部和中国内部自己的规律性而起的。两军相争,一胜一败,所以胜败,皆决于内因。胜者或因其强,或因其指挥无误,败者或因其弱,或因其指挥失宜,外因通过内因而引起作用。一九二七年中国大资产阶级战败了无产阶级,是通过中国无产阶级内部的(中国共产党内部的)机会主义而起作用的。当着我们清算了这种机会主义的时候,中国革命就重新发展了。后来,中国革命又受了敌人的严重的打击,是因为我们党内产生了冒险主义。当着我们清算了这种冒险主义的时候,我们的事业就又重新发展了。由此看来,一个政党要引导革命到胜利,必须依靠自己政治路线的正确和组织上的巩固。
辩证法的宇宙观,不论在中国,在欧洲,在古代就产生了。但是古代的辩证法带着自发的朴素的性质,根据当时的社会历史条件,还不可能有完备的理论,因而不能完全解释宇宙,后来就被形而上学所代替。生活在十八世纪末和十九世纪初期的德国著名哲学家黑格尔,对于辩证法曾经给了很重要的贡献,但是他的辩证法却是唯心的辩证法。直到无产阶级运动的伟大的活动家马克思和恩格斯综合了人类认识史的积极的成果,特别是批判地吸取了黑格尔的辩证法的合理的部分,创造了辩证唯物论和历史唯物论这个伟大的理论,才在人类认识史上起了一个空前的大革命。后来,经过列宁和斯大林,又发展了这个伟大的理论。这个理论一经传到中国来,就在中国思想界引起了极大的变化。
这个辩证法的宇宙观,主要地就是教导人们要善于去观察和分析各种事物的矛盾的运动,并根据这种分析,指出解决矛盾的方法。因此,具体地了解事物矛盾这一个法则,对于我们是非常重要的。
二 矛盾的普遍性
为了叙述的便利起见,我在这里先说矛盾的普遍性,再说矛盾的特殊性。这是因为马克思主义的伟大的创造者和继承者马克思、恩格斯、列宁、斯大林他们发现了唯物辩证法的宇宙观,已经把唯物辩证法应用在人类历史的分析和自然历史的分析的许多方面,应用在社会的变革和自然的变革(例如在苏联)的许多方面,获得了极其伟大的成功,矛盾的普遍性已经被很多人所承认,因此,关于这个问题只需要很少的话就可以说明白;而关于矛盾的特殊性的问题,则还有很多的同志,特别是教条主义者,弄不清楚。他们不了解矛盾的普遍性即寓于矛盾的特殊性之中。他们也不了解研究当前具体事物的矛盾的特殊性,对于我们指导革命实践的发展有何等重要的意义。因此,关于矛盾的特殊性的问题应当着重地加以研究,并用足够的篇幅加以说明。为了这个缘故,当着我们分析事物矛盾的法则的时候,我们就先来分析矛盾的普遍性的问题,然后再着重地分析矛盾的特殊性的问题,最后仍归到矛盾的普遍性的问题。
矛盾的普遍性或绝对性这个问题有两方面的意义。其一是说,矛盾存在于一切事物的发展过程中;其二是说,每一事物的发展过程中存在着自始至终的矛盾运动。
恩格斯说:“运动本身就是矛盾。”列宁对于对立统一法则所下的定义,说它就是“承认(发现)自然界(精神和社会两者也在内)的一切现象和过程都含有互相矛盾、互相排斥、互相对立的趋向”。这些意见是对的吗?是对的。一切事物中包含的矛盾方面的相互依赖和相互斗争,决定一切事物的生命,推动一切事物的发展。没有什么事物是不包含矛盾的,没有矛盾就没有世界。
矛盾是简单的运动形式(例如机械性的运动)的基础,更是复杂的运动形式的基础。
恩格斯这样说明过矛盾的普遍性:“如果简单的机械的移动本身包含着矛盾,那末,物质的更高的运动形式,特别是有机生命及其发展,就更加包含着矛盾。……生命首先就在于:生物在每一个瞬间是它自身,但却又是别的什么。所以,生命也是存在于物体和过程本身中的不断地自行产生并自行解决的矛盾;这一矛盾一停止,生命亦即停止,于是死就来到。同样,我们看到了,在思维的范围以内我们也不能避免矛盾,并且我们看到了,例如,人的内部无限的认识能力与此种认识能力仅在外部被局限的而且认识上也被局限的个别人们身上的实际的实现二者之间的矛盾,是在人类世代的无穷的——至少对于我们,实际上是无穷的——连续系列之中,是在无穷的前进运动之中解决的。”
“高等数学的主要基础之一,就是矛盾……”
“就是初等数学,也充满着矛盾。……”
列宁也这样说明过矛盾的普遍性:“在数学中,正和负,微分和积分。
在力学中,作用和反作用。
在物理学中,阳电和阴电。
在化学中,原子的化合和分解。
在社会科学中,阶级斗争。”
战争中的攻守,进退,胜败,都是矛盾着的现象。失去一方,他方就不存在。双方斗争而又联结,组成了战争的总体,推动了战争的发展,解决了战争的问题。
人的概念的每一差异,都应把它看作是客观矛盾的反映。客观矛盾反映入主观的思想,组成了概念的矛盾运动,推动了思想的发展,不断地解决了人们的思想问题。
党内不同思想的对立和斗争是经常发生的,这是社会的阶级矛盾和新旧事物的矛盾在党内的反映。党内如果没有矛盾和解决矛盾的思想斗争,党的生命也就停止了。
由此看来,不论是简单的运动形式,或复杂的运动形式,不论是客观现象,或思想现象,矛盾是普遍地存在着,矛盾存在于一切过程中,这一点已经弄清楚了。但是每一过程的开始阶段,是否也有矛盾存在呢?是否每一事物的发展过程具有自始至终的矛盾运动呢?
从苏联哲学界批判德波林学派的文章中看出,德波林学派有这样一种见解,他们认为矛盾不是一开始就在过程中出现,须待过程发展到一定的阶段才出现。那末,在那一时间以前,过程发展的原因不是由于内部的原因,而是由于外部的原因了。这样,德波林回到形而上学的外因论和机械论去了。拿这种见解去分析具体的问题,他们就看见在苏联条件下富农和一般农民之间只有差异,并无矛盾,完全同意了布哈林的意见。在分析法国革命时,他们就认为在革命前,工农资产阶级合组的第三等级中,也只有差异,并无矛盾。德波林学派这类见解是反马克思主义的。他们不知道世界上的每一差异中就已经包含着矛盾,差异就是矛盾。劳资之间,从两阶级发生的时候起,就是互相矛盾的,仅仅还没有激化而已。工农之间,即使在苏联的社会条件下,也有差异,它们的差异就是矛盾,仅仅不会激化成为对抗,不取阶级斗争的形态,不同于劳资间的矛盾;它们在社会主义建设中形成巩固的联盟,并在由社会主义走向共产主义的发展过程中逐渐地解决这个矛盾。这是矛盾的差别性的问题,不是矛盾的有无的问题。矛盾是普遍的、绝对的,存在于事物发展的一切过程中,又贯串于一切过程的始终。
新过程的发生是什么呢?这是旧的统一和组成此统一的对立成分让位于新的统一和组成此统一的对立成分,于是新过程就代替旧过程而发生。旧过程完结了,新过程发生了。新过程又包含着新矛盾,开始它自己的矛盾发展史。
事物发展过程的自始至终的矛盾运动,列宁指出马克思在《资本论》中模范地作了这样的分析。这是研究任何事物发展过程所必须应用的方法。列宁自己也正确地应用了它,贯彻于他的全部著作中。
“马克思在《资本论》中,首先分析的是资产阶级社会(商品社会)里最简单的、最普通的、最基本的、最常见的、最平常的、碰到亿万次的关系——商品交换。这一分析在这个最简单的现象之中(资产阶级社会的这个‘细胞’之中)暴露了现代社会的一切矛盾(以及一切矛盾的胚芽)。往后的叙述又向我们表明了这些矛盾和这个社会各个部分总和的自始至终的发展(增长与运动两者)。”
列宁说了上面的话之后,接着说道:“这应该是一般辩证法的……叙述(以及研究)方法。”
中国共产党人必须学会这个方法,才能正确地分析中国革命的历史和现状,并推断革命的将来。
三 矛盾的特殊性
矛盾存在于一切事物发展的过程中,矛盾贯串于每一事物发展过程的始终,这是矛盾的普遍性和绝对性,前面已经说过了。现在来说矛盾的特殊性和相对性。
这个问题,应从几种情形中去研究。
首先是各种物质运动形式中的矛盾,都带特殊性。人的认识物质,就是认识物质的运动形式,因为除了运动的物质以外,世界上什么也没有,而物质的运动则必取一定的形式。对于物质的每一种运动形式,必须注意它和其它各种运动形式的共同点。但是,尤其重要的,成为我们认识事物的基础的东西,则是必须注意它的特殊点,就是说,注意它和其它运动形式的质的区别。只有注意了这一点,才有可能区别事物。任何运动形式,其内部都包含着本身特殊的矛盾。这种特殊的矛盾,就构成一事物区别于他事物的特殊的本质。这就是世界上诸种事物所以有千差万别的内在的原因,或者叫做根据。自然界存在着许多的运动形式,机械运动、发声、发光、发热、电流、化分、化合等等都是。所有这些物质的运动形式,都是互相依存的,又是本质上互相区别的。每一物质的运动形式所具有的特殊的本质,为它自己的特殊的矛盾所规定。这种情形,不但在自然界中存在着,在社会现象和思想现象中也是同样地存在着。每一种社会形式和思想形式,都有它的特殊的矛盾和特殊的本质。
科学研究的区分,就是根据科学对象所具有的特殊的矛盾性。因此,对于某一现象的领域所特有的某一种矛盾的研究,就构成某一门科学的对象。例如,数学中的正数和负数,机械学中的作用和反作用,物理学中的阴电和阳电,化学中的化分和化合,社会科学中的生产力和生产关系、阶级和阶级的互相斗争,军事学中的攻击和防御,哲学中的唯心论和唯物论、形而上学观和辩证法观等等,都是因为具有特殊的矛盾和特殊的本质,才构成了不同的科学研究的对象。固然,如果不认识矛盾的普遍性,就无从发现事物运动发展的普遍的原因或普遍的根据;但是,如果不研究矛盾的特殊性,就无从确定一事物不同于他事物的特殊的本质,就无从发现事物运动发展的特殊的原因,或特殊的根据,也就无从辨别事物,无从区分科学研究的领域。
就人类认识运动的秩序说来,总是由认识个别的和特殊的事物,逐步地扩大到认识一般的事物。人们总是首先认识了许多不同事物的特殊的本质,然后才有可能更进一步地进行概括工作,认识诸种事物的共同的本质。当着人们已经认识了这种共同的本质以后,就以这种共同的认识为指导,继续地向着尚未研究过的或者尚未深入地研究过的各种具体的事物进行研究,找出其特殊的本质,这样才可以补充、丰富和发展这种共同的本质的认识,而使这种共同的本质的认识不致变成枯槁的和僵死的东西。这是两个认识的过程:一个是由特殊到一般,一个是由一般到特殊。人类的认识总是这样循环往复地进行的,而每一次的循环(只要是严格地按照科学的方法)都可能使人类的认识提高一步,使人类的认识不断地深化。我们的教条主义者在这个问题上的错误,就是,一方面,不懂得必须研究矛盾的特殊性,认识各别事物的特殊的本质,才有可能充分地认识矛盾的普遍性,充分地认识诸种事物的共同的本质;另一方面,不懂得在我们认识了事物的共同的本质以后,还必须继续研究那些尚未深入地研究过的或者新冒出来的具体的事物。我们的教条主义者是懒汉,他们拒绝对于具体事物做任何艰苦的研究工作,他们把一般真理看成是凭空出现的东西,把它变成为人们所不能够捉摸的纯粹抽象的公式,完全否认了并且颠倒了这个人类认识真理的正常秩序。他们也不懂得人类认识的两个过程的互相联结——由特殊到一般,又由一般到特殊,他们完全不懂得马克思主义的认识论。
不但要研究每一个大系统的物质运动形式的特殊的矛盾性及其所规定的本质,而且要研究每一个物质运动形式在其发展长途中的每一个过程的特殊的矛盾及其本质。一切运动形式的每一个实在的非臆造的发展过程内,都是不同质的。我们的研究工作必须着重这一点,而且必须从这一点开始。
不同质的矛盾,只有用不同质的方法才能解决。例如,无产阶级和资产阶级的矛盾,用社会主义革命的方法去解决;人民大众和封建制度的矛盾,用民主革命的方法去解决;殖民地和帝国主义的矛盾,用民族革命战争的方法去解决;在社会主义社会中工人阶级和农民阶级的矛盾,用农业集体化和农业机械化的方法去解决;共产党内的矛盾,用批评和自我批评的方法去解决;社会和自然的矛盾,用发展生产力的方法去解决。过程变化,旧过程和旧矛盾消灭,新过程和新矛盾发生,解决矛盾的方法也因之而不同。俄国的二月革命和十月革命所解决的矛盾及其所用以解决矛盾的方法是根本上不相同的。用不同的方法去解决不同的矛盾,这是马克思列宁主义者必须严格地遵守的一个原则。教条主义者不遵守这个原则,他们不了解诸种革命情况的区别,因而也不了解应当用不同的方法去解决不同的矛盾,而只是千篇一律地使用一种自以为不可改变的公式到处硬套,这就只能使革命遭受挫折,或者将本来做得好的事情弄得很坏。
为要暴露事物发展过程中的矛盾在其总体上、在其相互联结上的特殊性,就是说暴露事物发展过程的本质,就必须暴露过程中矛盾各方面的特殊性,否则暴露过程的本质成为不可能,这也是我们作研究工作时必须十分注意的。
一个大的事物,在其发展过程中,包含着许多的矛盾。例如,在中国资产阶级民主革命过程中,有中国社会各被压迫阶级和帝国主义的矛盾,有人民大众和封建制度的矛盾,有无产阶级和资产阶级的矛盾,有农民及城市小资产阶级和资产阶级的矛盾,有各个反动的统治集团之间的矛盾等等,情形是非常复杂的。这些矛盾,不但各各有其特殊性,不能一律看待,而且每一矛盾的两方面,又各各有其特点,也是不能一律看待的。我们从事中国革命的人,不但要在各个矛盾的总体上,即矛盾的相互联结上,了解其特殊性,而且只有从矛盾的各个方面着手研究,才有可能了解其总体。所谓了解矛盾的各个方面,就是了解它们每一方面各占何等特定的地位,各用何种具体形式和对方发生互相依存又互相矛盾的关系,在互相依存又互相矛盾中,以及依存破裂后,又各用何种具体的方法和对方作斗争。研究这些问题,是十分重要的事情。列宁说:马克思主义的最本质的东西,马克思主义的活的灵魂,就在于具体地分析具体的情况。就是说的这个意思。我们的教条主义者违背列宁的指示,从来不用脑筋具体地分析任何事物,做起文章或演说来,总是空洞无物的八股调,在我们党内造成了一种极坏的作风。
研究问题,忌带主观性、片面性和表面性。所谓主观性,就是不知道客观地看问题,也就是不知道用唯物的观点去看问题。这一点,我在《实践论》一文中已经说过了。所谓片面性,就是不知道全面地看问题。例如:只了解中国一方、不了解日本一方,只了解共产党一方、不了解国民党一方,只了解无产阶级一方、不了解资产阶级一方,只了解农民一方、不了解地主一方,只了解顺利情形一方、不了解困难情形一方,只了解过去一方、不了解将来一方,只了解个体一方、不了解总体一方,只了解缺点一方、不了解成绩一方,只了解原告一方、不了解被告一方,只了解革命的秘密工作一方、不了解革命的公开工作一方,如此等等。一句话,不了解矛盾各方的特点。这就叫做片面地看问题。或者叫做只看见局部,不看见全体,只看见树木,不看见森林。这样,是不能找出解决矛盾的方法的,是不能完成革命任务的,是不能做好所任工作的,是不能正确地发展党内的思想斗争的。孙子论军事说:“知彼知己,百战不殆。”他说的是作战的双方。唐朝人魏征说过:“兼听则明,偏信则暗。”也懂得片面性不对。可是我们的同志看问题,往往带片面性,这样的人就往往碰钉子。《水浒传》上宋江三打祝家庄,两次都因情况不明,方法不对,打了败仗。后来改变方法,从调查情形入手,于是熟悉了盘陀路,拆散了李家庄、扈家庄和祝家庄的联盟,并且布置了藏在敌人营盘里的伏兵,用了和外国故事中所说木马计相像的方法,第三次就打了胜仗。《水浒传》上有很多唯物辩证法的事例,这个三打祝家庄,算是最好的一个。列宁说:“要真正地认识对象,就必须把握和研究它的一切方面、一切联系和‘媒介’。我们决不会完全地作到这一点,可是要求全面性,将使我们防止错误,防止僵化。”我们应该记得他的话。表面性,是对矛盾总体和矛盾各方的特点都不去看,否认深入事物里面精细地研究矛盾特点的必要,仅仅站在那里远远地望一望,粗枝大叶地看到一点矛盾的形相,就想动手去解决矛盾(答复问题、解决纠纷、处理工作、指挥战争)。这样的做法,没有不出乱子的。中国的教条主义和经验主义的同志们所以犯错误,就是因为他们看事物的方法是主观的、片面的和表面的。片面性、表面性也是主观性,因为一切客观事物本来是互相联系的和具有内部规律的,人们不去如实地反映这些情况,而只是片面地或表面地去看它们,不认识事物的互相联系,不认识事物的内部规律,所以这种方法是主观主义的。
不但事物发展的全过程中的矛盾运动,在其相互联结上,在其各方情况上,我们必须注意其特点,而且在过程发展的各个阶段中,也有其特点,也必须注意。
事物发展过程的根本矛盾及为此根本矛盾所规定的过程的本质,非到过程完结之日,是不会消灭的;但是事物发展的长过程中的各个发展的阶段,情形又往往互相区别。这是因为事物发展过程的根本矛盾的性质和过程的本质虽然没有变化,但是根本矛盾在长过程中的各个发展阶段上采取了逐渐激化的形式。并且,被根本矛盾所规定或影响的许多大小矛盾中,有些是激化了,有些是暂时地或局部地解决了,或者缓和了,又有些是发生了,因此,过程就显出阶段性来。如果人们不去注意事物发展过程中的阶段性,人们就不能适当地处理事物的矛盾。
例如,自由竞争时代的资本主义发展为帝国主义,这时,无产阶级和资产阶级这两个根本矛盾着的阶级的性质和这个社会的资本主义的本质,并没有变化;但是,两阶级的矛盾激化了,独占资本和自由资本之间的矛盾发生了,宗主国和殖民地的矛盾激化了,各资本主义国家间的矛盾即由各国发展不平衡的状态而引起的矛盾特别尖锐地表现出来了,因此形成了资本主义的特殊阶段,形成了帝国主义阶段。列宁主义之所以成为帝国主义和无产阶级革命时代的马克思主义,就是因为列宁和斯大林正确地说明了这些矛盾,并正确地作出了解决这些矛盾的无产阶级革命的理论和策略。
拿从辛亥革命开始的中国资产阶级民主革命过程的情形来看,也有了若干特殊阶段。特别是在资产阶级领导时期的革命和在无产阶级领导时期的革命,区别为两个很大不同的历史阶段。这就是:由于无产阶级的领导,根本地改变了革命的面貌,引出了阶级关系的新调度,农民革命的大发动,反帝国主义和反封建主义的革命彻底性,由民主革命转变到社会主义革命的可能性,等等。所有这些,都是在资产阶级领导革命时期不可能出现的。虽然整个过程中根本矛盾的性质,过程之反帝反封建的民主革命的性质(其反面是半殖民地半封建的性质),并没有变化,但是,在这长时间中,经过了辛亥革命失败和北洋军阀统治,第一次民族统一战线的建立和一九二四年至一九二七年的革命,统一战线破裂和资产阶级转入反革命,新的军阀战争,土地革命战争,第二次民族统一战线建立和抗日战争等等大事变,二十多年间经过了几个发展阶段。在这些阶段中,包含着有些矛盾激化了(例如土地革命战争和日本侵入东北四省),有些矛盾部分地或暂时地解决了(例如北洋军阀的被消灭,我们没收了地主的土地),有些矛盾重新发生了(例如新军阀之间的斗争,南方各革命根据地丧失后地主又重新收回土地)等等特殊的情形。
研究事物发展过程中的各个发展阶段上的矛盾的特殊性,不但必须在其联结上、在其总体上去看,而且必须从各个阶段中矛盾的各个方面去看。
例如国共两党。国民党方面,在第一次统一战线时期,因为它实行了孙中山的联俄、联共、援助工农的三大政策,所以它是革命的、有朝气的,它是各阶级的民主革命的联盟。一九二七年以后,国民党变到了与此相反的方面,成了地主和大资产阶级的反动集团。一九三六年十二月西安事变后又开始向停止内战、联合共产党共同反对日本帝国主义这个方面转变。这就是国民党在三个阶段上的特点。形成这些特点,当然有种种的原因。中国共产党方面,在第一次统一战线时期,它是幼年的党,它英勇地领导了一九二四年至一九二七年的革命;但在对于革命的性质、任务和方法的认识方面,却表现了它的幼年性,因此在这次革命的后期所发生的陈独秀主义能够起作用,使这次革命遭受了失败。一九二七年以后,它又英勇地领导了土地革命战争,创立了革命的军队和革命的根据地,但是它也犯过冒险主义的错误,使军队和根据地都受了很大的损失。一九三五年以后,它又纠正了冒险主义的错误,领导了新的抗日的统一战线,这个伟大的斗争现在正在发展。在这个阶段上,共产党是一个经过了两次革命的考验、有了丰富的经验的党。这些就是中国共产党在三个阶段上的特点。形成这些特点也有种种的原因。不研究这些特点,就不能了解两党在各个发展阶段上的特殊的相互关系:统一战线的建立,统一战线的破裂,再一个统一战线的建立。而要研究两党的种种特点,更根本的就必须研究这两党的阶级基础以及因此在各个时期所形成的它们和其它方面的矛盾的对立。例如,国民党在它第一次联合共产党的时期,一方面有和国外帝国主义的矛盾,因而它反对帝国主义;另一方面有和国内人民大众的矛盾,它在口头上虽然允许给予劳动人民以许多的利益,但在实际上则只给予很少的利益,或者简直什么也不给。在它进行反共战争的时期,则和帝国主义、封建主义合作反对人民大众,一笔勾销了人民大众原来在革命中所争得的一切利益,激化了它和人民大众的矛盾。现在抗日时期,国民党和日本帝国主义有矛盾,它一面要联合共产党,同时它对共产党和国内人民并不放松其斗争和压迫。共产党则无论在哪一时期,均和人民大众站在一道,反对帝国主义和封建主义;但在现在的抗日时期,由于国民党表示抗日,它对国民党和国内封建势力,也就采取了缓和的政策。由于这些情况,所以或者造成了两党的联合,或者造成了两党的斗争,而且即使在两党联合的时期也有又联合又斗争的复杂的情况。如果我们不去研究这些矛盾方面的特点,我们就不但不能了解这两个党各各和其它方面的关系,也不能了解两党之间的相互关系。
由此看来,不论研究何种矛盾的特性——各个物质运动形式的矛盾,各个运动形式在各个发展过程中的矛盾,各个发展过程的矛盾的各方面,各个发展过程在其各个发展阶段上的矛盾以及各个发展阶段上的矛盾的各方面,研究所有这些矛盾的特性,都不能带主观随意性,必须对它们实行具体的分析。离开具体的分析,就不能认识任何矛盾的特性。我们必须时刻记得列宁的话:对于具体的事物作具体的分析。
这种具体的分析,马克思、恩格斯首先给了我们以很好的模范。
当马克思、恩格斯把这事物矛盾的法则应用到社会历史过程的研究的时候,他们看出生产力和生产关系之间的矛盾,看出剥削阶级和被剥削阶级之间的矛盾以及由于这些矛盾所产生的经济基础和政治及思想等上层建筑之间的矛盾,而这些矛盾如何不可避免地会在各种不同的阶级社会中,引出各种不同的社会革命。
马克思把这一法则应用到资本主义社会经济结构的研究的时候,他看出这一社会的基本矛盾在于生产的社会性和占有制的私人性之间的矛盾。这个矛盾表现于在各别企业中的生产的有组织性和在全社会中的生产的无组织性之间的矛盾。这个矛盾的阶级表现则是资产阶级和无产阶级之间的矛盾。
由于事物范围的极其广大,发展的无限性,所以,在一定场合为普遍性的东西,而在另一一定场合则变为特殊性。反之,在一定场合为特殊性的东西,而在另一一定场合则变为普遍性。资本主义制度所包含的生产社会化和生产资料私人占有制的矛盾,是所有有资本主义的存在和发展的各国所共有的东西,对于资本主义说来,这是矛盾的普遍性。但是资本主义的这种矛盾,乃是一般阶级社会发展在一定历史阶段上的东西,对于一般阶级社会中的生产力和生产关系的矛盾说来,这是矛盾的特殊性。然而,当着马克思把资本主义社会这一切矛盾的特殊性解剖出来之后,同时也就更进一步地、更充分地、更完全地把一般阶级社会中这个生产力和生产关系的矛盾的普遍性阐发出来了。
由于特殊的事物是和普遍的事物联结的,由于每一个事物内部不但包含了矛盾的特殊性,而且包含了矛盾的普遍性,普遍性即存在于特殊性之中,所以,当着我们研究一定事物的时候,就应当去发现这两方面及其互相联结,发现一事物内部的特殊性和普遍性的两方面及其互相联结,发现一事物和它以外的许多事物的互相联结。斯大林在他的名著《论列宁主义基础》一书中说明列宁主义的历史根源的时候,他分析了列宁主义所由产生的国际环境,分析了在帝国主义条件下已经发展到极点的资本主义的诸矛盾,以及这些矛盾使无产阶级革命成为直接实践的问题,并造成了直接冲击资本主义的良好的条件。不但如此,他又分析了为什么俄国成为列宁主义的策源地,分析了沙皇俄国当时是帝国主义一切矛盾的集合点以及俄国无产阶级所以能够成为国际的革命无产阶级的先锋队的原因。这样,斯大林分析了帝国主义的矛盾的普遍性,说明列宁主义是帝国主义和无产阶级革命时代的马克思主义;又分析了沙俄帝国主义在这一般矛盾中所具有的特殊性,说明俄国成了无产阶级革命理论和策略的故乡,而在这种特殊性中间就包含了矛盾的普遍性。斯大林的这种分析,给我们提供了认识矛盾的特殊性和普遍性及其互相联结的模范。
马克思和恩格斯,同样地列宁和斯大林,他们对于应用辩证法到客观现象的研究的时候,总是指导人们不要带上任何的主观随意性,而必须从客观的实际运动所包含的具体的条件,去看出这些现象中的具体的矛盾、矛盾各方面的具体的地位以及矛盾的具体的相互关系。我们的教条主义者因为没有这种研究态度,所以弄得一无是处。我们必须以教条主义的失败为鉴戒,学会这种研究态度,舍此没有第二种研究法。
矛盾的普遍性和矛盾的特殊性的关系,就是矛盾的共性和个性的关系。其共性是矛盾存在于一切过程中,并贯串于一切过程的始终,矛盾即是运动,即是事物,即是过程,也即是思想。否认事物的矛盾就是否认了一切。这是共通的道理,古今中外,概莫能外。所以它是共性,是绝对性。然而这种共性,即包含于一切个性之中,无个性即无共性。假如除去一切个性,还有什么共性呢?因为矛盾的各各特殊,所以造成了个性。一切个性都是有条件地暂时地存在的,所以是相对的。
这一共性个性、绝对相对的道理,是关于事物矛盾的问题的精髓,不懂得它,就等于抛弃了辩证法。
四 主要的矛盾和主要的矛盾方面
在矛盾特殊性的问题中,还有两种情形必须特别地提出来加以分析,这就是主要的矛盾和主要的矛盾方面。
在复杂的事物的发展过程中,有许多的矛盾存在,其中必有一种是主要的矛盾,由于它的存在和发展规定或影响着其它矛盾的存在和发展。
例如在资本主义社会中,无产阶级和资产阶级这两个矛盾着的力量是主要的矛盾;其它的矛盾力量,例如,残存的封建阶级和资产阶级的矛盾,农民小资产者和资产阶级的矛盾,无产阶级和农民小资产者的矛盾,自由资产阶级和垄断资产阶级的矛盾,资产阶级的民主主义和资产阶级的法西斯主义的矛盾,资本主义国家相互间的矛盾,帝国主义和殖民地的矛盾,以及其它的矛盾,都为这个主要的矛盾力量所规定、所影响。
半殖民地的国家如中国,其主要矛盾和非主要矛盾的关系呈现着复杂的情况。
当着帝国主义向这种国家举行侵略战争的时候,这种国家的内部各阶级,除开一些叛国分子以外,能够暂时地团结起来举行民族战争去反对帝国主义。这时,帝国主义和这种国家之间的矛盾成为主要的矛盾,而这种国家内部各阶级的一切矛盾(包括封建制度和人民大众之间这个主要矛盾在内),便都暂时地降到次要和服从的地位。中国一八四〇年的鸦片战争,一八九四年的中日战争,一九〇〇年的义和团战争和目前的中日战争,都有这种情形。
然而在另一种情形之下,则矛盾的地位起了变化。当着帝国主义不是用战争压迫而是用政治、经济、文化等比较温和的形式进行压迫的时候,半殖民地国家的统治阶级就会向帝国主义投降,二者结成同盟,共同压迫人民大众。这种时候,人民大众往往采取国内战争的形式,去反对帝国主义和封建阶级的同盟,而帝国主义则往往采取间接的方式去援助半殖民地国家的反动派压迫人民,而不采取直接行动,显出了内部矛盾的特别尖锐性。中国的辛亥革命战争,一九二四年至一九二七年的革命战争,一九二七年以后的十年土地革命战争,都有这种情形。还有半殖民地国家各个反动的统治集团之间的内战,例如在中国的军阀战争,也属于这一类。
当着国内革命战争发展到从根本上威胁帝国主义及其走狗国内反动派的存在的时候,帝国主义就往往采取上述方法以外的方法,企图维持其统治:或者分化革命阵线的内部,或者直接出兵援助国内反动派。这时,外国帝国主义和国内反动派完全公开地站在一个极端,人民大众则站在另一极端,成为一个主要矛盾,而规定或影响其它矛盾的发展状态。十月革命后各资本主义国家援助俄国反动派,是武装干涉的例子。一九二七年的蒋介石的叛变,是分化革命阵线的例子。
然而不管怎样,过程发展的各个阶段中,只有一种主要的矛盾起着领导的作用,是完全没有疑义的。
由此可知,任何过程如果有多数矛盾存在的话,其中必定有一种是主要的,起着领导的、决定的作用,其它则处于次要和服从的地位。因此,研究任何过程,如果是存在着两个以上矛盾的复杂过程的话,就要用全力找出它的主要矛盾。捉住了这个主要矛盾,一切问题就迎刃而解了。这是马克思研究资本主义社会告诉我们的方法。列宁和斯大林研究帝国主义和资本主义总危机的时候,列宁和斯大林研究苏联经济的时候,也告诉了这种方法。万千的学问家和实行家,不懂得这种方法,结果如堕烟海,找不到中心,也就找不到解决矛盾的方法。
不能把过程中所有的矛盾平均看待,必须把它们区别为主要的和次要的两类,着重于捉住主要的矛盾,已如上述。但是在各种矛盾之中,不论是主要的或次要的,矛盾着的两个方面,又是否可以平均看待呢?也是不可以的。无论什么矛盾,矛盾的诸方面,其发展是不平衡的。有时候似乎势均力敌,然而这只是暂时的和相对的情形,基本的形态则是不平衡。矛盾着的两方面中,必有一方面是主要的,他方面是次要的。其主要的方面,即所谓矛盾起主导作用的方面。事物的性质,主要地是由取得支配地位的矛盾的主要方面所规定的。
然而这种情形不是固定的,矛盾的主要和非主要的方面互相转化着,事物的性质也就随着起变化。在矛盾发展的一定过程或一定阶段上,主要方面属于甲方,非主要方面属于乙方;到了另一发展阶段或另一发展过程时,就互易其位置,这是依靠事物发展中矛盾双方斗争的力量的增减程度来决定的。
我们常常说“新陈代谢”这句话。新陈代谢是宇宙间普遍的永远不可抵抗的规律。依事物本身的性质和条件,经过不同的飞跃形式,一事物转化为他事物,就是新陈代谢的过程。任何事物的内部都有其新旧两个方面的矛盾,形成为一系列的曲折的斗争。斗争的结果,新的方面由小变大,上升为支配的东西;旧的方面则由大变小,变成逐步归于灭亡的东西。而一当新的方面对于旧的方面取得支配地位的时候,旧事物的性质就变化为新事物的性质。由此可见,事物的性质主要地是由取得支配地位的矛盾的主要方面所规定的。取得支配地位的矛盾的主要方面起了变化,事物的性质也就随着起变化。
在资本主义社会中,资本主义已从旧的封建主义社会时代的附庸地位,转化成了取得支配地位的力量,社会的性质也就由封建主义的变为资本主义的。在新的资本主义社会时代,封建势力则由原来处在支配地位的力量转化为附庸的力量,随着也就逐步地归于消灭了,例如英法诸国就是如此。随着生产力的发展,资产阶级由新的起进步作用的阶级,转化为旧的起反动作用的阶级,以至于最后被无产阶级所推翻,而转化为私有的生产资料被剥夺和失去权力的阶级,这个阶级也就要逐步归于消灭了。人数比资产阶级多得多、并和资产阶级同时生长、但被资产阶级统治着的无产阶级,是一个新的力量,它由初期的附属于资产阶级的地位,逐步地壮大起来,成为独立的和在历史上起主导作用的阶级,以至最后夺取政权成为统治阶级。这时,社会的性质,就由旧的资本主义的社会转化成了新的社会主义的社会。这就是苏联已经走过和一切其它国家必然要走的道路。
就中国的情形来说,帝国主义处在形成半殖民地这种矛盾的主要地位,压迫中国人民,中国则由独立国变为半殖民地。然而事情必然会变化,在双方斗争的局势中,中国人民在无产阶级领导之下所生长起来的力量必然会把中国由半殖民地变为独立国,而帝国主义则将被打倒,旧中国必然要变为新中国。
旧中国变为新中国,还包含着国内旧的封建势力和新的人民势力之间的情况的变化。旧的封建地主阶级将被打倒,由统治者变为被统治者,这个阶级也就会要逐步归于消灭。人民则将在无产阶级领导之下,由被统治者变为统治者。这时,中国社会的性质就会起变化,由旧的半殖民地和半封建的社会变为新的民主的社会。
这种互相转化的事情,过去已有经验。统治中国将近三百年的清朝帝国,曾在辛亥革命时期被打倒;而孙中山领导的革命同盟会,则曾经一度取得了胜利。在一九二四年至一九二七年的革命战争中,共产党和国民党联合的南方革命势力,曾经由弱小的力量变得强大起来,取得了北伐的胜利;而称雄一时的北洋军阀则被打倒了。一九二七年,共产党领导的人民力量,受了国民党反动势力的打击,变得很小了;但因肃清了自己内部的机会主义,就又逐步地壮大起来。在共产党领导的革命根据地内,农民由被统治者转化为统治者,地主则作了相反的转化。世界上总是这样以新的代替旧的,总是这样新陈代谢、除旧布新或推陈出新的。
革命斗争中的某些时候,困难条件超过顺利条件,在这种时候,困难是矛盾的主要方面,顺利是其次要方面。然而由于革命党人的努力,能够逐步地克服困难,开展顺利的新局面,困难的局面让位于顺利的局面。一九二七年中国革命失败后的情形,中国红军在长征中的情形,都是如此。现在的中日战争,中国又处在困难地位,但是我们能够改变这种情况,使中日双方的情况发生根本的变化。在相反的情形之下,顺利也能转化为困难,如果是革命党人犯了错误的话。一九二四年至一九二七年的革命的胜利,变为失败了。一九二七年以后在南方各省发展起来的革命根据地,至一九三四年都失败了。
研究学问的时候,由不知到知的矛盾也是如此。当着我们刚才开始研究马克思主义的时候,对于马克思主义的无知或知之不多的情况,和马克思主义的知识之间,互相矛盾着。然而由于努力学习,可以由无知转化为有知,由知之不多转化为知之甚多,由对于马克思主义的盲目性改变为能够自由运用马克思主义。
有人觉得有些矛盾并不是这样。例如,生产力和生产关系的矛盾,生产力是主要的;理论和实践的矛盾,实践是主要的;经济基础和上层建筑的矛盾,经济基础是主要的:它们的地位并不互相转化。这是机械唯物论的见解,不是辩证唯物论的见解。诚然,生产力、实践、经济基础,一般地表现为主要的决定的作用,谁不承认这一点,谁就不是唯物论者。然而,生产关系、理论、上层建筑这些方面,在一定条件之下,又转过来表现其为主要的决定的作用,这也是必须承认的。当着不变更生产关系,生产力就不能发展的时候,生产关系的变更就起了主要的决定的作用。当着如同列宁所说“没有革命的理论,就不会有革命的运动”的时候,革命理论的创立和提倡就起了主要的决定的作用。当着某一件事情(任何事情都是一样)要做,但是还没有方针、方法、计划或政策的时候,确定方针、方法、计划或政策,也就是主要的决定的东西。当着政治文化等等上层建筑阻碍着经济基础的发展的时候,对于政治上和文化上的革新就成为主要的决定的东西了。我们这样说,是否违反了唯物论呢?没有。因为我们承认总的历史发展中是物质的东西决定精神的东西,是社会的存在决定社会的意识;但是同时又承认而且必须承认精神的东西的反作用,社会意识对于社会存在的反作用,上层建筑对于经济基础的反作用。这不是违反唯物论,正是避免了机械唯物论,坚持了辩证唯物论。
在研究矛盾特殊性的问题中,如果不研究过程中主要的矛盾和非主要的矛盾以及矛盾之主要的方面和非主要的方面这两种情形,也就是说不研究这两种矛盾情况的差别性,那就将陷入抽象的研究,不能具体地懂得矛盾的情况,因而也就不能找出解决矛盾的正确的方法。这两种矛盾情况的差别性或特殊性,都是矛盾力量的不平衡性。世界上没有绝对地平衡发展的东西,我们必须反对平衡论,或均衡论。同时,这种具体的矛盾状况,以及矛盾的主要方面和非主要方面在发展过程中的变化,正是表现出新事物代替旧事物的力量。对于矛盾的各种不平衡情况的研究,对于主要的矛盾和非主要的矛盾、主要的矛盾方面和非主要的矛盾方面的研究,成为革命政党正确地决定其政治上和军事上的战略战术方针的重要方法之一,是一切共产党人都应当注意的。
五 矛盾诸方面的同一性和斗争性
在懂得了矛盾的普遍性和特殊性的问题之后,我们必须进而研究矛盾诸方面的同一性和斗争性的问题。
同一性、统一性、一致性、互相渗透、互相贯通、互相依赖(或依存)、互相联结或互相合作,这些不同的名词都是一个意思,说的是如下两种情形:第一、事物发展过程中的每一种矛盾的两个方面,各以和它对立着的方面为自己存在的前提,双方共处于一个统一体中;第二、矛盾着的双方,依据一定的条件,各向着其相反的方面转化。这些就是所谓同一性。
列宁说:“辩证法是这样的一种学说:它研究对立怎样能够是同一的,又怎样成为同一的(怎样变成同一的),——在怎样的条件之下它们互相转化,成为同一的,——为什么人的头脑不应当把这些对立看作死的、凝固的东西,而应当看作生动的、有条件的、可变动的、互相转化的东西。”
列宁这段话是什么意思呢?
一切过程中矛盾着的各方面,本来是互相排斥、互相斗争、互相对立的。世界上一切事物的过程里和人们的思想里,都包含着这样带矛盾性的方面,无一例外。单纯的过程只有一对矛盾,复杂的过程则有一对以上的矛盾。各对矛盾之间,又互相成为矛盾。这样地组成客观世界的一切事物和人们的思想,并推使它们发生运动。
如此说来,只是极不同一,极不统一,怎样又说是同一或统一呢?
原来矛盾着的各方面,不能孤立地存在。假如没有和它作对的矛盾的一方,它自己这一方就失去了存在的条件。试想一切矛盾着的事物或人们心中矛盾着的概念,任何一方面能够独立地存在吗?没有生,死就不见;没有死,生也不见。没有上,无所谓下;没有下,也无所谓上。没有祸,无所谓福;没有福,也无所谓祸。没有顺利,无所谓困难;没有困难,也无所谓顺利。没有地主,就没有佃农;没有佃农,也就没有地主。没有资产阶级,就没有无产阶级;没有无产阶级,也就没有资产阶级。没有帝国主义的民族压迫,就没有殖民地和半殖民地;没有殖民地和半殖民地,也就没有帝国主义的民族压迫。一切对立的成分都是这样,因一定的条件,一面互相对立,一面又互相联结、互相贯通、互相渗透、互相依赖,这种性质,叫做同一性。一切矛盾着的方面都因一定条件具备着不同一性,所以称为矛盾。然而又具备着同一性,所以互相联结。列宁所谓辩证法研究“对立怎样能够是同一的”,就是说的这种情形。怎样能够呢?因为互为存在的条件。这是同一性的第一种意义。
然而单说了矛盾双方互为存在的条件,双方之间有同一性,因而能够共处于一个统一体中,这样就够了吗?还不够。事情不是矛盾双方互相依存就完了,更重要的,还在于矛盾着的事物的互相转化。这就是说,事物内部矛盾着的两方面,因为一定的条件而各向着和自己相反的方面转化了去,向着它的对立方面所处的地位转化了去。这就是矛盾的同一性的第二种意义。
为什么这里也有同一性呢?你们看,被统治的无产阶级经过革命转化为统治者,原来是统治者的资产阶级却转化为被统治者,转化到对方原来所占的地位。苏联已经是这样做了,全世界也将要这样做。试问其间没有在一定条件之下的联系和同一性,如何能够发生这样的变化呢?
曾在中国近代历史的一定阶段上起过某种积极作用的国民党,因为它的固有的阶级性和帝国主义的引诱(这些就是条件),在一九二七年以后转化为反革命,又由于中日矛盾的尖锐化和共产党的统一战线政策(这些就是条件),而被迫着赞成抗日。矛盾着的东西这一个变到那一个,其间包含了一定的同一性。
我们实行过的土地革命,已经是并且还将是这样的过程,拥有土地的地主阶级转化为失掉土地的阶级,而曾经是失掉土地的农民却转化为取得土地的小私有者。有无、得失之间,因一定条件而互相联结,二者具有同一性。在社会主义条件之下,农民的私有制又将转化为社会主义农业的公有制,苏联已经这样做了,全世界将来也会这样做。私产和公产之间有一条由此达彼的桥梁,哲学上名之曰同一性,或互相转化、互相渗透。
巩固无产阶级的专政或人民的专政,正是准备着取消这种专政,走到消灭任何国家制度的更高阶段去的条件。建立和发展共产党,正是准备着消灭共产党和一切政党制度的条件。建立共产党领导的革命军,进行革命战争,正是准备着永远消灭战争的条件。这许多相反的东西,同时却是相成的东西。
大家知道,战争与和平是互相转化的。战争转化为和平,例如第一次世界大战转化为战后的和平,中国的内战现在也停止了,出现了国内的和平。和平转化为战争,例如一九二七年的国共合作转化为战争,现在的世界和平局面也可能转化为第二次世界大战。为什么是这样?因为在阶级社会中战争与和平这样矛盾着的事物,在一定条件下具备着同一性。
一切矛盾着的东西,互相联系着,不但在一定条件之下共处于一个统一体中,而且在一定条件之下互相转化,这就是矛盾的同一性的全部意义。列宁所谓“怎样成为同一的(怎样变成同一的),——在怎样的条件之下它们互相转化,成为同一的”,就是这个意思。
“为什么人的头脑不应当把这些对立看作死的、凝固的东西,而应当看作生动的、有条件的、可变动的、互相转化的东西”呢?因为客观事物本来是如此的。客观事物中矛盾着的诸方面的统一或同一性,本来不是死的、凝固的,而是生动的、有条件的、可变动的、暂时的、相对的东西,一切矛盾都依一定条件向它们的反面转化着。这种情况,反映在人们的思想里,就成了马克思主义的唯物辩证法的宇宙观。只有现在的和历史上的反动的统治阶级以及为他们服务的形而上学,不是把对立的事物当作生动的、有条件的、可变动的、互相转化的东西去看,而是当作死的、凝固的东西去看,并且把这种错误的看法到处宣传,迷惑人民群众,以达其继续统治的目的。共产党人的任务就在于揭露反动派和形而上学的错误思想,宣传事物的本来的辩证法,促成事物的转化,达到革命的目的。
所谓矛盾在一定条件下的同一性,就是说,我们所说的矛盾乃是现实的矛盾,具体的矛盾,而矛盾的互相转化也是现实的、具体的。神话中的许多变化,例如《山海经》中所说的“夸父追日”,《淮南子》中所说的“羿射九日”,《西游记》中所说的孙悟空七十二变和《聊斋志异》中的许多鬼狐变人的故事等等,这种神话中所说的矛盾的互相变化,乃是无数复杂的现实矛盾的互相变化对于人们所引起的一种幼稚的、想象的、主观幻想的变化,并不是具体的矛盾所表现出来的具体的变化。马克思说:“任何神话都是用想象和借助想象以征服自然力,支配自然力,把自然力加以形象化;因而,随着这些自然力之实际上被支配,神话也就消失了。”这种神话中的(还有童话中的)千变万化的故事,虽然因为它们想象出人们征服自然力等等,而能够吸引人们的喜欢,并且最好的神话具有“永久的魅力”(马克思),但神话并不是根据具体的矛盾之一定的条件而构成的,所以它们并不是现实之科学的反映。这就是说,神话或童话中矛盾构成的诸方面,并不是具体的同一性,只是幻想的同一性。科学地反映现实变化的同一性的,就是马克思主义的辩证法。
为什么鸡蛋能够转化为鸡子,而石头不能够转化为鸡子呢?为什么战争与和平有同一性,而战争与石头却没有同一性呢?为什么人能生人不能生出其它的东西呢?没有别的,就是因为矛盾的同一性要在一定的必要的条件之下。缺乏一定的必要的条件,就没有任何的同一性。
为什么俄国在一九一七年二月的资产阶级民主革命和同年十月的无产阶级社会主义革命直接地联系着,而法国资产阶级革命没有直接地联系于社会主义的革命,一八七一年的巴黎公社终于失败了呢?为什么蒙古和中亚细亚的游牧制度又直接地和社会主义联系了呢?为什么中国的革命可以避免资本主义的前途,可以和社会主义直接联系起来,不要再走西方国家的历史老路,不要经过一个资产阶级专政的时期呢?没有别的,都是由于当时的具体条件。一定的必要的条件具备了,事物发展的过程就发生一定的矛盾,而且这种或这些矛盾互相依存,又互相转化,否则,一切都不可能。
同一性的问题如此。那末,什么是斗争性呢?同一性和斗争性的关系是怎样的呢?
列宁说:“对立的统一(一致、同一、合一),是有条件的、一时的、暂存的、相对的。互相排斥的对立的斗争则是绝对的,正如发展、运动是绝对的一样。”
列宁这段话是什么意思呢?
一切过程都有始有终,一切过程都转化为它们的对立物。一切过程的常住性是相对的,但是一种过程转化为他种过程的这种变动性则是绝对的。
无论什么事物的运动都采取两种状态,相对地静止的状态和显着地变动的状态。两种状态的运动都是由事物内部包含的两个矛盾着的因素互相斗争所引起的。当着事物的运动在第一种状态的时候,它只有数量的变化,没有性质的变化,所以显出好似静止的面貌。当着事物的运动在第二种状态的时候,它已由第一种状态中的数量的变化达到了某一个最高点,引起了统一物的分解,发生了性质的变化,所以显出显着地变化的面貌。我们在日常生活中所看见的统一、团结、联合、调和、均势、相持、僵局、静止、有常、平衡、凝聚、吸引等等,都是事物处在量变状态中所显现的面貌。而统一物的分解,团结、联合、调和、均势、相持、僵局、静止、有常、平衡、凝聚、吸引等等状态的破坏,变到相反的状态,便都是事物在质变状态中、在一种过程过渡到他种过程的变化中所显现的面貌。事物总是不断地由第一种状态转化为第二种状态,而矛盾的斗争则存在于两种状态中,并经过第二种状态而达到矛盾的解决。所以说,对立的统一是有条件的、暂时的、相对的,而对立的互相排除的斗争则是绝对的。
前面我们曾经说,两个相反的东西中间有同一性,所以二者能够共处于一个统一体中,又能够互相转化,这是说的条件性,即是说在一定条件之下,矛盾的东西能够统一起来,又能够互相转化;无此一定条件,就不能成为矛盾,不能共居,也不能转化。由于一定的条件才构成了矛盾的同一性,所以说同一性是有条件的、相对的。这里我们又说,矛盾的斗争贯串于过程的始终,并使一过程向着他过程转化,矛盾的斗争无所不在,所以说矛盾的斗争性是无条件的、绝对的。
有条件的相对的同一性和无条件的绝对的斗争性相结合,构成了一切事物的矛盾运动。
我们中国人常说:“相反相成。”就是说相反的东西有同一性。这句话是辩证法的,是违反形而上学的。“相反”就是说两个矛盾方面的互相排斥,或互相斗争。“相成”就是说在一定条件之下两个矛盾方面互相联结起来,获得了同一性。而斗争性即寓于同一性之中,没有斗争性就没有同一性。
在同一性中存在着斗争性,在特殊性中存在着普遍性,在个性中存在着共性。拿列宁的话来说,叫做“在相对的东西里面有着绝对的东西”。
六 对抗在矛盾中的地位
在矛盾的斗争性的问题中,包含着对抗是什么的问题。我们回答道:对抗是矛盾斗争的一种形式,而不是矛盾斗争的一切形式。
在人类历史中,存在着阶级的对抗,这是矛盾斗争的一种特殊的表现。剥削阶级和被剥削阶级之间的矛盾,无论在奴隶社会也好,封建社会也好,资本主义社会也好,互相矛盾着的两阶级,长期地并存于一个社会中,它们互相斗争着,但要待两阶级的矛盾发展到了一定的阶段的时候,双方才取外部对抗的形式,发展为革命。阶级社会中,由和平向战争的转化,也是如此。
炸弹在未爆炸的时候,是矛盾物因一定条件共居于一个统一体中的时候。待至新的条件(发火)出现,才发生了爆炸。自然界中一切到了最后要采取外部冲突形式去解决旧矛盾产生新事物的现象,都有与此相仿佛的情形。
认识这种情形,极为重要。它使我们懂得,在阶级社会中,革命和革命战争是不可避免的,舍此不能完成社会发展的飞跃,不能推翻反动的统治阶级,而使人民获得政权。共产党人必须揭露反动派所谓社会革命是不必要的和不可能的等等欺骗的宣传,坚持马克思列宁主义的社会革命论,使人民懂得,这不但是完全必要的,而且是完全可能的,整个人类的历史和苏联的胜利,都证明了这个科学的真理。
但是我们必须具体地研究各种矛盾斗争的情况,不应当将上面所说的公式不适当地套在一切事物的身上。矛盾和斗争是普遍的、绝对的,但是解决矛盾的方法,即斗争的形式,则因矛盾的性质不同而不相同。有些矛盾具有公开的对抗性,有些矛盾则不是这样。根据事物的具体发展,有些矛盾是由原来还非对抗性的,而发展成为对抗性的;也有些矛盾则由原来是对抗性的,而发展成为非对抗性的。
共产党内正确思想和错误思想的矛盾,如前所说,在阶级存在的时候,这是阶级矛盾对于党内的反映。这种矛盾,在开始的时候,或在个别的问题上,并不一定马上表现为对抗性的。但随着阶级斗争的发展,这种矛盾也就可能发展为对抗性的。苏联共产党的历史告诉我们:列宁、斯大林的正确思想和托洛茨基、布哈林等人的错误思想的矛盾,在开始的时候还没有表现为对抗的形式,但随后就发展为对抗的了。中国共产党的历史也有过这样的情形。我们党内许多同志的正确思想和陈独秀、张国焘等人的错误思想的矛盾,在开始的时候也没有表现为对抗的形式,但随后就发展为对抗的了。目前我们党内的正确思想和错误思想的矛盾,没有表现为对抗的形式,如果犯错误的同志能够改正自己的错误,那就不会发展为对抗性的东西。因此,党一方面必须对于错误思想进行严肃的斗争,另方面又必须充分地给犯错误的同志留有自己觉悟的机会。在这样的情况下,过火的斗争,显然是不适当的。但如果犯错误的人坚持错误,并扩大下去,这种矛盾也就存在着发展为对抗性的东西的可能性。
经济上城市和乡村的矛盾,在资本主义社会里面(那里资产阶级统治的城市残酷地掠夺乡村),在中国的国民党统治区域里面(那里外国帝国主义和本国买办大资产阶级所统治的城市极野蛮地掠夺乡村),那是极其对抗的矛盾。但在社会主义国家里面,在我们的革命根据地里面,这种对抗的矛盾就变为非对抗的矛盾,而当到达共产主义社会的时候,这种矛盾就会消灭。
列宁说:“对抗和矛盾断然不同。在社会主义下,对抗消灭了,矛盾存在着。”这就是说,对抗只是矛盾斗争的一种形式,而不是它的一切形式,不能到处套用这个公式。
七 结论
说到这里,我们可以总起来说几句。事物矛盾的法则,即对立统一的法则,是自然和社会的根本法则,因而也是思维的根本法则。它是和形而上学的宇宙观相反的。它对于人类的认识史是一个大革命。按照辩证唯物论的观点看来,矛盾存在于一切客观事物和主观思维的过程中,矛盾贯串于一切过程的始终,这是矛盾的普遍性和绝对性。矛盾着的事物及其每一个侧面各有其特点,这是矛盾的特殊性和相对性。矛盾着的事物依一定的条件有同一性,因此能够共居于一个统一体中,又能够互相转化到相反的方面去,这又是矛盾的特殊性和相对性。然而矛盾的斗争则是不断的,不管在它们共居的时候,或者在它们互相转化的时候,都有斗争的存在,尤其是在它们互相转化的时候,斗争的表现更为显着,这又是矛盾的普遍性和绝对性。当着我们研究矛盾的特殊性和相对性的时候,要注意矛盾和矛盾方面的主要的和非主要的区别;当着我们研究矛盾的普遍性和斗争性的时候,要注意矛盾的各种不同的斗争形式的区别。否则就要犯错误。如果我们经过研究真正懂得了上述这些要点,我们就能够击破违反马克思列宁主义基本原则的不利于我们的革命事业的那些教条主义的思想;也能够使有经验的同志们整理自己的经验,使之带上原则性,而避免重复经验主义的错误。这些,就是我们研究矛盾法则的一些简单的结论。
