Speech at the Conference of Secretaries of Provincial, Municipal and Autonomous Region Party Committees
Mao Zedong · Chairman of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China
- Context
- Mao addressed provincial, municipal and autonomous region Party committee secretaries at a conference in two talks, on January 18 and 27, 1957, warning against Right deviation, defending co-operatives and the Hundred Flowers policy, and reviewing foreign relations.
- Main themes
- Ideological trends within the Party and society, rural co-operatives and Right deviation, student unrest and the Hungarian incident, "great democracy", criticism of Stalin and the CPSU Twentieth Congress, Hundred Flowers policy and poisonous weeds, remoulding of intellectuals and capitalists, Sino-American and Sino-Soviet relations, Suez crisis and inter-imperialist contradictions, legal system and suppression of counter-revolutionaries, agriculture as the foundation of industry, dialectics and the unity of opposites
- Duration
- ~116 min
- Words
- 13,957
- Sentences
- 780
- Readability
- 55
- Grade
- 10.0
- Syntax
- 2.83
- Vocabulary
- 2.17
Translated from Chinese Source: GitHub qinglee/maoxuan (毛泽东选集) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other780 sentences in 100 paragraphs
I. Talk of 18 January
This meeting has three main questions to discuss: the question of ideological trends, the rural question, and the economic question. Today I will talk about the question of ideological trends.
The question of ideological trends is one we must take firm hold of. I am raising it here as the first question. At present, problems that deserve a great deal of attention have appeared in ideological trends inside the Party and in ideological trends in society.
One kind of problem has arisen in our own household. For example, some cadres now scramble for fame and gain and care for nothing but profit. In the course of grading, there were people like this: being promoted one grade was not enough, and even when promoted two grades they still lay in bed crying their eyes out; presumably they had to be promoted three grades before they would get up. With this fuss of theirs, one problem got solved: no more cadre grading of any sort, it will not be done at all; wages will be roughly equal with slight differences, and that is that. In the old Beiyang warlord government there was a premier called Tang Shaoyi, who later became county magistrate of Zhongshan County in Guangdong. If a premier of the old society could go and be a county magistrate, why can't our ministers go and be county magistrates? In my view, those who make a fuss over grades, who can be raised but not lowered, are on this point not even as good as this old bureaucrat. They do not compete in hardship, in doing more work and enjoying less; instead they compete in ostentation, in grades, in status. This kind of thinking has developed a great deal in the Party now and deserves our attention.
Does agricultural co-operation have prospects or not? Are co-operatives better, or is the individual economy better? This question has been raised again too. Last year, there was no problem in places with good harvests, and none in the severely stricken areas either; it was the co-operatives that were stricken but not severely, that harvested but not abundantly, where problems arose. In co-operatives of this kind, the value of a work-point had been promised too high at first and later did not come to that much; the members' income did not increase and even fell. So talk started: are co-operatives still any good, do we still want them? This kind of talk is reflected among some cadres inside the Party as well. Some cadres say co-operatives have no superiority. Some ministers went to the countryside to have a look, and after coming back to Beijing the atmosphere they spread was not good; they said the peasants were listless and no longer keen on farming, as if the co-operatives were on the verge of collapse and extinction. Some co-operative chairmen cannot hold their heads up; they are being cursed everywhere, criticised from above and criticised in the newspapers too. Some Party committees' propaganda department heads do not dare to publicise the superiority of co-operatives. Liao Luyan, the Minister of Agriculture, who is also deputy head of the Party Central Committee's Rural Work Department, says that he himself has lost heart, and the responsible cadres under him have lost heart too; it is no good whichever way you look at it, and the forty articles of the agricultural development programme no longer count. What do you do when you have lost heart? That is easy to handle: if you have no air, we just pump some air into you. Now the propaganda in the newspapers has turned around a bit; it talks at length about the superiority of co-operatives, says only good things and not bad things, and will keep this up for a few months to pump up some morale.
The year before last we opposed Right deviation; last year we opposed "rash advance", and the result of opposing "rash advance" was another Right deviation. The Right deviation I am speaking of refers to Right deviation on the question of the socialist revolution, mainly on the question of the socialist transformation of the countryside. A wind like this has blown up among our cadres, like a typhoon, and it deserves special attention. Among our ministers, vice-ministers, bureau and department heads and provincial-level cadres, a considerable proportion come from landlord, rich peasant and well-to-do middle peasant families; some have an old father who is a landlord and still has no right to vote. When these cadres go home, their families tell them that sort of bad talk, which boils down to: the co-operatives are no good and won't last. The well-to-do middle peasants are a vacillating stratum; their idea of farming on their own is raising its head again, and some want to withdraw from the co-operatives. This wind among our cadres reflects the thinking of these classes and strata.
Co-operation will certainly be done well, but it cannot be done completely well within a year or two. This must be explained clearly to comrades in the Party, the government, the army and among the people. The co-operatives have only this much history; most of them have a history of only a year to a year and a half, and very little experience. People who have spent a lifetime making revolution still make mistakes; these people have only been at it a year to a year and a half, so how can you demand that they make no mistakes at all? As soon as there is a bit of wind and a bit of rain, saying co-operation is no good — this idea is itself a big mistake. In fact, most co-operatives are run well or fairly well. Just produce one well-run co-operative, and you can knock down all the strange arguments against co-operation. Why can this co-op be run well and other co-ops cannot? Why does this co-op have superiority and other co-ops do not? Go everywhere and talk at length about this co-op's experience. Every province can surely find one model like that! Find the co-op with the worst conditions, poor terrain, very low output in the past, very poor; don't find one whose conditions were good to begin with. Of course, you can do dozens, but as long as you do one well, that counts as victory.
Problems have also arisen in the schools; in a good many places students have been making trouble. At a school in Shijiazhuang, some of the graduates could not be given jobs for the time being and had their studies extended by a year, which made the students dissatisfied. A small number of counter-revolutionaries took the opportunity to incite them and organised a demonstration march, saying they would seize the Shijiazhuang broadcasting station and proclaim a "Hungary". They put up a lot of slogans, of which these three were the most prominent: "Down with fascism!" "We want war, not peace!" "Socialism has no superiority!" According to them, the Communist Party is fascist, and all of us must be overthrown. The slogans they put forward were so reactionary that the workers did not sympathise, the peasants did not sympathise, the masses in every quarter did not sympathise. At Tsinghua University in Beijing, a student openly declared: "One day I'll just kill thousands and tens of thousands of people, that's all!" Once "let a hundred flowers bloom, let a hundred schools of thought contend" came along, this "school" came out too. Comrade Deng Xiaoping went to this university and gave a talk; he said, if you want to kill thousands and tens of thousands, then we will exercise dictatorship.
According to an investigation by Beijing Municipality, most of the students in our institutions of higher learning are the children of landlords, rich peasants, the bourgeoisie and well-to-do middle peasants; those of working-class and poor and lower-middle peasant origin are under twenty per cent. It is probably much the same for the whole country. This situation should be changed, but it will take time. Among some university students, Gomułka is very popular, and Tito and Kardelj are very popular too. On the other hand, the landlords and rich peasants in the countryside and the capitalists and the democratic parties in the cities are, for the most part, still fairly well behaved; when the disturbances broke out in Poland and Hungary they did not make trouble, they did not jump out and say they wanted to kill thousands and tens of thousands. Their good behaviour should be analysed. It is because they have no capital left; the working class and the poor and lower-middle peasants do not listen to them, there is nothing under their feet. If the world changes, if an atom bomb smashes Beijing and Shanghai to pieces, won't these people change? That would be hard to say. Then the landlords, rich peasants, the bourgeoisie and the democratic parties would all divide. They are old hands at the ways of the world, and many of them are keeping hidden now. Their children, these student kids, have no experience, and they have brought out into the open things like "kill thousands and tens of thousands" and "socialism has no superiority".
Among some professors there are also all sorts of strange arguments: we don't want the Communist Party, the Communist Party can't lead them, socialism is no good, and so on and so forth. They had these ideas before but didn't voice them; with a hundred schools of thought contending we let them speak, and out came these words. The film The Life of Wu Xun — have you seen it? There is a writing brush in it, several zhang long, symbolising the "men of culture", and one sweep of it is quite formidable. Now that they want to come out, presumably they want to sweep us away. Do they want a restoration?
Last year there were several big storms internationally. The Twentieth Congress of the CPSU came out in a big way against Stalin; after that the imperialists staged two big anti-communist storms, and in the international communist movement there were also two big storms of debate. In these storms some parties in Europe and the Americas suffered considerable effects and losses, while the parties of the Eastern countries suffered relatively small effects and losses. As soon as the CPSU "Twentieth Congress" came along, some people who had been very active in supporting Stalin before became very active in opposing him. In my view these people do not talk Marxism-Leninism, do not analyse problems, and are also lacking in revolutionary morality. Marxism-Leninism also includes proletarian revolutionary morality. You supported him so much before; now you ought to give at least some reasons before you can make this turn! Without giving any reason at all, they suddenly turn a hundred and eighty degrees, as if they had never supported Stalin, when in fact they used to support him very much. The question of Stalin involves the whole international communist movement; the parties of every country are involved.
The overwhelming majority of cadres in our Party were dissatisfied with the CPSU "Twentieth Congress", and considered that Stalin was attacked too much. This is a normal sentiment, a normal reaction. But a small number of people were shaken. Every time a typhoon comes, before the rain the ants come out of their holes; their "noses" are very sensitive, they understand meteorology. When the typhoon of the CPSU "Twentieth Congress" blew, some ants came out of their holes in China too. These are the vacillating elements in the Party; whenever there is an opportunity they will waver. When they heard Stalin being beaten to death with a single blow of the club, they felt very comfortable, and swung over that way, shouting long live, saying Khrushchev is right about everything, that was what I advocated all along. Later the imperialists dealt a few blows, and there were a few blows within the international communist movement, so that even Khrushchev had to change his tune somewhat, and they swung back again. The general trend was such that they had no choice but to swing back. A tuft of grass on top of the wall falls whichever way the wind blows. Swinging back is not their true heart; swinging over the other way is their true heart. Those inside and outside the Party who cheered on the Polish and Hungarian events cheered them well! Every time they opened their mouths it was Poznań, and every time they closed them it was Hungary. That made them show their heads: the ants came out of their holes, and the turtles and tortoises all came out too. They turned with Gomułka's baton; when Gomułka said great democracy, they said great democracy too. Now the situation has changed and they have gone quiet. Keeping quiet is not their true heart; in their hearts they still want to speak up.
When a typhoon blows, the vacillating elements cannot stand firm; they are bound to sway. This is a law. I urge everyone to pay attention to this question. Some people sway a few times, gain experience, and then stop swaying. There is a kind of person who will sway forever, like rice and crops of that sort, which sway as soon as the wind blows because their stalks are thin. Sorghum and maize are somewhat better; their stalks are thicker. Only the big trees stand straight and cannot be uprooted. There are typhoons every year, and ideological typhoons and political typhoons, domestic and international, also come every year. This is a natural phenomenon of society. A political party is a kind of society, a political society. The first category of political society is parties and factions. A party is an organisation of a class. Our Communist Party of China is a proletarian party, made up mainly of people of worker and semi-proletarian poor peasant origin. But many Party members also come from landlord, rich peasant and capitalist families, or are of well-to-do middle peasant and urban petty-bourgeois origin. A considerable number of them, though they have struggled arduously for many years and been tempered somewhat, have not learned much Marxism, and ideologically and spiritually they are still like rice: as soon as the wind blows they sway.
Some Party members have passed every kind of test in the past, but find the test of socialism hard to pass. There are typical people like this; Xue Xun is one. She was originally deputy secretary of the Hebei Provincial Party Committee and vice-governor. When did she begin to waver? It was when the unified purchase and marketing was first put into effect. Unified purchase and marketing is an important step in carrying out socialism. But she resolutely opposed it, opposed it no matter what. Another is Meng Yongqian, deputy director of the All-China Federation of Supply and Marketing Co-operatives. He submitted a written statement, a letter, also resolutely opposing unified purchase and marketing. When agricultural co-operation was carried out, there were also people in the Party who rose up against it. In short, there are senior cadres like this in the Party who cannot pass the test of socialism and who vacillate. Is this sort of thing over? No. Will these people become firm in ten years' time and truly believe in socialism? Not necessarily either. Ten years from now, if some problem arises, they may still say, I foresaw this long ago.
A document has been distributed to you comrades reflecting the ideological trends of certain army cadres. Although the views of these cadres contain some reasonable parts — for example, that the wages of some cadres are too high and the peasants resent it — the general direction of their views is unsound and their fundamental line is wrong. They criticise our Party's policy as being "Left" in the countryside and Right in the cities. Although China has 9.6 million square kilometres, there are altogether only two places: one is called the countryside and one is called the cities. According to what they say, both are wrong.
The so-called "Left" rural policy means that the peasants' income is not much, less than the workers'. This must be analysed; one cannot look at income alone. Workers' income is generally higher than peasants', but the value they produce is greater than the peasants', and their necessary living expenses are also greater than the peasants'. The improvement of the peasants' life depends mainly on the peasants' own efforts to develop production. The government also helps the peasants vigorously, for example by building water conservancy works, issuing agricultural loans, and so on. Our agricultural tax, including taxes on side-occupations, amounts to about eight per cent of the peasants' total output value, and many side-occupations are not taxed. Our unified purchase of grain is at normal prices. The profit the state gets from the peasants in the exchange of industrial and agricultural products is also very small. We do not have the Soviet system of compulsory deliveries. In the exchange of industrial and agricultural products we narrow the price scissors, rather than widening them as the Soviet Union does. Our policy is very different from the Soviet Union's. Therefore it cannot be said that our rural policy is "Left".
Among the senior cadres of our army, some may have gone home themselves, or had relatives come to stay, and heard what the well-to-do middle peasants, rich peasants and landlords say, and been affected by it, and so they cry out about the peasants' hardships on their behalf. In the first half of 1955 a considerable number of people in the Party cried out about the peasants' hardships, echoing Liang Shuming and his like, as if only these two groups represented the peasants and knew the peasants' sufferings. As for our Party Central Committee, in their view it does not represent the peasants, the provincial Party committees do not represent them either, and the majority of Party members do not represent them. Jiangsu conducted an investigation: in some areas, thirty per cent of cadres at the county, district and township levels cried out about the peasants' hardships. When it was looked into later, most of these people who cried out about the peasants' hardships turned out to come from relatively well-off families with surplus grain to sell. The so-called "hardship" of these people is having surplus grain. So-called "helping the peasants" and "caring for the peasants" means not selling surplus grain to the state. Whom, after all, do these people who cry out about hardship represent? They do not represent the broad masses of peasants but a small number of well-to-do peasants.
As for saying that the urban policy is Right, it does look a bit like that, because we have taken the capitalists on and still give them seven years of fixed interest. What to do after seven years? We will see when the time comes. It would be best to leave a tail and still give them some fixed interest. By paying out this little bit of money we have bought a whole class. The Central Committee considered this policy carefully. The capitalists, together with the democratic personages and intellectuals connected with them, generally have a relatively high level of cultural and technical knowledge. By buying over this class, we strip them of their political capital and leave them nothing to say. There are two ways of stripping: one is to pay money to buy them, the other is to make arrangements for them and give them something to do. In this way the political capital is not in their hands but in ours. We must strip them of their political capital completely, and whatever has not been stripped clean must still be stripped. Therefore it also cannot be said that our urban policy is Right.
Our rural policy is correct, and our urban policy is correct too. Therefore a big nationwide upheaval like the Hungarian incident cannot be stirred up. All it amounts to is a small number of people making a fuss here and there, wanting to have so-called great democracy. There is nothing frightening about great democracy either. On this question I differ from you; some of you comrades seem very afraid. I say, if great democracy comes, first, don't be afraid; second, analyse it, see what they say and what they do. When those bad people engage in so-called great democracy, they are bound to take wrong actions and say wrong things, exposing and isolating themselves. Is "killing thousands and tens of thousands" a way to resolve contradictions among the people? Can it win the sympathy of the majority? "Down with fascism", "socialism has no superiority" — isn't this an open violation of the Constitution? That the Communist Party and the political power led by the Communist Party are revolutionary, that socialism has superiority — this is all stated in the Constitution and acknowledged by the people of the whole country. "We want war, not peace" — fine! You call for war, there are only a handful of you altogether, you don't have enough troops, and your officers aren't trained either. These kids have gone mad! At that school in Shijiazhuang, when those three slogans were discussed, of seventy representatives only a dozen or so were in favour, and fifty-odd were against. Then the slogans were taken to the four thousand students for discussion, and none of them were in favour, so those dozen or so were isolated. The extremely reactionary elements who put forward and stuck to these slogans were just a few people. If they hadn't engaged in great democracy and put up slogans everywhere, we still wouldn't know what they wanted to do. Once they engaged in great democracy, their tails were caught. One good thing about the Hungarian incident is that it drew these ants of ours in China out of their holes.
In Hungary, when great democracy came, the Party, the government and the army all collapsed. In China this will not happen. A few student kids charge in and the Party, government and army completely disintegrate — that could only happen if all of us were completely good-for-nothing. So don't be afraid of great democracy. When trouble breaks out, the abscess is easy to deal with; this is a good thing. We were not afraid of imperialism before and we are not afraid of it now. We were never afraid of Chiang Kai-shek either. Are we now afraid of great democracy? I say don't be afraid. If anyone uses so-called great democracy to oppose the socialist system and overthrow the leadership of the Communist Party, we will exercise the dictatorship of the proletariat over them.
On the question of intellectuals, there is now a deviation: emphasising placement rather than remoulding; there is a lot of placement and very little remoulding. Once a hundred flowers blooming and a hundred schools of thought contending came along, people did not dare to remould the intellectuals. We dare to remould the capitalists; why don't we dare to remould the intellectuals and democratic personages?
As for letting a hundred flowers bloom, I think we should still let them bloom. Some comrades think only fragrant flowers can be allowed to bloom, not poisonous weeds. This view shows that they understand very poorly the policy of letting a hundred flowers bloom and a hundred schools of thought contend. Generally speaking, counter-revolutionary speech is of course not allowed to bloom. But when it appears not with a counter-revolutionary face but with a revolutionary face, then we have no choice but to let it bloom; only in this way is it advantageous for us to identify it and struggle against it. Two kinds of things grow in the fields: one is called grain, the other is called weeds. Weeds have to be hoed every year, several times a year. If you say only fragrant flowers should bloom and no poisonous weeds, that is like saying only grain may grow in the field and not a single blade of weed. Say it as you may, anyone who has been to the fields knows that so long as you don't set to hoeing, there will actually be just as many weeds. Weeds have one good thing about them: turned over, they become fertiliser. You say they are of no use? The useless can be turned into the useful. The peasants have to struggle against the weeds in the fields every year, and our Party's writers, artists, critics and professors also have to struggle every year against the weeds in the ideological field. What is called being tempered means coming through struggle. When your weeds grow, I hoe them. This opposite is constantly appearing. There will still be weeds in ten thousand years, so we must also be prepared to struggle for ten thousand years.
All in all, last year was an eventful autumn: internationally it was a year of storms stirred up by Khrushchev and Gomułka, and at home it was a year of very intense socialist transformation. It is still an eventful time now; all kinds of ideas will continue to be exposed, and I hope you comrades will pay attention.
II. Talk of 27 January
Now I will make a few points.
The first point: achievements must be adequately estimated. In our revolution and construction, achievements are primary, though there are also shortcomings and mistakes. With so many achievements, exaggeration will not do, but underestimating them will lead to mistakes, possibly big mistakes. This question was in fact settled at the Second Plenary Session of the Eighth Central Committee, and it has been raised many times again at this meeting, which shows that it has not yet been settled in some comrades' minds. Among democratic personages in particular there is a line of talk: "You always say that achievements are fundamental; that doesn't settle anything. Who doesn't know that achievements are fundamental and there are also shortcomings and mistakes!" But achievements really are fundamental. If we do not affirm this, we lose heart. With regard to co-operation, there has indeed been loss of heart!
The second point: overall planning with due consideration for all, so that each finds its proper place. This has always been our policy. We adopted this policy in Yan'an. In August 1944 Ta Kung Pao published an editorial saying something to the effect that one should not "set up a separate kitchen". During the Chongqing negotiations I told the people in charge of Ta Kung Pao: I very much agree with what you said, but Generalissimo Chiang has to provide the food; if he won't provide food for us, what can I do but set up a separate kitchen? At that time one of the slogans we put to Chiang Kai-shek was that each should find its proper place. Now we are the ones in charge. Our policy is overall planning with due consideration for all, so that each finds its proper place. This includes taking on all the military and government personnel left behind by the Kuomintang; even those who ran off to Taiwan can come back. As for counter-revolutionaries, all those who are not executed are remoulded and given a way to make a living. The democratic parties are kept on and coexist with us for a long time, and their members are given placements. In short, we take care of all six hundred million people in the country. Take unified purchase and marketing: we take care of all the urban population and the grain-deficient households in the countryside. Or take urban youth: whether they go to school, or to the countryside, or to factories, or to the border regions, there must always be some arrangement for them. For families in which no one is employed, there must also be relief; the principle is always that no one starves to death. All of this is overall planning with due consideration for all. What sort of policy is this? It is to mobilise all positive forces for building socialism. This is a strategic policy. It is better to carry out such a policy; fewer disturbances arise. This idea of overall planning with due consideration for all must be explained clearly to everyone.
Comrade Ke Qingshi said we must try every possible means. That is very well said; we must try every possible means to resolve difficulties. This slogan should be publicised. The difficulties we face now are not very big; what's so terrible about them! Compared with the Long March, climbing snow mountains and crossing grasslands, things are surely a bit better. On the Long March, after crossing the Dadu River, which way were we to go? To the north it was all high mountains, and the population was very sparse; at that time we put forward that we must overcome the difficulties by a thousand means and a hundred stratagems. What does a thousand means and a hundred stratagems mean? A thousand means is nine hundred and ninety-nine means plus one; a hundred stratagems is ninety-nine stratagems plus one. So far you have not yet come up with a few means and a few stratagems. How many means and how many stratagems do the provinces and the central ministries actually have? As long as every possible means is tried, difficulties can be resolved.
The third point: international questions. In the Middle East there was the Suez Canal incident. One man, called Nasser, nationalised the canal; another man, called Eden, sent an army to fight; then a third man, called Eisenhower, wanted to drive the British out and grab the place for himself. The British bourgeoisie has always been crafty and cunning; it is a class that is best at making compromises at the right time. Now it has let the Middle East fall into American hands. This mistake is a big one! How many mistakes like this can be counted in its history? Why did it lose its head and make this mistake this time? Because the United States was pressing too hard, it lost its composure and wanted to take back the Middle East and stop the United States. Was Britain's spearhead directed mainly against Egypt? No. Britain's move was aimed at the United States, and the United States' at Britain.
From this incident we can see the focus of the present world struggle. Of course, the contradiction between the imperialist countries and the socialist countries is a very sharp contradiction, but they are now using the pretext of anti-communism to fight over territory. What territory are they fighting over? The territory of the one thousand million people of Asia and Africa. At present their contest is concentrated on the Middle East, a region of great strategic significance, especially the Suez Canal area of Egypt. There, two kinds of contradictions and three kinds of forces are in conflict. Of the two kinds of contradictions, one is the contradiction between imperialism and imperialism, that is, between the United States and Britain, and between the United States and France; the other is the contradiction between imperialism and the oppressed nations. Of the three kinds of forces, the first is the biggest imperialist power, the United States; the second is the second-rate imperialist powers, Britain and France; the third is the oppressed nations. At present the main arena of imperialist contention is Asia and Africa. National independence movements have arisen throughout these regions. The methods the United States uses are both civil and military; that is how it is in the Middle East.
Their quarrelling is to our advantage. Our policy should be to consolidate the socialist countries and not yield an inch of territory. Whoever wants us to yield, we must struggle against them. Outside this sphere, let them quarrel. Then should we speak out or not? We should speak out. We must support the anti-imperialist struggles of the peoples of Asia, Africa and Latin America and the revolutionary struggles of the peoples of all countries.
Between the imperialist countries and us, there is some of us in them and some of them in us. We support the people's revolution there, and they carry out subversive activities here. Among them there are our people, namely the communist parties there, the revolutionary workers, peasants and intellectuals, and progressive people. Among us there are their people; taking China as an example, these are many people among the bourgeoisie and in the democratic parties, and also the landlord class. At present these people seem obedient and have not made trouble yet. But if atom bombs were to land on Beijing, what would they do? Wouldn't they rebel? That is very much open to question. As for the people undergoing reform through labour, the ringleaders of the trouble at that school in Shijiazhuang, and that university student in Beijing who wanted to kill thousands and tens of thousands — needless to say. We must digest them; we must remould the landlords and capitalists into working people. This too is a strategic policy. Eliminating classes will take a very long time.
In short, our view of international questions is still this: the imperialists are fighting among themselves, competing with each other for colonies, and this contradiction is the bigger one. They use their contradiction with us as a pretext to cover up the contradictions among themselves. We can make use of their contradictions; there is a great deal to be done here. This is a major matter bearing on our foreign policy.
Let me talk about Sino-American relations. At this meeting we have distributed Eisenhower's letter to Chiang Kai-shek. In my view this letter mainly pours cold water on Chiang Kai-shek and then pumps a little air into him. The letter says he needs to be calm and not impulsive, meaning don't go to war, rely on the United Nations. That is pouring cold water. Chiang Kai-shek is a bit impulsive. Pumping air into him means saying that a hard-line policy toward the Communist Party should continue, and pinning hopes on our having disturbances. In his view, disturbances have already broken out and the Communist Party has no way of stopping them. Each has his own observations!
I still think it is better to establish diplomatic relations with the United States a few years later. That is more advantageous. The Soviet Union established diplomatic relations with the United States seventeen years after the October Revolution. A world economic crisis broke out in 1929 and lasted until 1933. In that year Hitler came to power in Germany and Roosevelt came to power in the United States, and only at that time did the Soviet Union and the United States establish diplomatic relations. We may establish diplomatic relations with the United States after the completion of the Third Five-Year Plan, that is to say, after eighteen years or even longer. We are in no hurry to get into the United Nations either, just as we are in no hurry to establish diplomatic relations with the United States. We adopt this policy in order to strip the United States of its political capital as much as possible and put it in a position of being unreasonable and isolated. You won't let us into the United Nations and won't establish diplomatic relations with us? Very well; the longer you drag it out, the more you will owe us. The longer you drag it out, the more unreasonable you become, and the more isolated you will be at home in the United States and in international public opinion. In Yan'an I once told an American: if your United States does not recognise this government of ours for a hundred years, I don't believe you still won't recognise it in the hundred-and-first year. Sooner or later the United States will establish diplomatic relations with us. When Americans come into China then and take a look, they will feel it is too late for regrets. Because this place, China, will have changed: the house will have been swept clean, the "four pests" eliminated, they won't find many friends any more, and scattering a few germs won't have much effect either.
After the Second World War the capitalist countries were very unstable, in disorder, with people uneasy. All the countries of the world were uneasy, China included. But we are, after all, a bit more at ease than they are. Study it and see: between the socialist countries and the imperialist countries, mainly the United States, who is actually afraid of whom? I say both are afraid. The question is who is more afraid of whom. My inclination is this: the imperialists are a bit more afraid of us. Making such an estimate may carry a danger, namely that everyone goes off to sleep and sleeps for three days without waking. Therefore we must always reckon with two possibilities. Besides the good possibility, there is also a bad possibility, namely that the imperialists will go mad. The imperialists harbour evil intentions and are always up to mischief. Of course, it is not so easy for the imperialists to fight a world war now; they have to consider what the result of fighting would be.
Now let me talk about Sino-Soviet relations. In my view there will always be wrangling; don't imagine there is no wrangling among communist parties. Where in the world is there no wrangling? Marxism is an ism of wrangling; it is about contradiction and struggle. Contradictions always exist, and where there are contradictions there is struggle. At present there are some contradictions between China and the Soviet Union. Their way of thinking about problems and doing things, their historical habits, are different from ours. Therefore we must do work on them. I have always said we must do work on comrades. Some people say, since we are all communists, we should all be equally good, so why do we still need to do work? Doing work means engaging in the united front, doing work on democratic personages; why do we still need to do work on Communist Party members? This view is wrong. There are still all kinds of different opinions inside the Communist Party. Some people have joined the Party organisationally but have not yet come round ideologically; even some veteran cadres do not speak the same language as us. Therefore we must often have heart-to-heart talks, consult individually or collectively, hold many meetings, and do the work of straightening out thinking.
As I see it, the situation is stronger than some people, even stronger than high officials. Under the pressure of the situation, those diehards in the Soviet Union who still want to go in for that great-power chauvinism will find it won't work. Our present policy is still to help them, and the method is to talk with them directly, face to face. When our delegation went to the Soviet Union this time, it poked through some issues with them. I said to Comrade Enlai over the telephone that these people have been blinded by gain, and the best way to deal with them is to give them a good tongue-lashing. What is this gain? Nothing more than fifty million tons of steel, four hundred million tons of coal and eighty million tons of oil. What does that amount to? That doesn't count for anything. Seeing this little bit of stuff, their heads swell right up — what kind of Communist Party members, what kind of Marxists are these! I say add ten times, a hundred times as much, and it still doesn't count. All you've done is dig a little bit of stuff out of the earth, turn it into steel, and make it into cars, aeroplanes and such; what's so wonderful about that! Yet you carry it on your back as such a huge burden that you disregard every revolutionary principle — if that isn't being blinded by gain, what is! Becoming a high official can also blind one with gain. Being first secretary is also a kind of gain, and it easily makes one's head dizzy. When the dizziness gets severe, one must use some method or other to give him a good tongue-lashing. This time Comrade Enlai was not polite in Moscow; he argued with them, and got them arguing too. That is good; get things straight face to face. They want to influence us, and we want to influence them. We didn't poke through everything either; we didn't use up all our magic weapons at once, we kept a handful in reserve. There will always be contradictions; for the present, so long as things are broadly passable, we can seek common ground while reserving differences, and leave the differences to be discussed in the future. If they insist on going on like this, one day everything will be poked through.
On our own side, we must not exaggerate in external propaganda. At all times we must be modest and prudent and keep our tails tucked in tighter. We must still learn from the Soviet Union, but learn selectively, learn advanced things, not backward things. For backward things there is another way of learning, namely not learning them. When we know about their mistakes, we can avoid making those mistakes. We must certainly learn whatever of theirs is useful to us. We must learn what is beneficial from all the countries of the world. Knowledge must be sought in every direction; seeking it in only one place makes it monotonous.
The fourth point: let a hundred flowers bloom, let a hundred schools of thought contend. This policy was put forward after the criticism of the Hu Feng counter-revolutionary clique. I think it is still correct; it is in keeping with dialectics.
On dialectics, Lenin said: "In brief, dialectics can be defined as the doctrine of the unity of opposites. This grasps the kernel of dialectics, but it requires explanation and development." Explanation and development — that is our job. We must explain; at present we explain too little. We must also develop; we have rich experience in revolution and should develop this doctrine. Lenin also said: "The unity (coincidence, identity, equilibrium) of opposites is conditional, temporary, transitory, relative. The struggle of mutually exclusive opposites is absolute, just as development and motion are absolute." Starting from this viewpoint, we put forward the policy of letting a hundred flowers bloom and a hundred schools of thought contend.
Truth develops by comparison with falsehood and in struggle against it. Beauty develops by comparison with ugliness and in struggle against it. So too with good and evil: good deeds and good people develop by comparison with evil deeds and evil people and in struggle against them. In short, fragrant flowers develop by comparison with poisonous weeds and in struggle against them. To forbid people to come face to face with falsehood, ugliness and hostile things, with idealism and metaphysics, with the things of Confucius, Laozi and Chiang Kai-shek — such a policy is a dangerous policy. It will lead to the decline of people's thinking, to one-track minds, people who cannot face the world and cannot stage a rival performance.
In philosophy, materialism and idealism are a unity of opposites; these two things struggle against each other. There are two other things, called dialectics and metaphysics, which are also a unity of opposites and struggle against each other. Whenever one talks philosophy, one cannot do without these two pairs. The Soviet Union now does not deal in pairs; it deals only in "individual households", saying only fragrant flowers are to bloom and no poisonous weeds, and it does not acknowledge the existence of idealism and metaphysics in socialist countries. In fact, every country has idealism, has metaphysics, has poisonous weeds. Many of the poisonous weeds in the Soviet Union appear in the name of fragrant flowers, and many of the strange arguments there wear the hat of materialism or socialist realism. We openly acknowledge the struggle between materialism and idealism, between dialectics and metaphysics, between fragrant flowers and poisonous weeds. This struggle must go on forever, advancing a step at each stage.
I advise the comrades present: if you understand materialism and dialectics, you still need to make up some study of their opposites, idealism and metaphysics. The books of Kant and Hegel, of Confucius and Chiang Kai-shek — these negative things need to be read. If you don't understand idealism and metaphysics and have never struggled against these negative things, your materialism and dialectics are not solid. The shortcoming of some of our Communist Party members and Communist Party intellectuals is precisely that they know too little about the negative things. Having read a few books by Marx, they just repeat them, which is rather monotonous. Their speeches and articles lack persuasiveness. If you don't study the negative things, you cannot refute them. Marx, Engels and Lenin were not like this. They worked hard to learn and study all kinds of things, contemporary and historical, and taught people to do the same. The three component parts of Marxism came into being in the course of studying bourgeois things — German classical philosophy, English classical economics and French utopian socialism — and struggling against them. Stalin was rather worse in this. For example, in his period German classical idealist philosophy was described as a reaction of the German aristocracy to the French Revolution. Drawing such a conclusion amounted to negating German classical idealist philosophy wholesale. He negated German military science, saying that since the Germans had been defeated, their military science could no longer be used, and Clausewitz's books should not be read either.
Stalin had a great deal of metaphysics, and taught many people to practise metaphysics. In the History of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Bolsheviks): Short Course he says that Marxist dialectics has four basic features. His first feature speaks of the interconnection of things, as if everything is connected for no reason at all. What, after all, is connected? It is the two opposing aspects that are connected. Everything has two opposing aspects. His fourth feature speaks of the internal contradictions of things, but speaks only of the struggle of opposites and not of the unity of opposites. According to the basic law of dialectics, the unity of opposites, opposites both struggle and are united, are both mutually exclusive and mutually connected, and under certain conditions transform into each other.
The entry on identity in the fourth edition of the Soviet Short Philosophical Dictionary reflects Stalin's view. The dictionary says: "Phenomena such as war and peace, the bourgeoisie and the proletariat, life and death, and so on, cannot be identical, because they are fundamentally opposed and mutually exclusive." That is to say, these fundamentally opposed phenomena have no Marxist identity; they are only mutually exclusive, not mutually connected, and cannot transform into each other under certain conditions. This view is fundamentally wrong.
In their view, war is war and peace is peace; the two are only mutually exclusive, without any connection; war cannot transform into peace and peace cannot transform into war. Lenin quoted Clausewitz's words: "War is the continuation of politics by other means." Struggle in peacetime is politics, and war is also politics, but using special means. War and peace are both mutually exclusive and mutually connected, and under certain conditions they transform into each other. If war is not brewing in peacetime, why does a war suddenly come? If peace is not brewing in the midst of war, why does peace suddenly come?
If life and death cannot transform into each other, then where, may I ask, did living things come from? Originally there were only non-living things on earth; living things came later, transformed from non-living, that is, dead, things. All living things have metabolism; they grow, reproduce and die. In the course of life activity, life and death are also constantly struggling against each other and transforming into each other.
If the bourgeoisie and the proletariat cannot transform into each other, why is it that through revolution the proletariat becomes the ruler and the bourgeoisie becomes the ruled? For example, we and Chiang Kai-shek's Kuomintang were fundamentally opposed. As a result of the two opposing sides struggling against and excluding each other, the positions of both us and the Kuomintang have changed: they went from rulers to ruled, and we went from ruled to rulers. The Kuomintang people who fled to Taiwan are no more than a tenth; nine-tenths remained on the mainland. Those who remained we are now remoulding; this is a unity of opposites under new circumstances. With that tenth who went to Taiwan, we are still in a unity of opposites, and we must also transform them through struggle.
Stalin could not connect this struggle and unity of opposites. The thinking of some people in the Soviet Union is metaphysics, rigid like that: either this or that, not acknowledging the unity of opposites. Therefore they make political mistakes. We adhere to the viewpoint of the unity of opposites and adopt the policy of letting a hundred flowers bloom and a hundred schools of thought contend. While fragrant flowers bloom, poisonous weeds are bound to come out as well. This is nothing to be afraid of, and under certain conditions it is even beneficial.
Some phenomena are unavoidable for a period, and once they have come out there are ways to deal with them. For example, in the past the repertoire was controlled very tightly; this could not be performed, that could not be performed. Now, with things opened up, The Black Basin, The Thunderbolt Retribution, all sorts of ox-demons and snake-spirits have run onto the stage. What about this phenomenon? I think it's good to let them run about a bit. Many people have never seen plays with ox-demons and snake-spirits; only when they see these ugly figures will they realise that things which should not be put on the stage have been put on. Then those plays can be criticised and reformed, or banned. Some people say certain local operas are bad and even local people oppose them. I think it's all right for such operas to be performed a little. Whether they can stand on their feet or not, and how many audiences they still have, let practice judge; don't be in a hurry to ban them.
We have now decided to expand the circulation of Reference News from two thousand copies to four hundred thousand, so that people both inside and outside the Party can read it. This is the Communist Party publishing a newspaper for the imperialists, printing even the reactionary statements that curse us. Why do this? The aim is to put poisonous weeds, non-Marxist and anti-Marxist things, in front of our comrades, in front of the masses and the democratic personages, so that they are tempered. Don't seal them off; sealing them off is actually dangerous. On this point our practice differs from the Soviet Union's. Why do we vaccinate against smallpox? It is to artificially put a virus into the human body, carrying out "germ warfare" to struggle against you, so that your body produces immunity. Publishing Reference News and other negative teaching material is "vaccination", strengthening the political immunity of cadres and masses.
Harmful statements must be promptly and forcefully refuted. For example, the article "On 'Unavoidable'" published in the People's Daily says that the mistakes in our work are not unavoidable, and that we use the word "unavoidable" to excuse the mistakes in our work. This is a harmful statement. It seems this article could have been left unpublished. Since it was to be published, there should have been preparations to refute it promptly, to stage a rival performance. In carrying out revolution and construction, we can hardly avoid making some mistakes; this has been proved by historical experience. The article "More on the Historical Experience of the Dictatorship of the Proletariat" is a big theory of the unavoidable. Which of our comrades wants to make mistakes? Mistakes are always recognised afterwards; at the start everyone thinks he is one hundred per cent Marxist. Of course, we should not think that, because mistakes are unavoidable, it doesn't matter if we make a few. But we must also acknowledge that it is truly impossible to make no mistakes in our work. The question is to make fewer of them and smaller ones.
Unhealthy tendencies in society must be beaten down. Whether in the Party, among democratic personages, or among young students, wherever there is an unhealthy tendency — that is, not the mistake of an individual but something that has become a trend — it must be beaten down. The way to beat it down is by reasoning. So long as it is persuasive, the unhealthy tendency can be beaten down. If it is not persuasive, and you just curse a few times, the unhealthy wind will blow harder and harder. On major questions, full preparations must be made, and when we are sure of ourselves, refutations with full persuasive power should be published. The secretaries must take charge of the newspapers personally and write articles personally.
Of the two mutually opposing and mutually struggling aspects of a unity, there is always a principal one and a secondary one. In our country of the dictatorship of the proletariat, poisonous weeds of course cannot be allowed to spread everywhere. Whether in the Party or in the ideological and literary and art circles, we must strive to ensure that what is principal and dominant is fragrant flowers, is Marxism. Poisonous weeds, non-Marxist and anti-Marxist things, can only be in a subordinate position. In a certain sense this can be compared to the relationship between the nucleus and the electrons in an atom. An atom has two parts: one is called the nucleus, the other the electrons. The nucleus is very small but very heavy. Electrons are very light; an electron is only about one eighteen-hundredth of the lightest nucleus. The nucleus can also be split, but it is held together rather firmly. The electrons are somewhat "liberal"; a few can run off, and a few more can come. The relationship between the nucleus and the electrons is also a unity of opposites, with a principal and a secondary. Seen from this viewpoint, letting a hundred flowers bloom and a hundred schools of thought contend is beneficial and harmless.
The fifth point: the question of disturbances. In a socialist society, disturbances by a small number of people are a new problem, well worth studying.
Things in society are always a unity of opposites. Socialist society is also a unity of opposites; there is the unity of opposites among the people, and the unity of opposites between ourselves and the enemy. The basic reason why small numbers of people still make trouble in our country is that there are still all kinds of opposing aspects in society — positive and negative — there are still opposing classes, opposing people, opposing opinions.
We have basically completed the socialist transformation of the ownership of the means of production, but there is still a bourgeoisie, there are still landlords and rich peasants, there are still local despots and counter-revolutionaries. They are dispossessed classes; we are now oppressing them, they harbour hatred in their hearts, and many of them will flare up whenever they get the chance. When the Hungarian incident happened, they hoped Hungary would be thrown into chaos and hoped China would best be thrown into chaos too. This is their class nature.
The strange arguments put out by some democratic personages and professors are also opposed to us. They talk idealism, we talk materialism. They say the Communist Party cannot run science, socialism has no superiority, co-operation is terrible; we say the Communist Party can run science, socialism has superiority, co-operation is excellent.
There are also quite a few people among the students who are opposed to us. Most of today's university students come from exploiting-class families, so it is not at all surprising that some of them oppose us. There are people like this in Beijing, in Shijiazhuang, and in other places too.
There are also people in society who curse our provincial Party committees as "stiff corpses". Are the provincial Party committees stiff corpses? I don't think our provincial Party committees are dead at all, so how can they be stiff? Cursing the provincial committees as "stiff corpses" and our saying that they are not stiff corpses — these too are opposed.
In our Party there are also all kinds of opposing opinions. For example, regarding the CPSU "Twentieth Congress" beating Stalin to death with one blow, there are two opposing opinions, against and for. Differing opinions within the Party arise all the time; no sooner are opinions in agreement than, a month or two later, new differing opinions come out.
In people's way of thinking, seeking truth from facts and subjectivism are opposed. I think there will be subjectivism in every year. Ten thousand years from now there won't be any subjectivism at all? I don't believe it.
A factory, a co-operative, a school, an organisation, a family — in short, anywhere and at any time, there are opposing aspects. Therefore disturbances by small numbers of people in society will occur every year.
Should we be afraid of disturbances or not? We communists have never been afraid of imperialism, of Chiang Kai-shek's Kuomintang, of the landlord class or of the bourgeoisie; now to be afraid of students making trouble, afraid of peasants making trouble in the co-operatives — that is rather strange! Only Duan Qirui was afraid of mass disturbances, and Chiang Kai-shek. Apart from them, some people in Hungary and the Soviet Union were afraid too. Towards disturbances by small numbers of people we should adopt an active attitude, not a passive one; that is, not be afraid, be prepared. There is no way out in being afraid. The more you fear, the more the ghosts come. Only by not being afraid of trouble and being mentally prepared can you avoid being put on the defensive. I think we should be prepared for big trouble. If you are prepared for big trouble, it may not come; if you are not prepared for big trouble, disturbances will come.
The development of things has only two possibilities, good and bad. On both international and domestic questions, we must reckon with two possibilities. You say this year will be peaceful; it may well be peaceful. But it is not good to base your work on such an estimate; you should plan on the basis of the worst. Internationally, the worst would be a world war and atom bombs being dropped. Domestically, the worst would be a big nationwide upheaval, a "Hungarian incident", with several million people rising up against us, occupying several hundred counties, and fighting their way to Beijing. At worst we would go back to Yan'an; that is where we came from. We have lived in Beijing for seven years; what if in the eighth year we were invited back to Yan'an? Would everyone just give up the ghost and weep bitterly? Of course, we have no plans now to go back to Yan'an, to "make a feint with the spear and turn the horse and ride off". At the time of the "Seventh Congress" I said we must reckon with seventeen difficulties, including a thousand li of barren land, great famine, nothing to eat, and the loss of all the county towns. Because we made such full estimates, we were always in the initiative. Now that we have won the country, we must still plan on the basis of the worst possibility.
Some disturbances by small numbers of people arise because of bureaucratism and subjectivism in the leadership, which have led to mistakes in political or economic policy. In other cases it is not that the policy was wrong but that the working method was wrong, too rigid. Another factor is the existence of counter-revolutionaries and bad elements. It is impossible to avoid disturbances by small numbers of people completely. This is another theory of the unavoidable. But so long as we do not make major mistakes of line, there will not be a big nationwide upheaval. Even if we made a major mistake of line and a nationwide upheaval occurred, I think it would quickly be quelled and the country would not perish. Of course, if we handled things badly, it is still quite possible that history would take a bit of a backward road, a bit of a regression. The 1911 Revolution took a backward road: the emperor was overthrown, and then there was an emperor again, then warlords. Revolution happens because there are problems, and after the revolution problems arise again. I believe that if there were a big nationwide upheaval, there would always be masses and their leaders to take the situation in hand, perhaps us, perhaps others. After such a big upheaval, once the abscess had burst, our country would only become more consolidated. China will always move forward.
As regards disturbances by small numbers of people, first, we do not encourage them; second, if people insist on making trouble, let them. Our Constitution provides for freedom of procession and demonstration; it does not provide for freedom to strike, but it does not prohibit it either, so striking does not violate the Constitution. If people want to strike or petition and you insist on stopping them, that is not good. I say, whoever wants to make trouble can make trouble, for as long as they want; if one month is not enough, then two months; in short, don't wind things up until they've had enough. If you are in a hurry to wind it up, one day they will make trouble again anyway. In schools where students make trouble, don't give them holidays; just have a real Battle of the Red Cliffs. What good does this do? It fully exposes the problems, makes clear what is right and wrong, lets everyone be tempered, and makes those who have no justification, those bad people, lose.
We must learn a kind of art of leadership: don't always keep things covered up. As soon as someone voices strange arguments, goes on strike, or petitions, you knock him back with one blow of the club, always feeling that this is something that should not exist in the world. If it should not exist, why does it exist? Evidently it is something that should exist. If you don't allow strikes, don't allow petitions, don't allow bad things to be said, and just keep suppressing, then at some point you will become a Rákosi. It is the same inside and outside the Party. All kinds of strange arguments, strange things and contradictions are better exposed. Contradictions must be exposed and resolved.
Disturbances must be handled according to several different situations. In one kind the trouble is justified; we should admit our mistakes and correct them. In another the trouble is not justified, and it must be rebuffed. If the trouble has reason, it ought to be made; if it has no reason, nothing will come of it. Then there is the kind where the trouble is partly right and partly wrong: we accept the right part and criticise the wrong part; we must not retreat step by step without principle and agree to every demand. Except for large-scale, genuine counter-revolutionary riots, which must be suppressed by armed force, we must not lightly use force, must not open fire. Duan Qirui's "March 18" massacre used the method of opening fire, and as a result he brought himself down. We must not learn Duan Qirui's methods.
With those who make trouble, we must do our work well, divide them, and distinguish the majority from the minority. The majority must be guided and educated well, so that they change step by step; do not hurt them. I think everywhere is small at both ends and big in the middle. We must win over the middle step by step, and then we will have the upper hand. Those who lead the disturbances must be analysed. Some people who dare to take the lead in making trouble may, after education, become useful talent. As for the small number of bad people, apart from those who have committed the most serious crimes, don't arrest them, don't lock them up, don't expel them either. Keep them in their original units, strip them of all their political capital, isolate them, and use them as teachers by negative example. That university student at Tsinghua who wanted to kill thousands and tens of thousands — when our Comrade Deng Xiaoping went to speak, he invited him to serve as a teacher. Someone like that, with no arms and no pistol — what are you afraid of him for? If you expel him in one go, your place becomes nice and clean. But it does not win people's hearts. Expelled from your place, he will find a job somewhere else. So hurrying to expel such people is not a good method. Such people represent the reactionary classes; it is not a question of individuals. Dealing with them simply is quick and neat, but their role as teachers by negative example is not used to the full. When university students in the Soviet Union made trouble, they just expelled a few ringleaders; they did not understand that bad things can be used as teaching material and put to our use. Of course, for the tiny minority who engage in counter-revolutionary riots like the Hungarian incident, dictatorship must be exercised.
As for the democratic personages, we should let them stage rival performances and give them a free hand to criticise. If we don't do this, we will be a bit like the Kuomintang. The Kuomintang was very afraid of criticism; every time the People's Political Council met, they were in fear and trembling. The criticisms of the democratic personages are of only two kinds: one is wrong, the other is not wrong. What is not wrong can make up for our shortcomings; what is wrong must be refuted. As for people like Liang Shuming, Peng Yihu and Zhang Naiqi, if they have farts let them fart; letting them out is advantageous, letting everyone take a sniff to see whether it is fragrant or stinking; through discussion we win over the majority and isolate them. If they want to make trouble, let them make trouble to their hearts' content. He who does much evil will come to destruction. The more wrong the things they say, the better; the bigger the mistakes they make, the better; that way they will be more isolated, and the better they will educate the people by negative example. Towards the democratic personages we must both unite and struggle, differentiating according to circumstances; with some we must take the initiative, with others we must let them expose themselves; we strike after they strike, not before.
The struggle against bourgeois ideology and the struggle against bad people and bad deeds are long-term, lasting several decades or even several centuries. The working class, the working people and the revolutionary intellectuals will gain experience and be tempered in the struggle, which is very beneficial.
Bad things have a dual nature: one aspect is bad, the other is good. Many comrades are still not clear about this. Bad things contain good factors. To see bad people and bad deeds only as bad is to look at problems one-sidedly and metaphysically, not dialectically; it is not the Marxist viewpoint. Bad people and bad deeds are bad on the one hand, but on the other hand have a good effect. For example, a bad person like Wang Ming plays the good role of a teacher by negative example. Likewise, good things contain bad factors. For example, the great victories of the seven years since liberation, and especially the great victories of last year, have made some comrades swell-headed and conceited, so that when suddenly a small number of people made trouble, they felt it was quite unexpected.
The fundamental reason for being both afraid of disturbances and handling them simplistically is that ideologically people do not acknowledge that socialist society is a unity of opposites, in which contradictions, classes and class struggle exist.
For a long time Stalin did not acknowledge the contradiction between the relations of production and the productive forces, or between the superstructure and the economic base, under the socialist system. Only in Economic Problems of Socialism in the USSR, written a year before his death, did he speak haltingly of the contradiction between the relations of production and the productive forces under the socialist system, saying that if policies were wrong and adjustments were not made well, problems would arise. But he still did not put forward the contradiction between the relations of production and the productive forces and the contradiction between the superstructure and the economic base under the socialist system as an overall question; he still did not recognise that these contradictions are the basic contradictions that drive socialist society forward. He thought that his realm was secure. We must not think that our realm is secure; it is both secure and not secure.
According to dialectics, just as man must die one day, the socialist system, as a historical phenomenon, must one day perish and be negated by the communist system. If one says that the socialist system will not perish, that the socialist relations of production and superstructure will not perish, then what kind of Marxism is that? Isn't that the same as religious dogma, the same as theology preaching that God does not perish?
How to handle contradictions between ourselves and the enemy and contradictions among the people in socialist society is a science, well worth studying properly. As regards the situation in our country, class struggle at present is in part contradictions between ourselves and the enemy, but mostly manifests itself as contradictions among the people. The present disturbances by small numbers of people reflect this situation. If the earth is destroyed ten thousand years from now, then at least within these ten thousand years there will still be the problem of disturbances. But we cannot concern ourselves with things as far off as ten thousand years; within the space of a few five-year plans we must seriously gain experience in handling this problem.
We must strengthen our work and correct our mistakes and shortcomings. What work must we strengthen? In industry, agriculture, commerce, education, the army, the government and the Party, political and ideological work must be strengthened. At present everyone is busy with professional work, with routine affairs — economic affairs, cultural and educational affairs, defence affairs, Party affairs — and not doing political and ideological work; that is very dangerous. Now our General Secretary, Comrade Deng Xiaoping, has gone personally to Tsinghua University to give a report, and I ask all of you to go out personally too. The leading comrades of the Central Committee and of the Party committees of the provinces, municipalities and autonomous regions must all personally go out and do political and ideological work. After the Second World War the Communist Party of the Soviet Union and the parties of some East European countries stopped talking about the basic principles of Marxism. Class struggle, the dictatorship of the proletariat, Party leadership, democratic centralism, the Party's ties with the masses — they stopped talking about all these, and the atmosphere grew thin. The result was the Hungarian incident. We must adhere to the basic theory of Marxism. Every province, municipality and autonomous region must get theoretical work going and train Marxist theorists and critics in a planned way.
Organisations must be streamlined. The state is an instrument of class struggle. A class is not the same as the state; the state is made up of a part (a minority) of the ruling class. Government offices do need some people, but the fewer the better. At present the state apparatus is huge, with a great many departments, and many people are squatting in the offices with nothing to do. This problem must be solved. First, staff must be reduced; second, appropriate arrangements must be made for those to be cut, so that they all have a real place to go. The Party, the government and the army must all do this.
We must go down to the lower levels to study problems. I hope that comrades of the Central Committee and the principal responsible comrades of the provinces, municipalities, autonomous regions and ministries will all do this. I hear that many responsible comrades no longer go down; that is not good. The central organs are very hard up; you can't pick up any knowledge at all in this place. Whatever knowledge you are looking for, you won't find it squatting in an office. The places that really produce knowledge are factories, co-operatives and shops. How to run a factory, how to run a co-operative, how to run a shop — these cannot be figured out in an office. The higher up you go, the less there is. To solve problems, you must go down yourself, or invite people from below to come up. If you neither go down nor invite people from below to come up, problems cannot be solved. I propose that secretaries of the Party committees of provinces, municipalities and autonomous regions concurrently serve as secretary of a county Party committee, or as secretary of the Party committee of a factory or school, and that prefectural and county Party secretaries also concurrently serve as secretary of a unit at a lower level. In this way they can gain experience and guide the whole.
We must maintain close ties with the masses. Being divorced from the masses, bureaucratism, will inevitably get you beaten. The leaders of Hungary did no investigation and study and did not understand the situation of the masses; when the big upheaval came, they still did not know where the cause lay. At present the leaders of some of our ministries and of the Party committees of some provinces, municipalities and autonomous regions do not understand the ideological trends of the masses; when people are brewing trouble, brewing riots, they have no idea at all, and when something happens they are caught off guard. We must take this as a warning. Comrades of the Central Committee and the principal responsible comrades of the provinces, municipalities, autonomous regions and ministries must spend some time each year going round grassroots units such as factories, co-operatives, shops and schools, carrying out investigation and study, finding out what the situation of the masses is, how many are advanced, intermediate and backward, and how well our mass work is being done, so as to have a clear picture. We must rely on the working class, rely on the poor peasants and lower-middle peasants, rely on the advanced elements; there must always be something to rely on. Only in this way is it possible to avoid an incident like Hungary's.
The sixth point: the question of the legal system. Three things: we must abide by the law, we must suppress counter-revolutionaries, and we must affirm the achievements in suppressing counter-revolutionaries.
We must abide by the law and must not undermine the revolutionary legal system. Law is part of the superstructure. Our laws are made by the working people themselves. They uphold revolutionary order, protect the interests of the working people, protect the socialist economic base, and protect the productive forces. We require everyone to abide by the revolutionary legal system; it is not only you democratic personages who are required to abide by the law.
We must suppress counter-revolutionaries. Those who have not completed their plans for suppressing counter-revolutionaries must complete them this year, and if a bit of tail is left over, it must be completed next year. Some units have carried out the suppression of counter-revolutionaries, but have not cleaned them out completely; they must be cleaned out step by step through struggle. There are not many counter-revolutionaries left; this must be affirmed. In places where there is trouble, the broad masses will not follow the counter-revolutionaries; those who follow the counter-revolutionaries are only a part and only temporarily. At the same time it must also be affirmed that there are still counter-revolutionaries and the work of suppressing them is not finished.
We must affirm the achievements in suppressing counter-revolutionaries. The achievements in suppressing counter-revolutionaries are great. There have been mistakes too, and of course they must be treated seriously. We must back up the cadres who do the work of suppressing counter-revolutionaries, and must not go soft just because some democratic personages curse. If you curse every day, with nothing else to do after eating but cursing people, that's up to you. I say the more cursing the better; the three things I have said can never be cursed down.
Who knows how much cursing the Communist Party has taken. The Kuomintang cursed us as "communist bandits", and anyone who had dealings with us was said to be "colluding with bandits". In the end the "bandits" turned out better than they, the non-"bandits". Since ancient times no advanced thing has been welcomed at the start; it always gets cursed. Marxism and the Communist Party were cursed from the very beginning. Ten thousand years from now, advanced things will still be cursed at the start.
The suppression of counter-revolutionaries must be persisted in; wherever there are counter-revolutionaries they must be suppressed. The legal system must be observed. Acting according to law does not mean having one's hands and feet tied. Not suppressing counter-revolutionaries when they exist, having one's hands and feet tied, is wrong. We must act boldly and freely in accordance with the law.
The seventh point: the agricultural question. We must strive for a good harvest this year. If there is a good harvest this year, people's minds can be set at ease and the co-operatives can be fairly well consolidated. In the Soviet Union and in some East European countries, when they carried out co-operation, grain output always fell for a number of years. We have carried out co-operation for a few years, and did it on a big scale last year, and not only did output not fall, it actually rose. If there is another good harvest this year, it will be unprecedented in the history of co-operation and in the history of the international communist movement.
The whole Party must attach importance to agriculture. Agriculture has an enormous bearing on the national economy and the people's livelihood; great attention must be paid to it. Not taking hold of grain is very dangerous. If we do not take hold of grain, one day there will be great chaos under heaven.
First, agriculture bears on the question of food for the rural population of five hundred million, the question of eating meat and oil, and the question of other non-commodity agricultural products for daily use. The part the peasants supply for themselves is enormous in quantity. For example, last year more than 360 billion jin of grain was produced; commodity grain, including the public grain tax, was about 80-odd billion jin, less than a quarter, and more than three-quarters went to the peasants. If agriculture is done well and the peasants can supply themselves, five hundred million people are stabilised.
Second, agriculture also bears on the question of food for the population of the cities and industrial and mining areas. Only when commodity agricultural products have developed can the needs of the industrial population be supplied and industry be developed. On the basis of developing agricultural production, the commodity rate of agricultural products, especially grain, must be raised step by step. With food to eat, we needn't fear a small number of people making trouble in schools and factories.
Third, agriculture is the main source of raw materials for light industry, and the countryside is an important market for light industry. Only when agriculture has developed can light industry obtain sufficient raw materials and light industrial products find a broad market.
Fourth, the countryside is also an important market for heavy industry. For example, chemical fertiliser, all kinds of agricultural machinery, and part of the electric power, coal and oil are supplied to the countryside, and railways, highways and large water conservancy projects also serve agriculture. We have now established a socialist agricultural economy, and whether for developing light industry or heavy industry, the countryside is an enormous market.
Fifth, at present our export goods are mainly agricultural products. Agricultural products are turned into foreign exchange, with which all kinds of industrial equipment can be imported.
Sixth, agriculture is an important source of accumulation. When agriculture develops, it can provide more funds for developing industry.
Therefore, in a certain sense it can be said that agriculture is industry. Industrial departments must be persuaded to face the countryside and support agriculture. To carry out industrialisation well, this is what must be done.
What is the best proportion, within co-operative income, between agriculture's own accumulation and the accumulation the state obtains from agriculture? Please study this, and discuss and arrive at an appropriate proportion. The aim is to enable agriculture to carry out expanded reproduction, so that as a market for industry it becomes bigger and as a source of accumulation it provides more. First let agriculture itself accumulate more; only then can it accumulate more for industry. Accumulating only for industry, with agriculture itself accumulating too little or nothing at all, is draining the pond to catch the fish, and is in fact unfavourable to the development of industry.
Attention must also be paid to the proportion between the co-operatives' accumulation and the members' income. The co-operatives must use the law of value for economic accounting, must run the co-operatives diligently and thriftily, and increase accumulation little by little. If there is a good harvest this year, accumulation should be a bit more than last year, but not too much; let the peasants first eat a bit more of their fill. In a good harvest year accumulate a bit more; in a disaster year or half-disaster year accumulate nothing or a bit less. That is, accumulation goes in waves, or one could say in spirals. Because all things in the world are contradictory, are unities of opposites, their motion and development all go in waves. The light coming from the sun is called light waves; what radio stations send out is called electric waves; the transmission of sound is called sound waves. Water has water waves, heat has heat waves. In a certain sense walking also goes in waves; walking step by step is going in waves. Singing opera also goes in waves; you finish one line before singing the second, nobody sings seven or eight lines in one breath. Writing also goes in waves; you finish one character before writing the next, you cannot write several hundred characters in a single stroke. This is the tortuousness of the contradictory motion of things.
In short, we must act according to dialectics. This is what Comrade Deng Xiaoping said. I think the whole Party must study dialectics and advocate acting according to dialectics. The whole Party must pay attention to ideological and theoretical work, build up a contingent of Marxist theorists, and strengthen the study and propagation of Marxist theory. We must use the Marxist doctrine of the unity of opposites to observe and handle the new problems of class contradictions and class struggle in socialist society, and to observe and handle the new problems in the international struggle.
The original Chinese. The tags above are read on the English translation's sentences.
一 一月十八日的讲话
这次会议,要讨论的问题主要是三个:思想动向问题,农村问题,经济问题。今天我讲一讲思想动向问题。
思想动向问题,我们应当抓住。这里当作第一个问题提出来。现在,党内的思想动向,社会上的思想动向,出现了很值得注意的问题。
有一种问题是我们自己家里出的。比如,现在有些干部争名夺利,唯利是图。在评级过程中,有那样的人,升了一级不够,甚至升了两级还躺在床上哭鼻子,大概要升三级才起床。他这么一闹,就解决了一个问题,什么干部评级,根本不评了,工资大体平均、略有差别就是了。以前北洋军阀政府里有个内阁总理,叫唐绍仪,后头当了广东中山县的县长。旧社会的一个内阁总理可以去当县长,为什么我们的部长倒不能去当县长?我看,那些闹级别,升得降不得的人,在这一点上,还不如这个旧官僚。他们不是比艰苦,比多做工作少得享受,而是比阔气,比级别,比地位。这类思想在党内现在有很大的发展,值得我们注意。
农业合作化究竟是有希望,还是没有希望?是合作社好,还是个体经济好?,这个问题也重新提出来了。去年这一年,丰收的地方没有问题,重灾区也没有问题,就是那种灾而不重、收而不丰的合作社发生了问题。这类合作社,工分所值,原先许的愿大了,后头没有那么多,社员收入没有增加,甚至还有减少。于是议论就来了:合作社还好不好,要不要?这种议论也反映到党内的一些干部中间。有些干部说,合作社没有什么优越性。有些部长到乡下去看了一下,回到北京后,放的空气不妙,说是农民无精打采,不积极耕种了,似乎合作社大有崩溃灭亡之势。有些合作社社长抬不起头来,到处挨骂,上面批评,报纸上也批评。有些党委的宣传部长不敢宣传合作社的优越性。农业部的部长廖鲁言,又是党中央农村工作部的副部长,据他讲,他自己泄了气,他下面的负责干部也泄了气,横直是不行了,农业发展纲要四十条也不算数了。泄了气怎么办?这个事情好办,你没有气,给你打点气就是了。现在报纸上的宣传转了一下,大讲合作社的优越性,专讲好话,不讲坏话,搞那么几个月,鼓一点气。
前年反右倾,去年反“冒进”,反“冒进”的结果又出了个右倾。我说的这个右倾,是指在社会主义革命问题上,主要是在农村社会主义改造问题上的右倾。我们的干部中间刮起了这么一股风,象台风一样,特别值得注意。我们的部长、副部长、司局长和省一级的干部中,相当一部分人,出身于地主、富农和富裕中农家庭,有些人的老太爷是地主,现在还没有选举权。这些干部回到家里去,家里人就讲那么一些坏话,无非是合作社不行,长不了。富裕中农是一个动摇的阶层,他们的单干思想现在又在抬头,有些人想退社。我们干部中的这股风,反映了这些阶级和阶层的思想。
合作化一定能化好,但是一两年内不可能完全化好。要向党、政、军、民各界的同志们讲清楚。合作社只有这么一点历史,大多数合作社只有一年到一年半的历史,经验很少。搞了一辈子革命的人还会犯错误,人家只搞了一年到一年半,你怎么能要求他一点错误都不犯呢?一有点风,有点雨,就说合作化不行了,这种思想本身就是个大错误。事实上,多数合作社是办得好的和比较好的。只要拿出一个办得好的合作社,就可以把反对合作化的一切怪论打下去。为什么这个社能办好,别的社就不能办好?为什么这个社有优越性,别的社就没有优越性?你就到处大讲这个社的经验。一个省总可以找出这样一个典型嘛!要找那个条件最差,地势不好,过去产量很低,很穷的社,不要找那个本来条件就好的社。当然,你搞几十个也可以,但是,你只要搞好一个,就算胜利。
在学校里头也出了问题,好些地方学生闹事。石家庄一个学校,有一部分毕业生暂时不能就业,学习要延长一年,引起学生不满。少数反革命分子乘机进行煽动,组织示威游行,说是要夺取石家庄广播电台,宣布来一个“匈牙利”。他们贴了好多标语,其中有这样三个最突出的口号:“打倒法西斯!”“要战争不要和平!”“社会主义没有优越性!”照他们讲来,共产党是法西斯,我们这些人都要打倒。他们提出的口号那样反动,工人不同情,农民不同情,各方面的群众都不同情。北京清华大学,有个学生公开提出:“总有一天老子要杀几千几万人就是了!”百花齐放、百家争鸣一来,这一“家”也出来了。邓小平同志去这个大学讲了一次话,他说,你要杀几千几万人,我们就要专政。
我们高等学校的学生,据北京市的调查,大多数是地主、富农、资产阶级以及富裕中农的子弟,工人阶级、贫下中农出身的还不到百分之二十。全国恐怕也差不多。这种情况应当改变,但是需要时间。在一部分大学生中间,哥穆尔卡很吃得开,铁托、卡德尔也很吃得开。倒是乡下的地主、富农,城市里的资本家、民主党派,多数还比较守规矩,他们在波兰、匈牙利闹风潮的时候还没有闹乱子,没有跳出来说要杀几千几万人。对于他们的这个守规矩,应当有分析。因为他们没有本钱了,工人阶级、贫下中农不听他们的,他们脚底下是空的。如果天下有变,一个原子弹把北京、上海打得稀烂,这些人不起变化呀?那就难说了。那时,地主,富农,资产阶级,民主党派,都要分化。他们老于世故,许多人现在隐藏着。他们的子弟,这些学生娃娃们,没有经验,把什么“要杀几千几万人”、什么“社会主义没有优越性”这些东西都端出来了。
在一些教授中,也有各种怪议论,不要共产党呀,共产党领导不了他呀,社会主义不好呀,如此等等。他们有这么一些思想,过去没有讲,百家争鸣,让他们讲,这些话就出来了。电影《武训传》,你们看了没有?那里头有一枝笔,几丈长,象征“文化人”,那一扫可厉害啦。他们现在要出来,大概是要扫我们了。是不是想复辟?
去年这一年,国际上闹了几次大风潮。苏共二十次代表大会大反斯大林,这以后,帝国主义搞了两次反共大风潮,国际共产主义运动中也有两次大的辩论风潮。在这几次风潮中,欧洲美洲有些党受的影响和损失相当大,东方各国的党受的影响和损失比较小。苏共“二十大”一来,有些从前拥护斯大林非常积极的人,这时候也反得很积极。我看这些人不讲马克思列宁主义,对问题不作分析,也缺乏革命道德。马克思列宁主义也包括无产阶级的革命道德。你从前那么拥护,现在总要讲一点理由,才能转过这个弯来吧!理由一点不讲,忽然转这么一百八十度,好象老子从来就是不拥护斯大林的,其实从前是很拥护的。斯大林问题牵涉整个国际共产主义运动,各国党都牵涉到了。
对苏共“二十大”,我们党内绝大多数干部是不满意的,认为整斯大林整得太过了。这是一种正常的情绪,正常的反映。但是,也有少数人起了波动。每逢台风一来,下雨之前,蚂蚁就要出洞,它们“鼻子”很灵,懂得气象学。苏共“二十大”的台风一刮,中国也有那么一些蚂蚁出洞。这是党内的动摇分子,一有机会他们就要动摇。他们听了把斯大林一棍子打死,舒服得很,就摇过去,喊万岁,说赫鲁晓夫一切都对,老子从前就是这个主张。后头帝国主义几棍子,国际共产主义运动内部几棍子,连赫鲁晓夫的腔调都不得不有所改变,他们又摇过来了。大势所趋,不摇过来不行。墙上一南草,风吹两边倒。摇过来不是本心,摇过去才是本心。党内党外那些捧波、匈事件的人捧得好呀!开口波兹南,闭口匈牙利。这一下就露出头来了,蚂蚁出洞了,乌龟王八都出来了。他们随着哥穆尔卡的棍子转,哥穆尔卡说大民主,他们也说大民主。现在情况起了变化,他们不吭声了。不吭声不是本心,本心还是要吭声的。
台风一刮,动摇分子挡不住,就要摇摆,这是规律。我劝大家注意这个问题。有些人摇那么几次,取得了经验,就不摇了。有那么一种人,是永远要摇下去的,就象稻子那一类作物,因为秆子细,风一吹就要摇。高粱、玉米比较好些,秆子比较粗。只有大树挺立不拔。台风年年都有,国内国际的思想台风、政治台风也是年年都有。这是一种社会的自然现象。政党就是一种社会,是一种政治的社会。政治社会的第一类就是党派。党是阶级的组织。我们中国共产党是无产阶级政党,主要是由工人和半无产阶级的贫农出身的人组成的。但是,也有许多党员是地主、富农、资本家家庭出身,或者是富裕中农和城市小资产阶级出身。他们中间有相当多的人,虽然艰苦奋斗多少年,有所锻炼,但是马克思主义学得不多,在思想方面,精神方面,还是跟稻子一样,风一吹就要摇。
有些党员,过去各种关都过了,就是社会主义这一关难过。有这样典型的人,薛迅就是一个。她原来是河北省的省委副书记、副省长。她是什么时候动摇的呢?就是在开始实行统购统销的时候。统购统销是实行社会主义的一个重要步骤。她却坚决反对,无论如何要反对。还有一个,就是全国供销合作总社副主任孟用潜。他上书言事,有信一封,也坚决反对统购统销。实行农业合作化,党内也有人起来反对。总而言之,党内有这样的高级干部,他们过不了社会主义这一关,是动摇的。这类事情结束没有呢?没有。是不是十年以后这些人就坚定起来,真正相信社会主义呢?那也不一定。十年以后,遇到出什么问题,他们还可能说,我早就料到了的。
发给同志们一个材料,是反映某些军队干部的思想动向的。这些干部的意见中虽然有某些合理的部分,比如说有些干部的工资太高,农民看不惯,但是,他们的意见总的方向不妥,根本路线不对。他们批评我们党的政策是农村“左”了,城市右了。中国虽然有九百六十万平方公里,但是合共只有两块地方,一块叫农村,一块叫城市。照他们这一讲,都错了。
所谓农村政策“左”了,就是说农民收入不多,比工人少。这要有分析,不能光看收入。工人收入一般是比农民多,但是他们生产的价值比农民大,生活必需的支出也比农民多。农民生活的改善,主要依靠农民自己努力发展生产。政府也大力帮助农民,比如兴修水利,发放农贷,等等。我们的农业税,包括副业的税收,约占农民生产总值的百分之八,很多副业没有抽税。我们统购粮食,是按照正常的价格。国家在工业品和农业品交换中间从农民那里得到的利润也很少。我们没有苏联那种义务交售制度。我们对于工农业产品的交换是缩小剪刀差,而不是象苏联那样扩大剪刀差。我们的政策跟苏联大不相同。所以,不能说我们的农村政策“左”了。
在我们军队的高级干部中间,有些人可能是自己回家,或者是接了亲属来,听到富裕中农、富农、地主的那些话,受了触动,于是就替农民叫苦。一九五五年上半年,党内有相当多的人替农民叫苦,跟梁漱溟之流相呼应,好象只有他们这两部分人才代表农民,才知道农民的疾苦。至于我们党中央,在他们”看来,那是不代表农民的,省委也是不代表的,党员的大多数都是不代表的。江苏作了一个调查,有的地区,县区乡三级干部中间,有百分之三十的人替农民叫苦。后头一查,这些替农民叫苦的人,大多数是家里比较富裕,有余粮出卖的人。这些人的所谓“苦”,就是有余粮。所谓“帮助农民”、“关心农民”,就是有余粮不要卖给国家。这些叫苦的人到底代表谁呢?他们不是代表广大农民群众,而是代表少数富裕农民。
至于说城市政策右了,看起来也有点象,因为我们把资本家包了下来,还给他们七年的定息。七年以后怎么办?到时候还要看。最好留个尾巴,还给点定息。出这么一点钱,就买了这样一个阶级。这个政策,中央是仔细考虑过的。资本家加上跟他们有联系的民主人士和知识分子,文化技术知识一般比较高。我们把这个阶级买过来,剥夺他们的政治资本,使他们无话可讲。剥的办法,一个是出钱买,一个是安排,给他们事做。这样,政治资本就不在他们手里,而在我们手里。我们要把他们的政治资本剥夺干净,没有剥夺干净的还要剥。所以,也不能说我们的城市政策右了。
我们的农村政策是正确的,我们的城市政策也是正确的。所以,象匈牙利事件那样的全国性大乱子闹不起来。无非是少数人这里闹一下,那里闹一下,要搞所谓大民主。大民主也没有什么可怕。在这个问题上,我跟你们不同,你们有些同志好象很怕。我说来一个大民主,第一不怕,第二要加以分析,看他讲什么,做什么。那些坏人在搞所谓大民主的时候,一定要做出错误的行动,讲出错误的话,暴露和孤立他们自己。“杀几千几万人”,是解决人民内部矛盾的方法吗?能得到大多数人同情吗?“打倒法西斯”,“社会主义没有优越性”,这不是公然违反宪法吗?共产党和共产党领导的政权是革命的,社会主义有优越性,这都是宪法里头讲了的,是全国人民公认的。“要战争不要和平”,那好呀!你来号召战争,统共那么几个人,你的兵就不够,军官也没有训练好。这些娃娃们发疯了!石家庄那个学校,把那三个口号一讨论,七十个代表,只有十几个人赞成,有五十几个人反对。然后,又把这几个口号拿到四千学生里头去讨论,结果都不赞成,这十几个人就孤立了。提出和坚持这几个口号的极反动分子,只有几个人。他们不搞什么大民主,不到处贴标语,还不晓得他们想干什么。他们一搞大民主,尾巴就被抓住了。匈牙利事件的一个好处,就是把我们中国的这些蚂蚁引出了洞。
在匈牙利,大民主一来,把党政军都搞垮了。在中国,这一条是不会发生的。几个学生娃娃一冲,党政军就全部瓦解,那除非我们这些人完全是饭桶。所以,不要怕大民主。出了乱子,那个脓包就好解决了,这是好事。帝国主义,我们从前不怕,现在也不怕。我们也从来不怕蒋介石。现在怕大民主?我看不要怕。如果有人用什么大民主来反对社会主义制度,推翻共产党的领导,我们就对他们实行无产阶级专政。
在知识分子问题上,现在有一种偏向,就是重安排不重改造,安排很多,改造很少。百花齐放、百家争鸣一来,不敢去改造知识分子了。我们敢于改造资本家,为什么对知识分子和民主人士不敢改造呢?
百花齐放,我看还是要放。有些同志认为,只能放香花,不能放毒草。这种看法,表明他们对百花齐放、百家争鸣的方针很不理解。一般说来,反革命的言论当然不让放。但是,它不用反革命的面貌出现,而用革命的面貌出现,那就只好让它放,这样才有利于对它进行鉴别和斗争。田里长着两种东西,一种叫粮食,一种叫杂草。杂草年年要锄,一年要锄几次。你说只要放香花,不要放毒草,那就等于要田里只能长粮食,不能长一根草。话尽管那样讲,凡是到田里看过的都知道,只要你不去动手锄,草实际上还是有那么多。杂草有个好处,翻过来就是肥料。你说它没有用?可以化无用为有用。农民需要年年跟田里的杂草作斗争,我们党的作家、艺术家、评论家、教授,也需要年年跟思想领域的杂草作斗争。所谓锻炼出来的,就是奋斗出来的。你草长,我就锄。这个对立面是不断出现的。杂草一万年还会有,所以我们也要准备斗争一万年。
总而言之,去年这一年是多事之秋,国际上是赫鲁晓夫、哥穆尔卡闹风潮的一年,国内是社会主义改造很激烈的一年。现在还是多事之秋,各种思想还要继续暴露出来,希望同志们注意。
二 一月二十七日的讲话
现在,我讲几点意见。
第一点,要足够地估计成绩。我们的革命和建设,成绩是主要的,缺点错误也有。有那么多成绩,夸大是不行的,但是估低了就要犯错误,可能要犯大错误。这个问题,本来八届二中全会已经解决了,这次会上还多次谈到,可见在一些同志思想上还没有解决。特别在民主人士里头有一种议论:“你们总是讲成绩是基本的,这不解决问题。谁不知道成绩是基本的,还有缺点错误呀!”但是,确实成绩是基本的。不肯定这一点,就泄气。对合作化就有泄气之事嘛!
第二点,统筹兼顾,各得其所。这是我们历来的方针。在延安的时候,就采取这个方针。一九四四年八月,《大公报》作社评一篇,说什么不要“另起炉灶”。重庆谈判期间,我对《大公报》的负责人讲,你那个话我很赞成,但是蒋委员长要管饭,他不管我们的饭,我不另起炉灶怎么办?那个时候,我们向蒋介石提出的一个口号,就是要各得其所。现在是我们管事了。我们的方针就是统筹兼顾,各得其所。包括把国民党留下来的军政人员都包下来,连跑到台湾去的也可以回来。对反革命分子,凡是不杀的,都加以改造,给生活出路。民主党派保留下来,长期共存,对它的成员给予安排。总而言之,全国六亿人口,我们统统管着。比如统购统销,一切城市人口和农村里头的缺粮户,我们都管。又比如城市青年,或者进学校,或者到农村去,或者到工厂去,或者到边疆去,总要有个安排。对那些全家没有人就业的,还要救济,总以不饿死人为原则。所有这些,都是统筹兼顾。这是一个什么方针呢?就是调动一切积极力量,为了建设社会主义。这是一个战略方针。实行这样一个方针比较好,乱子出得比较少。这种统筹兼顾的思想,要向大家说清楚。
柯庆施同志讲,要想尽一切办法。这个话很好,就是要想尽一切办法解决困难。这个口号应当宣传。我们现在遇到的困难不算很大,有什么了不起呀!比起万里长征,爬雪山过草地,总要好一点吧。长征途中,在过了大渡河以后,究竟怎么走呢?北面统是高山,人口又很少,我们那个时候提出要千方百计克服困难。什么叫千方百计呢?千方者,就是九百九十九方加一方,百计者,就是九十九计加一计。现在你们还没有提出几个方几个计来。各省、中央各部究竟有多少方多少计呀?只要想尽一切办法,困难是可以解决的。
第三点,国际问题。在中东,出了一个苏伊士运河事件。一个人,叫纳赛尔,把运河收归国有了;另外一个人,叫艾登,出一支兵去打;接着,第三个人,叫艾森豪威尔威尔,要赶走英国人,把这个地方霸起来。英国资产阶级历来老奸巨猾,是最善于在适当的时候作出妥协的一个阶级。现在它把中东搞到美国人手里去了。这个错误可大啦!这样的错误,在它历史上数得出多少呀?这一回为什么冲昏头脑犯这个错误呢?因为美国压得太凶,它沉不住气,想把中东夺回去,阻止美国。英国的矛头主要是对埃及的吗?不是。英国的文章是对付美国的,美国是对付英国的。
从这个事件可以看出当前世界斗争的重点。当然,帝国主义国家跟社会主义国家的矛盾是很厉害的矛盾,但是,他们现在是假借反共产主义之名来争地盘。争什么地盘呢?争亚洲非洲十亿人口的地盘。目前他们的争夺集中在中东这个具有重大战略意义的地区,特别是埃及苏伊士运河地区。在那里冲突的,有两类矛盾和三种力量。两类矛盾,一类是帝国主义跟帝国主义之间的矛盾,即美国跟英国、美国跟法国之间的矛盾,一类是帝国主义跟被压迫民族之间的矛盾。三种力量,第一种是最大的帝国主义美国,第二种是二等帝国主义英、法,第三种就是被压迫民族。现在帝国主义争夺的主要场所是亚洲非洲。在这些地区都出现了民族独立运动。美国采用的办法,有文的,也有武的,在中东就是这样。
他们闹,对我们有利。我们的方针应当是,把社会主义国家巩固起来,寸土不让。谁要我们让,就一定要跟他斗争。出了这个范围,让他们去闹。那末,我们要不要讲话呢?我们是要讲话的。对亚洲、非洲、拉丁美洲人民的反帝斗争,对各国人民的革命斗争,我们就是要支持。
帝国主义国家和我们之间,是你中有我,我中有你。我们支持他们那里的人民革命,他们在我们这里搞颠覆活动。他们里头有我们的人,就是那里的共产党,革命的工人、农民、知识分子,进步人士。我们里头有他们的人,拿中国来说,就是资产阶级中间和民主党派中间的许多人,还有地主阶级。现在这些人看起来还听话,还没有闹事。但是假使原子弹打到北京来了,他们怎么样?不造反呀?那就大成问题了。至于那些劳改犯,石家庄那个学校闹事的领袖人物,北京那个要杀几千几万人的大学生,就更不用说了。我们一定要把他们消化掉,要把地主、资本家改造成为劳动者,这也是一条战略方针。消灭阶级,要很长的时间。
总之,对于国际问题的观察,我们认为还是这样:帝国主义之间闹,互相争夺殖民地,这个矛盾大些。他们是假借跟我们的矛盾来掩盖他们之间的矛盾。我们可以利用他们的矛盾,这里很有文章可做。这是关系我们对外方针的一件大事。
讲一讲中美关系。我们在会上印发了艾森豪威尔威尔给蒋介石的信。我看这封信主要是给蒋介石泼冷水,然后又打点气。信上说需要冷静,不要冲动,就是说不要打仗,要靠联合国。这是泼冷水。蒋介石就是有那么一点冲动。打气,就是说要对共产党继续采取强硬的政策,还把希望寄托在我们出乱子上。在他看来,乱子已经出了,共产党是没有办法阻止它的。各有各的观察吧!
我还是这样看,迟几年跟美国建立外交关系为好。这比较有利。苏联跟美国建交,是在十月革命之后十七年。一九二九年爆发世界经济危机,持续到一九三三年。这一年,德国是希特勒上台,美国是罗斯福上台,这个时候,苏美才建交。我们跟美国建交,可能要在第三个五年计划完成以后,也就是说,要经过十八年或者更长的时间。我们也不急于进联合国,就同我们不急于跟美国建交一样。我们采取这个方针,是为了尽量剥夺美国的政治资本,使它处于没有道理和孤立的地位。不要我们进联合国,不跟我们建交,那末好吧,你拖的时间越长,欠我们的账就越多。越拖越没有道理,在美国国内,在国际舆论上,你就越孤立。我在延安就跟一个美国人讲过,你美国一百年不承认我们这个政府,一百零一年你还不承认,我就不信。总有一天,美国要跟我们建交。那时美国人跑进中国来一看,就会感到后悔无及。因为中国这个地方变了,房子打扫干净了,“四害”也除了,他们再找不到多少朋友了,散布一点细菌也没有多大作用了。
第二次世界大战以后,资本主义各国很不稳定,乱,人心不安。世界各国都不安,中国也在内。但是,我们总比他们安一点。你们研究一下看,在社会主义国家和帝国主义国家主要是美国之间,究竟谁怕谁?我说都怕。问题是谁怕谁多一点?我有这么一个倾向:帝国主义怕我们多一点。作这样的估计也许有个危险,就是大家都睡觉去了,一睡三天不醒。因此,总要估计到有两种可能性。除了好的可能性,还有一种坏的可能性,就是帝国主义要发疯。帝国主义是不怀好心的,总是要捣鬼的。当然,现在帝国主义要打世界大战也不那么容易,打起来的结果如何,他们要考虑。
再讲一讲中苏关系。我看总是要扯皮的,不要设想共产党之间就没有皮扯。世界上哪有不扯皮的?马克思主义就是个扯皮的主义,就是讲矛盾讲斗争的。矛盾是经常有的,有矛盾就有斗争。现在中苏之间就有那么一些矛盾。他们想问题做事情的方法,他们的历史习惯,跟我们不同。因此,要对他们做工作。我历来说,对同志要做工作。有人说,既然都是共产党员,就应当一样好,为什么还要做工作呀?做工作就是搞统一战线,做民主人士的工作,为什么还要做共产党员的工作呀?这种看法不对。共产党里头还是有各种不同的意见。有些人组织上进了党,思想上还没有通,甚至有些老干部跟我们的语言也不一致。所以,经常要谈心,要个别商谈或者集体商谈,要开多少次会,做打通思想的工作。
据我看,形势比一些人强,甚至比大官强。在形势的压迫下,苏联那些顽固分子还要搞大国沙文主义那一套,行不通了。我们目前的方针,还是帮助他们,办法就是同他们当面直接讲。这次我们的代表团到苏联去,就给他们捅穿了一些问题。我在电话里跟恩来同志说,这些人利令智昏,对他们的办法,最好是臭骂一顿。什么叫利呢?无非是五千万吨钢,四亿吨煤,八千万吨石油。这算什么?这叫不算数。看见这么一点东西,就居然胀满了一脑壳,这叫什么共产党员,什么马克思主义者!我说再加十倍,加一百倍,也不算数。你无非是在地球上挖了那么一点东西,变成钢材,做成汽车飞机之类,这有什么了不起!可是你把它当作那么大的包袱背在背上,什么革命原则都不顾了,这还不叫利令智昏!官做大了也可以利令智昏。当了第一书记,也是一种利,也容易使头脑发昏。昏得厉害的时候,就得用一种什么办法去臭骂他一顿。这回恩来同志在莫斯科就不客气了,跟他们抬杠子了,搞得他们也抬了。这样好,当面扯清楚。他们想影响我们,我们想影响他们。我们也没有一切都捅穿,法宝不一次使用干净,手里还留了一把。矛盾总是有的,目前只要大体过得去,可以求同存异,那些不同的将来再讲。如果他们硬是这样走下去,总有一天要统统捅出来。
在我们自己方面,对外宣传不要夸大。无论什么时候,都要谦虚谨慎,把尾巴夹紧一些。对苏联的东西还是要学习,但要有选择地学,学先进的东西,不是学落后的东西。对落后的东西是另一种学法,就是不学。他错误的东西,我们知道了,就可以避免犯那个错误。他那些对我们有用的东西一定要学。世界上所有国家的有益的东西,我们都要学。找知识要到各方面去找,只到一个地方去找,就单调了。
第四点,百花齐放,百家争鸣。这个方针,是在批判了胡风反革命集团之后提出来的,我看还是对的,是合乎辩证法的。
关于辩证法,列宁说过:“可以把辩证法简要地确定为关于对立统一的学说。这样就会抓住辩证法的核心,可是这需要解释和发展。”解释和发展,这就是我们的工作。要解释,我们现在解释太少了。还要发展,我们在革命中有丰富的经验,应当发展这个学说。列宁还说:“对立的统一(一致、同一、均势),是有条件的、一时的、暂存的、相对的。互相排斥的对立的斗争则是绝对的,正如发展、运动是绝对的一样。”从这种观点出发,我们提出了百花齐放、百家争鸣这个方针。
真理是跟谬误相比较,并且同它作斗争发展起来的。美是跟丑相比较,并且同它作斗争发展起来的。善恶也是这样,善事、善人是跟恶事、恶人相比较,并且同它作斗争发展起来的。总之,香花是跟毒草相比较,并且同它作斗争发展起来的。禁止人们跟谬误、丑恶、敌对的东西见面,跟唯心主义、形而上学的东西见面,跟孔子、老子、蒋介石的东西见面,这样的政策是危险的政策。它将引导人们思想衰退,单打一,见不得世面,唱不得对台戏。
在哲学里边,唯物主义和唯心主义是对立统一,这两个东西是相互斗争的。还有两个东西,叫做辩证法和形而上学,也是对立统一、相互斗争的。一讲哲学,就少不了这两个对子。苏联现在不搞对子,只搞“单干户”,说是只放香花,不放毒草,不承认社会主义国家中唯心主义和形而上学的存在。事实上,无论哪个国家,都有唯心主义,都有形而上学,都有毒草。苏联那里的许多毒草,是以香花的名义出现的,那里的许多怪议论,都戴着唯物主义或社会主义现实主义的帽子。我们公开承认唯物主义和唯心主义、辩证法和形而上学、香花和毒草的斗争。这种斗争,要永远斗下去,每一个阶段都要前进一步。
我劝在座的同志,你们如果懂得唯物主义和辩证法,那就还需要补学一点它的对立面唯心主义和形而上学。康德和黑格尔的书,孔子和蒋介石的书,这些反面的东西,需要读一读。不懂得唯心主义和形而上学,没有同这些反面的东西作过斗争,你那个唯物主义和辩证法是不巩固的。我们有些共产党员、共产党的知识分子的缺点,恰恰是对于反面的东西知道得太少。读了几本马克思的书,就那么照着讲,比较单调。讲话,写文章,缺乏说服力。你不研究反面的东西,就驳不倒它。马克思、恩格斯、列宁都不是这样。他们努力学习和研究当代的和历史上的各种东西,并且教人们也这么做。马克思主义的三个组成部分,是在研究资产阶级的东西,研究德国的古典哲学、英国的古典经济学、法国的空想社会主义,并且跟它们作斗争的过程中产生的。斯大林就比较差一些。比如在他那个时期,把德国古典唯心主义哲学说成是德国贵族对于法国革命的一种反动。作这样一个结论,就把德国古典唯心主义哲学全盘否定了。他否定德国的军事学,说德国人打了败仗,那个军事学也用不得了,克劳塞维茨的书也不应当读了。
斯大林有许多形而上学,并且教会许多人搞形而上学。他在《苏联共产党(布)历史简明教程》中讲,马克思主义辩证法有四个基本特征。他第一条讲事物的联系,好像无缘无故什么东西都是联系的。究竟是什么东西联系呢?就是对立的两个侧面的联系。各种事物都有对立的两个侧面。他第四条讲事物的内在矛盾,又只讲对立面的斗争,不讲对立面的统一。按照对立统一这个辩证法的根本规律,对立面是斗争的,又是统一的,是互相排斥的,又是互相联系的,在一定条件下互相转化的。
苏联编的《简明哲学辞典》第四版关于同一性的一条,就反映了斯大林的观点。辞典里说:“像战争与和平、资产阶级与无产阶级、生与死等等现象不能是同一的,因为它们是根本对立和相互排斥的。”这就是说,这些根本对立的现象,没有马克思主义的同一性,它们只是互相排斥,不互相联结,不能在一定条件下互相转化。这种说法,是根本错误的。
在他们看来,战争就是战争,和平就是和平,两个东西只是互相排斥,毫无联系,战争不能转化到和平,和平不能转化到战争。列宁引用过克劳塞维茨的话:“战争是政治通过另一种手段的继续。”和平时期的斗争是政治,战争也是政治,但用的是特殊手段。战争与和平既互相排斥,又互相联结,并在一定条件下互相转化。和平时期不酝酿战争,为什么突然来一个战争?战争中间不酝酿和平,为什么突然来一个和平?
生与死不能转化,请问生物从何而来?地球上原来只有无生物,生物是后来才有的,是由无生物即死物转化而来的。生物都有新陈代谢,有生长、繁殖和死亡。在生命活动的过程中,生与死也在不断地互相斗争、互相转化。
资产阶级与无产阶级不能转化,为什么经过革命,无产阶级变为统治者,资产阶级变为被统治者?比如,我们和蒋介石国民党就是根本对立的。对立双方互相斗争、互相排斥的结果,我们和国民党的地位都起了变化,他们由统治者变为被统治者,我们由被统治者变为统治者。逃到台湾去的国民党不过十分之一,留在大陆上的有十分之九。留下来的这一部分,我们正在改造他们,这是在新的情况下的对立统一到台湾去的那十分之一,我们跟他们还是对立统一,也要经过斗争转化他们。
对立面的这种斗争和统一,斯大林就联系不起来。苏联一些人的思想就是形而上学,就是那么硬化,要么这样,要么那样,不承认对立统一。因此,在政治上就犯错误。我们坚持对立统一的观点,采取百花齐放、百家争鸣的方针。在放香花的同时,也必然会有毒草放出来。这并不可怕,在一定条件下还有益。
有些现象在一个时期是不可避免的,等它放出来以后就有办法了。比如,过去把剧目控制得很死,不准演这样演那样。现在一放,什么《乌盆记》、《天雷报》,什么牛鬼蛇神都跑到戏台上来了。这种现象怎么样?我看跑一跑好。许多人没有看过牛鬼蛇神的戏,等看到这些丑恶的形象,才晓得不应当搬上舞台的东西也搬上来了。然后,对那些戏加以批判、改造,或者禁止。有人说,有的地方戏不好,连本地人也反对。我看这种戏演一点也可以。究竟它站得住脚站不住脚,还有多少观众,让实践来判断,不忙去禁止。
现在,我们决定扩大发行《参考消息》,从两千份扩大到四十万份,使党内党外都能看到。这是共产党替帝国主义出版报纸,连那些骂我们的反动言论也登。为什么要这样做呢?目的就是把毒草,把非马克思主义和反马克思主义的东西,摆在我们同志面前,摆在人民群众和民主人士面前,让他们受到锻炼。不要封锁起来,封锁起来反而危险。这一条我们跟苏联的做法不同。为什么要种牛痘?就是人为地把一种病毒放到人体里面去,实行“细菌战”,跟你作斗争,使你的身体里头产生一种免疫力。发行《参考消息》以及出版其它反面教材,就是“种牛痘”,增强干部和群众在政治上的免疫力。
对于一些有害的言论,要及时给予有力的反驳。比如《人民日报》登载的《说“难免”》那篇文章,说我们工作中的错误并不是难免的,我们是用“难免”这句话来宽恕我们工作中的错误。这就是一种有害的言论。这篇文章,似乎可以不登。既然要登,就应当准备及时反驳,唱一个对台戏。我们搞革命和建设,总难免要犯一些错误,这是历史经验证明了的。《再论无产阶级专政的历史经验》那篇文章,就是个大难免论。我们的同志谁愿意犯错误?错误都是后头才认识到的,开头都自以为是百分之百的马克思主义。当然,我们不要因为错误难免就觉得犯一点也不要紧。但是,还要承认工作中不犯错误确实是不可能的。问题是要犯得少一些,犯得小一些。
社会上的歪风一定要打下去。无论党内也好,民主人士中间也好,青年学生中间也好,凡是歪风,就是说,不是个别人的错误,而是形成了一股风的,一定要打下去。打的办法就是说理。只要有说服力,就可以把歪风打下去。没有说服力,只是骂几句,那股歪风就会越刮越大。对于重大问题,要作好充分准备,在有把握的时候,发表有充分说服力的反驳文章。书记要亲自管报纸,亲自写文章。
统一物的两个互相对立互相斗争的侧面,总有个主,有个次。在我们无产阶级专政的国家里,当然不能让毒草到处泛滥。无论在党内,还是在思想界、文艺界,主要的和占统治地位的,必须力争是香花,是马克思主义。毒草,非马克思主义和反马克思主义的东西,只能处在被统治的地位。在一定的意义上,这可以比作原子里面的原子核和电子的关系。一个原子分两部分,一部分叫原子核,一部分叫电子。原子核很小,可是很重。电子很轻,一个电子大约只有最轻的原子核的一千八百分之一。原子核也是可以分割的,不过结合得比较牢固。电子可有些“自由主义”了,可以跑掉几个,又来几个。原子核和电子的关系,也是对立统一,有主有次。从这样的观点看来,百花齐放百家争鸣,就是有益无害的了。
第五点,闹事问题。在社会主义社会里,少数人闹事,是个新问题,很值得研究。
社会上的事情总是对立统一的。社会主义社会也是对立统一的,有人民内部的对立统一,有敌我之间的对立统一。在我们的国家里还有少数人闹事,基本原因就在于社会上仍然有各种对立的方面——正面和反面,仍然有对立的阶级,对立的人们,对立的意见。
我们已经基本上完成了生产资料所有制的社会主义改造,但是还有资产阶级,还有地主、富农,还有恶霸和反革命。他们是被剥夺的阶级,现在我们压迫他们,他们心怀仇恨,很多人一有机会就要发作。在匈牙利事件发生的时候,他们希望把匈牙利搞乱,也希望最好把中国搞乱。这是他们的阶级本性。
有些民主人士和教授放的那些怪议论,跟我们也是对立的。他们讲唯心论,我们讲唯物论。他们说,共产党不能管科学,社会主义没有优越性,合作化坏得很;我们说,共产党能够管科学,社会主义有优越性,合作化好得很。
学生中间跟我们对立的人也不少。现在的大学生大多数是剥削阶级家庭出身的,其中有反对我们的人,毫不奇怪。这样的人北京有,石家庄有,其它地方也有。
社会上还有那样的人,骂我们的省委是“僵尸”。省委是不是僵尸?我看我们的省委根本就没有死,怎么僵呢?骂省委是“僵尸”跟我们说省委不是僵尸,也是对立的。
在我们党内,也有各种对立的意见。比如,对苏共“二十大”一棍子打死斯大林,就有反对和拥护两种对立的意见。党内的不同意见是经常发生的,意见刚刚一致,过一两个月,新的不同意见又出来了。
在人们的思想方法方面,实事求是和主观主义是对立的。我看那一年都会有主观主义。一万年以后,就一点主观主义都没有呀?我不相信。
一个工厂,一个合作社,一个学校,一个团体,一个家庭,总之,无论什么地方,无论什么时候,都有对立的方面。所以,社会上少数人闹事,年年都会有。
对于闹事,究竟是怕,还是不怕?我们共产党历来对帝国主义、蒋介石国民党、地主阶级、资产阶级都不怕,现在倒怕学生闹事,怕农民闹社,这才有点怪哩!对群众闹事,只有段祺瑞怕,蒋介石怕。此外,匈牙利和苏联也有些人怕。我们对于少数人闹事,应当采取积极态度,不应当采取消极态度,就是说不怕,要准备着。怕是没有出路的。越怕,鬼就越来。不怕闹,有精神准备,才不致陷于被动。我看要准备出大事。你准备出大事,就可能不出,你不准备出大事,乱子就出来了。
事情的发展,无非是好坏两种可能。无论对国际问题,对国内问题,都要估计到两种可能。你说今年会太平,也许会太平。但是,你把工作放在这种估计的基础上就不好,要放在最坏的基础上来设想。在国际,无非是打世界大战,甩原子弹。在国内,无非是出全国性的大乱子,出“匈牙利事件”,有几百万人起来反对我们,占领几百个县,而且打到北京来。我们无非再到延安去,我们就是从那个地方来的。我们已经在北京住了七年,第八年又请我们回延安怎么办?大家就呜呼哀哉,痛哭流涕?当然,我们现在并没有打算回延安,来个“虚晃一枪,回马便走”。“七大”的时候,我讲了要估计到十七条困难,其中包括赤地千里,大灾荒,没有饭吃,所有县城都丢掉。我们作了这样充分的估计,所以始终处于主动地位。现在我们得了天下,还是要从最坏的可能来设想。
发生少数人闹事,有些是由于领导上存在着官僚主义和主观主义,在政治的或经济的政策上犯了错误。还有一些不是政策不对,而是工作方法不对,太生硬了。再一个因素,是反革命分子和坏分子的存在。少数人闹事要完全避免是不可能的。这又是个难免论。但是,只要不犯大的路线错误,全国性的大乱子是不会出的。即使犯了大的路线错误,出了全国性的乱子,我看也会很快平息,不至于亡国。当然,如果我们搞得不好,历史走一点回头路,有点回归,这还是很可能的。辛亥革命就走了回头路,革掉了皇帝,又来了皇帝,来了军阀。有问题才革命,革了命又出问题。我相信,假如出一次全国性的大乱子,那时总会有群众和他们的领袖人物来收拾时局,也许是我们,也许是别人。经过那样一次大乱子,脓包破了以后,我们的国家只会更加巩固。中国总是要前进的。
对于少数人闹事,第一条是不提倡,第二条是有人硬要闹就让他闹。我们宪法上规定有游行、示威自由,没有规定罢工自由,但是也没有禁止,所以罢工并不违反宪法。有人要罢工,要请愿,你硬要去阻止,那不好。我看,谁想闹谁就闹,想闹多久就闹多久,一个月不够就两个月,总之没有闹够就不收场。你急于收场,总有一天他还是要闹。凡有学生闹事的学校,不要放假,硬是来它一场赤壁鏖兵。这有什么好处呢?就是把问题充分暴露出来,把是非搞清楚,使大家得到锻炼,使那些没有道理的人、那些坏人闹输。
要学会这么一种领导艺术,不要什么事情总是捂着。人家一发怪议论,一罢工,一请愿,你就把他一棍子打回去,总觉得这是世界上不应有之事。不应有之事为什么又有了呢?可见得是应有之事。你不许罢工,不许请愿,不许讲坏话,横直是压,压到一个时候就要变拉科西。党内、党外都是这样。各种怪议论,怪事,矛盾,以揭露为好。要揭露矛盾,解决矛盾。
对于闹事,要分几种情况处理。一种是闹得对的,我们应当承认错误,并且改正。一种是闹得不对的,要驳回去。闹得有道理,是应当闹的;闹得无道理,是闹不出什么名堂的。再有一种是闹得有对有不对的,对的部分我们接受,不对的部分加以批评,不能步步后退,毫无原则,什么要求都答应。除了大规模的真正的反革命暴乱必须武装镇压以外,不要轻易使用武力,不要开枪。段祺瑞搞的“三一八”惨案,就是用开枪的办法,结果把自己打倒了。我们不能学段祺瑞的办法。
对闹事的人,要做好工作,加以分化,把多数人、少数人区别开来。对多数人,要好好引导、教育,使他们逐步转变,不要挫伤他们。我看什么地方都是两头小中间大。要把中间派一步一步地争取过来,这样,我们就占优势了。对带头闹事的人,要有分析。有些人敢于带头闹,经过教育,可能成为有用之材。对少数坏人,除了最严重犯罪的以外,也不要捉,不要关,不要开除。要留在原单位,剥夺他的一切政治资本,使他孤立起来,利用他当反面教员。清华大学那个要杀几千几万人的大学生,我们邓小平同志去讲话,就请他当教员。这样的人,又没有武装,又没有手枪,你怕他干什么?你一下把他开除,你那里很干净了。但是不得人心。你这个地方开除了,他就要在别的地方就业。所以,急于开除这些人不是好办法。这种人代表反动的阶级,不是个别人的问题,简单处理,爽快是爽快,但是反面教员的作用没有尽量利用。苏联大学生闹事,他们就开除几个领袖人物,他们不懂得坏事可以当作教材,为我们所用。当然,对于搞匈牙利事件那样反革命暴乱的极少数人,就必须实行专政。
对民主人士,我们要让他们唱对台戏,放手让他们批评。如果我们不这样做,就有点象国民党了。国民党很怕批评,每次开参政会就诚惶诚恐。民主人士的批评也无非是两种:一种是错的,一种是不错的。不错的可以补足我们的短处;错的要反驳。至于梁漱溟、彭一湖、章乃器那一类人,他们有屁就让他们放,放出来有利,让大家闻一闻,是香的还是臭的,经过讨论,争取多数,使他们孤立起来。他们要闹,就让他们闹够。多行不义必自毙。他们讲的话越错越好,犯的错误越大越好,这样他们就越孤立,就越能从反面教育人民。我们对待民主人士,要又团结又斗争,分别情况,有一些要主动采取措施,有一些要让他暴露,后发制人,不要先发制人。
对资产阶级思想的斗争,对坏人坏事的斗争,是长期的,要几十年甚至几百年。工人阶级、劳动人民和革命知识分子,将在斗争中取得经验,受到锻炼,这是很有益处的。
坏事有两重性,一重是坏,一重是好。这一点,现在很多同志还不清楚。坏事里头包含着好的因素。把坏人坏事只看成坏,是片面地形而上学地观察问题,不是辩证地观察问题,不是马克思主义的观点。坏人坏事一方面是坏,另一方面有好的作用。比如,象王明这样的坏人,就起着反面教员的好作用。同样,好事里头也包含着坏的因素。比如,解放以后七年来的大胜利,特别是去年这一年的大胜利,使有些同志脑筋膨胀,骄傲起来了,突然来了个少数人闹事,就感到出乎意料之外。
对闹事又怕,又简单处理,根本的原因,就是思想上不承认社会主义社会是对立统一的,是存在着矛盾、阶级和阶级斗争的。
斯大林在一个长时期里不承认社会主义制度下生产关系和生产力之间的矛盾,上层建筑和经济基础之间的矛盾。直到他逝世前一年写的《苏联社会主义经济问题》,才吞吞吐吐地谈到了社会主义制度下生产关系和生产力之间的矛盾,说如果政策不对,调节得不好,是要出问题的。但是,他还是没有把社会主义制度下生产关系和生产力之间的矛盾,上层建筑和经济基础之间的矛盾,当作全面性的问题提出来,他还是没有认识到这些矛盾是推动社会主义社会向前发展的基本矛盾。他以为他那个天下稳固了。我们不要以为天下稳固了,它又稳固又不稳固。
按照辩证法,就象人总有一天要死一样,社会主义制度作为一种历史现象,总有一天要灭亡,要被共产主义制度所否定。如果说,社会主义制度是不会灭亡的,社会主义的生产关系和上层建筑是不会灭亡的,那还是什么马克思主义呢?那不是跟宗教教义一样,跟宣传上帝不灭亡的神学一样?
怎样处理社会主义社会的敌我矛盾和人民内部矛盾,这是一门科学,值得好好研究。就我国的情况来说,现在的阶级斗争,一部分是敌我矛盾,大量表现的是人民内部矛盾。当前的少数人闹事就反映了这种状况。如果一万年以后地球毁灭了,至少在这一万年以内,还有闹事的问题。不过我们管不着一万年那么远的事情,我们要在几个五年计划的时间内,认真取得处理这个问题的经验。
要加强我们的工作,改正我们的错误和缺点。加强什么工作呢?工、农、商、学、兵、政、党,都要加强政治思想工作。现在大家搞业务,搞事务,什么经济事务,文教事务,国防事务,党的事务,不搞政治思想工作,那就很危险。现在我们的总书记邓小平同志,亲自出马到清华大学作报告,也请你们大家都出马。中央和省市自治区党委的领导同志,都要亲自出马做政治思想工作。第二次世界大战以后,苏联共产党,东欧一些国家的党,不讲马克思主义的基本原则了。阶级斗争,无产阶级专政,党的领导,民主集中制,党与群众的联系,这些他们都不讲了,空气不浓厚了。结果出了个匈牙利事件。我们一定要坚持马克思主义的基本理论。每个省市自治区都要把理论工作搞起来,有计划地培养马克思主义的理论家和评论家。
要精简机构。国家是阶级斗争的工具。阶级不等于国家,国家是由占统治地位的阶级出一部分人(少数人)组成的。机关工作是需要一点人,但是越少越好。现在国家机构庞大,部门很多,许多人蹲在机关里头没有事做。这个问题要解决。第一条,必须减人;第二条,对准备减的人,必须作出适当安排,使他们都有切实的归宿。党、政、军都要这样做。
要到下面去研究问题。我希望中央的同志,各省市自治区、各部的主要负责同志都这样做。听说现在许多负责同志不下去了,这不好。中央机关苦得很,在这个地方一点知识也捞不到。你要找什么知识,蹲在机关里是找不到的。真正出知识的地方是工厂、合作社、商店。工厂怎么办,合作社怎么办,商店怎么办,在机关里是搞不清楚的。越是上层越没有东西。要解决问题,一定要自己下去,或者是请下面的人上来。第一不下去,第二不请下面的人上来,就不能解决问题。我建议,省市自治区党委书记兼一个县委书记,或者兼一个工厂或学校的党委书记,地委书记、县委书记也要兼一个下级单位的书记。这样可以取得经验,指导全局。
要密切联系群众。脱离群众,官僚主义,势必要挨打。匈牙利的领导人,没有调查研究,不了解群众情况,等到大乱子出来了,还不晓得原因在什么地方。现在我们有些部和省市自治区党委的领导,不了解群众的思想动态,有人酝酿闹事,酝酿暴动,根本不知道,出了事就措手不及。我们一定要引为鉴戒。中央的同志,各省市自治区、各部的主要负责同志,一年总要有一段时间到工厂、合作社、商店、学校等基层单位去跑一跑,进行调查研究,搞清楚群众的情况怎样,先进的、中间的、落后的各有多少,我们的群众工作做得如何,做到心中有数。要依靠工人阶级,依靠贫农下中农,依靠先进分子,总要有个依靠。这样,才有可能避免出匈牙利那样的事件。
第六点,法制问题。讲三条:一定要守法,一定要肃反,一定要肯定肃反的成绩。
一定要守法,不要破坏革命的法制。法律是上层建筑。我们的法律,是劳动人民自己制定的。它是维护革命秩序,保护劳动人民利益,保护社会主义经济基础,保护生产力的。我们要求所有的人都遵守革命法制,并不是只要你民主人士守法。
一定要肃反。没有完成肃反计划的,今年要完成,如果留下一点尾巴,明年一定要完成。有些单位进行过肃反,但是肃而不清,必须在斗争中逐步肃清。反革命不多了,这一点要肯定。在闹事的地方,广大群众是不会跟反革命跑的,跟反革命跑的只是部分的、暂时的。同时也要肯定,还有反革命,肃反工作没有完。
一定要肯定肃反的成绩。肃反的成绩是伟大的。错误也有,当然要严肃对待。要给做肃反工作的干部撑腰,不能因为一些民主人士一骂就软下来。你天天骂,吃了饭没有别的事做,专做骂人的事,那由你。我看越骂越好,我讲的这三条总是骂不倒的。
共产党不晓得挨了多少骂。国民党骂我们是“共匪”,别人跟我们通,就叫“通匪”。结果,还是“匪”比他们非“匪”好。自古以来,没有先进的东西一开始就受欢迎,它总是要挨骂。马克思主义、共产党从开始就是挨骂的。一万年以后,先进的东西开始也还是要挨骂的。
肃反要坚持,有反必肃。法制要遵守。按照法律办事,不等于束手束脚。有反不肃,束手束脚,是不对的。要按照法律放手放脚。
第七点,农业问题。要争取今年丰收。今年来一个丰收,人心就可以稳定,合作社就可以相当巩固。在苏联,在东欧一些国家,搞合作化,粮食总要减产多少年。我们搞了几年合作化,去年大搞一年,不但没有减产,而且还增产了。如果今年再来一个丰收,那在合作化的历史上,在国际共产主义运动的历史上,就是没有先例的。
全党一定要重视农业。农业关系国计民生极大要注意不抓粮食很危险。不抓粮食,总有一天要天下大乱。
首先,农业关系到五亿农村人口的吃饭问题,吃肉吃油问题,以及其它日用的非商品性农产品问题。这个农民自给的部分,数量极大。比如,去年生产了三千六百多亿斤粮食,商品粮包括公粮在内,大约是八百多亿斤,不到四分之一,四分之三以上归农民。农业搞好了,农民能自给,五亿人口稳定了。
第二,农业也关系到城市和工矿区人口的吃饭问题。商品性的农产品发展了,才能供应工业人口的需要,才能发展工业。要在发展农业生产的基础上,逐步提高农产品特别是粮食的商品率。有了饭吃,学校、工厂少数人闹事也不怕。
第三,农业是轻工业原料的主要来源,农村是轻工业的重要市场。只有农业发展了,轻工业生产才能得到足够的原料,轻工业产品才能得到广阔的市场。
第四,农村又是重工业的重要市场。比如,化学肥料,各种各样的农业机械,部分的电力、煤炭、石油,是供应农村的,铁路、公路和大型水利工程,也都为农业服务。现在,我们建立了社会主义的农业经济,无论是发展轻工业还是发展重工业,农村都是极大的市场。
第五,现在出口物资主要是农产品。农产品变成外汇,就可以进口各种工业设备。
第六,农业是积累的重要来源。农业发展起来了,就可以为发展工业提供更多的资金。
因此,在一定的意义上可以说,农业就是工业。要说服工业部门面向农村,支援农业。要搞好工业化,就应当这样做。
农业本身的积累和国家从农业取得的积累,在合作社收入中究竟各占多大比例为好?请大家研究,议出一个适当的比例来。其目的,就是要使农业能够扩大再生产,使它作为工业的市场更大,作为积累的来源更多。先让农业本身积累多,然后才能为工业积累更多。只为工业积累,农业本身积累得太少或者没有积累,竭泽而渔,对于工业的发展反而不利。
合作社的积累和社员收入的比例,也要注意。合作社要利用价值法则搞经济核算,要勤俭办社,逐步增加一点积累。今年如果丰收,积累要比去年多一点,但是不能太多,还是先让农民吃饱一点。丰收年多积累一点,灾荒年或者半灾荒年就不积累或者少积累一点。就是说,积累是波浪式的,或者叫作螺旋式的。世界上的事物,因为都是矛盾着的,都是对立统一的,所以,它们的运动、发展,都是波浪式的。太阳的光射来叫光波,无线电台发出的叫电波,声音的传播叫声波。水有水波,热有热浪。在一定意义上讲,走路也是起波的,一步一步走就是起波。唱戏也是起波的,唱完一句再唱第二句,没有一口气唱七八句的。写字也起波,写完一个字再写一个字,不能一笔写几百个字。这是事物矛盾运动的曲折性。
总之,要照辩证法办事。这是邓小平同志讲的。我看,全党都要学习辩证法,提倡照辩证法办事。全党都要注意思想理论工作,建立马克思主义的理论队伍,加强马克思主义理论的研究和宣传。要运用马克思主义的对立统一学说,观察和处理社会主义社会阶级矛盾和阶级斗争的新问题,观察和处理国际斗争中的新问题。